From 628f88721d5d4ff4ecc86f81bce8aa418aebe652 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kmitchener Date: Sun, 19 Nov 2023 12:42:29 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 1/6] datafusion v33 --- datafusion/results/single.json | 90 ++++++++++----------- index.html | 138 ++++++++++++++++----------------- 2 files changed, 114 insertions(+), 114 deletions(-) diff --git a/datafusion/results/single.json b/datafusion/results/single.json index f90a381ca..fd6df3b80 100644 --- a/datafusion/results/single.json +++ b/datafusion/results/single.json @@ -1,9 +1,9 @@ { "system": "DataFusion (Parquet, single)", - "date": "2023-07-29", + "date": "2023-11-19", "machine": "c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2", "cluster_size": 1, - "comment": "v28.0.0 (51b4392)", + "comment": "v33.0.0 (d2efaa9)", "tags": ["Rust", "column-oriented", "embedded", "stateless"], @@ -11,48 +11,48 @@ "data_size": 14779976446, "result": [ -[2.641, 0.232, 0.216], -[0.092, 0.074, 0.073], -[0.159, 0.121, 0.117], -[0.351, 0.122, 0.120], -[1.142, 0.874, 0.869], -[1.399, 1.303, 1.329], -[0.096, 0.075, 0.076], -[0.094, 0.074, 0.076], -[1.516, 1.481, 1.475], -[2.711, 2.582, 2.583], -[0.429, 0.332, 0.327], -[0.558, 0.357, 0.360], -[1.374, 1.323, 1.336], -[3.559, 2.670, 2.733], -[1.519, 1.487, 1.477], -[1.041, 0.981, 0.988], -[3.248, 2.748, 2.801], -[3.139, 2.696, 2.688], -[7.014, 5.770, 5.775], -[0.271, 0.111, 0.109], -[9.975, 1.558, 1.578], -[11.163, 1.926, 1.881], -[22.053, 4.208, 4.194], -[56.007, 12.132, 12.113], -[2.559, 0.602, 0.586], -[0.737, 0.479, 0.489], -[2.548, 0.589, 0.589], -[9.550, 2.299, 2.286], -[9.076, 5.399, 5.388], -[0.579, 0.568, 0.584], -[2.214, 1.136, 1.136], -[5.734, 1.593, 1.598], -[8.357, 7.896, 8.053], -[11.556, 7.358, 7.369], -[12.051, 7.878, 7.956], -[1.866, 1.820, 1.807], -[0.448, 0.347, 0.358], -[0.231, 0.197, 0.195], -[0.248, 0.198, 0.188], -[0.843, 0.725, 0.722], -[0.138, 0.091, 0.095], -[0.115, 0.089, 0.088], -[0.124, 0.097, 0.092] +[0.076, 0.045, 0.045], +[0.110, 0.061, 0.062], +[0.200, 0.109, 0.106], +[1.529, 0.117, 0.113], +[2.265, 0.832, 0.836], +[2.652, 1.246, 1.247], +[0.091, 0.065, 0.071], +[0.100, 0.063, 0.063], +[2.465, 1.490, 1.478], +[3.672, 2.539, 2.496], +[1.627, 0.344, 0.330], +[1.885, 0.366, 0.369], +[2.679, 1.253, 1.236], +[6.053, 2.504, 2.505], +[2.885, 1.386, 1.382], +[1.776, 0.968, 0.927], +[5.752, 2.709, 2.689], +[5.639, 2.646, 2.629], +[10.707, 5.692, 5.799], +[1.171, 0.100, 0.105], +[20.537, 1.570, 1.575], +[23.093, 1.901, 1.897], +[44.658, 4.103, 4.065], +[112.447, 11.674, 11.654], +[5.791, 0.581, 0.558], +[2.340, 0.511, 0.529], +[5.823, 0.626, 0.632], +[19.944, 2.333, 2.343], +[17.608, 5.052, 5.086], +[0.557, 0.500, 0.494], +[4.888, 1.140, 1.126], +[11.791, 1.553, 1.566], +[12.415, 7.764, 7.724], +[21.279, 6.722, 6.816], +[21.569, 7.325, 7.297], +[1.981, 1.839, 1.821], +[0.466, 0.306, 0.312], +[0.254, 0.185, 0.182], +[0.284, 0.173, 0.171], +[0.887, 0.685, 0.667], +[0.171, 0.092, 0.095], +[0.144, 0.086, 0.087], +[0.151, 0.101, 0.097] ] } diff --git a/index.html b/index.html index 2cddf2a32..0d6a60b93 100644 --- a/index.html +++ b/index.html @@ -332,9 +332,9 @@ const data = [ {"system":"Athena (partitioned)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"serverless","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["stateless","managed","Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":0,"data_size":13800000000,"result":[[2.777,3.275,2.925],[1.503,3.136,4.003],[4.544,3.833,3.64],[3.9,2.514,3.522],[3.46,2.186,3.244],[3.624,2.742,3.185],[2.21,1.984,3.123],[3.207,2.403,2.685],[2.936,2.014,3.869],[8.333,7.102,4.434],[7.401,4.697,3.155],[4.214,3.065,4.748],[6.207,4.213,2.576],[3.428,3.085,3.401],[2.92,3.3,3.278],[2.205,2.558,2.419],[4.641,3.888,2.155],[3.219,2.822,3.292],[3.23,3.579,4.31],[2.288,3.543,3.95],[3.032,2.859,2.807],[3.926,3.247,2.928],[4.477,4.048,4.392],[7.407,6.375,6.123],[2.611,2.872,2.827],[2.566,2.567,3.6],[3.673,3.733,2.925],[2.426,3.218,2.78],[5.125,3.778,4.25],[4.565,4.03,4.066],[3.628,3.219,2.953],[6.207,5.973,3.158],[4.339,5.601,4.234],[2.618,3.107,3.433],[4.661,2.79,2.846],[2.373,1.629,2.734],[2.721,2.15,1.962],[3.207,2.154,2.186],[2.453,2.477,3.217],[2.691,4.732,3.584],[2.589,2.613,3.231],[1.926,3.617,1.82],[1.506,2.404,2.343]],"source":"athena/results/partitioned.json"} ,{"system":"Athena (single)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"serverless","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["stateless","managed","Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":0,"data_size":13800000000,"result":[[2.268,1.327,2.137],[3.427,2.248,3.605],[3.254,2.548,2.316],[3.025,2.314,3.003],[2.264,2.876,4.213],[3.044,2.745,2.698],[2.732,2.199,2.659],[2.022,3.692,3.072],[2.746,2.477,2.785],[3.53,2.782,4.031],[2.709,2.047,2.853],[2.318,1.969,3.4],[2.635,1.935,2.707],[3.049,3.38,3.071],[3.661,2.387,2.476],[2.479,2.591,2.21],[3.093,3.698,4.351],[3.479,3.236,2.274],[4.36,2.97,3.457],[2.525,2.384,3.328],[3.34,3.174,3.409],[3.163,2.971,3.034],[2.999,3.539,2.906],[6.454,7.597,7.858],[2.754,1.951,2.645],[2.852,3.018,2.718],[2.513,2.678,2.417],[3.293,2.521,2.771],[4.392,3.863,3.981],[3.658,4.246,4.027],[3.028,3.87,2.337],[2.923,3.635,3.591],[3.142,4.105,3.15],[3.66,3.187,4.745],[2.652,2.695,2.742],[2.262,2.776,1.815],[1.881,2.212,2.053],[1.934,2.551,1.524],[2.069,2.26,1.805],[2.626,2.902,2.793],[1.791,2.082,2.481],[3.757,2.6,1.946],[2.608,1.994,3.967]],"source":"athena/results/single.json"} -,{"system":"Aurora for MySQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"16acu","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Some queries cannot run due to ERROR 1114 (HY000) at line 1: The table '/rdsdbdata/tmp/#sqlaff_e5_0' is full","tags":["managed","C++","MySQL compatible","row-oriented"],"load_time":7687.318,"data_size":89614492631,"result":[[740.42,739.91,746.65],[828.2,835.67,832.87],[830.08,830.98,832.38],[829.88,832.83,830.87],[845.99,842.4,843.21],[869.51,870.69,869.75],[823.77,829.08,825.54],[827.74,832.87,829.25],[916.26,909.46,929.17],[946.49,939.27,932.32],[852.37,857.69,854.74],[857.99,864.05,825.14],[null,null,null],[863.37,860.2,865.62],[null,null,null],[891.84,895.28,893.68],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[1420.12,1419.34,1445.08],[28.94,0.21,0.21],[917.64,917.56,916.92],[923.47,921.7,923.82],[919.95,918.37,920.17],[1002.19,1002.07,1001.2],[902.23,902.65,901.8],[901.17,900.02,898.3],[900.04,898.89,903.35],[901.78,902.71,901.28],[null,null,null],[1153.29,1154,1156.46],[862.57,863.35,859.69],[923.14,921.1,923.92],[1370.78,1401.72,1401.44],[1454.67,1455.55,1458.79],[1463.31,1466.75,1461.83],[941.03,944.07,937.23],[7.42,2.8,2.77],[2.57,2.52,2.59],[1.5,1.52,1.59],[3.62,3.57,3.61],[0.95,0.94,0.94],[0.9,0.92,0.91],[1.69,1.72,1.69]],"source":"aurora-mysql/results/16acu.json"} +,{"system":"Aurora for MySQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"16acu","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Some queries cannot run due to ERROR 1114 (HY000) at line 1: The table '/rdsdbdata/tmp/#sqlaff_e5_0' is full","tags":["managed","C++","MySQL compatible","row-oriented"],"load_time":7687.318,"data_size":89614492631,"result":[[740.42,739.91,746.65],[828.2,835.67,832.87],[830.08,830.98,832.38],[829.88,832.83,830.87],[845.99,842.4,843.21],[869.51,870.69,869.75],[823.77,829.08,825.54],[827.74,832.87,829.25],[916.26,909.46,929.17],[946.49,939.27,932.32],[852.37,857.69,854.74],[857.99,864.05,825.14],[null,null,null],[863.37,860.2,865.62],[null,null,null],[891.84,895.28,893.68],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[1420.12,1419.34,1445.08],[28.94,0.21,0.21],[917.64,917.56,916.92],[923.47,921.7,923.82],[919.95,918.37,920.17],[1002.19,1002.07,1001.2],[902.23,902.65,901.8],[901.17,900.02,898.3],[900.04,898.89,903.35],[901.78,902.71,901.28],[null,null,null],[1153.29,1154,1156.46],[862.57,863.35,859.69],[923.14,921.1,923.92],[1370.78,1401.72,1401.44],[1454.67,1455.55,1458.79],[1463.31,1466.75,1461.83],[941.03,944.07,937.23],[7.42,2.80,2.77],[2.57,2.52,2.59],[1.50,1.52,1.59],[3.62,3.57,3.61],[0.95,0.94,0.94],[0.90,0.92,0.91],[1.69,1.72,1.69]],"source":"aurora-mysql/results/16acu.json"} ,{"system":"Aurora for PostgreSQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"16acu","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["managed","C","PostgreSQL compatible","row-oriented"],"load_time":2127,"data_size":52183852646,"result":[[12.8361,5.71812,5.8241],[61.2565,62.1402,63.7173],[68.0578,68.1218,67.609],[7.83207,5.90193,6.0461],[48.7194,48.0233,48.2198],[289.492,304.639,282.436],[6.30572,6.31857,6.21598],[53.644,53.8931,53.5307],[131.526,131.45,131.102],[137.724,136.921,137.758],[57.2079,56.2775,56.2152],[56.5349,56.2048,55.9569],[82.3897,82.8866,83.534],[97.0569,97.1392,96.4731],[85.6557,86.7783,86.2804],[49.4325,42.4309,42.5743],[111.537,114.59,111.807],[88.4322,89.3756,87.7899],[160.781,163.866,161.394],[1025.04,2.10165,2.10065],[106.741,56.2731,56.1535],[59.2681,59.5272,59.536],[58.6083,57.6054,57.3935],[54.8271,55.1397,56.3487],[54.718,52.469,53.271],[53.5387,53.1926,52.4008],[52.0042,51.9581,52.2453],[60.1317,59.9695,59.2187],[244.608,242.954,243.815],[91.8674,92.4165,91.5884],[63.7122,64.277,64.2783],[69.2596,68.9535,69.4508],[234.222,241.138,240.316],[488.169,462.257,460.466],[472.929,471.809,476.635],[103.664,116.131,103.467],[16.8124,3.34058,3.37782],[0.852414,0.832073,0.859857],[0.305464,0.31166,0.306694],[4.55625,4.54098,4.58501],[0.299746,0.297532,0.30334],[0.275732,0.279817,0.27766],[0.332107,0.324387,0.320099]],"source":"aurora-postgresql/results/16acu.json"} -,{"system":"ByConity","date":"2023-06-21","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":343.482,"data_size":14602455235,"result":[[0.003,0.003,0.003],[0.03,0.05,0.025],[0.137,0.049,0.048],[0.318,0.062,0.056],[0.564,0.479,0.475],[0.983,0.772,0.766],[0.054,0.044,0.036],[0.039,0.03,0.031],[0.717,0.6,0.611],[0.813,0.633,0.665],[0.348,0.238,0.234],[0.351,0.256,0.277],[0.899,0.765,0.756],[1.447,1.139,1.07],[1.07,0.867,0.861],[0.976,0.917,0.882],[2.614,2.385,2.425],[1.801,1.622,1.591],[4.729,4.366,4.437],[0.218,0.136,0.106],[8.703,0.786,0.722],[9.845,0.799,0.813],[18.827,1.709,1.682],[56.739,5.832,4.243],[1.777,0.267,0.27],[0.395,0.205,0.229],[1.776,0.244,0.263],[8.509,0.718,0.707],[11.414,10.222,10.292],[2.118,2.104,2.115],[1.413,0.624,0.614],[4.403,0.765,0.77],[5.21,4.964,4.947],[9.678,3.707,3.651],[9.684,3.661,3.712],[1.317,1.16,1.199],[0.22,0.152,0.101],[0.084,0.061,0.041],[0.08,0.035,0.053],[0.246,0.169,0.17],[0.083,0.025,0.034],[0.036,0.027,0.028],[0.054,0.047,0.019]],"source":"byconity/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"ByConity","date":"2023-06-21","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":343.482,"data_size":14602455235,"result":[[0.003,0.003,0.003],[0.030,0.050,0.025],[0.137,0.049,0.048],[0.318,0.062,0.056],[0.564,0.479,0.475],[0.983,0.772,0.766],[0.054,0.044,0.036],[0.039,0.030,0.031],[0.717,0.600,0.611],[0.813,0.633,0.665],[0.348,0.238,0.234],[0.351,0.256,0.277],[0.899,0.765,0.756],[1.447,1.139,1.070],[1.070,0.867,0.861],[0.976,0.917,0.882],[2.614,2.385,2.425],[1.801,1.622,1.591],[4.729,4.366,4.437],[0.218,0.136,0.106],[8.703,0.786,0.722],[9.845,0.799,0.813],[18.827,1.709,1.682],[56.739,5.832,4.243],[1.777,0.267,0.270],[0.395,0.205,0.229],[1.776,0.244,0.263],[8.509,0.718,0.707],[11.414,10.222,10.292],[2.118,2.104,2.115],[1.413,0.624,0.614],[4.403,0.765,0.770],[5.210,4.964,4.947],[9.678,3.707,3.651],[9.684,3.661,3.712],[1.317,1.160,1.199],[0.220,0.152,0.101],[0.084,0.061,0.041],[0.080,0.035,0.053],[0.246,0.169,0.170],[0.083,0.025,0.034],[0.036,0.027,0.028],[0.054,0.047,0.019]],"source":"byconity/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"ByteHouse","date":"2022-07-27","machine":"L","tags":["managed","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","C++"],"load_time":745,"data_size":27190000000,"result":[[0.239865,0.0870234,0.222015],[0.182402,0.105131,0.131712],[0.200164,0.13875,0.121221],[0.38027,0.140809,0.106769],[0.345668,0.315182,0.3484],[0.499999,0.346608,0.376732],[0.163644,0.199362,0.104804],[0.135081,0.121857,0.132218],[0.498781,0.443817,0.451166],[0.925841,0.931702,0.938799],[0.208082,0.138678,0.154934],[0.1849,0.166067,0.189213],[0.375623,0.440097,0.408131],[2.876857214,2.879602691,2.856211343],[0.514966,0.481675,0.525073],[0.379692,0.403246,0.409433],[1.07893968,0.981566,0.998549],[0.970913,0.991069,1.019743901],[2.32956516,2.028961393,2.058936806],[0.121056,0.0874094,0.117498],[1.242306022,0.409433,0.381256],[0.333268,0.362866,0.368105],[0.724634,0.616216,0.609811],[8.372272024,1.940810909,1.919313531],[0.215081,0.16656,0.183373],[0.159827,0.173928,0.160971],[0.173209,0.217374,0.178429],[0.364914,0.392851,0.392753],[3.258063215,3.055232843,3.158432938],[0.969086,0.944354,1.001753137],[0.33521,0.344545,0.435078],[0.563083,0.597303,0.54695],[2.824918949,2.784792896,2.773636287],[2.04203589,1.985002429,1.96329676],[1.972932613,1.905925254,2.000995567],[0.660906,0.638376,0.638797],[0.273916,0.291013,0.275462],[0.197361,0.204497,0.245296],[0.158102,0.190007,0.220325],[0.420387,0.410065,0.391049],[0.185806,0.152663,0.138554],[0.302098,0.146736,0.132355],[0.153148,0.138142,0.140028]],"source":"bytehouse/results/l.json"} ,{"system":"ByteHouse","date":"2022-07-27","machine":"M","tags":["managed","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","C++"],"load_time":745,"data_size":27190000000,"result":[[0.204356,0.124087,0.111343],[0.162147,0.120088,0.129223],[0.138304,0.124968,0.100887],[0.424216,0.193393,0.148192],[0.626537,0.636493,0.701694],[0.700354,0.61407,0.563147],[0.226713,0.107379,0.105274],[0.115582,0.129062,0.135826],[0.908611,0.890668,0.930481],[1.072457112,1.196782563,1.085087466],[0.185372,0.229904,0.228918],[0.210959,0.220222,0.229587],[0.77719,0.751063,0.808261],[3.443675466,3.529152804,3.431081103],[0.918561,0.941661,0.964774],[0.81437,0.826625,0.830821],[2.154593924,2.196733859,2.145739942],[2.002076959,2.010973594,1.968857393],[5.072657424,5.071079422,4.954039807],[0.127813,0.107606,0.105492],[1.344124274,0.76118,0.738414],[0.847975,0.866883,0.790545],[2.17366727,1.90929253,1.956613481],[6.798822715,6.030441596,5.961431634],[0.232659,0.24189,0.225892],[0.22483,0.213993,0.165657],[0.249597,0.23609,0.234343],[0.886731,0.895649,0.93452],[8.905864883,8.909027527,9.119373795],[2.729399515,2.700112742,2.80527209],[0.599962,0.679839,0.657434],[1.120159397,1.130162921,1.114698924],[6.566110112,6.552839157,6.49319341],[4.601181289,4.529338346,4.554859438],[4.54498289,4.497598791,4.527396409],[1.33884046,1.347533604,1.313194291],[0.298073,0.29527,0.27903],[0.163254,0.188463,0.15891],[0.210311,0.197546,0.140187],[0.395194,0.434253,0.45348],[0.175269,0.17503,0.145714],[0.159227,0.126441,0.119968],[0.188247,0.140864,0.117428]],"source":"bytehouse/results/m.json"} ,{"system":"ByteHouse","date":"2022-07-27","machine":"S","tags":["managed","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","C++"],"load_time":745,"data_size":27190000000,"result":[[0.465819,0.116044,0.10382],[0.12678,0.120683,0.178592],[0.19001,0.153998,0.150897],[0.241946,0.125373,0.139151],[1.069480177,1.034297324,1.106595058],[1.562573773,1.206818889,1.221545036],[0.152539,0.122294,0.117231],[0.130834,0.117555,0.132048],[1.599240755,1.514699748,1.542136004],[1.341486754,1.417470413,1.509794379],[0.273263,0.302114,0.37113],[0.323308,0.317832,0.346367],[1.350003276,1.463167781,1.394062227],[6.526322756,6.562415941,6.603599898],[1.657413456,1.617141092,1.658355897],[1.301159782,1.328003217,1.417677445],[4.200100191,4.116794792,4.145844627],[4.083672003,3.939048097,4.009026718],[7.324285002,7.220264513,7.23919483],[0.124951,0.102059,0.120177],[1.358183279,0.815601,0.825568],[0.950995,0.890438,0.994714],[2.508912285,1.891410174,1.924645465],[9.532990518,6.816463253,6.810721155],[0.288955,0.257077,0.323011],[0.287261,0.252905,0.301686],[0.352302,0.289875,0.325013],[0.8885,0.853163,0.90298],[11.996772143,11.335378584,10.928031696],[3.223346367,3.274467765,3.039989844],[1.076384222,1.121689429,1.066842857],[1.584906113,1.634423718,1.636641605],[11.265273648,11.250953518,11.265621391],[6.284396525,6.419369583,6.503485024],[6.301652951,6.381827207,6.450726416],[1.645218925,1.660535448,1.591234664],[0.290394,0.268129,0.259014],[0.209527,0.20071,0.271621],[0.168356,0.156549,0.17388],[0.459272,0.45036,0.456921],[0.15138,0.149573,0.137896],[0.130298,0.127121,0.13154],[0.159379,0.147829,0.111582]],"source":"bytehouse/results/s.json"} @@ -342,92 +342,92 @@ ,{"system":"chDB","date":"2023-05-05","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","embedded","stateless","serverless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.2142074100000002,0.06882208100000753,0.06698695899999052],[0.21433474400001273,0.05794623400001342,0.057398905000013656],[0.25145876300001646,0.09365810799999963,0.0927742330000001],[0.43362701600000264,0.09151721000000634,0.09002429299999903],[0.6274811319999856,0.45731702300000165,0.44805708699999514],[1.016439422000019,0.7270457869999802,0.7281644760000177],[0.17415907900002026,0.07338490300000444,0.07135004600002048],[0.15761252199999376,0.06434131999998272,0.06364797699998803],[0.9011239490000094,0.6279251530000067,0.6617304419999925],[1.3989778490000049,0.7784884470000009,0.7991503589999809],[0.6405131490000144,0.288082022999987,0.2907754610000097],[0.7087472860000048,0.3404617630000075,0.34405304700001693],[0.9884754980000139,0.742467481999995,0.7458478129999833],[2.446865468999988,1.077438581999985,1.0773534190000191],[1.1237870280000095,0.860952731999987,0.8733325050000076],[0.7824573620000024,0.5994026669999926,0.603801035999993],[3.0189614590000247,2.1247967310000035,2.136651298000004],[2.268133656999993,1.342204492999997,1.3375202990000048],[6.154855214999998,4.1472972940000545,4.200881827000046],[0.42060202400000435,0.09300883100002011,0.09273820700002489],[9.440000580999993,1.2985261019999825,1.3186195140000336],[11.130420060999995,1.750144492000004,1.7870355000000018],[21.657440298999973,4.191915921000032,4.128165265999996],[55.73274844499997,16.125229505999982,15.999065228999996],[2.6613450219999777,0.5245296020000296,0.44928111000001536],[0.8606326020000097,0.41947248600001785,0.42714392499999576],[2.6127060599999936,0.4240091479999819,0.4173263879999922],[9.625697985999977,1.537415798999973,1.5635347990000241],[10.62851167499997,10.254705237999985,10.246708373000047],[1.3997938080000267,1.2829287249999766,1.3373195980000219],[2.629494959999988,0.8007238929999971,0.8009190960000296],[6.257382670000027,1.0821710089999783,1.0986213179999709],[7.894820188999972,5.682761884999991,5.684027975000049],[10.944004618000008,4.332272504000002,4.397889952000014],[10.888015042000006,4.304654096000036,4.363871365000023],[1.245383650000008,0.9663471250000839,0.9393379179999783],[10.02239869799996,1.5317859549999184,1.6102954730000647],[9.042795040000101,1.4587223329999688,1.4796740619999582],[9.98100896599999,1.5930554510000547,1.5763176469999962],[18.767428479000046,3.416737495999996,3.394079593000015],[2.949028655999996,0.3381267659999594,0.3303272449999213],[2.2183266100000765,0.2911085360000243,0.28956761999995706],[1.3416713980000168,0.31786464999993314,0.25272847500002626]],"source":"chdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"chDB","date":"2023-05-05","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","embedded","stateless","serverless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.25085395600000027,0.13717639500001155,0.10192336299999738],[0.19351914300000317,0.23702443199998413,0.23030831299999477],[0.38653160600000547,0.10727562700000703,0.1079391199999975],[0.5821646519999888,0.11063486399999078,0.10717972199998371],[1.554399705999998,1.2151783790000081,1.2112660370000015],[2.035837005000019,1.4492607999999905,1.3240938330000063],[0.21244647899999336,0.22758840500000588,0.09454707199998325],[0.37854534199999534,0.0806291579999936,0.07829879499999493],[0.8155532019999896,0.407321249000006,0.381915843999991],[1.5566488579999884,0.47072470199998406,0.4231783470000039],[0.7227343300000086,0.2129163369999958,0.2129321280000056],[0.6888460250000037,0.22112879700000576,0.2325982460000091],[0.979024948000017,0.3725961359999985,0.3622014049999791],[2.2554182020000155,0.45391694599999255,0.44524926799999776],[0.9685399139999902,0.41066436499997394,0.39307313000000477],[0.5552744130000065,0.3293312250000042,0.32380252500001916],[2.5407928539999887,0.8057684110000025,0.8117435089999958],[2.480627472000009,0.717416046000011,0.7006543530000044],[4.715823697000019,1.428862315999993,1.3309564099999989],[0.4274330179999879,0.08513459599998896,0.07622262399999613],[9.466044803999978,0.42960786800000506,0.4351132179999979],[11.144097670000008,0.655176608000005,0.5562489730000095],[21.659016025,0.8626887380000028,0.8547264640000094],[55.93614273,5.38185286800001,4.2953555569999935],[2.6935396330000003,0.23816812000001164,0.22127673400001413],[0.8375048199999924,0.20675362399998676,0.20651609999998755],[2.677874332999977,0.18914798399998745,0.19894682300002842],[9.629668981999998,0.5783150890000002,0.5699679560000277],[8.665696378000007,2.074512052999978,2.170078869000008],[1.0702536989999771,0.7750411739999663,0.7929929419999553],[2.597370228999978,0.42321389300002465,0.40198629100001426],[6.139428893999991,0.5609760049999863,0.5218740169999592],[5.420712613999967,1.790675226000019,1.8716358959999866],[10.126479325000048,1.5676798349999785,1.2933676730000343],[10.00519733799996,1.298088000000007,1.408291107000025],[0.7715717759999734,0.45679534399999966,0.38578160100001924],[10.047253146999992,0.46224451500000896,0.5013313469999616],[9.027152569999998,0.4774934599999483,0.45599200899999914],[10.028154845000017,0.48999347899996337,0.5015574689999767],[18.814411635,0.8736013170000092,0.6722256219999849],[3.0613838720000217,0.1627915900000403,0.1635108240000136],[2.376407903000029,0.15505116399998542,0.14369173599999385],[1.335110277999945,0.20318408099996077,0.12870271500003128]],"source":"chdb/results/c6a.metal.json"} ,{"system":"Citus","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","PostgreSQL compatible","column-oriented"],"load_time":1579,"data_size":18980918899,"result":[[7.58503,6.70447,6.52499],[6.33941,5.06063,5.00238],[11.7488,9.86417,9.93223],[12.6306,9.36305,9.17061],[40.6101,39.0803,38.1187],[117.654,113.912,113.441],[10.3404,8.08936,7.70732],[6.31542,4.72821,4.72989],[82.5425,77.2124,76.9219],[91.1776,83.4492,82.4727],[14.5474,10.0815,10.3873],[15.4899,11.2922,11.1877],[19.9794,15.5002,17.4492],[76.9216,72.5172,72.7915],[21.5446,17.5691,18.561],[56.9438,54.6387,53.5745],[75.0977,69.7842,70.0259],[31.3299,27.0267,26.3216],[129.417,122.956,121.182],[3.73386,2.14148,2.12737],[34.6021,27.9727,28.6878],[37.152,29.6193,29.2966],[52.2157,37.8589,37.6994],[181.955,149.08,148.471],[15.4687,11.3138,10.3856],[10.2779,8.46868,8.8324],[14.4687,10.4076,11.4263],[47.009,40.2969,39.6888],[749.946,742.979,744.461],[69.4383,67.5636,67.2128],[27.0317,21.4008,20.9524],[36.6675,25.6347,26.4408],[140.424,130.546,129.738],[106.959,92.033,90.1609],[110.98,94.4787,96.2656],[64.4474,60.1853,60.6816],[6.17549,6.25376,5.87004],[1.99153,1.81776,1.80596],[1.00141,0.800271,0.801975],[7.91778,7.70928,8.33299],[0.929845,0.642076,0.638478],[0.866536,0.683567,0.680218],[0.937823,0.784747,0.765929]],"source":"citus/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"192GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":224.417,"data_size":9940946872,"result":[[0.003,0.004,0.003],[0.77,0.067,0.022],[0.351,0.69,0.045],[0.762,0.072,0.586],[0.324,0.432,0.361],[0.861,0.697,0.786],[0.509,0.054,0.031],[0.035,0.542,0.394],[0.986,0.624,0.64],[0.705,0.658,0.621],[0.295,0.245,0.191],[0.346,0.335,0.295],[0.706,0.808,0.809],[0.856,0.857,0.968],[0.836,0.861,0.983],[0.431,0.434,0.387],[1.55,1.564,1.692],[1.379,1.084,1.405],[3.511,3.56,3.617],[0.072,0.134,0.035],[1.324,2.146,1.026],[1.294,1.591,1.237],[2.004,1.217,2.248],[4.849,6.715,3.885],[0.432,0.354,0.354],[0.365,0.367,0.309],[0.351,0.44,0.394],[1.106,1.224,0.971],[8.116,9.85,9.576],[1.224,1.211,0.82],[0.69,0.646,0.699],[0.865,0.847,0.746],[3.477,2.954,2.843],[2.562,2.985,2.519],[2.451,2.462,2.528],[0.967,0.918,0.883],[0.095,0.089,0.091],[0.049,0.057,0.148],[0.138,0.072,0.07],[0.299,0.195,0.218],[0.058,0.329,0.047],[0.021,0.045,0.027],[0.038,0.029,0.033]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.192GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"24GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":898.272,"data_size":9949087959,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.134,0.151,1.04],[0.481,0.547,0.228],[0.952,0.427,0.56],[2.505,2.465,2.421],[3.252,3.143,3.498],[0.281,0.121,0.139],[0.048,0.042,0.043],[4.113,2.525,2.291],[2.742,2.965,2.652],[1.161,1.069,1.193],[1.555,1.333,1.357],[3.277,3.667,3.194],[4.85,5.542,5.12],[4.442,4.498,4.674],[2.645,2.745,2.731],[11.061,10.301,10.394],[8.293,7.391,7.995],[32.636,30.847,30.519],[0.099,0.133,0.129],[7.746,9.111,5.625],[13.131,6.666,6.92],[24.838,12.782,8.131],[33.065,23.814,46.946],[1.903,1.852,2.352],[1.172,1.294,1.241],[1.913,1.883,1.851],[6.512,5.868,6.225],[58.901,55.853,55.978],[3.891,5.452,4],[2.982,3.194,3.433],[5.779,4.125,4.88],[32.403,35.532,34.985],[27.241,27.673,26.393],[26.661,25.919,28.05],[4.74,4.937,4.659],[0.361,0.175,0.168],[0.079,0.101,0.07],[0.177,0.088,0.072],[0.336,0.341,0.327],[0.231,0.033,0.039],[0.056,0.192,0.027],[0.023,0.021,0.026]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.24GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"360GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":216.929,"data_size":9942386190,"result":[[0.003,0.005,0.003],[0.651,0.021,0.647],[0.307,0.039,0.293],[0.638,0.628,0.14],[0.273,0.303,0.259],[0.585,0.521,0.431],[0.117,0.025,0.066],[0.059,0.032,0.042],[0.61,0.54,1.024],[1.158,1.01,0.534],[0.236,0.234,0.223],[0.289,0.21,0.249],[0.444,0.455,0.454],[0.582,0.592,0.644],[0.739,0.586,0.513],[0.313,0.32,0.369],[1.126,1.175,1.242],[0.838,0.828,0.792],[1.88,2.022,2.056],[0.036,0.058,0.043],[0.95,0.921,1.028],[0.842,0.832,0.827],[0.931,1.435,0.904],[2.66,2.337,5.094],[0.258,0.27,0.235],[0.305,0.214,0.231],[0.257,0.261,0.238],[0.77,1.022,0.812],[5.886,4.937,5.757],[0.655,0.627,0.638],[0.427,0.675,0.476],[0.541,0.595,0.696],[2.303,2.386,1.514],[1.604,1.685,1.776],[1.59,1.616,1.653],[0.621,0.722,0.49],[0.174,0.156,0.093],[0.084,0.046,0.059],[0.061,0.132,0.083],[0.283,0.315,0.207],[0.062,0.316,0.037],[0.21,0.037,0.032],[0.029,0.038,0.052]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.360GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"48GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":313.53,"data_size":9941379875,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.575,0.147,0.015],[0.248,0.775,0.09],[0.789,0.388,0.179],[1.162,1.033,1.021],[1.732,1.498,2.214],[0.128,0.052,0.079],[0.058,0.03,0.047],[1.56,1.619,1.152],[1.958,1.49,1.82],[0.498,0.453,0.45],[0.643,0.797,0.615],[1.818,1.617,2.116],[2.826,2.798,2.674],[2.364,2.222,2.019],[1.275,1.221,1.322],[5.23,4.694,5.178],[3.506,3.187,2.962],[9.025,11.452,10.064],[0.098,0.058,0.09],[4.267,3.073,3.884],[2.856,3.725,2.821],[6.76,3.852,3.267],[15.132,10.307,11.082],[0.956,0.905,0.933],[0.607,0.724,0.662],[0.915,0.917,0.888],[2.453,2.441,2.577],[22.966,24.132,22.6],[1.99,1.856,2.246],[1.629,1.615,1.535],[2.691,2.884,1.926],[14.293,15.228,13.532],[6.949,7.111,9.26],[7.081,8.422,8.627],[3.143,2.628,2.513],[0.193,0.129,0.155],[0.048,0.051,0.086],[0.121,0.07,0.076],[0.37,0.21,0.179],[0.044,0.242,0.04],[0.042,0.031,0.042],[0.151,0.031,0.024]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.48GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"720GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":220.239,"data_size":9941859054,"result":[[0.004,0.004,0.005],[0.118,0.059,0.637],[0.248,0.166,0.036],[0.175,0.516,0.501],[0.222,0.192,0.195],[0.405,0.262,0.264],[0.164,0.054,0.026],[0.058,0.421,0.064],[0.522,0.411,0.549],[0.552,0.451,0.457],[0.245,0.18,0.21],[0.196,0.211,0.178],[0.514,0.266,0.571],[0.662,0.635,0.593],[0.398,0.4,0.365],[0.236,0.223,0.343],[0.665,0.631,0.652],[0.474,0.526,0.469],[1.462,1.219,1.468],[0.032,0.027,0.055],[0.762,1.088,0.477],[0.553,0.502,0.507],[0.928,0.618,0.706],[4.07,3.194,1.992],[0.206,0.163,0.147],[0.128,0.177,0.114],[0.177,0.171,0.172],[0.528,0.647,0.6],[4.037,4.033,4.04],[0.663,0.629,0.65],[0.286,0.302,0.299],[0.395,0.366,0.335],[1.704,1.802,1.76],[1.307,1.265,1.361],[1.276,1.281,1.38],[0.351,0.317,0.319],[0.134,0.12,0.122],[0.07,0.053,0.064],[0.086,0.082,0.087],[0.171,0.18,0.204],[0.063,0.034,0.046],[0.059,0.05,0.044],[0.061,0.049,0.039]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.720GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"96GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":227.755,"data_size":9942057937,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.709,0.039,0.317],[0.163,0.295,0.754],[0.33,0.144,0.813],[0.661,0.869,0.654],[1.315,1.402,1.182],[0.177,0.042,0.07],[0.586,0.052,0.042],[1.178,1.141,1.472],[1.062,1.06,0.875],[0.605,0.374,0.403],[0.492,0.443,0.409],[1.228,1.3,1.254],[2.161,1.633,1.644],[1.493,1.734,1.602],[0.986,0.939,0.823],[3.121,3.165,2.713],[1.867,1.716,3.116],[5.606,7.876,5.516],[0.168,0.262,0.084],[2.063,1.632,1.636],[2.995,3.168,1.861],[2.431,4.313,2.309],[12.271,6.228,7.296],[0.751,0.699,0.659],[0.489,0.475,0.563],[0.692,0.592,0.554],[1.75,1.626,1.768],[14.788,15.976,15.28],[1.456,1.202,1.483],[0.985,1.104,1.059],[2.162,1.552,1.099],[4.401,6.886,6.793],[4.445,4.203,4.891],[4.964,4.319,4.943],[1.4,1.475,1.427],[0.101,0.12,0.119],[0.08,0.088,0.048],[0.122,0.067,0.047],[0.214,0.186,0.263],[0.137,0.025,0.026],[0.157,0.057,0.042],[0.023,0.058,0.037]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.96GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-08","machine":"1430GB","cluster_size":"dedicated","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":225.127,"data_size":9940236142,"result":[[0.014,0.014,0.007],[0.09,0.471,0.027],[0.52,0.029,0.325],[0.332,0.375,0.033],[0.529,0.845,0.54],[0.932,0.752,0.669],[0.356,0.068,0.061],[0.074,0.071,0.037],[0.502,0.421,0.35],[0.401,0.333,0.347],[0.261,0.245,0.139],[0.206,0.263,0.154],[0.229,0.338,0.204],[0.377,0.342,0.291],[0.275,0.284,0.241],[0.173,0.137,0.144],[0.484,0.451,0.492],[0.326,0.327,0.355],[0.975,0.888,0.886],[0.032,0.038,0.053],[0.693,0.566,0.423],[0.345,0.336,0.729],[0.485,0.41,0.377],[2.533,2.148,1.213],[0.177,0.242,0.093],[0.194,0.365,0.239],[0.334,0.218,0.245],[0.773,0.655,0.323],[1.728,1.8,1.713],[0.387,0.408,0.385],[0.195,0.183,0.171],[0.557,0.377,0.24],[1.193,1.251,1.148],[0.707,0.794,0.776],[0.697,0.838,0.857],[0.31,0.229,0.332],[0.15,0.1,0.105],[0.049,0.062,0.045],[0.076,0.065,0.163],[0.219,0.186,0.19],[0.167,0.037,0.037],[0.053,0.037,0.031],[0.039,0.029,0.028]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dedicated.standard.1430GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"dev","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":700.114,"data_size":9944443104,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.114,0.112,0.044],[0.53,0.223,0.231],[0.658,0.321,0.578],[2.042,1.725,1.454],[2.508,2.023,2.725],[0.091,0.091,0.084],[0.033,0.081,0.035],[1.891,2.362,2.009],[2.071,1.951,2.251],[1.077,0.666,0.809],[1.082,0.89,0.977],[2.813,3.022,2.817],[3.666,3.734,3.593],[3.647,3.371,2.7],[2.513,1.743,1.641],[6.708,9.375,8.844],[4.948,6.079,5.46],[26.159,20.86,17.466],[0.395,0.08,0.107],[3.658,3.448,6.485],[6.897,6.948,4.022],[8.765,7.751,4.769],[13.487,27.999,20.242],[1.132,1.961,1.199],[0.799,0.705,0.838],[2.009,1.063,1.744],[3.712,5.554,3.618],[32.808,60.019,32.276],[3.389,2.354,3.351],[1.779,2.202,2.205],[3.687,3.694,2.223],[23.809,16.334,16.007],[19.995,19.951,17.978],[16.47,19.988,19.945],[3.228,2.638,3.916],[0.303,0.103,0.105],[0.257,0.093,0.064],[0.08,0.136,0.066],[0.27,0.275,0.347],[0.055,0.205,0.056],[0.182,0.059,0.033],[0.082,0.176,0.03]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dev.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"192GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":343.743,"data_size":9944304173,"result":[[0.003,0.002,0.002],[0.026,1.152,0.018],[0.088,0.529,0.089],[1.196,0.067,0.062],[0.275,0.266,0.698],[0.498,0.447,1.528],[0.598,0.62,0.034],[0.533,0.026,0.16],[0.676,0.628,0.524],[0.814,0.588,0.571],[0.195,0.296,0.282],[0.215,0.208,0.35],[0.613,0.5,0.781],[0.879,0.708,0.821],[0.601,0.595,0.957],[0.335,0.319,0.326],[1.624,1.323,1.492],[0.877,1.269,0.95],[3.889,2.801,3.879],[0.059,0.077,0.192],[1.162,1.376,0.826],[1.079,0.976,0.823],[2.241,1.161,1.293],[6.01,3.231,6.571],[0.335,0.279,0.269],[0.224,0.253,0.235],[0.335,0.319,0.315],[0.745,0.939,0.725],[6.356,6.294,7.592],[0.77,0.725,0.806],[0.543,0.526,0.473],[0.782,0.832,0.696],[3.412,2.442,2.937],[1.812,1.819,1.889],[2.386,2.62,2.594],[0.795,0.747,0.866],[0.129,0.122,0.102],[0.063,0.086,0.046],[0.063,0.068,0.081],[0.153,0.191,0.229],[0.05,0.061,0.039],[0.046,0.028,0.026],[0.072,0.022,0.019]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.192GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"24GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":763.464,"data_size":9946144862,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.265,0.022,0.022],[0.408,0.24,0.267],[0.994,0.342,0.479],[2.284,1.765,2.514],[3.99,2.548,2.53],[0.187,0.088,0.087],[0.029,0.155,0.029],[2.035,1.852,2.887],[2.812,2.227,2.535],[1.173,1.064,1.109],[1.373,1.144,0.872],[3.742,2.382,3.517],[6.107,3.781,3.69],[3.56,7.737,3.467],[2.87,2.274,2.313],[8.827,10.482,10.345],[6.702,5.775,6.96],[23.942,30.504,28.644],[0.089,0.111,0.105],[10.025,4.656,8.109],[5.292,6.732,6.562],[19.192,7.473,7.452],[41.852,20.429,17.857],[1.486,1.817,2.216],[0.952,1.092,1.101],[1.458,1.779,1.431],[5.706,4.643,4.71],[54.04,52.301,50.632],[3.204,2.606,2.534],[3.222,2.917,2.78],[5.636,3.353,3.353],[24.542,33.083,32.492],[20.607,25.238,20.718],[25.099,20.741,25.281],[4.873,4.468,4.134],[0.144,0.18,0.261],[0.098,0.054,0.059],[0.064,0.075,0.073],[0.436,0.333,0.322],[0.213,0.037,0.043],[0.025,0.029,0.223],[0.027,0.023,0.021]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.24GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"360GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":329.494,"data_size":9944755537,"result":[[0.004,0.004,0.003],[1.018,0.069,1.415],[1.146,0.035,0.188],[1.053,0.047,0.047],[0.267,0.233,0.219],[0.602,0.504,0.609],[0.923,0.673,1.034],[0.837,0.582,0.051],[0.676,0.739,0.481],[0.928,0.626,0.478],[0.312,0.234,0.239],[0.402,0.308,0.232],[0.402,0.513,0.483],[0.548,0.621,0.638],[0.54,0.477,0.516],[0.383,0.298,0.344],[1.156,0.922,0.865],[0.73,0.896,0.651],[1.836,1.689,2.031],[0.032,0.051,0.152],[0.962,0.987,0.591],[0.898,1.133,0.821],[2.602,0.917,1.33],[4.678,2.837,2.668],[0.764,0.29,0.261],[0.148,0.146,0.205],[0.276,0.192,0.28],[0.822,0.907,0.839],[5.19,6.455,5.898],[0.775,0.68,0.657],[0.451,0.436,0.66],[0.488,1.211,0.486],[2.9,2.543,2.817],[1.725,1.921,2.194],[1.76,2.202,1.664],[0.756,0.639,0.867],[0.18,0.228,0.111],[0.1,0.098,0.092],[0.097,0.176,0.076],[0.255,0.384,0.25],[0.183,0.089,0.045],[0.17,0.301,0.031],[0.056,0.063,0.017]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.360GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"48GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":342.555,"data_size":9944039775,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.166,1.205,0.852],[0.185,0.247,0.103],[0.34,0.172,0.261],[1.33,1.641,1.018],[1.569,1.416,1.901],[0.162,0.144,0.058],[0.07,0.04,0.082],[1.404,1.195,1.07],[1.619,1.457,1.155],[0.568,0.48,0.526],[0.74,0.656,0.591],[1.607,1.521,2.311],[4.133,2.108,2.593],[3.2,2.605,2.843],[1.224,1.431,1.814],[6.083,6.614,3.921],[5.476,4.496,2.886],[13.246,9.49,16.402],[0.064,0.057,0.046],[3.035,3.445,2.538],[2.825,2.889,2.424],[5.096,4.32,2.742],[11.694,7.609,14.963],[0.805,1.069,0.957],[0.557,0.57,0.693],[1.085,1.013,1.038],[3.069,3.055,2.036],[22.679,27.661,21.333],[2.542,1.791,1.931],[1.26,1.748,1.249],[3.443,2.476,2.798],[12.3,16.949,15.784],[7.072,6.025,6.006],[5.654,9.278,5.854],[3.19,2.635,3.008],[0.329,0.116,0.286],[0.226,0.081,0.198],[0.064,0.096,0.12],[0.357,0.375,0.211],[0.179,0.092,0.079],[0.216,0.031,0.026],[0.295,0.037,0.156]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.48GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"708GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":332.613,"data_size":9955529328,"result":[[0.008,0.004,0.003],[0.978,0.027,0.131],[0.171,0.034,0.447],[0.851,0.047,1.202],[0.413,0.285,0.157],[0.996,0.269,0.389],[0.119,0.103,0.027],[0.042,0.033,0.103],[0.507,0.414,0.432],[0.448,0.474,0.374],[0.29,0.259,0.145],[0.269,0.193,0.237],[0.361,0.276,0.324],[0.407,0.348,0.355],[0.452,0.405,0.311],[0.208,0.159,0.238],[0.66,0.578,0.617],[0.458,0.464,0.638],[1.284,1.711,1.098],[0.027,0.058,0.052],[0.629,0.83,0.737],[0.502,0.474,0.647],[0.979,0.622,1.044],[1.77,3.892,4.164],[0.248,0.175,0.184],[0.172,0.121,0.114],[0.143,0.349,0.193],[0.459,0.454,0.461],[3.294,3.247,3.36],[0.665,0.483,0.491],[0.24,0.245,0.242],[0.35,0.303,0.352],[1.782,1.407,1.462],[0.916,1.417,1.379],[1.188,1.309,1.2],[0.37,0.383,0.326],[0.103,0.095,0.085],[0.052,0.047,0.067],[0.1,0.085,0.092],[0.179,0.189,0.188],[0.094,0.04,0.052],[0.044,0.042,0.055],[0.027,0.023,0.031]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.708GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"96GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":347.594,"data_size":9946918782,"result":[[0.005,0.002,0.003],[0.127,0.025,1.637],[0.204,1.207,0.082],[1.777,0.287,1.093],[0.64,0.741,0.702],[1.423,1.238,1.37],[0.139,0.128,0.041],[0.101,0.08,0.031],[1.052,0.837,0.902],[1.051,1.13,1.001],[0.406,0.343,0.395],[0.531,0.434,0.395],[1.308,1.559,1.377],[1.649,1.71,2.276],[1.823,1.607,1.604],[0.897,0.995,0.71],[3.035,4.213,2.684],[2.647,2.39,2.203],[6.204,8.062,5.8],[0.134,0.06,0.072],[2.525,1.48,1.432],[3.288,1.977,1.978],[3.821,2.437,1.965],[8.819,11.01,7.518],[0.571,0.666,0.652],[0.453,0.479,0.546],[0.578,0.556,0.553],[1.653,1.512,1.577],[14.345,13.001,13.298],[1.229,1.155,1.454],[1.215,1.164,0.941],[1.591,1.965,1.533],[6.665,6.808,5.717],[4.75,5.407,5.341],[5.569,5.417,5.732],[1.4,1.462,1.651],[0.121,0.188,0.081],[0.047,0.042,0.072],[0.091,0.051,0.06],[0.227,0.208,0.16],[0.05,0.03,0.026],[0.027,0.061,0.037],[0.021,0.017,0.051]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.96GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"dev","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":573.697,"data_size":9944356651,"result":[[0.002,0.003,0.002],[0.11,0.884,0.363],[0.307,0.166,0.245],[0.624,0.485,0.275],[1.616,1.292,1.614],[2.591,2.192,2.484],[0.139,0.069,0.516],[0.105,0.037,0.102],[1.507,2.259,1.592],[2.481,1.774,1.806],[0.559,0.777,0.697],[0.681,0.57,0.92],[1.818,1.888,1.738],[3.266,3.113,4.488],[2.576,2.658,3.535],[1.551,1.555,1.926],[7.342,7.817,6.89],[5.789,6.373,4.137],[28.36,17.62,27.891],[0.06,0.053,0.44],[2.887,5.945,5],[3.713,6.44,3.736],[7.915,4.291,4.111],[11.21,27.281,19.303],[0.896,1.808,1.61],[0.631,1.026,1.015],[1.705,0.942,0.967],[2.979,2.904,5.303],[51.146,50.49,50.144],[2.103,1.933,3.405],[2.998,1.414,2.24],[2.496,3.989,2.741],[23.552,22.336,13.822],[14.086,12.553,19.012],[19.032,12.498,12.244],[3.916,3.466,3.089],[0.215,0.081,0.079],[0.091,0.236,0.041],[0.18,0.046,0.048],[0.378,0.158,0.266],[0.06,0.032,0.182],[0.049,0.132,0.04],[0.025,0.218,0.032]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.dev.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (data lake, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[1.578,0.756,0.793],[2.768,2.082,1.039],[2.57,1.545,1.429],[3.179,1.613,1.137],[1.451,1.401,1.397],[1.707,1.79,1.503],[1.242,0.919,0.961],[0.843,0.929,0.889],[1.44,1.446,1.716],[2.142,2.037,2.654],[1.861,1.528,1.514],[1.616,1.926,1.833],[1.608,1.59,1.669],[2.426,2.573,2.161],[1.645,1.691,1.775],[1.495,1.347,1.63],[3.611,3.167,3.792],[2.648,2.548,2.454],[6.087,5.603,5.713],[1.038,0.719,1.005],[6.092,4.233,3.468],[4.082,4.177,3.945],[6.882,6.795,6.887],[21.255,21.006,21.191],[2.177,1.611,1.773],[1.307,1.213,1.2],[1.94,2.241,1.678],[3.51,3.507,3.526],[10.886,10.748,10.761],[1.18,1.299,1.294],[2.168,2.11,2.026],[3.262,3.06,3.524],[6.162,6.043,6.159],[5.715,5.717,5.722],[5.651,5.696,5.72],[1.915,1.676,1.713],[0.538,0.499,0.472],[0.401,0.448,0.429],[0.399,0.412,0.419],[0.651,0.661,0.647],[0.345,0.365,0.389],[0.372,0.311,0.37],[0.287,0.339,0.306]],"source":"clickhouse-datalake/results/c6a.4xlarge.partitioned.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (data lake, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.276,0.179,0.17],[0.321,0.381,0.292],[0.409,0.415,0.373],[0.384,0.325,0.365],[0.575,0.689,0.749],[0.716,0.69,0.809],[0.363,0.3,0.381],[0.286,0.28,0.355],[0.87,0.672,0.715],[0.871,0.904,1.062],[0.542,0.649,0.605],[0.623,0.623,0.686],[0.752,0.711,0.745],[0.938,0.89,1.002],[0.737,0.825,0.712],[0.629,0.619,0.804],[1.358,1.2,1.299],[1.107,1.113,1.111],[2.082,1.924,2.251],[0.36,0.336,0.381],[2.153,2.042,1.962],[2.441,2.152,2.2],[2.949,3.08,3.299],[8.931,7.83,7.971],[0.749,0.732,0.607],[0.504,0.401,0.49],[0.719,0.654,0.558],[2.19,2.242,2.221],[3.082,2.668,2.535],[0.957,0.79,0.918],[0.954,0.948,0.928],[1.656,1.556,1.186],[2.396,2.381,2.305],[2.929,2.936,3.149],[2.908,2.996,2.92],[0.84,0.824,0.825],[0.546,0.552,0.586],[0.407,0.358,0.36],[0.485,0.524,0.534],[0.701,0.738,0.693],[0.347,0.425,0.355],[0.357,0.362,0.381],[0.293,0.329,0.316]],"source":"clickhouse-datalake/results/c6a.metal.partitioned.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.033,0.042,0.031],[0.127,0.104,0.073],[0.368,0.146,0.131],[1.094,0.132,0.13],[1.264,0.441,0.439],[1.07,0.651,0.618],[0.125,0.111,0.11],[0.122,0.089,0.08],[0.937,0.589,0.585],[1.558,0.702,0.692],[0.771,0.311,0.318],[0.994,0.345,0.328],[1.286,0.76,0.752],[2.628,1.026,1.019],[1.299,0.891,0.893],[0.756,0.613,0.614],[3.099,1.935,1.941],[2.399,1.206,1.203],[6.018,4.231,4.22],[0.256,0.132,0.107],[10.236,1.693,1.763],[11.338,2.156,2.159],[22.178,5.051,5.063],[56.387,17.017,17.051],[2.802,0.454,0.467],[0.933,0.344,0.327],[2.945,0.456,0.424],[9.856,1.971,1.982],[9.751,9.425,9.424],[1.298,1.306,1.288],[2.781,0.686,0.693],[6.547,1.141,1.116],[7.078,4.471,4.375],[10.905,4.451,4.421],[10.964,4.434,4.427],[1.111,1.031,1.043],[0.247,0.149,0.151],[0.137,0.094,0.101],[0.169,0.092,0.101],[0.339,0.258,0.254],[0.134,0.069,0.082],[0.08,0.068,0.077],[0.079,0.065,0.062]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.4xlarge.partitioned.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.1,0.053,0.052],[0.228,0.205,0.202],[0.272,0.204,0.203],[0.385,0.231,0.229],[0.924,0.535,0.52],[0.88,0.769,0.755],[0.228,0.196,0.193],[0.248,0.207,0.21],[0.794,0.701,0.715],[1.319,0.819,0.788],[0.611,0.377,0.386],[0.702,0.422,0.422],[1.011,0.878,0.881],[2.354,1.183,1.153],[1.13,1.008,0.991],[0.754,0.698,0.666],[2.891,2.118,2.131],[2.154,1.399,1.373],[5.762,4.453,4.365],[0.349,0.219,0.21],[9.93,1.798,1.822],[11.35,2.18,2.184],[22.261,5.045,4.926],[56.815,16.303,15.993],[2.62,0.585,0.53],[0.808,0.423,0.423],[2.611,0.582,0.552],[9.79,1.997,1.927],[9.455,9.065,9.017],[1.464,1.369,1.391],[2.477,0.727,0.719],[6.131,1.18,1.166],[6.762,4.486,4.452],[10.905,4.466,4.384],[11.088,4.435,4.379],[1.212,1.1,1.104],[0.267,0.139,0.143],[0.171,0.121,0.116],[0.196,0.128,0.127],[0.325,0.192,0.19],[0.13,0.089,0.094],[0.108,0.089,0.084],[0.129,0.084,0.084]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.4xlarge.single.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.122,0.101,0.108],[0.144,0.13,0.14],[0.309,0.207,0.183],[1.01,0.212,0.187],[1.156,0.433,0.345],[1.162,0.474,0.468],[0.172,0.184,0.154],[0.153,0.137,0.131],[1.049,0.557,0.469],[1.66,0.531,0.578],[0.847,0.258,0.282],[1.143,0.281,0.289],[1.288,0.515,0.485],[2.576,0.562,0.579],[1.214,0.57,0.529],[0.69,0.434,0.401],[2.758,0.871,0.803],[2.598,0.691,0.741],[4.918,1.693,1.594],[0.29,0.165,0.158],[10.372,0.626,0.595],[11.779,0.84,0.793],[22.453,1.705,1.358],[57.223,5.525,5.151],[2.881,0.319,0.293],[1.101,0.241,0.298],[3.186,0.31,0.338],[10.18,0.774,0.714],[8.806,2.291,2.319],[0.793,0.576,0.806],[2.855,0.438,0.454],[6.529,0.598,0.587],[5.535,1.687,1.852],[10.397,1.626,1.744],[10.388,1.614,1.705],[0.52,0.593,0.545],[0.231,0.178,0.207],[0.189,0.117,0.179],[0.168,0.172,0.16],[0.391,0.304,0.284],[0.182,0.15,0.123],[0.14,0.113,0.13],[0.133,0.13,0.125]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.metal.partitioned.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.129,0.059,0.06],[0.217,0.199,0.192],[0.268,0.243,0.34],[0.451,0.237,0.251],[0.918,0.448,0.436],[0.994,0.478,0.447],[0.226,0.201,0.195],[0.254,0.242,0.243],[0.915,0.576,0.576],[1.433,0.587,0.621],[0.711,0.454,0.403],[0.802,0.369,0.379],[0.984,0.562,0.526],[2.359,0.618,0.604],[1.077,0.528,0.523],[0.549,0.464,0.514],[2.457,0.831,0.868],[2.334,0.829,0.724],[4.502,1.588,1.608],[0.331,0.243,0.253],[10.218,0.736,0.699],[11.692,1.05,0.839],[22.713,1.567,1.627],[57.945,5.061,4.701],[2.733,0.401,0.382],[0.906,0.316,0.291],[2.843,0.399,0.373],[10.111,0.688,0.695],[8.424,1.512,1.516],[0.807,0.805,0.815],[2.55,0.454,0.446],[6.148,0.602,0.627],[4.98,1.642,1.649],[10.361,1.502,1.471],[10.328,1.461,1.444],[0.686,0.636,0.641],[0.309,0.227,0.216],[0.184,0.136,0.137],[0.193,0.139,0.143],[0.343,0.254,0.224],[0.158,0.107,0.101],[0.134,0.103,0.098],[0.13,0.095,0.095]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.metal.single.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (web)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c5n.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","serverless","stateless"],"load_time":0.33,"data_size":14557009492,"result":[[0.003,0.002,0.002],[0.723,0.012,0.01],[1.157,0.032,0.029],[1.479,0.046,0.043],[0.926,0.321,0.323],[2.747,0.548,0.553],[0.251,0.019,0.018],[0.096,0.019,0.016],[1.461,0.564,0.572],[1.111,0.616,0.6],[1.107,0.222,0.217],[0.941,0.252,0.238],[1.527,0.58,0.588],[1.583,0.832,0.838],[1.855,0.733,0.683],[0.895,0.404,0.397],[2.682,1.597,1.59],[1.796,1.004,1.026],[4.569,3.061,3.133],[0.648,0.029,0.029],[3.691,0.793,0.758],[4.088,0.923,0.928],[5.969,1.173,1.158],[16.028,3.13,3.082],[1.281,0.294,0.287],[0.92,0.237,0.214],[1.223,0.296,0.289],[3.675,0.826,0.838],[13.169,11.735,11.817],[1.332,1.225,1.246],[1.841,0.528,0.518],[3.059,0.744,0.711],[3.953,2.726,2.893],[4.984,2.735,2.685],[5.345,2.706,2.706],[1.773,0.958,0.944],[0.361,0.082,0.068],[0.25,0.035,0.033],[0.491,0.03,0.037],[0.46,0.138,0.131],[0.32,0.016,0.016],[0.273,0.018,0.017],[0.223,0.013,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse-web/results/c5n.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (web)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","serverless","stateless"],"load_time":0.33,"data_size":14557009492,"result":[[0.097,0.003,0.003],[0.074,0.012,0.012],[0.175,0.022,0.022],[0.236,0.022,0.022],[0.29,0.204,0.184],[0.821,0.2,0.193],[0.085,0.015,0.017],[0.085,0.026,0.025],[0.424,0.251,0.248],[0.48,0.264,0.274],[0.363,0.098,0.098],[0.29,0.086,0.09],[0.665,0.189,0.186],[0.601,0.251,0.245],[0.753,0.225,0.227],[0.241,0.116,0.115],[0.733,0.356,0.349],[0.942,0.268,0.254],[1.379,0.633,0.626],[0.454,0.019,0.021],[4.154,0.259,0.236],[2.204,0.196,0.183],[3.137,0.33,0.294],[10.038,1.126,1.108],[0.666,0.127,0.086],[0.534,0.078,0.078],[1.267,0.148,0.124],[1.435,0.33,0.311],[2.385,1.394,1.381],[0.435,0.403,0.4],[0.787,0.149,0.14],[1.259,0.224,0.213],[1.435,0.794,0.788],[2.148,0.786,0.652],[2.029,0.677,0.655],[0.348,0.17,0.168],[0.514,0.053,0.066],[0.238,0.036,0.038],[0.381,0.036,0.037],[0.426,0.127,0.127],[0.291,0.029,0.026],[0.248,0.025,0.029],[0.283,0.014,0.017]],"source":"clickhouse-web/results/c6a.metal.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2022-11-18","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":504.026,"data_size":14580183513,"result":[[0.002,0.001,0.001],[0.019,0.013,0.011],[0.048,0.027,0.026],[0.432,0.036,0.034],[0.682,0.32,0.318],[0.654,0.512,0.538],[0.028,0.021,0.02],[0.02,0.019,0.015],[0.612,0.555,0.555],[0.87,0.619,0.612],[0.247,0.196,0.208],[0.263,0.229,0.208],[0.603,0.516,0.495],[1.401,0.786,0.787],[0.703,0.65,0.628],[0.547,0.498,0.511],[1.842,1.864,1.807],[1.23,1.103,1.113],[4.878,3.224,3.189],[0.205,0.029,0.016],[9.28,0.801,0.762],[9.827,0.864,0.847],[18.726,1.679,1.696],[42.181,2.599,2.51],[1.772,0.216,0.216],[0.647,0.163,0.158],[2.237,0.231,0.214],[8.837,0.783,0.768],[10.93,10.699,10.662],[1.224,1.224,1.202],[1.422,0.421,0.427],[4.382,0.52,0.511],[4.434,2.888,2.947],[9.39,2.65,2.65],[9.339,2.662,2.658],[1.024,0.915,0.964],[0.128,0.095,0.094],[0.056,0.04,0.043],[0.061,0.036,0.036],[0.239,0.182,0.197],[0.039,0.019,0.02],[0.025,0.013,0.017],[0.02,0.014,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (tuned)","date":"2022-11-18","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":504.026,"data_size":14580183513,"result":[[0.002,0.001,0.001],[0.02,0.01,0.01],[0.046,0.035,0.025],[0.115,0.032,0.031],[0.365,0.299,0.3],[0.531,0.444,0.431],[0.042,0.019,0.018],[0.019,0.014,0.014],[0.745,0.641,0.607],[0.634,0.593,0.577],[0.211,0.176,0.169],[0.226,0.19,0.188],[0.637,0.483,0.482],[1.343,0.755,0.733],[0.658,0.577,0.576],[0.531,0.5,0.521],[1.861,1.679,1.66],[1.136,0.698,0.676],[4.071,3.124,3.121],[0.069,0.022,0.014],[8.678,0.77,0.755],[9.854,0.881,0.867],[16.218,1.344,1.325],[13.598,1.244,1.22],[1.773,0.216,0.21],[0.662,0.159,0.16],[2.247,0.22,0.213],[8.837,0.782,0.752],[7.061,1.026,1.063],[1.346,1.223,1.245],[1.375,0.375,0.42],[4.419,0.521,0.503],[4.457,2.88,2.944],[9.361,2.718,2.64],[9.405,2.614,2.616],[0.998,0.923,0.98],[0.119,0.093,0.097],[0.053,0.043,0.043],[0.055,0.04,0.041],[0.257,0.203,0.219],[0.044,0.02,0.019],[0.029,0.014,0.013],[0.025,0.013,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c5.4xlarge.tuned.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":470.639,"data_size":14472294250,"result":[[0.005,0.002,0.001],[0.052,0.007,0.007],[0.052,0.019,0.019],[0.435,0.029,0.026],[0.914,0.356,0.35],[0.831,0.456,0.449],[0.022,0.022,0.019],[0.049,0.013,0.012],[0.602,0.497,0.489],[0.906,0.546,0.533],[0.2,0.128,0.133],[0.639,0.15,0.151],[1.368,0.585,0.575],[1.722,0.804,0.806],[1.115,0.656,0.641],[0.57,0.53,0.51],[2.388,1.719,1.674],[2.113,0.941,0.921],[5.165,3.43,3.407],[0.348,0.027,0.018],[9.892,0.576,0.556],[10.577,0.67,0.653],[12.949,1.087,1.072],[37.277,2.46,2.428],[2.05,0.174,0.173],[1.132,0.147,0.147],[2.604,0.166,0.165],[9.524,0.652,0.637],[9.399,8.993,8.931],[2.462,2.451,2.456],[1.754,0.462,0.452],[4.614,0.623,0.635],[5.449,3.831,4.013],[11.139,3.306,3.284],[11.103,3.33,3.308],[1.054,0.972,0.989],[0.093,0.055,0.065],[0.037,0.025,0.026],[0.044,0.022,0.021],[0.16,0.114,0.104],[0.036,0.015,0.014],[0.022,0.012,0.01],[0.017,0.012,0.01]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (tuned)","date":"2022-11-18","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":506.939,"data_size":15117484912,"result":[[0.001,0.001,0.001],[0.054,0.011,0.01],[0.046,0.021,0.02],[0.094,0.027,0.026],[0.453,0.331,0.331],[0.562,0.469,0.465],[0.028,0.018,0.018],[0.018,0.013,0.012],[0.778,0.872,0.868],[0.602,0.528,0.516],[0.176,0.339,0.285],[0.302,0.234,0.213],[0.61,0.549,0.521],[1.476,0.761,0.762],[0.711,0.563,0.571],[0.604,0.63,0.617],[1.92,1.851,1.836],[1.119,0.529,0.524],[4.461,3.293,3.297],[0.055,0.018,0.013],[8.747,0.673,0.675],[9.854,0.752,0.739],[16.229,1.519,1.528],[13.744,1.227,1.196],[1.776,0.158,0.165],[0.837,0.132,0.131],[2.352,0.161,0.156],[9.004,0.812,0.79],[7.094,1.113,1.107],[2.597,2.512,2.457],[1.402,0.388,0.395],[4.447,0.605,0.597],[5.316,4.105,4.14],[9.772,3.251,3.27],[9.767,3.278,3.15],[0.988,0.843,0.953],[0.217,0.135,0.145],[0.062,0.051,0.055],[0.069,0.04,0.047],[0.236,0.16,0.158],[0.034,0.016,0.015],[0.022,0.013,0.013],[0.023,0.011,0.014]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.4xlarge.tuned.json"} -,{"hide":true,"system":"ClickHouse (zstd)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":417.533,"data_size":9997826232,"result":[[0.004,0.002,0.001],[0.069,0.017,0.016],[0.073,0.051,0.048],[0.158,0.067,0.066],[1.603,1.545,1.709],[1.225,1.105,1.1],[0.033,0.026,0.024],[0.023,0.021,0.02],[0.71,0.621,0.614],[0.813,0.715,0.713],[0.292,0.231,0.245],[0.35,0.269,0.271],[0.785,0.692,0.704],[1.209,1.044,1.066],[1.034,0.908,0.897],[0.993,0.94,0.909],[2.818,2.595,2.611],[1.804,1.717,1.711],[4.846,4.692,4.714],[0.081,0.025,0.02],[5.511,1.388,1.385],[6.304,1.306,1.293],[11.938,2.406,2.4],[30.031,4.268,4.242],[0.964,0.337,0.335],[0.326,0.264,0.26],[0.997,0.338,0.338],[5.523,1.148,1.14],[7.319,5.744,5.796],[2.235,2.236,2.199],[0.86,0.66,0.664],[3.695,0.772,0.764],[5.044,4.82,4.821],[6.786,4.133,4.093],[6.769,4.11,4.17],[1.289,1.188,1.221],[0.093,0.069,0.075],[0.037,0.033,0.029],[0.047,0.033,0.03],[0.185,0.151,0.155],[0.027,0.021,0.017],[0.02,0.012,0.015],[0.017,0.013,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.4xlarge.zstd.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":137.872,"data_size":14467272630,"result":[[0.03,0.003,0.003],[0.055,0.012,0.013],[0.048,0.02,0.02],[0.586,0.022,0.024],[0.843,0.213,0.199],[1.016,0.18,0.175],[0.024,0.018,0.018],[0.045,0.026,0.026],[0.743,0.26,0.252],[1.015,0.271,0.269],[0.383,0.09,0.093],[0.699,0.103,0.101],[1.208,0.181,0.154],[1.866,0.216,0.19],[1.193,0.194,0.175],[0.507,0.128,0.124],[2.004,0.379,0.355],[1.574,0.255,0.243],[3.505,0.657,0.608],[0.08,0.011,0.012],[9.202,0.14,0.123],[10.663,0.158,0.147],[12.847,0.236,0.206],[35.704,0.57,0.541],[1.806,0.062,0.047],[1.243,0.044,0.04],[2.699,0.06,0.05],[9.516,0.282,0.278],[7.811,1.26,1.249],[0.42,0.409,0.4],[1.443,0.113,0.11],[5.026,0.183,0.153],[4.271,1.126,0.728],[9.322,0.801,0.714],[9.09,0.737,0.676],[0.226,0.187,0.184],[0.088,0.06,0.064],[0.046,0.032,0.034],[0.055,0.025,0.028],[0.189,0.148,0.128],[0.04,0.033,0.017],[0.028,0.018,0.019],[0.024,0.017,0.023]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.metal.