diff --git a/changelog/fix-5854-use-correct-payment-method-id b/changelog/fix-5854-use-correct-payment-method-id
new file mode 100644
index 00000000000..b8834ad2f85
--- /dev/null
+++ b/changelog/fix-5854-use-correct-payment-method-id
@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+Significance: patch
+Type: fix
+
+Supply correct payment method instance to process_redirect_payment.
diff --git a/includes/payment-methods/class-upe-split-payment-gateway.php b/includes/payment-methods/class-upe-split-payment-gateway.php
index d48c378986f..705ee64932a 100644
--- a/includes/payment-methods/class-upe-split-payment-gateway.php
+++ b/includes/payment-methods/class-upe-split-payment-gateway.php
@@ -160,13 +160,31 @@ public function should_use_stripe_platform_on_checkout_page() {
 	 * @return UPE_Payment_Method|false UPE payment method instance.
 	 */
 	public function get_selected_payment_method( $payment_method_type ) {
-		if ( $payment_method_type !== $this->stripe_id ) {
-			return false;
+		return WC_Payments::get_payment_method_by_id( $payment_method_type );
+	}
+
+	/**
+	 * Set formatted readable payment method title for order,
+	 * using payment method details from accompanying charge.
+	 *
+	 * @param WC_Order   $order WC Order being processed.
+	 * @param string     $payment_method_type Stripe payment method key.
+	 * @param array|bool $payment_method_details Array of payment method details from charge or false.
+	 */
+	public function set_payment_method_title_for_order( $order, $payment_method_type, $payment_method_details ) {
+		$payment_method = $this->get_selected_payment_method( $payment_method_type );
+		if ( ! $payment_method ) {
+			return;
 		}
 
-		return $this->payment_method;
-	}
+		$payment_method_title = $payment_method->get_title( $payment_method_details );
 
+		$payment_gateway = 'card' === $payment_method->get_id() ? self::GATEWAY_ID : self::GATEWAY_ID . '_' . $payment_method_type;
+
+		$order->set_payment_method( $payment_gateway );
+		$order->set_payment_method_title( $payment_method_title );
+		$order->save();
+	}
 
 	/**
 	 * Handle AJAX request for updating a payment intent for Stripe UPE.
diff --git a/tests/unit/payment-methods/test-class-upe-split-payment-gateway.php b/tests/unit/payment-methods/test-class-upe-split-payment-gateway.php
index 0616178084d..237b892ae0f 100644
--- a/tests/unit/payment-methods/test-class-upe-split-payment-gateway.php
+++ b/tests/unit/payment-methods/test-class-upe-split-payment-gateway.php
@@ -272,6 +272,8 @@ public function set_up() {
 						'is_payment_recurring',
 						'get_payment_method_ids_enabled_at_checkout',
 						'wc_payments_get_payment_gateway_by_id',
+						'get_selected_payment_method',
+						'remove_upe_payment_intent_from_session',
 					]
 				)
 				->getMock();
@@ -1199,6 +1201,8 @@ public function test_process_redirect_payment_intent_processing() {
 		$intent_id           = 'pi_mock';
 		$payment_method_id   = 'pm_mock';
 
+		$card_method = $this->mock_payment_methods['card'];
+
 		$payment_intent = WC_Helper_Intention::create_intention( [ 'status' => $intent_status ] );
 
 		$mock_upe_gateway->expects( $this->once() )
@@ -1207,6 +1211,10 @@ public function test_process_redirect_payment_intent_processing() {
 				$this->returnValue( [ $user, $customer_id ] )
 			);
 
+		$mock_upe_gateway->expects( $this->any() )
+			->method( 'get_selected_payment_method' )
+			->willReturn( $card_method );
+
 		$this->mock_wcpay_request( Get_Intention::class, 1, $intent_id )
 			->expects( $this->once() )
 			->method( 'format_response' )
@@ -1216,6 +1224,9 @@ public function test_process_redirect_payment_intent_processing() {
 