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (tuned)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":136.869,"data_size":14571706777,"result":[[0.003,0.001,0.001],[0.046,0.051,0.035],[0.044,0.039,0.04],[0.074,0.025,0.036],[0.231,0.097,0.089],[0.97,0.123,0.12],[0.017,0.018,0.019],[0.03,0.029,0.023],[0.18,0.153,0.137],[0.946,0.269,0.283],[0.116,0.062,0.06],[0.195,0.056,0.059],[1.026,0.158,0.137],[1.575,0.188,0.176],[0.837,0.153,0.161],[0.192,0.122,0.123],[1.767,0.34,0.324],[1.088,0.098,0.098],[3.413,0.891,0.787],[0.039,0.021,0.012],[9.017,0.292,0.258],[10.048,0.286,0.251],[20.084,0.454,0.445],[39.564,0.718,0.741],[1.762,0.056,0.046],[0.894,0.035,0.043],[2.421,0.061,0.047],[10.479,0.447,0.439],[7.089,0.282,0.27],[0.429,0.384,0.395],[1.284,0.093,0.091],[4.753,0.183,0.159],[3.618,1.03,0.714],[8.792,0.636,0.623],[8.765,0.626,0.603],[0.213,0.195,0.206],[0.103,0.074,0.067],[0.047,0.035,0.034],[0.053,0.035,0.033],[0.198,0.166,0.142],[0.035,0.026,0.019],[0.027,0.019,0.027],[0.027,0.014,0.016]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.metal.tuned.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-03-14","machine":"m5d.24xlarge","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":457.716,"data_size":14577617512,"result":[[0.016,0.001,0.001],[0.084,0.011,0.01],[0.051,0.018,0.019],[0.168,0.021,0.021],[0.581,0.189,0.193],[0.652,0.244,0.233],[0.02,0.015,0.015],[0.027,0.023,0.025],[0.491,0.376,0.381],[0.64,0.406,0.401],[0.225,0.134,0.132],[0.25,0.144,0.144],[0.508,0.235,0.214],[1.375,0.316,0.301],[0.561,0.233,0.226],[0.28,0.189,0.186],[1.576,0.69,0.655],[1.194,0.369,0.372],[3.253,1.21,1.14],[0.102,0.029,0.023],[8.583,0.424,0.323],[9.837,0.381,0.369],[18.744,0.846,0.718],[42.086,1.119,1.112],[1.771,0.171,0.114],[0.673,0.085,0.083],[2.287,0.136,0.126],[8.892,0.405,0.361],[7.333,2.971,3.049],[0.801,0.756,0.774],[1.339,0.202,0.197],[4.481,0.278,0.256],[3.866,1.649,1.634],[9.055,1.189,1.105],[8.955,1.259,1.044],[0.396,0.362,0.344],[0.136,0.103,0.113],[0.066,0.046,0.046],[0.097,0.041,0.056],[0.274,0.248,0.208],[0.047,0.024,0.023],[0.026,0.02,0.023],[0.037,0.022,0.039]],"source":"clickhouse/results/m5d.24xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (zstd)","date":"2023-03-14","machine":"m5d.24xlarge","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":394.198,"data_size":9997207883,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.001],[0.042,0.039,0.03],[0.051,0.028,0.027],[0.14,0.029,0.035],[0.248,0.191,0.185],[0.296,0.247,0.251],[0.018,0.017,0.019],[0.025,0.023,0.024],[0.427,0.398,0.384],[0.464,0.412,0.404],[0.221,0.143,0.152],[0.236,0.164,0.156],[0.306,0.236,0.233],[0.702,0.352,0.349],[0.329,0.266,0.321],[0.264,0.219,0.2],[0.881,0.639,0.652],[0.646,0.394,0.36],[2.279,1.23,1.151],[0.087,0.036,0.015],[5.403,0.403,0.377],[6.292,0.475,0.434],[11.918,0.845,0.768],[29.658,1.359,1.268],[0.959,0.13,0.14],[0.321,0.092,0.104],[1.455,0.128,0.119],[5.854,0.428,0.425],[5.267,2.886,2.715],[0.793,0.773,0.767],[0.576,0.212,0.21],[3.811,0.363,0.276],[3.577,1.568,1.64],[5.892,1.272,1.187],[5.825,1.26,1.307],[0.43,0.42,0.37],[0.098,0.109,0.087],[0.044,0.046,0.048],[0.087,0.05,0.042],[0.249,0.201,0.189],[0.049,0.033,0.029],[0.031,0.025,0.014],[0.032,0.021,0.021]],"source":"clickhouse/results/m5d.24xlarge.zstd.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-06-09","machine":"m6i.32xlarge","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":457.716,"data_size":14577617512,"result":[[0.03,0.005,0.005],[0.043,0.013,0.017],[0.056,0.018,0.016],[0.563,0.017,0.015],[0.725,0.184,0.152],[1.038,0.197,0.205],[0.02,0.022,0.016],[0.04,0.026,0.025],[0.541,0.316,0.313],[0.882,0.342,0.331],[0.187,0.108,0.1],[0.544,0.11,0.13],[1.085,0.194,0.195],[1.765,0.299,0.226],[0.961,0.212,0.183],[0.392,0.147,0.164],[1.971,0.522,0.452],[1.322,0.31,0.288],[3.522,0.851,0.864],[0.063,0.019,0.017],[9.149,0.299,0.245],[10.334,0.242,0.269],[19.542,0.553,0.488],[35.625,0.827,0.766],[1.814,0.176,0.137],[1.165,0.089,0.084],[2.569,0.117,0.065],[9.402,0.315,0.226],[7.811,3.556,1.758],[0.476,0.441,0.437],[1.513,0.161,0.197],[4.901,0.25,0.173],[4.006,1.059,1.004],[9.185,1.026,0.808],[9.369,0.786,0.788],[0.354,0.284,0.301],[0.124,0.069,0.065],[0.051,0.036,0.041],[0.085,0.038,0.032],[0.21,0.142,0.143],[0.04,0.033,0.024],[0.022,0.02,0.024],[0.027,0.022,0.018]],"source":"clickhouse/results/m6i.32xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"192GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":224.417,"data_size":9940946872,"result":[[0.003,0.004,0.003],[0.770,0.067,0.022],[0.351,0.690,0.045],[0.762,0.072,0.586],[0.324,0.432,0.361],[0.861,0.697,0.786],[0.509,0.054,0.031],[0.035,0.542,0.394],[0.986,0.624,0.640],[0.705,0.658,0.621],[0.295,0.245,0.191],[0.346,0.335,0.295],[0.706,0.808,0.809],[0.856,0.857,0.968],[0.836,0.861,0.983],[0.431,0.434,0.387],[1.550,1.564,1.692],[1.379,1.084,1.405],[3.511,3.560,3.617],[0.072,0.134,0.035],[1.324,2.146,1.026],[1.294,1.591,1.237],[2.004,1.217,2.248],[4.849,6.715,3.885],[0.432,0.354,0.354],[0.365,0.367,0.309],[0.351,0.440,0.394],[1.106,1.224,0.971],[8.116,9.850,9.576],[1.224,1.211,0.820],[0.690,0.646,0.699],[0.865,0.847,0.746],[3.477,2.954,2.843],[2.562,2.985,2.519],[2.451,2.462,2.528],[0.967,0.918,0.883],[0.095,0.089,0.091],[0.049,0.057,0.148],[0.138,0.072,0.070],[0.299,0.195,0.218],[0.058,0.329,0.047],[0.021,0.045,0.027],[0.038,0.029,0.033]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.192GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"24GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":898.272,"data_size":9949087959,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.134,0.151,1.040],[0.481,0.547,0.228],[0.952,0.427,0.560],[2.505,2.465,2.421],[3.252,3.143,3.498],[0.281,0.121,0.139],[0.048,0.042,0.043],[4.113,2.525,2.291],[2.742,2.965,2.652],[1.161,1.069,1.193],[1.555,1.333,1.357],[3.277,3.667,3.194],[4.850,5.542,5.120],[4.442,4.498,4.674],[2.645,2.745,2.731],[11.061,10.301,10.394],[8.293,7.391,7.995],[32.636,30.847,30.519],[0.099,0.133,0.129],[7.746,9.111,5.625],[13.131,6.666,6.920],[24.838,12.782,8.131],[33.065,23.814,46.946],[1.903,1.852,2.352],[1.172,1.294,1.241],[1.913,1.883,1.851],[6.512,5.868,6.225],[58.901,55.853,55.978],[3.891,5.452,4.000],[2.982,3.194,3.433],[5.779,4.125,4.880],[32.403,35.532,34.985],[27.241,27.673,26.393],[26.661,25.919,28.050],[4.740,4.937,4.659],[0.361,0.175,0.168],[0.079,0.101,0.070],[0.177,0.088,0.072],[0.336,0.341,0.327],[0.231,0.033,0.039],[0.056,0.192,0.027],[0.023,0.021,0.026]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.24GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"360GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":216.929,"data_size":9942386190,"result":[[0.003,0.005,0.003],[0.651,0.021,0.647],[0.307,0.039,0.293],[0.638,0.628,0.140],[0.273,0.303,0.259],[0.585,0.521,0.431],[0.117,0.025,0.066],[0.059,0.032,0.042],[0.610,0.540,1.024],[1.158,1.010,0.534],[0.236,0.234,0.223],[0.289,0.210,0.249],[0.444,0.455,0.454],[0.582,0.592,0.644],[0.739,0.586,0.513],[0.313,0.320,0.369],[1.126,1.175,1.242],[0.838,0.828,0.792],[1.880,2.022,2.056],[0.036,0.058,0.043],[0.950,0.921,1.028],[0.842,0.832,0.827],[0.931,1.435,0.904],[2.660,2.337,5.094],[0.258,0.270,0.235],[0.305,0.214,0.231],[0.257,0.261,0.238],[0.770,1.022,0.812],[5.886,4.937,5.757],[0.655,0.627,0.638],[0.427,0.675,0.476],[0.541,0.595,0.696],[2.303,2.386,1.514],[1.604,1.685,1.776],[1.590,1.616,1.653],[0.621,0.722,0.490],[0.174,0.156,0.093],[0.084,0.046,0.059],[0.061,0.132,0.083],[0.283,0.315,0.207],[0.062,0.316,0.037],[0.210,0.037,0.032],[0.029,0.038,0.052]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.360GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"48GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":313.530,"data_size":9941379875,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.575,0.147,0.015],[0.248,0.775,0.090],[0.789,0.388,0.179],[1.162,1.033,1.021],[1.732,1.498,2.214],[0.128,0.052,0.079],[0.058,0.030,0.047],[1.560,1.619,1.152],[1.958,1.490,1.820],[0.498,0.453,0.450],[0.643,0.797,0.615],[1.818,1.617,2.116],[2.826,2.798,2.674],[2.364,2.222,2.019],[1.275,1.221,1.322],[5.230,4.694,5.178],[3.506,3.187,2.962],[9.025,11.452,10.064],[0.098,0.058,0.090],[4.267,3.073,3.884],[2.856,3.725,2.821],[6.760,3.852,3.267],[15.132,10.307,11.082],[0.956,0.905,0.933],[0.607,0.724,0.662],[0.915,0.917,0.888],[2.453,2.441,2.577],[22.966,24.132,22.600],[1.990,1.856,2.246],[1.629,1.615,1.535],[2.691,2.884,1.926],[14.293,15.228,13.532],[6.949,7.111,9.260],[7.081,8.422,8.627],[3.143,2.628,2.513],[0.193,0.129,0.155],[0.048,0.051,0.086],[0.121,0.070,0.076],[0.370,0.210,0.179],[0.044,0.242,0.040],[0.042,0.031,0.042],[0.151,0.031,0.024]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.48GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"720GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":220.239,"data_size":9941859054,"result":[[0.004,0.004,0.005],[0.118,0.059,0.637],[0.248,0.166,0.036],[0.175,0.516,0.501],[0.222,0.192,0.195],[0.405,0.262,0.264],[0.164,0.054,0.026],[0.058,0.421,0.064],[0.522,0.411,0.549],[0.552,0.451,0.457],[0.245,0.180,0.210],[0.196,0.211,0.178],[0.514,0.266,0.571],[0.662,0.635,0.593],[0.398,0.400,0.365],[0.236,0.223,0.343],[0.665,0.631,0.652],[0.474,0.526,0.469],[1.462,1.219,1.468],[0.032,0.027,0.055],[0.762,1.088,0.477],[0.553,0.502,0.507],[0.928,0.618,0.706],[4.070,3.194,1.992],[0.206,0.163,0.147],[0.128,0.177,0.114],[0.177,0.171,0.172],[0.528,0.647,0.600],[4.037,4.033,4.040],[0.663,0.629,0.650],[0.286,0.302,0.299],[0.395,0.366,0.335],[1.704,1.802,1.760],[1.307,1.265,1.361],[1.276,1.281,1.380],[0.351,0.317,0.319],[0.134,0.120,0.122],[0.070,0.053,0.064],[0.086,0.082,0.087],[0.171,0.180,0.204],[0.063,0.034,0.046],[0.059,0.050,0.044],[0.061,0.049,0.039]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.720GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"96GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":227.755,"data_size":9942057937,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.709,0.039,0.317],[0.163,0.295,0.754],[0.330,0.144,0.813],[0.661,0.869,0.654],[1.315,1.402,1.182],[0.177,0.042,0.070],[0.586,0.052,0.042],[1.178,1.141,1.472],[1.062,1.060,0.875],[0.605,0.374,0.403],[0.492,0.443,0.409],[1.228,1.300,1.254],[2.161,1.633,1.644],[1.493,1.734,1.602],[0.986,0.939,0.823],[3.121,3.165,2.713],[1.867,1.716,3.116],[5.606,7.876,5.516],[0.168,0.262,0.084],[2.063,1.632,1.636],[2.995,3.168,1.861],[2.431,4.313,2.309],[12.271,6.228,7.296],[0.751,0.699,0.659],[0.489,0.475,0.563],[0.692,0.592,0.554],[1.750,1.626,1.768],[14.788,15.976,15.280],[1.456,1.202,1.483],[0.985,1.104,1.059],[2.162,1.552,1.099],[4.401,6.886,6.793],[4.445,4.203,4.891],[4.964,4.319,4.943],[1.400,1.475,1.427],[0.101,0.120,0.119],[0.080,0.088,0.048],[0.122,0.067,0.047],[0.214,0.186,0.263],[0.137,0.025,0.026],[0.157,0.057,0.042],[0.023,0.058,0.037]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.96GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-08","machine":"1430GB","cluster_size":"dedicated","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":225.127,"data_size":9940236142,"result":[[0.014,0.014,0.007],[0.090,0.471,0.027],[0.520,0.029,0.325],[0.332,0.375,0.033],[0.529,0.845,0.540],[0.932,0.752,0.669],[0.356,0.068,0.061],[0.074,0.071,0.037],[0.502,0.421,0.350],[0.401,0.333,0.347],[0.261,0.245,0.139],[0.206,0.263,0.154],[0.229,0.338,0.204],[0.377,0.342,0.291],[0.275,0.284,0.241],[0.173,0.137,0.144],[0.484,0.451,0.492],[0.326,0.327,0.355],[0.975,0.888,0.886],[0.032,0.038,0.053],[0.693,0.566,0.423],[0.345,0.336,0.729],[0.485,0.410,0.377],[2.533,2.148,1.213],[0.177,0.242,0.093],[0.194,0.365,0.239],[0.334,0.218,0.245],[0.773,0.655,0.323],[1.728,1.800,1.713],[0.387,0.408,0.385],[0.195,0.183,0.171],[0.557,0.377,0.240],[1.193,1.251,1.148],[0.707,0.794,0.776],[0.697,0.838,0.857],[0.310,0.229,0.332],[0.150,0.100,0.105],[0.049,0.062,0.045],[0.076,0.065,0.163],[0.219,0.186,0.190],[0.167,0.037,0.037],[0.053,0.037,0.031],[0.039,0.029,0.028]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dedicated.standard.1430GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"dev","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":700.114,"data_size":9944443104,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.114,0.112,0.044],[0.530,0.223,0.231],[0.658,0.321,0.578],[2.042,1.725,1.454],[2.508,2.023,2.725],[0.091,0.091,0.084],[0.033,0.081,0.035],[1.891,2.362,2.009],[2.071,1.951,2.251],[1.077,0.666,0.809],[1.082,0.890,0.977],[2.813,3.022,2.817],[3.666,3.734,3.593],[3.647,3.371,2.700],[2.513,1.743,1.641],[6.708,9.375,8.844],[4.948,6.079,5.460],[26.159,20.860,17.466],[0.395,0.080,0.107],[3.658,3.448,6.485],[6.897,6.948,4.022],[8.765,7.751,4.769],[13.487,27.999,20.242],[1.132,1.961,1.199],[0.799,0.705,0.838],[2.009,1.063,1.744],[3.712,5.554,3.618],[32.808,60.019,32.276],[3.389,2.354,3.351],[1.779,2.202,2.205],[3.687,3.694,2.223],[23.809,16.334,16.007],[19.995,19.951,17.978],[16.470,19.988,19.945],[3.228,2.638,3.916],[0.303,0.103,0.105],[0.257,0.093,0.064],[0.080,0.136,0.066],[0.270,0.275,0.347],[0.055,0.205,0.056],[0.182,0.059,0.033],[0.082,0.176,0.030]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dev.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"192GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":343.743,"data_size":9944304173,"result":[[0.003,0.002,0.002],[0.026,1.152,0.018],[0.088,0.529,0.089],[1.196,0.067,0.062],[0.275,0.266,0.698],[0.498,0.447,1.528],[0.598,0.620,0.034],[0.533,0.026,0.160],[0.676,0.628,0.524],[0.814,0.588,0.571],[0.195,0.296,0.282],[0.215,0.208,0.350],[0.613,0.500,0.781],[0.879,0.708,0.821],[0.601,0.595,0.957],[0.335,0.319,0.326],[1.624,1.323,1.492],[0.877,1.269,0.950],[3.889,2.801,3.879],[0.059,0.077,0.192],[1.162,1.376,0.826],[1.079,0.976,0.823],[2.241,1.161,1.293],[6.010,3.231,6.571],[0.335,0.279,0.269],[0.224,0.253,0.235],[0.335,0.319,0.315],[0.745,0.939,0.725],[6.356,6.294,7.592],[0.770,0.725,0.806],[0.543,0.526,0.473],[0.782,0.832,0.696],[3.412,2.442,2.937],[1.812,1.819,1.889],[2.386,2.620,2.594],[0.795,0.747,0.866],[0.129,0.122,0.102],[0.063,0.086,0.046],[0.063,0.068,0.081],[0.153,0.191,0.229],[0.050,0.061,0.039],[0.046,0.028,0.026],[0.072,0.022,0.019]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.192GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"24GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":763.464,"data_size":9946144862,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.265,0.022,0.022],[0.408,0.240,0.267],[0.994,0.342,0.479],[2.284,1.765,2.514],[3.990,2.548,2.530],[0.187,0.088,0.087],[0.029,0.155,0.029],[2.035,1.852,2.887],[2.812,2.227,2.535],[1.173,1.064,1.109],[1.373,1.144,0.872],[3.742,2.382,3.517],[6.107,3.781,3.690],[3.560,7.737,3.467],[2.870,2.274,2.313],[8.827,10.482,10.345],[6.702,5.775,6.960],[23.942,30.504,28.644],[0.089,0.111,0.105],[10.025,4.656,8.109],[5.292,6.732,6.562],[19.192,7.473,7.452],[41.852,20.429,17.857],[1.486,1.817,2.216],[0.952,1.092,1.101],[1.458,1.779,1.431],[5.706,4.643,4.710],[54.040,52.301,50.632],[3.204,2.606,2.534],[3.222,2.917,2.780],[5.636,3.353,3.353],[24.542,33.083,32.492],[20.607,25.238,20.718],[25.099,20.741,25.281],[4.873,4.468,4.134],[0.144,0.180,0.261],[0.098,0.054,0.059],[0.064,0.075,0.073],[0.436,0.333,0.322],[0.213,0.037,0.043],[0.025,0.029,0.223],[0.027,0.023,0.021]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.24GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"360GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":329.494,"data_size":9944755537,"result":[[0.004,0.004,0.003],[1.018,0.069,1.415],[1.146,0.035,0.188],[1.053,0.047,0.047],[0.267,0.233,0.219],[0.602,0.504,0.609],[0.923,0.673,1.034],[0.837,0.582,0.051],[0.676,0.739,0.481],[0.928,0.626,0.478],[0.312,0.234,0.239],[0.402,0.308,0.232],[0.402,0.513,0.483],[0.548,0.621,0.638],[0.540,0.477,0.516],[0.383,0.298,0.344],[1.156,0.922,0.865],[0.730,0.896,0.651],[1.836,1.689,2.031],[0.032,0.051,0.152],[0.962,0.987,0.591],[0.898,1.133,0.821],[2.602,0.917,1.330],[4.678,2.837,2.668],[0.764,0.290,0.261],[0.148,0.146,0.205],[0.276,0.192,0.280],[0.822,0.907,0.839],[5.190,6.455,5.898],[0.775,0.680,0.657],[0.451,0.436,0.660],[0.488,1.211,0.486],[2.900,2.543,2.817],[1.725,1.921,2.194],[1.760,2.202,1.664],[0.756,0.639,0.867],[0.180,0.228,0.111],[0.100,0.098,0.092],[0.097,0.176,0.076],[0.255,0.384,0.250],[0.183,0.089,0.045],[0.170,0.301,0.031],[0.056,0.063,0.017]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.360GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"48GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":342.555,"data_size":9944039775,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.166,1.205,0.852],[0.185,0.247,0.103],[0.340,0.172,0.261],[1.330,1.641,1.018],[1.569,1.416,1.901],[0.162,0.144,0.058],[0.070,0.040,0.082],[1.404,1.195,1.070],[1.619,1.457,1.155],[0.568,0.480,0.526],[0.740,0.656,0.591],[1.607,1.521,2.311],[4.133,2.108,2.593],[3.200,2.605,2.843],[1.224,1.431,1.814],[6.083,6.614,3.921],[5.476,4.496,2.886],[13.246,9.490,16.402],[0.064,0.057,0.046],[3.035,3.445,2.538],[2.825,2.889,2.424],[5.096,4.320,2.742],[11.694,7.609,14.963],[0.805,1.069,0.957],[0.557,0.570,0.693],[1.085,1.013,1.038],[3.069,3.055,2.036],[22.679,27.661,21.333],[2.542,1.791,1.931],[1.260,1.748,1.249],[3.443,2.476,2.798],[12.300,16.949,15.784],[7.072,6.025,6.006],[5.654,9.278,5.854],[3.190,2.635,3.008],[0.329,0.116,0.286],[0.226,0.081,0.198],[0.064,0.096,0.120],[0.357,0.375,0.211],[0.179,0.092,0.079],[0.216,0.031,0.026],[0.295,0.037,0.156]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.48GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"708GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":332.613,"data_size":9955529328,"result":[[0.008,0.004,0.003],[0.978,0.027,0.131],[0.171,0.034,0.447],[0.851,0.047,1.202],[0.413,0.285,0.157],[0.996,0.269,0.389],[0.119,0.103,0.027],[0.042,0.033,0.103],[0.507,0.414,0.432],[0.448,0.474,0.374],[0.290,0.259,0.145],[0.269,0.193,0.237],[0.361,0.276,0.324],[0.407,0.348,0.355],[0.452,0.405,0.311],[0.208,0.159,0.238],[0.660,0.578,0.617],[0.458,0.464,0.638],[1.284,1.711,1.098],[0.027,0.058,0.052],[0.629,0.830,0.737],[0.502,0.474,0.647],[0.979,0.622,1.044],[1.770,3.892,4.164],[0.248,0.175,0.184],[0.172,0.121,0.114],[0.143,0.349,0.193],[0.459,0.454,0.461],[3.294,3.247,3.360],[0.665,0.483,0.491],[0.240,0.245,0.242],[0.350,0.303,0.352],[1.782,1.407,1.462],[0.916,1.417,1.379],[1.188,1.309,1.200],[0.370,0.383,0.326],[0.103,0.095,0.085],[0.052,0.047,0.067],[0.100,0.085,0.092],[0.179,0.189,0.188],[0.094,0.040,0.052],[0.044,0.042,0.055],[0.027,0.023,0.031]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.708GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"96GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":347.594,"data_size":9946918782,"result":[[0.005,0.002,0.003],[0.127,0.025,1.637],[0.204,1.207,0.082],[1.777,0.287,1.093],[0.640,0.741,0.702],[1.423,1.238,1.370],[0.139,0.128,0.041],[0.101,0.080,0.031],[1.052,0.837,0.902],[1.051,1.130,1.001],[0.406,0.343,0.395],[0.531,0.434,0.395],[1.308,1.559,1.377],[1.649,1.710,2.276],[1.823,1.607,1.604],[0.897,0.995,0.710],[3.035,4.213,2.684],[2.647,2.390,2.203],[6.204,8.062,5.800],[0.134,0.060,0.072],[2.525,1.480,1.432],[3.288,1.977,1.978],[3.821,2.437,1.965],[8.819,11.010,7.518],[0.571,0.666,0.652],[0.453,0.479,0.546],[0.578,0.556,0.553],[1.653,1.512,1.577],[14.345,13.001,13.298],[1.229,1.155,1.454],[1.215,1.164,0.941],[1.591,1.965,1.533],[6.665,6.808,5.717],[4.750,5.407,5.341],[5.569,5.417,5.732],[1.400,1.462,1.651],[0.121,0.188,0.081],[0.047,0.042,0.072],[0.091,0.051,0.060],[0.227,0.208,0.160],[0.050,0.030,0.026],[0.027,0.061,0.037],[0.021,0.017,0.051]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.96GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"dev","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":573.697,"data_size":9944356651,"result":[[0.002,0.003,0.002],[0.110,0.884,0.363],[0.307,0.166,0.245],[0.624,0.485,0.275],[1.616,1.292,1.614],[2.591,2.192,2.484],[0.139,0.069,0.516],[0.105,0.037,0.102],[1.507,2.259,1.592],[2.481,1.774,1.806],[0.559,0.777,0.697],[0.681,0.570,0.920],[1.818,1.888,1.738],[3.266,3.113,4.488],[2.576,2.658,3.535],[1.551,1.555,1.926],[7.342,7.817,6.890],[5.789,6.373,4.137],[28.360,17.620,27.891],[0.060,0.053,0.440],[2.887,5.945,5.000],[3.713,6.440,3.736],[7.915,4.291,4.111],[11.210,27.281,19.303],[0.896,1.808,1.610],[0.631,1.026,1.015],[1.705,0.942,0.967],[2.979,2.904,5.303],[51.146,50.490,50.144],[2.103,1.933,3.405],[2.998,1.414,2.240],[2.496,3.989,2.741],[23.552,22.336,13.822],[14.086,12.553,19.012],[19.032,12.498,12.244],[3.916,3.466,3.089],[0.215,0.081,0.079],[0.091,0.236,0.041],[0.180,0.046,0.048],[0.378,0.158,0.266],[0.060,0.032,0.182],[0.049,0.132,0.040],[0.025,0.218,0.032]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.dev.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (data lake, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[1.578,0.756,0.793],[2.768,2.082,1.039],[2.570,1.545,1.429],[3.179,1.613,1.137],[1.451,1.401,1.397],[1.707,1.790,1.503],[1.242,0.919,0.961],[0.843,0.929,0.889],[1.440,1.446,1.716],[2.142,2.037,2.654],[1.861,1.528,1.514],[1.616,1.926,1.833],[1.608,1.590,1.669],[2.426,2.573,2.161],[1.645,1.691,1.775],[1.495,1.347,1.630],[3.611,3.167,3.792],[2.648,2.548,2.454],[6.087,5.603,5.713],[1.038,0.719,1.005],[6.092,4.233,3.468],[4.082,4.177,3.945],[6.882,6.795,6.887],[21.255,21.006,21.191],[2.177,1.611,1.773],[1.307,1.213,1.200],[1.940,2.241,1.678],[3.510,3.507,3.526],[10.886,10.748,10.761],[1.180,1.299,1.294],[2.168,2.110,2.026],[3.262,3.060,3.524],[6.162,6.043,6.159],[5.715,5.717,5.722],[5.651,5.696,5.720],[1.915,1.676,1.713],[0.538,0.499,0.472],[0.401,0.448,0.429],[0.399,0.412,0.419],[0.651,0.661,0.647],[0.345,0.365,0.389],[0.372,0.311,0.370],[0.287,0.339,0.306]],"source":"clickhouse-datalake/results/c6a.4xlarge.partitioned.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (data lake, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.276,0.179,0.170],[0.321,0.381,0.292],[0.409,0.415,0.373],[0.384,0.325,0.365],[0.575,0.689,0.749],[0.716,0.690,0.809],[0.363,0.300,0.381],[0.286,0.280,0.355],[0.870,0.672,0.715],[0.871,0.904,1.062],[0.542,0.649,0.605],[0.623,0.623,0.686],[0.752,0.711,0.745],[0.938,0.890,1.002],[0.737,0.825,0.712],[0.629,0.619,0.804],[1.358,1.200,1.299],[1.107,1.113,1.111],[2.082,1.924,2.251],[0.360,0.336,0.381],[2.153,2.042,1.962],[2.441,2.152,2.200],[2.949,3.080,3.299],[8.931,7.830,7.971],[0.749,0.732,0.607],[0.504,0.401,0.490],[0.719,0.654,0.558],[2.190,2.242,2.221],[3.082,2.668,2.535],[0.957,0.790,0.918],[0.954,0.948,0.928],[1.656,1.556,1.186],[2.396,2.381,2.305],[2.929,2.936,3.149],[2.908,2.996,2.920],[0.840,0.824,0.825],[0.546,0.552,0.586],[0.407,0.358,0.360],[0.485,0.524,0.534],[0.701,0.738,0.693],[0.347,0.425,0.355],[0.357,0.362,0.381],[0.293,0.329,0.316]],"source":"clickhouse-datalake/results/c6a.metal.partitioned.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.033,0.042,0.031],[0.127,0.104,0.073],[0.368,0.146,0.131],[1.094,0.132,0.130],[1.264,0.441,0.439],[1.070,0.651,0.618],[0.125,0.111,0.110],[0.122,0.089,0.080],[0.937,0.589,0.585],[1.558,0.702,0.692],[0.771,0.311,0.318],[0.994,0.345,0.328],[1.286,0.760,0.752],[2.628,1.026,1.019],[1.299,0.891,0.893],[0.756,0.613,0.614],[3.099,1.935,1.941],[2.399,1.206,1.203],[6.018,4.231,4.220],[0.256,0.132,0.107],[10.236,1.693,1.763],[11.338,2.156,2.159],[22.178,5.051,5.063],[56.387,17.017,17.051],[2.802,0.454,0.467],[0.933,0.344,0.327],[2.945,0.456,0.424],[9.856,1.971,1.982],[9.751,9.425,9.424],[1.298,1.306,1.288],[2.781,0.686,0.693],[6.547,1.141,1.116],[7.078,4.471,4.375],[10.905,4.451,4.421],[10.964,4.434,4.427],[1.111,1.031,1.043],[0.247,0.149,0.151],[0.137,0.094,0.101],[0.169,0.092,0.101],[0.339,0.258,0.254],[0.134,0.069,0.082],[0.080,0.068,0.077],[0.079,0.065,0.062]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.4xlarge.partitioned.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.100,0.053,0.052],[0.228,0.205,0.202],[0.272,0.204,0.203],[0.385,0.231,0.229],[0.924,0.535,0.520],[0.880,0.769,0.755],[0.228,0.196,0.193],[0.248,0.207,0.210],[0.794,0.701,0.715],[1.319,0.819,0.788],[0.611,0.377,0.386],[0.702,0.422,0.422],[1.011,0.878,0.881],[2.354,1.183,1.153],[1.130,1.008,0.991],[0.754,0.698,0.666],[2.891,2.118,2.131],[2.154,1.399,1.373],[5.762,4.453,4.365],[0.349,0.219,0.210],[9.930,1.798,1.822],[11.350,2.180,2.184],[22.261,5.045,4.926],[56.815,16.303,15.993],[2.620,0.585,0.530],[0.808,0.423,0.423],[2.611,0.582,0.552],[9.790,1.997,1.927],[9.455,9.065,9.017],[1.464,1.369,1.391],[2.477,0.727,0.719],[6.131,1.180,1.166],[6.762,4.486,4.452],[10.905,4.466,4.384],[11.088,4.435,4.379],[1.212,1.100,1.104],[0.267,0.139,0.143],[0.171,0.121,0.116],[0.196,0.128,0.127],[0.325,0.192,0.190],[0.130,0.089,0.094],[0.108,0.089,0.084],[0.129,0.084,0.084]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.4xlarge.single.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.122,0.101,0.108],[0.144,0.130,0.140],[0.309,0.207,0.183],[1.010,0.212,0.187],[1.156,0.433,0.345],[1.162,0.474,0.468],[0.172,0.184,0.154],[0.153,0.137,0.131],[1.049,0.557,0.469],[1.660,0.531,0.578],[0.847,0.258,0.282],[1.143,0.281,0.289],[1.288,0.515,0.485],[2.576,0.562,0.579],[1.214,0.570,0.529],[0.690,0.434,0.401],[2.758,0.871,0.803],[2.598,0.691,0.741],[4.918,1.693,1.594],[0.290,0.165,0.158],[10.372,0.626,0.595],[11.779,0.840,0.793],[22.453,1.705,1.358],[57.223,5.525,5.151],[2.881,0.319,0.293],[1.101,0.241,0.298],[3.186,0.310,0.338],[10.180,0.774,0.714],[8.806,2.291,2.319],[0.793,0.576,0.806],[2.855,0.438,0.454],[6.529,0.598,0.587],[5.535,1.687,1.852],[10.397,1.626,1.744],[10.388,1.614,1.705],[0.520,0.593,0.545],[0.231,0.178,0.207],[0.189,0.117,0.179],[0.168,0.172,0.160],[0.391,0.304,0.284],[0.182,0.150,0.123],[0.140,0.113,0.130],[0.133,0.130,0.125]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.metal.partitioned.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.129,0.059,0.060],[0.217,0.199,0.192],[0.268,0.243,0.340],[0.451,0.237,0.251],[0.918,0.448,0.436],[0.994,0.478,0.447],[0.226,0.201,0.195],[0.254,0.242,0.243],[0.915,0.576,0.576],[1.433,0.587,0.621],[0.711,0.454,0.403],[0.802,0.369,0.379],[0.984,0.562,0.526],[2.359,0.618,0.604],[1.077,0.528,0.523],[0.549,0.464,0.514],[2.457,0.831,0.868],[2.334,0.829,0.724],[4.502,1.588,1.608],[0.331,0.243,0.253],[10.218,0.736,0.699],[11.692,1.050,0.839],[22.713,1.567,1.627],[57.945,5.061,4.701],[2.733,0.401,0.382],[0.906,0.316,0.291],[2.843,0.399,0.373],[10.111,0.688,0.695],[8.424,1.512,1.516],[0.807,0.805,0.815],[2.550,0.454,0.446],[6.148,0.602,0.627],[4.980,1.642,1.649],[10.361,1.502,1.471],[10.328,1.461,1.444],[0.686,0.636,0.641],[0.309,0.227,0.216],[0.184,0.136,0.137],[0.193,0.139,0.143],[0.343,0.254,0.224],[0.158,0.107,0.101],[0.134,0.103,0.098],[0.130,0.095,0.095]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.metal.single.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (web)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c5n.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","serverless","stateless"],"load_time":0.330,"data_size":14557009492,"result":[[0.003,0.002,0.002],[0.723,0.012,0.010],[1.157,0.032,0.029],[1.479,0.046,0.043],[0.926,0.321,0.323],[2.747,0.548,0.553],[0.251,0.019,0.018],[0.096,0.019,0.016],[1.461,0.564,0.572],[1.111,0.616,0.600],[1.107,0.222,0.217],[0.941,0.252,0.238],[1.527,0.580,0.588],[1.583,0.832,0.838],[1.855,0.733,0.683],[0.895,0.404,0.397],[2.682,1.597,1.590],[1.796,1.004,1.026],[4.569,3.061,3.133],[0.648,0.029,0.029],[3.691,0.793,0.758],[4.088,0.923,0.928],[5.969,1.173,1.158],[16.028,3.130,3.082],[1.281,0.294,0.287],[0.920,0.237,0.214],[1.223,0.296,0.289],[3.675,0.826,0.838],[13.169,11.735,11.817],[1.332,1.225,1.246],[1.841,0.528,0.518],[3.059,0.744,0.711],[3.953,2.726,2.893],[4.984,2.735,2.685],[5.345,2.706,2.706],[1.773,0.958,0.944],[0.361,0.082,0.068],[0.250,0.035,0.033],[0.491,0.030,0.037],[0.460,0.138,0.131],[0.320,0.016,0.016],[0.273,0.018,0.017],[0.223,0.013,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse-web/results/c5n.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (web)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","serverless","stateless"],"load_time":0.330,"data_size":14557009492,"result":[[0.097,0.003,0.003],[0.074,0.012,0.012],[0.175,0.022,0.022],[0.236,0.022,0.022],[0.290,0.204,0.184],[0.821,0.200,0.193],[0.085,0.015,0.017],[0.085,0.026,0.025],[0.424,0.251,0.248],[0.480,0.264,0.274],[0.363,0.098,0.098],[0.290,0.086,0.090],[0.665,0.189,0.186],[0.601,0.251,0.245],[0.753,0.225,0.227],[0.241,0.116,0.115],[0.733,0.356,0.349],[0.942,0.268,0.254],[1.379,0.633,0.626],[0.454,0.019,0.021],[4.154,0.259,0.236],[2.204,0.196,0.183],[3.137,0.330,0.294],[10.038,1.126,1.108],[0.666,0.127,0.086],[0.534,0.078,0.078],[1.267,0.148,0.124],[1.435,0.330,0.311],[2.385,1.394,1.381],[0.435,0.403,0.400],[0.787,0.149,0.140],[1.259,0.224,0.213],[1.435,0.794,0.788],[2.148,0.786,0.652],[2.029,0.677,0.655],[0.348,0.170,0.168],[0.514,0.053,0.066],[0.238,0.036,0.038],[0.381,0.036,0.037],[0.426,0.127,0.127],[0.291,0.029,0.026],[0.248,0.025,0.029],[0.283,0.014,0.017]],"source":"clickhouse-web/results/c6a.metal.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2022-11-18","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":504.026,"data_size":14580183513,"result":[[0.002,0.001,0.001],[0.019,0.013,0.011],[0.048,0.027,0.026],[0.432,0.036,0.034],[0.682,0.320,0.318],[0.654,0.512,0.538],[0.028,0.021,0.020],[0.020,0.019,0.015],[0.612,0.555,0.555],[0.870,0.619,0.612],[0.247,0.196,0.208],[0.263,0.229,0.208],[0.603,0.516,0.495],[1.401,0.786,0.787],[0.703,0.650,0.628],[0.547,0.498,0.511],[1.842,1.864,1.807],[1.230,1.103,1.113],[4.878,3.224,3.189],[0.205,0.029,0.016],[9.280,0.801,0.762],[9.827,0.864,0.847],[18.726,1.679,1.696],[42.181,2.599,2.510],[1.772,0.216,0.216],[0.647,0.163,0.158],[2.237,0.231,0.214],[8.837,0.783,0.768],[10.930,10.699,10.662],[1.224,1.224,1.202],[1.422,0.421,0.427],[4.382,0.520,0.511],[4.434,2.888,2.947],[9.390,2.650,2.650],[9.339,2.662,2.658],[1.024,0.915,0.964],[0.128,0.095,0.094],[0.056,0.040,0.043],[0.061,0.036,0.036],[0.239,0.182,0.197],[0.039,0.019,0.020],[0.025,0.013,0.017],[0.020,0.014,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (tuned)","date":"2022-11-18","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":504.026,"data_size":14580183513,"result":[[0.002,0.001,0.001],[0.020,0.010,0.010],[0.046,0.035,0.025],[0.115,0.032,0.031],[0.365,0.299,0.300],[0.531,0.444,0.431],[0.042,0.019,0.018],[0.019,0.014,0.014],[0.745,0.641,0.607],[0.634,0.593,0.577],[0.211,0.176,0.169],[0.226,0.190,0.188],[0.637,0.483,0.482],[1.343,0.755,0.733],[0.658,0.577,0.576],[0.531,0.500,0.521],[1.861,1.679,1.660],[1.136,0.698,0.676],[4.071,3.124,3.121],[0.069,0.022,0.014],[8.678,0.770,0.755],[9.854,0.881,0.867],[16.218,1.344,1.325],[13.598,1.244,1.220],[1.773,0.216,0.210],[0.662,0.159,0.160],[2.247,0.220,0.213],[8.837,0.782,0.752],[7.061,1.026,1.063],[1.346,1.223,1.245],[1.375,0.375,0.420],[4.419,0.521,0.503],[4.457,2.880,2.944],[9.361,2.718,2.640],[9.405,2.614,2.616],[0.998,0.923,0.980],[0.119,0.093,0.097],[0.053,0.043,0.043],[0.055,0.040,0.041],[0.257,0.203,0.219],[0.044,0.020,0.019],[0.029,0.014,0.013],[0.025,0.013,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c5.4xlarge.tuned.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":470.639,"data_size":14472294250,"result":[[0.005,0.002,0.001],[0.052,0.007,0.007],[0.052,0.019,0.019],[0.435,0.029,0.026],[0.914,0.356,0.350],[0.831,0.456,0.449],[0.022,0.022,0.019],[0.049,0.013,0.012],[0.602,0.497,0.489],[0.906,0.546,0.533],[0.200,0.128,0.133],[0.639,0.150,0.151],[1.368,0.585,0.575],[1.722,0.804,0.806],[1.115,0.656,0.641],[0.570,0.530,0.510],[2.388,1.719,1.674],[2.113,0.941,0.921],[5.165,3.430,3.407],[0.348,0.027,0.018],[9.892,0.576,0.556],[10.577,0.670,0.653],[12.949,1.087,1.072],[37.277,2.460,2.428],[2.050,0.174,0.173],[1.132,0.147,0.147],[2.604,0.166,0.165],[9.524,0.652,0.637],[9.399,8.993,8.931],[2.462,2.451,2.456],[1.754,0.462,0.452],[4.614,0.623,0.635],[5.449,3.831,4.013],[11.139,3.306,3.284],[11.103,3.330,3.308],[1.054,0.972,0.989],[0.093,0.055,0.065],[0.037,0.025,0.026],[0.044,0.022,0.021],[0.160,0.114,0.104],[0.036,0.015,0.014],[0.022,0.012,0.010],[0.017,0.012,0.010]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (tuned)","date":"2022-11-18","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":506.939,"data_size":15117484912,"result":[[0.001,0.001,0.001],[0.054,0.011,0.010],[0.046,0.021,0.020],[0.094,0.027,0.026],[0.453,0.331,0.331],[0.562,0.469,0.465],[0.028,0.018,0.018],[0.018,0.013,0.012],[0.778,0.872,0.868],[0.602,0.528,0.516],[0.176,0.339,0.285],[0.302,0.234,0.213],[0.610,0.549,0.521],[1.476,0.761,0.762],[0.711,0.563,0.571],[0.604,0.630,0.617],[1.920,1.851,1.836],[1.119,0.529,0.524],[4.461,3.293,3.297],[0.055,0.018,0.013],[8.747,0.673,0.675],[9.854,0.752,0.739],[16.229,1.519,1.528],[13.744,1.227,1.196],[1.776,0.158,0.165],[0.837,0.132,0.131],[2.352,0.161,0.156],[9.004,0.812,0.790],[7.094,1.113,1.107],[2.597,2.512,2.457],[1.402,0.388,0.395],[4.447,0.605,0.597],[5.316,4.105,4.140],[9.772,3.251,3.270],[9.767,3.278,3.150],[0.988,0.843,0.953],[0.217,0.135,0.145],[0.062,0.051,0.055],[0.069,0.040,0.047],[0.236,0.160,0.158],[0.034,0.016,0.015],[0.022,0.013,0.013],[0.023,0.011,0.014]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.4xlarge.tuned.json"} +,{"hide":true,"system":"ClickHouse (zstd)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":417.533,"data_size":9997826232,"result":[[0.004,0.002,0.001],[0.069,0.017,0.016],[0.073,0.051,0.048],[0.158,0.067,0.066],[1.603,1.545,1.709],[1.225,1.105,1.100],[0.033,0.026,0.024],[0.023,0.021,0.020],[0.710,0.621,0.614],[0.813,0.715,0.713],[0.292,0.231,0.245],[0.350,0.269,0.271],[0.785,0.692,0.704],[1.209,1.044,1.066],[1.034,0.908,0.897],[0.993,0.940,0.909],[2.818,2.595,2.611],[1.804,1.717,1.711],[4.846,4.692,4.714],[0.081,0.025,0.020],[5.511,1.388,1.385],[6.304,1.306,1.293],[11.938,2.406,2.400],[30.031,4.268,4.242],[0.964,0.337,0.335],[0.326,0.264,0.260],[0.997,0.338,0.338],[5.523,1.148,1.140],[7.319,5.744,5.796],[2.235,2.236,2.199],[0.860,0.660,0.664],[3.695,0.772,0.764],[5.044,4.820,4.821],[6.786,4.133,4.093],[6.769,4.110,4.170],[1.289,1.188,1.221],[0.093,0.069,0.075],[0.037,0.033,0.029],[0.047,0.033,0.030],[0.185,0.151,0.155],[0.027,0.021,0.017],[0.020,0.012,0.015],[0.017,0.013,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.4xlarge.zstd.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":137.872,"data_size":14467272630,"result":[[0.030,0.003,0.003],[0.055,0.012,0.013],[0.048,0.020,0.020],[0.586,0.022,0.024],[0.843,0.213,0.199],[1.016,0.180,0.175],[0.024,0.018,0.018],[0.045,0.026,0.026],[0.743,0.260,0.252],[1.015,0.271,0.269],[0.383,0.090,0.093],[0.699,0.103,0.101],[1.208,0.181,0.154],[1.866,0.216,0.190],[1.193,0.194,0.175],[0.507,0.128,0.124],[2.004,0.379,0.355],[1.574,0.255,0.243],[3.505,0.657,0.608],[0.080,0.011,0.012],[9.202,0.140,0.123],[10.663,0.158,0.147],[12.847,0.236,0.206],[35.704,0.570,0.541],[1.806,0.062,0.047],[1.243,0.044,0.040],[2.699,0.060,0.050],[9.516,0.282,0.278],[7.811,1.260,1.249],[0.420,0.409,0.400],[1.443,0.113,0.110],[5.026,0.183,0.153],[4.271,1.126,0.728],[9.322,0.801,0.714],[9.090,0.737,0.676],[0.226,0.187,0.184],[0.088,0.060,0.064],[0.046,0.032,0.034],[0.055,0.025,0.028],[0.189,0.148,0.128],[0.040,0.033,0.017],[0.028,0.018,0.019],[0.024,0.017,0.023]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.metal.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (tuned)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":136.869,"data_size":14571706777,"result":[[0.003,0.001,0.001],[0.046,0.051,0.035],[0.044,0.039,0.040],[0.074,0.025,0.036],[0.231,0.097,0.089],[0.970,0.123,0.120],[0.017,0.018,0.019],[0.030,0.029,0.023],[0.180,0.153,0.137],[0.946,0.269,0.283],[0.116,0.062,0.060],[0.195,0.056,0.059],[1.026,0.158,0.137],[1.575,0.188,0.176],[0.837,0.153,0.161],[0.192,0.122,0.123],[1.767,0.340,0.324],[1.088,0.098,0.098],[3.413,0.891,0.787],[0.039,0.021,0.012],[9.017,0.292,0.258],[10.048,0.286,0.251],[20.084,0.454,0.445],[39.564,0.718,0.741],[1.762,0.056,0.046],[0.894,0.035,0.043],[2.421,0.061,0.047],[10.479,0.447,0.439],[7.089,0.282,0.270],[0.429,0.384,0.395],[1.284,0.093,0.091],[4.753,0.183,0.159],[3.618,1.030,0.714],[8.792,0.636,0.623],[8.765,0.626,0.603],[0.213,0.195,0.206],[0.103,0.074,0.067],[0.047,0.035,0.034],[0.053,0.035,0.033],[0.198,0.166,0.142],[0.035,0.026,0.019],[0.027,0.019,0.027],[0.027,0.014,0.016]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.metal.tuned.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-03-14","machine":"m5d.24xlarge","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":457.716,"data_size":14577617512,"result":[[0.016,0.001,0.001],[0.084,0.011,0.010],[0.051,0.018,0.019],[0.168,0.021,0.021],[0.581,0.189,0.193],[0.652,0.244,0.233],[0.020,0.015,0.015],[0.027,0.023,0.025],[0.491,0.376,0.381],[0.640,0.406,0.401],[0.225,0.134,0.132],[0.250,0.144,0.144],[0.508,0.235,0.214],[1.375,0.316,0.301],[0.561,0.233,0.226],[0.280,0.189,0.186],[1.576,0.690,0.655],[1.194,0.369,0.372],[3.253,1.210,1.140],[0.102,0.029,0.023],[8.583,0.424,0.323],[9.837,0.381,0.369],[18.744,0.846,0.718],[42.086,1.119,1.112],[1.771,0.171,0.114],[0.673,0.085,0.083],[2.287,0.136,0.126],[8.892,0.405,0.361],[7.333,2.971,3.049],[0.801,0.756,0.774],[1.339,0.202,0.197],[4.481,0.278,0.256],[3.866,1.649,1.634],[9.055,1.189,1.105],[8.955,1.259,1.044],[0.396,0.362,0.344],[0.136,0.103,0.113],[0.066,0.046,0.046],[0.097,0.041,0.056],[0.274,0.248,0.208],[0.047,0.024,0.023],[0.026,0.020,0.023],[0.037,0.022,0.039]],"source":"clickhouse/results/m5d.24xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (zstd)","date":"2023-03-14","machine":"m5d.24xlarge","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":394.198,"data_size":9997207883,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.001],[0.042,0.039,0.030],[0.051,0.028,0.027],[0.140,0.029,0.035],[0.248,0.191,0.185],[0.296,0.247,0.251],[0.018,0.017,0.019],[0.025,0.023,0.024],[0.427,0.398,0.384],[0.464,0.412,0.404],[0.221,0.143,0.152],[0.236,0.164,0.156],[0.306,0.236,0.233],[0.702,0.352,0.349],[0.329,0.266,0.321],[0.264,0.219,0.200],[0.881,0.639,0.652],[0.646,0.394,0.360],[2.279,1.230,1.151],[0.087,0.036,0.015],[5.403,0.403,0.377],[6.292,0.475,0.434],[11.918,0.845,0.768],[29.658,1.359,1.268],[0.959,0.130,0.140],[0.321,0.092,0.104],[1.455,0.128,0.119],[5.854,0.428,0.425],[5.267,2.886,2.715],[0.793,0.773,0.767],[0.576,0.212,0.210],[3.811,0.363,0.276],[3.577,1.568,1.640],[5.892,1.272,1.187],[5.825,1.260,1.307],[0.430,0.420,0.370],[0.098,0.109,0.087],[0.044,0.046,0.048],[0.087,0.050,0.042],[0.249,0.201,0.189],[0.049,0.033,0.029],[0.031,0.025,0.014],[0.032,0.021,0.021]],"source":"clickhouse/results/m5d.24xlarge.zstd.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-06-09","machine":"m6i.32xlarge","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":457.716,"data_size":14577617512,"result":[[0.030,0.005,0.005],[0.043,0.013,0.017],[0.056,0.018,0.016],[0.563,0.017,0.015],[0.725,0.184,0.152],[1.038,0.197,0.205],[0.020,0.022,0.016],[0.040,0.026,0.025],[0.541,0.316,0.313],[0.882,0.342,0.331],[0.187,0.108,0.100],[0.544,0.110,0.130],[1.085,0.194,0.195],[1.765,0.299,0.226],[0.961,0.212,0.183],[0.392,0.147,0.164],[1.971,0.522,0.452],[1.322,0.310,0.288],[3.522,0.851,0.864],[0.063,0.019,0.017],[9.149,0.299,0.245],[10.334,0.242,0.269],[19.542,0.553,0.488],[35.625,0.827,0.766],[1.814,0.176,0.137],[1.165,0.089,0.084],[2.569,0.117,0.065],[9.402,0.315,0.226],[7.811,3.556,1.758],[0.476,0.441,0.437],[1.513,0.161,0.197],[4.901,0.250,0.173],[4.006,1.059,1.004],[9.185,1.026,0.808],[9.369,0.786,0.788],[0.354,0.284,0.301],[0.124,0.069,0.065],[0.051,0.036,0.041],[0.085,0.038,0.032],[0.210,0.142,0.143],[0.040,0.033,0.024],[0.022,0.020,0.024],[0.027,0.022,0.018]],"source":"clickhouse/results/m6i.32xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"CrateDB","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"For some queries it gives \"Data too large\".","tags":["Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":10687,"data_size":109636633416,"result":[[0.008162,0.005118,0.002553],[0.350014,0.39977,0.133775],[2.58426,2.47192,2.59779],[2.12939,0.532981,0.507246],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[1.18488,1.06603,1.07219],[0.209264,0.073284,0.067912],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[1.68892,1.2866,1.47428],[1.62976,1.43073,1.26904],[12.7517,13.0334,13.2685],[18.8587,null,18.6951],[11.2982,11.2108,11.577],[20.2964,20.4035,19.1076],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[0.202044,0.010009,0.005566],[9.22964,4.54606,0.774149],[1.41673,1.09885,0.789775],[12.3933,8.06911,1.69671],[1.45018,0.969528,0.979718],[0.357589,0.14887,0.153326],[0.189282,0.133963,0.130279],[0.153222,0.140756,0.139861],[27.5195,19.6862,20.1825],[72.7575,68.2,67.1238],[144.533,146.579,152.144],[8.76866,9.00563,8.46917],[17.6652,16.6755,16.0558],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[42.2967,44.9621,44.4386],[0.786911,0.4904,0.508416],[0.602075,0.226261,0.182399],[0.131407,0.058958,0.054518],[0.954736,1.1361,1.14233],[0.23764,0.139109,0.134472],[0.110253,0.057695,0.056073],[0.124285,0.150479,0.066226]],"source":"cratedb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":368,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002554,0.002257,0.002058],[0.041885,0.026659,0.026301],[0.377386,0.047169,0.046246],[1.111276,0.043512,0.042424],[1.337056,0.378329,0.378],[1.517051,0.516229,0.513954],[0.040641,0.02423,0.025701],[0.048797,0.029641,0.028597],[1.695267,0.591075,0.582311],[2.82141,0.663166,0.666039],[1.407029,0.255046,0.253865],[1.971179,0.258693,0.254872],[1.548181,0.639874,0.63798],[3.217226,1.0459,1.038888],[1.861833,0.815691,0.806401],[0.768044,0.530842,0.528053],[3.639183,2.567878,2.556752],[2.787874,1.658994,1.6746],[7.466028,4.180932,4.241429],[0.006217,0.003521,0.013345],[10.689073,0.56204,0.551567],[12.984685,0.686805,0.676753],[23.748547,1.311328,1.267505],[6.763271,0.285252,0.273009],[0.132152,0.028291,0.028296],[1.943504,0.226601,0.224721],[0.326737,0.029324,0.027575],[11.538898,0.516586,0.502331],[9.223633,6.920732,6.945943],[0.153429,0.074415,0.073831],[5.458251,0.556813,0.550952],[7.330739,0.895601,0.866605],[7.677006,4.602414,4.704338],[11.838616,2.964448,3.080231],[11.848512,2.947774,3.029332],[0.57868,0.525259,0.491508],[0.086986,0.062111,0.062906],[0.06579,0.032106,0.031138],[0.030254,0.01606,0.017036],[0.124381,0.093671,0.095871],[0.029603,0.019117,0.022236],[0.019694,0.010848,0.016053],[0.019806,0.010239,0.010112]],"source":"databend/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":357,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002354,0.001796,0.001676],[0.03541,0.019995,0.020233],[0.387346,0.031738,0.031385],[1.13763,0.030899,0.030119],[1.405919,0.423186,0.423155],[1.562987,0.578546,0.580928],[0.032613,0.014625,0.014217],[0.032749,0.02213,0.022904],[1.735342,0.53332,0.524569],[2.804289,0.599192,0.595315],[1.369841,0.17547,0.186941],[2.0922,0.181471,0.181655],[1.750355,0.683891,0.67764],[3.213623,1.051686,1.04771],[1.881785,0.830412,0.813682],[0.813736,0.602403,0.591426],[3.880537,2.488562,2.4804],[2.782833,1.3676,1.344967],[7.815274,4.236312,4.263853],[0.006507,0.003202,0.003167],[10.674944,0.451903,0.43883],[12.984352,0.543479,0.531805],[23.749905,1.028132,1.006847],[6.267209,0.20805,0.194846],[0.273405,0.027663,0.027727],[1.813349,0.183311,0.180188],[0.441909,0.027818,0.027427],[11.5565,0.410411,0.397217],[11.878248,11.803086,11.842988],[0.147288,0.058588,0.056877],[5.500723,0.496444,0.488228],[7.438851,0.982329,0.97478],[8.228235,5.575889,5.488849],[12.279272,3.42623,3.439635],[12.288545,3.465759,3.472598],[0.629652,0.542064,0.549532],[0.068277,0.055286,0.062397],[0.028899,0.023338,0.026963],[0.024785,0.016914,0.014623],[0.094073,0.082865,0.088973],[0.024245,0.013744,0.017487],[0.018292,0.009779,0.008906],[0.018714,0.009268,0.009275]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":70,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.073969,0.002969,0.002275],[0.289053,0.0145,0.013984],[0.597566,0.020848,0.022175],[1.241144,0.019701,0.019218],[1.407042,0.266073,0.245832],[1.707674,0.265472,0.272181],[0.037721,0.015296,0.014786],[0.044271,0.019238,0.018279],[1.814285,0.29248,0.287474],[3.034563,0.304214,0.31072],[1.634329,0.286281,0.299248],[1.937083,0.177104,0.188476],[1.52924,0.28984,0.289497],[3.075821,0.461813,0.428307],[1.708843,0.27206,0.275821],[0.83204,0.234342,0.218837],[3.085068,0.494668,0.480146],[2.891979,0.477079,0.457178],[6.122974,0.690913,0.634832],[0.186429,0.004711,0.00394],[10.868874,0.099969,0.086985],[13.480312,0.11198,0.10336],[24.405612,0.431874,0.440055],[10.061871,0.2325,0.242135],[0.647733,0.046068,0.039222],[2.100647,0.046711,0.043591],[1.391526,0.041194,0.039617],[11.536597,0.093705,0.088706],[9.839564,1.566094,1.5916],[0.16243,0.049029,0.049039],[5.631392,0.26343,0.225562],[7.261623,0.304319,0.279184],[5.646363,1.06771,0.910199],[11.17362,0.789665,0.684581],[11.251824,0.766817,0.682614],[0.663092,0.261053,0.272992],[0.40079,0.083889,0.091102],[0.073341,0.021988,0.028371],[0.091126,0.019851,0.013461],[0.151101,0.058686,0.058112],[0.281109,0.016812,0.014878],[0.398818,0.015711,0.022669],[0.222298,0.011058,0.014887]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.metal.json"} -,{"system":"DataFusion (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-07-29","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"v28.0.0 (51b4392)","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[2.641,0.232,0.216],[0.092,0.074,0.073],[0.159,0.121,0.117],[0.351,0.122,0.12],[1.142,0.874,0.869],[1.399,1.303,1.329],[0.096,0.075,0.076],[0.094,0.074,0.076],[1.516,1.481,1.475],[2.711,2.582,2.583],[0.429,0.332,0.327],[0.558,0.357,0.36],[1.374,1.323,1.336],[3.559,2.67,2.733],[1.519,1.487,1.477],[1.041,0.981,0.988],[3.248,2.748,2.801],[3.139,2.696,2.688],[7.014,5.77,5.775],[0.271,0.111,0.109],[9.975,1.558,1.578],[11.163,1.926,1.881],[22.053,4.208,4.194],[56.007,12.132,12.113],[2.559,0.602,0.586],[0.737,0.479,0.489],[2.548,0.589,0.589],[9.55,2.299,2.286],[9.076,5.399,5.388],[0.579,0.568,0.584],[2.214,1.136,1.136],[5.734,1.593,1.598],[8.357,7.896,8.053],[11.556,7.358,7.369],[12.051,7.878,7.956],[1.866,1.82,1.807],[0.448,0.347,0.358],[0.231,0.197,0.195],[0.248,0.198,0.188],[0.843,0.725,0.722],[0.138,0.091,0.095],[0.115,0.089,0.088],[0.124,0.097,0.092]],"source":"datafusion/results/single.json"} -,{"system":"Apache Doris","date":"2022-11-20","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":415,"data_size":17170564642,"result":[[0.07,0.03,0.03],[0.13,0.04,0.04],[0.11,0.04,0.03],[1.12,0.04,0.06],[1.06,1.06,1.05],[0.85,0.78,0.76],[0.01,0.02,0.02],[0.04,0.03,0.03],[0.57,0.56,0.54],[0.61,0.61,0.63],[0.16,0.11,0.11],[0.15,0.13,0.13],[0.59,0.58,0.58],[0.89,0.91,0.88],[0.79,0.77,0.77],[0.37,0.37,0.38],[1.09,1.07,1.09],[0.26,0.26,0.3],[2.1,2.02,2.04],[0.03,0.01,0.02],[10.82,1.14,1.14],[9,2.87,0.94],[12.17,1.29,0.98],[32.09,2.35,2.27],[1.28,0.13,0.14],[0.12,0.13,0.12],[0.14,0.15,0.14],[10.55,1.19,1.18],[10.04,9.56,9.52],[0.71,0.72,0.65],[1.84,0.44,0.42],[2.13,0.5,0.51],[3.17,3.16,3.37],[12,4.4,4.51],[11.83,4.46,4.27],[1.16,1.11,1.12],[0.07,0.05,0.05],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.15,0.14,0.12],[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02]],"source":"doris/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Druid","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Druid is killed and restarted after every query. Otherwise some queries make Druid degraded and results are incorrect. For example after Q13 even SELECT 1 works for 7 seconds","tags":["Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":19620,"data_size":45188608472,"result":[[0.032365,0.016716,0.016921],[0.400766,0.275591,0.271057],[0.38235,0.152084,0.151652],[1.379492,0.137201,0.128902],[3.278731,2.527105,2.515128],[8.576382,6.54654,6.503001],[null,null,null],[0.563852,0.273795,0.275086],[11.509993,10.636571,10.597993],[13.357647,12.42121,12.337247],[1.636875,0.8213,0.900056],[1.692544,0.512066,0.440511],[2.453274,1.769806,1.807207],[8.503408,7.261406,7.334872],[61.056041,59.251083,59.500549],[8.62067,8.236657,8.22538],[164.840762,null,null],[24.165797,22.308466,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[25.973369,25.597864,25.602509],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[7.805347,6.629776,6.947366],[0.257845,0.020327,0.016976],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[32.948154,31.04677,29.221959],[null,null,null],[7.230865,7.033713,6.972421],[20.54625,19.237428,19.258469],[54.065945,52.451318,52.466653],[null,null,null],[17.499267,null,null],[null,null,null],[60.478315,60.05494,60.458946],[1.698088,1.490317,1.461969],[1.409572,0.939003,0.907252],[0.866729,0.329539,0.287435],[null,null,null],[0.932473,0.420781,0.359095],[0.723142,0.3253,0.296865],[0.603483,0.150892,0.140716]],"source":"druid/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":368,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002554,0.002257,0.002058],[0.041885,0.026659,0.026301],[0.377386,0.047169,0.046246],[1.111276,0.043512,0.042424],[1.337056,0.378329,0.378000],[1.517051,0.516229,0.513954],[0.040641,0.024230,0.025701],[0.048797,0.029641,0.028597],[1.695267,0.591075,0.582311],[2.821410,0.663166,0.666039],[1.407029,0.255046,0.253865],[1.971179,0.258693,0.254872],[1.548181,0.639874,0.637980],[3.217226,1.045900,1.038888],[1.861833,0.815691,0.806401],[0.768044,0.530842,0.528053],[3.639183,2.567878,2.556752],[2.787874,1.658994,1.674600],[7.466028,4.180932,4.241429],[0.006217,0.003521,0.013345],[10.689073,0.562040,0.551567],[12.984685,0.686805,0.676753],[23.748547,1.311328,1.267505],[6.763271,0.285252,0.273009],[0.132152,0.028291,0.028296],[1.943504,0.226601,0.224721],[0.326737,0.029324,0.027575],[11.538898,0.516586,0.502331],[9.223633,6.920732,6.945943],[0.153429,0.074415,0.073831],[5.458251,0.556813,0.550952],[7.330739,0.895601,0.866605],[7.677006,4.602414,4.704338],[11.838616,2.964448,3.080231],[11.848512,2.947774,3.029332],[0.578680,0.525259,0.491508],[0.086986,0.062111,0.062906],[0.065790,0.032106,0.031138],[0.030254,0.016060,0.017036],[0.124381,0.093671,0.095871],[0.029603,0.019117,0.022236],[0.019694,0.010848,0.016053],[0.019806,0.010239,0.010112]],"source":"databend/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":357,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002354,0.001796,0.001676],[0.035410,0.019995,0.020233],[0.387346,0.031738,0.031385],[1.137630,0.030899,0.030119],[1.405919,0.423186,0.423155],[1.562987,0.578546,0.580928],[0.032613,0.014625,0.014217],[0.032749,0.022130,0.022904],[1.735342,0.533320,0.524569],[2.804289,0.599192,0.595315],[1.369841,0.175470,0.186941],[2.092200,0.181471,0.181655],[1.750355,0.683891,0.677640],[3.213623,1.051686,1.047710],[1.881785,0.830412,0.813682],[0.813736,0.602403,0.591426],[3.880537,2.488562,2.480400],[2.782833,1.367600,1.344967],[7.815274,4.236312,4.263853],[0.006507,0.003202,0.003167],[10.674944,0.451903,0.438830],[12.984352,0.543479,0.531805],[23.749905,1.028132,1.006847],[6.267209,0.208050,0.194846],[0.273405,0.027663,0.027727],[1.813349,0.183311,0.180188],[0.441909,0.027818,0.027427],[11.556500,0.410411,0.397217],[11.878248,11.803086,11.842988],[0.147288,0.058588,0.056877],[5.500723,0.496444,0.488228],[7.438851,0.982329,0.974780],[8.228235,5.575889,5.488849],[12.279272,3.426230,3.439635],[12.288545,3.465759,3.472598],[0.629652,0.542064,0.549532],[0.068277,0.055286,0.062397],[0.028899,0.023338,0.026963],[0.024785,0.016914,0.014623],[0.094073,0.082865,0.088973],[0.024245,0.013744,0.017487],[0.018292,0.009779,0.008906],[0.018714,0.009268,0.009275]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":70,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.073969,0.002969,0.002275],[0.289053,0.014500,0.013984],[0.597566,0.020848,0.022175],[1.241144,0.019701,0.019218],[1.407042,0.266073,0.245832],[1.707674,0.265472,0.272181],[0.037721,0.015296,0.014786],[0.044271,0.019238,0.018279],[1.814285,0.292480,0.287474],[3.034563,0.304214,0.310720],[1.634329,0.286281,0.299248],[1.937083,0.177104,0.188476],[1.529240,0.289840,0.289497],[3.075821,0.461813,0.428307],[1.708843,0.272060,0.275821],[0.832040,0.234342,0.218837],[3.085068,0.494668,0.480146],[2.891979,0.477079,0.457178],[6.122974,0.690913,0.634832],[0.186429,0.004711,0.003940],[10.868874,0.099969,0.086985],[13.480312,0.111980,0.103360],[24.405612,0.431874,0.440055],[10.061871,0.232500,0.242135],[0.647733,0.046068,0.039222],[2.100647,0.046711,0.043591],[1.391526,0.041194,0.039617],[11.536597,0.093705,0.088706],[9.839564,1.566094,1.591600],[0.162430,0.049029,0.049039],[5.631392,0.263430,0.225562],[7.261623,0.304319,0.279184],[5.646363,1.067710,0.910199],[11.173620,0.789665,0.684581],[11.251824,0.766817,0.682614],[0.663092,0.261053,0.272992],[0.400790,0.083889,0.091102],[0.073341,0.021988,0.028371],[0.091126,0.019851,0.013461],[0.151101,0.058686,0.058112],[0.281109,0.016812,0.014878],[0.398818,0.015711,0.022669],[0.222298,0.011058,0.014887]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.metal.json"} +,{"system":"DataFusion (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-11-19","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"v33.0.0 (d2efaa9)","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.076,0.045,0.045],[0.110,0.061,0.062],[0.200,0.109,0.106],[1.529,0.117,0.113],[2.265,0.832,0.836],[2.652,1.246,1.247],[0.091,0.065,0.071],[0.100,0.063,0.063],[2.465,1.490,1.478],[3.672,2.539,2.496],[1.627,0.344,0.330],[1.885,0.366,0.369],[2.679,1.253,1.236],[6.053,2.504,2.505],[2.885,1.386,1.382],[1.776,0.968,0.927],[5.752,2.709,2.689],[5.639,2.646,2.629],[10.707,5.692,5.799],[1.171,0.100,0.105],[20.537,1.570,1.575],[23.093,1.901,1.897],[44.658,4.103,4.065],[112.447,11.674,11.654],[5.791,0.581,0.558],[2.340,0.511,0.529],[5.823,0.626,0.632],[19.944,2.333,2.343],[17.608,5.052,5.086],[0.557,0.500,0.494],[4.888,1.140,1.126],[11.791,1.553,1.566],[12.415,7.764,7.724],[21.279,6.722,6.816],[21.569,7.325,7.297],[1.981,1.839,1.821],[0.466,0.306,0.312],[0.254,0.185,0.182],[0.284,0.173,0.171],[0.887,0.685,0.667],[0.171,0.092,0.095],[0.144,0.086,0.087],[0.151,0.101,0.097]],"source":"datafusion/results/single.json"} +,{"system":"Apache Doris","date":"2022-11-20","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":415,"data_size":17170564642,"result":[[0.07,0.03,0.03],[0.13,0.04,0.04],[0.11,0.04,0.03],[1.12,0.04,0.06],[1.06,1.06,1.05],[0.85,0.78,0.76],[0.01,0.02,0.02],[0.04,0.03,0.03],[0.57,0.56,0.54],[0.61,0.61,0.63],[0.16,0.11,0.11],[0.15,0.13,0.13],[0.59,0.58,0.58],[0.89,0.91,0.88],[0.79,0.77,0.77],[0.37,0.37,0.38],[1.09,1.07,1.09],[0.26,0.26,0.30],[2.10,2.02,2.04],[0.03,0.01,0.02],[10.82,1.14,1.14],[9.00,2.87,0.94],[12.17,1.29,0.98],[32.09,2.35,2.27],[1.28,0.13,0.14],[0.12,0.13,0.12],[0.14,0.15,0.14],[10.55,1.19,1.18],[10.04,9.56,9.52],[0.71,0.72,0.65],[1.84,0.44,0.42],[2.13,0.50,0.51],[3.17,3.16,3.37],[12.00,4.40,4.51],[11.83,4.46,4.27],[1.16,1.11,1.12],[0.07,0.05,0.05],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.15,0.14,0.12],[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02]],"source":"doris/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"Druid","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Druid is killed and restarted after every query. Otherwise some queries make Druid degraded and results are incorrect. For example after Q13 even SELECT 1 works for 7 seconds","tags":["Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":19620,"data_size":45188608472,"result":[[0.032365,0.016716,0.016921],[0.400766,0.275591,0.271057],[0.382350,0.152084,0.151652],[1.379492,0.137201,0.128902],[3.278731,2.527105,2.515128],[8.576382,6.546540,6.503001],[null,null,null],[0.563852,0.273795,0.275086],[11.509993,10.636571,10.597993],[13.357647,12.421210,12.337247],[1.636875,0.821300,0.900056],[1.692544,0.512066,0.440511],[2.453274,1.769806,1.807207],[8.503408,7.261406,7.334872],[61.056041,59.251083,59.500549],[8.620670,8.236657,8.225380],[164.840762,null,null],[24.165797,22.308466,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[25.973369,25.597864,25.602509],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[7.805347,6.629776,6.947366],[0.257845,0.020327,0.016976],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[32.948154,31.046770,29.221959],[null,null,null],[7.230865,7.033713,6.972421],[20.546250,19.237428,19.258469],[54.065945,52.451318,52.466653],[null,null,null],[17.499267,null,null],[null,null,null],[60.478315,60.054940,60.458946],[1.698088,1.490317,1.461969],[1.409572,0.939003,0.907252],[0.866729,0.329539,0.287435],[null,null,null],[0.932473,0.420781,0.359095],[0.723142,0.325300,0.296865],[0.603483,0.150892,0.140716]],"source":"druid/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"DuckDB (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.06858791799959363,0.044711035000091215,0.042833501000131946],[0.08466665400010243,0.061327259999870876,0.06103660400003719],[0.14877448299967,0.10559172700004638,0.10446714899990184],[0.33234463500002676,0.09389112100006969,0.09252776699986498],[1.1345820209999147,0.5388421589996142,0.5428325200000472],[0.8665522809997128,0.7525683420003588,0.7726315990003059],[0.14739966299976004,0.12885476300016308,0.1280705589997524],[0.08514470599993729,0.0660608250000223,0.06364701199981937],[0.7901016199998594,0.6670942910000122,0.6656622149998839],[1.112716422000176,0.9176106790000631,0.8993262330000107],[0.4155927659999179,0.21104949600021428,0.21018879099983678],[1.0025453209996158,0.2506203090001691,0.24569647199996325],[1.2344316989997424,0.6329478739999104,0.6651636070000677],[2.456399698000041,1.0311697550000645,1.0137859460000982],[0.9334836890002407,0.6877674190000107,0.70905577800022],[0.673465615999703,0.5981919160003599,0.6082133740001154],[2.494906011999774,1.4013747280000644,1.3922408849998646],[2.375765204000345,1.324844154999937,1.3226832469999863],[4.690465237999888,2.3323504360000697,2.3752783559998534],[0.20363476300008188,0.08883917699995436,0.08691825200003223],[9.97606974700011,1.850158613000076,1.8413504770001055],[10.993020309999793,1.688866285000131,1.6903490720001173],[21.570115048999924,3.479486579999957,3.460369050999816],[55.44843658699983,11.133978315999684,11.129654930000015],[2.6089661060000253,0.48738706799986176,0.47928872500006037],[0.7135218759999589,0.3805757249997441,0.35711958900037644],[2.769580591999784,0.4973172830000294,0.4876009600002362],[9.315595299000051,1.488970874000188,1.4658663950003756],[8.170337007999933,4.1328330040000765,4.145880016000319],[4.665519644000142,4.670076305000293,4.6598440840002695],[2.2809909809998317,0.781899636000162,0.7691932829998223],[6.008987953999622,0.9412647040003321,0.9506733889998031],[6.1903129289999015,3.628633594999883,3.815570798999943],[9.97725304100004,2.979070244000013,2.997355967999738],[9.978100522000204,2.992902611000318,3.022268540999903],[0.92484311599992,0.8439210039996397,0.8562627520000206],[0.23992238600021665,0.13403623200019865,0.1317714319998231],[0.1254186490000393,0.09669256999995923,0.09850224299998445],[0.13835749800000485,0.09647460799988039,0.0929961749998256],[0.3313648240000475,0.2376939770001627,0.24857611900006304],[0.07056037899974399,0.05403545599983772,0.051252997999654326],[0.07037150599990127,0.04856322000023283,0.04816857199966762],[0.06874101699986568,0.04819512300036877,0.04709468300006847]],"source":"duckdb-parquet/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"DuckDB","date":"2023-09-26","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded"],"load_time":584,"data_size":25332035584,"result":[[0.026924091999717348,0.003037471999959962,0.0030087130003266793],[0.16772413799981223,0.012932972999806225,0.012755570000081207],[1.2386933419998059,0.03195383900037996,0.03169731600019077],[1.193935569000132,0.05566495500033852,0.055519788000310655],[1.2719721720000052,0.4797815800002354,0.47364618500023425],[1.7204052460001549,0.5739197209995837,0.6044714929998918],[0.13692102499999237,0.016513684000074136,0.016418880999935936],[0.42878113500000836,0.013978246000078798,0.01376930500009621],[2.144393795000269,0.5794733759998962,0.5795776770000884],[2.8978004400000827,0.7554636660001961,0.7576688170001944],[1.4596238879998964,0.18253447699999015,0.18234920899976714],[2.0671171230001164,0.20573082399960185,0.20432037900036448],[2.0727818139998817,0.49253306799982965,0.5038160149997566],[3.3520127649999267,0.8635853699997824,0.8859385079999811],[2.076823574000173,0.5337086039999122,0.5591845710000598],[0.6800219409997226,0.5261602820000917,0.5328403540002],[3.3403330400001323,1.2221616189999622,1.2723400309996578],[3.3052175400002852,1.2275647739998021,1.2696754610001335],[6.236794336999992,2.1919357929996295,2.266641716000322],[0.34883063199958997,0.038191365000329824,0.03821421199972974],[20.648422884999945,0.8656416110002283,0.8617157950002365],[22.367165485999976,0.6310706739996021,0.6244764059997578],[38.236362885999824,0.9444063159999132,0.9462657369999761],[95.79474400300023,4.57907104800006,4.498353044000396],[4.15015750900011,0.1932854189999489,0.18837451800027338],[1.9394079560001956,0.19987759199966604,0.19433718700020108],[4.543052850000095,0.20305141100016044,0.19478781699990577],[20.80425411499982,0.5468405399997209,0.5366565440003797],[14.24943101000008,4.494378264999796,4.4872481480001625],[0.7351944990000447,0.6778340149999167,0.6781058520000443],[4.485817211999802,0.4642300189998423,0.472603571000036],[7.575815559000148,0.6107541849996778,0.629833944999973],[7.22739360200012,4.044819612000083,4.163989215000129],[20.450376160999895,2.465135957000257,2.461840141999801],[20.466968382999767,2.605108253999788,2.608107234000272],[0.8528685460000816,0.6727260970001225,0.6969227390000015],[0.11805038800002876,0.03027148999990459,0.0272187630002918],[0.07883884800003216,0.015259446000072785,0.012236310999924171],[0.09153883999988466,0.017189998000048945,0.013864642000044114],[0.1759261150000384,0.06460375899996507,0.06465984499982369],[0.09337568199998714,0.00883036599998377,0.007896293999692716],[0.08930611300002056,0.008033808000163845,0.007339697000134038],[0.06956559599984757,0.009394902000167349,0.009093027000290022]],"source":"duckdb/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"DuckDB","date":"2023-09-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded"],"load_time":557,"data_size":25409892352,"result":[[0.028086780999728944,0.002414253000097233,0.0021636960000250838],[0.46563523099985105,0.010625985999922705,0.01016174400001546],[0.8891034559997024,0.025961164999898756,0.025551394000103755],[1.2264355699999214,0.03623923299983289,0.036103159000049345],[1.2716879180002252,0.3992600950000451,0.39979254900026717],[1.7464284959996803,0.476917694000349,0.4876424449998922],[0.3640209790000881,0.014415404999908787,0.013864879999800905],[0.4231801880000603,0.011493789000269317,0.011028166999949462],[1.9182373680000637,0.4695572649998212,0.473022095000033],[2.8863619510002536,0.6202132429998528,0.6272343959999489],[1.469674029000089,0.15033233000031032,0.1493539050002255],[2.122888372000034,0.16747449600006803,0.16623175400036416],[2.19689435600003,0.41368822100002944,0.4245434929998737],[3.353093207999791,0.7176920880001489,0.7419013379999342],[2.106729788999928,0.45157940500030236,0.45956111399982547],[0.7618140450003921,0.44360254799994436,0.4438193040000442],[3.3160554369997044,1.0091327439999986,1.0501606820002962],[3.2899087420000797,0.9937532539997846,1.0319792189998225],[6.147077066000293,1.8601839829998426,1.7930358930002512],[0.5478519510002116,0.029630810000071506,0.029407205000097747],[20.476412891999644,0.7287512409998271,0.7185980860003838],[22.457170643000154,0.5557742740002141,0.5497367680000025],[38.57942790900006,0.7984957059998123,0.7973248660000536],[96.20789085900014,3.8985825760000807,3.8594193190001533],[4.189989236000201,0.16466093799999726,0.1578326910002943],[2.0615221919997566,0.16868170299994745,0.1622597460000179],[4.6220101120002255,0.17378973800032327,0.1636861649999446],[20.925809684999876,0.4753908990001037,0.46921747900023547],[14.220432916999926,3.337972157999957,3.3373912329998348],[0.584624170999632,0.4804462130000502,0.4832376250001289],[4.546239200999935,0.39545450399964466,0.3945328300001165],[7.614473170999645,0.5206363369998144,0.5212976839998191],[6.800434293000308,3.344280624000021,3.4436193860001367],[20.560247130000334,2.172507063000012,2.1904886800002714],[20.578359694000028,2.2406041530002767,2.3070416179998574],[0.7716577450000841,0.5659581239997351,0.5712790600000517],[0.15594478200000594,0.02518773699966914,0.023627209000096627],[0.10974644699990677,0.012240085000030376,0.01144400700013648],[0.12063824999995632,0.01217633400028717,0.01063554699976521],[0.24521544600020206,0.04823300399993968,0.0470517949997884],[0.13470358900030988,0.007704704999923706,0.006628890000229148],[0.13843043999986548,0.006789723999645503,0.006517027999962011],[0.08625227099992117,0.0081432560000394,0.00758258299993031]],"source":"duckdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"DuckDB","date":"2023-09-26","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded"],"load_time":143.93,"data_size":28223746048,"result":[[0.03236215499964601,0.001631959999940591,0.0017349720001220703],[0.2017167620001601,0.004977931000212266,0.004112590999739041],[1.7824451350002164,0.01057577699975809,0.00924506499995914],[1.5068001750000803,0.011147404999974242,0.008505592999881628],[1.9968912629997249,0.3409851499995966,0.3641603260002739],[2.19996057499975,0.42094028299970887,0.37727264799968907],[0.21778730100004395,0.009304663999955665,0.006554180999955861],[0.6552495579999231,0.00758900300024834,0.006111935000262747],[3.237778974000321,0.37195273199995427,0.37644760800003496],[4.101916444999915,0.3916224780000448,0.4356481650002024],[1.981583973999932,0.10101389099963853,0.0828059509999548],[2.5021246000001156,0.12936520600032964,0.06469776399990224],[2.0287027350000244,0.2671814919999633,0.2580042009999488],[5.0058850400000665,2.5847008529999584,0.9242121399997814],[2.3203943019998405,0.23897008799985997,0.2951310849998663],[0.9209703480000826,0.37256716299998516,0.20133301800024128],[3.6552786790002756,0.49283485800015114,0.4653434940000807],[3.684886160000133,0.5913837480002258,0.6050533939996967],[6.08533725999996,1.1212222939998355,1.2291971190002187],[0.7086644400001205,0.012204473000110738,0.011541186000158632],[22.877518454999972,0.24069266800006517,0.14223928199999136],[24.865264503000162,0.11923907699974734,0.09882567700014988],[44.523412047999955,0.43662231000007523,0.2732989429996451],[106.65310618600006,2.291449360000115,1.0823644299998705],[4.273118970999803,0.11639817900004346,0.04853129599996464],[1.9446537600001648,0.18474681899988354,0.07775153500006127],[4.282858682999631,0.1974552310002764,0.07218202500007465],[22.900311010999758,0.16852921000008791,0.137986748000003],[15.712022881999928,1.605772540000089,1.495060542000374],[0.35286867500008157,0.12376627899993764,0.09917158700000073],[4.9339620559999275,0.19886905099974683,0.25272748499992304],[7.844819150999683,0.2757238479998705,0.3000885700002982],[6.1183534870001495,1.578629292000187,1.6954807430001892],[22.53793776099974,1.0309925289998318,1.407939608000106],[22.57955366799979,1.7960458739999012,2.255313027000284],[0.6876235540003108,0.331532089999655,0.2276349650001066],[1.1719605680000313,0.061066774999744666,0.040371307999976125],[1.5213748269998177,0.04644827699985399,0.03365288300028624],[1.7530375439996533,0.05019643499963422,0.02876765000019077],[3.1484079319998273,0.09479282800020883,0.059220590999757405],[2.582429621999836,0.03467660899968905,0.013035046999902988],[3.2146319700000276,0.03065071499986516,0.013175667999803409],[1.291933348999919,0.027330930000061926,0.011119961000076728]],"source":"duckdb/results/c6a.metal.json"} -,{"system":"Elasticsearch","date":"2022-07-20","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 1500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Java","search"],"load_time":10071.796,"data_size":76633643596,"result":[[0,0,0],[0.53,1.667,1.67],[13.977,14.071,13.991],[6.761,6.694,6.744],[4.38,4.413,4.432],[156.644,156.142,156.421],[6.252,6.206,6.301],[1.721,1.714,1.709],[16,16.05,16.432],[32.227,32.35,32.389],[1.784,1.778,1.772],[2.22,2.212,2.214],[5.197,5.25,5.201],[5.238,5.187,5.191],[5.564,5.598,5.63],[5.512,5.589,5.455],[12.825,12.748,12.841],[12.315,12.394,12.167],[36.529,36.493,36.737],[0.002,0.002,0.002],[13.372,13.321,13.418],[16.461,16.487,16.459],[26.246,25.728,25.837],[13.416,13.365,13.541],[1.028,1.045,1.026],[1.286,1.288,1.297],[1.028,1.03,1.032],[116.649,117.058,117.61],[null,null,null],[1480.142,1484.714,1483.256],[2.193,2.155,2.157],[2.238,2.233,2.257],[8.843,8.538,8.611],[16.879,16.863,16.949],[16.787,16.85,16.853],[47.658,46.439,46.566],[10.1,10.095,10.063],[7.803,7.834,7.821],[10.097,9.961,10.188],[16.014,16.064,16.065],[0.143,0.144,0.144],[0.13,0.131,0.131],[0.337,0.337,0.336]],"source":"elasticsearch/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"hide":true,"system":"Elasticsearch (tuned)","date":"2022-07-25","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 1500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Tuned by repeated benchmark to find the optimal Elasticsearch shard number and size for this resource type and workload","tags":["Java","search"],"load_time":5264.429,"data_size":91680375082,"result":[[0,0,0],[0.195,0.38,0.381],[3.559,3.504,3.493],[1.972,1.632,1.609],[1.066,1.055,1.065],[42.797,41.784,41.63],[1.575,1.561,1.565],[0.387,0.385,0.401],[4.005,4.042,3.985],[7.786,7.81,7.91],[0.613,0.489,0.494],[0.667,0.604,0.6],[1.467,1.401,1.413],[1.473,1.491,1.477],[1.592,1.524,1.526],[1.334,1.318,1.314],[3.203,3.192,3.219],[3.104,3.108,3.107],[8.973,9.051,9.087],[0.038,0.002,0.002],[8.41,4.558,4.55],[5.904,5.417,5.425],[12.761,9.118,9.103],[4.534,4.537,4.542],[0.326,0.294,0.288],[0.411,0.369,0.369],[0.292,0.292,0.291],[40.03,34.1,34.044],[null,null,null],[380.687,385.475,388.004],[0.746,0.542,0.538],[1.989,0.564,0.551],[1.993,2.019,1.997],[5.635,5.286,5.257],[5.242,5.207,5.266],[11.442,11.569,11.639],[3.625,3.604,3.583],[3.063,2.916,2.92],[3.581,3.494,3.497],[5.54,5.206,5.227],[0.108,0.025,0.026],[0.059,0.021,0.023],[0.071,0.071,0.071]],"source":"elasticsearch/results/c6a.4xlarge.tuned.json"} +,{"system":"Elasticsearch","date":"2022-07-20","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 1500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Java","search"],"load_time":10071.796,"data_size":76633643596,"result":[[0,0,0],[0.5300,1.6670,1.6700],[13.9770,14.0710,13.9910],[6.7610,6.6940,6.7440],[4.3800,4.4130,4.4320],[156.6440,156.1420,156.4210],[6.2520,6.2060,6.3010],[1.7210,1.7140,1.7090],[16.0000,16.0500,16.4320],[32.2270,32.3500,32.3890],[1.7840,1.7780,1.7720],[2.2200,2.2120,2.2140],[5.1970,5.2500,5.2010],[5.2380,5.1870,5.1910],[5.5640,5.5980,5.6300],[5.5120,5.5890,5.4550],[12.8250,12.7480,12.8410],[12.3150,12.3940,12.1670],[36.5290,36.4930,36.7370],[0.0020,0.0020,0.0020],[13.3720,13.3210,13.4180],[16.4610,16.4870,16.4590],[26.2460,25.7280,25.8370],[13.4160,13.3650,13.5410],[1.0280,1.0450,1.0260],[1.2860,1.2880,1.2970],[1.0280,1.0300,1.0320],[116.6490,117.0580,117.6100],[null,null,null],[1480.1420,1484.7140,1483.2560],[2.1930,2.1550,2.1570],[2.2380,2.2330,2.2570],[8.8430,8.5380,8.6110],[16.8790,16.8630,16.9490],[16.7870,16.8500,16.8530],[47.6580,46.4390,46.5660],[10.1000,10.0950,10.0630],[7.8030,7.8340,7.8210],[10.0970,9.9610,10.1880],[16.0140,16.0640,16.0650],[0.1430,0.1440,0.1440],[0.1300,0.1310,0.1310],[0.3370,0.3370,0.3360]],"source":"elasticsearch/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"hide":true,"system":"Elasticsearch (tuned)","date":"2022-07-25","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 1500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Tuned by repeated benchmark to find the optimal Elasticsearch shard number and size for this resource type and workload","tags":["Java","search"],"load_time":5264.429,"data_size":91680375082,"result":[[0,0,0],[0.1950,0.3800,0.3810],[3.5590,3.5040,3.4930],[1.9720,1.6320,1.6090],[1.0660,1.0550,1.0650],[42.7970,41.7840,41.6300],[1.5750,1.5610,1.5650],[0.3870,0.3850,0.4010],[4.0050,4.0420,3.9850],[7.7860,7.8100,7.9100],[0.6130,0.4890,0.4940],[0.6670,0.6040,0.6000],[1.4670,1.4010,1.4130],[1.4730,1.4910,1.4770],[1.5920,1.5240,1.5260],[1.3340,1.3180,1.3140],[3.2030,3.1920,3.2190],[3.1040,3.1080,3.1070],[8.9730,9.0510,9.0870],[0.0380,0.0020,0.0020],[8.4100,4.5580,4.5500],[5.9040,5.4170,5.4250],[12.7610,9.1180,9.1030],[4.5340,4.5370,4.5420],[0.3260,0.2940,0.2880],[0.4110,0.3690,0.3690],[0.2920,0.2920,0.2910],[40.0300,34.1000,34.0440],[null,null,null],[380.6870,385.4750,388.0040],[0.7460,0.5420,0.5380],[1.9890,0.5640,0.5510],[1.9930,2.0190,1.9970],[5.6350,5.2860,5.2570],[5.2420,5.2070,5.2660],[11.4420,11.5690,11.6390],[3.6250,3.6040,3.5830],[3.0630,2.9160,2.9200],[3.5810,3.4940,3.4970],[5.5400,5.2060,5.2270],[0.1080,0.0250,0.0260],[0.0590,0.0210,0.0230],[0.0710,0.0710,0.0710]],"source":"elasticsearch/results/c6a.4xlarge.tuned.json"} ,{"system":"Greenplum","date":"2022-08-18","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","column-oriented","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":1080,"data_size":42000000000,"result":[[2.19644,1.27581,1.07334],[1.36821,1.09289,1.00081],[1.84455,1.93433,1.9734],[1.38533,1.07306,0.997511],[10.4301,10.1377,10.0064],[3.24183,3.67479,3.23526],[1.81177,1.22447,1.72696],[1.28568,1.12341,1.02112],[3.5159,3.7946,3.51106],[5.78795,5.90487,5.95635],[1.50773,1.80496,1.26395],[1.68682,1.93425,1.54081],[2.29378,2.75715,2.22458],[3.41812,3.09848,3.0303],[2.96859,2.96836,2.9949],[3.04409,3.00935,2.98848],[4.10668,3.98626,4.00533],[3.51045,3.14617,3.02558],[9.31981,9.03239,9.00459],[0.563991,0.853628,0.971569],[8.40649,3.29997,3.82986],[9.52108,3.52917,3.86565],[18.4842,4.56174,4.67819],[50.449,16.4463,16.4923],[1.96056,1.59658,1.85278],[1.76567,1.51262,1.52955],[2.11338,1.81927,1.92422],[8.6392,5.18686,5.77986],[51.8749,52.0756,52.2289],[63.6736,63.868,63.3526],[2.92731,2.88967,2.96908],[4.83141,3.88826,3.41858],[42.2016,40.1165,39.4692],[14.5369,10.3602,10.4522],[14.7224,10.829,10.8651],[5.32702,5.79151,5.20852],[0.339799,0.158694,0.160555],[0.173487,0.112253,0.112419],[0.158136,0.102158,0.101214],[0.341324,0.263589,0.24586],[0.171119,0.109181,0.108795],[0.178617,0.117175,0.117738],[0.205935,0.137013,0.137252]],"source":"greenplum/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"HeavyAI","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous names: OmniSci, mapD. Many queries cannot run due to errors and limitations.","tags":["C++","column-oriented"],"load_time":572.633,"data_size":50887437386,"result":[[6.525,0.022,0.029],[0.301,0.042,0.04],[0.287,0.095,0.093],[2.572,0.039,0.04],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[7.327,0.093,0.097],[0.244,0.043,0.038],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[2.939,0.295,0.294],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[4.716,3.91,3.955],[null,null,null],[0.154,0.083,0.106],[14.426,0.07,0.071],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[2.276,0.258,0.272],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[1.832,1.64,1.602],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[14.811,0.494,0.497],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[1.941,0.255,0.255],[5.457,0.172,0.283],[0.476,0.269,0.256],[14.239,0.179,0.178],[3.992,0.112,0.112],[1.031,0.116,0.116],[1.365,0.089,0.088]],"source":"heavyai/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Hydra","date":"2023-09-19","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","PostgreSQL compatible","column-oriented"],"load_time":1222,"data_size":18995669982,"result":[[0.381752,0.249001,0.243783],[0.261088,0.211013,0.209277],[0.6692,0.634666,0.627473],[0.545165,0.431892,0.439854],[22.4371,21.8547,21.731],[34.8689,33.0467,32.5865],[0.410038,0.377206,0.376254],[0.22464,0.206133,0.204092],[27.1582,26.4292,26.5203],[30.1541,29.4784,30.2199],[3.31616,2.76618,2.75128],[3.55764,3.28978,3.27316],[7.74401,7.64012,7.6384],[10.703,10.2599,10.2098],[8.70712,8.33702,8.29268],[17.9937,17.5084,17.5291],[22.8406,22.2649,22.1176],[4.08958,3.59194,3.61345],[39.0156,37.7258,37.8926],[0.267125,0.233304,0.233594],[3.12914,2.74305,2.72563],[2.91522,2.89177,2.90416],[3.76881,3.62139,3.62348],[26.322,20.5805,20.3337],[1.69125,1.05602,1.06068],[1.06135,0.828339,0.831532],[1.26898,1.06035,1.05212],[4.17896,4.03193,4.03657],[43.0503,42.5091,42.3298],[7.89438,7.50181,7.39528],[9.33451,8.76728,8.79973],[15.0403,14.6597,14.3034],[58.8221,58.6056,58.6859],[34.2914,35.0405,34.2519],[36.3141,35.6205,36.5728],[14.2056,13.8882,13.8284],[0.367202,0.33666,0.33517],[0.22008,0.172653,0.167434],[0.15307,0.126572,0.126678],[1.11688,0.671288,0.696326],[0.160667,0.145181,0.141243],[0.137686,0.122734,0.118493],[0.197786,0.123078,0.122094]],"source":"hydra/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Infobright","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Only 90% of data successfully loaded. Some queries run for days.","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":2317,"data_size":13760341294,"result":[[0.01,0,0],[2.39,2.4,2.44],[0,0,0],[7.21,6.04,6.91],[16.09,16.86,15.69],[48.8,42.37,48.63],[0,0,0],[3.48,2.42,2.42],[23.56,24.78,22.21],[32.87,31.71,34.48],[14.8,14.83,14.11],[16.7,16.53,17.37],[1752.91,1999.88,1961.4],[1193.43,1167,1220.47],[2184.81,2316.12,2224.14],[32.58,30.69,31.58],[300.17,16221.33,16168.44],[122.4,120.49,124.67],[78927.44,79250.44,78504.89],[3.38,1.22,1.21],[289.73,302.3,285.83],[415.82,389.23,403.28],[573.82,590.81,575.06],[300.13,293.96,285.64],[41.42,37.48,39.64],[75.2,75.37,72.07],[39.22,41.52,40.11],[449.56,445.03,448.68],[null,null,null],[450.87,488.3,453.83],[58.69,59.29,58.07],[84.47,78.92,79.38],[517.97,520.29,504.96],[182468.89,182468.89,182468.89],[182468.89,182468.89,182468.89],[68.43,66.93,67.68],[8.3,3.62,3.61],[1.04,0.62,0.62],[0.22,0.18,0.18],[567.78,566.52,563.02],[0.29,0.14,0.11],[0.17,0.08,0.08],[1.37,1.34,1.32]],"source":"infobright/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Kinetica","date":"2023-01-04","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["column-oriented"],"load_time":1374,"data_size":null,"result":[[0.52,0.048,0.047],[0.504,0.349,0.048],[0.274,0.11,0.047],[1.782,8.797,0.046],[1.835,1.692,0.676],[2.123,1.176,0.203],[0.37,0.094,0.047],[0.149,0.081,0.05],[3.394,3.162,0.556],[3.609,3.344,1.727],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[2.475,2.355,2.269],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[0.109,0.09,0.06],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[2.084,0.173,0.177],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[24.669,23.317,0.093],[3.282,1.192,1.114],[4.848,2.753,2.768],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[0.521,0.1,0.055],[0.182,0.071,0.054],[0.122,0.089,0.053]],"source":"kinetica/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"MariaDB ColumnStore","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: InfiniDB.","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":2507.8,"data_size":19712857022,"result":[[0.151,0.158,0.148],[0.1,0.101,0.106],[1.221,1.233,1.226],[0.739,0.736,0.741],[2.025,2.046,2.004],[3.725,4.801,3.755],[0.871,0.749,0.736],[0.118,0.108,0.103],[2.108,2.029,2.029],[4.225,4.271,4.288],[1.711,1.402,1.407],[1.526,1.435,1.42],[5.339,4.172,3.61],[4.692,4.729,4.96],[4.013,3.86,3.918],[3.236,2.68,2.629],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[0.137,0.109,0.147],[12.331,6.069,8.619],[2.162,2.178,2.192],[16.849,30.463,26.639],[92,90.208,92.814],[3.042,1.763,1.791],[1.779,1.772,1.749],[1.793,1.821,1.888],[13.036,10.747,9.59],[null,null,null],[78.224,79.141,77.806],[2.837,2.654,2.675],[5.833,4.552,3.678],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[3.626,3.546,3.709],[1.719,1.787,1.876],[1.345,0.906,0.91],[0.117,0.091,0.093],[1.217,1.133,1.133],[0.114,0.063,0.062],[0.1,0.062,0.061],[null,null,null]],"source":"mariadb-columnstore/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"MariaDB ColumnStore","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: InfiniDB.","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":2507.8,"data_size":19712857022,"result":[[0.151,0.158,0.148],[0.100,0.101,0.106],[1.221,1.233,1.226],[0.739,0.736,0.741],[2.025,2.046,2.004],[3.725,4.801,3.755],[0.871,0.749,0.736],[0.118,0.108,0.103],[2.108,2.029,2.029],[4.225,4.271,4.288],[1.711,1.402,1.407],[1.526,1.435,1.420],[5.339,4.172,3.610],[4.692,4.729,4.960],[4.013,3.860,3.918],[3.236,2.680,2.629],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[0.137,0.109,0.147],[12.331,6.069,8.619],[2.162,2.178,2.192],[16.849,30.463,26.639],[92,90.208,92.814],[3.042,1.763,1.791],[1.779,1.772,1.749],[1.793,1.821,1.888],[13.036,10.747,9.590],[null,null,null],[78.224,79.141,77.806],[2.837,2.654,2.675],[5.833,4.552,3.678],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[3.626,3.546,3.709],[1.719,1.787,1.876],[1.345,0.906,0.910],[0.117,0.091,0.093],[1.217,1.133,1.133],[0.114,0.063,0.062],[0.100,0.062,0.061],[null,null,null]],"source":"mariadb-columnstore/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"hide":true,"system":"MariaDB","date":"2023-03-16","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"For some reason many queries run in almost exactly one hour. Most likely a coincidence. It is installed from Debian packages, which might explain the abysmal performance.","tags":["C++","row-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":8625,"data_size":104270986073,"result":[[2325.7,2320,2333.78],[2334.78,2332.22,2327.4],[2348.31,2364.93,2375.47],[2378.97,2384.7,2404.94],[2440.64,2424.09,2426.42],[2672.27,2688.11,2690.41],[2431.34,2443.24,2434.15],[2436.65,2428.4,2433.15],[2498.67,2502.58,2489.58],[2530.63,2520.99,2526.05],[3214.94,3152.09,3133.92],[3189.99,3169.31,3148.69],[2554.55,2556.7,2546.32],[8019,8082.98,8090.95],[2610.89,2587.29,2597.82],[2956.4,2965.74,2976.53],[3093.56,3104.46,3100.55],[3050.67,3036.62,3103.31],[3533.67,3477.88,3570.5],[2453.61,2436.78,2427.24],[2521.56,2514.54,2519.21],[2542.57,2540.39,2544.67],[2558.61,2567.56,2563.08],[2579.95,2568.24,2571.27],[2507.4,2522.47,2517.66],[2543.29,2536.27,2528.08],[2532.54,2530.23,2526.74],[2563.83,2548.74,2545.44],[2926.8,2897.01,2920.1],[2940.88,2963.93,2982.09],[2626.55,2621.43,2635.34],[2623.32,2616.79,2583.39],[3729.89,3730.41,3734.37],[3047.16,3063.14,3090.9],[3096.45,3111.46,3103.45],[3124.1,3097.9,3097.01],[20.222,13.586,12.646],[12.03,11.99,12.006],[10.709,11.112,11.187],[14.77,14.692,14.271],[10.71,11.108,11.218],[11.676,11.118,11.19],[null,null,null]],"source":"mariadb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"MonetDB","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","column-oriented"],"load_time":939,"data_size":49696606499,"result":[[0.000218,0.000157,0.000155],[0.101903,0.019908,0.018439],[0.282431,0.035987,0.034938],[2.868,0.029387,0.029207],[4.675,4.515,4.511],[6.584,4.269,4.65],[0.528827,0.063135,0.065742],[0.506863,0.020966,0.021687],[8.343,4.457,4.408],[7.224,6.548,7.576],[0.267003,0.233353,0.230444],[0.347206,0.28358,0.266085],[5.389,3.099,3.074],[7.653,7.759,8.596],[3.276,3.326,3.292],[5.31,3.465,3.578],[9.341,9.143,9.536],[9.584,9.604,9.419],[19.539,19.783,19.611],[0.004509,0.000702,0.000643],[20.801,1.57,1.603],[2.752,0.418221,0.395884],[14.717,0.800894,0.395477],[14.429,1.804,1.869],[1.386,0.159602,0.156426],[0.189736,0.167664,0.168781],[0.164681,0.176666,0.17126],[3.005,3.113,3.882],[null,null,null],[2.751,2.846,2.676],[7.937,2.579,2.447],[5.12,3.492,3.467],[22.862,22.567,23.211],[33.437,18.889,19.043],[18.898,19.583,19.047],[14.774,12.984,13.803],[3.865,0.322143,0.323117],[0.192149,0.177791,0.175984],[0.194173,0.159398,0.165201],[0.680778,0.592252,0.560738],[0.106465,0.10638,0.102692],[0.154871,0.153752,0.155782],[0.11459,0.09639,0.095594]],"source":"monetdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"MonetDB","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","column-oriented"],"load_time":939,"data_size":49696606499,"result":[[0.000218,0.000157,0.000155],[0.101903,0.019908,0.018439],[0.282431,0.035987,0.034938],[2.868,0.029387,0.029207],[4.675,4.515,4.511],[6.584,4.269,4.650],[0.528827,0.063135,0.065742],[0.506863,0.020966,0.021687],[8.343,4.457,4.408],[7.224,6.548,7.576],[0.267003,0.233353,0.230444],[0.347206,0.28358,0.266085],[5.389,3.099,3.074],[7.653,7.759,8.596],[3.276,3.326,3.292],[5.310,3.465,3.578],[9.341,9.143,9.536],[9.584,9.604,9.419],[19.539,19.783,19.611],[0.004509,0.000702,0.000643],[20.801,1.570,1.603],[2.752,0.418221,0.395884],[14.717,0.800894,0.395477],[14.429,1.804,1.869],[1.386,0.159602,0.156426],[0.189736,0.167664,0.168781],[0.164681,0.176666,0.17126],[3.005,3.113,3.882],[null,null,null],[2.751,2.846,2.676],[7.937,2.579,2.447],[5.120,3.492,3.467],[22.862,22.567,23.211],[33.437,18.889,19.043],[18.898,19.583,19.047],[14.774,12.984,13.803],[3.865,0.322143,0.323117],[0.192149,0.177791,0.175984],[0.194173,0.159398,0.165201],[0.680778,0.592252,0.560738],[0.106465,0.10638,0.102692],[0.154871,0.153752,0.155782],[0.11459,0.09639,0.095594]],"source":"monetdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"MongoDB","date":"2022-10-25","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["row-oriented","document","C++"],"load_time":44824,"data_size":86397751448,"result":[[64.713,63.126,62.48],[0.402,0.398,0.398],[116.556,115.775,115.935],[116.883,92.054,91.646],[28.523,25.694,25.618],[19.974,10.235,10.204],[0.005,0.003,0.003],[0.656,0.644,0.65],[390.984,377.012,377.204],[2331.229,2617.011,2659.976],[403.396,410.754,389.201],[400.136,391.611,384.638],[90.255,70.314,70.648],[171.232,133.632,133.416],[57.835,57.8,57.136],[474.638,421.62,419.999],[332.07,266.801,266.967],[246.706,246.484,246.741],[466.25,465.911,465.399],[0.01,0.003,0.002],[238.439,70.732,69.911],[152.131,20.13,20.276],[28.018,23.201,23.292],[118.896,79.388,74.994],[21.888,11.393,11.423],[0.005,0.002,0.002],[31.821,15.74,15.353],[113.3,110.56,109.007],[287.151,178.123,177.878],[1099.097,1076.143,1064.104],[4987.582,4947.372,4873.488],[4816.666,4748.195,4823.137],[982.576,933.784,912.187],[1081.243,706.058,585.97],[593.68,570.279,594.089],[544.094,427.503,419.334],[11.766,5.643,4.975],[1.628,1.651,1.626],[3.444,2.222,2.232],[10.562,8.762,9.151],[0.724,0.445,0.446],[0.423,0.413,0.388],[1.601,2.202,2.375]],"source":"mongodb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"MySQL (MyISAM)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","row-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":2512,"data_size":121588958061,"result":[[0,0,0],[283.32,276.83,274.52],[276.93,278.29,283.27],[28.83,23.63,21.55],[46.41,40.81,40.93],[467.04,467.39,469.08],[31.02,25.89,24.2],[277.89,275.3,277.3],[329.34,325.8,325.35],[342.86,338.43,336.95],[282.03,279.87,281.22],[277.74,282.68,282],[335.66,334.83,336.44],[305.24,310.39,307.3],[337.41,338.52,342.94],[308.66,307.34,306.27],[738.38,748.44,740.75],[738.75,734.01,738.25],[867.01,872.92,868.84],[25.65,20.61,18.46],[312.39,313.67,306.66],[301.66,305.12,308.01],[298.12,298.44,312.4],[311.34,309.9,311.85],[281.87,278.5,275],[277.46,277.46,277.46],[280.75,278.04,281.76],[263.9,417.39,406.88],[707.21,711.96,705],[668.1,668.33,665.96],[330.31,333.36,331.94],[506.57,506.18,500.53],[2604.49,2681.96,2703.12],[830.65,832.88,831.14],[831.98,830.46,833.41],[608.49,608.51,613.68],[4.56,4.13,4.16],[3.8,3.8,3.7],[1.65,1.45,1.46],[6.33,5.14,6.15],[1.6,1.41,1.41],[1.56,1.42,1.39],[7.04,1.17,1.13]],"source":"mysql-myisam/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"MySQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","row-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":9472,"data_size":171953585825,"result":[[339.77,339.88,339.77],[364.91,371.86,367.55],[366.2,368.91,389.66],[364.39,377.53,571.45],[377.69,390.02,384.86],[569.48,576.51,574.68],[367.4,368.23,370.41],[371.29,384.02,613.22],[478.85,683.22,495.68],[489.9,635.96,662.43],[386.07,396.49,640.15],[389.13,412.55,444.12],[447.97,455.54,448.06],[423.22,845.44,813.6],[452.48,460.07,453.98],[577.54,623.21,586.49],[852.07,856.36,862.66],[838.09,848.92,851.12],[1006.37,1011.16,1023.17],[369.76,375.61,415.28],[412.45,419.9,456.62],[411.65,432.88,482.2],[412.73,420.73,429.5],[551.16,577.62,545.45],[382.89,394.76,386.37],[380.9,391.4,385.05],[385.3,394.67,460.32],[388.95,394.7,387.21],[800.33,807.9,807.11],[706.03,745.27,718.9],[450.9,489.59,530.97],[625.5,651.93,647.32],[2721.13,2792.12,2819.26],[945.9,954.94,957.54],[945.42,953.78,965.16],[684.36,716.29,708.75],[10.01,3.79,3.77],[7.48,3.32,3.27],[5.09,0.98,0.96],[8.7,4.77,4.68],[4.82,0.76,0.74],[4.46,0.77,0.75],[7.04,1.17,1.13]],"source":"mysql/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"MySQL (MyISAM)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","row-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":2512,"data_size":121588958061,"result":[[0.00,0.00,0.00],[283.32,276.83,274.52],[276.93,278.29,283.27],[28.83,23.63,21.55],[46.41,40.81,40.93],[467.04,467.39,469.08],[31.02,25.89,24.20],[277.89,275.3,277.3],[329.34,325.8,325.35],[342.86,338.43,336.95],[282.03,279.87,281.22],[277.74,282.68,282],[335.66,334.83,336.44],[305.24,310.39,307.3],[337.41,338.52,342.94],[308.66,307.34,306.27],[738.38,748.44,740.75],[738.75,734.01,738.25],[867.01,872.92,868.84],[25.65,20.61,18.46],[312.39,313.67,306.66],[301.66,305.12,308.01],[298.12,298.44,312.4],[311.34,309.9,311.85],[281.87,278.5,275],[277.46,277.46,277.46],[280.75,278.04,281.76],[263.9,417.39,406.88],[707.21,711.96,705],[668.1,668.33,665.96],[330.31,333.36,331.94],[506.57,506.18,500.53],[2604.49,2681.96,2703.12],[830.65,832.88,831.14],[831.98,830.46,833.41],[608.49,608.51,613.68],[4.56,4.13,4.16],[3.80,3.80,3.70],[1.65,1.45,1.46],[6.33,5.14,6.15],[1.60,1.41,1.41],[1.56,1.42,1.39],[7.04,1.17,1.13]],"source":"mysql-myisam/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"MySQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","row-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":9472,"data_size":171953585825,"result":[[339.77,339.88,339.77],[364.91,371.86,367.55],[366.2,368.91,389.66],[364.39,377.53,571.45],[377.69,390.02,384.86],[569.48,576.51,574.68],[367.4,368.23,370.41],[371.29,384.02,613.22],[478.85,683.22,495.68],[489.9,635.96,662.43],[386.07,396.49,640.15],[389.13,412.55,444.12],[447.97,455.54,448.06],[423.22,845.44,813.6],[452.48,460.07,453.98],[577.54,623.21,586.49],[852.07,856.36,862.66],[838.09,848.92,851.12],[1006.37,1011.16,1023.17],[369.76,375.61,415.28],[412.45,419.9,456.62],[411.65,432.88,482.2],[412.73,420.73,429.5],[551.16,577.62,545.45],[382.89,394.76,386.37],[380.9,391.4,385.05],[385.3,394.67,460.32],[388.95,394.7,387.21],[800.33,807.90,807.11],[706.03,745.27,718.9],[450.9,489.59,530.97],[625.5,651.93,647.32],[2721.13,2792.12,2819.26],[945.9,954.94,957.54],[945.42,953.78,965.16],[684.36,716.29,708.75],[10.01,3.79,3.77],[7.48,3.32,3.27],[5.09,0.98,0.96],[8.70,4.77,4.68],[4.82,0.76,0.74],[4.46,0.77,0.75],[7.04,1.17,1.13]],"source":"mysql/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Pinot","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"It successfully loaded only 94465149 out of 99997497 records. Some queries returned NullPointerException. The loading process is painful - splitting to 100 pieces required. It does not correctly report errors on data loading, the results may be incorrect.","tags":["Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":2032,"data_size":null,"result":[[0.002,0.001,0.001],[0.186,0.186,0.185],[0.251,0.276,0.258],[0.475,0.281,0.238],[3.907,3.655,3.633],[30.471,14.687,14.93],[null,null,null],[0.135,0.134,0.148],[3.039,2.902,2.938],[3.159,3.212,3.225],[4.217,4.197,4.384],[4.145,4.124,4.121],[2.989,3.145,3.18],[6.402,6.886,6.374],[3.245,3.35,3.129],[5.112,5.027,5.141],[5.509,5.279,5.257],[0.865,0.856,0.829],[null,null,null],[0.017,0.015,0.015],[54.348,19.562,19.128],[null,null,null],[76.596,74.719,14.228],[7.441,5.77,5.87],[0.376,0.327,0.286],[7.689,0.395,1.281],[3.434,0.499,0.5],[27.679,2.378,2.393],[null,null,null],[2.221,2.227,2.167],[4.941,4.639,4.565],[5.641,5.37,5.007],[5.295,5.006,5.357],[5.28,5.21,5.105],[6.231,6.238,6.385],[5.918,5.933,5.934],[0.26,0.202,0.21],[0.364,0.072,0.069],[0.042,0.034,0.035],[1.483,0.686,0.651],[0.113,0.071,0.079],[0.042,0.051,0.037],[null,null,null]],"source":"pinot/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"hide":true,"system":"PostgreSQL (tuned)","date":"2022-12-18","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","row-oriented","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":11800,"data_size":128875248605,"result":[[4.10957,0.687829,0.702019],[3.92694,0.63874,0.636411],[262.331,262.793,262.826],[6.14366,1.16457,1.20297],[26.752,27.4474,27.4878],[50.6555,47.6136,49.2373],[0.035605,0.002266,0.002208],[1.07557,0.599462,0.597673],[18.537,17.4348,17.7942],[309.49,306.831,306.894],[7.78261,2.95749,3.00855],[325.58,315.688,319.237],[4.03189,2.31557,2.21055],[18.8998,10.0497,10.0307],[272.381,271.91,271.87],[5.91906,4.17788,4.21394],[15.6578,15.8794,15.937],[0.025629,0.001484,0.00153],[312.64,312.543,310.582],[0.026206,0.001114,0.001115],[13.1447,0.090463,0.104537],[0.11893,0.093162,0.090471],[18.7775,0.107025,0.110361],[0.131412,0.089608,0.087852],[0.048958,0.00153,0.001405],[0.016134,0.001351,0.001268],[0.021939,0.001781,0.00164],[265.557,260.971,261.025],[277.516,276.053,277.378],[7.56565,6.50964,6.54902],[266.723,266.389,266.231],[269.738,269.255,269.193],[331.115,330.011,330.913],[416.169,421.255,423.724],[408.434,409.538,407.552],[35.5578,18.1707,18.6893],[3.17403,0.652905,0.698142],[0.730699,0.489315,0.465665],[0.563463,0.319131,0.3182],[1.23744,0.989391,1.01963],[0.752814,0.509212,0.511453],[0.677541,0.435178,0.437736],[1.18281,0.688545,0.697523]],"source":"postgresql-tuned/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"PostgreSQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","row-oriented","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":2342,"data_size":77797067741,"result":[[439.753,309.785,282.017],[317.874,254.238,254.941],[262.883,263.072,263.09],[32.421,5.31,5.06],[57.134,42.648,42.334],[358.423,356.315,358.342],[31.524,5.35,4.994],[263.145,263.193,263.165],[323.659,322.858,321.918],[327.395,326.17,326.231],[265.983,265.681,265.912],[269.984,265.336,265.379],[284.096,284.56,282.234],[277.25,279.455,280.035],[285.66,286.2,283.611],[66.605,32.023,38.282],[312.452,304.431,305.391],[289.209,290.449,287.578],[331.706,327.485,334.428],[24.646,2.543,2.263],[267.561,267.496,267.524],[267.729,267.69,268.184],[263.074,263.12,267.04],[267.602,267.488,267.494],[263.141,263.859,263.137],[262.923,263.102,263.113],[262.885,263.088,263.114],[267.864,269.127,268.204],[303.376,306.925,308.664],[263.221,263.119,263.148],[270.814,270.575,270.294],[278.342,275.925,276.224],[584.599,576.932,591.502],[462.576,446.962,439.779],[429.93,417.696,416.704],[296.875,297.283,295.14],[3.461,0.842,0.794],[2.179,0.564,0.558],[2.258,0.566,0.416],[2.805,1.311,1.317],[2.936,0.82,0.615],[2.197,0.736,0.535],[1.983,0.32,0.312]],"source":"postgresql/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"PostgreSQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","row-oriented","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":2342,"data_size":77797067741,"result":[[439.753,309.785,282.017],[317.874,254.238,254.941],[262.883,263.072,263.090],[32.421,5.310,5.060],[57.134,42.648,42.334],[358.423,356.315,358.342],[31.524,5.350,4.994],[263.145,263.193,263.165],[323.659,322.858,321.918],[327.395,326.170,326.231],[265.983,265.681,265.912],[269.984,265.336,265.379],[284.096,284.560,282.234],[277.250,279.455,280.035],[285.660,286.200,283.611],[66.605,32.023,38.282],[312.452,304.431,305.391],[289.209,290.449,287.578],[331.706,327.485,334.428],[24.646,2.543,2.263],[267.561,267.496,267.524],[267.729,267.690,268.184],[263.074,263.120,267.040],[267.602,267.488,267.494],[263.141,263.859,263.137],[262.923,263.102,263.113],[262.885,263.088,263.114],[267.864,269.127,268.204],[303.376,306.925,308.664],[263.221,263.119,263.148],[270.814,270.575,270.294],[278.342,275.925,276.224],[584.599,576.932,591.502],[462.576,446.962,439.779],[429.930,417.696,416.704],[296.875,297.283,295.140],[3.461,0.842,0.794],[2.179,0.564,0.558],[2.258,0.566,0.416],[2.805,1.311,1.317],[2.936,0.820,0.615],[2.197,0.736,0.535],[1.983,0.320,0.312]],"source":"postgresql/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"QuestDB (partitioned)","date":"2023-08-07","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Data load for partitioned tables is multi-threaded and thus more efficient.","tags":["Java","time-series"],"load_time":283,"data_size":126686660753,"result":[[0.00797009,0.0026682,0.000222614],[1.1466,0.0743637,0.0350691],[1.33896,0.0294108,0.0242091],[2.88612,0.0116978,0.0115375],[6.32544,6.21946,6.12302],[10.682,9.70659,9.67993],[2.07087,0.0299815,0.0251919],[0.212583,0.223532,0.226999],[9.60538,8.88499,8.54807],[10.3833,10.6572,10.2222],[11.6556,7.75986,9.77087],[10.7876,10.2966,9.82955],[6.22005,5.68946,5.31396],[15.575,20.1012,21.951],[5.70846,5.55251,5.54523],[9.41636,9.11746,9.692],[12.9052,12.4855,12.6248],[12.0557,11.936,12.4488],[20.3953,20.5126,20.2717],[0.0431935,0.0264225,0.0254709],[71.9626,2.33681,2.75973],[2.45832,2.31771,2.58355],[48.1856,1.5962,1.3926],[67.7625,0.0476454,0.215789],[0.00885858,0.00393648,0.00325621],[2.35187,2.58716,2.59413],[2.01155,2.0116,2.01174],[7.89161,12.5432,11.7973],[96.8203,70.0744,70.5522],[0.0433241,0.0477017,0.0384908],[14.4465,14.1308,14.7048],[25.9898,26.6603,25.2982],[25.3329,25.5566,25.6693],[24.2448,24.657,25.0246],[24.9036,25.6605,25.2338],[13.5415,13.897,13.403],[0.566165,0.446011,0.473455],[0.376493,0.436516,0.444282],[0.019405,0.00734841,0.00715677],[0.0346318,0.00728625,0.00714942],[0.0225874,0.00709796,0.0185377],[0.0197833,0.00725278,0.0184759],[0.0191112,0.00719778,0.00711133]],"source":"questdb-partitioned/results/c6a.metal.json"} ,{"system":"QuestDB","date":"2023-08-07","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Java","time-series"],"load_time":981.7,"data_size":126680518693,"result":[[0.0112942,0.000225934,0.000253604],[0.556282,0.0313342,0.0218474],[1.42613,0.0565074,0.0541284],[2.87937,0.0520613,0.0495966],[4.63829,4.78606,4.79014],[10.338,6.1454,6.25674],[2.05945,0.027138,0.0279756],[0.098727,0.0829763,0.0507432],[6.53065,6.20068,6.32223],[8.10852,8.52982,8.27696],[8.48286,6.21364,6.07288],[6.78112,6.8087,6.70625],[4.89741,4.88513,4.91099],[10.5121,10.3625,11.87],[5.48412,5.44099,5.50898],[6.71723,6.61622,6.54155],[9.56474,9.55091,9.45236],[8.81386,8.96912,9.03472],[19.8604,20.0578,20.015],[0.0260623,0.0230254,0.0231277],[70.7859,5.24388,4.94915],[4.9527,5.53141,5.41446],[52.5849,22.9005,3.33657],[191.166,191.779,191.454],[9.19877,1.75408,1.75161],[2.27065,2.27486,2.24858],[2.13631,2.15004,2.23218],[72.2267,5.46021,5.32763],[106.031,56.3334,56.953],[0.572298,0.0139396,0.025344],[20.1234,10.4109,10.3593],[27.7933,27.2404,26.7903],[28.0558,28.8441,28.436],[59.4847,71.2648,30.2944],[24.2383,24.6024,24.3966],[11.254,11.3405,11.1291],[0.69854,0.602302,0.665329],[0.6388,0.498475,0.522627],[0.0250828,0.0086267,0.00843358],[0.0610679,0.00877569,0.0086065],[0.0319684,0.00839335,0.00924688],[0.0223462,0.00852395,0.00838955],[0.0244013,0.00847416,0.00863221]],"source":"questdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-29","machine":"serverless","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":1889,"data_size":30300000000,"result":[[0.204673,0.204057,0.199682],[2.57227,0.06361,0.029767],[4.436641,0.063275,0.038419],[4.045285,0.095483,0.036212],[3.836475,0.331029,0.302588],[3.870503,0.354183,0.334163],[4.415212,0.138202,0.202982],[4.595758,0.218455,0.218352],[5.014696,0.681662,0.748541],[5.225219,1.547334,1.545263],[4.584578,0.72432,0.662759],[4.989708,0.325297,0.664825],[4.113529,0.36393,0.343591],[4.261916,0.638592,0.606164],[4.05665,0.359074,0.467625],[4.562217,0.324242,0.323635],[4.794707,0.392733,0.552696],[2.785799,0.555024,0.533908],[5.186795,0.834753,0.821691],[2.538645,0.055274,0.025005],[2.952623,0.389594,0.235447],[4.522708,0.587444,0.607969],[6.980801,0.932761,0.949326],[27.480743,0.934181,0.912692],[3.802747,0.068159,0.06577],[3.781327,0.065613,0.065988],[3.995625,0.067925,0.067972],[4.607562,0.395705,0.441231],[5.138266,0.800484,0.79964],[5.705465,1.236098,1.133279],[5.105528,0.32746,0.348947],[5.075262,0.452786,0.339682],[4.465012,0.955494,0.742195],[4.586866,0.783934,0.812498],[5.182903,1.04809,1.058838],[4.331838,0.452791,0.325946],[5.790735,0.553011,0.582903],[5.600699,0.588159,0.589788],[5.217314,0.519302,0.423573],[6.281955,0.687085,0.494527],[3.990623,0.501763,0.533571],[4.451641,0.464027,0.231731],[3.953942,0.288126,0.283841]],"source":"redshift-serverless/results/serverless.json"} +,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-29","machine":"serverless","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":1889,"data_size":30300000000,"result":[[0.204673,0.204057,0.199682],[2.572270,0.063610,0.029767],[4.436641,0.063275,0.038419],[4.045285,0.095483,0.036212],[3.836475,0.331029,0.302588],[3.870503,0.354183,0.334163],[4.415212,0.138202,0.202982],[4.595758,0.218455,0.218352],[5.014696,0.681662,0.748541],[5.225219,1.547334,1.545263],[4.584578,0.724320,0.662759],[4.989708,0.325297,0.664825],[4.113529,0.363930,0.343591],[4.261916,0.638592,0.606164],[4.056650,0.359074,0.467625],[4.562217,0.324242,0.323635],[4.794707,0.392733,0.552696],[2.785799,0.555024,0.533908],[5.186795,0.834753,0.821691],[2.538645,0.055274,0.025005],[2.952623,0.389594,0.235447],[4.522708,0.587444,0.607969],[6.980801,0.932761,0.949326],[27.480743,0.934181,0.912692],[3.802747,0.068159,0.065770],[3.781327,0.065613,0.065988],[3.995625,0.067925,0.067972],[4.607562,0.395705,0.441231],[5.138266,0.800484,0.799640],[5.705465,1.236098,1.133279],[5.105528,0.327460,0.348947],[5.075262,0.452786,0.339682],[4.465012,0.955494,0.742195],[4.586866,0.783934,0.812498],[5.182903,1.048090,1.058838],[4.331838,0.452791,0.325946],[5.790735,0.553011,0.582903],[5.600699,0.588159,0.589788],[5.217314,0.519302,0.423573],[6.281955,0.687085,0.494527],[3.990623,0.501763,0.533571],[4.451641,0.464027,0.231731],[3.953942,0.288126,0.283841]],"source":"redshift-serverless/results/serverless.json"} ,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2023-03-16","machine":"dc2.8xlarge","cluster_size":2,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2485,"data_size":27278704640,"result":[[0.091406,0.086338,0.087612],[3.69766,0.134031,0.091109],[3.5111,0.168351,0.142172],[3.60815,0.258997,0.218437],[0.889436,0.837116,0.849539],[0.731434,0.637602,0.614294],[0.18962,0.102182,0.112139],[3.62328,0.131585,0.106394],[5.24115,1.36685,1.31341],[10.9166,5.36471,5.42147],[5.42547,0.276808,0.290985],[5.64058,0.279121,0.279034],[5.46763,0.53574,0.5168],[5.29286,1.07603,1.03563],[5.78458,0.536501,0.549506],[3.21523,1.12748,1.13882],[6.54437,2.03254,2.00971],[5.98581,1.92732,1.81327],[7.66486,2.55847,2.56672],[3.42706,0.12806,0.098883],[4.73143,0.925719,0.859908],[4.83294,1.13573,0.965813],[9.84339,2.50898,2.52251],[40.4326,4.64149,3.80256],[5.19757,0.247997,0.264246],[5.41506,0.209713,0.260805],[4.77753,0.216233,0.267095],[5.56149,0.814863,0.785771],[134.925,129.613,129.588],[8.71915,0.56382,0.435913],[4.87089,0.885857,0.849695],[6.30403,0.576453,0.533121],[7.8966,2.51425,2.4379],[3.59329,3.52192,3.5328],[8.12716,3.53348,3.57861],[5.20591,1.00374,0.871943],[5.04128,1.00458,0.958819],[5.07238,1.01154,1.01714],[4.55457,0.394789,0.369611],[4.56489,0.511554,0.459726],[4.09241,0.155302,0.137224],[4.12911,0.15957,0.129961],[4.13896,0.14336,0.113134]],"source":"redshift/results/2x.dc2.8xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-25","machine":"ra3.16xlarge","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":1829,"data_size":26330791936,"result":[[0.077429,0.024911,0.023306],[2.53116,0.059213,0.027695],[3.583972,0.063486,0.036182],[2.376308,0.084898,0.058801],[0.1555,0.109031,0.114305],[0.2439,0.198301,0.176052],[0.130623,0.028745,0.029271],[3.740631,0.035144,0.033783],[3.615666,0.136355,0.133104],[5.125836,1.432898,1.413138],[3.781026,0.090368,0.088729],[3.996543,0.111767,0.102832],[3.665831,0.168544,0.158393],[3.980324,0.305395,0.308288],[3.868897,0.181746,0.182552],[3.625138,0.146538,0.143406],[4.024699,0.340789,0.339775],[2.646998,0.442014,0.385201],[4.370081,0.663792,0.664333],[2.517381,0.055869,0.029468],[2.892161,0.361342,0.335877],[4.306186,0.364156,0.365814],[6.576232,1.030228,1.037391],[26.654131,1.354625,1.361705],[3.641366,0.103397,0.093371],[3.593615,0.079071,0.081853],[3.822308,0.083556,0.081115],[3.824567,0.295163,0.338925],[5.321484,1.061397,1.052438],[4.795037,0.267308,0.203014],[4.466789,0.164681,0.162661],[4.715724,0.204908,0.204441],[4.148436,0.664311,0.658639],[0.958589,0.91596,0.916875],[4.43871,0.940025,0.940112],[4.152015,0.137629,0.140684],[4.881633,0.303343,0.30078],[5.020373,0.314807,0.316961],[4.586323,0.065513,0.076092],[5.424183,0.100862,0.106056],[2.947259,0.080757,0.046727],[3.585538,0.074431,0.047424],[3.753716,0.04414,0.042809]],"source":"redshift/results/4x.ra3.16xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-25","machine":"ra3.4xlarge","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":1904,"data_size":22313697280,"result":[[2.135081,0.017989,0.01775],[2.4142,0.022495,0.022023],[6.414938,0.057299,0.055643],[6.411557,0.178071,0.1771],[3.710171,0.300286,0.303593],[3.876626,0.454045,0.477494],[6.41068,0.037709,0.036684],[5.793739,0.024525,0.023881],[5.769831,0.465373,0.490227],[5.939799,3.530177,3.57276],[6.115389,0.177672,0.161334],[6.230233,0.170112,0.166583],[4.046352,0.479846,0.481283],[4.620393,0.923121,0.952839],[4.18785,0.509904,0.518239],[5.660648,0.413803,0.411108],[5.886176,1.123718,1.103859],[3.556251,1.336332,1.381805],[6.040107,1.981635,1.965932],[2.484137,0.030438,0.029756],[4.105144,1.515947,1.515338],[6.21666,1.581792,1.581579],[9.005864,3.555306,3.567163],[30.723242,4.88672,4.885439],[5.678108,0.240413,0.239727],[5.923512,0.232055,0.231429],[5.809703,0.242922,0.242932],[5.820199,1.254403,1.2539],[8.798963,4.587414,4.592794],[13.184562,0.925342,0.873526],[6.617764,0.406749,0.404641],[6.770537,0.587831,0.586834],[5.173074,1.685266,1.713844],[6.216833,2.82166,2.859146],[6.262067,2.851894,2.835493],[5.716614,0.313373,0.328139],[5.683282,0.95632,0.97491],[5.83116,1.103328,1.10476],[6.917177,0.124116,0.107132],[7.662737,0.149158,0.149209],[4.621167,0.044216,0.043012],[4.572912,0.042941,0.042108],[5.906381,0.027692,0.026924]],"source":"redshift/results/4x.ra3.