 		$mock_upe_gateway->process_redirect_payment( $order_id, $intent_id, $save_payment_method );
 
+		$mock_upe_gateway->expects( $this->any() )
+			->method( 'remove_upe_payment_intent_from_session' );
+
 		$result_order = wc_get_order( $order_id );
 		$note         = wc_get_order_notes(
 			[
@@ -1247,6 +1258,8 @@ public function test_process_redirect_payment_intent_succeded() {
 		$intent_id           = 'pi_mock';
 		$payment_method_id   = 'pm_mock';
 
+		$card_method = $this->mock_payment_methods['card'];
+
 		$payment_intent = WC_Helper_Intention::create_intention( [ 'status' => $intent_status ] );
 
 		$mock_upe_gateway->expects( $this->once() )
@@ -1260,6 +1273,10 @@ public function test_process_redirect_payment_intent_succeded() {
 			->method( 'format_response' )
 			->willReturn( $payment_intent );
 
+		$mock_upe_gateway->expects( $this->any() )
+			->method( 'get_selected_payment_method' )
+			->willReturn( $card_method );
+
 		$this->set_cart_contains_subscription_items( false );
 
 		$mock_upe_gateway->process_redirect_payment( $order_id, $intent_id, $save_payment_method );
@@ -1289,6 +1306,8 @@ public function test_process_redirect_setup_intent_succeded() {
 		$payment_method_id   = 'pm_mock';
 		$token               = WC_Helper_Token::create_token( $payment_method_id );
 
+		$card_method = $this->mock_payment_methods['card'];
+
 		$order->set_shipping_total( 0 );
 		$order->set_shipping_tax( 0 );
 		$order->set_cart_tax( 0 );
@@ -1327,6 +1346,10 @@ public function test_process_redirect_setup_intent_succeded() {
 				$this->returnValue( $token )
 			);
 
+		$mock_upe_gateway->expects( $this->any() )
+			->method( 'get_selected_payment_method' )
+			->willReturn( $card_method );
+
 		$this->set_cart_contains_subscription_items( true );
 
 		$mock_upe_gateway->process_redirect_payment( $order_id, $intent_id, $save_payment_method );
@@ -1356,6 +1379,8 @@ public function test_process_redirect_payment_save_payment_token() {
 		$payment_method_id   = 'pm_mock';
 		$token               = WC_Helper_Token::create_token( $payment_method_id );
 
+		$card_method = $this->mock_payment_methods['card'];
+
 		$payment_intent = WC_Helper_Intention::create_intention( [ 'status' => $intent_status ] );
 
 		$mock_upe_gateway->expects( $this->once() )
@@ -1375,6 +1400,10 @@ public function test_process_redirect_payment_save_payment_token() {
 				$this->returnValue( $token )
 			);
 
+		$mock_upe_gateway->expects( $this->any() )
+			->method( 'get_selected_payment_method' )
+			->willReturn( $card_method );
+
 		$this->set_cart_contains_subscription_items( false );
 
 		$mock_upe_gateway->process_redirect_payment( $order_id, $intent_id, $save_payment_method );
@@ -1477,6 +1506,10 @@ public function test_correct_payment_method_title_for_order() {
 		foreach ( $charge_payment_method_details as $i => $payment_method_details ) {
 			$payment_method_id = $payment_method_details['type'];
 			$mock_upe_gateway  = $this->mock_payment_gateways[ $payment_method_id ];
+			$payment_method    = $this->mock_payment_methods[ $payment_method_id ];
+			$mock_upe_gateway->expects( $this->any() )
+				->method( 'get_selected_payment_method' )
+				->willReturn( $payment_method );
 			$mock_upe_gateway->set_payment_method_title_for_order( $order, $payment_method_id, $payment_method_details );
 			$this->assertEquals( $expected_payment_method_titles[ $i ], $order->get_payment_method_title() );
 		}