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-29","machine":"ra3.xlplus","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2103,"data_size":21060648960,"result":[[0.079613,0.033549,0.03409],[2.968579,0.063904,0.041282],[4.080153,0.13095,0.108882],[3.210337,0.34364,0.298495],[4.544852,0.631037,0.582424],[4.387295,1.084085,1.060912],[3.068245,0.108602,0.082147],[4.600868,0.045357,0.044651],[5.016095,0.9119,0.867873],[6.649061,2.367888,2.313359],[5.443231,0.309726,0.290368],[5.668514,0.333039,0.313292],[5.188214,1.085051,1.149722],[6.32409,1.961323,1.973299],[5.49248,1.14419,1.123103],[4.882748,0.733695,0.7748],[6.401272,2.257003,2.278818],[5.977724,2.511508,2.403787],[7.838491,3.47004,3.546783],[2.942119,0.094772,0.052837],[5.742532,2.535047,2.498187],[7.144539,2.607847,2.610038],[13.254883,6.773696,6.784579],[21.841477,11.673254,9.552525],[4.594945,0.474181,0.478285],[4.635551,0.494066,0.455041],[4.832767,0.474136,0.474433],[6.19406,2.059882,2.06739],[12.694282,7.745891,7.737045],[19.926847,1.349867,1.27298],[6.178553,0.845828,0.858791],[6.394659,1.080842,1.070668],[8.112381,3.869544,3.9868],[10.048186,5.276152,5.259864],[9.260186,5.163649,5.210499],[4.766534,0.646525,0.657038],[7.602645,1.880335,1.884086],[7.527802,2.172033,2.190131],[5.57036,0.229991,0.228068],[6.632048,0.286827,0.275382],[4.224273,0.103105,0.077275],[4.614709,0.102518,0.075337],[4.389546,0.052659,0.050885]],"source":"redshift/results/4x.ra3.xplus.json"} -,{"system":"SelectDB","date":"2022-11-02","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":526,"data_size":17122903966,"result":[[0.03,0.04,0.02],[0.15,0.03,0.03],[0.13,0.05,0.05],[1.05,0.06,0.05],[0.34,0.28,0.27],[0.82,0.57,0.57],[0.01,0.02,0.02],[0.22,0.02,0.02],[0.56,0.46,0.45],[0.52,0.51,0.5],[0.4,0.11,0.12],[0.18,0.12,0.12],[0.54,0.5,0.49],[0.83,0.93,0.95],[0.74,0.89,0.72],[0.32,0.31,0.31],[1.08,1.08,1.09],[0.27,0.35,0.23],[2.18,2.04,1.98],[0.02,0.01,0.02],[10.74,1.3,1.31],[8.36,3.46,0.99],[12.21,1.23,1.04],[5.2,0.52,0.5],[0.11,0.04,0.05],[0.39,0.13,0.13],[0.05,0.04,0.04],[9.43,1.8,1.16],[9.93,9.69,9.6],[0.83,0.78,0.78],[1.77,0.38,0.37],[2.57,0.41,0.43],[2.77,2.75,3.11],[11.62,4.01,3.95],[11.63,4.03,5.97],[0.46,0.4,0.39],[0.11,0.06,0.06],[0.06,0.03,0.03],[0.03,0.03,0.02],[0.13,0.11,0.1],[0.05,0.02,0.03],[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02]],"source":"selectdb/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"SelectDB","date":"2022-11-02","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":444,"data_size":17122903978,"result":[[0.03,0.03,0.02],[0.36,0.05,0.04],[0.18,0.07,0.06],[0.96,0.06,0.06],[0.32,0.28,0.29],[0.86,0.62,0.61],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[0.04,0.02,0.03],[0.5,0.47,0.47],[0.53,0.74,0.55],[0.31,0.11,0.11],[0.15,0.1,0.14],[0.57,0.62,0.55],[0.85,0.92,0.96],[0.77,0.9,0.74],[0.32,0.32,0.32],[1.22,0.99,0.98],[0.23,0.22,0.25],[2.01,1.8,1.82],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[10.76,1.05,1.04],[8.99,2.84,0.84],[12.21,1.04,0.87],[5.79,0.3,0.29],[0.12,0.04,0.04],[0.41,0.12,0.13],[0.04,0.04,0.03],[9.67,1.59,1.11],[9.06,8.23,7.84],[0.67,0.55,0.57],[1.76,0.37,0.77],[2.1,0.42,0.43],[2.78,2.76,3.11],[11.56,4.04,4.21],[11.52,4.05,4.28],[0.5,0.41,0.41],[0.63,0.05,0.05],[0.06,0.03,0.03],[0.03,0.02,0.03],[0.16,0.13,0.12],[0.06,0.01,0.03],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.03,0.02]],"source":"selectdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"SelectDB","date":"2022-10-08","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":369,"data_size":17123069872,"result":[[0.01,0.01,0],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.04,0.04,0.05],[0.07,0.06,0.07],[0.17,0.15,0.17],[0.3,0.3,0.28],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.32,0.33,0.34],[0.36,0.37,0.34],[0.11,0.11,0.25],[0.11,0.11,0.1],[0.23,0.23,0.23],[0.55,0.75,0.89],[0.32,0.3,0.31],[0.18,0.16,0.19],[0.53,0.51,0.5],[0.2,0.2,0.2],[1.04,1.06,1.3],[0.01,0.01,0],[0.59,0.6,0.66],[0.48,0.34,0.34],[0.38,0.38,0.37],[0.25,0.26,0.25],[0.04,0.04,0.04],[0.15,0.15,0.14],[0.04,0.04,0.04],[0.55,0.54,0.54],[1.39,1.36,1.34],[0.68,0.69,0.76],[0.24,0.23,0.23],[0.21,0.2,0.21],[1.45,1.53,2.05],[1.84,1.92,1.67],[1.83,1.75,1.9],[0.19,0.22,0.2],[0.03,0.04,0.04],[0.03,0.03,0.03],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.06,0.06,0.06],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02]],"source":"selectdb/results/c6a.metal.json"} -,{"system":"SingleStore","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: MemSQL. Some queries did not run due to memory limits","tags":["MySQL compatible","column-oriented"],"load_time":690,"data_size":29836263469,"result":[[0.09,0,0],[0.23,0.04,0.01],[0.47,0.15,0.15],[0.63,0.09,0.08],[1.65,1.23,1.2],[7.96,2.79,2.63],[0.1,0,0],[0.17,0.02,0.02],[1.9,1.4,1.39],[4.79,3.52,3.48],[0.94,0.22,0.23],[0.89,0.24,0.23],[5.82,2.26,2.25],[6.97,4.62,4.66],[3.05,2.28,2.31],[3.92,2.7,2.28],[5.83,4.48,4.42],[4.76,4.13,4.12],[14.03,null,null],[0.57,0.05,0.04],[18.18,1.74,1.94],[20.85,2.17,0.98],[31.98,3.12,1.22],[78.96,3.35,108.85],[2.82,0.39,0.32],[1.83,0.44,0.35],[2.81,0.33,0.32],[18.33,2.57,1.15],[null,null,null],[3.56,2.4,2.4],[3.83,1.11,1.11],[7.35,1.73,1.7],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[2.53,1.92,1.84],[0.92,0.23,0.19],[0.84,0.15,0.08],[0.7,0.05,0.05],[3.12,0.38,0.36],[0.29,0.03,0.03],[0.22,0.06,0.02],[0.27,0.11,0.12]],"source":"singlestore/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"SingleStore","date":"2022-07-15","machine":"S2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: MemSQL. Some queries did not run due to unsupported regex","tags":["MySQL compatible","column-oriented","managed"],"load_time":1145,"data_size":19219978649,"result":[[0.1,0.04,0.01],[0.13,0,0.01],[0.57,0.09,0.1],[0.64,0.13,0.08],[2.04,1.39,1.32],[2.56,1.95,2.15],[0.12,0.01,0],[0.34,0.06,0.01],[2.14,1.71,1.71],[5.7,5.1,5.49],[1.02,0.25,0.28],[1.05,0.29,0.25],[2.38,1.91,1.74],[4.04,3.4,3.46],[2.19,1.6,1.75],[1.9,1.56,1.55],[4.92,4.26,4.46],[4.13,4.01,4.03],[10.11,9.61,9.56],[0.36,0.05,0.1],[1.61,1.29,1.24],[1.04,0.55,0.57],[1.38,0.96,0.89],[3,2.15,2.31],[0.66,0.28,0.2],[0.67,0.19,0.16],[0.69,0.18,0.16],[1.14,0.56,0.56],[null,null,null],[3.43,1.69,1.51],[1.73,1.06,1.03],[2.17,1.6,1.45],[11.17,10.42,10.74],[9.94,9.61,9.66],[10.22,9.84,9.84],[2.31,1.79,1.97],[0.4,0.2,0.14],[0.35,0.16,0.09],[0.28,0.08,0.08],[0.68,0.28,0.36],[0.25,0.15,0.02],[0.23,0.1,0.01],[0.24,0.1,0.03]],"source":"singlestore/results/s2.json"} -,{"system":"SingleStore","date":"2022-07-15","machine":"S24","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: MemSQL. Some queries did not run due to unsupported regex","tags":["MySQL compatible","column-oriented","managed"],"load_time":1043,"data_size":19219978649,"result":[[0.1,0.04,0.07],[0.12,0.06,0],[0.42,0.05,0.01],[0.34,0.05,0.01],[0.97,0.29,0.23],[0.87,0.34,0.25],[0.06,0.04,0],[0.15,0.01,0.01],[1.04,0.39,0.31],[1.68,0.96,0.85],[0.3,0.19,0.09],[0.3,0.21,0.08],[0.56,0.26,0.35],[0.7,0.48,0.43],[0.64,0.35,0.27],[0.98,0.4,0.36],[1.52,0.75,0.86],[0.7,0.74,0.71],[1.73,1.07,0.96],[0.15,0.05,0.01],[0.37,0.2,0.26],[0.55,0.14,0.25],[0.41,0.31,0.31],[0.66,0.39,0.46],[0.52,0.12,0.08],[0.3,0.08,0.15],[0.32,0.16,0.07],[0.82,0.21,0.13],[null,null,null],[2.28,0.34,0.38],[0.55,0.28,0.17],[0.53,0.29,0.34],[1.75,1.07,1.04],[2.05,1.41,1.43],[2.11,1.45,1.4],[1.14,0.53,0.45],[0.34,0.12,0.24],[0.29,0.09,0.21],[0.35,0.11,0.18],[0.59,0.22,0.39],[0.3,0.07,0.15],[0.27,0.22,0.16],[0.29,0.06,0.06]],"source":"singlestore/results/s24.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"2XL","cluster_size":32,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.177,0.052,0.09],[0.903,0.324,0.782],[0.458,2.909,0.275],[0.881,0.316,0.166],[0.404,0.257,0.256],[0.481,0.325,0.339],[0.056,0.062,0.06],[0.183,0.324,0.28],[0.444,0.314,0.32],[0.408,0.426,0.417],[0.345,0.241,0.253],[0.406,0.245,0.235],[0.521,1.259,0.326],[0.466,0.493,0.526],[0.447,0.349,0.362],[0.327,0.322,0.302],[0.462,0.508,0.461],[0.489,0.481,0.455],[0.731,0.659,0.674],[0.151,0.156,0.16],[0.832,0.339,0.312],[0.289,0.292,0.34],[0.591,0.484,0.419],[2.661,0.716,0.696],[0.19,0.199,0.377],[0.181,0.182,0.194],[0.22,0.209,0.195],[0.368,0.33,0.347],[0.677,0.645,0.646],[0.877,0.886,0.871],[0.415,0.282,0.301],[1.265,0.404,0.55],[0.786,0.75,0.757],[0.905,0.835,0.841],[0.864,0.865,0.823],[0.352,0.36,0.364],[0.201,0.186,0.2],[0.143,0.137,0.276],[0.29,0.132,0.146],[0.31,0.301,0.304],[0.212,0.197,0.17],[0.223,0.174,0.177],[0.172,0.172,0.172]],"source":"snowflake/results/2xl.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"3XL","cluster_size":64,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.165,0.061,0.049],[1.356,1.252,1.502],[1.287,0.47,0.325],[0.627,0.331,0.181],[0.265,0.265,0.483],[0.887,0.45,0.298],[0.054,0.066,0.062],[0.182,0.222,0.194],[0.408,0.438,0.319],[0.434,0.462,0.411],[1.357,0.247,0.412],[0.343,0.25,0.517],[0.273,0.289,0.6],[0.404,0.405,0.392],[0.379,0.304,0.455],[0.275,0.271,0.264],[0.418,0.386,0.388],[0.417,0.434,0.567],[0.753,0.759,0.506],[0.291,0.307,0.4],[0.954,0.423,0.28],[0.568,0.562,0.248],[0.568,0.477,0.496],[1.458,0.492,0.514],[0.179,0.3,0.184],[0.165,0.169,0.176],[0.197,0.186,0.19],[0.289,0.547,0.397],[0.513,0.544,0.632],[0.766,0.754,0.775],[0.389,0.374,0.383],[0.484,0.297,0.286],[0.505,0.505,0.734],[0.656,0.598,0.621],[0.634,0.646,0.609],[0.309,0.298,0.37],[0.192,0.219,0.212],[0.84,0.174,0.139],[0.172,0.163,0.151],[0.323,0.296,0.347],[0.2,0.154,0.144],[0.191,0.121,0.125],[0.137,0.233,0.148]],"source":"snowflake/results/3xl.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"4XL","cluster_size":128,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.164,0.061,0.078],[2.471,2.436,1.927],[1.656,0.222,0.639],[0.336,1.244,0.206],[0.435,0.414,0.373],[0.52,0.495,0.326],[0.052,0.051,0.057],[0.244,0.515,0.358],[0.473,0.477,0.659],[0.706,0.523,0.499],[0.619,0.361,0.303],[0.463,0.367,0.29],[0.385,0.319,0.376],[0.661,0.436,0.452],[0.446,0.317,0.336],[0.504,0.283,0.395],[0.478,1.395,0.35],[0.555,1.041,0.993],[0.565,0.558,1.473],[0.31,0.684,0.278],[0.637,1.202,0.249],[0.467,0.294,0.436],[0.671,0.478,0.611],[6.262,0.449,0.425],[0.476,0.213,0.184],[0.552,0.241,0.201],[0.458,0.415,0.402],[0.339,0.357,0.322],[0.732,0.549,0.483],[0.914,0.757,0.743],[0.718,0.31,0.606],[0.605,0.363,0.425],[0.468,0.86,0.784],[0.868,1.787,0.713],[0.807,0.691,0.544],[0.485,0.338,0.672],[0.263,0.221,0.23],[0.147,0.145,0.139],[0.135,0.239,0.136],[0.322,0.378,0.348],[0.236,0.138,0.132],[0.193,0.124,0.139],[0.146,0.145,0.139]],"source":"snowflake/results/4xl.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"L","cluster_size":8,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.067,0.054,0.051],[1.158,1.409,0.19],[1.47,0.566,0.715],[0.892,0.534,0.264],[0.474,0.499,0.489],[0.95,0.65,0.699],[0.069,0.055,0.11],[0.317,0.307,0.321],[0.949,0.593,0.654],[0.713,1.099,0.86],[0.622,0.37,0.404],[0.457,0.369,0.414],[0.61,0.566,0.653],[0.97,1.006,0.976],[1.517,0.636,0.603],[0.532,0.541,0.533],[1.018,1.001,1.022],[0.942,0.996,0.94],[2.246,1.596,1.56],[0.181,0.184,0.2],[1.135,0.788,0.609],[0.669,0.528,0.524],[1.164,0.827,0.882],[3.545,2.214,2.107],[0.559,0.431,0.426],[0.34,0.296,0.383],[0.695,0.314,0.368],[0.628,0.658,0.637],[1.511,1.385,1,440],[1.39,1.418,1.322],[1.107,0.687,0.537],[1.026,0.737,0.659],[1.712,1.681,1.728],[2.141,2.13,2.225],[2.163,2.157,2.11],[0.65,0.619,0.627],[0.204,0.195,0.225],[0.159,0.152,0.156],[0.146,0.136,0.15],[0.359,0.29,0.364],[0.196,0.129,0.227],[0.201,0.128,0.143],[0.176,0.129,0.146]],"source":"snowflake/results/l.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"M","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.054,0.062,0.064],[0.698,0.563,0.407],[0.586,0.412,0.266],[1.386,0.363,0.301],[0.814,0.825,0.984],[1.303,1.024,1.048],[0.069,0.066,0.062],[0.334,0.254,0.27],[1.043,0.952,0.993],[1.21,1.209,1.171],[0.667,0.483,0.456],[0.543,0.495,0.5],[1.005,0.889,0.888],[1.644,1.646,1.652],[1.054,1.044,0.966],[0.893,0.874,0.907],[1.737,1.779,1.837],[1.518,1.539,1.526],[3.082,2.818,2.842],[0.309,0.286,0.256],[1.594,1.017,0.993],[0.781,0.853,0.735],[1.461,1.226,1.08],[5.308,2.974,2.642],[0.511,0.625,0.467],[0.405,0.382,0.439],[0.601,0.535,0.471],[0.947,1.624,1.192],[2.631,2.486,2.49],[1.938,1.96,1.954],[1.93,0.83,0.835],[1.359,1.14,1.062],[3.599,3.623,3.621],[3.619,3.741,3.663],[3.725,3.614,3.786],[1.149,1.126,1.055],[0.202,0.207,0.196],[0.152,0.139,0.145],[0.149,0.144,0.148],[0.383,0.287,0.294],[0.203,0.137,0.119],[0.2,0.312,0.137],[0.149,0.13,0.214]],"source":"snowflake/results/m.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"S","cluster_size":2,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.186,0.06,0.062],[0.98,0.574,0.311],[0.977,0.554,0.426],[0.686,0.573,0.404],[1.386,1.384,1.349],[1.871,1.697,1.704],[0.052,0.059,0.227],[0.309,0.536,0.508],[1.768,1.631,1.635],[2.039,2.219,1.908],[0.807,0.647,0.587],[0.763,0.69,0.631],[1.403,1.586,1.404],[2.593,2.584,2.554],[1.67,1.538,1.653],[1.659,1.509,1.514],[2.875,2.99,2.998],[2.605,2.549,2.598],[6.12,5.894,5.766],[0.32,0.431,0.416],[2.406,1.703,1.609],[1.189,1.186,1.163],[2.104,1.441,1.37],[7.144,5.174,4.139],[0.839,0.659,0.641],[0.527,0.518,0.509],[0.633,0.621,0.695],[1.491,1.509,1.514],[4.848,4.485,4.571],[3.067,3.106,3.098],[1.521,1.224,1.236],[1.839,1.69,1.497],[5.692,5.751,6.087],[6.733,6.755,6.712],[6.722,6.709,6.676],[1.704,1.686,1.676],[0.203,0.231,0.218],[0.151,0.134,0.214],[0.14,0.156,0.163],[0.317,0.328,0.319],[0.166,0.133,0.141],[0.166,0.12,0.14],[0.12,0.119,0.126]],"source":"snowflake/results/s.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"XL","cluster_size":16,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.071,0.053,0.057],[0.998,0.61,0.24],[0.42,1.138,1.051],[0.653,0.264,0.178],[0.352,0.312,0.349],[1.126,0.431,0.42],[0.067,0.057,0.054],[0.225,0.217,0.2],[0.617,0.366,0.371],[1.006,0.541,0.498],[0.463,0.425,0.293],[0.431,0.36,0.339],[0.392,0.371,0.386],[0.588,0.581,0.59],[0.634,0.414,0.4],[0.368,0.41,0.388],[0.594,0.639,0.663],[0.616,0.581,0.569],[1.092,0.933,0.901],[0.493,0.213,0.16],[0.886,0.48,0.442],[0.448,0.337,0.399],[0.84,0.572,0.505],[2.251,1.23,0.959],[0.295,0.253,0.241],[0.214,0.239,0.278],[0.261,0.232,0.314],[0.422,0.429,0.403],[0.892,0.934,0.883],[1.041,1.017,1.009],[0.715,0.442,0.363],[0.845,0.413,0.461],[1.101,1.085,1.102],[1.294,1.272,1.339],[1.839,1.327,1.241],[0.439,0.399,0.393],[0.199,0.211,0.19],[0.157,0.143,0.14],[0.145,0.157,0.141],[0.331,0.291,0.333],[0.173,0.214,0.138],[0.189,0.15,0.159],[0.135,0.149,0.138]],"source":"snowflake/results/xl.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"XS","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.169,0.055,0.056],[1.184,0.582,0.386],[1.35,0.56,0.568],[1.27,0.554,0.538],[2.516,2.564,2.506],[2.935,2.649,2.67],[0.052,0.05,0.064],[0.383,0.387,0.397],[3.249,2.993,3.014],[3.589,3.627,3.887],[1.243,0.986,0.966],[1.325,1.08,1.073],[2.038,2.046,2.035],[3.738,3.626,3.718],[2.318,2.159,2.176],[2.733,2.637,2.668],[5.607,5.683,5.667],[3.978,3.923,3.879],[10.085,9.871,9.844],[0.45,0.375,0.469],[5.474,3.103,3.06],[2.012,1.982,1.971],[3.365,2.471,2.501],[11.96,10.619,9.518],[1.074,1.059,1.026],[0.856,0.846,0.879],[1.1,1.085,1.083],[3.057,3.228,3.117],[9.406,9.019,9.158],[6.196,6.243,6.911],[2.906,2.343,2.017],[2.954,2.666,2.565],[9.459,9.565,9.557],[9.555,9.529,9.368],[9.409,9.185,9.294],[2.796,2.88,2.685],[0.299,0.249,0.262],[0.156,0.145,0.18],[0.147,0.146,0.16],[0.371,0.357,0.356],[0.166,0.133,0.155],[0.218,0.14,0.135],[0.14,0.152,0.158]],"source":"snowflake/results/xs.json"} +,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-25","machine":"ra3.16xlarge","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":1829,"data_size":26330791936,"result":[[0.077429,0.024911,0.023306],[2.531160,0.059213,0.027695],[3.583972,0.063486,0.036182],[2.376308,0.084898,0.058801],[0.155500,0.109031,0.114305],[0.243900,0.198301,0.176052],[0.130623,0.028745,0.029271],[3.740631,0.035144,0.033783],[3.615666,0.136355,0.133104],[5.125836,1.432898,1.413138],[3.781026,0.090368,0.088729],[3.996543,0.111767,0.102832],[3.665831,0.168544,0.158393],[3.980324,0.305395,0.308288],[3.868897,0.181746,0.182552],[3.625138,0.146538,0.143406],[4.024699,0.340789,0.339775],[2.646998,0.442014,0.385201],[4.370081,0.663792,0.664333],[2.517381,0.055869,0.029468],[2.892161,0.361342,0.335877],[4.306186,0.364156,0.365814],[6.576232,1.030228,1.037391],[26.654131,1.354625,1.361705],[3.641366,0.103397,0.093371],[3.593615,0.079071,0.081853],[3.822308,0.083556,0.081115],[3.824567,0.295163,0.338925],[5.321484,1.061397,1.052438],[4.795037,0.267308,0.203014],[4.466789,0.164681,0.162661],[4.715724,0.204908,0.204441],[4.148436,0.664311,0.658639],[0.958589,0.915960,0.916875],[4.438710,0.940025,0.940112],[4.152015,0.137629,0.140684],[4.881633,0.303343,0.300780],[5.020373,0.314807,0.316961],[4.586323,0.065513,0.076092],[5.424183,0.100862,0.106056],[2.947259,0.080757,0.046727],[3.585538,0.074431,0.047424],[3.753716,0.044140,0.042809]],"source":"redshift/results/4x.ra3.16xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-25","machine":"ra3.4xlarge","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":1904,"data_size":22313697280,"result":[[2.135081,0.017989,0.017750],[2.414200,0.022495,0.022023],[6.414938,0.057299,0.055643],[6.411557,0.178071,0.177100],[3.710171,0.300286,0.303593],[3.876626,0.454045,0.477494],[6.410680,0.037709,0.036684],[5.793739,0.024525,0.023881],[5.769831,0.465373,0.490227],[5.939799,3.530177,3.572760],[6.115389,0.177672,0.161334],[6.230233,0.170112,0.166583],[4.046352,0.479846,0.481283],[4.620393,0.923121,0.952839],[4.187850,0.509904,0.518239],[5.660648,0.413803,0.411108],[5.886176,1.123718,1.103859],[3.556251,1.336332,1.381805],[6.040107,1.981635,1.965932],[2.484137,0.030438,0.029756],[4.105144,1.515947,1.515338],[6.216660,1.581792,1.581579],[9.005864,3.555306,3.567163],[30.723242,4.886720,4.885439],[5.678108,0.240413,0.239727],[5.923512,0.232055,0.231429],[5.809703,0.242922,0.242932],[5.820199,1.254403,1.253900],[8.798963,4.587414,4.592794],[13.184562,0.925342,0.873526],[6.617764,0.406749,0.404641],[6.770537,0.587831,0.586834],[5.173074,1.685266,1.713844],[6.216833,2.821660,2.859146],[6.262067,2.851894,2.835493],[5.716614,0.313373,0.328139],[5.683282,0.956320,0.974910],[5.831160,1.103328,1.104760],[6.917177,0.124116,0.107132],[7.662737,0.149158,0.149209],[4.621167,0.044216,0.043012],[4.572912,0.042941,0.042108],[5.906381,0.027692,0.026924]],"source":"redshift/results/4x.ra3.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-29","machine":"ra3.xlplus","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2103,"data_size":21060648960,"result":[[0.079613,0.033549,0.034090],[2.968579,0.063904,0.041282],[4.080153,0.130950,0.108882],[3.210337,0.343640,0.298495],[4.544852,0.631037,0.582424],[4.387295,1.084085,1.060912],[3.068245,0.108602,0.082147],[4.600868,0.045357,0.044651],[5.016095,0.911900,0.867873],[6.649061,2.367888,2.313359],[5.443231,0.309726,0.290368],[5.668514,0.333039,0.313292],[5.188214,1.085051,1.149722],[6.324090,1.961323,1.973299],[5.492480,1.144190,1.123103],[4.882748,0.733695,0.774800],[6.401272,2.257003,2.278818],[5.977724,2.511508,2.403787],[7.838491,3.470040,3.546783],[2.942119,0.094772,0.052837],[5.742532,2.535047,2.498187],[7.144539,2.607847,2.610038],[13.254883,6.773696,6.784579],[21.841477,11.673254,9.552525],[4.594945,0.474181,0.478285],[4.635551,0.494066,0.455041],[4.832767,0.474136,0.474433],[6.194060,2.059882,2.067390],[12.694282,7.745891,7.737045],[19.926847,1.349867,1.272980],[6.178553,0.845828,0.858791],[6.394659,1.080842,1.070668],[8.112381,3.869544,3.986800],[10.048186,5.276152,5.259864],[9.260186,5.163649,5.210499],[4.766534,0.646525,0.657038],[7.602645,1.880335,1.884086],[7.527802,2.172033,2.190131],[5.570360,0.229991,0.228068],[6.632048,0.286827,0.275382],[4.224273,0.103105,0.077275],[4.614709,0.102518,0.075337],[4.389546,0.052659,0.050885]],"source":"redshift/results/4x.ra3.xplus.json"} +,{"system":"SelectDB","date":"2022-11-02","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":526,"data_size":17122903966,"result":[[0.03,0.04,0.02],[0.15,0.03,0.03],[0.13,0.05,0.05],[1.05,0.06,0.05],[0.34,0.28,0.27],[0.82,0.57,0.57],[0.01,0.02,0.02],[0.22,0.02,0.02],[0.56,0.46,0.45],[0.52,0.51,0.50],[0.40,0.11,0.12],[0.18,0.12,0.12],[0.54,0.50,0.49],[0.83,0.93,0.95],[0.74,0.89,0.72],[0.32,0.31,0.31],[1.08,1.08,1.09],[0.27,0.35,0.23],[2.18,2.04,1.98],[0.02,0.01,0.02],[10.74,1.30,1.31],[8.36,3.46,0.99],[12.21,1.23,1.04],[5.20,0.52,0.50],[0.11,0.04,0.05],[0.39,0.13,0.13],[0.05,0.04,0.04],[9.43,1.80,1.16],[9.93,9.69,9.60],[0.83,0.78,0.78],[1.77,0.38,0.37],[2.57,0.41,0.43],[2.77,2.75,3.11],[11.62,4.01,3.95],[11.63,4.03,5.97],[0.46,0.40,0.39],[0.11,0.06,0.06],[0.06,0.03,0.03],[0.03,0.03,0.02],[0.13,0.11,0.10],[0.05,0.02,0.03],[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02]],"source":"selectdb/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"SelectDB","date":"2022-11-02","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":444,"data_size":17122903978,"result":[[0.03,0.03,0.02],[0.36,0.05,0.04],[0.18,0.07,0.06],[0.96,0.06,0.06],[0.32,0.28,0.29],[0.86,0.62,0.61],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[0.04,0.02,0.03],[0.50,0.47,0.47],[0.53,0.74,0.55],[0.31,0.11,0.11],[0.15,0.10,0.14],[0.57,0.62,0.55],[0.85,0.92,0.96],[0.77,0.90,0.74],[0.32,0.32,0.32],[1.22,0.99,0.98],[0.23,0.22,0.25],[2.01,1.80,1.82],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[10.76,1.05,1.04],[8.99,2.84,0.84],[12.21,1.04,0.87],[5.79,0.30,0.29],[0.12,0.04,0.04],[0.41,0.12,0.13],[0.04,0.04,0.03],[9.67,1.59,1.11],[9.06,8.23,7.84],[0.67,0.55,0.57],[1.76,0.37,0.77],[2.10,0.42,0.43],[2.78,2.76,3.11],[11.56,4.04,4.21],[11.52,4.05,4.28],[0.50,0.41,0.41],[0.63,0.05,0.05],[0.06,0.03,0.03],[0.03,0.02,0.03],[0.16,0.13,0.12],[0.06,0.01,0.03],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.03,0.02]],"source":"selectdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"SelectDB","date":"2022-10-08","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":369,"data_size":17123069872,"result":[[0.01,0.01,0.00],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.04,0.04,0.05],[0.07,0.06,0.07],[0.17,0.15,0.17],[0.30,0.30,0.28],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.32,0.33,0.34],[0.36,0.37,0.34],[0.11,0.11,0.25],[0.11,0.11,0.10],[0.23,0.23,0.23],[0.55,0.75,0.89],[0.32,0.30,0.31],[0.18,0.16,0.19],[0.53,0.51,0.50],[0.20,0.20,0.20],[1.04,1.06,1.30],[0.01,0.01,0.00],[0.59,0.60,0.66],[0.48,0.34,0.34],[0.38,0.38,0.37],[0.25,0.26,0.25],[0.04,0.04,0.04],[0.15,0.15,0.14],[0.04,0.04,0.04],[0.55,0.54,0.54],[1.39,1.36,1.34],[0.68,0.69,0.76],[0.24,0.23,0.23],[0.21,0.20,0.21],[1.45,1.53,2.05],[1.84,1.92,1.67],[1.83,1.75,1.90],[0.19,0.22,0.20],[0.03,0.04,0.04],[0.03,0.03,0.03],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.06,0.06,0.06],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02]],"source":"selectdb/results/c6a.metal.json"} +,{"system":"SingleStore","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: MemSQL. Some queries did not run due to memory limits","tags":["MySQL compatible","column-oriented"],"load_time":690,"data_size":29836263469,"result":[[0.09,0.00,0.00],[0.23,0.04,0.01],[0.47,0.15,0.15],[0.63,0.09,0.08],[1.65,1.23,1.20],[7.96,2.79,2.63],[0.10,0.00,0.00],[0.17,0.02,0.02],[1.90,1.40,1.39],[4.79,3.52,3.48],[0.94,0.22,0.23],[0.89,0.24,0.23],[5.82,2.26,2.25],[6.97,4.62,4.66],[3.05,2.28,2.31],[3.92,2.70,2.28],[5.83,4.48,4.42],[4.76,4.13,4.12],[14.03,null,null],[0.57,0.05,0.04],[18.18,1.74,1.94],[20.85,2.17,0.98],[31.98,3.12,1.22],[78.96,3.35,108.85],[2.82,0.39,0.32],[1.83,0.44,0.35],[2.81,0.33,0.32],[18.33,2.57,1.15],[null,null,null],[3.56,2.40,2.40],[3.83,1.11,1.11],[7.35,1.73,1.70],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[2.53,1.92,1.84],[0.92,0.23,0.19],[0.84,0.15,0.08],[0.70,0.05,0.05],[3.12,0.38,0.36],[0.29,0.03,0.03],[0.22,0.06,0.02],[0.27,0.11,0.12]],"source":"singlestore/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"SingleStore","date":"2022-07-15","machine":"S2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: MemSQL. Some queries did not run due to unsupported regex","tags":["MySQL compatible","column-oriented","managed"],"load_time":1145,"data_size":19219978649,"result":[[0.10,0.04,0.01],[0.13,0.00,0.01],[0.57,0.09,0.10],[0.64,0.13,0.08],[2.04,1.39,1.32],[2.56,1.95,2.15],[0.12,0.01,0.00],[0.34,0.06,0.01],[2.14,1.71,1.71],[5.70,5.10,5.49],[1.02,0.25,0.28],[1.05,0.29,0.25],[2.38,1.91,1.74],[4.04,3.40,3.46],[2.19,1.60,1.75],[1.90,1.56,1.55],[4.92,4.26,4.46],[4.13,4.01,4.03],[10.11,9.61,9.56],[0.36,0.05,0.10],[1.61,1.29,1.24],[1.04,0.55,0.57],[1.38,0.96,0.89],[3.00,2.15,2.31],[0.66,0.28,0.20],[0.67,0.19,0.16],[0.69,0.18,0.16],[1.14,0.56,0.56],[null,null,null],[3.43,1.69,1.51],[1.73,1.06,1.03],[2.17,1.60,1.45],[11.17,10.42,10.74],[9.94,9.61,9.66],[10.22,9.84,9.84],[2.31,1.79,1.97],[0.40,0.20,0.14],[0.35,0.16,0.09],[0.28,0.08,0.08],[0.68,0.28,0.36],[0.25,0.15,0.02],[0.23,0.10,0.01],[0.24,0.10,0.03]],"source":"singlestore/results/s2.json"} +,{"system":"SingleStore","date":"2022-07-15","machine":"S24","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: MemSQL. Some queries did not run due to unsupported regex","tags":["MySQL compatible","column-oriented","managed"],"load_time":1043,"data_size":19219978649,"result":[[0.10,0.04,0.07],[0.12,0.06,0.00],[0.42,0.05,0.01],[0.34,0.05,0.01],[0.97,0.29,0.23],[0.87,0.34,0.25],[0.06,0.04,0.00],[0.15,0.01,0.01],[1.04,0.39,0.31],[1.68,0.96,0.85],[0.30,0.19,0.09],[0.30,0.21,0.08],[0.56,0.26,0.35],[0.70,0.48,0.43],[0.64,0.35,0.27],[0.98,0.40,0.36],[1.52,0.75,0.86],[0.70,0.74,0.71],[1.73,1.07,0.96],[0.15,0.05,0.01],[0.37,0.20,0.26],[0.55,0.14,0.25],[0.41,0.31,0.31],[0.66,0.39,0.46],[0.52,0.12,0.08],[0.30,0.08,0.15],[0.32,0.16,0.07],[0.82,0.21,0.13],[null,null,null],[2.28,0.34,0.38],[0.55,0.28,0.17],[0.53,0.29,0.34],[1.75,1.07,1.04],[2.05,1.41,1.43],[2.11,1.45,1.40],[1.14,0.53,0.45],[0.34,0.12,0.24],[0.29,0.09,0.21],[0.35,0.11,0.18],[0.59,0.22,0.39],[0.30,0.07,0.15],[0.27,0.22,0.16],[0.29,0.06,0.06]],"source":"singlestore/results/s24.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"2XL","cluster_size":32,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.177,0.052,0.090],[0.903,0.324,0.782],[0.458,2.909,0.275],[0.881,0.316,0.166],[0.404,0.257,0.256],[0.481,0.325,0.339],[0.056,0.062,0.060],[0.183,0.324,0.280],[0.444,0.314,0.320],[0.408,0.426,0.417],[0.345,0.241,0.253],[0.406,0.245,0.235],[0.521,1.259,0.326],[0.466,0.493,0.526],[0.447,0.349,0.362],[0.327,0.322,0.302],[0.462,0.508,0.461],[0.489,0.481,0.455],[0.731,0.659,0.674],[0.151,0.156,0.160],[0.832,0.339,0.312],[0.289,0.292,0.340],[0.591,0.484,0.419],[2.661,0.716,0.696],[0.190,0.199,0.377],[0.181,0.182,0.194],[0.220,0.209,0.195],[0.368,0.330,0.347],[0.677,0.645,0.646],[0.877,0.886,0.871],[0.415,0.282,0.301],[1.265,0.404,0.550],[0.786,0.750,0.757],[0.905,0.835,0.841],[0.864,0.865,0.823],[0.352,0.360,0.364],[0.201,0.186,0.200],[0.143,0.137,0.276],[0.290,0.132,0.146],[0.310,0.301,0.304],[0.212,0.197,0.170],[0.223,0.174,0.177],[0.172,0.172,0.172]],"source":"snowflake/results/2xl.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"3XL","cluster_size":64,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.165,0.061,0.049],[1.356,1.252,1.502],[1.287,0.470,0.325],[0.627,0.331,0.181],[0.265,0.265,0.483],[0.887,0.450,0.298],[0.054,0.066,0.062],[0.182,0.222,0.194],[0.408,0.438,0.319],[0.434,0.462,0.411],[1.357,0.247,0.412],[0.343,0.250,0.517],[0.273,0.289,0.600],[0.404,0.405,0.392],[0.379,0.304,0.455],[0.275,0.271,0.264],[0.418,0.386,0.388],[0.417,0.434,0.567],[0.753,0.759,0.506],[0.291,0.307,0.400],[0.954,0.423,0.280],[0.568,0.562,0.248],[0.568,0.477,0.496],[1.458,0.492,0.514],[0.179,0.300,0.184],[0.165,0.169,0.176],[0.197,0.186,0.190],[0.289,0.547,0.397],[0.513,0.544,0.632],[0.766,0.754,0.775],[0.389,0.374,0.383],[0.484,0.297,0.286],[0.505,0.505,0.734],[0.656,0.598,0.621],[0.634,0.646,0.609],[0.309,0.298,0.370],[0.192,0.219,0.212],[0.840,0.174,0.139],[0.172,0.163,0.151],[0.323,0.296,0.347],[0.200,0.154,0.144],[0.191,0.121,0.125],[0.137,0.233,0.148]],"source":"snowflake/results/3xl.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"4XL","cluster_size":128,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.164,0.061,0.078],[2.471,2.436,1.927],[1.656,0.222,0.639],[0.336,1.244,0.206],[0.435,0.414,0.373],[0.520,0.495,0.326],[0.052,0.051,0.057],[0.244,0.515,0.358],[0.473,0.477,0.659],[0.706,0.523,0.499],[0.619,0.361,0.303],[0.463,0.367,0.290],[0.385,0.319,0.376],[0.661,0.436,0.452],[0.446,0.317,0.336],[0.504,0.283,0.395],[0.478,1.395,0.350],[0.555,1.041,0.993],[0.565,0.558,1.473],[0.310,0.684,0.278],[0.637,1.202,0.249],[0.467,0.294,0.436],[0.671,0.478,0.611],[6.262,0.449,0.425],[0.476,0.213,0.184],[0.552,0.241,0.201],[0.458,0.415,0.402],[0.339,0.357,0.322],[0.732,0.549,0.483],[0.914,0.757,0.743],[0.718,0.310,0.606],[0.605,0.363,0.425],[0.468,0.860,0.784],[0.868,1.787,0.713],[0.807,0.691,0.544],[0.485,0.338,0.672],[0.263,0.221,0.230],[0.147,0.145,0.139],[0.135,0.239,0.136],[0.322,0.378,0.348],[0.236,0.138,0.132],[0.193,0.124,0.139],[0.146,0.145,0.139]],"source":"snowflake/results/4xl.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"L","cluster_size":8,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.067,0.054,0.051],[1.158,1.409,0.190],[1.470,0.566,0.715],[0.892,0.534,0.264],[0.474,0.499,0.489],[0.950,0.650,0.699],[0.069,0.055,0.110],[0.317,0.307,0.321],[0.949,0.593,0.654],[0.713,1.099,0.860],[0.622,0.370,0.404],[0.457,0.369,0.414],[0.610,0.566,0.653],[0.970,1.006,0.976],[1.517,0.636,0.603],[0.532,0.541,0.533],[1.018,1.001,1.022],[0.942,0.996,0.940],[2.246,1.596,1.560],[0.181,0.184,0.200],[1.135,0.788,0.609],[0.669,0.528,0.524],[1.164,0.827,0.882],[3.545,2.214,2.107],[0.559,0.431,0.426],[0.340,0.296,0.383],[0.695,0.314,0.368],[0.628,0.658,0.637],[1.511,1.385,1,440],[1.390,1.418,1.322],[1.107,0.687,0.537],[1.026,0.737,0.659],[1.712,1.681,1.728],[2.141,2.130,2.225],[2.163,2.157,2.110],[0.650,0.619,0.627],[0.204,0.195,0.225],[0.159,0.152,0.156],[0.146,0.136,0.150],[0.359,0.290,0.364],[0.196,0.129,0.227],[0.201,0.128,0.143],[0.176,0.129,0.146]],"source":"snowflake/results/l.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"M","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.054,0.062,0.064],[0.698,0.563,0.407],[0.586,0.412,0.266],[1.386,0.363,0.301],[0.814,0.825,0.984],[1.303,1.024,1.048],[0.069,0.066,0.062],[0.334,0.254,0.270],[1.043,0.952,0.993],[1.210,1.209,1.171],[0.667,0.483,0.456],[0.543,0.495,0.500],[1.005,0.889,0.888],[1.644,1.646,1.652],[1.054,1.044,0.966],[0.893,0.874,0.907],[1.737,1.779,1.837],[1.518,1.539,1.526],[3.082,2.818,2.842],[0.309,0.286,0.256],[1.594,1.017,0.993],[0.781,0.853,0.735],[1.461,1.226,1.080],[5.308,2.974,2.642],[0.511,0.625,0.467],[0.405,0.382,0.439],[0.601,0.535,0.471],[0.947,1.624,1.192],[2.631,2.486,2.490],[1.938,1.960,1.954],[1.930,0.830,0.835],[1.359,1.140,1.062],[3.599,3.623,3.621],[3.619,3.741,3.663],[3.725,3.614,3.786],[1.149,1.126,1.055],[0.202,0.207,0.196],[0.152,0.139,0.145],[0.149,0.144,0.148],[0.383,0.287,0.294],[0.203,0.137,0.119],[0.200,0.312,0.137],[0.149,0.130,0.214]],"source":"snowflake/results/m.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"S","cluster_size":2,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.186,0.060,0.062],[0.980,0.574,0.311],[0.977,0.554,0.426],[0.686,0.573,0.404],[1.386,1.384,1.349],[1.871,1.697,1.704],[0.052,0.059,0.227],[0.309,0.536,0.508],[1.768,1.631,1.635],[2.039,2.219,1.908],[0.807,0.647,0.587],[0.763,0.690,0.631],[1.403,1.586,1.404],[2.593,2.584,2.554],[1.670,1.538,1.653],[1.659,1.509,1.514],[2.875,2.990,2.998],[2.605,2.549,2.598],[6.120,5.894,5.766],[0.320,0.431,0.416],[2.406,1.703,1.609],[1.189,1.186,1.163],[2.104,1.441,1.370],[7.144,5.174,4.139],[0.839,0.659,0.641],[0.527,0.518,0.509],[0.633,0.621,0.695],[1.491,1.509,1.514],[4.848,4.485,4.571],[3.067,3.106,3.098],[1.521,1.224,1.236],[1.839,1.690,1.497],[5.692,5.751,6.087],[6.733,6.755,6.712],[6.722,6.709,6.676],[1.704,1.686,1.676],[0.203,0.231,0.218],[0.151,0.134,0.214],[0.140,0.156,0.163],[0.317,0.328,0.319],[0.166,0.133,0.141],[0.166,0.120,0.140],[0.120,0.119,0.126]],"source":"snowflake/results/s.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"XL","cluster_size":16,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.071,0.053,0.057],[0.998,0.610,0.240],[0.420,1.138,1.051],[0.653,0.264,0.178],[0.352,0.312,0.349],[1.126,0.431,0.420],[0.067,0.057,0.054],[0.225,0.217,0.200],[0.617,0.366,0.371],[1.006,0.541,0.498],[0.463,0.425,0.293],[0.431,0.360,0.339],[0.392,0.371,0.386],[0.588,0.581,0.590],[0.634,0.414,0.400],[0.368,0.410,0.388],[0.594,0.639,0.663],[0.616,0.581,0.569],[1.092,0.933,0.901],[0.493,0.213,0.160],[0.886,0.480,0.442],[0.448,0.337,0.399],[0.840,0.572,0.505],[2.251,1.230,0.959],[0.295,0.253,0.241],[0.214,0.239,0.278],[0.261,0.232,0.314],[0.422,0.429,0.403],[0.892,0.934,0.883],[1.041,1.017,1.009],[0.715,0.442,0.363],[0.845,0.413,0.461],[1.101,1.085,1.102],[1.294,1.272,1.339],[1.839,1.327,1.241],[0.439,0.399,0.393],[0.199,0.211,0.190],[0.157,0.143,0.140],[0.145,0.157,0.141],[0.331,0.291,0.333],[0.173,0.214,0.138],[0.189,0.150,0.159],[0.135,0.149,0.138]],"source":"snowflake/results/xl.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"XS","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.169,0.055,0.056],[1.184,0.582,0.386],[1.350,0.560,0.568],[1.270,0.554,0.538],[2.516,2.564,2.506],[2.935,2.649,2.670],[0.052,0.050,0.064],[0.383,0.387,0.397],[3.249,2.993,3.014],[3.589,3.627,3.887],[1.243,0.986,0.966],[1.325,1.080,1.073],[2.038,2.046,2.035],[3.738,3.626,3.718],[2.318,2.159,2.176],[2.733,2.637,2.668],[5.607,5.683,5.667],[3.978,3.923,3.879],[10.085,9.871,9.844],[0.450,0.375,0.469],[5.474,3.103,3.060],[2.012,1.982,1.971],[3.365,2.471,2.501],[11.960,10.619,9.518],[1.074,1.059,1.026],[0.856,0.846,0.879],[1.100,1.085,1.083],[3.057,3.228,3.117],[9.406,9.019,9.158],[6.196,6.243,6.911],[2.906,2.343,2.017],[2.954,2.666,2.565],[9.459,9.565,9.557],[9.555,9.529,9.368],[9.409,9.185,9.294],[2.796,2.880,2.685],[0.299,0.249,0.262],[0.156,0.145,0.180],[0.147,0.146,0.160],[0.371,0.357,0.356],[0.166,0.133,0.155],[0.218,0.140,0.135],[0.140,0.152,0.158]],"source":"snowflake/results/xs.json"} ,{"system":"SQLite","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","embedded","row-oriented"],"load_time":2608,"data_size":75776589824,"result":[[752.739,2.003,1.2],[304.302,291.521,286.965],[293.964,287.619,287.219],[758.302,5.879,5.65],[836.393,48.593,48.452],[362.605,344.884,356.245],[763.993,11.602,10.795],[296.348,286.879,287.557],[365.816,360.339,354.126],[374.403,365.196,362.261],[302.989,293.888,298.432],[303.64,291.729,295.347],[316.824,298.18,301.006],[320.665,301.15,305.227],[313.593,301.021,301.626],[794.881,47,47.225],[355.346,344.615,342.442],[316.499,305.971,305.007],[398.177,380.383,385.571],[751.82,5.082,4.913],[295.522,286.573,287.368],[298.58,287.182,288.303],[296.474,288.747,288.638],[296.579,287.127,287.361],[304.709,286.865,287.56],[300.391,290.633,288.587],[294.605,286.91,287.799],[305.986,312.111,305.626],[null,null,null],[411.225,397.614,394.253],[307.711,295.181,300.266],[312.472,299.079,298.19],[386.674,378.347,376.963],[409.742,409.554,420.273],[468.73,453.709,458.149],[366.015,347.446,346.728],[2.911,0.781,0.757],[1.599,0.609,0.587],[1.288,0.256,0.238],[2.469,1.582,1.52],[1.274,0.303,0.283],[1.322,0.317,0.314],[1.498,0.602,0.613]],"source":"sqlite/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"StarRocks","date":"2022-09-25","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":492,"data_size":17233927256,"result":[[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.21,0.03,0.04],[1.88,0.07,0.07],[3.4,0.09,0.1],[0.37,0.34,0.33],[2.71,0.88,0.84],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.06,0.03,0.03],[1.66,0.53,0.47],[1.58,1.52,1.47],[0.68,0.1,0.11],[1.26,0.12,0.12],[0.54,0.54,0.54],[0.99,0.96,0.99],[0.81,0.77,0.8],[0.41,0.39,0.4],[1.45,1.49,1.52],[0.52,0.52,0.51],[2.98,2.6,2.56],[0.02,0.01,0],[12.97,1.1,1.11],[14.84,0.91,0.94],[27.68,1.96,1.94],[46.49,1.49,1.22],[0.16,0.11,0.07],[0.94,0.12,0.12],[0.06,0.05,0.04],[13.99,1.44,1.42],[11.58,10.2,10.37],[0.22,0.1,0.11],[4.6,0.38,0.36],[4.15,0.53,0.52],[3.54,3.48,3.48],[15.22,6.08,6.17],[14.9,6.34,6.31],[1.86,0.59,0.51],[0.99,0.09,0.08],[0.42,0.05,0.05],[0.15,0.04,0.04],[1.27,0.18,0.18],[0.32,0.04,0.03],[0.11,0.03,0.04],[0.08,0.03,0.02]],"source":"starrocks/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"StarRocks","date":"2023-02-10","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":433,"data_size":17705230744,"result":[[0.04,0.04,0.03],[0.12,0.03,0.03],[0.66,0.06,0.06],[2.08,0.08,0.06],[0.1,0.08,0.09],[2.19,0.22,0.21],[0.04,0.02,0.03],[0.06,0.04,0.04],[0.99,0.12,0.12],[0.73,0.74,0.7],[0.13,0.06,0.05],[1.04,0.06,0.07],[0.17,0.18,0.17],[0.23,0.23,0.23],[0.54,0.18,0.18],[0.09,0.09,0.08],[0.31,0.32,0.3],[0.12,0.1,0.11],[1.27,0.48,0.44],[0.01,0.01,0],[12.09,0.17,0.15],[0.17,0.13,0.12],[10.91,0.28,0.24],[28.25,0.86,1.36],[0.03,0.03,0.02],[0.06,0.04,0.04],[0.02,0.03,0.02],[0.63,0.24,0.21],[8.77,1.6,1.64],[0.12,0.1,0.1],[1.33,0.13,0.13],[3.46,0.18,0.19],[0.97,0.86,0.86],[0.95,0.96,0.98],[0.96,0.97,0.97],[0.14,0.12,0.14],[0.07,0.06,0.06],[0.05,0.04,0.04],[0.04,0.03,0.03],[0.1,0.09,0.09],[0.47,0.03,0.03],[0.25,0.03,0.03],[0.04,0.03,0.03]],"source":"starrocks/results/c6a.metal.json"} +,{"system":"StarRocks","date":"2022-09-25","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":492,"data_size":17233927256,"result":[[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.21,0.03,0.04],[1.88,0.07,0.07],[3.40,0.09,0.10],[0.37,0.34,0.33],[2.71,0.88,0.84],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.06,0.03,0.03],[1.66,0.53,0.47],[1.58,1.52,1.47],[0.68,0.10,0.11],[1.26,0.12,0.12],[0.54,0.54,0.54],[0.99,0.96,0.99],[0.81,0.77,0.80],[0.41,0.39,0.40],[1.45,1.49,1.52],[0.52,0.52,0.51],[2.98,2.60,2.56],[0.02,0.01,0.00],[12.97,1.10,1.11],[14.84,0.91,0.94],[27.68,1.96,1.94],[46.49,1.49,1.22],[0.16,0.11,0.07],[0.94,0.12,0.12],[0.06,0.05,0.04],[13.99,1.44,1.42],[11.58,10.20,10.37],[0.22,0.10,0.11],[4.60,0.38,0.36],[4.15,0.53,0.52],[3.54,3.48,3.48],[15.22,6.08,6.17],[14.90,6.34,6.31],[1.86,0.59,0.51],[0.99,0.09,0.08],[0.42,0.05,0.05],[0.15,0.04,0.04],[1.27,0.18,0.18],[0.32,0.04,0.03],[0.11,0.03,0.04],[0.08,0.03,0.02]],"source":"starrocks/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"StarRocks","date":"2023-02-10","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":433,"data_size":17705230744,"result":[[0.04,0.04,0.03],[0.12,0.03,0.03],[0.66,0.06,0.06],[2.08,0.08,0.06],[0.10,0.08,0.09],[2.19,0.22,0.21],[0.04,0.02,0.03],[0.06,0.04,0.04],[0.99,0.12,0.12],[0.73,0.74,0.70],[0.13,0.06,0.05],[1.04,0.06,0.07],[0.17,0.18,0.17],[0.23,0.23,0.23],[0.54,0.18,0.18],[0.09,0.09,0.08],[0.31,0.32,0.30],[0.12,0.10,0.11],[1.27,0.48,0.44],[0.01,0.01,0.00],[12.09,0.17,0.15],[0.17,0.13,0.12],[10.91,0.28,0.24],[28.25,0.86,1.36],[0.03,0.03,0.02],[0.06,0.04,0.04],[0.02,0.03,0.02],[0.63,0.24,0.21],[8.77,1.60,1.64],[0.12,0.10,0.10],[1.33,0.13,0.13],[3.46,0.18,0.19],[0.97,0.86,0.86],[0.95,0.96,0.98],[0.96,0.97,0.97],[0.14,0.12,0.14],[0.07,0.06,0.06],[0.05,0.04,0.04],[0.04,0.03,0.03],[0.10,0.09,0.09],[0.47,0.03,0.03],[0.25,0.03,0.03],[0.04,0.03,0.03]],"source":"starrocks/results/c6a.metal.json"} ,{"system":"TimescaleDB (compression)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","PostgreSQL compatible","column-oriented","time-series"],"load_time":4605,"data_size":20333747165,"result":[[2.28686,1.63642,1.64263],[32.6848,1.63476,1.40052],[60.8633,3.70484,3.59342],[36.4029,2.87091,2.80739],[110.391,38.9688,38.0549],[147.379,66.2513,65.6379],[33.0294,2.92031,2.84375],[33.0221,1.2984,1.19227],[115.694,47.4651,47.0125],[156.347,51.577,51.2694],[68.3301,4.75521,4.68007],[77.4356,5.55128,5.56577],[49.7741,11.2911,11.3265],[81.1014,14.9111,14.9541],[82.9569,14.6156,14.6331],[62.0338,26.399,26.3351],[103.259,36.4122,36.6076],[92.8828,26.2395,25.8991],[144.281,63.5102,63.7661],[7.00679,0.573073,0.536283],[75.0203,7.86344,7.90495],[81.2825,9.15868,9.01775],[104.084,13.9528,13.8435],[132.531,81.522,82.1561],[80.6965,3.28231,3.16574],[39.7693,2.51443,2.43849],[80.4245,3.26941,3.13916],[104.015,13.7044,13.5313],[307.26,253.127,252.147],[42.8549,22.4187,22.0325],[137.601,14.9592,14.6804],[136.767,22.8007,22.131],[263.005,168.551,163.355],[156.919,92.6308,91.702],[160.842,96.0512,97.1773],[62.8357,28.0336,28.7397],[1.75869,0.561604,0.541215],[0.46607,0.191863,0.19021],[0.303671,0.137579,0.136615],[2.32031,1.49223,1.52369],[0.563764,0.14192,0.138234],[0.372428,0.122989,0.123709],[0.448574,0.159092,0.154687]],"source":"timescaledb-compressed/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"TimescaleDB","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","PostgreSQL compatible","row-oriented","time-series"],"load_time":1620,"data_size":72882392030,"result":[[437.7,215.793,176.42],[327.026,259.568,244.578],[262.978,263.09,263.083],[262.807,263.046,266.847],[337.497,334.964,330.852],[355.689,356.801,362.894],[262.762,263.012,262.968],[263.055,263.016,263.028],[319.928,319.388,320.704],[323.584,322.224,322.488],[265.979,265.465,265.375],[266.019,265.543,265.462],[277.018,276.3,276.595],[280.352,279.251,279.572],[279.915,279.896,279.674],[296.377,298.506,297.659],[314.448,314.605,312.57],[302.668,302.672,303.039],[325.81,324.061,324.376],[262.447,262.698,262.704],[267.581,267.467,267.482],[268.085,267.466,267.696],[263.391,263.097,263.126],[38.291,0.435,0.335],[0.127,0.005,0.005],[263.138,263.1,263.092],[0.889,0.341,0.339],[267.586,267.498,267.491],[289.086,290.012,290.093],[263.22,263.071,263.109],[274.78,273.995,273.998],[282.217,281.39,281.47],[429.273,426.588,439.431],[448.808,418.724,418.207],[455.196,422.75,423.142],[299.263,296.937,297.261],[18.693,1.552,1.481],[18.125,0.945,0.937],[18.528,1.062,0.902],[18.268,1.779,1.77],[19.615,1.965,1.966],[18.97,1.435,1.43],[18.33,1.153,0.952]],"source":"timescaledb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"TimescaleDB","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","PostgreSQL compatible","row-oriented","time-series"],"load_time":1620,"data_size":72882392030,"result":[[437.700,215.793,176.420],[327.026,259.568,244.578],[262.978,263.090,263.083],[262.807,263.046,266.847],[337.497,334.964,330.852],[355.689,356.801,362.894],[262.762,263.012,262.968],[263.055,263.016,263.028],[319.928,319.388,320.704],[323.584,322.224,322.488],[265.979,265.465,265.375],[266.019,265.543,265.462],[277.018,276.300,276.595],[280.352,279.251,279.572],[279.915,279.896,279.674],[296.377,298.506,297.659],[314.448,314.605,312.570],[302.668,302.672,303.039],[325.810,324.061,324.376],[262.447,262.698,262.704],[267.581,267.467,267.482],[268.085,267.466,267.696],[263.391,263.097,263.126],[38.291,0.435,0.335],[0.127,0.005,0.005],[263.138,263.100,263.092],[0.889,0.341,0.339],[267.586,267.498,267.491],[289.086,290.012,290.093],[263.220,263.071,263.109],[274.780,273.995,273.998],[282.217,281.390,281.470],[429.273,426.588,439.431],[448.808,418.724,418.207],[455.196,422.750,423.142],[299.263,296.937,297.261],[18.693,1.552,1.481],[18.125,0.945,0.937],[18.528,1.062,0.902],[18.268,1.779,1.770],[19.615,1.965,1.966],[18.970,1.435,1.430],[18.330,1.153,0.952]],"source":"timescaledb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ]; // end of data const additional_data_size_points = [ From 12cbdb9007d6202a8b585041c365f91f9acc75f6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Kirk Mitchener Date: Thu, 30 Nov 2023 00:34:06 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 2/6] update for 500gb gp2 --- datafusion/results/single.json | 88 +++++++++++++++++----------------- 1 file changed, 44 insertions(+), 44 deletions(-) diff --git a/datafusion/results/single.json b/datafusion/results/single.json index fd6df3b80..19bd8f83f 100644 --- a/datafusion/results/single.json +++ b/datafusion/results/single.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "system": "DataFusion (Parquet, single)", - "date": "2023-11-19", + "date": "2023-07-29", "machine": "c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2", "cluster_size": 1, "comment": "v33.0.0 (d2efaa9)", @@ -11,48 +11,48 @@ "data_size": 14779976446, "result": [ -[0.076, 0.045, 0.045], -[0.110, 0.061, 0.062], -[0.200, 0.109, 0.106], -[1.529, 0.117, 0.113], -[2.265, 0.832, 0.836], -[2.652, 1.246, 1.247], -[0.091, 0.065, 0.071], -[0.100, 0.063, 0.063], -[2.465, 1.490, 1.478], -[3.672, 2.539, 2.496], -[1.627, 0.344, 0.330], -[1.885, 0.366, 0.369], -[2.679, 1.253, 1.236], -[6.053, 2.504, 2.505], -[2.885, 1.386, 1.382], -[1.776, 0.968, 0.927], -[5.752, 2.709, 2.689], -[5.639, 2.646, 2.629], -[10.707, 5.692, 5.799], -[1.171, 0.100, 0.105], -[20.537, 1.570, 1.575], -[23.093, 1.901, 1.897], -[44.658, 4.103, 4.065], -[112.447, 11.674, 11.654], -[5.791, 0.581, 0.558], -[2.340, 0.511, 0.529], -[5.823, 0.626, 0.632], -[19.944, 2.333, 2.343], -[17.608, 5.052, 5.086], -[0.557, 0.500, 0.494], -[4.888, 1.140, 1.126], -[11.791, 1.553, 1.566], -[12.415, 7.764, 7.724], -[21.279, 6.722, 6.816], -[21.569, 7.325, 7.297], -[1.981, 1.839, 1.821], -[0.466, 0.306, 0.312], -[0.254, 0.185, 0.182], -[0.284, 0.173, 0.171], -[0.887, 0.685, 0.667], -[0.171, 0.092, 0.095], -[0.144, 0.086, 0.087], -[0.151, 0.101, 0.097] +[0.068, 0.045, 0.046], +[0.098, 0.060, 0.062], +[0.175, 0.111, 0.106], +[0.401, 0.107, 0.108], +[1.011, 0.812, 0.815], +[1.356, 1.258, 1.230], +[0.094, 0.069, 0.068], +[0.096, 0.065, 0.063], +[1.548, 1.432, 1.459], +[2.676, 2.483, 2.472], +[0.488, 0.342, 0.337], +[0.525, 0.353, 0.360], +[1.350, 1.246, 1.244], +[3.263, 2.467, 2.480], +[1.460, 1.376, 1.394], +[1.019, 0.940, 0.934], +[3.053, 2.688, 2.713], +[2.989, 2.598, 2.615], +[6.715, 5.675, 5.654], +[0.311, 0.098, 0.102], +[9.910, 1.566, 1.577], +[11.127, 1.946, 1.856], +[21.951, 4.155, 4.082], +[55.962, 11.448, 11.448], +[2.450, 0.555, 0.576], +[0.719, 0.507, 0.503], +[2.437, 0.637, 0.635], +[9.570, 2.371, 2.326], +[9.068, 5.013, 4.951], +[0.553, 0.488, 0.477], +[2.074, 1.104, 1.121], +[5.590, 1.526, 1.552], +[8.068, 7.646, 7.726], +[11.579, 6.687, 6.672], +[11.953, 7.284, 7.291], +[1.911, 1.814, 1.828], +[0.440, 0.311, 0.322], +[0.231, 0.184, 0.180], +[0.242, 0.171, 0.170], +[0.840, 0.676, 0.658], +[0.153, 0.094, 0.098], +[0.129, 0.089, 0.089], +[0.156, 0.097, 0.105] ] } From ebd799507da1093f006a5b964d7e4652f88896e0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Kirk Mitchener Date: Thu, 30 Nov 2023 00:42:23 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 3/6] update index.html --- index.html | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/index.html b/index.html index 0d6a60b93..836719aad 100644 --- a/index.html +++ b/index.html @@ -379,7 +379,7 @@ ,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":368,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002554,0.002257,0.002058],[0.041885,0.026659,0.026301],[0.377386,0.047169,0.046246],[1.111276,0.043512,0.042424],[1.337056,0.378329,0.378000],[1.517051,0.516229,0.513954],[0.040641,0.024230,0.025701],[0.048797,0.029641,0.028597],[1.695267,0.591075,0.582311],[2.821410,0.663166,0.666039],[1.407029,0.255046,0.253865],[1.971179,0.258693,0.254872],[1.548181,0.639874,0.637980],[3.217226,1.045900,1.038888],[1.861833,0.815691,0.806401],[0.768044,0.530842,0.528053],[3.639183,2.567878,2.556752],[2.787874,1.658994,1.674600],[7.466028,4.180932,4.241429],[0.006217,0.003521,0.013345],[10.689073,0.562040,0.551567],[12.984685,0.686805,0.676753],[23.748547,1.311328,1.267505],[6.763271,0.285252,0.273009],[0.132152,0.028291,0.028296],[1.943504,0.226601,0.224721],[0.326737,0.029324,0.027575],[11.538898,0.516586,0.502331],[9.223633,6.920732,6.945943],[0.153429,0.074415,0.073831],[5.458251,0.556813,0.550952],[7.330739,0.895601,0.866605],[7.677006,4.602414,4.704338],[11.838616,2.964448,3.080231],[11.848512,2.947774,3.029332],[0.578680,0.525259,0.491508],[0.086986,0.062111,0.062906],[0.065790,0.032106,0.031138],[0.030254,0.016060,0.017036],[0.124381,0.093671,0.095871],[0.029603,0.019117,0.022236],[0.019694,0.010848,0.016053],[0.019806,0.010239,0.010112]],"source":"databend/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":357,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002354,0.001796,0.001676],[0.035410,0.019995,0.020233],[0.387346,0.031738,0.031385],[1.137630,0.030899,0.030119],[1.405919,0.423186,0.423155],[1.562987,0.578546,0.580928],[0.032613,0.014625,0.014217],[0.032749,0.022130,0.022904],[1.735342,0.533320,0.524569],[2.804289,0.599192,0.595315],[1.369841,0.175470,0.186941],[2.092200,0.181471,0.181655],[1.750355,0.683891,0.677640],[3.213623,1.051686,1.047710],[1.881785,0.830412,0.813682],[0.813736,0.602403,0.591426],[3.880537,2.488562,2.480400],[2.782833,1.367600,1.344967],[7.815274,4.236312,4.263853],[0.006507,0.003202,0.003167],[10.674944,0.451903,0.438830],[12.984352,0.543479,0.531805],[23.749905,1.028132,1.006847],[6.267209,0.208050,0.194846],[0.273405,0.027663,0.027727],[1.813349,0.183311,0.180188],[0.441909,0.027818,0.027427],[11.556500,0.410411,0.397217],[11.878248,11.803086,11.842988],[0.147288,0.058588,0.056877],[5.500723,0.496444,0.488228],[7.438851,0.982329,0.974780],[8.228235,5.575889,5.488849],[12.279272,3.426230,3.439635],[12.288545,3.465759,3.472598],[0.629652,0.542064,0.549532],[0.068277,0.055286,0.062397],[0.028899,0.023338,0.026963],[0.024785,0.016914,0.014623],[0.094073,0.082865,0.088973],[0.024245,0.013744,0.017487],[0.018292,0.009779,0.008906],[0.018714,0.009268,0.009275]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":70,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.073969,0.002969,0.002275],[0.289053,0.014500,0.013984],[0.597566,0.020848,0.022175],[1.241144,0.019701,0.019218],[1.407042,0.266073,0.245832],[1.707674,0.265472,0.272181],[0.037721,0.015296,0.014786],[0.044271,0.019238,0.018279],[1.814285,0.292480,0.287474],[3.034563,0.304214,0.310720],[1.634329,0.286281,0.299248],[1.937083,0.177104,0.188476],[1.529240,0.289840,0.289497],[3.075821,0.461813,0.428307],[1.708843,0.272060,0.275821],[0.832040,0.234342,0.218837],[3.085068,0.494668,0.480146],[2.891979,0.477079,0.457178],[6.122974,0.690913,0.634832],[0.186429,0.004711,0.003940],[10.868874,0.099969,0.086985],[13.480312,0.111980,0.103360],[24.405612,0.431874,0.440055],[10.061871,0.232500,0.242135],[0.647733,0.046068,0.039222],[2.100647,0.046711,0.043591],[1.391526,0.041194,0.039617],[11.536597,0.093705,0.088706],[9.839564,1.566094,1.591600],[0.162430,0.049029,0.049039],[5.631392,0.263430,0.225562],[7.261623,0.304319,0.279184],[5.646363,1.067710,0.910199],[11.173620,0.789665,0.684581],[11.251824,0.766817,0.682614],[0.663092,0.261053,0.272992],[0.400790,0.083889,0.091102],[0.073341,0.021988,0.028371],[0.091126,0.019851,0.013461],[0.151101,0.058686,0.058112],[0.281109,0.016812,0.014878],[0.398818,0.015711,0.022669],[0.222298,0.011058,0.014887]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.metal.json"} -,{"system":"DataFusion (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-11-19","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"v33.0.0 (d2efaa9)","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.076,0.045,0.045],[0.110,0.061,0.062],[0.200,0.109,0.106],[1.529,0.117,0.113],[2.265,0.832,0.836],[2.652,1.246,1.247],[0.091,0.065,0.071],[0.100,0.063,0.063],[2.465,1.490,1.478],[3.672,2.539,2.496],[1.627,0.344,0.330],[1.885,0.366,0.369],[2.679,1.253,1.236],[6.053,2.504,2.505],[2.885,1.386,1.382],[1.776,0.968,0.927],[5.752,2.709,2.689],[5.639,2.646,2.629],[10.707,5.692,5.799],[1.171,0.100,0.105],[20.537,1.570,1.575],[23.093,1.901,1.897],[44.658,4.103,4.065],[112.447,11.674,11.654],[5.791,0.581,0.558],[2.340,0.511,0.529],[5.823,0.626,0.632],[19.944,2.333,2.343],[17.608,5.052,5.086],[0.557,0.500,0.494],[4.888,1.140,1.126],[11.791,1.553,1.566],[12.415,7.764,7.724],[21.279,6.722,6.816],[21.569,7.325,7.297],[1.981,1.839,1.821],[0.466,0.306,0.312],[0.254,0.185,0.182],[0.284,0.173,0.171],[0.887,0.685,0.667],[0.171,0.092,0.095],[0.144,0.086,0.087],[0.151,0.101,0.097]],"source":"datafusion/results/single.json"} +,{"system":"DataFusion (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-07-29","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"v33.0.0 (d2efaa9)","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.068,0.045,0.046],[0.098,0.060,0.062],[0.175,0.111,0.106],[0.401,0.107,0.108],[1.011,0.812,0.815],[1.356,1.258,1.230],[0.094,0.069,0.068],[0.096,0.065,0.063],[1.548,1.432,1.459],[2.676,2.483,2.472],[0.488,0.342,0.337],[0.525,0.353,0.360],[1.350,1.246,1.244],[3.263,2.467,2.480],[1.460,1.376,1.394],[1.019,0.940,0.934],[3.053,2.688,2.713],[2.989,2.598,2.615],[6.715,5.675,5.654],[0.311,0.098,0.102],[9.910,1.566,1.577],[11.127,1.946,1.856],[21.951,4.155,4.082],[55.962,11.448,11.448],[2.450,0.555,0.576],[0.719,0.507,0.503],[2.437,0.637,0.635],[9.570,2.371,2.326],[9.068,5.013,4.951],[0.553,0.488,0.477],[2.074,1.104,1.121],[5.590,1.526,1.552],[8.068,7.646,7.726],[11.579,6.687,6.672],[11.953,7.284,7.291],[1.911,1.814,1.828],[0.440,0.311,0.322],[0.231,0.184,0.180],[0.242,0.171,0.170],[0.840,0.676,0.658],[0.153,0.094,0.098],[0.129,0.089,0.089],[0.156,0.097,0.105]],"source":"datafusion/results/single.json"} ,{"system":"Apache Doris","date":"2022-11-20","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":415,"data_size":17170564642,"result":[[0.07,0.03,0.03],[0.13,0.04,0.04],[0.11,0.04,0.03],[1.12,0.04,0.06],[1.06,1.06,1.05],[0.85,0.78,0.76],[0.01,0.02,0.02],[0.04,0.03,0.03],[0.57,0.56,0.54],[0.61,0.61,0.63],[0.16,0.11,0.11],[0.15,0.13,0.13],[0.59,0.58,0.58],[0.89,0.91,0.88],[0.79,0.77,0.77],[0.37,0.37,0.38],[1.09,1.07,1.09],[0.26,0.26,0.30],[2.10,2.02,2.04],[0.03,0.01,0.02],[10.82,1.14,1.14],[9.00,2.87,0.94],[12.17,1.29,0.98],[32.09,2.35,2.27],[1.28,0.13,0.14],[0.12,0.13,0.12],[0.14,0.15,0.14],[10.55,1.19,1.18],[10.04,9.56,9.52],[0.71,0.72,0.65],[1.84,0.44,0.42],[2.13,0.50,0.51],[3.17,3.16,3.37],[12.00,4.40,4.51],[11.83,4.46,4.27],[1.16,1.11,1.12],[0.07,0.05,0.05],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.15,0.14,0.12],[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02]],"source":"doris/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Druid","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Druid is killed and restarted after every query. Otherwise some queries make Druid degraded and results are incorrect. For example after Q13 even SELECT 1 works for 7 seconds","tags":["Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":19620,"data_size":45188608472,"result":[[0.032365,0.016716,0.016921],[0.400766,0.275591,0.271057],[0.382350,0.152084,0.151652],[1.379492,0.137201,0.128902],[3.278731,2.527105,2.515128],[8.576382,6.546540,6.503001],[null,null,null],[0.563852,0.273795,0.275086],[11.509993,10.636571,10.597993],[13.357647,12.421210,12.337247],[1.636875,0.821300,0.900056],[1.692544,0.512066,0.440511],[2.453274,1.769806,1.807207],[8.503408,7.261406,7.334872],[61.056041,59.251083,59.500549],[8.620670,8.236657,8.225380],[164.840762,null,null],[24.165797,22.308466,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[25.973369,25.597864,25.602509],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[7.805347,6.629776,6.947366],[0.257845,0.020327,0.016976],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[32.948154,31.046770,29.221959],[null,null,null],[7.230865,7.033713,6.972421],[20.546250,19.237428,19.258469],[54.065945,52.451318,52.466653],[null,null,null],[17.499267,null,null],[null,null,null],[60.478315,60.054940,60.458946],[1.698088,1.490317,1.461969],[1.409572,0.939003,0.907252],[0.866729,0.329539,0.287435],[null,null,null],[0.932473,0.420781,0.359095],[0.723142,0.325300,0.296865],[0.603483,0.150892,0.140716]],"source":"druid/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"DuckDB (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.06858791799959363,0.044711035000091215,0.042833501000131946],[0.08466665400010243,0.061327259999870876,0.06103660400003719],[0.14877448299967,0.10559172700004638,0.10446714899990184],[0.33234463500002676,0.09389112100006969,0.09252776699986498],[1.1345820209999147,0.5388421589996142,0.5428325200000472],[0.8665522809997128,0.7525683420003588,0.7726315990003059],[0.14739966299976004,0.12885476300016308,0.1280705589997524],[0.08514470599993729,0.0660608250000223,0.06364701199981937],[0.7901016199998594,0.6670942910000122,0.6656622149998839],[1.112716422000176,0.9176106790000631,0.8993262330000107],[0.4155927659999179,0.21104949600021428,0.21018879099983678],[1.0025453209996158,0.2506203090001691,0.24569647199996325],[1.2344316989997424,0.6329478739999104,0.6651636070000677],[2.456399698000041,1.0311697550000645,1.0137859460000982],[0.9334836890002407,0.6877674190000107,0.70905577800022],[0.673465615999703,0.5981919160003599,0.6082133740001154],[2.494906011999774,1.4013747280000644,1.3922408849998646],[2.375765204000345,1.324844154999937,1.3226832469999863],[4.690465237999888,2.3323504360000697,2.3752783559998534],[0.20363476300008188,0.08883917699995436,0.08691825200003223],[9.97606974700011,1.850158613000076,1.8413504770001055],[10.993020309999793,1.688866285000131,1.6903490720001173],[21.570115048999924,3.479486579999957,3.460369050999816],[55.44843658699983,11.133978315999684,11.129654930000015],[2.6089661060000253,0.48738706799986176,0.47928872500006037],[0.7135218759999589,0.3805757249997441,0.35711958900037644],[2.769580591999784,0.4973172830000294,0.4876009600002362],[9.315595299000051,1.488970874000188,1.4658663950003756],[8.170337007999933,4.1328330040000765,4.145880016000319],[4.665519644000142,4.670076305000293,4.6598440840002695],[2.2809909809998317,0.781899636000162,0.7691932829998223],[6.008987953999622,0.9412647040003321,0.9506733889998031],[6.1903129289999015,3.628633594999883,3.815570798999943],[9.97725304100004,2.979070244000013,2.997355967999738],[9.978100522000204,2.992902611000318,3.022268540999903],[0.92484311599992,0.8439210039996397,0.8562627520000206],[0.23992238600021665,0.13403623200019865,0.1317714319998231],[0.1254186490000393,0.09669256999995923,0.09850224299998445],[0.13835749800000485,0.09647460799988039,0.0929961749998256],[0.3313648240000475,0.2376939770001627,0.24857611900006304],[0.07056037899974399,0.05403545599983772,0.051252997999654326],[0.07037150599990127,0.04856322000023283,0.04816857199966762],[0.06874101699986568,0.04819512300036877,0.04709468300006847]],"source":"duckdb-parquet/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} From f3c0bde054254b07b6335a08880948bd21172a33 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Kirk Mitchener Date: Thu, 30 Nov 2023 00:47:19 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 4/6] reset index.html --- index.html | 136 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++--------------------------- 1 file changed, 68 insertions(+), 68 deletions(-) diff --git a/index.html b/index.html index 836719aad..67618591a 100644 --- a/index.html +++ b/index.html @@ -332,9 +332,9 @@ const data = [ {"system":"Athena (partitioned)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"serverless","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["stateless","managed","Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":0,"data_size":13800000000,"result":[[2.777,3.275,2.925],[1.503,3.136,4.003],[4.544,3.833,3.64],[3.9,2.514,3.522],[3.46,2.186,3.244],[3.624,2.742,3.185],[2.21,1.984,3.123],[3.207,2.403,2.685],[2.936,2.014,3.869],[8.333,7.102,4.434],[7.401,4.697,3.155],[4.214,3.065,4.748],[6.207,4.213,2.576],[3.428,3.085,3.401],[2.92,3.3,3.278],[2.205,2.558,2.419],[4.641,3.888,2.155],[3.219,2.822,3.292],[3.23,3.579,4.31],[2.288,3.543,3.95],[3.032,2.859,2.807],[3.926,3.247,2.928],[4.477,4.048,4.392],[7.407,6.375,6.123],[2.611,2.872,2.827],[2.566,2.567,3.6],[3.673,3.733,2.925],[2.426,3.218,2.78],[5.125,3.778,4.25],[4.565,4.03,4.066],[3.628,3.219,2.953],[6.207,5.973,3.158],[4.339,5.601,4.234],[2.618,3.107,3.433],[4.661,2.79,2.846],[2.373,1.629,2.734],[2.721,2.15,1.962],[3.207,2.154,2.186],[2.453,2.477,3.217],[2.691,4.732,3.584],[2.589,2.613,3.231],[1.926,3.617,1.82],[1.506,2.404,2.343]],"source":"athena/results/partitioned.json"} ,{"system":"Athena (single)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"serverless","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["stateless","managed","Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":0,"data_size":13800000000,"result":[[2.268,1.327,2.137],[3.427,2.248,3.605],[3.254,2.548,2.316],[3.025,2.314,3.003],[2.264,2.876,4.213],[3.044,2.745,2.698],[2.732,2.199,2.659],[2.022,3.692,3.072],[2.746,2.477,2.785],[3.53,2.782,4.031],[2.709,2.047,2.853],[2.318,1.969,3.4],[2.635,1.935,2.707],[3.049,3.38,3.071],[3.661,2.387,2.476],[2.479,2.591,2.21],[3.093,3.698,4.351],[3.479,3.236,2.274],[4.36,2.97,3.457],[2.525,2.384,3.328],[3.34,3.174,3.409],[3.163,2.971,3.034],[2.999,3.539,2.906],[6.454,7.597,7.858],[2.754,1.951,2.645],[2.852,3.018,2.718],[2.513,2.678,2.417],[3.293,2.521,2.771],[4.392,3.863,3.981],[3.658,4.246,4.027],[3.028,3.87,2.337],[2.923,3.635,3.591],[3.142,4.105,3.15],[3.66,3.187,4.745],[2.652,2.695,2.742],[2.262,2.776,1.815],[1.881,2.212,2.053],[1.934,2.551,1.524],[2.069,2.26,1.805],[2.626,2.902,2.793],[1.791,2.082,2.481],[3.757,2.6,1.946],[2.608,1.994,3.967]],"source":"athena/results/single.json"} -,{"system":"Aurora for MySQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"16acu","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Some queries cannot run due to ERROR 1114 (HY000) at line 1: The table '/rdsdbdata/tmp/#sqlaff_e5_0' is full","tags":["managed","C++","MySQL compatible","row-oriented"],"load_time":7687.318,"data_size":89614492631,"result":[[740.42,739.91,746.65],[828.2,835.67,832.87],[830.08,830.98,832.38],[829.88,832.83,830.87],[845.99,842.4,843.21],[869.51,870.69,869.75],[823.77,829.08,825.54],[827.74,832.87,829.25],[916.26,909.46,929.17],[946.49,939.27,932.32],[852.37,857.69,854.74],[857.99,864.05,825.14],[null,null,null],[863.37,860.2,865.62],[null,null,null],[891.84,895.28,893.68],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[1420.12,1419.34,1445.08],[28.94,0.21,0.21],[917.64,917.56,916.92],[923.47,921.7,923.82],[919.95,918.37,920.17],[1002.19,1002.07,1001.2],[902.23,902.65,901.8],[901.17,900.02,898.3],[900.04,898.89,903.35],[901.78,902.71,901.28],[null,null,null],[1153.29,1154,1156.46],[862.57,863.35,859.69],[923.14,921.1,923.92],[1370.78,1401.72,1401.44],[1454.67,1455.55,1458.79],[1463.31,1466.75,1461.83],[941.03,944.07,937.23],[7.42,2.80,2.77],[2.57,2.52,2.59],[1.50,1.52,1.59],[3.62,3.57,3.61],[0.95,0.94,0.94],[0.90,0.92,0.91],[1.69,1.72,1.69]],"source":"aurora-mysql/results/16acu.json"} +,{"system":"Aurora for MySQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"16acu","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Some queries cannot run due to ERROR 1114 (HY000) at line 1: The table '/rdsdbdata/tmp/#sqlaff_e5_0' is full","tags":["managed","C++","MySQL compatible","row-oriented"],"load_time":7687.318,"data_size":89614492631,"result":[[740.42,739.91,746.65],[828.2,835.67,832.87],[830.08,830.98,832.38],[829.88,832.83,830.87],[845.99,842.4,843.21],[869.51,870.69,869.75],[823.77,829.08,825.54],[827.74,832.87,829.25],[916.26,909.46,929.17],[946.49,939.27,932.32],[852.37,857.69,854.74],[857.99,864.05,825.14],[null,null,null],[863.37,860.2,865.62],[null,null,null],[891.84,895.28,893.68],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[1420.12,1419.34,1445.08],[28.94,0.21,0.21],[917.64,917.56,916.92],[923.47,921.7,923.82],[919.95,918.37,920.17],[1002.19,1002.07,1001.2],[902.23,902.65,901.8],[901.17,900.02,898.3],[900.04,898.89,903.35],[901.78,902.71,901.28],[null,null,null],[1153.29,1154,1156.46],[862.57,863.35,859.69],[923.14,921.1,923.92],[1370.78,1401.72,1401.44],[1454.67,1455.55,1458.79],[1463.31,1466.75,1461.83],[941.03,944.07,937.23],[7.42,2.8,2.77],[2.57,2.52,2.59],[1.5,1.52,1.59],[3.62,3.57,3.61],[0.95,0.94,0.94],[0.9,0.92,0.91],[1.69,1.72,1.69]],"source":"aurora-mysql/results/16acu.json"} ,{"system":"Aurora for PostgreSQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"16acu","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["managed","C","PostgreSQL compatible","row-oriented"],"load_time":2127,"data_size":52183852646,"result":[[12.8361,5.71812,5.8241],[61.2565,62.1402,63.7173],[68.0578,68.1218,67.609],[7.83207,5.90193,6.0461],[48.7194,48.0233,48.2198],[289.492,304.639,282.436],[6.30572,6.31857,6.21598],[53.644,53.8931,53.5307],[131.526,131.45,131.102],[137.724,136.921,137.758],[57.2079,56.2775,56.2152],[56.5349,56.2048,55.9569],[82.3897,82.8866,83.534],[97.0569,97.1392,96.4731],[85.6557,86.7783,86.2804],[49.4325,42.4309,42.5743],[111.537,114.59,111.807],[88.4322,89.3756,87.7899],[160.781,163.866,161.394],[1025.04,2.10165,2.10065],[106.741,56.2731,56.1535],[59.2681,59.5272,59.536],[58.6083,57.6054,57.3935],[54.8271,55.1397,56.3487],[54.718,52.469,53.271],[53.5387,53.1926,52.4008],[52.0042,51.9581,52.2453],[60.1317,59.9695,59.2187],[244.608,242.954,243.815],[91.8674,92.4165,91.5884],[63.7122,64.277,64.2783],[69.2596,68.9535,69.4508],[234.222,241.138,240.316],[488.169,462.257,460.466],[472.929,471.809,476.635],[103.664,116.131,103.467],[16.8124,3.34058,3.37782],[0.852414,0.832073,0.859857],[0.305464,0.31166,0.306694],[4.55625,4.54098,4.58501],[0.299746,0.297532,0.30334],[0.275732,0.279817,0.27766],[0.332107,0.324387,0.320099]],"source":"aurora-postgresql/results/16acu.json"} -,{"system":"ByConity","date":"2023-06-21","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":343.482,"data_size":14602455235,"result":[[0.003,0.003,0.003],[0.030,0.050,0.025],[0.137,0.049,0.048],[0.318,0.062,0.056],[0.564,0.479,0.475],[0.983,0.772,0.766],[0.054,0.044,0.036],[0.039,0.030,0.031],[0.717,0.600,0.611],[0.813,0.633,0.665],[0.348,0.238,0.234],[0.351,0.256,0.277],[0.899,0.765,0.756],[1.447,1.139,1.070],[1.070,0.867,0.861],[0.976,0.917,0.882],[2.614,2.385,2.425],[1.801,1.622,1.591],[4.729,4.366,4.437],[0.218,0.136,0.106],[8.703,0.786,0.722],[9.845,0.799,0.813],[18.827,1.709,1.682],[56.739,5.832,4.243],[1.777,0.267,0.270],[0.395,0.205,0.229],[1.776,0.244,0.263],[8.509,0.718,0.707],[11.414,10.222,10.292],[2.118,2.104,2.115],[1.413,0.624,0.614],[4.403,0.765,0.770],[5.210,4.964,4.947],[9.678,3.707,3.651],[9.684,3.661,3.712],[1.317,1.160,1.199],[0.220,0.152,0.101],[0.084,0.061,0.041],[0.080,0.035,0.053],[0.246,0.169,0.170],[0.083,0.025,0.034],[0.036,0.027,0.028],[0.054,0.047,0.019]],"source":"byconity/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"ByConity","date":"2023-06-21","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":343.482,"data_size":14602455235,"result":[[0.003,0.003,0.003],[0.03,0.05,0.025],[0.137,0.049,0.048],[0.318,0.062,0.056],[0.564,0.479,0.475],[0.983,0.772,0.766],[0.054,0.044,0.036],[0.039,0.03,0.031],[0.717,0.6,0.611],[0.813,0.633,0.665],[0.348,0.238,0.234],[0.351,0.256,0.277],[0.899,0.765,0.756],[1.447,1.139,1.07],[1.07,0.867,0.861],[0.976,0.917,0.882],[2.614,2.385,2.425],[1.801,1.622,1.591],[4.729,4.366,4.437],[0.218,0.136,0.106],[8.703,0.786,0.722],[9.845,0.799,0.813],[18.827,1.709,1.682],[56.739,5.832,4.243],[1.777,0.267,0.27],[0.395,0.205,0.229],[1.776,0.244,0.263],[8.509,0.718,0.707],[11.414,10.222,10.292],[2.118,2.104,2.115],[1.413,0.624,0.614],[4.403,0.765,0.77],[5.21,4.964,4.947],[9.678,3.707,3.651],[9.684,3.661,3.712],[1.317,1.16,1.199],[0.22,0.152,0.101],[0.084,0.061,0.041],[0.08,0.035,0.053],[0.246,0.169,0.17],[0.083,0.025,0.034],[0.036,0.027,0.028],[0.054,0.047,0.019]],"source":"byconity/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"ByteHouse","date":"2022-07-27","machine":"L","tags":["managed","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","C++"],"load_time":745,"data_size":27190000000,"result":[[0.239865,0.0870234,0.222015],[0.182402,0.105131,0.131712],[0.200164,0.13875,0.121221],[0.38027,0.140809,0.106769],[0.345668,0.315182,0.3484],[0.499999,0.346608,0.376732],[0.163644,0.199362,0.104804],[0.135081,0.121857,0.132218],[0.498781,0.443817,0.451166],[0.925841,0.931702,0.938799],[0.208082,0.138678,0.154934],[0.1849,0.166067,0.189213],[0.375623,0.440097,0.408131],[2.876857214,2.879602691,2.856211343],[0.514966,0.481675,0.525073],[0.379692,0.403246,0.409433],[1.07893968,0.981566,0.998549],[0.970913,0.991069,1.019743901],[2.32956516,2.028961393,2.058936806],[0.121056,0.0874094,0.117498],[1.242306022,0.409433,0.381256],[0.333268,0.362866,0.368105],[0.724634,0.616216,0.609811],[8.372272024,1.940810909,1.919313531],[0.215081,0.16656,0.183373],[0.159827,0.173928,0.160971],[0.173209,0.217374,0.178429],[0.364914,0.392851,0.392753],[3.258063215,3.055232843,3.158432938],[0.969086,0.944354,1.001753137],[0.33521,0.344545,0.435078],[0.563083,0.597303,0.54695],[2.824918949,2.784792896,2.773636287],[2.04203589,1.985002429,1.96329676],[1.972932613,1.905925254,2.000995567],[0.660906,0.638376,0.638797],[0.273916,0.291013,0.275462],[0.197361,0.204497,0.245296],[0.158102,0.190007,0.220325],[0.420387,0.410065,0.391049],[0.185806,0.152663,0.138554],[0.302098,0.146736,0.132355],[0.153148,0.138142,0.140028]],"source":"bytehouse/results/l.json"} ,{"system":"ByteHouse","date":"2022-07-27","machine":"M","tags":["managed","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","C++"],"load_time":745,"data_size":27190000000,"result":[[0.204356,0.124087,0.111343],[0.162147,0.120088,0.129223],[0.138304,0.124968,0.100887],[0.424216,0.193393,0.148192],[0.626537,0.636493,0.701694],[0.700354,0.61407,0.563147],[0.226713,0.107379,0.105274],[0.115582,0.129062,0.135826],[0.908611,0.890668,0.930481],[1.072457112,1.196782563,1.085087466],[0.185372,0.229904,0.228918],[0.210959,0.220222,0.229587],[0.77719,0.751063,0.808261],[3.443675466,3.529152804,3.431081103],[0.918561,0.941661,0.964774],[0.81437,0.826625,0.830821],[2.154593924,2.196733859,2.145739942],[2.002076959,2.010973594,1.968857393],[5.072657424,5.071079422,4.954039807],[0.127813,0.107606,0.105492],[1.344124274,0.76118,0.738414],[0.847975,0.866883,0.790545],[2.17366727,1.90929253,1.956613481],[6.798822715,6.030441596,5.961431634],[0.232659,0.24189,0.225892],[0.22483,0.213993,0.165657],[0.249597,0.23609,0.234343],[0.886731,0.895649,0.93452],[8.905864883,8.909027527,9.119373795],[2.729399515,2.700112742,2.80527209],[0.599962,0.679839,0.657434],[1.120159397,1.130162921,1.114698924],[6.566110112,6.552839157,6.49319341],[4.601181289,4.529338346,4.554859438],[4.54498289,4.497598791,4.527396409],[1.33884046,1.347533604,1.313194291],[0.298073,0.29527,0.27903],[0.163254,0.188463,0.15891],[0.210311,0.197546,0.140187],[0.395194,0.434253,0.45348],[0.175269,0.17503,0.145714],[0.159227,0.126441,0.119968],[0.188247,0.140864,0.117428]],"source":"bytehouse/results/m.json"} ,{"system":"ByteHouse","date":"2022-07-27","machine":"S","tags":["managed","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","C++"],"load_time":745,"data_size":27190000000,"result":[[0.465819,0.116044,0.10382],[0.12678,0.120683,0.178592],[0.19001,0.153998,0.150897],[0.241946,0.125373,0.139151],[1.069480177,1.034297324,1.106595058],[1.562573773,1.206818889,1.221545036],[0.152539,0.122294,0.117231],[0.130834,0.117555,0.132048],[1.599240755,1.514699748,1.542136004],[1.341486754,1.417470413,1.509794379],[0.273263,0.302114,0.37113],[0.323308,0.317832,0.346367],[1.350003276,1.463167781,1.394062227],[6.526322756,6.562415941,6.603599898],[1.657413456,1.617141092,1.658355897],[1.301159782,1.328003217,1.417677445],[4.200100191,4.116794792,4.145844627],[4.083672003,3.939048097,4.009026718],[7.324285002,7.220264513,7.23919483],[0.124951,0.102059,0.120177],[1.358183279,0.815601,0.825568],[0.950995,0.890438,0.994714],[2.508912285,1.891410174,1.924645465],[9.532990518,6.816463253,6.810721155],[0.288955,0.257077,0.323011],[0.287261,0.252905,0.301686],[0.352302,0.289875,0.325013],[0.8885,0.853163,0.90298],[11.996772143,11.335378584,10.928031696],[3.223346367,3.274467765,3.039989844],[1.076384222,1.121689429,1.066842857],[1.584906113,1.634423718,1.636641605],[11.265273648,11.250953518,11.265621391],[6.284396525,6.419369583,6.503485024],[6.301652951,6.381827207,6.450726416],[1.645218925,1.660535448,1.591234664],[0.290394,0.268129,0.259014],[0.209527,0.20071,0.271621],[0.168356,0.156549,0.17388],[0.459272,0.45036,0.456921],[0.15138,0.149573,0.137896],[0.130298,0.127121,0.13154],[0.159379,0.147829,0.111582]],"source":"bytehouse/results/s.json"} @@ -342,92 +342,92 @@ ,{"system":"chDB","date":"2023-05-05","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","embedded","stateless","serverless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.2142074100000002,0.06882208100000753,0.06698695899999052],[0.21433474400001273,0.05794623400001342,0.057398905000013656],[0.25145876300001646,0.09365810799999963,0.0927742330000001],[0.43362701600000264,0.09151721000000634,0.09002429299999903],[0.6274811319999856,0.45731702300000165,0.44805708699999514],[1.016439422000019,0.7270457869999802,0.7281644760000177],[0.17415907900002026,0.07338490300000444,0.07135004600002048],[0.15761252199999376,0.06434131999998272,0.06364797699998803],[0.9011239490000094,0.6279251530000067,0.6617304419999925],[1.3989778490000049,0.7784884470000009,0.7991503589999809],[0.6405131490000144,0.288082022999987,0.2907754610000097],[0.7087472860000048,0.3404617630000075,0.34405304700001693],[0.9884754980000139,0.742467481999995,0.7458478129999833],[2.446865468999988,1.077438581999985,1.0773534190000191],[1.1237870280000095,0.860952731999987,0.8733325050000076],[0.7824573620000024,0.5994026669999926,0.603801035999993],[3.0189614590000247,2.1247967310000035,2.136651298000004],[2.268133656999993,1.342204492999997,1.3375202990000048],[6.154855214999998,4.1472972940000545,4.200881827000046],[0.42060202400000435,0.09300883100002011,0.09273820700002489],[9.440000580999993,1.2985261019999825,1.3186195140000336],[11.130420060999995,1.750144492000004,1.7870355000000018],[21.657440298999973,4.191915921000032,4.128165265999996],[55.73274844499997,16.125229505999982,15.999065228999996],[2.6613450219999777,0.5245296020000296,0.44928111000001536],[0.8606326020000097,0.41947248600001785,0.42714392499999576],[2.6127060599999936,0.4240091479999819,0.4173263879999922],[9.625697985999977,1.537415798999973,1.5635347990000241],[10.62851167499997,10.254705237999985,10.246708373000047],[1.3997938080000267,1.2829287249999766,1.3373195980000219],[2.629494959999988,0.8007238929999971,0.8009190960000296],[6.257382670000027,1.0821710089999783,1.0986213179999709],[7.894820188999972,5.682761884999991,5.684027975000049],[10.944004618000008,4.332272504000002,4.397889952000014],[10.888015042000006,4.304654096000036,4.363871365000023],[1.245383650000008,0.9663471250000839,0.9393379179999783],[10.02239869799996,1.5317859549999184,1.6102954730000647],[9.042795040000101,1.4587223329999688,1.4796740619999582],[9.98100896599999,1.5930554510000547,1.5763176469999962],[18.767428479000046,3.416737495999996,3.394079593000015],[2.949028655999996,0.3381267659999594,0.3303272449999213],[2.2183266100000765,0.2911085360000243,0.28956761999995706],[1.3416713980000168,0.31786464999993314,0.25272847500002626]],"source":"chdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"chDB","date":"2023-05-05","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","embedded","stateless","serverless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.25085395600000027,0.13717639500001155,0.10192336299999738],[0.19351914300000317,0.23702443199998413,0.23030831299999477],[0.38653160600000547,0.10727562700000703,0.1079391199999975],[0.5821646519999888,0.11063486399999078,0.10717972199998371],[1.554399705999998,1.2151783790000081,1.2112660370000015],[2.035837005000019,1.4492607999999905,1.3240938330000063],[0.21244647899999336,0.22758840500000588,0.09454707199998325],[0.37854534199999534,0.0806291579999936,0.07829879499999493],[0.8155532019999896,0.407321249000006,0.381915843999991],[1.5566488579999884,0.47072470199998406,0.4231783470000039],[0.7227343300000086,0.2129163369999958,0.2129321280000056],[0.6888460250000037,0.22112879700000576,0.2325982460000091],[0.979024948000017,0.3725961359999985,0.3622014049999791],[2.2554182020000155,0.45391694599999255,0.44524926799999776],[0.9685399139999902,0.41066436499997394,0.39307313000000477],[0.5552744130000065,0.3293312250000042,0.32380252500001916],[2.5407928539999887,0.8057684110000025,0.8117435089999958],[2.480627472000009,0.717416046000011,0.7006543530000044],[4.715823697000019,1.428862315999993,1.3309564099999989],[0.4274330179999879,0.08513459599998896,0.07622262399999613],[9.466044803999978,0.42960786800000506,0.4351132179999979],[11.144097670000008,0.655176608000005,0.5562489730000095],[21.659016025,0.8626887380000028,0.8547264640000094],[55.93614273,5.38185286800001,4.2953555569999935],[2.6935396330000003,0.23816812000001164,0.22127673400001413],[0.8375048199999924,0.20675362399998676,0.20651609999998755],[2.677874332999977,0.18914798399998745,0.19894682300002842],[9.629668981999998,0.5783150890000002,0.5699679560000277],[8.665696378000007,2.074512052999978,2.170078869000008],[1.0702536989999771,0.7750411739999663,0.7929929419999553],[2.597370228999978,0.42321389300002465,0.40198629100001426],[6.139428893999991,0.5609760049999863,0.5218740169999592],[5.420712613999967,1.790675226000019,1.8716358959999866],[10.126479325000048,1.5676798349999785,1.2933676730000343],[10.00519733799996,1.298088000000007,1.408291107000025],[0.7715717759999734,0.45679534399999966,0.38578160100001924],[10.047253146999992,0.46224451500000896,0.5013313469999616],[9.027152569999998,0.4774934599999483,0.45599200899999914],[10.028154845000017,0.48999347899996337,0.5015574689999767],[18.814411635,0.8736013170000092,0.6722256219999849],[3.0613838720000217,0.1627915900000403,0.1635108240000136],[2.376407903000029,0.15505116399998542,0.14369173599999385],[1.335110277999945,0.20318408099996077,0.12870271500003128]],"source":"chdb/results/c6a.metal.json"} ,{"system":"Citus","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","PostgreSQL compatible","column-oriented"],"load_time":1579,"data_size":18980918899,"result":[[7.58503,6.70447,6.52499],[6.33941,5.06063,5.00238],[11.7488,9.86417,9.93223],[12.6306,9.36305,9.17061],[40.6101,39.0803,38.1187],[117.654,113.912,113.441],[10.3404,8.08936,7.70732],[6.31542,4.72821,4.72989],[82.5425,77.2124,76.9219],[91.1776,83.4492,82.4727],[14.5474,10.0815,10.3873],[15.4899,11.2922,11.1877],[19.9794,15.5002,17.4492],[76.9216,72.5172,72.7915],[21.5446,17.5691,18.561],[56.9438,54.6387,53.5745],[75.0977,69.7842,70.0259],[31.3299,27.0267,26.3216],[129.417,122.956,121.182],[3.73386,2.14148,2.12737],[34.6021,27.9727,28.6878],[37.152,29.6193,29.2966],[52.2157,37.8589,37.6994],[181.955,149.08,148.471],[15.4687,11.3138,10.3856],[10.2779,8.46868,8.8324],[14.4687,10.4076,11.4263],[47.009,40.2969,39.6888],[749.946,742.979,744.461],[69.4383,67.5636,67.2128],[27.0317,21.4008,20.9524],[36.6675,25.6347,26.4408],[140.424,130.546,129.738],[106.959,92.033,90.1609],[110.98,94.4787,96.2656],[64.4474,60.1853,60.6816],[6.17549,6.25376,5.87004],[1.99153,1.81776,1.80596],[1.00141,0.800271,0.801975],[7.91778,7.70928,8.33299],[0.929845,0.642076,0.638478],[0.866536,0.683567,0.680218],[0.937823,0.784747,0.765929]],"source":"citus/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"192GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":224.417,"data_size":9940946872,"result":[[0.003,0.004,0.003],[0.770,0.067,0.022],[0.351,0.690,0.045],[0.762,0.072,0.586],[0.324,0.432,0.361],[0.861,0.697,0.786],[0.509,0.054,0.031],[0.035,0.542,0.394],[0.986,0.624,0.640],[0.705,0.658,0.621],[0.295,0.245,0.191],[0.346,0.335,0.295],[0.706,0.808,0.809],[0.856,0.857,0.968],[0.836,0.861,0.983],[0.431,0.434,0.387],[1.550,1.564,1.692],[1.379,1.084,1.405],[3.511,3.560,3.617],[0.072,0.134,0.035],[1.324,2.146,1.026],[1.294,1.591,1.237],[2.004,1.217,2.248],[4.849,6.715,3.885],[0.432,0.354,0.354],[0.365,0.367,0.309],[0.351,0.440,0.394],[1.106,1.224,0.971],[8.116,9.850,9.576],[1.224,1.211,0.820],[0.690,0.646,0.699],[0.865,0.847,0.746],[3.477,2.954,2.843],[2.562,2.985,2.519],[2.451,2.462,2.528],[0.967,0.918,0.883],[0.095,0.089,0.091],[0.049,0.057,0.148],[0.138,0.072,0.070],[0.299,0.195,0.218],[0.058,0.329,0.047],[0.021,0.045,0.027],[0.038,0.029,0.033]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.192GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"24GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":898.272,"data_size":9949087959,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.134,0.151,1.040],[0.481,0.547,0.228],[0.952,0.427,0.560],[2.505,2.465,2.421],[3.252,3.143,3.498],[0.281,0.121,0.139],[0.048,0.042,0.043],[4.113,2.525,2.291],[2.742,2.965,2.652],[1.161,1.069,1.193],[1.555,1.333,1.357],[3.277,3.667,3.194],[4.850,5.542,5.120],[4.442,4.498,4.674],[2.645,2.745,2.731],[11.061,10.301,10.394],[8.293,7.391,7.995],[32.636,30.847,30.519],[0.099,0.133,0.129],[7.746,9.111,5.625],[13.131,6.666,6.920],[24.838,12.782,8.131],[33.065,23.814,46.946],[1.903,1.852,2.352],[1.172,1.294,1.241],[1.913,1.883,1.851],[6.512,5.868,6.225],[58.901,55.853,55.978],[3.891,5.452,4.000],[2.982,3.194,3.433],[5.779,4.125,4.880],[32.403,35.532,34.985],[27.241,27.673,26.393],[26.661,25.919,28.050],[4.740,4.937,4.659],[0.361,0.175,0.168],[0.079,0.101,0.070],[0.177,0.088,0.072],[0.336,0.341,0.327],[0.231,0.033,0.039],[0.056,0.192,0.027],[0.023,0.021,0.026]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.24GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"360GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":216.929,"data_size":9942386190,"result":[[0.003,0.005,0.003],[0.651,0.021,0.647],[0.307,0.039,0.293],[0.638,0.628,0.140],[0.273,0.303,0.259],[0.585,0.521,0.431],[0.117,0.025,0.066],[0.059,0.032,0.042],[0.610,0.540,1.024],[1.158,1.010,0.534],[0.236,0.234,0.223],[0.289,0.210,0.249],[0.444,0.455,0.454],[0.582,0.592,0.644],[0.739,0.586,0.513],[0.313,0.320,0.369],[1.126,1.175,1.242],[0.838,0.828,0.792],[1.880,2.022,2.056],[0.036,0.058,0.043],[0.950,0.921,1.028],[0.842,0.832,0.827],[0.931,1.435,0.904],[2.660,2.337,5.094],[0.258,0.270,0.235],[0.305,0.214,0.231],[0.257,0.261,0.238],[0.770,1.022,0.812],[5.886,4.937,5.757],[0.655,0.627,0.638],[0.427,0.675,0.476],[0.541,0.595,0.696],[2.303,2.386,1.514],[1.604,1.685,1.776],[1.590,1.616,1.653],[0.621,0.722,0.490],[0.174,0.156,0.093],[0.084,0.046,0.059],[0.061,0.132,0.083],[0.283,0.315,0.207],[0.062,0.316,0.037],[0.210,0.037,0.032],[0.029,0.038,0.052]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.360GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"48GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":313.530,"data_size":9941379875,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.575,0.147,0.015],[0.248,0.775,0.090],[0.789,0.388,0.179],[1.162,1.033,1.021],[1.732,1.498,2.214],[0.128,0.052,0.079],[0.058,0.030,0.047],[1.560,1.619,1.152],[1.958,1.490,1.820],[0.498,0.453,0.450],[0.643,0.797,0.615],[1.818,1.617,2.116],[2.826,2.798,2.674],[2.364,2.222,2.019],[1.275,1.221,1.322],[5.230,4.694,5.178],[3.506,3.187,2.962],[9.025,11.452,10.064],[0.098,0.058,0.090],[4.267,3.073,3.884],[2.856,3.725,2.821],[6.760,3.852,3.267],[15.132,10.307,11.082],[0.956,0.905,0.933],[0.607,0.724,0.662],[0.915,0.917,0.888],[2.453,2.441,2.577],[22.966,24.132,22.600],[1.990,1.856,2.246],[1.629,1.615,1.535],[2.691,2.884,1.926],[14.293,15.228,13.532],[6.949,7.111,9.260],[7.081,8.422,8.627],[3.143,2.628,2.513],[0.193,0.129,0.155],[0.048,0.051,0.086],[0.121,0.070,0.076],[0.370,0.210,0.179],[0.044,0.242,0.040],[0.042,0.031,0.042],[0.151,0.031,0.024]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.48GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"720GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":220.239,"data_size":9941859054,"result":[[0.004,0.004,0.005],[0.118,0.059,0.637],[0.248,0.166,0.036],[0.175,0.516,0.501],[0.222,0.192,0.195],[0.405,0.262,0.264],[0.164,0.054,0.026],[0.058,0.421,0.064],[0.522,0.411,0.549],[0.552,0.451,0.457],[0.245,0.180,0.210],[0.196,0.211,0.178],[0.514,0.266,0.571],[0.662,0.635,0.593],[0.398,0.400,0.365],[0.236,0.223,0.343],[0.665,0.631,0.652],[0.474,0.526,0.469],[1.462,1.219,1.468],[0.032,0.027,0.055],[0.762,1.088,0.477],[0.553,0.502,0.507],[0.928,0.618,0.706],[4.070,3.194,1.992],[0.206,0.163,0.147],[0.128,0.177,0.114],[0.177,0.171,0.172],[0.528,0.647,0.600],[4.037,4.033,4.040],[0.663,0.629,0.650],[0.286,0.302,0.299],[0.395,0.366,0.335],[1.704,1.802,1.760],[1.307,1.265,1.361],[1.276,1.281,1.380],[0.351,0.317,0.319],[0.134,0.120,0.122],[0.070,0.053,0.064],[0.086,0.082,0.087],[0.171,0.180,0.204],[0.063,0.034,0.046],[0.059,0.050,0.044],[0.061,0.049,0.039]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.720GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"96GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":227.755,"data_size":9942057937,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.709,0.039,0.317],[0.163,0.295,0.754],[0.330,0.144,0.813],[0.661,0.869,0.654],[1.315,1.402,1.182],[0.177,0.042,0.070],[0.586,0.052,0.042],[1.178,1.141,1.472],[1.062,1.060,0.875],[0.605,0.374,0.403],[0.492,0.443,0.409],[1.228,1.300,1.254],[2.161,1.633,1.644],[1.493,1.734,1.602],[0.986,0.939,0.823],[3.121,3.165,2.713],[1.867,1.716,3.116],[5.606,7.876,5.516],[0.168,0.262,0.084],[2.063,1.632,1.636],[2.995,3.168,1.861],[2.431,4.313,2.309],[12.271,6.228,7.296],[0.751,0.699,0.659],[0.489,0.475,0.563],[0.692,0.592,0.554],[1.750,1.626,1.768],[14.788,15.976,15.280],[1.456,1.202,1.483],[0.985,1.104,1.059],[2.162,1.552,1.099],[4.401,6.886,6.793],[4.445,4.203,4.891],[4.964,4.319,4.943],[1.400,1.475,1.427],[0.101,0.120,0.119],[0.080,0.088,0.048],[0.122,0.067,0.047],[0.214,0.186,0.263],[0.137,0.025,0.026],[0.157,0.057,0.042],[0.023,0.058,0.037]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.96GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-08","machine":"1430GB","cluster_size":"dedicated","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":225.127,"data_size":9940236142,"result":[[0.014,0.014,0.007],[0.090,0.471,0.027],[0.520,0.029,0.325],[0.332,0.375,0.033],[0.529,0.845,0.540],[0.932,0.752,0.669],[0.356,0.068,0.061],[0.074,0.071,0.037],[0.502,0.421,0.350],[0.401,0.333,0.347],[0.261,0.245,0.139],[0.206,0.263,0.154],[0.229,0.338,0.204],[0.377,0.342,0.291],[0.275,0.284,0.241],[0.173,0.137,0.144],[0.484,0.451,0.492],[0.326,0.327,0.355],[0.975,0.888,0.886],[0.032,0.038,0.053],[0.693,0.566,0.423],[0.345,0.336,0.729],[0.485,0.410,0.377],[2.533,2.148,1.213],[0.177,0.242,0.093],[0.194,0.365,0.239],[0.334,0.218,0.245],[0.773,0.655,0.323],[1.728,1.800,1.713],[0.387,0.408,0.385],[0.195,0.183,0.171],[0.557,0.377,0.240],[1.193,1.251,1.148],[0.707,0.794,0.776],[0.697,0.838,0.857],[0.310,0.229,0.332],[0.150,0.100,0.105],[0.049,0.062,0.045],[0.076,0.065,0.163],[0.219,0.186,0.190],[0.167,0.037,0.037],[0.053,0.037,0.031],[0.039,0.029,0.028]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dedicated.standard.1430GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"dev","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":700.114,"data_size":9944443104,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.114,0.112,0.044],[0.530,0.223,0.231],[0.658,0.321,0.578],[2.042,1.725,1.454],[2.508,2.023,2.725],[0.091,0.091,0.084],[0.033,0.081,0.035],[1.891,2.362,2.009],[2.071,1.951,2.251],[1.077,0.666,0.809],[1.082,0.890,0.977],[2.813,3.022,2.817],[3.666,3.734,3.593],[3.647,3.371,2.700],[2.513,1.743,1.641],[6.708,9.375,8.844],[4.948,6.079,5.460],[26.159,20.860,17.466],[0.395,0.080,0.107],[3.658,3.448,6.485],[6.897,6.948,4.022],[8.765,7.751,4.769],[13.487,27.999,20.242],[1.132,1.961,1.199],[0.799,0.705,0.838],[2.009,1.063,1.744],[3.712,5.554,3.618],[32.808,60.019,32.276],[3.389,2.354,3.351],[1.779,2.202,2.205],[3.687,3.694,2.223],[23.809,16.334,16.007],[19.995,19.951,17.978],[16.470,19.988,19.945],[3.228,2.638,3.916],[0.303,0.103,0.105],[0.257,0.093,0.064],[0.080,0.136,0.066],[0.270,0.275,0.347],[0.055,0.205,0.056],[0.182,0.059,0.033],[0.082,0.176,0.030]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dev.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"192GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":343.743,"data_size":9944304173,"result":[[0.003,0.002,0.002],[0.026,1.152,0.018],[0.088,0.529,0.089],[1.196,0.067,0.062],[0.275,0.266,0.698],[0.498,0.447,1.528],[0.598,0.620,0.034],[0.533,0.026,0.160],[0.676,0.628,0.524],[0.814,0.588,0.571],[0.195,0.296,0.282],[0.215,0.208,0.350],[0.613,0.500,0.781],[0.879,0.708,0.821],[0.601,0.595,0.957],[0.335,0.319,0.326],[1.624,1.323,1.492],[0.877,1.269,0.950],[3.889,2.801,3.879],[0.059,0.077,0.192],[1.162,1.376,0.826],[1.079,0.976,0.823],[2.241,1.161,1.293],[6.010,3.231,6.571],[0.335,0.279,0.269],[0.224,0.253,0.235],[0.335,0.319,0.315],[0.745,0.939,0.725],[6.356,6.294,7.592],[0.770,0.725,0.806],[0.543,0.526,0.473],[0.782,0.832,0.696],[3.412,2.442,2.937],[1.812,1.819,1.889],[2.386,2.620,2.594],[0.795,0.747,0.866],[0.129,0.122,0.102],[0.063,0.086,0.046],[0.063,0.068,0.081],[0.153,0.191,0.229],[0.050,0.061,0.039],[0.046,0.028,0.026],[0.072,0.022,0.019]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.192GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"24GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":763.464,"data_size":9946144862,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.265,0.022,0.022],[0.408,0.240,0.267],[0.994,0.342,0.479],[2.284,1.765,2.514],[3.990,2.548,2.530],[0.187,0.088,0.087],[0.029,0.155,0.029],[2.035,1.852,2.887],[2.812,2.227,2.535],[1.173,1.064,1.109],[1.373,1.144,0.872],[3.742,2.382,3.517],[6.107,3.781,3.690],[3.560,7.737,3.467],[2.870,2.274,2.313],[8.827,10.482,10.345],[6.702,5.775,6.960],[23.942,30.504,28.644],[0.089,0.111,0.105],[10.025,4.656,8.109],[5.292,6.732,6.562],[19.192,7.473,7.452],[41.852,20.429,17.857],[1.486,1.817,2.216],[0.952,1.092,1.101],[1.458,1.779,1.431],[5.706,4.643,4.710],[54.040,52.301,50.632],[3.204,2.606,2.534],[3.222,2.917,2.780],[5.636,3.353,3.353],[24.542,33.083,32.492],[20.607,25.238,20.718],[25.099,20.741,25.281],[4.873,4.468,4.134],[0.144,0.180,0.261],[0.098,0.054,0.059],[0.064,0.075,0.073],[0.436,0.333,0.322],[0.213,0.037,0.043],[0.025,0.029,0.223],[0.027,0.023,0.021]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.24GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"360GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":329.494,"data_size":9944755537,"result":[[0.004,0.004,0.003],[1.018,0.069,1.415],[1.146,0.035,0.188],[1.053,0.047,0.047],[0.267,0.233,0.219],[0.602,0.504,0.609],[0.923,0.673,1.034],[0.837,0.582,0.051],[0.676,0.739,0.481],[0.928,0.626,0.478],[0.312,0.234,0.239],[0.402,0.308,0.232],[0.402,0.513,0.483],[0.548,0.621,0.638],[0.540,0.477,0.516],[0.383,0.298,0.344],[1.156,0.922,0.865],[0.730,0.896,0.651],[1.836,1.689,2.031],[0.032,0.051,0.152],[0.962,0.987,0.591],[0.898,1.133,0.821],[2.602,0.917,1.330],[4.678,2.837,2.668],[0.764,0.290,0.261],[0.148,0.146,0.205],[0.276,0.192,0.280],[0.822,0.907,0.839],[5.190,6.455,5.898],[0.775,0.680,0.657],[0.451,0.436,0.660],[0.488,1.211,0.486],[2.900,2.543,2.817],[1.725,1.921,2.194],[1.760,2.202,1.664],[0.756,0.639,0.867],[0.180,0.228,0.111],[0.100,0.098,0.092],[0.097,0.176,0.076],[0.255,0.384,0.250],[0.183,0.089,0.045],[0.170,0.301,0.031],[0.056,0.063,0.017]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.360GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"48GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":342.555,"data_size":9944039775,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.166,1.205,0.852],[0.185,0.247,0.103],[0.340,0.172,0.261],[1.330,1.641,1.018],[1.569,1.416,1.901],[0.162,0.144,0.058],[0.070,0.040,0.082],[1.404,1.195,1.070],[1.619,1.457,1.155],[0.568,0.480,0.526],[0.740,0.656,0.591],[1.607,1.521,2.311],[4.133,2.108,2.593],[3.200,2.605,2.843],[1.224,1.431,1.814],[6.083,6.614,3.921],[5.476,4.496,2.886],[13.246,9.490,16.402],[0.064,0.057,0.046],[3.035,3.445,2.538],[2.825,2.889,2.424],[5.096,4.320,2.742],[11.694,7.609,14.963],[0.805,1.069,0.957],[0.557,0.570,0.693],[1.085,1.013,1.038],[3.069,3.055,2.036],[22.679,27.661,21.333],[2.542,1.791,1.931],[1.260,1.748,1.249],[3.443,2.476,2.798],[12.300,16.949,15.784],[7.072,6.025,6.006],[5.654,9.278,5.854],[3.190,2.635,3.008],[0.329,0.116,0.286],[0.226,0.081,0.198],[0.064,0.096,0.120],[0.357,0.375,0.211],[0.179,0.092,0.079],[0.216,0.031,0.026],[0.295,0.037,0.156]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.48GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"708GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":332.613,"data_size":9955529328,"result":[[0.008,0.004,0.003],[0.978,0.027,0.131],[0.171,0.034,0.447],[0.851,0.047,1.202],[0.413,0.285,0.157],[0.996,0.269,0.389],[0.119,0.103,0.027],[0.042,0.033,0.103],[0.507,0.414,0.432],[0.448,0.474,0.374],[0.290,0.259,0.145],[0.269,0.193,0.237],[0.361,0.276,0.324],[0.407,0.348,0.355],[0.452,0.405,0.311],[0.208,0.159,0.238],[0.660,0.578,0.617],[0.458,0.464,0.638],[1.284,1.711,1.098],[0.027,0.058,0.052],[0.629,0.830,0.737],[0.502,0.474,0.647],[0.979,0.622,1.044],[1.770,3.892,4.164],[0.248,0.175,0.184],[0.172,0.121,0.114],[0.143,0.349,0.193],[0.459,0.454,0.461],[3.294,3.247,3.360],[0.665,0.483,0.491],[0.240,0.245,0.242],[0.350,0.303,0.352],[1.782,1.407,1.462],[0.916,1.417,1.379],[1.188,1.309,1.200],[0.370,0.383,0.326],[0.103,0.095,0.085],[0.052,0.047,0.067],[0.100,0.085,0.092],[0.179,0.189,0.188],[0.094,0.040,0.052],[0.044,0.042,0.055],[0.027,0.023,0.031]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.708GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"96GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":347.594,"data_size":9946918782,"result":[[0.005,0.002,0.003],[0.127,0.025,1.637],[0.204,1.207,0.082],[1.777,0.287,1.093],[0.640,0.741,0.702],[1.423,1.238,1.370],[0.139,0.128,0.041],[0.101,0.080,0.031],[1.052,0.837,0.902],[1.051,1.130,1.001],[0.406,0.343,0.395],[0.531,0.434,0.395],[1.308,1.559,1.377],[1.649,1.710,2.276],[1.823,1.607,1.604],[0.897,0.995,0.710],[3.035,4.213,2.684],[2.647,2.390,2.203],[6.204,8.062,5.800],[0.134,0.060,0.072],[2.525,1.480,1.432],[3.288,1.977,1.978],[3.821,2.437,1.965],[8.819,11.010,7.518],[0.571,0.666,0.652],[0.453,0.479,0.546],[0.578,0.556,0.553],[1.653,1.512,1.577],[14.345,13.001,13.298],[1.229,1.155,1.454],[1.215,1.164,0.941],[1.591,1.965,1.533],[6.665,6.808,5.717],[4.750,5.407,5.341],[5.569,5.417,5.732],[1.400,1.462,1.651],[0.121,0.188,0.081],[0.047,0.042,0.072],[0.091,0.051,0.060],[0.227,0.208,0.160],[0.050,0.030,0.026],[0.027,0.061,0.037],[0.021,0.017,0.051]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.96GB.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"dev","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":573.697,"data_size":9944356651,"result":[[0.002,0.003,0.002],[0.110,0.884,0.363],[0.307,0.166,0.245],[0.624,0.485,0.275],[1.616,1.292,1.614],[2.591,2.192,2.484],[0.139,0.069,0.516],[0.105,0.037,0.102],[1.507,2.259,1.592],[2.481,1.774,1.806],[0.559,0.777,0.697],[0.681,0.570,0.920],[1.818,1.888,1.738],[3.266,3.113,4.488],[2.576,2.658,3.535],[1.551,1.555,1.926],[7.342,7.817,6.890],[5.789,6.373,4.137],[28.360,17.620,27.891],[0.060,0.053,0.440],[2.887,5.945,5.000],[3.713,6.440,3.736],[7.915,4.291,4.111],[11.210,27.281,19.303],[0.896,1.808,1.610],[0.631,1.026,1.015],[1.705,0.942,0.967],[2.979,2.904,5.303],[51.146,50.490,50.144],[2.103,1.933,3.405],[2.998,1.414,2.240],[2.496,3.989,2.741],[23.552,22.336,13.822],[14.086,12.553,19.012],[19.032,12.498,12.244],[3.916,3.466,3.089],[0.215,0.081,0.079],[0.091,0.236,0.041],[0.180,0.046,0.048],[0.378,0.158,0.266],[0.060,0.032,0.182],[0.049,0.132,0.040],[0.025,0.218,0.032]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.dev.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (data lake, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[1.578,0.756,0.793],[2.768,2.082,1.039],[2.570,1.545,1.429],[3.179,1.613,1.137],[1.451,1.401,1.397],[1.707,1.790,1.503],[1.242,0.919,0.961],[0.843,0.929,0.889],[1.440,1.446,1.716],[2.142,2.037,2.654],[1.861,1.528,1.514],[1.616,1.926,1.833],[1.608,1.590,1.669],[2.426,2.573,2.161],[1.645,1.691,1.775],[1.495,1.347,1.630],[3.611,3.167,3.792],[2.648,2.548,2.454],[6.087,5.603,5.713],[1.038,0.719,1.005],[6.092,4.233,3.468],[4.082,4.177,3.945],[6.882,6.795,6.887],[21.255,21.006,21.191],[2.177,1.611,1.773],[1.307,1.213,1.200],[1.940,2.241,1.678],[3.510,3.507,3.526],[10.886,10.748,10.761],[1.180,1.299,1.294],[2.168,2.110,2.026],[3.262,3.060,3.524],[6.162,6.043,6.159],[5.715,5.717,5.722],[5.651,5.696,5.720],[1.915,1.676,1.713],[0.538,0.499,0.472],[0.401,0.448,0.429],[0.399,0.412,0.419],[0.651,0.661,0.647],[0.345,0.365,0.389],[0.372,0.311,0.370],[0.287,0.339,0.306]],"source":"clickhouse-datalake/results/c6a.4xlarge.partitioned.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (data lake, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.276,0.179,0.170],[0.321,0.381,0.292],[0.409,0.415,0.373],[0.384,0.325,0.365],[0.575,0.689,0.749],[0.716,0.690,0.809],[0.363,0.300,0.381],[0.286,0.280,0.355],[0.870,0.672,0.715],[0.871,0.904,1.062],[0.542,0.649,0.605],[0.623,0.623,0.686],[0.752,0.711,0.745],[0.938,0.890,1.002],[0.737,0.825,0.712],[0.629,0.619,0.804],[1.358,1.200,1.299],[1.107,1.113,1.111],[2.082,1.924,2.251],[0.360,0.336,0.381],[2.153,2.042,1.962],[2.441,2.152,2.200],[2.949,3.080,3.299],[8.931,7.830,7.971],[0.749,0.732,0.607],[0.504,0.401,0.490],[0.719,0.654,0.558],[2.190,2.242,2.221],[3.082,2.668,2.535],[0.957,0.790,0.918],[0.954,0.948,0.928],[1.656,1.556,1.186],[2.396,2.381,2.305],[2.929,2.936,3.149],[2.908,2.996,2.920],[0.840,0.824,0.825],[0.546,0.552,0.586],[0.407,0.358,0.360],[0.485,0.524,0.534],[0.701,0.738,0.693],[0.347,0.425,0.355],[0.357,0.362,0.381],[0.293,0.329,0.316]],"source":"clickhouse-datalake/results/c6a.metal.partitioned.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.033,0.042,0.031],[0.127,0.104,0.073],[0.368,0.146,0.131],[1.094,0.132,0.130],[1.264,0.441,0.439],[1.070,0.651,0.618],[0.125,0.111,0.110],[0.122,0.089,0.080],[0.937,0.589,0.585],[1.558,0.702,0.692],[0.771,0.311,0.318],[0.994,0.345,0.328],[1.286,0.760,0.752],[2.628,1.026,1.019],[1.299,0.891,0.893],[0.756,0.613,0.614],[3.099,1.935,1.941],[2.399,1.206,1.203],[6.018,4.231,4.220],[0.256,0.132,0.107],[10.236,1.693,1.763],[11.338,2.156,2.159],[22.178,5.051,5.063],[56.387,17.017,17.051],[2.802,0.454,0.467],[0.933,0.344,0.327],[2.945,0.456,0.424],[9.856,1.971,1.982],[9.751,9.425,9.424],[1.298,1.306,1.288],[2.781,0.686,0.693],[6.547,1.141,1.116],[7.078,4.471,4.375],[10.905,4.451,4.421],[10.964,4.434,4.427],[1.111,1.031,1.043],[0.247,0.149,0.151],[0.137,0.094,0.101],[0.169,0.092,0.101],[0.339,0.258,0.254],[0.134,0.069,0.082],[0.080,0.068,0.077],[0.079,0.065,0.062]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.4xlarge.partitioned.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.100,0.053,0.052],[0.228,0.205,0.202],[0.272,0.204,0.203],[0.385,0.231,0.229],[0.924,0.535,0.520],[0.880,0.769,0.755],[0.228,0.196,0.193],[0.248,0.207,0.210],[0.794,0.701,0.715],[1.319,0.819,0.788],[0.611,0.377,0.386],[0.702,0.422,0.422],[1.011,0.878,0.881],[2.354,1.183,1.153],[1.130,1.008,0.991],[0.754,0.698,0.666],[2.891,2.118,2.131],[2.154,1.399,1.373],[5.762,4.453,4.365],[0.349,0.219,0.210],[9.930,1.798,1.822],[11.350,2.180,2.184],[22.261,5.045,4.926],[56.815,16.303,15.993],[2.620,0.585,0.530],[0.808,0.423,0.423],[2.611,0.582,0.552],[9.790,1.997,1.927],[9.455,9.065,9.017],[1.464,1.369,1.391],[2.477,0.727,0.719],[6.131,1.180,1.166],[6.762,4.486,4.452],[10.905,4.466,4.384],[11.088,4.435,4.379],[1.212,1.100,1.104],[0.267,0.139,0.143],[0.171,0.121,0.116],[0.196,0.128,0.127],[0.325,0.192,0.190],[0.130,0.089,0.094],[0.108,0.089,0.084],[0.129,0.084,0.084]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.4xlarge.single.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.122,0.101,0.108],[0.144,0.130,0.140],[0.309,0.207,0.183],[1.010,0.212,0.187],[1.156,0.433,0.345],[1.162,0.474,0.468],[0.172,0.184,0.154],[0.153,0.137,0.131],[1.049,0.557,0.469],[1.660,0.531,0.578],[0.847,0.258,0.282],[1.143,0.281,0.289],[1.288,0.515,0.485],[2.576,0.562,0.579],[1.214,0.570,0.529],[0.690,0.434,0.401],[2.758,0.871,0.803],[2.598,0.691,0.741],[4.918,1.693,1.594],[0.290,0.165,0.158],[10.372,0.626,0.595],[11.779,0.840,0.793],[22.453,1.705,1.358],[57.223,5.525,5.151],[2.881,0.319,0.293],[1.101,0.241,0.298],[3.186,0.310,0.338],[10.180,0.774,0.714],[8.806,2.291,2.319],[0.793,0.576,0.806],[2.855,0.438,0.454],[6.529,0.598,0.587],[5.535,1.687,1.852],[10.397,1.626,1.744],[10.388,1.614,1.705],[0.520,0.593,0.545],[0.231,0.178,0.207],[0.189,0.117,0.179],[0.168,0.172,0.160],[0.391,0.304,0.284],[0.182,0.150,0.123],[0.140,0.113,0.130],[0.133,0.130,0.125]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.metal.partitioned.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.129,0.059,0.060],[0.217,0.199,0.192],[0.268,0.243,0.340],[0.451,0.237,0.251],[0.918,0.448,0.436],[0.994,0.478,0.447],[0.226,0.201,0.195],[0.254,0.242,0.243],[0.915,0.576,0.576],[1.433,0.587,0.621],[0.711,0.454,0.403],[0.802,0.369,0.379],[0.984,0.562,0.526],[2.359,0.618,0.604],[1.077,0.528,0.523],[0.549,0.464,0.514],[2.457,0.831,0.868],[2.334,0.829,0.724],[4.502,1.588,1.608],[0.331,0.243,0.253],[10.218,0.736,0.699],[11.692,1.050,0.839],[22.713,1.567,1.627],[57.945,5.061,4.701],[2.733,0.401,0.382],[0.906,0.316,0.291],[2.843,0.399,0.373],[10.111,0.688,0.695],[8.424,1.512,1.516],[0.807,0.805,0.815],[2.550,0.454,0.446],[6.148,0.602,0.627],[4.980,1.642,1.649],[10.361,1.502,1.471],[10.328,1.461,1.444],[0.686,0.636,0.641],[0.309,0.227,0.216],[0.184,0.136,0.137],[0.193,0.139,0.143],[0.343,0.254,0.224],[0.158,0.107,0.101],[0.134,0.103,0.098],[0.130,0.095,0.095]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.metal.single.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (web)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c5n.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","serverless","stateless"],"load_time":0.330,"data_size":14557009492,"result":[[0.003,0.002,0.002],[0.723,0.012,0.010],[1.157,0.032,0.029],[1.479,0.046,0.043],[0.926,0.321,0.323],[2.747,0.548,0.553],[0.251,0.019,0.018],[0.096,0.019,0.016],[1.461,0.564,0.572],[1.111,0.616,0.600],[1.107,0.222,0.217],[0.941,0.252,0.238],[1.527,0.580,0.588],[1.583,0.832,0.838],[1.855,0.733,0.683],[0.895,0.404,0.397],[2.682,1.597,1.590],[1.796,1.004,1.026],[4.569,3.061,3.133],[0.648,0.029,0.029],[3.691,0.793,0.758],[4.088,0.923,0.928],[5.969,1.173,1.158],[16.028,3.130,3.082],[1.281,0.294,0.287],[0.920,0.237,0.214],[1.223,0.296,0.289],[3.675,0.826,0.838],[13.169,11.735,11.817],[1.332,1.225,1.246],[1.841,0.528,0.518],[3.059,0.744,0.711],[3.953,2.726,2.893],[4.984,2.735,2.685],[5.345,2.706,2.706],[1.773,0.958,0.944],[0.361,0.082,0.068],[0.250,0.035,0.033],[0.491,0.030,0.037],[0.460,0.138,0.131],[0.320,0.016,0.016],[0.273,0.018,0.017],[0.223,0.013,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse-web/results/c5n.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (web)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","serverless","stateless"],"load_time":0.330,"data_size":14557009492,"result":[[0.097,0.003,0.003],[0.074,0.012,0.012],[0.175,0.022,0.022],[0.236,0.022,0.022],[0.290,0.204,0.184],[0.821,0.200,0.193],[0.085,0.015,0.017],[0.085,0.026,0.025],[0.424,0.251,0.248],[0.480,0.264,0.274],[0.363,0.098,0.098],[0.290,0.086,0.090],[0.665,0.189,0.186],[0.601,0.251,0.245],[0.753,0.225,0.227],[0.241,0.116,0.115],[0.733,0.356,0.349],[0.942,0.268,0.254],[1.379,0.633,0.626],[0.454,0.019,0.021],[4.154,0.259,0.236],[2.204,0.196,0.183],[3.137,0.330,0.294],[10.038,1.126,1.108],[0.666,0.127,0.086],[0.534,0.078,0.078],[1.267,0.148,0.124],[1.435,0.330,0.311],[2.385,1.394,1.381],[0.435,0.403,0.400],[0.787,0.149,0.140],[1.259,0.224,0.213],[1.435,0.794,0.788],[2.148,0.786,0.652],[2.029,0.677,0.655],[0.348,0.170,0.168],[0.514,0.053,0.066],[0.238,0.036,0.038],[0.381,0.036,0.037],[0.426,0.127,0.127],[0.291,0.029,0.026],[0.248,0.025,0.029],[0.283,0.014,0.017]],"source":"clickhouse-web/results/c6a.metal.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2022-11-18","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":504.026,"data_size":14580183513,"result":[[0.002,0.001,0.001],[0.019,0.013,0.011],[0.048,0.027,0.026],[0.432,0.036,0.034],[0.682,0.320,0.318],[0.654,0.512,0.538],[0.028,0.021,0.020],[0.020,0.019,0.015],[0.612,0.555,0.555],[0.870,0.619,0.612],[0.247,0.196,0.208],[0.263,0.229,0.208],[0.603,0.516,0.495],[1.401,0.786,0.787],[0.703,0.650,0.628],[0.547,0.498,0.511],[1.842,1.864,1.807],[1.230,1.103,1.113],[4.878,3.224,3.189],[0.205,0.029,0.016],[9.280,0.801,0.762],[9.827,0.864,0.847],[18.726,1.679,1.696],[42.181,2.599,2.510],[1.772,0.216,0.216],[0.647,0.163,0.158],[2.237,0.231,0.214],[8.837,0.783,0.768],[10.930,10.699,10.662],[1.224,1.224,1.202],[1.422,0.421,0.427],[4.382,0.520,0.511],[4.434,2.888,2.947],[9.390,2.650,2.650],[9.339,2.662,2.658],[1.024,0.915,0.964],[0.128,0.095,0.094],[0.056,0.040,0.043],[0.061,0.036,0.036],[0.239,0.182,0.197],[0.039,0.019,0.020],[0.025,0.013,0.017],[0.020,0.014,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (tuned)","date":"2022-11-18","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":504.026,"data_size":14580183513,"result":[[0.002,0.001,0.001],[0.020,0.010,0.010],[0.046,0.035,0.025],[0.115,0.032,0.031],[0.365,0.299,0.300],[0.531,0.444,0.431],[0.042,0.019,0.018],[0.019,0.014,0.014],[0.745,0.641,0.607],[0.634,0.593,0.577],[0.211,0.176,0.169],[0.226,0.190,0.188],[0.637,0.483,0.482],[1.343,0.755,0.733],[0.658,0.577,0.576],[0.531,0.500,0.521],[1.861,1.679,1.660],[1.136,0.698,0.676],[4.071,3.124,3.121],[0.069,0.022,0.014],[8.678,0.770,0.755],[9.854,0.881,0.867],[16.218,1.344,1.325],[13.598,1.244,1.220],[1.773,0.216,0.210],[0.662,0.159,0.160],[2.247,0.220,0.213],[8.837,0.782,0.752],[7.061,1.026,1.063],[1.346,1.223,1.245],[1.375,0.375,0.420],[4.419,0.521,0.503],[4.457,2.880,2.944],[9.361,2.718,2.640],[9.405,2.614,2.616],[0.998,0.923,0.980],[0.119,0.093,0.097],[0.053,0.043,0.043],[0.055,0.040,0.041],[0.257,0.203,0.219],[0.044,0.020,0.019],[0.029,0.014,0.013],[0.025,0.013,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c5.4xlarge.tuned.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":470.639,"data_size":14472294250,"result":[[0.005,0.002,0.001],[0.052,0.007,0.007],[0.052,0.019,0.019],[0.435,0.029,0.026],[0.914,0.356,0.350],[0.831,0.456,0.449],[0.022,0.022,0.019],[0.049,0.013,0.012],[0.602,0.497,0.489],[0.906,0.546,0.533],[0.200,0.128,0.133],[0.639,0.150,0.151],[1.368,0.585,0.575],[1.722,0.804,0.806],[1.115,0.656,0.641],[0.570,0.530,0.510],[2.388,1.719,1.674],[2.113,0.941,0.921],[5.165,3.430,3.407],[0.348,0.027,0.018],[9.892,0.576,0.556],[10.577,0.670,0.653],[12.949,1.087,1.072],[37.277,2.460,2.428],[2.050,0.174,0.173],[1.132,0.147,0.147],[2.604,0.166,0.165],[9.524,0.652,0.637],[9.399,8.993,8.931],[2.462,2.451,2.456],[1.754,0.462,0.452],[4.614,0.623,0.635],[5.449,3.831,4.013],[11.139,3.306,3.284],[11.103,3.330,3.308],[1.054,0.972,0.989],[0.093,0.055,0.065],[0.037,0.025,0.026],[0.044,0.022,0.021],[0.160,0.114,0.104],[0.036,0.015,0.014],[0.022,0.012,0.010],[0.017,0.012,0.010]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (tuned)","date":"2022-11-18","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":506.939,"data_size":15117484912,"result":[[0.001,0.001,0.001],[0.054,0.011,0.010],[0.046,0.021,0.020],[0.094,0.027,0.026],[0.453,0.331,0.331],[0.562,0.469,0.465],[0.028,0.018,0.018],[0.018,0.013,0.012],[0.778,0.872,0.868],[0.602,0.528,0.516],[0.176,0.339,0.285],[0.302,0.234,0.213],[0.610,0.549,0.521],[1.476,0.761,0.762],[0.711,0.563,0.571],[0.604,0.630,0.617],[1.920,1.851,1.836],[1.119,0.529,0.524],[4.461,3.293,3.297],[0.055,0.018,0.013],[8.747,0.673,0.675],[9.854,0.752,0.739],[16.229,1.519,1.528],[13.744,1.227,1.196],[1.776,0.158,0.165],[0.837,0.132,0.131],[2.352,0.161,0.156],[9.004,0.812,0.790],[7.094,1.113,1.107],[2.597,2.512,2.457],[1.402,0.388,0.395],[4.447,0.605,0.597],[5.316,4.105,4.140],[9.772,3.251,3.270],[9.767,3.278,3.150],[0.988,0.843,0.953],[0.217,0.135,0.145],[0.062,0.051,0.055],[0.069,0.040,0.047],[0.236,0.160,0.158],[0.034,0.016,0.015],[0.022,0.013,0.013],[0.023,0.011,0.014]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.4xlarge.tuned.json"} -,{"hide":true,"system":"ClickHouse (zstd)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":417.533,"data_size":9997826232,"result":[[0.004,0.002,0.001],[0.069,0.017,0.016],[0.073,0.051,0.048],[0.158,0.067,0.066],[1.603,1.545,1.709],[1.225,1.105,1.100],[0.033,0.026,0.024],[0.023,0.021,0.020],[0.710,0.621,0.614],[0.813,0.715,0.713],[0.292,0.231,0.245],[0.350,0.269,0.271],[0.785,0.692,0.704],[1.209,1.044,1.066],[1.034,0.908,0.897],[0.993,0.940,0.909],[2.818,2.595,2.611],[1.804,1.717,1.711],[4.846,4.692,4.714],[0.081,0.025,0.020],[5.511,1.388,1.385],[6.304,1.306,1.293],[11.938,2.406,2.400],[30.031,4.268,4.242],[0.964,0.337,0.335],[0.326,0.264,0.260],[0.997,0.338,0.338],[5.523,1.148,1.140],[7.319,5.744,5.796],[2.235,2.236,2.199],[0.860,0.660,0.664],[3.695,0.772,0.764],[5.044,4.820,4.821],[6.786,4.133,4.093],[6.769,4.110,4.170],[1.289,1.188,1.221],[0.093,0.069,0.075],[0.037,0.033,0.029],[0.047,0.033,0.030],[0.185,0.151,0.155],[0.027,0.021,0.017],[0.020,0.012,0.015],[0.017,0.013,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.4xlarge.zstd.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":137.872,"data_size":14467272630,"result":[[0.030,0.003,0.003],[0.055,0.012,0.013],[0.048,0.020,0.020],[0.586,0.022,0.024],[0.843,0.213,0.199],[1.016,0.180,0.175],[0.024,0.018,0.018],[0.045,0.026,0.026],[0.743,0.260,0.252],[1.015,0.271,0.269],[0.383,0.090,0.093],[0.699,0.103,0.101],[1.208,0.181,0.154],[1.866,0.216,0.190],[1.193,0.194,0.175],[0.507,0.128,0.124],[2.004,0.379,0.355],[1.574,0.255,0.243],[3.505,0.657,0.608],[0.080,0.011,0.012],[9.202,0.140,0.123],[10.663,0.158,0.147],[12.847,0.236,0.206],[35.704,0.570,0.541],[1.806,0.062,0.047],[1.243,0.044,0.040],[2.699,0.060,0.050],[9.516,0.282,0.278],[7.811,1.260,1.249],[0.420,0.409,0.400],[1.443,0.113,0.110],[5.026,0.183,0.153],[4.271,1.126,0.728],[9.322,0.801,0.714],[9.090,0.737,0.676],[0.226,0.187,0.184],[0.088,0.060,0.064],[0.046,0.032,0.034],[0.055,0.025,0.028],[0.189,0.148,0.128],[0.040,0.033,0.017],[0.028,0.018,0.019],[0.024,0.017,0.023]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.metal.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (tuned)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":136.869,"data_size":14571706777,"result":[[0.003,0.001,0.001],[0.046,0.051,0.035],[0.044,0.039,0.040],[0.074,0.025,0.036],[0.231,0.097,0.089],[0.970,0.123,0.120],[0.017,0.018,0.019],[0.030,0.029,0.023],[0.180,0.153,0.137],[0.946,0.269,0.283],[0.116,0.062,0.060],[0.195,0.056,0.059],[1.026,0.158,0.137],[1.575,0.188,0.176],[0.837,0.153,0.161],[0.192,0.122,0.123],[1.767,0.340,0.324],[1.088,0.098,0.098],[3.413,0.891,0.787],[0.039,0.021,0.012],[9.017,0.292,0.258],[10.048,0.286,0.251],[20.084,0.454,0.445],[39.564,0.718,0.741],[1.762,0.056,0.046],[0.894,0.035,0.043],[2.421,0.061,0.047],[10.479,0.447,0.439],[7.089,0.282,0.270],[0.429,0.384,0.395],[1.284,0.093,0.091],[4.753,0.183,0.159],[3.618,1.030,0.714],[8.792,0.636,0.623],[8.765,0.626,0.603],[0.213,0.195,0.206],[0.103,0.074,0.067],[0.047,0.035,0.034],[0.053,0.035,0.033],[0.198,0.166,0.142],[0.035,0.026,0.019],[0.027,0.019,0.027],[0.027,0.014,0.016]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.metal.tuned.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-03-14","machine":"m5d.24xlarge","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":457.716,"data_size":14577617512,"result":[[0.016,0.001,0.001],[0.084,0.011,0.010],[0.051,0.018,0.019],[0.168,0.021,0.021],[0.581,0.189,0.193],[0.652,0.244,0.233],[0.020,0.015,0.015],[0.027,0.023,0.025],[0.491,0.376,0.381],[0.640,0.406,0.401],[0.225,0.134,0.132],[0.250,0.144,0.144],[0.508,0.235,0.214],[1.375,0.316,0.301],[0.561,0.233,0.226],[0.280,0.189,0.186],[1.576,0.690,0.655],[1.194,0.369,0.372],[3.253,1.210,1.140],[0.102,0.029,0.023],[8.583,0.424,0.323],[9.837,0.381,0.369],[18.744,0.846,0.718],[42.086,1.119,1.112],[1.771,0.171,0.114],[0.673,0.085,0.083],[2.287,0.136,0.126],[8.892,0.405,0.361],[7.333,2.971,3.049],[0.801,0.756,0.774],[1.339,0.202,0.197],[4.481,0.278,0.256],[3.866,1.649,1.634],[9.055,1.189,1.105],[8.955,1.259,1.044],[0.396,0.362,0.344],[0.136,0.103,0.113],[0.066,0.046,0.046],[0.097,0.041,0.056],[0.274,0.248,0.208],[0.047,0.024,0.023],[0.026,0.020,0.023],[0.037,0.022,0.039]],"source":"clickhouse/results/m5d.24xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse (zstd)","date":"2023-03-14","machine":"m5d.24xlarge","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":394.198,"data_size":9997207883,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.001],[0.042,0.039,0.030],[0.051,0.028,0.027],[0.140,0.029,0.035],[0.248,0.191,0.185],[0.296,0.247,0.251],[0.018,0.017,0.019],[0.025,0.023,0.024],[0.427,0.398,0.384],[0.464,0.412,0.404],[0.221,0.143,0.152],[0.236,0.164,0.156],[0.306,0.236,0.233],[0.702,0.352,0.349],[0.329,0.266,0.321],[0.264,0.219,0.200],[0.881,0.639,0.652],[0.646,0.394,0.360],[2.279,1.230,1.151],[0.087,0.036,0.015],[5.403,0.403,0.377],[6.292,0.475,0.434],[11.918,0.845,0.768],[29.658,1.359,1.268],[0.959,0.130,0.140],[0.321,0.092,0.104],[1.455,0.128,0.119],[5.854,0.428,0.425],[5.267,2.886,2.715],[0.793,0.773,0.767],[0.576,0.212,0.210],[3.811,0.363,0.276],[3.577,1.568,1.640],[5.892,1.272,1.187],[5.825,1.260,1.307],[0.430,0.420,0.370],[0.098,0.109,0.087],[0.044,0.046,0.048],[0.087,0.050,0.042],[0.249,0.201,0.189],[0.049,0.033,0.029],[0.031,0.025,0.014],[0.032,0.021,0.021]],"source":"clickhouse/results/m5d.24xlarge.zstd.json"} -,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-06-09","machine":"m6i.32xlarge","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":457.716,"data_size":14577617512,"result":[[0.030,0.005,0.005],[0.043,0.013,0.017],[0.056,0.018,0.016],[0.563,0.017,0.015],[0.725,0.184,0.152],[1.038,0.197,0.205],[0.020,0.022,0.016],[0.040,0.026,0.025],[0.541,0.316,0.313],[0.882,0.342,0.331],[0.187,0.108,0.100],[0.544,0.110,0.130],[1.085,0.194,0.195],[1.765,0.299,0.226],[0.961,0.212,0.183],[0.392,0.147,0.164],[1.971,0.522,0.452],[1.322,0.310,0.288],[3.522,0.851,0.864],[0.063,0.019,0.017],[9.149,0.299,0.245],[10.334,0.242,0.269],[19.542,0.553,0.488],[35.625,0.827,0.766],[1.814,0.176,0.137],[1.165,0.089,0.084],[2.569,0.117,0.065],[9.402,0.315,0.226],[7.811,3.556,1.758],[0.476,0.441,0.437],[1.513,0.161,0.197],[4.901,0.250,0.173],[4.006,1.059,1.004],[9.185,1.026,0.808],[9.369,0.786,0.788],[0.354,0.284,0.301],[0.124,0.069,0.065],[0.051,0.036,0.041],[0.085,0.038,0.032],[0.210,0.142,0.143],[0.040,0.033,0.024],[0.022,0.020,0.024],[0.027,0.022,0.018]],"source":"clickhouse/results/m6i.32xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"192GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":224.417,"data_size":9940946872,"result":[[0.003,0.004,0.003],[0.77,0.067,0.022],[0.351,0.69,0.045],[0.762,0.072,0.586],[0.324,0.432,0.361],[0.861,0.697,0.786],[0.509,0.054,0.031],[0.035,0.542,0.394],[0.986,0.624,0.64],[0.705,0.658,0.621],[0.295,0.245,0.191],[0.346,0.335,0.295],[0.706,0.808,0.809],[0.856,0.857,0.968],[0.836,0.861,0.983],[0.431,0.434,0.387],[1.55,1.564,1.692],[1.379,1.084,1.405],[3.511,3.56,3.617],[0.072,0.134,0.035],[1.324,2.146,1.026],[1.294,1.591,1.237],[2.004,1.217,2.248],[4.849,6.715,3.885],[0.432,0.354,0.354],[0.365,0.367,0.309],[0.351,0.44,0.394],[1.106,1.224,0.971],[8.116,9.85,9.576],[1.224,1.211,0.82],[0.69,0.646,0.699],[0.865,0.847,0.746],[3.477,2.954,2.843],[2.562,2.985,2.519],[2.451,2.462,2.528],[0.967,0.918,0.883],[0.095,0.089,0.091],[0.049,0.057,0.148],[0.138,0.072,0.07],[0.299,0.195,0.218],[0.058,0.329,0.047],[0.021,0.045,0.027],[0.038,0.029,0.033]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.192GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"24GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":898.272,"data_size":9949087959,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.134,0.151,1.04],[0.481,0.547,0.228],[0.952,0.427,0.56],[2.505,2.465,2.421],[3.252,3.143,3.498],[0.281,0.121,0.139],[0.048,0.042,0.043],[4.113,2.525,2.291],[2.742,2.965,2.652],[1.161,1.069,1.193],[1.555,1.333,1.357],[3.277,3.667,3.194],[4.85,5.542,5.12],[4.442,4.498,4.674],[2.645,2.745,2.731],[11.061,10.301,10.394],[8.293,7.391,7.995],[32.636,30.847,30.519],[0.099,0.133,0.129],[7.746,9.111,5.625],[13.131,6.666,6.92],[24.838,12.782,8.131],[33.065,23.814,46.946],[1.903,1.852,2.352],[1.172,1.294,1.241],[1.913,1.883,1.851],[6.512,5.868,6.225],[58.901,55.853,55.978],[3.891,5.452,4],[2.982,3.194,3.433],[5.779,4.125,4.88],[32.403,35.532,34.985],[27.241,27.673,26.393],[26.661,25.919,28.05],[4.74,4.937,4.659],[0.361,0.175,0.168],[0.079,0.101,0.07],[0.177,0.088,0.072],[0.336,0.341,0.327],[0.231,0.033,0.039],[0.056,0.192,0.027],[0.023,0.021,0.026]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.24GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"360GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":216.929,"data_size":9942386190,"result":[[0.003,0.005,0.003],[0.651,0.021,0.647],[0.307,0.039,0.293],[0.638,0.628,0.14],[0.273,0.303,0.259],[0.585,0.521,0.431],[0.117,0.025,0.066],[0.059,0.032,0.042],[0.61,0.54,1.024],[1.158,1.01,0.534],[0.236,0.234,0.223],[0.289,0.21,0.249],[0.444,0.455,0.454],[0.582,0.592,0.644],[0.739,0.586,0.513],[0.313,0.32,0.369],[1.126,1.175,1.242],[0.838,0.828,0.792],[1.88,2.022,2.056],[0.036,0.058,0.043],[0.95,0.921,1.028],[0.842,0.832,0.827],[0.931,1.435,0.904],[2.66,2.337,5.094],[0.258,0.27,0.235],[0.305,0.214,0.231],[0.257,0.261,0.238],[0.77,1.022,0.812],[5.886,4.937,5.757],[0.655,0.627,0.638],[0.427,0.675,0.476],[0.541,0.595,0.696],[2.303,2.386,1.514],[1.604,1.685,1.776],[1.59,1.616,1.653],[0.621,0.722,0.49],[0.174,0.156,0.093],[0.084,0.046,0.059],[0.061,0.132,0.083],[0.283,0.315,0.207],[0.062,0.316,0.037],[0.21,0.037,0.032],[0.029,0.038,0.052]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.360GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"48GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":313.53,"data_size":9941379875,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.575,0.147,0.015],[0.248,0.775,0.09],[0.789,0.388,0.179],[1.162,1.033,1.021],[1.732,1.498,2.214],[0.128,0.052,0.079],[0.058,0.03,0.047],[1.56,1.619,1.152],[1.958,1.49,1.82],[0.498,0.453,0.45],[0.643,0.797,0.615],[1.818,1.617,2.116],[2.826,2.798,2.674],[2.364,2.222,2.019],[1.275,1.221,1.322],[5.23,4.694,5.178],[3.506,3.187,2.962],[9.025,11.452,10.064],[0.098,0.058,0.09],[4.267,3.073,3.884],[2.856,3.725,2.821],[6.76,3.852,3.267],[15.132,10.307,11.082],[0.956,0.905,0.933],[0.607,0.724,0.662],[0.915,0.917,0.888],[2.453,2.441,2.577],[22.966,24.132,22.6],[1.99,1.856,2.246],[1.629,1.615,1.535],[2.691,2.884,1.926],[14.293,15.228,13.532],[6.949,7.111,9.26],[7.081,8.422,8.627],[3.143,2.628,2.513],[0.193,0.129,0.155],[0.048,0.051,0.086],[0.121,0.07,0.076],[0.37,0.21,0.179],[0.044,0.242,0.04],[0.042,0.031,0.042],[0.151,0.031,0.024]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.48GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"720GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":220.239,"data_size":9941859054,"result":[[0.004,0.004,0.005],[0.118,0.059,0.637],[0.248,0.166,0.036],[0.175,0.516,0.501],[0.222,0.192,0.195],[0.405,0.262,0.264],[0.164,0.054,0.026],[0.058,0.421,0.064],[0.522,0.411,0.549],[0.552,0.451,0.457],[0.245,0.18,0.21],[0.196,0.211,0.178],[0.514,0.266,0.571],[0.662,0.635,0.593],[0.398,0.4,0.365],[0.236,0.223,0.343],[0.665,0.631,0.652],[0.474,0.526,0.469],[1.462,1.219,1.468],[0.032,0.027,0.055],[0.762,1.088,0.477],[0.553,0.502,0.507],[0.928,0.618,0.706],[4.07,3.194,1.992],[0.206,0.163,0.147],[0.128,0.177,0.114],[0.177,0.171,0.172],[0.528,0.647,0.6],[4.037,4.033,4.04],[0.663,0.629,0.65],[0.286,0.302,0.299],[0.395,0.366,0.335],[1.704,1.802,1.76],[1.307,1.265,1.361],[1.276,1.281,1.38],[0.351,0.317,0.319],[0.134,0.12,0.122],[0.07,0.053,0.064],[0.086,0.082,0.087],[0.171,0.18,0.204],[0.063,0.034,0.046],[0.059,0.05,0.044],[0.061,0.049,0.039]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.720GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"96GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":227.755,"data_size":9942057937,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.709,0.039,0.317],[0.163,0.295,0.754],[0.33,0.144,0.813],[0.661,0.869,0.654],[1.315,1.402,1.182],[0.177,0.042,0.07],[0.586,0.052,0.042],[1.178,1.141,1.472],[1.062,1.06,0.875],[0.605,0.374,0.403],[0.492,0.443,0.409],[1.228,1.3,1.254],[2.161,1.633,1.644],[1.493,1.734,1.602],[0.986,0.939,0.823],[3.121,3.165,2.713],[1.867,1.716,3.116],[5.606,7.876,5.516],[0.168,0.262,0.084],[2.063,1.632,1.636],[2.995,3.168,1.861],[2.431,4.313,2.309],[12.271,6.228,7.296],[0.751,0.699,0.659],[0.489,0.475,0.563],[0.692,0.592,0.554],[1.75,1.626,1.768],[14.788,15.976,15.28],[1.456,1.202,1.483],[0.985,1.104,1.059],[2.162,1.552,1.099],[4.401,6.886,6.793],[4.445,4.203,4.891],[4.964,4.319,4.943],[1.4,1.475,1.427],[0.101,0.12,0.119],[0.08,0.088,0.048],[0.122,0.067,0.047],[0.214,0.186,0.263],[0.137,0.025,0.026],[0.157,0.057,0.042],[0.023,0.058,0.037]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.96GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-08","machine":"1430GB","cluster_size":"dedicated","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":225.127,"data_size":9940236142,"result":[[0.014,0.014,0.007],[0.09,0.471,0.027],[0.52,0.029,0.325],[0.332,0.375,0.033],[0.529,0.845,0.54],[0.932,0.752,0.669],[0.356,0.068,0.061],[0.074,0.071,0.037],[0.502,0.421,0.35],[0.401,0.333,0.347],[0.261,0.245,0.139],[0.206,0.263,0.154],[0.229,0.338,0.204],[0.377,0.342,0.291],[0.275,0.284,0.241],[0.173,0.137,0.144],[0.484,0.451,0.492],[0.326,0.327,0.355],[0.975,0.888,0.886],[0.032,0.038,0.053],[0.693,0.566,0.423],[0.345,0.336,0.729],[0.485,0.41,0.377],[2.533,2.148,1.213],[0.177,0.242,0.093],[0.194,0.365,0.239],[0.334,0.218,0.245],[0.773,0.655,0.323],[1.728,1.8,1.713],[0.387,0.408,0.385],[0.195,0.183,0.171],[0.557,0.377,0.24],[1.193,1.251,1.148],[0.707,0.794,0.776],[0.697,0.838,0.857],[0.31,0.229,0.332],[0.15,0.1,0.105],[0.049,0.062,0.045],[0.076,0.065,0.163],[0.219,0.186,0.19],[0.167,0.037,0.037],[0.053,0.037,0.031],[0.039,0.029,0.028]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dedicated.standard.1430GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (aws)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"dev","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","aws"],"load_time":700.114,"data_size":9944443104,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.114,0.112,0.044],[0.53,0.223,0.231],[0.658,0.321,0.578],[2.042,1.725,1.454],[2.508,2.023,2.725],[0.091,0.091,0.084],[0.033,0.081,0.035],[1.891,2.362,2.009],[2.071,1.951,2.251],[1.077,0.666,0.809],[1.082,0.89,0.977],[2.813,3.022,2.817],[3.666,3.734,3.593],[3.647,3.371,2.7],[2.513,1.743,1.641],[6.708,9.375,8.844],[4.948,6.079,5.46],[26.159,20.86,17.466],[0.395,0.08,0.107],[3.658,3.448,6.485],[6.897,6.948,4.022],[8.765,7.751,4.769],[13.487,27.999,20.242],[1.132,1.961,1.199],[0.799,0.705,0.838],[2.009,1.063,1.744],[3.712,5.554,3.618],[32.808,60.019,32.276],[3.389,2.354,3.351],[1.779,2.202,2.205],[3.687,3.694,2.223],[23.809,16.334,16.007],[19.995,19.951,17.978],[16.47,19.988,19.945],[3.228,2.638,3.916],[0.303,0.103,0.105],[0.257,0.093,0.064],[0.08,0.136,0.066],[0.27,0.275,0.347],[0.055,0.205,0.056],[0.182,0.059,0.033],[0.082,0.176,0.03]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dev.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"192GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":343.743,"data_size":9944304173,"result":[[0.003,0.002,0.002],[0.026,1.152,0.018],[0.088,0.529,0.089],[1.196,0.067,0.062],[0.275,0.266,0.698],[0.498,0.447,1.528],[0.598,0.62,0.034],[0.533,0.026,0.16],[0.676,0.628,0.524],[0.814,0.588,0.571],[0.195,0.296,0.282],[0.215,0.208,0.35],[0.613,0.5,0.781],[0.879,0.708,0.821],[0.601,0.595,0.957],[0.335,0.319,0.326],[1.624,1.323,1.492],[0.877,1.269,0.95],[3.889,2.801,3.879],[0.059,0.077,0.192],[1.162,1.376,0.826],[1.079,0.976,0.823],[2.241,1.161,1.293],[6.01,3.231,6.571],[0.335,0.279,0.269],[0.224,0.253,0.235],[0.335,0.319,0.315],[0.745,0.939,0.725],[6.356,6.294,7.592],[0.77,0.725,0.806],[0.543,0.526,0.473],[0.782,0.832,0.696],[3.412,2.442,2.937],[1.812,1.819,1.889],[2.386,2.62,2.594],[0.795,0.747,0.866],[0.129,0.122,0.102],[0.063,0.086,0.046],[0.063,0.068,0.081],[0.153,0.191,0.229],[0.05,0.061,0.039],[0.046,0.028,0.026],[0.072,0.022,0.019]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.192GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"24GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":763.464,"data_size":9946144862,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.265,0.022,0.022],[0.408,0.24,0.267],[0.994,0.342,0.479],[2.284,1.765,2.514],[3.99,2.548,2.53],[0.187,0.088,0.087],[0.029,0.155,0.029],[2.035,1.852,2.887],[2.812,2.227,2.535],[1.173,1.064,1.109],[1.373,1.144,0.872],[3.742,2.382,3.517],[6.107,3.781,3.69],[3.56,7.737,3.467],[2.87,2.274,2.313],[8.827,10.482,10.345],[6.702,5.775,6.96],[23.942,30.504,28.644],[0.089,0.111,0.105],[10.025,4.656,8.109],[5.292,6.732,6.562],[19.192,7.473,7.452],[41.852,20.429,17.857],[1.486,1.817,2.216],[0.952,1.092,1.101],[1.458,1.779,1.431],[5.706,4.643,4.71],[54.04,52.301,50.632],[3.204,2.606,2.534],[3.222,2.917,2.78],[5.636,3.353,3.353],[24.542,33.083,32.492],[20.607,25.238,20.718],[25.099,20.741,25.281],[4.873,4.468,4.134],[0.144,0.18,0.261],[0.098,0.054,0.059],[0.064,0.075,0.073],[0.436,0.333,0.322],[0.213,0.037,0.043],[0.025,0.029,0.223],[0.027,0.023,0.021]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.24GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"360GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":329.494,"data_size":9944755537,"result":[[0.004,0.004,0.003],[1.018,0.069,1.415],[1.146,0.035,0.188],[1.053,0.047,0.047],[0.267,0.233,0.219],[0.602,0.504,0.609],[0.923,0.673,1.034],[0.837,0.582,0.051],[0.676,0.739,0.481],[0.928,0.626,0.478],[0.312,0.234,0.239],[0.402,0.308,0.232],[0.402,0.513,0.483],[0.548,0.621,0.638],[0.54,0.477,0.516],[0.383,0.298,0.344],[1.156,0.922,0.865],[0.73,0.896,0.651],[1.836,1.689,2.031],[0.032,0.051,0.152],[0.962,0.987,0.591],[0.898,1.133,0.821],[2.602,0.917,1.33],[4.678,2.837,2.668],[0.764,0.29,0.261],[0.148,0.146,0.205],[0.276,0.192,0.28],[0.822,0.907,0.839],[5.19,6.455,5.898],[0.775,0.68,0.657],[0.451,0.436,0.66],[0.488,1.211,0.486],[2.9,2.543,2.817],[1.725,1.921,2.194],[1.76,2.202,1.664],[0.756,0.639,0.867],[0.18,0.228,0.111],[0.1,0.098,0.092],[0.097,0.176,0.076],[0.255,0.384,0.25],[0.183,0.089,0.045],[0.17,0.301,0.031],[0.056,0.063,0.017]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.360GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"48GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":342.555,"data_size":9944039775,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.002],[0.166,1.205,0.852],[0.185,0.247,0.103],[0.34,0.172,0.261],[1.33,1.641,1.018],[1.569,1.416,1.901],[0.162,0.144,0.058],[0.07,0.04,0.082],[1.404,1.195,1.07],[1.619,1.457,1.155],[0.568,0.48,0.526],[0.74,0.656,0.591],[1.607,1.521,2.311],[4.133,2.108,2.593],[3.2,2.605,2.843],[1.224,1.431,1.814],[6.083,6.614,3.921],[5.476,4.496,2.886],[13.246,9.49,16.402],[0.064,0.057,0.046],[3.035,3.445,2.538],[2.825,2.889,2.424],[5.096,4.32,2.742],[11.694,7.609,14.963],[0.805,1.069,0.957],[0.557,0.57,0.693],[1.085,1.013,1.038],[3.069,3.055,2.036],[22.679,27.661,21.333],[2.542,1.791,1.931],[1.26,1.748,1.249],[3.443,2.476,2.798],[12.3,16.949,15.784],[7.072,6.025,6.006],[5.654,9.278,5.854],[3.19,2.635,3.008],[0.329,0.116,0.286],[0.226,0.081,0.198],[0.064,0.096,0.12],[0.357,0.375,0.211],[0.179,0.092,0.079],[0.216,0.031,0.026],[0.295,0.037,0.156]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.48GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"708GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":332.613,"data_size":9955529328,"result":[[0.008,0.004,0.003],[0.978,0.027,0.131],[0.171,0.034,0.447],[0.851,0.047,1.202],[0.413,0.285,0.157],[0.996,0.269,0.389],[0.119,0.103,0.027],[0.042,0.033,0.103],[0.507,0.414,0.432],[0.448,0.474,0.374],[0.29,0.259,0.145],[0.269,0.193,0.237],[0.361,0.276,0.324],[0.407,0.348,0.355],[0.452,0.405,0.311],[0.208,0.159,0.238],[0.66,0.578,0.617],[0.458,0.464,0.638],[1.284,1.711,1.098],[0.027,0.058,0.052],[0.629,0.83,0.737],[0.502,0.474,0.647],[0.979,0.622,1.044],[1.77,3.892,4.164],[0.248,0.175,0.184],[0.172,0.121,0.114],[0.143,0.349,0.193],[0.459,0.454,0.461],[3.294,3.247,3.36],[0.665,0.483,0.491],[0.24,0.245,0.242],[0.35,0.303,0.352],[1.782,1.407,1.462],[0.916,1.417,1.379],[1.188,1.309,1.2],[0.37,0.383,0.326],[0.103,0.095,0.085],[0.052,0.047,0.067],[0.1,0.085,0.092],[0.179,0.189,0.188],[0.094,0.04,0.052],[0.044,0.042,0.055],[0.027,0.023,0.031]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.708GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"96GB","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":347.594,"data_size":9946918782,"result":[[0.005,0.002,0.003],[0.127,0.025,1.637],[0.204,1.207,0.082],[1.777,0.287,1.093],[0.64,0.741,0.702],[1.423,1.238,1.37],[0.139,0.128,0.041],[0.101,0.08,0.031],[1.052,0.837,0.902],[1.051,1.13,1.001],[0.406,0.343,0.395],[0.531,0.434,0.395],[1.308,1.559,1.377],[1.649,1.71,2.276],[1.823,1.607,1.604],[0.897,0.995,0.71],[3.035,4.213,2.684],[2.647,2.39,2.203],[6.204,8.062,5.8],[0.134,0.06,0.072],[2.525,1.48,1.432],[3.288,1.977,1.978],[3.821,2.437,1.965],[8.819,11.01,7.518],[0.571,0.666,0.652],[0.453,0.479,0.546],[0.578,0.556,0.553],[1.653,1.512,1.577],[14.345,13.001,13.298],[1.229,1.155,1.454],[1.215,1.164,0.941],[1.591,1.965,1.533],[6.665,6.808,5.717],[4.75,5.407,5.341],[5.569,5.417,5.732],[1.4,1.462,1.651],[0.121,0.188,0.081],[0.047,0.042,0.072],[0.091,0.051,0.06],[0.227,0.208,0.16],[0.05,0.03,0.026],[0.027,0.061,0.037],[0.021,0.017,0.051]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.96GB.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)","date":"2023-09-03","machine":"dev","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","managed","gcp"],"load_time":573.697,"data_size":9944356651,"result":[[0.002,0.003,0.002],[0.11,0.884,0.363],[0.307,0.166,0.245],[0.624,0.485,0.275],[1.616,1.292,1.614],[2.591,2.192,2.484],[0.139,0.069,0.516],[0.105,0.037,0.102],[1.507,2.259,1.592],[2.481,1.774,1.806],[0.559,0.777,0.697],[0.681,0.57,0.92],[1.818,1.888,1.738],[3.266,3.113,4.488],[2.576,2.658,3.535],[1.551,1.555,1.926],[7.342,7.817,6.89],[5.789,6.373,4.137],[28.36,17.62,27.891],[0.06,0.053,0.44],[2.887,5.945,5],[3.713,6.44,3.736],[7.915,4.291,4.111],[11.21,27.281,19.303],[0.896,1.808,1.61],[0.631,1.026,1.015],[1.705,0.942,0.967],[2.979,2.904,5.303],[51.146,50.49,50.144],[2.103,1.933,3.405],[2.998,1.414,2.24],[2.496,3.989,2.741],[23.552,22.336,13.822],[14.086,12.553,19.012],[19.032,12.498,12.244],[3.916,3.466,3.089],[0.215,0.081,0.079],[0.091,0.236,0.041],[0.18,0.046,0.048],[0.378,0.158,0.266],[0.06,0.032,0.182],[0.049,0.132,0.04],[0.025,0.218,0.032]],"source":"clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.dev.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (data lake, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[1.578,0.756,0.793],[2.768,2.082,1.039],[2.57,1.545,1.429],[3.179,1.613,1.137],[1.451,1.401,1.397],[1.707,1.79,1.503],[1.242,0.919,0.961],[0.843,0.929,0.889],[1.44,1.446,1.716],[2.142,2.037,2.654],[1.861,1.528,1.514],[1.616,1.926,1.833],[1.608,1.59,1.669],[2.426,2.573,2.161],[1.645,1.691,1.775],[1.495,1.347,1.63],[3.611,3.167,3.792],[2.648,2.548,2.454],[6.087,5.603,5.713],[1.038,0.719,1.005],[6.092,4.233,3.468],[4.082,4.177,3.945],[6.882,6.795,6.887],[21.255,21.006,21.191],[2.177,1.611,1.773],[1.307,1.213,1.2],[1.94,2.241,1.678],[3.51,3.507,3.526],[10.886,10.748,10.761],[1.18,1.299,1.294],[2.168,2.11,2.026],[3.262,3.06,3.524],[6.162,6.043,6.159],[5.715,5.717,5.722],[5.651,5.696,5.72],[1.915,1.676,1.713],[0.538,0.499,0.472],[0.401,0.448,0.429],[0.399,0.412,0.419],[0.651,0.661,0.647],[0.345,0.365,0.389],[0.372,0.311,0.37],[0.287,0.339,0.306]],"source":"clickhouse-datalake/results/c6a.4xlarge.partitioned.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (data lake, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.276,0.179,0.17],[0.321,0.381,0.292],[0.409,0.415,0.373],[0.384,0.325,0.365],[0.575,0.689,0.749],[0.716,0.69,0.809],[0.363,0.3,0.381],[0.286,0.28,0.355],[0.87,0.672,0.715],[0.871,0.904,1.062],[0.542,0.649,0.605],[0.623,0.623,0.686],[0.752,0.711,0.745],[0.938,0.89,1.002],[0.737,0.825,0.712],[0.629,0.619,0.804],[1.358,1.2,1.299],[1.107,1.113,1.111],[2.082,1.924,2.251],[0.36,0.336,0.381],[2.153,2.042,1.962],[2.441,2.152,2.2],[2.949,3.08,3.299],[8.931,7.83,7.971],[0.749,0.732,0.607],[0.504,0.401,0.49],[0.719,0.654,0.558],[2.19,2.242,2.221],[3.082,2.668,2.535],[0.957,0.79,0.918],[0.954,0.948,0.928],[1.656,1.556,1.186],[2.396,2.381,2.305],[2.929,2.936,3.149],[2.908,2.996,2.92],[0.84,0.824,0.825],[0.546,0.552,0.586],[0.407,0.358,0.36],[0.485,0.524,0.534],[0.701,0.738,0.693],[0.347,0.425,0.355],[0.357,0.362,0.381],[0.293,0.329,0.316]],"source":"clickhouse-datalake/results/c6a.metal.partitioned.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.033,0.042,0.031],[0.127,0.104,0.073],[0.368,0.146,0.131],[1.094,0.132,0.13],[1.264,0.441,0.439],[1.07,0.651,0.618],[0.125,0.111,0.11],[0.122,0.089,0.08],[0.937,0.589,0.585],[1.558,0.702,0.692],[0.771,0.311,0.318],[0.994,0.345,0.328],[1.286,0.76,0.752],[2.628,1.026,1.019],[1.299,0.891,0.893],[0.756,0.613,0.614],[3.099,1.935,1.941],[2.399,1.206,1.203],[6.018,4.231,4.22],[0.256,0.132,0.107],[10.236,1.693,1.763],[11.338,2.156,2.159],[22.178,5.051,5.063],[56.387,17.017,17.051],[2.802,0.454,0.467],[0.933,0.344,0.327],[2.945,0.456,0.424],[9.856,1.971,1.982],[9.751,9.425,9.424],[1.298,1.306,1.288],[2.781,0.686,0.693],[6.547,1.141,1.116],[7.078,4.471,4.375],[10.905,4.451,4.421],[10.964,4.434,4.427],[1.111,1.031,1.043],[0.247,0.149,0.151],[0.137,0.094,0.101],[0.169,0.092,0.101],[0.339,0.258,0.254],[0.134,0.069,0.082],[0.08,0.068,0.077],[0.079,0.065,0.062]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.4xlarge.partitioned.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.1,0.053,0.052],[0.228,0.205,0.202],[0.272,0.204,0.203],[0.385,0.231,0.229],[0.924,0.535,0.52],[0.88,0.769,0.755],[0.228,0.196,0.193],[0.248,0.207,0.21],[0.794,0.701,0.715],[1.319,0.819,0.788],[0.611,0.377,0.386],[0.702,0.422,0.422],[1.011,0.878,0.881],[2.354,1.183,1.153],[1.13,1.008,0.991],[0.754,0.698,0.666],[2.891,2.118,2.131],[2.154,1.399,1.373],[5.762,4.453,4.365],[0.349,0.219,0.21],[9.93,1.798,1.822],[11.35,2.18,2.184],[22.261,5.045,4.926],[56.815,16.303,15.993],[2.62,0.585,0.53],[0.808,0.423,0.423],[2.611,0.582,0.552],[9.79,1.997,1.927],[9.455,9.065,9.017],[1.464,1.369,1.391],[2.477,0.727,0.719],[6.131,1.18,1.166],[6.762,4.486,4.452],[10.905,4.466,4.384],[11.088,4.435,4.379],[1.212,1.1,1.104],[0.267,0.139,0.143],[0.171,0.121,0.116],[0.196,0.128,0.127],[0.325,0.192,0.19],[0.13,0.089,0.094],[0.108,0.089,0.084],[0.129,0.084,0.084]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.4xlarge.single.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.122,0.101,0.108],[0.144,0.13,0.14],[0.309,0.207,0.183],[1.01,0.212,0.187],[1.156,0.433,0.345],[1.162,0.474,0.468],[0.172,0.184,0.154],[0.153,0.137,0.131],[1.049,0.557,0.469],[1.66,0.531,0.578],[0.847,0.258,0.282],[1.143,0.281,0.289],[1.288,0.515,0.485],[2.576,0.562,0.579],[1.214,0.57,0.529],[0.69,0.434,0.401],[2.758,0.871,0.803],[2.598,0.691,0.741],[4.918,1.693,1.594],[0.29,0.165,0.158],[10.372,0.626,0.595],[11.779,0.84,0.793],[22.453,1.705,1.358],[57.223,5.525,5.151],[2.881,0.319,0.293],[1.101,0.241,0.298],[3.186,0.31,0.338],[10.18,0.774,0.714],[8.806,2.291,2.319],[0.793,0.576,0.806],[2.855,0.438,0.454],[6.529,0.598,0.587],[5.535,1.687,1.852],[10.397,1.626,1.744],[10.388,1.614,1.705],[0.52,0.593,0.545],[0.231,0.178,0.207],[0.189,0.117,0.179],[0.168,0.172,0.16],[0.391,0.304,0.284],[0.182,0.15,0.123],[0.14,0.113,0.13],[0.133,0.13,0.125]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.metal.partitioned.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.129,0.059,0.06],[0.217,0.199,0.192],[0.268,0.243,0.34],[0.451,0.237,0.251],[0.918,0.448,0.436],[0.994,0.478,0.447],[0.226,0.201,0.195],[0.254,0.242,0.243],[0.915,0.576,0.576],[1.433,0.587,0.621],[0.711,0.454,0.403],[0.802,0.369,0.379],[0.984,0.562,0.526],[2.359,0.618,0.604],[1.077,0.528,0.523],[0.549,0.464,0.514],[2.457,0.831,0.868],[2.334,0.829,0.724],[4.502,1.588,1.608],[0.331,0.243,0.253],[10.218,0.736,0.699],[11.692,1.05,0.839],[22.713,1.567,1.627],[57.945,5.061,4.701],[2.733,0.401,0.382],[0.906,0.316,0.291],[2.843,0.399,0.373],[10.111,0.688,0.695],[8.424,1.512,1.516],[0.807,0.805,0.815],[2.55,0.454,0.446],[6.148,0.602,0.627],[4.98,1.642,1.649],[10.361,1.502,1.471],[10.328,1.461,1.444],[0.686,0.636,0.641],[0.309,0.227,0.216],[0.184,0.136,0.137],[0.193,0.139,0.143],[0.343,0.254,0.224],[0.158,0.107,0.101],[0.134,0.103,0.098],[0.13,0.095,0.095]],"source":"clickhouse-parquet/results/c6a.metal.single.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (web)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c5n.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","serverless","stateless"],"load_time":0.33,"data_size":14557009492,"result":[[0.003,0.002,0.002],[0.723,0.012,0.01],[1.157,0.032,0.029],[1.479,0.046,0.043],[0.926,0.321,0.323],[2.747,0.548,0.553],[0.251,0.019,0.018],[0.096,0.019,0.016],[1.461,0.564,0.572],[1.111,0.616,0.6],[1.107,0.222,0.217],[0.941,0.252,0.238],[1.527,0.58,0.588],[1.583,0.832,0.838],[1.855,0.733,0.683],[0.895,0.404,0.397],[2.682,1.597,1.59],[1.796,1.004,1.026],[4.569,3.061,3.133],[0.648,0.029,0.029],[3.691,0.793,0.758],[4.088,0.923,0.928],[5.969,1.173,1.158],[16.028,3.13,3.082],[1.281,0.294,0.287],[0.92,0.237,0.214],[1.223,0.296,0.289],[3.675,0.826,0.838],[13.169,11.735,11.817],[1.332,1.225,1.246],[1.841,0.528,0.518],[3.059,0.744,0.711],[3.953,2.726,2.893],[4.984,2.735,2.685],[5.345,2.706,2.706],[1.773,0.958,0.944],[0.361,0.082,0.068],[0.25,0.035,0.033],[0.491,0.03,0.037],[0.46,0.138,0.131],[0.32,0.016,0.016],[0.273,0.018,0.017],[0.223,0.013,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse-web/results/c5n.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (web)","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative","serverless","stateless"],"load_time":0.33,"data_size":14557009492,"result":[[0.097,0.003,0.003],[0.074,0.012,0.012],[0.175,0.022,0.022],[0.236,0.022,0.022],[0.29,0.204,0.184],[0.821,0.2,0.193],[0.085,0.015,0.017],[0.085,0.026,0.025],[0.424,0.251,0.248],[0.48,0.264,0.274],[0.363,0.098,0.098],[0.29,0.086,0.09],[0.665,0.189,0.186],[0.601,0.251,0.245],[0.753,0.225,0.227],[0.241,0.116,0.115],[0.733,0.356,0.349],[0.942,0.268,0.254],[1.379,0.633,0.626],[0.454,0.019,0.021],[4.154,0.259,0.236],[2.204,0.196,0.183],[3.137,0.33,0.294],[10.038,1.126,1.108],[0.666,0.127,0.086],[0.534,0.078,0.078],[1.267,0.148,0.124],[1.435,0.33,0.311],[2.385,1.394,1.381],[0.435,0.403,0.4],[0.787,0.149,0.14],[1.259,0.224,0.213],[1.435,0.794,0.788],[2.148,0.786,0.652],[2.029,0.677,0.655],[0.348,0.17,0.168],[0.514,0.053,0.066],[0.238,0.036,0.038],[0.381,0.036,0.037],[0.426,0.127,0.127],[0.291,0.029,0.026],[0.248,0.025,0.029],[0.283,0.014,0.017]],"source":"clickhouse-web/results/c6a.metal.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2022-11-18","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":504.026,"data_size":14580183513,"result":[[0.002,0.001,0.001],[0.019,0.013,0.011],[0.048,0.027,0.026],[0.432,0.036,0.034],[0.682,0.32,0.318],[0.654,0.512,0.538],[0.028,0.021,0.02],[0.02,0.019,0.015],[0.612,0.555,0.555],[0.87,0.619,0.612],[0.247,0.196,0.208],[0.263,0.229,0.208],[0.603,0.516,0.495],[1.401,0.786,0.787],[0.703,0.65,0.628],[0.547,0.498,0.511],[1.842,1.864,1.807],[1.23,1.103,1.113],[4.878,3.224,3.189],[0.205,0.029,0.016],[9.28,0.801,0.762],[9.827,0.864,0.847],[18.726,1.679,1.696],[42.181,2.599,2.51],[1.772,0.216,0.216],[0.647,0.163,0.158],[2.237,0.231,0.214],[8.837,0.783,0.768],[10.93,10.699,10.662],[1.224,1.224,1.202],[1.422,0.421,0.427],[4.382,0.52,0.511],[4.434,2.888,2.947],[9.39,2.65,2.65],[9.339,2.662,2.658],[1.024,0.915,0.964],[0.128,0.095,0.094],[0.056,0.04,0.043],[0.061,0.036,0.036],[0.239,0.182,0.197],[0.039,0.019,0.02],[0.025,0.013,0.017],[0.02,0.014,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (tuned)","date":"2022-11-18","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":504.026,"data_size":14580183513,"result":[[0.002,0.001,0.001],[0.02,0.01,0.01],[0.046,0.035,0.025],[0.115,0.032,0.031],[0.365,0.299,0.3],[0.531,0.444,0.431],[0.042,0.019,0.018],[0.019,0.014,0.014],[0.745,0.641,0.607],[0.634,0.593,0.577],[0.211,0.176,0.169],[0.226,0.19,0.188],[0.637,0.483,0.482],[1.343,0.755,0.733],[0.658,0.577,0.576],[0.531,0.5,0.521],[1.861,1.679,1.66],[1.136,0.698,0.676],[4.071,3.124,3.121],[0.069,0.022,0.014],[8.678,0.77,0.755],[9.854,0.881,0.867],[16.218,1.344,1.325],[13.598,1.244,1.22],[1.773,0.216,0.21],[0.662,0.159,0.16],[2.247,0.22,0.213],[8.837,0.782,0.752],[7.061,1.026,1.063],[1.346,1.223,1.245],[1.375,0.375,0.42],[4.419,0.521,0.503],[4.457,2.88,2.944],[9.361,2.718,2.64],[9.405,2.614,2.616],[0.998,0.923,0.98],[0.119,0.093,0.097],[0.053,0.043,0.043],[0.055,0.04,0.041],[0.257,0.203,0.219],[0.044,0.02,0.019],[0.029,0.014,0.013],[0.025,0.013,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c5.4xlarge.tuned.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":470.639,"data_size":14472294250,"result":[[0.005,0.002,0.001],[0.052,0.007,0.007],[0.052,0.019,0.019],[0.435,0.029,0.026],[0.914,0.356,0.35],[0.831,0.456,0.449],[0.022,0.022,0.019],[0.049,0.013,0.012],[0.602,0.497,0.489],[0.906,0.546,0.533],[0.2,0.128,0.133],[0.639,0.15,0.151],[1.368,0.585,0.575],[1.722,0.804,0.806],[1.115,0.656,0.641],[0.57,0.53,0.51],[2.388,1.719,1.674],[2.113,0.941,0.921],[5.165,3.43,3.407],[0.348,0.027,0.018],[9.892,0.576,0.556],[10.577,0.67,0.653],[12.949,1.087,1.072],[37.277,2.46,2.428],[2.05,0.174,0.173],[1.132,0.147,0.147],[2.604,0.166,0.165],[9.524,0.652,0.637],[9.399,8.993,8.931],[2.462,2.451,2.456],[1.754,0.462,0.452],[4.614,0.623,0.635],[5.449,3.831,4.013],[11.139,3.306,3.284],[11.103,3.33,3.308],[1.054,0.972,0.989],[0.093,0.055,0.065],[0.037,0.025,0.026],[0.044,0.022,0.021],[0.16,0.114,0.104],[0.036,0.015,0.014],[0.022,0.012,0.01],[0.017,0.012,0.01]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (tuned)","date":"2022-11-18","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":506.939,"data_size":15117484912,"result":[[0.001,0.001,0.001],[0.054,0.011,0.01],[0.046,0.021,0.02],[0.094,0.027,0.026],[0.453,0.331,0.331],[0.562,0.469,0.465],[0.028,0.018,0.018],[0.018,0.013,0.012],[0.778,0.872,0.868],[0.602,0.528,0.516],[0.176,0.339,0.285],[0.302,0.234,0.213],[0.61,0.549,0.521],[1.476,0.761,0.762],[0.711,0.563,0.571],[0.604,0.63,0.617],[1.92,1.851,1.836],[1.119,0.529,0.524],[4.461,3.293,3.297],[0.055,0.018,0.013],[8.747,0.673,0.675],[9.854,0.752,0.739],[16.229,1.519,1.528],[13.744,1.227,1.196],[1.776,0.158,0.165],[0.837,0.132,0.131],[2.352,0.161,0.156],[9.004,0.812,0.79],[7.094,1.113,1.107],[2.597,2.512,2.457],[1.402,0.388,0.395],[4.447,0.605,0.597],[5.316,4.105,4.14],[9.772,3.251,3.27],[9.767,3.278,3.15],[0.988,0.843,0.953],[0.217,0.135,0.145],[0.062,0.051,0.055],[0.069,0.04,0.047],[0.236,0.16,0.158],[0.034,0.016,0.015],[0.022,0.013,0.013],[0.023,0.011,0.014]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.4xlarge.tuned.json"} +,{"hide":true,"system":"ClickHouse (zstd)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":417.533,"data_size":9997826232,"result":[[0.004,0.002,0.001],[0.069,0.017,0.016],[0.073,0.051,0.048],[0.158,0.067,0.066],[1.603,1.545,1.709],[1.225,1.105,1.1],[0.033,0.026,0.024],[0.023,0.021,0.02],[0.71,0.621,0.614],[0.813,0.715,0.713],[0.292,0.231,0.245],[0.35,0.269,0.271],[0.785,0.692,0.704],[1.209,1.044,1.066],[1.034,0.908,0.897],[0.993,0.94,0.909],[2.818,2.595,2.611],[1.804,1.717,1.711],[4.846,4.692,4.714],[0.081,0.025,0.02],[5.511,1.388,1.385],[6.304,1.306,1.293],[11.938,2.406,2.4],[30.031,4.268,4.242],[0.964,0.337,0.335],[0.326,0.264,0.26],[0.997,0.338,0.338],[5.523,1.148,1.14],[7.319,5.744,5.796],[2.235,2.236,2.199],[0.86,0.66,0.664],[3.695,0.772,0.764],[5.044,4.82,4.821],[6.786,4.133,4.093],[6.769,4.11,4.17],[1.289,1.188,1.221],[0.093,0.069,0.075],[0.037,0.033,0.029],[0.047,0.033,0.03],[0.185,0.151,0.155],[0.027,0.021,0.017],[0.02,0.012,0.015],[0.017,0.013,0.013]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.4xlarge.zstd.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-09-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":137.872,"data_size":14467272630,"result":[[0.03,0.003,0.003],[0.055,0.012,0.013],[0.048,0.02,0.02],[0.586,0.022,0.024],[0.843,0.213,0.199],[1.016,0.18,0.175],[0.024,0.018,0.018],[0.045,0.026,0.026],[0.743,0.26,0.252],[1.015,0.271,0.269],[0.383,0.09,0.093],[0.699,0.103,0.101],[1.208,0.181,0.154],[1.866,0.216,0.19],[1.193,0.194,0.175],[0.507,0.128,0.124],[2.004,0.379,0.355],[1.574,0.255,0.243],[3.505,0.657,0.608],[0.08,0.011,0.012],[9.202,0.14,0.123],[10.663,0.158,0.147],[12.847,0.236,0.206],[35.704,0.57,0.541],[1.806,0.062,0.047],[1.243,0.044,0.04],[2.699,0.06,0.05],[9.516,0.282,0.278],[7.811,1.26,1.249],[0.42,0.409,0.4],[1.443,0.113,0.11],[5.026,0.183,0.153],[4.271,1.126,0.728],[9.322,0.801,0.714],[9.09,0.737,0.676],[0.226,0.187,0.184],[0.088,0.06,0.064],[0.046,0.032,0.034],[0.055,0.025,0.028],[0.189,0.148,0.128],[0.04,0.033,0.017],[0.028,0.018,0.019],[0.024,0.017,0.023]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.metal.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (tuned)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":136.869,"data_size":14571706777,"result":[[0.003,0.001,0.001],[0.046,0.051,0.035],[0.044,0.039,0.04],[0.074,0.025,0.036],[0.231,0.097,0.089],[0.97,0.123,0.12],[0.017,0.018,0.019],[0.03,0.029,0.023],[0.18,0.153,0.137],[0.946,0.269,0.283],[0.116,0.062,0.06],[0.195,0.056,0.059],[1.026,0.158,0.137],[1.575,0.188,0.176],[0.837,0.153,0.161],[0.192,0.122,0.123],[1.767,0.34,0.324],[1.088,0.098,0.098],[3.413,0.891,0.787],[0.039,0.021,0.012],[9.017,0.292,0.258],[10.048,0.286,0.251],[20.084,0.454,0.445],[39.564,0.718,0.741],[1.762,0.056,0.046],[0.894,0.035,0.043],[2.421,0.061,0.047],[10.479,0.447,0.439],[7.089,0.282,0.27],[0.429,0.384,0.395],[1.284,0.093,0.091],[4.753,0.183,0.159],[3.618,1.03,0.714],[8.792,0.636,0.623],[8.765,0.626,0.603],[0.213,0.195,0.206],[0.103,0.074,0.067],[0.047,0.035,0.034],[0.053,0.035,0.033],[0.198,0.166,0.142],[0.035,0.026,0.019],[0.027,0.019,0.027],[0.027,0.014,0.016]],"source":"clickhouse/results/c6a.metal.tuned.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-03-14","machine":"m5d.24xlarge","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":457.716,"data_size":14577617512,"result":[[0.016,0.001,0.001],[0.084,0.011,0.01],[0.051,0.018,0.019],[0.168,0.021,0.021],[0.581,0.189,0.193],[0.652,0.244,0.233],[0.02,0.015,0.015],[0.027,0.023,0.025],[0.491,0.376,0.381],[0.64,0.406,0.401],[0.225,0.134,0.132],[0.25,0.144,0.144],[0.508,0.235,0.214],[1.375,0.316,0.301],[0.561,0.233,0.226],[0.28,0.189,0.186],[1.576,0.69,0.655],[1.194,0.369,0.372],[3.253,1.21,1.14],[0.102,0.029,0.023],[8.583,0.424,0.323],[9.837,0.381,0.369],[18.744,0.846,0.718],[42.086,1.119,1.112],[1.771,0.171,0.114],[0.673,0.085,0.083],[2.287,0.136,0.126],[8.892,0.405,0.361],[7.333,2.971,3.049],[0.801,0.756,0.774],[1.339,0.202,0.197],[4.481,0.278,0.256],[3.866,1.649,1.634],[9.055,1.189,1.105],[8.955,1.259,1.044],[0.396,0.362,0.344],[0.136,0.103,0.113],[0.066,0.046,0.046],[0.097,0.041,0.056],[0.274,0.248,0.208],[0.047,0.024,0.023],[0.026,0.02,0.023],[0.037,0.022,0.039]],"source":"clickhouse/results/m5d.24xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse (zstd)","date":"2023-03-14","machine":"m5d.24xlarge","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":394.198,"data_size":9997207883,"result":[[0.002,0.002,0.001],[0.042,0.039,0.03],[0.051,0.028,0.027],[0.14,0.029,0.035],[0.248,0.191,0.185],[0.296,0.247,0.251],[0.018,0.017,0.019],[0.025,0.023,0.024],[0.427,0.398,0.384],[0.464,0.412,0.404],[0.221,0.143,0.152],[0.236,0.164,0.156],[0.306,0.236,0.233],[0.702,0.352,0.349],[0.329,0.266,0.321],[0.264,0.219,0.2],[0.881,0.639,0.652],[0.646,0.394,0.36],[2.279,1.23,1.151],[0.087,0.036,0.015],[5.403,0.403,0.377],[6.292,0.475,0.434],[11.918,0.845,0.768],[29.658,1.359,1.268],[0.959,0.13,0.14],[0.321,0.092,0.104],[1.455,0.128,0.119],[5.854,0.428,0.425],[5.267,2.886,2.715],[0.793,0.773,0.767],[0.576,0.212,0.21],[3.811,0.363,0.276],[3.577,1.568,1.64],[5.892,1.272,1.187],[5.825,1.26,1.307],[0.43,0.42,0.37],[0.098,0.109,0.087],[0.044,0.046,0.048],[0.087,0.05,0.042],[0.249,0.201,0.189],[0.049,0.033,0.029],[0.031,0.025,0.014],[0.032,0.021,0.021]],"source":"clickhouse/results/m5d.24xlarge.zstd.json"} +,{"system":"ClickHouse","date":"2023-06-09","machine":"m6i.32xlarge","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":457.716,"data_size":14577617512,"result":[[0.03,0.005,0.005],[0.043,0.013,0.017],[0.056,0.018,0.016],[0.563,0.017,0.015],[0.725,0.184,0.152],[1.038,0.197,0.205],[0.02,0.022,0.016],[0.04,0.026,0.025],[0.541,0.316,0.313],[0.882,0.342,0.331],[0.187,0.108,0.1],[0.544,0.11,0.13],[1.085,0.194,0.195],[1.765,0.299,0.226],[0.961,0.212,0.183],[0.392,0.147,0.164],[1.971,0.522,0.452],[1.322,0.31,0.288],[3.522,0.851,0.864],[0.063,0.019,0.017],[9.149,0.299,0.245],[10.334,0.242,0.269],[19.542,0.553,0.488],[35.625,0.827,0.766],[1.814,0.176,0.137],[1.165,0.089,0.084],[2.569,0.117,0.065],[9.402,0.315,0.226],[7.811,3.556,1.758],[0.476,0.441,0.437],[1.513,0.161,0.197],[4.901,0.25,0.173],[4.006,1.059,1.004],[9.185,1.026,0.808],[9.369,0.786,0.788],[0.354,0.284,0.301],[0.124,0.069,0.065],[0.051,0.036,0.041],[0.085,0.038,0.032],[0.21,0.142,0.143],[0.04,0.033,0.024],[0.022,0.02,0.024],[0.027,0.022,0.018]],"source":"clickhouse/results/m6i.32xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"CrateDB","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"For some queries it gives \"Data too large\".","tags":["Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":10687,"data_size":109636633416,"result":[[0.008162,0.005118,0.002553],[0.350014,0.39977,0.133775],[2.58426,2.47192,2.59779],[2.12939,0.532981,0.507246],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[1.18488,1.06603,1.07219],[0.209264,0.073284,0.067912],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[1.68892,1.2866,1.47428],[1.62976,1.43073,1.26904],[12.7517,13.0334,13.2685],[18.8587,null,18.6951],[11.2982,11.2108,11.577],[20.2964,20.4035,19.1076],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[0.202044,0.010009,0.005566],[9.22964,4.54606,0.774149],[1.41673,1.09885,0.789775],[12.3933,8.06911,1.69671],[1.45018,0.969528,0.979718],[0.357589,0.14887,0.153326],[0.189282,0.133963,0.130279],[0.153222,0.140756,0.139861],[27.5195,19.6862,20.1825],[72.7575,68.2,67.1238],[144.533,146.579,152.144],[8.76866,9.00563,8.46917],[17.6652,16.6755,16.0558],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[42.2967,44.9621,44.4386],[0.786911,0.4904,0.508416],[0.602075,0.226261,0.182399],[0.131407,0.058958,0.054518],[0.954736,1.1361,1.14233],[0.23764,0.139109,0.134472],[0.110253,0.057695,0.056073],[0.124285,0.150479,0.066226]],"source":"cratedb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":368,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002554,0.002257,0.002058],[0.041885,0.026659,0.026301],[0.377386,0.047169,0.046246],[1.111276,0.043512,0.042424],[1.337056,0.378329,0.378000],[1.517051,0.516229,0.513954],[0.040641,0.024230,0.025701],[0.048797,0.029641,0.028597],[1.695267,0.591075,0.582311],[2.821410,0.663166,0.666039],[1.407029,0.255046,0.253865],[1.971179,0.258693,0.254872],[1.548181,0.639874,0.637980],[3.217226,1.045900,1.038888],[1.861833,0.815691,0.806401],[0.768044,0.530842,0.528053],[3.639183,2.567878,2.556752],[2.787874,1.658994,1.674600],[7.466028,4.180932,4.241429],[0.006217,0.003521,0.013345],[10.689073,0.562040,0.551567],[12.984685,0.686805,0.676753],[23.748547,1.311328,1.267505],[6.763271,0.285252,0.273009],[0.132152,0.028291,0.028296],[1.943504,0.226601,0.224721],[0.326737,0.029324,0.027575],[11.538898,0.516586,0.502331],[9.223633,6.920732,6.945943],[0.153429,0.074415,0.073831],[5.458251,0.556813,0.550952],[7.330739,0.895601,0.866605],[7.677006,4.602414,4.704338],[11.838616,2.964448,3.080231],[11.848512,2.947774,3.029332],[0.578680,0.525259,0.491508],[0.086986,0.062111,0.062906],[0.065790,0.032106,0.031138],[0.030254,0.016060,0.017036],[0.124381,0.093671,0.095871],[0.029603,0.019117,0.022236],[0.019694,0.010848,0.016053],[0.019806,0.010239,0.010112]],"source":"databend/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":357,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002354,0.001796,0.001676],[0.035410,0.019995,0.020233],[0.387346,0.031738,0.031385],[1.137630,0.030899,0.030119],[1.405919,0.423186,0.423155],[1.562987,0.578546,0.580928],[0.032613,0.014625,0.014217],[0.032749,0.022130,0.022904],[1.735342,0.533320,0.524569],[2.804289,0.599192,0.595315],[1.369841,0.175470,0.186941],[2.092200,0.181471,0.181655],[1.750355,0.683891,0.677640],[3.213623,1.051686,1.047710],[1.881785,0.830412,0.813682],[0.813736,0.602403,0.591426],[3.880537,2.488562,2.480400],[2.782833,1.367600,1.344967],[7.815274,4.236312,4.263853],[0.006507,0.003202,0.003167],[10.674944,0.451903,0.438830],[12.984352,0.543479,0.531805],[23.749905,1.028132,1.006847],[6.267209,0.208050,0.194846],[0.273405,0.027663,0.027727],[1.813349,0.183311,0.180188],[0.441909,0.027818,0.027427],[11.556500,0.410411,0.397217],[11.878248,11.803086,11.842988],[0.147288,0.058588,0.056877],[5.500723,0.496444,0.488228],[7.438851,0.982329,0.974780],[8.228235,5.575889,5.488849],[12.279272,3.426230,3.439635],[12.288545,3.465759,3.472598],[0.629652,0.542064,0.549532],[0.068277,0.055286,0.062397],[0.028899,0.023338,0.026963],[0.024785,0.016914,0.014623],[0.094073,0.082865,0.088973],[0.024245,0.013744,0.017487],[0.018292,0.009779,0.008906],[0.018714,0.009268,0.009275]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":70,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.073969,0.002969,0.002275],[0.289053,0.014500,0.013984],[0.597566,0.020848,0.022175],[1.241144,0.019701,0.019218],[1.407042,0.266073,0.245832],[1.707674,0.265472,0.272181],[0.037721,0.015296,0.014786],[0.044271,0.019238,0.018279],[1.814285,0.292480,0.287474],[3.034563,0.304214,0.310720],[1.634329,0.286281,0.299248],[1.937083,0.177104,0.188476],[1.529240,0.289840,0.289497],[3.075821,0.461813,0.428307],[1.708843,0.272060,0.275821],[0.832040,0.234342,0.218837],[3.085068,0.494668,0.480146],[2.891979,0.477079,0.457178],[6.122974,0.690913,0.634832],[0.186429,0.004711,0.003940],[10.868874,0.099969,0.086985],[13.480312,0.111980,0.103360],[24.405612,0.431874,0.440055],[10.061871,0.232500,0.242135],[0.647733,0.046068,0.039222],[2.100647,0.046711,0.043591],[1.391526,0.041194,0.039617],[11.536597,0.093705,0.088706],[9.839564,1.566094,1.591600],[0.162430,0.049029,0.049039],[5.631392,0.263430,0.225562],[7.261623,0.304319,0.279184],[5.646363,1.067710,0.910199],[11.173620,0.789665,0.684581],[11.251824,0.766817,0.682614],[0.663092,0.261053,0.272992],[0.400790,0.083889,0.091102],[0.073341,0.021988,0.028371],[0.091126,0.019851,0.013461],[0.151101,0.058686,0.058112],[0.281109,0.016812,0.014878],[0.398818,0.015711,0.022669],[0.222298,0.011058,0.014887]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.metal.json"} +,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":368,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002554,0.002257,0.002058],[0.041885,0.026659,0.026301],[0.377386,0.047169,0.046246],[1.111276,0.043512,0.042424],[1.337056,0.378329,0.378],[1.517051,0.516229,0.513954],[0.040641,0.02423,0.025701],[0.048797,0.029641,0.028597],[1.695267,0.591075,0.582311],[2.82141,0.663166,0.666039],[1.407029,0.255046,0.253865],[1.971179,0.258693,0.254872],[1.548181,0.639874,0.63798],[3.217226,1.0459,1.038888],[1.861833,0.815691,0.806401],[0.768044,0.530842,0.528053],[3.639183,2.567878,2.556752],[2.787874,1.658994,1.6746],[7.466028,4.180932,4.241429],[0.006217,0.003521,0.013345],[10.689073,0.56204,0.551567],[12.984685,0.686805,0.676753],[23.748547,1.311328,1.267505],[6.763271,0.285252,0.273009],[0.132152,0.028291,0.028296],[1.943504,0.226601,0.224721],[0.326737,0.029324,0.027575],[11.538898,0.516586,0.502331],[9.223633,6.920732,6.945943],[0.153429,0.074415,0.073831],[5.458251,0.556813,0.550952],[7.330739,0.895601,0.866605],[7.677006,4.602414,4.704338],[11.838616,2.964448,3.080231],[11.848512,2.947774,3.029332],[0.57868,0.525259,0.491508],[0.086986,0.062111,0.062906],[0.06579,0.032106,0.031138],[0.030254,0.01606,0.017036],[0.124381,0.093671,0.095871],[0.029603,0.019117,0.022236],[0.019694,0.010848,0.016053],[0.019806,0.010239,0.010112]],"source":"databend/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":357,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002354,0.001796,0.001676],[0.03541,0.019995,0.020233],[0.387346,0.031738,0.031385],[1.13763,0.030899,0.030119],[1.405919,0.423186,0.423155],[1.562987,0.578546,0.580928],[0.032613,0.014625,0.014217],[0.032749,0.02213,0.022904],[1.735342,0.53332,0.524569],[2.804289,0.599192,0.595315],[1.369841,0.17547,0.186941],[2.0922,0.181471,0.181655],[1.750355,0.683891,0.67764],[3.213623,1.051686,1.04771],[1.881785,0.830412,0.813682],[0.813736,0.602403,0.591426],[3.880537,2.488562,2.4804],[2.782833,1.3676,1.344967],[7.815274,4.236312,4.263853],[0.006507,0.003202,0.003167],[10.674944,0.451903,0.43883],[12.984352,0.543479,0.531805],[23.749905,1.028132,1.006847],[6.267209,0.20805,0.194846],[0.273405,0.027663,0.027727],[1.813349,0.183311,0.180188],[0.441909,0.027818,0.027427],[11.5565,0.410411,0.397217],[11.878248,11.803086,11.842988],[0.147288,0.058588,0.056877],[5.500723,0.496444,0.488228],[7.438851,0.982329,0.97478],[8.228235,5.575889,5.488849],[12.279272,3.42623,3.439635],[12.288545,3.465759,3.472598],[0.629652,0.542064,0.549532],[0.068277,0.055286,0.062397],[0.028899,0.023338,0.026963],[0.024785,0.016914,0.014623],[0.094073,0.082865,0.088973],[0.024245,0.013744,0.017487],[0.018292,0.009779,0.008906],[0.018714,0.009268,0.009275]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":70,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.073969,0.002969,0.002275],[0.289053,0.0145,0.013984],[0.597566,0.020848,0.022175],[1.241144,0.019701,0.019218],[1.407042,0.266073,0.245832],[1.707674,0.265472,0.272181],[0.037721,0.015296,0.014786],[0.044271,0.019238,0.018279],[1.814285,0.29248,0.287474],[3.034563,0.304214,0.31072],[1.634329,0.286281,0.299248],[1.937083,0.177104,0.188476],[1.52924,0.28984,0.289497],[3.075821,0.461813,0.428307],[1.708843,0.27206,0.275821],[0.83204,0.234342,0.218837],[3.085068,0.494668,0.480146],[2.891979,0.477079,0.457178],[6.122974,0.690913,0.634832],[0.186429,0.004711,0.00394],[10.868874,0.099969,0.086985],[13.480312,0.11198,0.10336],[24.405612,0.431874,0.440055],[10.061871,0.2325,0.242135],[0.647733,0.046068,0.039222],[2.100647,0.046711,0.043591],[1.391526,0.041194,0.039617],[11.536597,0.093705,0.088706],[9.839564,1.566094,1.5916],[0.16243,0.049029,0.049039],[5.631392,0.26343,0.225562],[7.261623,0.304319,0.279184],[5.646363,1.06771,0.910199],[11.17362,0.789665,0.684581],[11.251824,0.766817,0.682614],[0.663092,0.261053,0.272992],[0.40079,0.083889,0.091102],[0.073341,0.021988,0.028371],[0.091126,0.019851,0.013461],[0.151101,0.058686,0.058112],[0.281109,0.016812,0.014878],[0.398818,0.015711,0.022669],[0.222298,0.011058,0.014887]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.metal.json"} ,{"system":"DataFusion (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-07-29","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"v33.0.0 (d2efaa9)","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.068,0.045,0.046],[0.098,0.060,0.062],[0.175,0.111,0.106],[0.401,0.107,0.108],[1.011,0.812,0.815],[1.356,1.258,1.230],[0.094,0.069,0.068],[0.096,0.065,0.063],[1.548,1.432,1.459],[2.676,2.483,2.472],[0.488,0.342,0.337],[0.525,0.353,0.360],[1.350,1.246,1.244],[3.263,2.467,2.480],[1.460,1.376,1.394],[1.019,0.940,0.934],[3.053,2.688,2.713],[2.989,2.598,2.615],[6.715,5.675,5.654],[0.311,0.098,0.102],[9.910,1.566,1.577],[11.127,1.946,1.856],[21.951,4.155,4.082],[55.962,11.448,11.448],[2.450,0.555,0.576],[0.719,0.507,0.503],[2.437,0.637,0.635],[9.570,2.371,2.326],[9.068,5.013,4.951],[0.553,0.488,0.477],[2.074,1.104,1.121],[5.590,1.526,1.552],[8.068,7.646,7.726],[11.579,6.687,6.672],[11.953,7.284,7.291],[1.911,1.814,1.828],[0.440,0.311,0.322],[0.231,0.184,0.180],[0.242,0.171,0.170],[0.840,0.676,0.658],[0.153,0.094,0.098],[0.129,0.089,0.089],[0.156,0.097,0.105]],"source":"datafusion/results/single.json"} -,{"system":"Apache Doris","date":"2022-11-20","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":415,"data_size":17170564642,"result":[[0.07,0.03,0.03],[0.13,0.04,0.04],[0.11,0.04,0.03],[1.12,0.04,0.06],[1.06,1.06,1.05],[0.85,0.78,0.76],[0.01,0.02,0.02],[0.04,0.03,0.03],[0.57,0.56,0.54],[0.61,0.61,0.63],[0.16,0.11,0.11],[0.15,0.13,0.13],[0.59,0.58,0.58],[0.89,0.91,0.88],[0.79,0.77,0.77],[0.37,0.37,0.38],[1.09,1.07,1.09],[0.26,0.26,0.30],[2.10,2.02,2.04],[0.03,0.01,0.02],[10.82,1.14,1.14],[9.00,2.87,0.94],[12.17,1.29,0.98],[32.09,2.35,2.27],[1.28,0.13,0.14],[0.12,0.13,0.12],[0.14,0.15,0.14],[10.55,1.19,1.18],[10.04,9.56,9.52],[0.71,0.72,0.65],[1.84,0.44,0.42],[2.13,0.50,0.51],[3.17,3.16,3.37],[12.00,4.40,4.51],[11.83,4.46,4.27],[1.16,1.11,1.12],[0.07,0.05,0.05],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.15,0.14,0.12],[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02]],"source":"doris/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Druid","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Druid is killed and restarted after every query. Otherwise some queries make Druid degraded and results are incorrect. For example after Q13 even SELECT 1 works for 7 seconds","tags":["Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":19620,"data_size":45188608472,"result":[[0.032365,0.016716,0.016921],[0.400766,0.275591,0.271057],[0.382350,0.152084,0.151652],[1.379492,0.137201,0.128902],[3.278731,2.527105,2.515128],[8.576382,6.546540,6.503001],[null,null,null],[0.563852,0.273795,0.275086],[11.509993,10.636571,10.597993],[13.357647,12.421210,12.337247],[1.636875,0.821300,0.900056],[1.692544,0.512066,0.440511],[2.453274,1.769806,1.807207],[8.503408,7.261406,7.334872],[61.056041,59.251083,59.500549],[8.620670,8.236657,8.225380],[164.840762,null,null],[24.165797,22.308466,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[25.973369,25.597864,25.602509],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[7.805347,6.629776,6.947366],[0.257845,0.020327,0.016976],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[32.948154,31.046770,29.221959],[null,null,null],[7.230865,7.033713,6.972421],[20.546250,19.237428,19.258469],[54.065945,52.451318,52.466653],[null,null,null],[17.499267,null,null],[null,null,null],[60.478315,60.054940,60.458946],[1.698088,1.490317,1.461969],[1.409572,0.939003,0.907252],[0.866729,0.329539,0.287435],[null,null,null],[0.932473,0.420781,0.359095],[0.723142,0.325300,0.296865],[0.603483,0.150892,0.140716]],"source":"druid/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"Apache Doris","date":"2022-11-20","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":415,"data_size":17170564642,"result":[[0.07,0.03,0.03],[0.13,0.04,0.04],[0.11,0.04,0.03],[1.12,0.04,0.06],[1.06,1.06,1.05],[0.85,0.78,0.76],[0.01,0.02,0.02],[0.04,0.03,0.03],[0.57,0.56,0.54],[0.61,0.61,0.63],[0.16,0.11,0.11],[0.15,0.13,0.13],[0.59,0.58,0.58],[0.89,0.91,0.88],[0.79,0.77,0.77],[0.37,0.37,0.38],[1.09,1.07,1.09],[0.26,0.26,0.3],[2.1,2.02,2.04],[0.03,0.01,0.02],[10.82,1.14,1.14],[9,2.87,0.94],[12.17,1.29,0.98],[32.09,2.35,2.27],[1.28,0.13,0.14],[0.12,0.13,0.12],[0.14,0.15,0.14],[10.55,1.19,1.18],[10.04,9.56,9.52],[0.71,0.72,0.65],[1.84,0.44,0.42],[2.13,0.5,0.51],[3.17,3.16,3.37],[12,4.4,4.51],[11.83,4.46,4.27],[1.16,1.11,1.12],[0.07,0.05,0.05],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.15,0.14,0.12],[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02]],"source":"doris/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"Druid","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Druid is killed and restarted after every query. Otherwise some queries make Druid degraded and results are incorrect. For example after Q13 even SELECT 1 works for 7 seconds","tags":["Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":19620,"data_size":45188608472,"result":[[0.032365,0.016716,0.016921],[0.400766,0.275591,0.271057],[0.38235,0.152084,0.151652],[1.379492,0.137201,0.128902],[3.278731,2.527105,2.515128],[8.576382,6.54654,6.503001],[null,null,null],[0.563852,0.273795,0.275086],[11.509993,10.636571,10.597993],[13.357647,12.42121,12.337247],[1.636875,0.8213,0.900056],[1.692544,0.512066,0.440511],[2.453274,1.769806,1.807207],[8.503408,7.261406,7.334872],[61.056041,59.251083,59.500549],[8.62067,8.236657,8.22538],[164.840762,null,null],[24.165797,22.308466,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[25.973369,25.597864,25.602509],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[7.805347,6.629776,6.947366],[0.257845,0.020327,0.016976],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[32.948154,31.04677,29.221959],[null,null,null],[7.230865,7.033713,6.972421],[20.54625,19.237428,19.258469],[54.065945,52.451318,52.466653],[null,null,null],[17.499267,null,null],[null,null,null],[60.478315,60.05494,60.458946],[1.698088,1.490317,1.461969],[1.409572,0.939003,0.907252],[0.866729,0.329539,0.287435],[null,null,null],[0.932473,0.420781,0.359095],[0.723142,0.3253,0.296865],[0.603483,0.150892,0.140716]],"source":"druid/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"DuckDB (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.06858791799959363,0.044711035000091215,0.042833501000131946],[0.08466665400010243,0.061327259999870876,0.06103660400003719],[0.14877448299967,0.10559172700004638,0.10446714899990184],[0.33234463500002676,0.09389112100006969,0.09252776699986498],[1.1345820209999147,0.5388421589996142,0.5428325200000472],[0.8665522809997128,0.7525683420003588,0.7726315990003059],[0.14739966299976004,0.12885476300016308,0.1280705589997524],[0.08514470599993729,0.0660608250000223,0.06364701199981937],[0.7901016199998594,0.6670942910000122,0.6656622149998839],[1.112716422000176,0.9176106790000631,0.8993262330000107],[0.4155927659999179,0.21104949600021428,0.21018879099983678],[1.0025453209996158,0.2506203090001691,0.24569647199996325],[1.2344316989997424,0.6329478739999104,0.6651636070000677],[2.456399698000041,1.0311697550000645,1.0137859460000982],[0.9334836890002407,0.6877674190000107,0.70905577800022],[0.673465615999703,0.5981919160003599,0.6082133740001154],[2.494906011999774,1.4013747280000644,1.3922408849998646],[2.375765204000345,1.324844154999937,1.3226832469999863],[4.690465237999888,2.3323504360000697,2.3752783559998534],[0.20363476300008188,0.08883917699995436,0.08691825200003223],[9.97606974700011,1.850158613000076,1.8413504770001055],[10.993020309999793,1.688866285000131,1.6903490720001173],[21.570115048999924,3.479486579999957,3.460369050999816],[55.44843658699983,11.133978315999684,11.129654930000015],[2.6089661060000253,0.48738706799986176,0.47928872500006037],[0.7135218759999589,0.3805757249997441,0.35711958900037644],[2.769580591999784,0.4973172830000294,0.4876009600002362],[9.315595299000051,1.488970874000188,1.4658663950003756],[8.170337007999933,4.1328330040000765,4.145880016000319],[4.665519644000142,4.670076305000293,4.6598440840002695],[2.2809909809998317,0.781899636000162,0.7691932829998223],[6.008987953999622,0.9412647040003321,0.9506733889998031],[6.1903129289999015,3.628633594999883,3.815570798999943],[9.97725304100004,2.979070244000013,2.997355967999738],[9.978100522000204,2.992902611000318,3.022268540999903],[0.92484311599992,0.8439210039996397,0.8562627520000206],[0.23992238600021665,0.13403623200019865,0.1317714319998231],[0.1254186490000393,0.09669256999995923,0.09850224299998445],[0.13835749800000485,0.09647460799988039,0.0929961749998256],[0.3313648240000475,0.2376939770001627,0.24857611900006304],[0.07056037899974399,0.05403545599983772,0.051252997999654326],[0.07037150599990127,0.04856322000023283,0.04816857199966762],[0.06874101699986568,0.04819512300036877,0.04709468300006847]],"source":"duckdb-parquet/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"DuckDB","date":"2023-09-26","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded"],"load_time":584,"data_size":25332035584,"result":[[0.026924091999717348,0.003037471999959962,0.0030087130003266793],[0.16772413799981223,0.012932972999806225,0.012755570000081207],[1.2386933419998059,0.03195383900037996,0.03169731600019077],[1.193935569000132,0.05566495500033852,0.055519788000310655],[1.2719721720000052,0.4797815800002354,0.47364618500023425],[1.7204052460001549,0.5739197209995837,0.6044714929998918],[0.13692102499999237,0.016513684000074136,0.016418880999935936],[0.42878113500000836,0.013978246000078798,0.01376930500009621],[2.144393795000269,0.5794733759998962,0.5795776770000884],[2.8978004400000827,0.7554636660001961,0.7576688170001944],[1.4596238879998964,0.18253447699999015,0.18234920899976714],[2.0671171230001164,0.20573082399960185,0.20432037900036448],[2.0727818139998817,0.49253306799982965,0.5038160149997566],[3.3520127649999267,0.8635853699997824,0.8859385079999811],[2.076823574000173,0.5337086039999122,0.5591845710000598],[0.6800219409997226,0.5261602820000917,0.5328403540002],[3.3403330400001323,1.2221616189999622,1.2723400309996578],[3.3052175400002852,1.2275647739998021,1.2696754610001335],[6.236794336999992,2.1919357929996295,2.266641716000322],[0.34883063199958997,0.038191365000329824,0.03821421199972974],[20.648422884999945,0.8656416110002283,0.8617157950002365],[22.367165485999976,0.6310706739996021,0.6244764059997578],[38.236362885999824,0.9444063159999132,0.9462657369999761],[95.79474400300023,4.57907104800006,4.498353044000396],[4.15015750900011,0.1932854189999489,0.18837451800027338],[1.9394079560001956,0.19987759199966604,0.19433718700020108],[4.543052850000095,0.20305141100016044,0.19478781699990577],[20.80425411499982,0.5468405399997209,0.5366565440003797],[14.24943101000008,4.494378264999796,4.4872481480001625],[0.7351944990000447,0.6778340149999167,0.6781058520000443],[4.485817211999802,0.4642300189998423,0.472603571000036],[7.575815559000148,0.6107541849996778,0.629833944999973],[7.22739360200012,4.044819612000083,4.163989215000129],[20.450376160999895,2.465135957000257,2.461840141999801],[20.466968382999767,2.605108253999788,2.608107234000272],[0.8528685460000816,0.6727260970001225,0.6969227390000015],[0.11805038800002876,0.03027148999990459,0.0272187630002918],[0.07883884800003216,0.015259446000072785,0.012236310999924171],[0.09153883999988466,0.017189998000048945,0.013864642000044114],[0.1759261150000384,0.06460375899996507,0.06465984499982369],[0.09337568199998714,0.00883036599998377,0.007896293999692716],[0.08930611300002056,0.008033808000163845,0.007339697000134038],[0.06956559599984757,0.009394902000167349,0.009093027000290022]],"source":"duckdb/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"DuckDB","date":"2023-09-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded"],"load_time":557,"data_size":25409892352,"result":[[0.028086780999728944,0.002414253000097233,0.0021636960000250838],[0.46563523099985105,0.010625985999922705,0.01016174400001546],[0.8891034559997024,0.025961164999898756,0.025551394000103755],[1.2264355699999214,0.03623923299983289,0.036103159000049345],[1.2716879180002252,0.3992600950000451,0.39979254900026717],[1.7464284959996803,0.476917694000349,0.4876424449998922],[0.3640209790000881,0.014415404999908787,0.013864879999800905],[0.4231801880000603,0.011493789000269317,0.011028166999949462],[1.9182373680000637,0.4695572649998212,0.473022095000033],[2.8863619510002536,0.6202132429998528,0.6272343959999489],[1.469674029000089,0.15033233000031032,0.1493539050002255],[2.122888372000034,0.16747449600006803,0.16623175400036416],[2.19689435600003,0.41368822100002944,0.4245434929998737],[3.353093207999791,0.7176920880001489,0.7419013379999342],[2.106729788999928,0.45157940500030236,0.45956111399982547],[0.7618140450003921,0.44360254799994436,0.4438193040000442],[3.3160554369997044,1.0091327439999986,1.0501606820002962],[3.2899087420000797,0.9937532539997846,1.0319792189998225],[6.147077066000293,1.8601839829998426,1.7930358930002512],[0.5478519510002116,0.029630810000071506,0.029407205000097747],[20.476412891999644,0.7287512409998271,0.7185980860003838],[22.457170643000154,0.5557742740002141,0.5497367680000025],[38.57942790900006,0.7984957059998123,0.7973248660000536],[96.20789085900014,3.8985825760000807,3.8594193190001533],[4.189989236000201,0.16466093799999726,0.1578326910002943],[2.0615221919997566,0.16868170299994745,0.1622597460000179],[4.6220101120002255,0.17378973800032327,0.1636861649999446],[20.925809684999876,0.4753908990001037,0.46921747900023547],[14.220432916999926,3.337972157999957,3.3373912329998348],[0.584624170999632,0.4804462130000502,0.4832376250001289],[4.546239200999935,0.39545450399964466,0.3945328300001165],[7.614473170999645,0.5206363369998144,0.5212976839998191],[6.800434293000308,3.344280624000021,3.4436193860001367],[20.560247130000334,2.172507063000012,2.1904886800002714],[20.578359694000028,2.2406041530002767,2.3070416179998574],[0.7716577450000841,0.5659581239997351,0.5712790600000517],[0.15594478200000594,0.02518773699966914,0.023627209000096627],[0.10974644699990677,0.012240085000030376,0.01144400700013648],[0.12063824999995632,0.01217633400028717,0.01063554699976521],[0.24521544600020206,0.04823300399993968,0.0470517949997884],[0.13470358900030988,0.007704704999923706,0.006628890000229148],[0.13843043999986548,0.006789723999645503,0.006517027999962011],[0.08625227099992117,0.0081432560000394,0.00758258299993031]],"source":"duckdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"DuckDB","date":"2023-09-26","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded"],"load_time":143.93,"data_size":28223746048,"result":[[0.03236215499964601,0.001631959999940591,0.0017349720001220703],[0.2017167620001601,0.004977931000212266,0.004112590999739041],[1.7824451350002164,0.01057577699975809,0.00924506499995914],[1.5068001750000803,0.011147404999974242,0.008505592999881628],[1.9968912629997249,0.3409851499995966,0.3641603260002739],[2.19996057499975,0.42094028299970887,0.37727264799968907],[0.21778730100004395,0.009304663999955665,0.006554180999955861],[0.6552495579999231,0.00758900300024834,0.006111935000262747],[3.237778974000321,0.37195273199995427,0.37644760800003496],[4.101916444999915,0.3916224780000448,0.4356481650002024],[1.981583973999932,0.10101389099963853,0.0828059509999548],[2.5021246000001156,0.12936520600032964,0.06469776399990224],[2.0287027350000244,0.2671814919999633,0.2580042009999488],[5.0058850400000665,2.5847008529999584,0.9242121399997814],[2.3203943019998405,0.23897008799985997,0.2951310849998663],[0.9209703480000826,0.37256716299998516,0.20133301800024128],[3.6552786790002756,0.49283485800015114,0.4653434940000807],[3.684886160000133,0.5913837480002258,0.6050533939996967],[6.08533725999996,1.1212222939998355,1.2291971190002187],[0.7086644400001205,0.012204473000110738,0.011541186000158632],[22.877518454999972,0.24069266800006517,0.14223928199999136],[24.865264503000162,0.11923907699974734,0.09882567700014988],[44.523412047999955,0.43662231000007523,0.2732989429996451],[106.65310618600006,2.291449360000115,1.0823644299998705],[4.273118970999803,0.11639817900004346,0.04853129599996464],[1.9446537600001648,0.18474681899988354,0.07775153500006127],[4.282858682999631,0.1974552310002764,0.07218202500007465],[22.900311010999758,0.16852921000008791,0.137986748000003],[15.712022881999928,1.605772540000089,1.495060542000374],[0.35286867500008157,0.12376627899993764,0.09917158700000073],[4.9339620559999275,0.19886905099974683,0.25272748499992304],[7.844819150999683,0.2757238479998705,0.3000885700002982],[6.1183534870001495,1.578629292000187,1.6954807430001892],[22.53793776099974,1.0309925289998318,1.407939608000106],[22.57955366799979,1.7960458739999012,2.255313027000284],[0.6876235540003108,0.331532089999655,0.2276349650001066],[1.1719605680000313,0.061066774999744666,0.040371307999976125],[1.5213748269998177,0.04644827699985399,0.03365288300028624],[1.7530375439996533,0.05019643499963422,0.02876765000019077],[3.1484079319998273,0.09479282800020883,0.059220590999757405],[2.582429621999836,0.03467660899968905,0.013035046999902988],[3.2146319700000276,0.03065071499986516,0.013175667999803409],[1.291933348999919,0.027330930000061926,0.011119961000076728]],"source":"duckdb/results/c6a.metal.json"} -,{"system":"Elasticsearch","date":"2022-07-20","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 1500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Java","search"],"load_time":10071.796,"data_size":76633643596,"result":[[0,0,0],[0.5300,1.6670,1.6700],[13.9770,14.0710,13.9910],[6.7610,6.6940,6.7440],[4.3800,4.4130,4.4320],[156.6440,156.1420,156.4210],[6.2520,6.2060,6.3010],[1.7210,1.7140,1.7090],[16.0000,16.0500,16.4320],[32.2270,32.3500,32.3890],[1.7840,1.7780,1.7720],[2.2200,2.2120,2.2140],[5.1970,5.2500,5.2010],[5.2380,5.1870,5.1910],[5.5640,5.5980,5.6300],[5.5120,5.5890,5.4550],[12.8250,12.7480,12.8410],[12.3150,12.3940,12.1670],[36.5290,36.4930,36.7370],[0.0020,0.0020,0.0020],[13.3720,13.3210,13.4180],[16.4610,16.4870,16.4590],[26.2460,25.7280,25.8370],[13.4160,13.3650,13.5410],[1.0280,1.0450,1.0260],[1.2860,1.2880,1.2970],[1.0280,1.0300,1.0320],[116.6490,117.0580,117.6100],[null,null,null],[1480.1420,1484.7140,1483.2560],[2.1930,2.1550,2.1570],[2.2380,2.2330,2.2570],[8.8430,8.5380,8.6110],[16.8790,16.8630,16.9490],[16.7870,16.8500,16.8530],[47.6580,46.4390,46.5660],[10.1000,10.0950,10.0630],[7.8030,7.8340,7.8210],[10.0970,9.9610,10.1880],[16.0140,16.0640,16.0650],[0.1430,0.1440,0.1440],[0.1300,0.1310,0.1310],[0.3370,0.3370,0.3360]],"source":"elasticsearch/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"hide":true,"system":"Elasticsearch (tuned)","date":"2022-07-25","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 1500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Tuned by repeated benchmark to find the optimal Elasticsearch shard number and size for this resource type and workload","tags":["Java","search"],"load_time":5264.429,"data_size":91680375082,"result":[[0,0,0],[0.1950,0.3800,0.3810],[3.5590,3.5040,3.4930],[1.9720,1.6320,1.6090],[1.0660,1.0550,1.0650],[42.7970,41.7840,41.6300],[1.5750,1.5610,1.5650],[0.3870,0.3850,0.4010],[4.0050,4.0420,3.9850],[7.7860,7.8100,7.9100],[0.6130,0.4890,0.4940],[0.6670,0.6040,0.6000],[1.4670,1.4010,1.4130],[1.4730,1.4910,1.4770],[1.5920,1.5240,1.5260],[1.3340,1.3180,1.3140],[3.2030,3.1920,3.2190],[3.1040,3.1080,3.1070],[8.9730,9.0510,9.0870],[0.0380,0.0020,0.0020],[8.4100,4.5580,4.5500],[5.9040,5.4170,5.4250],[12.7610,9.1180,9.1030],[4.5340,4.5370,4.5420],[0.3260,0.2940,0.2880],[0.4110,0.3690,0.3690],[0.2920,0.2920,0.2910],[40.0300,34.1000,34.0440],[null,null,null],[380.6870,385.4750,388.0040],[0.7460,0.5420,0.5380],[1.9890,0.5640,0.5510],[1.9930,2.0190,1.9970],[5.6350,5.2860,5.2570],[5.2420,5.2070,5.2660],[11.4420,11.5690,11.6390],[3.6250,3.6040,3.5830],[3.0630,2.9160,2.9200],[3.5810,3.4940,3.4970],[5.5400,5.2060,5.2270],[0.1080,0.0250,0.0260],[0.0590,0.0210,0.0230],[0.0710,0.0710,0.0710]],"source":"elasticsearch/results/c6a.4xlarge.tuned.json"} +,{"system":"Elasticsearch","date":"2022-07-20","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 1500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Java","search"],"load_time":10071.796,"data_size":76633643596,"result":[[0,0,0],[0.53,1.667,1.67],[13.977,14.071,13.991],[6.761,6.694,6.744],[4.38,4.413,4.432],[156.644,156.142,156.421],[6.252,6.206,6.301],[1.721,1.714,1.709],[16,16.05,16.432],[32.227,32.35,32.389],[1.784,1.778,1.772],[2.22,2.212,2.214],[5.197,5.25,5.201],[5.238,5.187,5.191],[5.564,5.598,5.63],[5.512,5.589,5.455],[12.825,12.748,12.841],[12.315,12.394,12.167],[36.529,36.493,36.737],[0.002,0.002,0.002],[13.372,13.321,13.418],[16.461,16.487,16.459],[26.246,25.728,25.837],[13.416,13.365,13.541],[1.028,1.045,1.026],[1.286,1.288,1.297],[1.028,1.03,1.032],[116.649,117.058,117.61],[null,null,null],[1480.142,1484.714,1483.256],[2.193,2.155,2.157],[2.238,2.233,2.257],[8.843,8.538,8.611],[16.879,16.863,16.949],[16.787,16.85,16.853],[47.658,46.439,46.566],[10.1,10.095,10.063],[7.803,7.834,7.821],[10.097,9.961,10.188],[16.014,16.064,16.065],[0.143,0.144,0.144],[0.13,0.131,0.131],[0.337,0.337,0.336]],"source":"elasticsearch/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"hide":true,"system":"Elasticsearch (tuned)","date":"2022-07-25","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 1500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Tuned by repeated benchmark to find the optimal Elasticsearch shard number and size for this resource type and workload","tags":["Java","search"],"load_time":5264.429,"data_size":91680375082,"result":[[0,0,0],[0.195,0.38,0.381],[3.559,3.504,3.493],[1.972,1.632,1.609],[1.066,1.055,1.065],[42.797,41.784,41.63],[1.575,1.561,1.565],[0.387,0.385,0.401],[4.005,4.042,3.985],[7.786,7.81,7.91],[0.613,0.489,0.494],[0.667,0.604,0.6],[1.467,1.401,1.413],[1.473,1.491,1.477],[1.592,1.524,1.526],[1.334,1.318,1.314],[3.203,3.192,3.219],[3.104,3.108,3.107],[8.973,9.051,9.087],[0.038,0.002,0.002],[8.41,4.558,4.55],[5.904,5.417,5.425],[12.761,9.118,9.103],[4.534,4.537,4.542],[0.326,0.294,0.288],[0.411,0.369,0.369],[0.292,0.292,0.291],[40.03,34.1,34.044],[null,null,null],[380.687,385.475,388.004],[0.746,0.542,0.538],[1.989,0.564,0.551],[1.993,2.019,1.997],[5.635,5.286,5.257],[5.242,5.207,5.266],[11.442,11.569,11.639],[3.625,3.604,3.583],[3.063,2.916,2.92],[3.581,3.494,3.497],[5.54,5.206,5.227],[0.108,0.025,0.026],[0.059,0.021,0.023],[0.071,0.071,0.071]],"source":"elasticsearch/results/c6a.4xlarge.tuned.json"} ,{"system":"Greenplum","date":"2022-08-18","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","column-oriented","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":1080,"data_size":42000000000,"result":[[2.19644,1.27581,1.07334],[1.36821,1.09289,1.00081],[1.84455,1.93433,1.9734],[1.38533,1.07306,0.997511],[10.4301,10.1377,10.0064],[3.24183,3.67479,3.23526],[1.81177,1.22447,1.72696],[1.28568,1.12341,1.02112],[3.5159,3.7946,3.51106],[5.78795,5.90487,5.95635],[1.50773,1.80496,1.26395],[1.68682,1.93425,1.54081],[2.29378,2.75715,2.22458],[3.41812,3.09848,3.0303],[2.96859,2.96836,2.9949],[3.04409,3.00935,2.98848],[4.10668,3.98626,4.00533],[3.51045,3.14617,3.02558],[9.31981,9.03239,9.00459],[0.563991,0.853628,0.971569],[8.40649,3.29997,3.82986],[9.52108,3.52917,3.86565],[18.4842,4.56174,4.67819],[50.449,16.4463,16.4923],[1.96056,1.59658,1.85278],[1.76567,1.51262,1.52955],[2.11338,1.81927,1.92422],[8.6392,5.18686,5.77986],[51.8749,52.0756,52.2289],[63.6736,63.868,63.3526],[2.92731,2.88967,2.96908],[4.83141,3.88826,3.41858],[42.2016,40.1165,39.4692],[14.5369,10.3602,10.4522],[14.7224,10.829,10.8651],[5.32702,5.79151,5.20852],[0.339799,0.158694,0.160555],[0.173487,0.112253,0.112419],[0.158136,0.102158,0.101214],[0.341324,0.263589,0.24586],[0.171119,0.109181,0.108795],[0.178617,0.117175,0.117738],[0.205935,0.137013,0.137252]],"source":"greenplum/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"HeavyAI","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous names: OmniSci, mapD. Many queries cannot run due to errors and limitations.","tags":["C++","column-oriented"],"load_time":572.633,"data_size":50887437386,"result":[[6.525,0.022,0.029],[0.301,0.042,0.04],[0.287,0.095,0.093],[2.572,0.039,0.04],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[7.327,0.093,0.097],[0.244,0.043,0.038],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[2.939,0.295,0.294],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[4.716,3.91,3.955],[null,null,null],[0.154,0.083,0.106],[14.426,0.07,0.071],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[2.276,0.258,0.272],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[1.832,1.64,1.602],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[14.811,0.494,0.497],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[1.941,0.255,0.255],[5.457,0.172,0.283],[0.476,0.269,0.256],[14.239,0.179,0.178],[3.992,0.112,0.112],[1.031,0.116,0.116],[1.365,0.089,0.088]],"source":"heavyai/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Hydra","date":"2023-09-19","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","PostgreSQL compatible","column-oriented"],"load_time":1222,"data_size":18995669982,"result":[[0.381752,0.249001,0.243783],[0.261088,0.211013,0.209277],[0.6692,0.634666,0.627473],[0.545165,0.431892,0.439854],[22.4371,21.8547,21.731],[34.8689,33.0467,32.5865],[0.410038,0.377206,0.376254],[0.22464,0.206133,0.204092],[27.1582,26.4292,26.5203],[30.1541,29.4784,30.2199],[3.31616,2.76618,2.75128],[3.55764,3.28978,3.27316],[7.74401,7.64012,7.6384],[10.703,10.2599,10.2098],[8.70712,8.33702,8.29268],[17.9937,17.5084,17.5291],[22.8406,22.2649,22.1176],[4.08958,3.59194,3.61345],[39.0156,37.7258,37.8926],[0.267125,0.233304,0.233594],[3.12914,2.74305,2.72563],[2.91522,2.89177,2.90416],[3.76881,3.62139,3.62348],[26.322,20.5805,20.3337],[1.69125,1.05602,1.06068],[1.06135,0.828339,0.831532],[1.26898,1.06035,1.05212],[4.17896,4.03193,4.03657],[43.0503,42.5091,42.3298],[7.89438,7.50181,7.39528],[9.33451,8.76728,8.79973],[15.0403,14.6597,14.3034],[58.8221,58.6056,58.6859],[34.2914,35.0405,34.2519],[36.3141,35.6205,36.5728],[14.2056,13.8882,13.8284],[0.367202,0.33666,0.33517],[0.22008,0.172653,0.167434],[0.15307,0.126572,0.126678],[1.11688,0.671288,0.696326],[0.160667,0.145181,0.141243],[0.137686,0.122734,0.118493],[0.197786,0.123078,0.122094]],"source":"hydra/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Infobright","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Only 90% of data successfully loaded. Some queries run for days.","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":2317,"data_size":13760341294,"result":[[0.01,0,0],[2.39,2.4,2.44],[0,0,0],[7.21,6.04,6.91],[16.09,16.86,15.69],[48.8,42.37,48.63],[0,0,0],[3.48,2.42,2.42],[23.56,24.78,22.21],[32.87,31.71,34.48],[14.8,14.83,14.11],[16.7,16.53,17.37],[1752.91,1999.88,1961.4],[1193.43,1167,1220.47],[2184.81,2316.12,2224.14],[32.58,30.69,31.58],[300.17,16221.33,16168.44],[122.4,120.49,124.67],[78927.44,79250.44,78504.89],[3.38,1.22,1.21],[289.73,302.3,285.83],[415.82,389.23,403.28],[573.82,590.81,575.06],[300.13,293.96,285.64],[41.42,37.48,39.64],[75.2,75.37,72.07],[39.22,41.52,40.11],[449.56,445.03,448.68],[null,null,null],[450.87,488.3,453.83],[58.69,59.29,58.07],[84.47,78.92,79.38],[517.97,520.29,504.96],[182468.89,182468.89,182468.89],[182468.89,182468.89,182468.89],[68.43,66.93,67.68],[8.3,3.62,3.61],[1.04,0.62,0.62],[0.22,0.18,0.18],[567.78,566.52,563.02],[0.29,0.14,0.11],[0.17,0.08,0.08],[1.37,1.34,1.32]],"source":"infobright/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Kinetica","date":"2023-01-04","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["column-oriented"],"load_time":1374,"data_size":null,"result":[[0.52,0.048,0.047],[0.504,0.349,0.048],[0.274,0.11,0.047],[1.782,8.797,0.046],[1.835,1.692,0.676],[2.123,1.176,0.203],[0.37,0.094,0.047],[0.149,0.081,0.05],[3.394,3.162,0.556],[3.609,3.344,1.727],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[2.475,2.355,2.269],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[0.109,0.09,0.06],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[2.084,0.173,0.177],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[24.669,23.317,0.093],[3.282,1.192,1.114],[4.848,2.753,2.768],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[0.521,0.1,0.055],[0.182,0.071,0.054],[0.122,0.089,0.053]],"source":"kinetica/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"MariaDB ColumnStore","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: InfiniDB.","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":2507.8,"data_size":19712857022,"result":[[0.151,0.158,0.148],[0.100,0.101,0.106],[1.221,1.233,1.226],[0.739,0.736,0.741],[2.025,2.046,2.004],[3.725,4.801,3.755],[0.871,0.749,0.736],[0.118,0.108,0.103],[2.108,2.029,2.029],[4.225,4.271,4.288],[1.711,1.402,1.407],[1.526,1.435,1.420],[5.339,4.172,3.610],[4.692,4.729,4.960],[4.013,3.860,3.918],[3.236,2.680,2.629],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[0.137,0.109,0.147],[12.331,6.069,8.619],[2.162,2.178,2.192],[16.849,30.463,26.639],[92,90.208,92.814],[3.042,1.763,1.791],[1.779,1.772,1.749],[1.793,1.821,1.888],[13.036,10.747,9.590],[null,null,null],[78.224,79.141,77.806],[2.837,2.654,2.675],[5.833,4.552,3.678],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[3.626,3.546,3.709],[1.719,1.787,1.876],[1.345,0.906,0.910],[0.117,0.091,0.093],[1.217,1.133,1.133],[0.114,0.063,0.062],[0.100,0.062,0.061],[null,null,null]],"source":"mariadb-columnstore/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"MariaDB ColumnStore","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: InfiniDB.","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":2507.8,"data_size":19712857022,"result":[[0.151,0.158,0.148],[0.1,0.101,0.106],[1.221,1.233,1.226],[0.739,0.736,0.741],[2.025,2.046,2.004],[3.725,4.801,3.755],[0.871,0.749,0.736],[0.118,0.108,0.103],[2.108,2.029,2.029],[4.225,4.271,4.288],[1.711,1.402,1.407],[1.526,1.435,1.42],[5.339,4.172,3.61],[4.692,4.729,4.96],[4.013,3.86,3.918],[3.236,2.68,2.629],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[0.137,0.109,0.147],[12.331,6.069,8.619],[2.162,2.178,2.192],[16.849,30.463,26.639],[92,90.208,92.814],[3.042,1.763,1.791],[1.779,1.772,1.749],[1.793,1.821,1.888],[13.036,10.747,9.59],[null,null,null],[78.224,79.141,77.806],[2.837,2.654,2.675],[5.833,4.552,3.678],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[3.626,3.546,3.709],[1.719,1.787,1.876],[1.345,0.906,0.91],[0.117,0.091,0.093],[1.217,1.133,1.133],[0.114,0.063,0.062],[0.1,0.062,0.061],[null,null,null]],"source":"mariadb-columnstore/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"hide":true,"system":"MariaDB","date":"2023-03-16","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"For some reason many queries run in almost exactly one hour. Most likely a coincidence. It is installed from Debian packages, which might explain the abysmal performance.","tags":["C++","row-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":8625,"data_size":104270986073,"result":[[2325.7,2320,2333.78],[2334.78,2332.22,2327.4],[2348.31,2364.93,2375.47],[2378.97,2384.7,2404.94],[2440.64,2424.09,2426.42],[2672.27,2688.11,2690.41],[2431.34,2443.24,2434.15],[2436.65,2428.4,2433.15],[2498.67,2502.58,2489.58],[2530.63,2520.99,2526.05],[3214.94,3152.09,3133.92],[3189.99,3169.31,3148.69],[2554.55,2556.7,2546.32],[8019,8082.98,8090.95],[2610.89,2587.29,2597.82],[2956.4,2965.74,2976.53],[3093.56,3104.46,3100.55],[3050.67,3036.62,3103.31],[3533.67,3477.88,3570.5],[2453.61,2436.78,2427.24],[2521.56,2514.54,2519.21],[2542.57,2540.39,2544.67],[2558.61,2567.56,2563.08],[2579.95,2568.24,2571.27],[2507.4,2522.47,2517.66],[2543.29,2536.27,2528.08],[2532.54,2530.23,2526.74],[2563.83,2548.74,2545.44],[2926.8,2897.01,2920.1],[2940.88,2963.93,2982.09],[2626.55,2621.43,2635.34],[2623.32,2616.79,2583.39],[3729.89,3730.41,3734.37],[3047.16,3063.14,3090.9],[3096.45,3111.46,3103.45],[3124.1,3097.9,3097.01],[20.222,13.586,12.646],[12.03,11.99,12.006],[10.709,11.112,11.187],[14.77,14.692,14.271],[10.71,11.108,11.218],[11.676,11.118,11.19],[null,null,null]],"source":"mariadb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"MonetDB","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","column-oriented"],"load_time":939,"data_size":49696606499,"result":[[0.000218,0.000157,0.000155],[0.101903,0.019908,0.018439],[0.282431,0.035987,0.034938],[2.868,0.029387,0.029207],[4.675,4.515,4.511],[6.584,4.269,4.650],[0.528827,0.063135,0.065742],[0.506863,0.020966,0.021687],[8.343,4.457,4.408],[7.224,6.548,7.576],[0.267003,0.233353,0.230444],[0.347206,0.28358,0.266085],[5.389,3.099,3.074],[7.653,7.759,8.596],[3.276,3.326,3.292],[5.310,3.465,3.578],[9.341,9.143,9.536],[9.584,9.604,9.419],[19.539,19.783,19.611],[0.004509,0.000702,0.000643],[20.801,1.570,1.603],[2.752,0.418221,0.395884],[14.717,0.800894,0.395477],[14.429,1.804,1.869],[1.386,0.159602,0.156426],[0.189736,0.167664,0.168781],[0.164681,0.176666,0.17126],[3.005,3.113,3.882],[null,null,null],[2.751,2.846,2.676],[7.937,2.579,2.447],[5.120,3.492,3.467],[22.862,22.567,23.211],[33.437,18.889,19.043],[18.898,19.583,19.047],[14.774,12.984,13.803],[3.865,0.322143,0.323117],[0.192149,0.177791,0.175984],[0.194173,0.159398,0.165201],[0.680778,0.592252,0.560738],[0.106465,0.10638,0.102692],[0.154871,0.153752,0.155782],[0.11459,0.09639,0.095594]],"source":"monetdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"MonetDB","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","column-oriented"],"load_time":939,"data_size":49696606499,"result":[[0.000218,0.000157,0.000155],[0.101903,0.019908,0.018439],[0.282431,0.035987,0.034938],[2.868,0.029387,0.029207],[4.675,4.515,4.511],[6.584,4.269,4.65],[0.528827,0.063135,0.065742],[0.506863,0.020966,0.021687],[8.343,4.457,4.408],[7.224,6.548,7.576],[0.267003,0.233353,0.230444],[0.347206,0.28358,0.266085],[5.389,3.099,3.074],[7.653,7.759,8.596],[3.276,3.326,3.292],[5.31,3.465,3.578],[9.341,9.143,9.536],[9.584,9.604,9.419],[19.539,19.783,19.611],[0.004509,0.000702,0.000643],[20.801,1.57,1.603],[2.752,0.418221,0.395884],[14.717,0.800894,0.395477],[14.429,1.804,1.869],[1.386,0.159602,0.156426],[0.189736,0.167664,0.168781],[0.164681,0.176666,0.17126],[3.005,3.113,3.882],[null,null,null],[2.751,2.846,2.676],[7.937,2.579,2.447],[5.12,3.492,3.467],[22.862,22.567,23.211],[33.437,18.889,19.043],[18.898,19.583,19.047],[14.774,12.984,13.803],[3.865,0.322143,0.323117],[0.192149,0.177791,0.175984],[0.194173,0.159398,0.165201],[0.680778,0.592252,0.560738],[0.106465,0.10638,0.102692],[0.154871,0.153752,0.155782],[0.11459,0.09639,0.095594]],"source":"monetdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"MongoDB","date":"2022-10-25","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["row-oriented","document","C++"],"load_time":44824,"data_size":86397751448,"result":[[64.713,63.126,62.48],[0.402,0.398,0.398],[116.556,115.775,115.935],[116.883,92.054,91.646],[28.523,25.694,25.618],[19.974,10.235,10.204],[0.005,0.003,0.003],[0.656,0.644,0.65],[390.984,377.012,377.204],[2331.229,2617.011,2659.976],[403.396,410.754,389.201],[400.136,391.611,384.638],[90.255,70.314,70.648],[171.232,133.632,133.416],[57.835,57.8,57.136],[474.638,421.62,419.999],[332.07,266.801,266.967],[246.706,246.484,246.741],[466.25,465.911,465.399],[0.01,0.003,0.002],[238.439,70.732,69.911],[152.131,20.13,20.276],[28.018,23.201,23.292],[118.896,79.388,74.994],[21.888,11.393,11.423],[0.005,0.002,0.002],[31.821,15.74,15.353],[113.3,110.56,109.007],[287.151,178.123,177.878],[1099.097,1076.143,1064.104],[4987.582,4947.372,4873.488],[4816.666,4748.195,4823.137],[982.576,933.784,912.187],[1081.243,706.058,585.97],[593.68,570.279,594.089],[544.094,427.503,419.334],[11.766,5.643,4.975],[1.628,1.651,1.626],[3.444,2.222,2.232],[10.562,8.762,9.151],[0.724,0.445,0.446],[0.423,0.413,0.388],[1.601,2.202,2.375]],"source":"mongodb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"MySQL (MyISAM)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","row-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":2512,"data_size":121588958061,"result":[[0.00,0.00,0.00],[283.32,276.83,274.52],[276.93,278.29,283.27],[28.83,23.63,21.55],[46.41,40.81,40.93],[467.04,467.39,469.08],[31.02,25.89,24.20],[277.89,275.3,277.3],[329.34,325.8,325.35],[342.86,338.43,336.95],[282.03,279.87,281.22],[277.74,282.68,282],[335.66,334.83,336.44],[305.24,310.39,307.3],[337.41,338.52,342.94],[308.66,307.34,306.27],[738.38,748.44,740.75],[738.75,734.01,738.25],[867.01,872.92,868.84],[25.65,20.61,18.46],[312.39,313.67,306.66],[301.66,305.12,308.01],[298.12,298.44,312.4],[311.34,309.9,311.85],[281.87,278.5,275],[277.46,277.46,277.46],[280.75,278.04,281.76],[263.9,417.39,406.88],[707.21,711.96,705],[668.1,668.33,665.96],[330.31,333.36,331.94],[506.57,506.18,500.53],[2604.49,2681.96,2703.12],[830.65,832.88,831.14],[831.98,830.46,833.41],[608.49,608.51,613.68],[4.56,4.13,4.16],[3.80,3.80,3.70],[1.65,1.45,1.46],[6.33,5.14,6.15],[1.60,1.41,1.41],[1.56,1.42,1.39],[7.04,1.17,1.13]],"source":"mysql-myisam/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"MySQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","row-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":9472,"data_size":171953585825,"result":[[339.77,339.88,339.77],[364.91,371.86,367.55],[366.2,368.91,389.66],[364.39,377.53,571.45],[377.69,390.02,384.86],[569.48,576.51,574.68],[367.4,368.23,370.41],[371.29,384.02,613.22],[478.85,683.22,495.68],[489.9,635.96,662.43],[386.07,396.49,640.15],[389.13,412.55,444.12],[447.97,455.54,448.06],[423.22,845.44,813.6],[452.48,460.07,453.98],[577.54,623.21,586.49],[852.07,856.36,862.66],[838.09,848.92,851.12],[1006.37,1011.16,1023.17],[369.76,375.61,415.28],[412.45,419.9,456.62],[411.65,432.88,482.2],[412.73,420.73,429.5],[551.16,577.62,545.45],[382.89,394.76,386.37],[380.9,391.4,385.05],[385.3,394.67,460.32],[388.95,394.7,387.21],[800.33,807.90,807.11],[706.03,745.27,718.9],[450.9,489.59,530.97],[625.5,651.93,647.32],[2721.13,2792.12,2819.26],[945.9,954.94,957.54],[945.42,953.78,965.16],[684.36,716.29,708.75],[10.01,3.79,3.77],[7.48,3.32,3.27],[5.09,0.98,0.96],[8.70,4.77,4.68],[4.82,0.76,0.74],[4.46,0.77,0.75],[7.04,1.17,1.13]],"source":"mysql/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"MySQL (MyISAM)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","row-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":2512,"data_size":121588958061,"result":[[0,0,0],[283.32,276.83,274.52],[276.93,278.29,283.27],[28.83,23.63,21.55],[46.41,40.81,40.93],[467.04,467.39,469.08],[31.02,25.89,24.2],[277.89,275.3,277.3],[329.34,325.8,325.35],[342.86,338.43,336.95],[282.03,279.87,281.22],[277.74,282.68,282],[335.66,334.83,336.44],[305.24,310.39,307.3],[337.41,338.52,342.94],[308.66,307.34,306.27],[738.38,748.44,740.75],[738.75,734.01,738.25],[867.01,872.92,868.84],[25.65,20.61,18.46],[312.39,313.67,306.66],[301.66,305.12,308.01],[298.12,298.44,312.4],[311.34,309.9,311.85],[281.87,278.5,275],[277.46,277.46,277.46],[280.75,278.04,281.76],[263.9,417.39,406.88],[707.21,711.96,705],[668.1,668.33,665.96],[330.31,333.36,331.94],[506.57,506.18,500.53],[2604.49,2681.96,2703.12],[830.65,832.88,831.14],[831.98,830.46,833.41],[608.49,608.51,613.68],[4.56,4.13,4.16],[3.8,3.8,3.7],[1.65,1.45,1.46],[6.33,5.14,6.15],[1.6,1.41,1.41],[1.56,1.42,1.39],[7.04,1.17,1.13]],"source":"mysql-myisam/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"MySQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","row-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":9472,"data_size":171953585825,"result":[[339.77,339.88,339.77],[364.91,371.86,367.55],[366.2,368.91,389.66],[364.39,377.53,571.45],[377.69,390.02,384.86],[569.48,576.51,574.68],[367.4,368.23,370.41],[371.29,384.02,613.22],[478.85,683.22,495.68],[489.9,635.96,662.43],[386.07,396.49,640.15],[389.13,412.55,444.12],[447.97,455.54,448.06],[423.22,845.44,813.6],[452.48,460.07,453.98],[577.54,623.21,586.49],[852.07,856.36,862.66],[838.09,848.92,851.12],[1006.37,1011.16,1023.17],[369.76,375.61,415.28],[412.45,419.9,456.62],[411.65,432.88,482.2],[412.73,420.73,429.5],[551.16,577.62,545.45],[382.89,394.76,386.37],[380.9,391.4,385.05],[385.3,394.67,460.32],[388.95,394.7,387.21],[800.33,807.9,807.11],[706.03,745.27,718.9],[450.9,489.59,530.97],[625.5,651.93,647.32],[2721.13,2792.12,2819.26],[945.9,954.94,957.54],[945.42,953.78,965.16],[684.36,716.29,708.75],[10.01,3.79,3.77],[7.48,3.32,3.27],[5.09,0.98,0.96],[8.7,4.77,4.68],[4.82,0.76,0.74],[4.46,0.77,0.75],[7.04,1.17,1.13]],"source":"mysql/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Pinot","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"It successfully loaded only 94465149 out of 99997497 records. Some queries returned NullPointerException. The loading process is painful - splitting to 100 pieces required. It does not correctly report errors on data loading, the results may be incorrect.","tags":["Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":2032,"data_size":null,"result":[[0.002,0.001,0.001],[0.186,0.186,0.185],[0.251,0.276,0.258],[0.475,0.281,0.238],[3.907,3.655,3.633],[30.471,14.687,14.93],[null,null,null],[0.135,0.134,0.148],[3.039,2.902,2.938],[3.159,3.212,3.225],[4.217,4.197,4.384],[4.145,4.124,4.121],[2.989,3.145,3.18],[6.402,6.886,6.374],[3.245,3.35,3.129],[5.112,5.027,5.141],[5.509,5.279,5.257],[0.865,0.856,0.829],[null,null,null],[0.017,0.015,0.015],[54.348,19.562,19.128],[null,null,null],[76.596,74.719,14.228],[7.441,5.77,5.87],[0.376,0.327,0.286],[7.689,0.395,1.281],[3.434,0.499,0.5],[27.679,2.378,2.393],[null,null,null],[2.221,2.227,2.167],[4.941,4.639,4.565],[5.641,5.37,5.007],[5.295,5.006,5.357],[5.28,5.21,5.105],[6.231,6.238,6.385],[5.918,5.933,5.934],[0.26,0.202,0.21],[0.364,0.072,0.069],[0.042,0.034,0.035],[1.483,0.686,0.651],[0.113,0.071,0.079],[0.042,0.051,0.037],[null,null,null]],"source":"pinot/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"hide":true,"system":"PostgreSQL (tuned)","date":"2022-12-18","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","row-oriented","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":11800,"data_size":128875248605,"result":[[4.10957,0.687829,0.702019],[3.92694,0.63874,0.636411],[262.331,262.793,262.826],[6.14366,1.16457,1.20297],[26.752,27.4474,27.4878],[50.6555,47.6136,49.2373],[0.035605,0.002266,0.002208],[1.07557,0.599462,0.597673],[18.537,17.4348,17.7942],[309.49,306.831,306.894],[7.78261,2.95749,3.00855],[325.58,315.688,319.237],[4.03189,2.31557,2.21055],[18.8998,10.0497,10.0307],[272.381,271.91,271.87],[5.91906,4.17788,4.21394],[15.6578,15.8794,15.937],[0.025629,0.001484,0.00153],[312.64,312.543,310.582],[0.026206,0.001114,0.001115],[13.1447,0.090463,0.104537],[0.11893,0.093162,0.090471],[18.7775,0.107025,0.110361],[0.131412,0.089608,0.087852],[0.048958,0.00153,0.001405],[0.016134,0.001351,0.001268],[0.021939,0.001781,0.00164],[265.557,260.971,261.025],[277.516,276.053,277.378],[7.56565,6.50964,6.54902],[266.723,266.389,266.231],[269.738,269.255,269.193],[331.115,330.011,330.913],[416.169,421.255,423.724],[408.434,409.538,407.552],[35.5578,18.1707,18.6893],[3.17403,0.652905,0.698142],[0.730699,0.489315,0.465665],[0.563463,0.319131,0.3182],[1.23744,0.989391,1.01963],[0.752814,0.509212,0.511453],[0.677541,0.435178,0.437736],[1.18281,0.688545,0.697523]],"source":"postgresql-tuned/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"PostgreSQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","row-oriented","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":2342,"data_size":77797067741,"result":[[439.753,309.785,282.017],[317.874,254.238,254.941],[262.883,263.072,263.090],[32.421,5.310,5.060],[57.134,42.648,42.334],[358.423,356.315,358.342],[31.524,5.350,4.994],[263.145,263.193,263.165],[323.659,322.858,321.918],[327.395,326.170,326.231],[265.983,265.681,265.912],[269.984,265.336,265.379],[284.096,284.560,282.234],[277.250,279.455,280.035],[285.660,286.200,283.611],[66.605,32.023,38.282],[312.452,304.431,305.391],[289.209,290.449,287.578],[331.706,327.485,334.428],[24.646,2.543,2.263],[267.561,267.496,267.524],[267.729,267.690,268.184],[263.074,263.120,267.040],[267.602,267.488,267.494],[263.141,263.859,263.137],[262.923,263.102,263.113],[262.885,263.088,263.114],[267.864,269.127,268.204],[303.376,306.925,308.664],[263.221,263.119,263.148],[270.814,270.575,270.294],[278.342,275.925,276.224],[584.599,576.932,591.502],[462.576,446.962,439.779],[429.930,417.696,416.704],[296.875,297.283,295.140],[3.461,0.842,0.794],[2.179,0.564,0.558],[2.258,0.566,0.416],[2.805,1.311,1.317],[2.936,0.820,0.615],[2.197,0.736,0.535],[1.983,0.320,0.312]],"source":"postgresql/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"PostgreSQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","row-oriented","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":2342,"data_size":77797067741,"result":[[439.753,309.785,282.017],[317.874,254.238,254.941],[262.883,263.072,263.09],[32.421,5.31,5.06],[57.134,42.648,42.334],[358.423,356.315,358.342],[31.524,5.35,4.994],[263.145,263.193,263.165],[323.659,322.858,321.918],[327.395,326.17,326.231],[265.983,265.681,265.912],[269.984,265.336,265.379],[284.096,284.56,282.234],[277.25,279.455,280.035],[285.66,286.2,283.611],[66.605,32.023,38.282],[312.452,304.431,305.391],[289.209,290.449,287.578],[331.706,327.485,334.428],[24.646,2.543,2.263],[267.561,267.496,267.524],[267.729,267.69,268.184],[263.074,263.12,267.04],[267.602,267.488,267.494],[263.141,263.859,263.137],[262.923,263.102,263.113],[262.885,263.088,263.114],[267.864,269.127,268.204],[303.376,306.925,308.664],[263.221,263.119,263.148],[270.814,270.575,270.294],[278.342,275.925,276.224],[584.599,576.932,591.502],[462.576,446.962,439.779],[429.93,417.696,416.704],[296.875,297.283,295.14],[3.461,0.842,0.794],[2.179,0.564,0.558],[2.258,0.566,0.416],[2.805,1.311,1.317],[2.936,0.82,0.615],[2.197,0.736,0.535],[1.983,0.32,0.312]],"source":"postgresql/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"QuestDB (partitioned)","date":"2023-08-07","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Data load for partitioned tables is multi-threaded and thus more efficient.","tags":["Java","time-series"],"load_time":283,"data_size":126686660753,"result":[[0.00797009,0.0026682,0.000222614],[1.1466,0.0743637,0.0350691],[1.33896,0.0294108,0.0242091],[2.88612,0.0116978,0.0115375],[6.32544,6.21946,6.12302],[10.682,9.70659,9.67993],[2.07087,0.0299815,0.0251919],[0.212583,0.223532,0.226999],[9.60538,8.88499,8.54807],[10.3833,10.6572,10.2222],[11.6556,7.75986,9.77087],[10.7876,10.2966,9.82955],[6.22005,5.68946,5.31396],[15.575,20.1012,21.951],[5.70846,5.55251,5.54523],[9.41636,9.11746,9.692],[12.9052,12.4855,12.6248],[12.0557,11.936,12.4488],[20.3953,20.5126,20.2717],[0.0431935,0.0264225,0.0254709],[71.9626,2.33681,2.75973],[2.45832,2.31771,2.58355],[48.1856,1.5962,1.3926],[67.7625,0.0476454,0.215789],[0.00885858,0.00393648,0.00325621],[2.35187,2.58716,2.59413],[2.01155,2.0116,2.01174],[7.89161,12.5432,11.7973],[96.8203,70.0744,70.5522],[0.0433241,0.0477017,0.0384908],[14.4465,14.1308,14.7048],[25.9898,26.6603,25.2982],[25.3329,25.5566,25.6693],[24.2448,24.657,25.0246],[24.9036,25.6605,25.2338],[13.5415,13.897,13.403],[0.566165,0.446011,0.473455],[0.376493,0.436516,0.444282],[0.019405,0.00734841,0.00715677],[0.0346318,0.00728625,0.00714942],[0.0225874,0.00709796,0.0185377],[0.0197833,0.00725278,0.0184759],[0.0191112,0.00719778,0.00711133]],"source":"questdb-partitioned/results/c6a.metal.json"} ,{"system":"QuestDB","date":"2023-08-07","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Java","time-series"],"load_time":981.7,"data_size":126680518693,"result":[[0.0112942,0.000225934,0.000253604],[0.556282,0.0313342,0.0218474],[1.42613,0.0565074,0.0541284],[2.87937,0.0520613,0.0495966],[4.63829,4.78606,4.79014],[10.338,6.1454,6.25674],[2.05945,0.027138,0.0279756],[0.098727,0.0829763,0.0507432],[6.53065,6.20068,6.32223],[8.10852,8.52982,8.27696],[8.48286,6.21364,6.07288],[6.78112,6.8087,6.70625],[4.89741,4.88513,4.91099],[10.5121,10.3625,11.87],[5.48412,5.44099,5.50898],[6.71723,6.61622,6.54155],[9.56474,9.55091,9.45236],[8.81386,8.96912,9.03472],[19.8604,20.0578,20.015],[0.0260623,0.0230254,0.0231277],[70.7859,5.24388,4.94915],[4.9527,5.53141,5.41446],[52.5849,22.9005,3.33657],[191.166,191.779,191.454],[9.19877,1.75408,1.75161],[2.27065,2.27486,2.24858],[2.13631,2.15004,2.23218],[72.2267,5.46021,5.32763],[106.031,56.3334,56.953],[0.572298,0.0139396,0.025344],[20.1234,10.4109,10.3593],[27.7933,27.2404,26.7903],[28.0558,28.8441,28.436],[59.4847,71.2648,30.2944],[24.2383,24.6024,24.3966],[11.254,11.3405,11.1291],[0.69854,0.602302,0.665329],[0.6388,0.498475,0.522627],[0.0250828,0.0086267,0.00843358],[0.0610679,0.00877569,0.0086065],[0.0319684,0.00839335,0.00924688],[0.0223462,0.00852395,0.00838955],[0.0244013,0.00847416,0.00863221]],"source":"questdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-29","machine":"serverless","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":1889,"data_size":30300000000,"result":[[0.204673,0.204057,0.199682],[2.572270,0.063610,0.029767],[4.436641,0.063275,0.038419],[4.045285,0.095483,0.036212],[3.836475,0.331029,0.302588],[3.870503,0.354183,0.334163],[4.415212,0.138202,0.202982],[4.595758,0.218455,0.218352],[5.014696,0.681662,0.748541],[5.225219,1.547334,1.545263],[4.584578,0.724320,0.662759],[4.989708,0.325297,0.664825],[4.113529,0.363930,0.343591],[4.261916,0.638592,0.606164],[4.056650,0.359074,0.467625],[4.562217,0.324242,0.323635],[4.794707,0.392733,0.552696],[2.785799,0.555024,0.533908],[5.186795,0.834753,0.821691],[2.538645,0.055274,0.025005],[2.952623,0.389594,0.235447],[4.522708,0.587444,0.607969],[6.980801,0.932761,0.949326],[27.480743,0.934181,0.912692],[3.802747,0.068159,0.065770],[3.781327,0.065613,0.065988],[3.995625,0.067925,0.067972],[4.607562,0.395705,0.441231],[5.138266,0.800484,0.799640],[5.705465,1.236098,1.133279],[5.105528,0.327460,0.348947],[5.075262,0.452786,0.339682],[4.465012,0.955494,0.742195],[4.586866,0.783934,0.812498],[5.182903,1.048090,1.058838],[4.331838,0.452791,0.325946],[5.790735,0.553011,0.582903],[5.600699,0.588159,0.589788],[5.217314,0.519302,0.423573],[6.281955,0.687085,0.494527],[3.990623,0.501763,0.533571],[4.451641,0.464027,0.231731],[3.953942,0.288126,0.283841]],"source":"redshift-serverless/results/serverless.json"} +,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-29","machine":"serverless","cluster_size":"serverless","comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":1889,"data_size":30300000000,"result":[[0.204673,0.204057,0.199682],[2.57227,0.06361,0.029767],[4.436641,0.063275,0.038419],[4.045285,0.095483,0.036212],[3.836475,0.331029,0.302588],[3.870503,0.354183,0.334163],[4.415212,0.138202,0.202982],[4.595758,0.218455,0.218352],[5.014696,0.681662,0.748541],[5.225219,1.547334,1.545263],[4.584578,0.72432,0.662759],[4.989708,0.325297,0.664825],[4.113529,0.36393,0.343591],[4.261916,0.638592,0.606164],[4.05665,0.359074,0.467625],[4.562217,0.324242,0.323635],[4.794707,0.392733,0.552696],[2.785799,0.555024,0.533908],[5.186795,0.834753,0.821691],[2.538645,0.055274,0.025005],[2.952623,0.389594,0.235447],[4.522708,0.587444,0.607969],[6.980801,0.932761,0.949326],[27.480743,0.934181,0.912692],[3.802747,0.068159,0.06577],[3.781327,0.065613,0.065988],[3.995625,0.067925,0.067972],[4.607562,0.395705,0.441231],[5.138266,0.800484,0.79964],[5.705465,1.236098,1.133279],[5.105528,0.32746,0.348947],[5.075262,0.452786,0.339682],[4.465012,0.955494,0.742195],[4.586866,0.783934,0.812498],[5.182903,1.04809,1.058838],[4.331838,0.452791,0.325946],[5.790735,0.553011,0.582903],[5.600699,0.588159,0.589788],[5.217314,0.519302,0.423573],[6.281955,0.687085,0.494527],[3.990623,0.501763,0.533571],[4.451641,0.464027,0.231731],[3.953942,0.288126,0.283841]],"source":"redshift-serverless/results/serverless.json"} ,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2023-03-16","machine":"dc2.8xlarge","cluster_size":2,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2485,"data_size":27278704640,"result":[[0.091406,0.086338,0.087612],[3.69766,0.134031,0.091109],[3.5111,0.168351,0.142172],[3.60815,0.258997,0.218437],[0.889436,0.837116,0.849539],[0.731434,0.637602,0.614294],[0.18962,0.102182,0.112139],[3.62328,0.131585,0.106394],[5.24115,1.36685,1.31341],[10.9166,5.36471,5.42147],[5.42547,0.276808,0.290985],[5.64058,0.279121,0.279034],[5.46763,0.53574,0.5168],[5.29286,1.07603,1.03563],[5.78458,0.536501,0.549506],[3.21523,1.12748,1.13882],[6.54437,2.03254,2.00971],[5.98581,1.92732,1.81327],[7.66486,2.55847,2.56672],[3.42706,0.12806,0.098883],[4.73143,0.925719,0.859908],[4.83294,1.13573,0.965813],[9.84339,2.50898,2.52251],[40.4326,4.64149,3.80256],[5.19757,0.247997,0.264246],[5.41506,0.209713,0.260805],[4.77753,0.216233,0.267095],[5.56149,0.814863,0.785771],[134.925,129.613,129.588],[8.71915,0.56382,0.435913],[4.87089,0.885857,0.849695],[6.30403,0.576453,0.533121],[7.8966,2.51425,2.4379],[3.59329,3.52192,3.5328],[8.12716,3.53348,3.57861],[5.20591,1.00374,0.871943],[5.04128,1.00458,0.958819],[5.07238,1.01154,1.01714],[4.55457,0.394789,0.369611],[4.56489,0.511554,0.459726],[4.09241,0.155302,0.137224],[4.12911,0.15957,0.129961],[4.13896,0.14336,0.113134]],"source":"redshift/results/2x.dc2.8xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-25","machine":"ra3.16xlarge","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":1829,"data_size":26330791936,"result":[[0.077429,0.024911,0.023306],[2.531160,0.059213,0.027695],[3.583972,0.063486,0.036182],[2.376308,0.084898,0.058801],[0.155500,0.109031,0.114305],[0.243900,0.198301,0.176052],[0.130623,0.028745,0.029271],[3.740631,0.035144,0.033783],[3.615666,0.136355,0.133104],[5.125836,1.432898,1.413138],[3.781026,0.090368,0.088729],[3.996543,0.111767,0.102832],[3.665831,0.168544,0.158393],[3.980324,0.305395,0.308288],[3.868897,0.181746,0.182552],[3.625138,0.146538,0.143406],[4.024699,0.340789,0.339775],[2.646998,0.442014,0.385201],[4.370081,0.663792,0.664333],[2.517381,0.055869,0.029468],[2.892161,0.361342,0.335877],[4.306186,0.364156,0.365814],[6.576232,1.030228,1.037391],[26.654131,1.354625,1.361705],[3.641366,0.103397,0.093371],[3.593615,0.079071,0.081853],[3.822308,0.083556,0.081115],[3.824567,0.295163,0.338925],[5.321484,1.061397,1.052438],[4.795037,0.267308,0.203014],[4.466789,0.164681,0.162661],[4.715724,0.204908,0.204441],[4.148436,0.664311,0.658639],[0.958589,0.915960,0.916875],[4.438710,0.940025,0.940112],[4.152015,0.137629,0.140684],[4.881633,0.303343,0.300780],[5.020373,0.314807,0.316961],[4.586323,0.065513,0.076092],[5.424183,0.100862,0.106056],[2.947259,0.080757,0.046727],[3.585538,0.074431,0.047424],[3.753716,0.044140,0.042809]],"source":"redshift/results/4x.ra3.16xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-25","machine":"ra3.4xlarge","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":1904,"data_size":22313697280,"result":[[2.135081,0.017989,0.017750],[2.414200,0.022495,0.022023],[6.414938,0.057299,0.055643],[6.411557,0.178071,0.177100],[3.710171,0.300286,0.303593],[3.876626,0.454045,0.477494],[6.410680,0.037709,0.036684],[5.793739,0.024525,0.023881],[5.769831,0.465373,0.490227],[5.939799,3.530177,3.572760],[6.115389,0.177672,0.161334],[6.230233,0.170112,0.166583],[4.046352,0.479846,0.481283],[4.620393,0.923121,0.952839],[4.187850,0.509904,0.518239],[5.660648,0.413803,0.411108],[5.886176,1.123718,1.103859],[3.556251,1.336332,1.381805],[6.040107,1.981635,1.965932],[2.484137,0.030438,0.029756],[4.105144,1.515947,1.515338],[6.216660,1.581792,1.581579],[9.005864,3.555306,3.567163],[30.723242,4.886720,4.885439],[5.678108,0.240413,0.239727],[5.923512,0.232055,0.231429],[5.809703,0.242922,0.242932],[5.820199,1.254403,1.253900],[8.798963,4.587414,4.592794],[13.184562,0.925342,0.873526],[6.617764,0.406749,0.404641],[6.770537,0.587831,0.586834],[5.173074,1.685266,1.713844],[6.216833,2.821660,2.859146],[6.262067,2.851894,2.835493],[5.716614,0.313373,0.328139],[5.683282,0.956320,0.974910],[5.831160,1.103328,1.104760],[6.917177,0.124116,0.107132],[7.662737,0.149158,0.149209],[4.621167,0.044216,0.043012],[4.572912,0.042941,0.042108],[5.906381,0.027692,0.026924]],"source":"redshift/results/4x.ra3.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-29","machine":"ra3.xlplus","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2103,"data_size":21060648960,"result":[[0.079613,0.033549,0.034090],[2.968579,0.063904,0.041282],[4.080153,0.130950,0.108882],[3.210337,0.343640,0.298495],[4.544852,0.631037,0.582424],[4.387295,1.084085,1.060912],[3.068245,0.108602,0.082147],[4.600868,0.045357,0.044651],[5.016095,0.911900,0.867873],[6.649061,2.367888,2.313359],[5.443231,0.309726,0.290368],[5.668514,0.333039,0.313292],[5.188214,1.085051,1.149722],[6.324090,1.961323,1.973299],[5.492480,1.144190,1.123103],[4.882748,0.733695,0.774800],[6.401272,2.257003,2.278818],[5.977724,2.511508,2.403787],[7.838491,3.470040,3.546783],[2.942119,0.094772,0.052837],[5.742532,2.535047,2.498187],[7.144539,2.607847,2.610038],[13.254883,6.773696,6.784579],[21.841477,11.673254,9.552525],[4.594945,0.474181,0.478285],[4.635551,0.494066,0.455041],[4.832767,0.474136,0.474433],[6.194060,2.059882,2.067390],[12.694282,7.745891,7.737045],[19.926847,1.349867,1.272980],[6.178553,0.845828,0.858791],[6.394659,1.080842,1.070668],[8.112381,3.869544,3.986800],[10.048186,5.276152,5.259864],[9.260186,5.163649,5.210499],[4.766534,0.646525,0.657038],[7.602645,1.880335,1.884086],[7.527802,2.172033,2.190131],[5.570360,0.229991,0.228068],[6.632048,0.286827,0.275382],[4.224273,0.103105,0.077275],[4.614709,0.102518,0.075337],[4.389546,0.052659,0.050885]],"source":"redshift/results/4x.ra3.xplus.json"} -,{"system":"SelectDB","date":"2022-11-02","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":526,"data_size":17122903966,"result":[[0.03,0.04,0.02],[0.15,0.03,0.03],[0.13,0.05,0.05],[1.05,0.06,0.05],[0.34,0.28,0.27],[0.82,0.57,0.57],[0.01,0.02,0.02],[0.22,0.02,0.02],[0.56,0.46,0.45],[0.52,0.51,0.50],[0.40,0.11,0.12],[0.18,0.12,0.12],[0.54,0.50,0.49],[0.83,0.93,0.95],[0.74,0.89,0.72],[0.32,0.31,0.31],[1.08,1.08,1.09],[0.27,0.35,0.23],[2.18,2.04,1.98],[0.02,0.01,0.02],[10.74,1.30,1.31],[8.36,3.46,0.99],[12.21,1.23,1.04],[5.20,0.52,0.50],[0.11,0.04,0.05],[0.39,0.13,0.13],[0.05,0.04,0.04],[9.43,1.80,1.16],[9.93,9.69,9.60],[0.83,0.78,0.78],[1.77,0.38,0.37],[2.57,0.41,0.43],[2.77,2.75,3.11],[11.62,4.01,3.95],[11.63,4.03,5.97],[0.46,0.40,0.39],[0.11,0.06,0.06],[0.06,0.03,0.03],[0.03,0.03,0.02],[0.13,0.11,0.10],[0.05,0.02,0.03],[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02]],"source":"selectdb/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"SelectDB","date":"2022-11-02","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":444,"data_size":17122903978,"result":[[0.03,0.03,0.02],[0.36,0.05,0.04],[0.18,0.07,0.06],[0.96,0.06,0.06],[0.32,0.28,0.29],[0.86,0.62,0.61],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[0.04,0.02,0.03],[0.50,0.47,0.47],[0.53,0.74,0.55],[0.31,0.11,0.11],[0.15,0.10,0.14],[0.57,0.62,0.55],[0.85,0.92,0.96],[0.77,0.90,0.74],[0.32,0.32,0.32],[1.22,0.99,0.98],[0.23,0.22,0.25],[2.01,1.80,1.82],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[10.76,1.05,1.04],[8.99,2.84,0.84],[12.21,1.04,0.87],[5.79,0.30,0.29],[0.12,0.04,0.04],[0.41,0.12,0.13],[0.04,0.04,0.03],[9.67,1.59,1.11],[9.06,8.23,7.84],[0.67,0.55,0.57],[1.76,0.37,0.77],[2.10,0.42,0.43],[2.78,2.76,3.11],[11.56,4.04,4.21],[11.52,4.05,4.28],[0.50,0.41,0.41],[0.63,0.05,0.05],[0.06,0.03,0.03],[0.03,0.02,0.03],[0.16,0.13,0.12],[0.06,0.01,0.03],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.03,0.02]],"source":"selectdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"SelectDB","date":"2022-10-08","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":369,"data_size":17123069872,"result":[[0.01,0.01,0.00],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.04,0.04,0.05],[0.07,0.06,0.07],[0.17,0.15,0.17],[0.30,0.30,0.28],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.32,0.33,0.34],[0.36,0.37,0.34],[0.11,0.11,0.25],[0.11,0.11,0.10],[0.23,0.23,0.23],[0.55,0.75,0.89],[0.32,0.30,0.31],[0.18,0.16,0.19],[0.53,0.51,0.50],[0.20,0.20,0.20],[1.04,1.06,1.30],[0.01,0.01,0.00],[0.59,0.60,0.66],[0.48,0.34,0.34],[0.38,0.38,0.37],[0.25,0.26,0.25],[0.04,0.04,0.04],[0.15,0.15,0.14],[0.04,0.04,0.04],[0.55,0.54,0.54],[1.39,1.36,1.34],[0.68,0.69,0.76],[0.24,0.23,0.23],[0.21,0.20,0.21],[1.45,1.53,2.05],[1.84,1.92,1.67],[1.83,1.75,1.90],[0.19,0.22,0.20],[0.03,0.04,0.04],[0.03,0.03,0.03],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.06,0.06,0.06],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02]],"source":"selectdb/results/c6a.metal.json"} -,{"system":"SingleStore","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: MemSQL. Some queries did not run due to memory limits","tags":["MySQL compatible","column-oriented"],"load_time":690,"data_size":29836263469,"result":[[0.09,0.00,0.00],[0.23,0.04,0.01],[0.47,0.15,0.15],[0.63,0.09,0.08],[1.65,1.23,1.20],[7.96,2.79,2.63],[0.10,0.00,0.00],[0.17,0.02,0.02],[1.90,1.40,1.39],[4.79,3.52,3.48],[0.94,0.22,0.23],[0.89,0.24,0.23],[5.82,2.26,2.25],[6.97,4.62,4.66],[3.05,2.28,2.31],[3.92,2.70,2.28],[5.83,4.48,4.42],[4.76,4.13,4.12],[14.03,null,null],[0.57,0.05,0.04],[18.18,1.74,1.94],[20.85,2.17,0.98],[31.98,3.12,1.22],[78.96,3.35,108.85],[2.82,0.39,0.32],[1.83,0.44,0.35],[2.81,0.33,0.32],[18.33,2.57,1.15],[null,null,null],[3.56,2.40,2.40],[3.83,1.11,1.11],[7.35,1.73,1.70],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[2.53,1.92,1.84],[0.92,0.23,0.19],[0.84,0.15,0.08],[0.70,0.05,0.05],[3.12,0.38,0.36],[0.29,0.03,0.03],[0.22,0.06,0.02],[0.27,0.11,0.12]],"source":"singlestore/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"SingleStore","date":"2022-07-15","machine":"S2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: MemSQL. Some queries did not run due to unsupported regex","tags":["MySQL compatible","column-oriented","managed"],"load_time":1145,"data_size":19219978649,"result":[[0.10,0.04,0.01],[0.13,0.00,0.01],[0.57,0.09,0.10],[0.64,0.13,0.08],[2.04,1.39,1.32],[2.56,1.95,2.15],[0.12,0.01,0.00],[0.34,0.06,0.01],[2.14,1.71,1.71],[5.70,5.10,5.49],[1.02,0.25,0.28],[1.05,0.29,0.25],[2.38,1.91,1.74],[4.04,3.40,3.46],[2.19,1.60,1.75],[1.90,1.56,1.55],[4.92,4.26,4.46],[4.13,4.01,4.03],[10.11,9.61,9.56],[0.36,0.05,0.10],[1.61,1.29,1.24],[1.04,0.55,0.57],[1.38,0.96,0.89],[3.00,2.15,2.31],[0.66,0.28,0.20],[0.67,0.19,0.16],[0.69,0.18,0.16],[1.14,0.56,0.56],[null,null,null],[3.43,1.69,1.51],[1.73,1.06,1.03],[2.17,1.60,1.45],[11.17,10.42,10.74],[9.94,9.61,9.66],[10.22,9.84,9.84],[2.31,1.79,1.97],[0.40,0.20,0.14],[0.35,0.16,0.09],[0.28,0.08,0.08],[0.68,0.28,0.36],[0.25,0.15,0.02],[0.23,0.10,0.01],[0.24,0.10,0.03]],"source":"singlestore/results/s2.json"} -,{"system":"SingleStore","date":"2022-07-15","machine":"S24","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: MemSQL. Some queries did not run due to unsupported regex","tags":["MySQL compatible","column-oriented","managed"],"load_time":1043,"data_size":19219978649,"result":[[0.10,0.04,0.07],[0.12,0.06,0.00],[0.42,0.05,0.01],[0.34,0.05,0.01],[0.97,0.29,0.23],[0.87,0.34,0.25],[0.06,0.04,0.00],[0.15,0.01,0.01],[1.04,0.39,0.31],[1.68,0.96,0.85],[0.30,0.19,0.09],[0.30,0.21,0.08],[0.56,0.26,0.35],[0.70,0.48,0.43],[0.64,0.35,0.27],[0.98,0.40,0.36],[1.52,0.75,0.86],[0.70,0.74,0.71],[1.73,1.07,0.96],[0.15,0.05,0.01],[0.37,0.20,0.26],[0.55,0.14,0.25],[0.41,0.31,0.31],[0.66,0.39,0.46],[0.52,0.12,0.08],[0.30,0.08,0.15],[0.32,0.16,0.07],[0.82,0.21,0.13],[null,null,null],[2.28,0.34,0.38],[0.55,0.28,0.17],[0.53,0.29,0.34],[1.75,1.07,1.04],[2.05,1.41,1.43],[2.11,1.45,1.40],[1.14,0.53,0.45],[0.34,0.12,0.24],[0.29,0.09,0.21],[0.35,0.11,0.18],[0.59,0.22,0.39],[0.30,0.07,0.15],[0.27,0.22,0.16],[0.29,0.06,0.06]],"source":"singlestore/results/s24.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"2XL","cluster_size":32,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.177,0.052,0.090],[0.903,0.324,0.782],[0.458,2.909,0.275],[0.881,0.316,0.166],[0.404,0.257,0.256],[0.481,0.325,0.339],[0.056,0.062,0.060],[0.183,0.324,0.280],[0.444,0.314,0.320],[0.408,0.426,0.417],[0.345,0.241,0.253],[0.406,0.245,0.235],[0.521,1.259,0.326],[0.466,0.493,0.526],[0.447,0.349,0.362],[0.327,0.322,0.302],[0.462,0.508,0.461],[0.489,0.481,0.455],[0.731,0.659,0.674],[0.151,0.156,0.160],[0.832,0.339,0.312],[0.289,0.292,0.340],[0.591,0.484,0.419],[2.661,0.716,0.696],[0.190,0.199,0.377],[0.181,0.182,0.194],[0.220,0.209,0.195],[0.368,0.330,0.347],[0.677,0.645,0.646],[0.877,0.886,0.871],[0.415,0.282,0.301],[1.265,0.404,0.550],[0.786,0.750,0.757],[0.905,0.835,0.841],[0.864,0.865,0.823],[0.352,0.360,0.364],[0.201,0.186,0.200],[0.143,0.137,0.276],[0.290,0.132,0.146],[0.310,0.301,0.304],[0.212,0.197,0.170],[0.223,0.174,0.177],[0.172,0.172,0.172]],"source":"snowflake/results/2xl.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"3XL","cluster_size":64,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.165,0.061,0.049],[1.356,1.252,1.502],[1.287,0.470,0.325],[0.627,0.331,0.181],[0.265,0.265,0.483],[0.887,0.450,0.298],[0.054,0.066,0.062],[0.182,0.222,0.194],[0.408,0.438,0.319],[0.434,0.462,0.411],[1.357,0.247,0.412],[0.343,0.250,0.517],[0.273,0.289,0.600],[0.404,0.405,0.392],[0.379,0.304,0.455],[0.275,0.271,0.264],[0.418,0.386,0.388],[0.417,0.434,0.567],[0.753,0.759,0.506],[0.291,0.307,0.400],[0.954,0.423,0.280],[0.568,0.562,0.248],[0.568,0.477,0.496],[1.458,0.492,0.514],[0.179,0.300,0.184],[0.165,0.169,0.176],[0.197,0.186,0.190],[0.289,0.547,0.397],[0.513,0.544,0.632],[0.766,0.754,0.775],[0.389,0.374,0.383],[0.484,0.297,0.286],[0.505,0.505,0.734],[0.656,0.598,0.621],[0.634,0.646,0.609],[0.309,0.298,0.370],[0.192,0.219,0.212],[0.840,0.174,0.139],[0.172,0.163,0.151],[0.323,0.296,0.347],[0.200,0.154,0.144],[0.191,0.121,0.125],[0.137,0.233,0.148]],"source":"snowflake/results/3xl.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"4XL","cluster_size":128,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.164,0.061,0.078],[2.471,2.436,1.927],[1.656,0.222,0.639],[0.336,1.244,0.206],[0.435,0.414,0.373],[0.520,0.495,0.326],[0.052,0.051,0.057],[0.244,0.515,0.358],[0.473,0.477,0.659],[0.706,0.523,0.499],[0.619,0.361,0.303],[0.463,0.367,0.290],[0.385,0.319,0.376],[0.661,0.436,0.452],[0.446,0.317,0.336],[0.504,0.283,0.395],[0.478,1.395,0.350],[0.555,1.041,0.993],[0.565,0.558,1.473],[0.310,0.684,0.278],[0.637,1.202,0.249],[0.467,0.294,0.436],[0.671,0.478,0.611],[6.262,0.449,0.425],[0.476,0.213,0.184],[0.552,0.241,0.201],[0.458,0.415,0.402],[0.339,0.357,0.322],[0.732,0.549,0.483],[0.914,0.757,0.743],[0.718,0.310,0.606],[0.605,0.363,0.425],[0.468,0.860,0.784],[0.868,1.787,0.713],[0.807,0.691,0.544],[0.485,0.338,0.672],[0.263,0.221,0.230],[0.147,0.145,0.139],[0.135,0.239,0.136],[0.322,0.378,0.348],[0.236,0.138,0.132],[0.193,0.124,0.139],[0.146,0.145,0.139]],"source":"snowflake/results/4xl.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"L","cluster_size":8,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.067,0.054,0.051],[1.158,1.409,0.190],[1.470,0.566,0.715],[0.892,0.534,0.264],[0.474,0.499,0.489],[0.950,0.650,0.699],[0.069,0.055,0.110],[0.317,0.307,0.321],[0.949,0.593,0.654],[0.713,1.099,0.860],[0.622,0.370,0.404],[0.457,0.369,0.414],[0.610,0.566,0.653],[0.970,1.006,0.976],[1.517,0.636,0.603],[0.532,0.541,0.533],[1.018,1.001,1.022],[0.942,0.996,0.940],[2.246,1.596,1.560],[0.181,0.184,0.200],[1.135,0.788,0.609],[0.669,0.528,0.524],[1.164,0.827,0.882],[3.545,2.214,2.107],[0.559,0.431,0.426],[0.340,0.296,0.383],[0.695,0.314,0.368],[0.628,0.658,0.637],[1.511,1.385,1,440],[1.390,1.418,1.322],[1.107,0.687,0.537],[1.026,0.737,0.659],[1.712,1.681,1.728],[2.141,2.130,2.225],[2.163,2.157,2.110],[0.650,0.619,0.627],[0.204,0.195,0.225],[0.159,0.152,0.156],[0.146,0.136,0.150],[0.359,0.290,0.364],[0.196,0.129,0.227],[0.201,0.128,0.143],[0.176,0.129,0.146]],"source":"snowflake/results/l.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"M","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.054,0.062,0.064],[0.698,0.563,0.407],[0.586,0.412,0.266],[1.386,0.363,0.301],[0.814,0.825,0.984],[1.303,1.024,1.048],[0.069,0.066,0.062],[0.334,0.254,0.270],[1.043,0.952,0.993],[1.210,1.209,1.171],[0.667,0.483,0.456],[0.543,0.495,0.500],[1.005,0.889,0.888],[1.644,1.646,1.652],[1.054,1.044,0.966],[0.893,0.874,0.907],[1.737,1.779,1.837],[1.518,1.539,1.526],[3.082,2.818,2.842],[0.309,0.286,0.256],[1.594,1.017,0.993],[0.781,0.853,0.735],[1.461,1.226,1.080],[5.308,2.974,2.642],[0.511,0.625,0.467],[0.405,0.382,0.439],[0.601,0.535,0.471],[0.947,1.624,1.192],[2.631,2.486,2.490],[1.938,1.960,1.954],[1.930,0.830,0.835],[1.359,1.140,1.062],[3.599,3.623,3.621],[3.619,3.741,3.663],[3.725,3.614,3.786],[1.149,1.126,1.055],[0.202,0.207,0.196],[0.152,0.139,0.145],[0.149,0.144,0.148],[0.383,0.287,0.294],[0.203,0.137,0.119],[0.200,0.312,0.137],[0.149,0.130,0.214]],"source":"snowflake/results/m.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"S","cluster_size":2,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.186,0.060,0.062],[0.980,0.574,0.311],[0.977,0.554,0.426],[0.686,0.573,0.404],[1.386,1.384,1.349],[1.871,1.697,1.704],[0.052,0.059,0.227],[0.309,0.536,0.508],[1.768,1.631,1.635],[2.039,2.219,1.908],[0.807,0.647,0.587],[0.763,0.690,0.631],[1.403,1.586,1.404],[2.593,2.584,2.554],[1.670,1.538,1.653],[1.659,1.509,1.514],[2.875,2.990,2.998],[2.605,2.549,2.598],[6.120,5.894,5.766],[0.320,0.431,0.416],[2.406,1.703,1.609],[1.189,1.186,1.163],[2.104,1.441,1.370],[7.144,5.174,4.139],[0.839,0.659,0.641],[0.527,0.518,0.509],[0.633,0.621,0.695],[1.491,1.509,1.514],[4.848,4.485,4.571],[3.067,3.106,3.098],[1.521,1.224,1.236],[1.839,1.690,1.497],[5.692,5.751,6.087],[6.733,6.755,6.712],[6.722,6.709,6.676],[1.704,1.686,1.676],[0.203,0.231,0.218],[0.151,0.134,0.214],[0.140,0.156,0.163],[0.317,0.328,0.319],[0.166,0.133,0.141],[0.166,0.120,0.140],[0.120,0.119,0.126]],"source":"snowflake/results/s.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"XL","cluster_size":16,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.071,0.053,0.057],[0.998,0.610,0.240],[0.420,1.138,1.051],[0.653,0.264,0.178],[0.352,0.312,0.349],[1.126,0.431,0.420],[0.067,0.057,0.054],[0.225,0.217,0.200],[0.617,0.366,0.371],[1.006,0.541,0.498],[0.463,0.425,0.293],[0.431,0.360,0.339],[0.392,0.371,0.386],[0.588,0.581,0.590],[0.634,0.414,0.400],[0.368,0.410,0.388],[0.594,0.639,0.663],[0.616,0.581,0.569],[1.092,0.933,0.901],[0.493,0.213,0.160],[0.886,0.480,0.442],[0.448,0.337,0.399],[0.840,0.572,0.505],[2.251,1.230,0.959],[0.295,0.253,0.241],[0.214,0.239,0.278],[0.261,0.232,0.314],[0.422,0.429,0.403],[0.892,0.934,0.883],[1.041,1.017,1.009],[0.715,0.442,0.363],[0.845,0.413,0.461],[1.101,1.085,1.102],[1.294,1.272,1.339],[1.839,1.327,1.241],[0.439,0.399,0.393],[0.199,0.211,0.190],[0.157,0.143,0.140],[0.145,0.157,0.141],[0.331,0.291,0.333],[0.173,0.214,0.138],[0.189,0.150,0.159],[0.135,0.149,0.138]],"source":"snowflake/results/xl.json"} -,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"XS","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.169,0.055,0.056],[1.184,0.582,0.386],[1.350,0.560,0.568],[1.270,0.554,0.538],[2.516,2.564,2.506],[2.935,2.649,2.670],[0.052,0.050,0.064],[0.383,0.387,0.397],[3.249,2.993,3.014],[3.589,3.627,3.887],[1.243,0.986,0.966],[1.325,1.080,1.073],[2.038,2.046,2.035],[3.738,3.626,3.718],[2.318,2.159,2.176],[2.733,2.637,2.668],[5.607,5.683,5.667],[3.978,3.923,3.879],[10.085,9.871,9.844],[0.450,0.375,0.469],[5.474,3.103,3.060],[2.012,1.982,1.971],[3.365,2.471,2.501],[11.960,10.619,9.518],[1.074,1.059,1.026],[0.856,0.846,0.879],[1.100,1.085,1.083],[3.057,3.228,3.117],[9.406,9.019,9.158],[6.196,6.243,6.911],[2.906,2.343,2.017],[2.954,2.666,2.565],[9.459,9.565,9.557],[9.555,9.529,9.368],[9.409,9.185,9.294],[2.796,2.880,2.685],[0.299,0.249,0.262],[0.156,0.145,0.180],[0.147,0.146,0.160],[0.371,0.357,0.356],[0.166,0.133,0.155],[0.218,0.140,0.135],[0.140,0.152,0.158]],"source":"snowflake/results/xs.json"} +,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-25","machine":"ra3.16xlarge","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":1829,"data_size":26330791936,"result":[[0.077429,0.024911,0.023306],[2.53116,0.059213,0.027695],[3.583972,0.063486,0.036182],[2.376308,0.084898,0.058801],[0.1555,0.109031,0.114305],[0.2439,0.198301,0.176052],[0.130623,0.028745,0.029271],[3.740631,0.035144,0.033783],[3.615666,0.136355,0.133104],[5.125836,1.432898,1.413138],[3.781026,0.090368,0.088729],[3.996543,0.111767,0.102832],[3.665831,0.168544,0.158393],[3.980324,0.305395,0.308288],[3.868897,0.181746,0.182552],[3.625138,0.146538,0.143406],[4.024699,0.340789,0.339775],[2.646998,0.442014,0.385201],[4.370081,0.663792,0.664333],[2.517381,0.055869,0.029468],[2.892161,0.361342,0.335877],[4.306186,0.364156,0.365814],[6.576232,1.030228,1.037391],[26.654131,1.354625,1.361705],[3.641366,0.103397,0.093371],[3.593615,0.079071,0.081853],[3.822308,0.083556,0.081115],[3.824567,0.295163,0.338925],[5.321484,1.061397,1.052438],[4.795037,0.267308,0.203014],[4.466789,0.164681,0.162661],[4.715724,0.204908,0.204441],[4.148436,0.664311,0.658639],[0.958589,0.91596,0.916875],[4.43871,0.940025,0.940112],[4.152015,0.137629,0.140684],[4.881633,0.303343,0.30078],[5.020373,0.314807,0.316961],[4.586323,0.065513,0.076092],[5.424183,0.100862,0.106056],[2.947259,0.080757,0.046727],[3.585538,0.074431,0.047424],[3.753716,0.04414,0.042809]],"source":"redshift/results/4x.ra3.16xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-25","machine":"ra3.4xlarge","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":1904,"data_size":22313697280,"result":[[2.135081,0.017989,0.01775],[2.4142,0.022495,0.022023],[6.414938,0.057299,0.055643],[6.411557,0.178071,0.1771],[3.710171,0.300286,0.303593],[3.876626,0.454045,0.477494],[6.41068,0.037709,0.036684],[5.793739,0.024525,0.023881],[5.769831,0.465373,0.490227],[5.939799,3.530177,3.57276],[6.115389,0.177672,0.161334],[6.230233,0.170112,0.166583],[4.046352,0.479846,0.481283],[4.620393,0.923121,0.952839],[4.18785,0.509904,0.518239],[5.660648,0.413803,0.411108],[5.886176,1.123718,1.103859],[3.556251,1.336332,1.381805],[6.040107,1.981635,1.965932],[2.484137,0.030438,0.029756],[4.105144,1.515947,1.515338],[6.21666,1.581792,1.581579],[9.005864,3.555306,3.567163],[30.723242,4.88672,4.885439],[5.678108,0.240413,0.239727],[5.923512,0.232055,0.231429],[5.809703,0.242922,0.242932],[5.820199,1.254403,1.2539],[8.798963,4.587414,4.592794],[13.184562,0.925342,0.873526],[6.617764,0.406749,0.404641],[6.770537,0.587831,0.586834],[5.173074,1.685266,1.713844],[6.216833,2.82166,2.859146],[6.262067,2.851894,2.835493],[5.716614,0.313373,0.328139],[5.683282,0.95632,0.97491],[5.83116,1.103328,1.10476],[6.917177,0.124116,0.107132],[7.662737,0.149158,0.149209],[4.621167,0.044216,0.043012],[4.572912,0.042941,0.042108],[5.906381,0.027692,0.026924]],"source":"redshift/results/4x.ra3.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"Redshift","date":"2022-07-29","machine":"ra3.xlplus","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2103,"data_size":21060648960,"result":[[0.079613,0.033549,0.03409],[2.968579,0.063904,0.041282],[4.080153,0.13095,0.108882],[3.210337,0.34364,0.298495],[4.544852,0.631037,0.582424],[4.387295,1.084085,1.060912],[3.068245,0.108602,0.082147],[4.600868,0.045357,0.044651],[5.016095,0.9119,0.867873],[6.649061,2.367888,2.313359],[5.443231,0.309726,0.290368],[5.668514,0.333039,0.313292],[5.188214,1.085051,1.149722],[6.32409,1.961323,1.973299],[5.49248,1.14419,1.123103],[4.882748,0.733695,0.7748],[6.401272,2.257003,2.278818],[5.977724,2.511508,2.403787],[7.838491,3.47004,3.546783],[2.942119,0.094772,0.052837],[5.742532,2.535047,2.498187],[7.144539,2.607847,2.610038],[13.254883,6.773696,6.784579],[21.841477,11.673254,9.552525],[4.594945,0.474181,0.478285],[4.635551,0.494066,0.455041],[4.832767,0.474136,0.474433],[6.19406,2.059882,2.06739],[12.694282,7.745891,7.737045],[19.926847,1.349867,1.27298],[6.178553,0.845828,0.858791],[6.394659,1.080842,1.070668],[8.112381,3.869544,3.9868],[10.048186,5.276152,5.259864],[9.260186,5.163649,5.210499],[4.766534,0.646525,0.657038],[7.602645,1.880335,1.884086],[7.527802,2.172033,2.190131],[5.57036,0.229991,0.228068],[6.632048,0.286827,0.275382],[4.224273,0.103105,0.077275],[4.614709,0.102518,0.075337],[4.389546,0.052659,0.050885]],"source":"redshift/results/4x.ra3.xplus.json"} +,{"system":"SelectDB","date":"2022-11-02","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":526,"data_size":17122903966,"result":[[0.03,0.04,0.02],[0.15,0.03,0.03],[0.13,0.05,0.05],[1.05,0.06,0.05],[0.34,0.28,0.27],[0.82,0.57,0.57],[0.01,0.02,0.02],[0.22,0.02,0.02],[0.56,0.46,0.45],[0.52,0.51,0.5],[0.4,0.11,0.12],[0.18,0.12,0.12],[0.54,0.5,0.49],[0.83,0.93,0.95],[0.74,0.89,0.72],[0.32,0.31,0.31],[1.08,1.08,1.09],[0.27,0.35,0.23],[2.18,2.04,1.98],[0.02,0.01,0.02],[10.74,1.3,1.31],[8.36,3.46,0.99],[12.21,1.23,1.04],[5.2,0.52,0.5],[0.11,0.04,0.05],[0.39,0.13,0.13],[0.05,0.04,0.04],[9.43,1.8,1.16],[9.93,9.69,9.6],[0.83,0.78,0.78],[1.77,0.38,0.37],[2.57,0.41,0.43],[2.77,2.75,3.11],[11.62,4.01,3.95],[11.63,4.03,5.97],[0.46,0.4,0.39],[0.11,0.06,0.06],[0.06,0.03,0.03],[0.03,0.03,0.02],[0.13,0.11,0.1],[0.05,0.02,0.03],[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02]],"source":"selectdb/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"SelectDB","date":"2022-11-02","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":444,"data_size":17122903978,"result":[[0.03,0.03,0.02],[0.36,0.05,0.04],[0.18,0.07,0.06],[0.96,0.06,0.06],[0.32,0.28,0.29],[0.86,0.62,0.61],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[0.04,0.02,0.03],[0.5,0.47,0.47],[0.53,0.74,0.55],[0.31,0.11,0.11],[0.15,0.1,0.14],[0.57,0.62,0.55],[0.85,0.92,0.96],[0.77,0.9,0.74],[0.32,0.32,0.32],[1.22,0.99,0.98],[0.23,0.22,0.25],[2.01,1.8,1.82],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[10.76,1.05,1.04],[8.99,2.84,0.84],[12.21,1.04,0.87],[5.79,0.3,0.29],[0.12,0.04,0.04],[0.41,0.12,0.13],[0.04,0.04,0.03],[9.67,1.59,1.11],[9.06,8.23,7.84],[0.67,0.55,0.57],[1.76,0.37,0.77],[2.1,0.42,0.43],[2.78,2.76,3.11],[11.56,4.04,4.21],[11.52,4.05,4.28],[0.5,0.41,0.41],[0.63,0.05,0.05],[0.06,0.03,0.03],[0.03,0.02,0.03],[0.16,0.13,0.12],[0.06,0.01,0.03],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.03,0.02]],"source":"selectdb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"SelectDB","date":"2022-10-08","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":369,"data_size":17123069872,"result":[[0.01,0.01,0],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.04,0.04,0.05],[0.07,0.06,0.07],[0.17,0.15,0.17],[0.3,0.3,0.28],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.32,0.33,0.34],[0.36,0.37,0.34],[0.11,0.11,0.25],[0.11,0.11,0.1],[0.23,0.23,0.23],[0.55,0.75,0.89],[0.32,0.3,0.31],[0.18,0.16,0.19],[0.53,0.51,0.5],[0.2,0.2,0.2],[1.04,1.06,1.3],[0.01,0.01,0],[0.59,0.6,0.66],[0.48,0.34,0.34],[0.38,0.38,0.37],[0.25,0.26,0.25],[0.04,0.04,0.04],[0.15,0.15,0.14],[0.04,0.04,0.04],[0.55,0.54,0.54],[1.39,1.36,1.34],[0.68,0.69,0.76],[0.24,0.23,0.23],[0.21,0.2,0.21],[1.45,1.53,2.05],[1.84,1.92,1.67],[1.83,1.75,1.9],[0.19,0.22,0.2],[0.03,0.04,0.04],[0.03,0.03,0.03],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.06,0.06,0.06],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02]],"source":"selectdb/results/c6a.metal.json"} +,{"system":"SingleStore","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: MemSQL. Some queries did not run due to memory limits","tags":["MySQL compatible","column-oriented"],"load_time":690,"data_size":29836263469,"result":[[0.09,0,0],[0.23,0.04,0.01],[0.47,0.15,0.15],[0.63,0.09,0.08],[1.65,1.23,1.2],[7.96,2.79,2.63],[0.1,0,0],[0.17,0.02,0.02],[1.9,1.4,1.39],[4.79,3.52,3.48],[0.94,0.22,0.23],[0.89,0.24,0.23],[5.82,2.26,2.25],[6.97,4.62,4.66],[3.05,2.28,2.31],[3.92,2.7,2.28],[5.83,4.48,4.42],[4.76,4.13,4.12],[14.03,null,null],[0.57,0.05,0.04],[18.18,1.74,1.94],[20.85,2.17,0.98],[31.98,3.12,1.22],[78.96,3.35,108.85],[2.82,0.39,0.32],[1.83,0.44,0.35],[2.81,0.33,0.32],[18.33,2.57,1.15],[null,null,null],[3.56,2.4,2.4],[3.83,1.11,1.11],[7.35,1.73,1.7],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[2.53,1.92,1.84],[0.92,0.23,0.19],[0.84,0.15,0.08],[0.7,0.05,0.05],[3.12,0.38,0.36],[0.29,0.03,0.03],[0.22,0.06,0.02],[0.27,0.11,0.12]],"source":"singlestore/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"SingleStore","date":"2022-07-15","machine":"S2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: MemSQL. Some queries did not run due to unsupported regex","tags":["MySQL compatible","column-oriented","managed"],"load_time":1145,"data_size":19219978649,"result":[[0.1,0.04,0.01],[0.13,0,0.01],[0.57,0.09,0.1],[0.64,0.13,0.08],[2.04,1.39,1.32],[2.56,1.95,2.15],[0.12,0.01,0],[0.34,0.06,0.01],[2.14,1.71,1.71],[5.7,5.1,5.49],[1.02,0.25,0.28],[1.05,0.29,0.25],[2.38,1.91,1.74],[4.04,3.4,3.46],[2.19,1.6,1.75],[1.9,1.56,1.55],[4.92,4.26,4.46],[4.13,4.01,4.03],[10.11,9.61,9.56],[0.36,0.05,0.1],[1.61,1.29,1.24],[1.04,0.55,0.57],[1.38,0.96,0.89],[3,2.15,2.31],[0.66,0.28,0.2],[0.67,0.19,0.16],[0.69,0.18,0.16],[1.14,0.56,0.56],[null,null,null],[3.43,1.69,1.51],[1.73,1.06,1.03],[2.17,1.6,1.45],[11.17,10.42,10.74],[9.94,9.61,9.66],[10.22,9.84,9.84],[2.31,1.79,1.97],[0.4,0.2,0.14],[0.35,0.16,0.09],[0.28,0.08,0.08],[0.68,0.28,0.36],[0.25,0.15,0.02],[0.23,0.1,0.01],[0.24,0.1,0.03]],"source":"singlestore/results/s2.json"} +,{"system":"SingleStore","date":"2022-07-15","machine":"S24","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Previous name: MemSQL. Some queries did not run due to unsupported regex","tags":["MySQL compatible","column-oriented","managed"],"load_time":1043,"data_size":19219978649,"result":[[0.1,0.04,0.07],[0.12,0.06,0],[0.42,0.05,0.01],[0.34,0.05,0.01],[0.97,0.29,0.23],[0.87,0.34,0.25],[0.06,0.04,0],[0.15,0.01,0.01],[1.04,0.39,0.31],[1.68,0.96,0.85],[0.3,0.19,0.09],[0.3,0.21,0.08],[0.56,0.26,0.35],[0.7,0.48,0.43],[0.64,0.35,0.27],[0.98,0.4,0.36],[1.52,0.75,0.86],[0.7,0.74,0.71],[1.73,1.07,0.96],[0.15,0.05,0.01],[0.37,0.2,0.26],[0.55,0.14,0.25],[0.41,0.31,0.31],[0.66,0.39,0.46],[0.52,0.12,0.08],[0.3,0.08,0.15],[0.32,0.16,0.07],[0.82,0.21,0.13],[null,null,null],[2.28,0.34,0.38],[0.55,0.28,0.17],[0.53,0.29,0.34],[1.75,1.07,1.04],[2.05,1.41,1.43],[2.11,1.45,1.4],[1.14,0.53,0.45],[0.34,0.12,0.24],[0.29,0.09,0.21],[0.35,0.11,0.18],[0.59,0.22,0.39],[0.3,0.07,0.15],[0.27,0.22,0.16],[0.29,0.06,0.06]],"source":"singlestore/results/s24.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"2XL","cluster_size":32,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.177,0.052,0.09],[0.903,0.324,0.782],[0.458,2.909,0.275],[0.881,0.316,0.166],[0.404,0.257,0.256],[0.481,0.325,0.339],[0.056,0.062,0.06],[0.183,0.324,0.28],[0.444,0.314,0.32],[0.408,0.426,0.417],[0.345,0.241,0.253],[0.406,0.245,0.235],[0.521,1.259,0.326],[0.466,0.493,0.526],[0.447,0.349,0.362],[0.327,0.322,0.302],[0.462,0.508,0.461],[0.489,0.481,0.455],[0.731,0.659,0.674],[0.151,0.156,0.16],[0.832,0.339,0.312],[0.289,0.292,0.34],[0.591,0.484,0.419],[2.661,0.716,0.696],[0.19,0.199,0.377],[0.181,0.182,0.194],[0.22,0.209,0.195],[0.368,0.33,0.347],[0.677,0.645,0.646],[0.877,0.886,0.871],[0.415,0.282,0.301],[1.265,0.404,0.55],[0.786,0.75,0.757],[0.905,0.835,0.841],[0.864,0.865,0.823],[0.352,0.36,0.364],[0.201,0.186,0.2],[0.143,0.137,0.276],[0.29,0.132,0.146],[0.31,0.301,0.304],[0.212,0.197,0.17],[0.223,0.174,0.177],[0.172,0.172,0.172]],"source":"snowflake/results/2xl.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"3XL","cluster_size":64,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.165,0.061,0.049],[1.356,1.252,1.502],[1.287,0.47,0.325],[0.627,0.331,0.181],[0.265,0.265,0.483],[0.887,0.45,0.298],[0.054,0.066,0.062],[0.182,0.222,0.194],[0.408,0.438,0.319],[0.434,0.462,0.411],[1.357,0.247,0.412],[0.343,0.25,0.517],[0.273,0.289,0.6],[0.404,0.405,0.392],[0.379,0.304,0.455],[0.275,0.271,0.264],[0.418,0.386,0.388],[0.417,0.434,0.567],[0.753,0.759,0.506],[0.291,0.307,0.4],[0.954,0.423,0.28],[0.568,0.562,0.248],[0.568,0.477,0.496],[1.458,0.492,0.514],[0.179,0.3,0.184],[0.165,0.169,0.176],[0.197,0.186,0.19],[0.289,0.547,0.397],[0.513,0.544,0.632],[0.766,0.754,0.775],[0.389,0.374,0.383],[0.484,0.297,0.286],[0.505,0.505,0.734],[0.656,0.598,0.621],[0.634,0.646,0.609],[0.309,0.298,0.37],[0.192,0.219,0.212],[0.84,0.174,0.139],[0.172,0.163,0.151],[0.323,0.296,0.347],[0.2,0.154,0.144],[0.191,0.121,0.125],[0.137,0.233,0.148]],"source":"snowflake/results/3xl.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"4XL","cluster_size":128,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.164,0.061,0.078],[2.471,2.436,1.927],[1.656,0.222,0.639],[0.336,1.244,0.206],[0.435,0.414,0.373],[0.52,0.495,0.326],[0.052,0.051,0.057],[0.244,0.515,0.358],[0.473,0.477,0.659],[0.706,0.523,0.499],[0.619,0.361,0.303],[0.463,0.367,0.29],[0.385,0.319,0.376],[0.661,0.436,0.452],[0.446,0.317,0.336],[0.504,0.283,0.395],[0.478,1.395,0.35],[0.555,1.041,0.993],[0.565,0.558,1.473],[0.31,0.684,0.278],[0.637,1.202,0.249],[0.467,0.294,0.436],[0.671,0.478,0.611],[6.262,0.449,0.425],[0.476,0.213,0.184],[0.552,0.241,0.201],[0.458,0.415,0.402],[0.339,0.357,0.322],[0.732,0.549,0.483],[0.914,0.757,0.743],[0.718,0.31,0.606],[0.605,0.363,0.425],[0.468,0.86,0.784],[0.868,1.787,0.713],[0.807,0.691,0.544],[0.485,0.338,0.672],[0.263,0.221,0.23],[0.147,0.145,0.139],[0.135,0.239,0.136],[0.322,0.378,0.348],[0.236,0.138,0.132],[0.193,0.124,0.139],[0.146,0.145,0.139]],"source":"snowflake/results/4xl.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"L","cluster_size":8,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.067,0.054,0.051],[1.158,1.409,0.19],[1.47,0.566,0.715],[0.892,0.534,0.264],[0.474,0.499,0.489],[0.95,0.65,0.699],[0.069,0.055,0.11],[0.317,0.307,0.321],[0.949,0.593,0.654],[0.713,1.099,0.86],[0.622,0.37,0.404],[0.457,0.369,0.414],[0.61,0.566,0.653],[0.97,1.006,0.976],[1.517,0.636,0.603],[0.532,0.541,0.533],[1.018,1.001,1.022],[0.942,0.996,0.94],[2.246,1.596,1.56],[0.181,0.184,0.2],[1.135,0.788,0.609],[0.669,0.528,0.524],[1.164,0.827,0.882],[3.545,2.214,2.107],[0.559,0.431,0.426],[0.34,0.296,0.383],[0.695,0.314,0.368],[0.628,0.658,0.637],[1.511,1.385,1,440],[1.39,1.418,1.322],[1.107,0.687,0.537],[1.026,0.737,0.659],[1.712,1.681,1.728],[2.141,2.13,2.225],[2.163,2.157,2.11],[0.65,0.619,0.627],[0.204,0.195,0.225],[0.159,0.152,0.156],[0.146,0.136,0.15],[0.359,0.29,0.364],[0.196,0.129,0.227],[0.201,0.128,0.143],[0.176,0.129,0.146]],"source":"snowflake/results/l.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"M","cluster_size":4,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.054,0.062,0.064],[0.698,0.563,0.407],[0.586,0.412,0.266],[1.386,0.363,0.301],[0.814,0.825,0.984],[1.303,1.024,1.048],[0.069,0.066,0.062],[0.334,0.254,0.27],[1.043,0.952,0.993],[1.21,1.209,1.171],[0.667,0.483,0.456],[0.543,0.495,0.5],[1.005,0.889,0.888],[1.644,1.646,1.652],[1.054,1.044,0.966],[0.893,0.874,0.907],[1.737,1.779,1.837],[1.518,1.539,1.526],[3.082,2.818,2.842],[0.309,0.286,0.256],[1.594,1.017,0.993],[0.781,0.853,0.735],[1.461,1.226,1.08],[5.308,2.974,2.642],[0.511,0.625,0.467],[0.405,0.382,0.439],[0.601,0.535,0.471],[0.947,1.624,1.192],[2.631,2.486,2.49],[1.938,1.96,1.954],[1.93,0.83,0.835],[1.359,1.14,1.062],[3.599,3.623,3.621],[3.619,3.741,3.663],[3.725,3.614,3.786],[1.149,1.126,1.055],[0.202,0.207,0.196],[0.152,0.139,0.145],[0.149,0.144,0.148],[0.383,0.287,0.294],[0.203,0.137,0.119],[0.2,0.312,0.137],[0.149,0.13,0.214]],"source":"snowflake/results/m.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"S","cluster_size":2,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.186,0.06,0.062],[0.98,0.574,0.311],[0.977,0.554,0.426],[0.686,0.573,0.404],[1.386,1.384,1.349],[1.871,1.697,1.704],[0.052,0.059,0.227],[0.309,0.536,0.508],[1.768,1.631,1.635],[2.039,2.219,1.908],[0.807,0.647,0.587],[0.763,0.69,0.631],[1.403,1.586,1.404],[2.593,2.584,2.554],[1.67,1.538,1.653],[1.659,1.509,1.514],[2.875,2.99,2.998],[2.605,2.549,2.598],[6.12,5.894,5.766],[0.32,0.431,0.416],[2.406,1.703,1.609],[1.189,1.186,1.163],[2.104,1.441,1.37],[7.144,5.174,4.139],[0.839,0.659,0.641],[0.527,0.518,0.509],[0.633,0.621,0.695],[1.491,1.509,1.514],[4.848,4.485,4.571],[3.067,3.106,3.098],[1.521,1.224,1.236],[1.839,1.69,1.497],[5.692,5.751,6.087],[6.733,6.755,6.712],[6.722,6.709,6.676],[1.704,1.686,1.676],[0.203,0.231,0.218],[0.151,0.134,0.214],[0.14,0.156,0.163],[0.317,0.328,0.319],[0.166,0.133,0.141],[0.166,0.12,0.14],[0.12,0.119,0.126]],"source":"snowflake/results/s.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"XL","cluster_size":16,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.071,0.053,0.057],[0.998,0.61,0.24],[0.42,1.138,1.051],[0.653,0.264,0.178],[0.352,0.312,0.349],[1.126,0.431,0.42],[0.067,0.057,0.054],[0.225,0.217,0.2],[0.617,0.366,0.371],[1.006,0.541,0.498],[0.463,0.425,0.293],[0.431,0.36,0.339],[0.392,0.371,0.386],[0.588,0.581,0.59],[0.634,0.414,0.4],[0.368,0.41,0.388],[0.594,0.639,0.663],[0.616,0.581,0.569],[1.092,0.933,0.901],[0.493,0.213,0.16],[0.886,0.48,0.442],[0.448,0.337,0.399],[0.84,0.572,0.505],[2.251,1.23,0.959],[0.295,0.253,0.241],[0.214,0.239,0.278],[0.261,0.232,0.314],[0.422,0.429,0.403],[0.892,0.934,0.883],[1.041,1.017,1.009],[0.715,0.442,0.363],[0.845,0.413,0.461],[1.101,1.085,1.102],[1.294,1.272,1.339],[1.839,1.327,1.241],[0.439,0.399,0.393],[0.199,0.211,0.19],[0.157,0.143,0.14],[0.145,0.157,0.141],[0.331,0.291,0.333],[0.173,0.214,0.138],[0.189,0.15,0.159],[0.135,0.149,0.138]],"source":"snowflake/results/xl.json"} +,{"system":"Snowflake","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"XS","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["managed","column-oriented"],"load_time":2524,"data_size":12300000000,"result":[[0.169,0.055,0.056],[1.184,0.582,0.386],[1.35,0.56,0.568],[1.27,0.554,0.538],[2.516,2.564,2.506],[2.935,2.649,2.67],[0.052,0.05,0.064],[0.383,0.387,0.397],[3.249,2.993,3.014],[3.589,3.627,3.887],[1.243,0.986,0.966],[1.325,1.08,1.073],[2.038,2.046,2.035],[3.738,3.626,3.718],[2.318,2.159,2.176],[2.733,2.637,2.668],[5.607,5.683,5.667],[3.978,3.923,3.879],[10.085,9.871,9.844],[0.45,0.375,0.469],[5.474,3.103,3.06],[2.012,1.982,1.971],[3.365,2.471,2.501],[11.96,10.619,9.518],[1.074,1.059,1.026],[0.856,0.846,0.879],[1.1,1.085,1.083],[3.057,3.228,3.117],[9.406,9.019,9.158],[6.196,6.243,6.911],[2.906,2.343,2.017],[2.954,2.666,2.565],[9.459,9.565,9.557],[9.555,9.529,9.368],[9.409,9.185,9.294],[2.796,2.88,2.685],[0.299,0.249,0.262],[0.156,0.145,0.18],[0.147,0.146,0.16],[0.371,0.357,0.356],[0.166,0.133,0.155],[0.218,0.14,0.135],[0.14,0.152,0.158]],"source":"snowflake/results/xs.json"} ,{"system":"SQLite","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","embedded","row-oriented"],"load_time":2608,"data_size":75776589824,"result":[[752.739,2.003,1.2],[304.302,291.521,286.965],[293.964,287.619,287.219],[758.302,5.879,5.65],[836.393,48.593,48.452],[362.605,344.884,356.245],[763.993,11.602,10.795],[296.348,286.879,287.557],[365.816,360.339,354.126],[374.403,365.196,362.261],[302.989,293.888,298.432],[303.64,291.729,295.347],[316.824,298.18,301.006],[320.665,301.15,305.227],[313.593,301.021,301.626],[794.881,47,47.225],[355.346,344.615,342.442],[316.499,305.971,305.007],[398.177,380.383,385.571],[751.82,5.082,4.913],[295.522,286.573,287.368],[298.58,287.182,288.303],[296.474,288.747,288.638],[296.579,287.127,287.361],[304.709,286.865,287.56],[300.391,290.633,288.587],[294.605,286.91,287.799],[305.986,312.111,305.626],[null,null,null],[411.225,397.614,394.253],[307.711,295.181,300.266],[312.472,299.079,298.19],[386.674,378.347,376.963],[409.742,409.554,420.273],[468.73,453.709,458.149],[366.015,347.446,346.728],[2.911,0.781,0.757],[1.599,0.609,0.587],[1.288,0.256,0.238],[2.469,1.582,1.52],[1.274,0.303,0.283],[1.322,0.317,0.314],[1.498,0.602,0.613]],"source":"sqlite/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"StarRocks","date":"2022-09-25","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":492,"data_size":17233927256,"result":[[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.21,0.03,0.04],[1.88,0.07,0.07],[3.40,0.09,0.10],[0.37,0.34,0.33],[2.71,0.88,0.84],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.06,0.03,0.03],[1.66,0.53,0.47],[1.58,1.52,1.47],[0.68,0.10,0.11],[1.26,0.12,0.12],[0.54,0.54,0.54],[0.99,0.96,0.99],[0.81,0.77,0.80],[0.41,0.39,0.40],[1.45,1.49,1.52],[0.52,0.52,0.51],[2.98,2.60,2.56],[0.02,0.01,0.00],[12.97,1.10,1.11],[14.84,0.91,0.94],[27.68,1.96,1.94],[46.49,1.49,1.22],[0.16,0.11,0.07],[0.94,0.12,0.12],[0.06,0.05,0.04],[13.99,1.44,1.42],[11.58,10.20,10.37],[0.22,0.10,0.11],[4.60,0.38,0.36],[4.15,0.53,0.52],[3.54,3.48,3.48],[15.22,6.08,6.17],[14.90,6.34,6.31],[1.86,0.59,0.51],[0.99,0.09,0.08],[0.42,0.05,0.05],[0.15,0.04,0.04],[1.27,0.18,0.18],[0.32,0.04,0.03],[0.11,0.03,0.04],[0.08,0.03,0.02]],"source":"starrocks/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"StarRocks","date":"2023-02-10","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":433,"data_size":17705230744,"result":[[0.04,0.04,0.03],[0.12,0.03,0.03],[0.66,0.06,0.06],[2.08,0.08,0.06],[0.10,0.08,0.09],[2.19,0.22,0.21],[0.04,0.02,0.03],[0.06,0.04,0.04],[0.99,0.12,0.12],[0.73,0.74,0.70],[0.13,0.06,0.05],[1.04,0.06,0.07],[0.17,0.18,0.17],[0.23,0.23,0.23],[0.54,0.18,0.18],[0.09,0.09,0.08],[0.31,0.32,0.30],[0.12,0.10,0.11],[1.27,0.48,0.44],[0.01,0.01,0.00],[12.09,0.17,0.15],[0.17,0.13,0.12],[10.91,0.28,0.24],[28.25,0.86,1.36],[0.03,0.03,0.02],[0.06,0.04,0.04],[0.02,0.03,0.02],[0.63,0.24,0.21],[8.77,1.60,1.64],[0.12,0.10,0.10],[1.33,0.13,0.13],[3.46,0.18,0.19],[0.97,0.86,0.86],[0.95,0.96,0.98],[0.96,0.97,0.97],[0.14,0.12,0.14],[0.07,0.06,0.06],[0.05,0.04,0.04],[0.04,0.03,0.03],[0.10,0.09,0.09],[0.47,0.03,0.03],[0.25,0.03,0.03],[0.04,0.03,0.03]],"source":"starrocks/results/c6a.metal.json"} +,{"system":"StarRocks","date":"2022-09-25","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":492,"data_size":17233927256,"result":[[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.21,0.03,0.04],[1.88,0.07,0.07],[3.4,0.09,0.1],[0.37,0.34,0.33],[2.71,0.88,0.84],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.06,0.03,0.03],[1.66,0.53,0.47],[1.58,1.52,1.47],[0.68,0.1,0.11],[1.26,0.12,0.12],[0.54,0.54,0.54],[0.99,0.96,0.99],[0.81,0.77,0.8],[0.41,0.39,0.4],[1.45,1.49,1.52],[0.52,0.52,0.51],[2.98,2.6,2.56],[0.02,0.01,0],[12.97,1.1,1.11],[14.84,0.91,0.94],[27.68,1.96,1.94],[46.49,1.49,1.22],[0.16,0.11,0.07],[0.94,0.12,0.12],[0.06,0.05,0.04],[13.99,1.44,1.42],[11.58,10.2,10.37],[0.22,0.1,0.11],[4.6,0.38,0.36],[4.15,0.53,0.52],[3.54,3.48,3.48],[15.22,6.08,6.17],[14.9,6.34,6.31],[1.86,0.59,0.51],[0.99,0.09,0.08],[0.42,0.05,0.05],[0.15,0.04,0.04],[1.27,0.18,0.18],[0.32,0.04,0.03],[0.11,0.03,0.04],[0.08,0.03,0.02]],"source":"starrocks/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"StarRocks","date":"2023-02-10","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":433,"data_size":17705230744,"result":[[0.04,0.04,0.03],[0.12,0.03,0.03],[0.66,0.06,0.06],[2.08,0.08,0.06],[0.1,0.08,0.09],[2.19,0.22,0.21],[0.04,0.02,0.03],[0.06,0.04,0.04],[0.99,0.12,0.12],[0.73,0.74,0.7],[0.13,0.06,0.05],[1.04,0.06,0.07],[0.17,0.18,0.17],[0.23,0.23,0.23],[0.54,0.18,0.18],[0.09,0.09,0.08],[0.31,0.32,0.3],[0.12,0.1,0.11],[1.27,0.48,0.44],[0.01,0.01,0],[12.09,0.17,0.15],[0.17,0.13,0.12],[10.91,0.28,0.24],[28.25,0.86,1.36],[0.03,0.03,0.02],[0.06,0.04,0.04],[0.02,0.03,0.02],[0.63,0.24,0.21],[8.77,1.6,1.64],[0.12,0.1,0.1],[1.33,0.13,0.13],[3.46,0.18,0.19],[0.97,0.86,0.86],[0.95,0.96,0.98],[0.96,0.97,0.97],[0.14,0.12,0.14],[0.07,0.06,0.06],[0.05,0.04,0.04],[0.04,0.03,0.03],[0.1,0.09,0.09],[0.47,0.03,0.03],[0.25,0.03,0.03],[0.04,0.03,0.03]],"source":"starrocks/results/c6a.metal.json"} ,{"system":"TimescaleDB (compression)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","PostgreSQL compatible","column-oriented","time-series"],"load_time":4605,"data_size":20333747165,"result":[[2.28686,1.63642,1.64263],[32.6848,1.63476,1.40052],[60.8633,3.70484,3.59342],[36.4029,2.87091,2.80739],[110.391,38.9688,38.0549],[147.379,66.2513,65.6379],[33.0294,2.92031,2.84375],[33.0221,1.2984,1.19227],[115.694,47.4651,47.0125],[156.347,51.577,51.2694],[68.3301,4.75521,4.68007],[77.4356,5.55128,5.56577],[49.7741,11.2911,11.3265],[81.1014,14.9111,14.9541],[82.9569,14.6156,14.6331],[62.0338,26.399,26.3351],[103.259,36.4122,36.6076],[92.8828,26.2395,25.8991],[144.281,63.5102,63.7661],[7.00679,0.573073,0.536283],[75.0203,7.86344,7.90495],[81.2825,9.15868,9.01775],[104.084,13.9528,13.8435],[132.531,81.522,82.1561],[80.6965,3.28231,3.16574],[39.7693,2.51443,2.43849],[80.4245,3.26941,3.13916],[104.015,13.7044,13.5313],[307.26,253.127,252.147],[42.8549,22.4187,22.0325],[137.601,14.9592,14.6804],[136.767,22.8007,22.131],[263.005,168.551,163.355],[156.919,92.6308,91.702],[160.842,96.0512,97.1773],[62.8357,28.0336,28.7397],[1.75869,0.561604,0.541215],[0.46607,0.191863,0.19021],[0.303671,0.137579,0.136615],[2.32031,1.49223,1.52369],[0.563764,0.14192,0.138234],[0.372428,0.122989,0.123709],[0.448574,0.159092,0.154687]],"source":"timescaledb-compressed/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} -,{"system":"TimescaleDB","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","PostgreSQL compatible","row-oriented","time-series"],"load_time":1620,"data_size":72882392030,"result":[[437.700,215.793,176.420],[327.026,259.568,244.578],[262.978,263.090,263.083],[262.807,263.046,266.847],[337.497,334.964,330.852],[355.689,356.801,362.894],[262.762,263.012,262.968],[263.055,263.016,263.028],[319.928,319.388,320.704],[323.584,322.224,322.488],[265.979,265.465,265.375],[266.019,265.543,265.462],[277.018,276.300,276.595],[280.352,279.251,279.572],[279.915,279.896,279.674],[296.377,298.506,297.659],[314.448,314.605,312.570],[302.668,302.672,303.039],[325.810,324.061,324.376],[262.447,262.698,262.704],[267.581,267.467,267.482],[268.085,267.466,267.696],[263.391,263.097,263.126],[38.291,0.435,0.335],[0.127,0.005,0.005],[263.138,263.100,263.092],[0.889,0.341,0.339],[267.586,267.498,267.491],[289.086,290.012,290.093],[263.220,263.071,263.109],[274.780,273.995,273.998],[282.217,281.390,281.470],[429.273,426.588,439.431],[448.808,418.724,418.207],[455.196,422.750,423.142],[299.263,296.937,297.261],[18.693,1.552,1.481],[18.125,0.945,0.937],[18.528,1.062,0.902],[18.268,1.779,1.770],[19.615,1.965,1.966],[18.970,1.435,1.430],[18.330,1.153,0.952]],"source":"timescaledb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} +,{"system":"TimescaleDB","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","PostgreSQL compatible","row-oriented","time-series"],"load_time":1620,"data_size":72882392030,"result":[[437.7,215.793,176.42],[327.026,259.568,244.578],[262.978,263.09,263.083],[262.807,263.046,266.847],[337.497,334.964,330.852],[355.689,356.801,362.894],[262.762,263.012,262.968],[263.055,263.016,263.028],[319.928,319.388,320.704],[323.584,322.224,322.488],[265.979,265.465,265.375],[266.019,265.543,265.462],[277.018,276.3,276.595],[280.352,279.251,279.572],[279.915,279.896,279.674],[296.377,298.506,297.659],[314.448,314.605,312.57],[302.668,302.672,303.039],[325.81,324.061,324.376],[262.447,262.698,262.704],[267.581,267.467,267.482],[268.085,267.466,267.696],[263.391,263.097,263.126],[38.291,0.435,0.335],[0.127,0.005,0.005],[263.138,263.1,263.092],[0.889,0.341,0.339],[267.586,267.498,267.491],[289.086,290.012,290.093],[263.22,263.071,263.109],[274.78,273.995,273.998],[282.217,281.39,281.47],[429.273,426.588,439.431],[448.808,418.724,418.207],[455.196,422.75,423.142],[299.263,296.937,297.261],[18.693,1.552,1.481],[18.125,0.945,0.937],[18.528,1.062,0.902],[18.268,1.779,1.77],[19.615,1.965,1.966],[18.97,1.435,1.43],[18.33,1.153,0.952]],"source":"timescaledb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ]; // end of data const additional_data_size_points = [ From 195cdc4bfce7630b1119c3410699b383438e42b3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Kirk Mitchener Date: Thu, 30 Nov 2023 00:49:47 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 5/6] fix date --- datafusion/results/single.json | 2 +- index.html | 2 +- 2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/datafusion/results/single.json b/datafusion/results/single.json index 19bd8f83f..8c0c53837 100644 --- a/datafusion/results/single.json +++ b/datafusion/results/single.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "system": "DataFusion (Parquet, single)", - "date": "2023-07-29", + "date": "2023-11-29", "machine": "c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2", "cluster_size": 1, "comment": "v33.0.0 (d2efaa9)", diff --git a/index.html b/index.html index 67618591a..7cbc93e00 100644 --- a/index.html +++ b/index.html @@ -379,7 +379,7 @@ ,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":368,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002554,0.002257,0.002058],[0.041885,0.026659,0.026301],[0.377386,0.047169,0.046246],[1.111276,0.043512,0.042424],[1.337056,0.378329,0.378],[1.517051,0.516229,0.513954],[0.040641,0.02423,0.025701],[0.048797,0.029641,0.028597],[1.695267,0.591075,0.582311],[2.82141,0.663166,0.666039],[1.407029,0.255046,0.253865],[1.971179,0.258693,0.254872],[1.548181,0.639874,0.63798],[3.217226,1.0459,1.038888],[1.861833,0.815691,0.806401],[0.768044,0.530842,0.528053],[3.639183,2.567878,2.556752],[2.787874,1.658994,1.6746],[7.466028,4.180932,4.241429],[0.006217,0.003521,0.013345],[10.689073,0.56204,0.551567],[12.984685,0.686805,0.676753],[23.748547,1.311328,1.267505],[6.763271,0.285252,0.273009],[0.132152,0.028291,0.028296],[1.943504,0.226601,0.224721],[0.326737,0.029324,0.027575],[11.538898,0.516586,0.502331],[9.223633,6.920732,6.945943],[0.153429,0.074415,0.073831],[5.458251,0.556813,0.550952],[7.330739,0.895601,0.866605],[7.677006,4.602414,4.704338],[11.838616,2.964448,3.080231],[11.848512,2.947774,3.029332],[0.57868,0.525259,0.491508],[0.086986,0.062111,0.062906],[0.06579,0.032106,0.031138],[0.030254,0.01606,0.017036],[0.124381,0.093671,0.095871],[0.029603,0.019117,0.022236],[0.019694,0.010848,0.016053],[0.019806,0.010239,0.010112]],"source":"databend/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":357,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002354,0.001796,0.001676],[0.03541,0.019995,0.020233],[0.387346,0.031738,0.031385],[1.13763,0.030899,0.030119],[1.405919,0.423186,0.423155],[1.562987,0.578546,0.580928],[0.032613,0.014625,0.014217],[0.032749,0.02213,0.022904],[1.735342,0.53332,0.524569],[2.804289,0.599192,0.595315],[1.369841,0.17547,0.186941],[2.0922,0.181471,0.181655],[1.750355,0.683891,0.67764],[3.213623,1.051686,1.04771],[1.881785,0.830412,0.813682],[0.813736,0.602403,0.591426],[3.880537,2.488562,2.4804],[2.782833,1.3676,1.344967],[7.815274,4.236312,4.263853],[0.006507,0.003202,0.003167],[10.674944,0.451903,0.43883],[12.984352,0.543479,0.531805],[23.749905,1.028132,1.006847],[6.267209,0.20805,0.194846],[0.273405,0.027663,0.027727],[1.813349,0.183311,0.180188],[0.441909,0.027818,0.027427],[11.5565,0.410411,0.397217],[11.878248,11.803086,11.842988],[0.147288,0.058588,0.056877],[5.500723,0.496444,0.488228],[7.438851,0.982329,0.97478],[8.228235,5.575889,5.488849],[12.279272,3.42623,3.439635],[12.288545,3.465759,3.472598],[0.629652,0.542064,0.549532],[0.068277,0.055286,0.062397],[0.028899,0.023338,0.026963],[0.024785,0.016914,0.014623],[0.094073,0.082865,0.088973],[0.024245,0.013744,0.017487],[0.018292,0.009779,0.008906],[0.018714,0.009268,0.009275]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":70,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.073969,0.002969,0.002275],[0.289053,0.0145,0.013984],[0.597566,0.020848,0.022175],[1.241144,0.019701,0.019218],[1.407042,0.266073,0.245832],[1.707674,0.265472,0.272181],[0.037721,0.015296,0.014786],[0.044271,0.019238,0.018279],[1.814285,0.29248,0.287474],[3.034563,0.304214,0.31072],[1.634329,0.286281,0.299248],[1.937083,0.177104,0.188476],[1.52924,0.28984,0.289497],[3.075821,0.461813,0.428307],[1.708843,0.27206,0.275821],[0.83204,0.234342,0.218837],[3.085068,0.494668,0.480146],[2.891979,0.477079,0.457178],[6.122974,0.690913,0.634832],[0.186429,0.004711,0.00394],[10.868874,0.099969,0.086985],[13.480312,0.11198,0.10336],[24.405612,0.431874,0.440055],[10.061871,0.2325,0.242135],[0.647733,0.046068,0.039222],[2.100647,0.046711,0.043591],[1.391526,0.041194,0.039617],[11.536597,0.093705,0.088706],[9.839564,1.566094,1.5916],[0.16243,0.049029,0.049039],[5.631392,0.26343,0.225562],[7.261623,0.304319,0.279184],[5.646363,1.06771,0.910199],[11.17362,0.789665,0.684581],[11.251824,0.766817,0.682614],[0.663092,0.261053,0.272992],[0.40079,0.083889,0.091102],[0.073341,0.021988,0.028371],[0.091126,0.019851,0.013461],[0.151101,0.058686,0.058112],[0.281109,0.016812,0.014878],[0.398818,0.015711,0.022669],[0.222298,0.011058,0.014887]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.metal.json"} -,{"system":"DataFusion (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-07-29","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"v33.0.0 (d2efaa9)","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.068,0.045,0.046],[0.098,0.060,0.062],[0.175,0.111,0.106],[0.401,0.107,0.108],[1.011,0.812,0.815],[1.356,1.258,1.230],[0.094,0.069,0.068],[0.096,0.065,0.063],[1.548,1.432,1.459],[2.676,2.483,2.472],[0.488,0.342,0.337],[0.525,0.353,0.360],[1.350,1.246,1.244],[3.263,2.467,2.480],[1.460,1.376,1.394],[1.019,0.940,0.934],[3.053,2.688,2.713],[2.989,2.598,2.615],[6.715,5.675,5.654],[0.311,0.098,0.102],[9.910,1.566,1.577],[11.127,1.946,1.856],[21.951,4.155,4.082],[55.962,11.448,11.448],[2.450,0.555,0.576],[0.719,0.507,0.503],[2.437,0.637,0.635],[9.570,2.371,2.326],[9.068,5.013,4.951],[0.553,0.488,0.477],[2.074,1.104,1.121],[5.590,1.526,1.552],[8.068,7.646,7.726],[11.579,6.687,6.672],[11.953,7.284,7.291],[1.911,1.814,1.828],[0.440,0.311,0.322],[0.231,0.184,0.180],[0.242,0.171,0.170],[0.840,0.676,0.658],[0.153,0.094,0.098],[0.129,0.089,0.089],[0.156,0.097,0.105]],"source":"datafusion/results/single.json"} +,{"system":"DataFusion (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-11-29","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"v33.0.0 (d2efaa9)","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.068,0.045,0.046],[0.098,0.060,0.062],[0.175,0.111,0.106],[0.401,0.107,0.108],[1.011,0.812,0.815],[1.356,1.258,1.230],[0.094,0.069,0.068],[0.096,0.065,0.063],[1.548,1.432,1.459],[2.676,2.483,2.472],[0.488,0.342,0.337],[0.525,0.353,0.360],[1.350,1.246,1.244],[3.263,2.467,2.480],[1.460,1.376,1.394],[1.019,0.940,0.934],[3.053,2.688,2.713],[2.989,2.598,2.615],[6.715,5.675,5.654],[0.311,0.098,0.102],[9.910,1.566,1.577],[11.127,1.946,1.856],[21.951,4.155,4.082],[55.962,11.448,11.448],[2.450,0.555,0.576],[0.719,0.507,0.503],[2.437,0.637,0.635],[9.570,2.371,2.326],[9.068,5.013,4.951],[0.553,0.488,0.477],[2.074,1.104,1.121],[5.590,1.526,1.552],[8.068,7.646,7.726],[11.579,6.687,6.672],[11.953,7.284,7.291],[1.911,1.814,1.828],[0.440,0.311,0.322],[0.231,0.184,0.180],[0.242,0.171,0.170],[0.840,0.676,0.658],[0.153,0.094,0.098],[0.129,0.089,0.089],[0.156,0.097,0.105]],"source":"datafusion/results/single.json"} ,{"system":"Apache Doris","date":"2022-11-20","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":415,"data_size":17170564642,"result":[[0.07,0.03,0.03],[0.13,0.04,0.04],[0.11,0.04,0.03],[1.12,0.04,0.06],[1.06,1.06,1.05],[0.85,0.78,0.76],[0.01,0.02,0.02],[0.04,0.03,0.03],[0.57,0.56,0.54],[0.61,0.61,0.63],[0.16,0.11,0.11],[0.15,0.13,0.13],[0.59,0.58,0.58],[0.89,0.91,0.88],[0.79,0.77,0.77],[0.37,0.37,0.38],[1.09,1.07,1.09],[0.26,0.26,0.3],[2.1,2.02,2.04],[0.03,0.01,0.02],[10.82,1.14,1.14],[9,2.87,0.94],[12.17,1.29,0.98],[32.09,2.35,2.27],[1.28,0.13,0.14],[0.12,0.13,0.12],[0.14,0.15,0.14],[10.55,1.19,1.18],[10.04,9.56,9.52],[0.71,0.72,0.65],[1.84,0.44,0.42],[2.13,0.5,0.51],[3.17,3.16,3.37],[12,4.4,4.51],[11.83,4.46,4.27],[1.16,1.11,1.12],[0.07,0.05,0.05],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.15,0.14,0.12],[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02]],"source":"doris/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Druid","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Druid is killed and restarted after every query. Otherwise some queries make Druid degraded and results are incorrect. For example after Q13 even SELECT 1 works for 7 seconds","tags":["Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":19620,"data_size":45188608472,"result":[[0.032365,0.016716,0.016921],[0.400766,0.275591,0.271057],[0.38235,0.152084,0.151652],[1.379492,0.137201,0.128902],[3.278731,2.527105,2.515128],[8.576382,6.54654,6.503001],[null,null,null],[0.563852,0.273795,0.275086],[11.509993,10.636571,10.597993],[13.357647,12.42121,12.337247],[1.636875,0.8213,0.900056],[1.692544,0.512066,0.440511],[2.453274,1.769806,1.807207],[8.503408,7.261406,7.334872],[61.056041,59.251083,59.500549],[8.62067,8.236657,8.22538],[164.840762,null,null],[24.165797,22.308466,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[25.973369,25.597864,25.602509],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[7.805347,6.629776,6.947366],[0.257845,0.020327,0.016976],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[32.948154,31.04677,29.221959],[null,null,null],[7.230865,7.033713,6.972421],[20.54625,19.237428,19.258469],[54.065945,52.451318,52.466653],[null,null,null],[17.499267,null,null],[null,null,null],[60.478315,60.05494,60.458946],[1.698088,1.490317,1.461969],[1.409572,0.939003,0.907252],[0.866729,0.329539,0.287435],[null,null,null],[0.932473,0.420781,0.359095],[0.723142,0.3253,0.296865],[0.603483,0.150892,0.140716]],"source":"druid/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"DuckDB (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-09-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14737666736,"result":[[0.06858791799959363,0.044711035000091215,0.042833501000131946],[0.08466665400010243,0.061327259999870876,0.06103660400003719],[0.14877448299967,0.10559172700004638,0.10446714899990184],[0.33234463500002676,0.09389112100006969,0.09252776699986498],[1.1345820209999147,0.5388421589996142,0.5428325200000472],[0.8665522809997128,0.7525683420003588,0.7726315990003059],[0.14739966299976004,0.12885476300016308,0.1280705589997524],[0.08514470599993729,0.0660608250000223,0.06364701199981937],[0.7901016199998594,0.6670942910000122,0.6656622149998839],[1.112716422000176,0.9176106790000631,0.8993262330000107],[0.4155927659999179,0.21104949600021428,0.21018879099983678],[1.0025453209996158,0.2506203090001691,0.24569647199996325],[1.2344316989997424,0.6329478739999104,0.6651636070000677],[2.456399698000041,1.0311697550000645,1.0137859460000982],[0.9334836890002407,0.6877674190000107,0.70905577800022],[0.673465615999703,0.5981919160003599,0.6082133740001154],[2.494906011999774,1.4013747280000644,1.3922408849998646],[2.375765204000345,1.324844154999937,1.3226832469999863],[4.690465237999888,2.3323504360000697,2.3752783559998534],[0.20363476300008188,0.08883917699995436,0.08691825200003223],[9.97606974700011,1.850158613000076,1.8413504770001055],[10.993020309999793,1.688866285000131,1.6903490720001173],[21.570115048999924,3.479486579999957,3.460369050999816],[55.44843658699983,11.133978315999684,11.129654930000015],[2.6089661060000253,0.48738706799986176,0.47928872500006037],[0.7135218759999589,0.3805757249997441,0.35711958900037644],[2.769580591999784,0.4973172830000294,0.4876009600002362],[9.315595299000051,1.488970874000188,1.4658663950003756],[8.170337007999933,4.1328330040000765,4.145880016000319],[4.665519644000142,4.670076305000293,4.6598440840002695],[2.2809909809998317,0.781899636000162,0.7691932829998223],[6.008987953999622,0.9412647040003321,0.9506733889998031],[6.1903129289999015,3.628633594999883,3.815570798999943],[9.97725304100004,2.979070244000013,2.997355967999738],[9.978100522000204,2.992902611000318,3.022268540999903],[0.92484311599992,0.8439210039996397,0.8562627520000206],[0.23992238600021665,0.13403623200019865,0.1317714319998231],[0.1254186490000393,0.09669256999995923,0.09850224299998445],[0.13835749800000485,0.09647460799988039,0.0929961749998256],[0.3313648240000475,0.2376939770001627,0.24857611900006304],[0.07056037899974399,0.05403545599983772,0.051252997999654326],[0.07037150599990127,0.04856322000023283,0.04816857199966762],[0.06874101699986568,0.04819512300036877,0.04709468300006847]],"source":"duckdb-parquet/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} From 986c3405ab3658199da869aa40822d503b15b47e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Kirk Mitchener Date: Sat, 2 Dec 2023 16:12:51 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 6/6] add DataFusion results for partitioned files --- datafusion/benchmark.sh | 13 +++-- datafusion/create_partitioned.sql | 3 + datafusion/{create.sql => create_single.sql} | 0 datafusion/results/partitioned.json | 58 ++++++++++++++++++++ datafusion/run.sh | 38 +++++++++---- index.html | 1 + 6 files changed, 98 insertions(+), 15 deletions(-) mode change 100644 => 100755 datafusion/benchmark.sh create mode 100644 datafusion/create_partitioned.sql rename datafusion/{create.sql => create_single.sql} (100%) create mode 100644 datafusion/results/partitioned.json mode change 100644 => 100755 datafusion/run.sh diff --git a/datafusion/benchmark.sh b/datafusion/benchmark.sh old mode 100644 new mode 100755 index 481cb47e7..285e40976 --- a/datafusion/benchmark.sh +++ b/datafusion/benchmark.sh @@ -14,15 +14,20 @@ sudo yum install gcc -y # Install DataFusion main branch git clone https://github.com/apache/arrow-datafusion.git cd arrow-datafusion/datafusion-cli -git checkout 22.0.0 +git checkout 33.0.0 CARGO_PROFILE_RELEASE_LTO=true RUSTFLAGS="-C codegen-units=1" cargo build --release export PATH="`pwd`/target/release:$PATH" cd ../.. -# Download benchmark target data +# Download benchmark target data, single file wget --no-verbose --continue https://datasets.clickhouse.com/hits_compatible/hits.parquet +# Download benchmark target data, partitioned +mkdir -p partitioned +seq 0 99 | xargs -P100 -I{} bash -c 'wget --no-verbose --directory-prefix partitioned --continue https://datasets.clickhouse.com/hits_compatible/athena_partitioned/hits_{}.parquet' + +# Run benchmarks for single parquet and partitioned +./run.sh single +./run.sh partitioned -# Run -bash run.sh diff --git a/datafusion/create_partitioned.sql b/datafusion/create_partitioned.sql new file mode 100644 index 000000000..17a8b5b4d --- /dev/null +++ b/datafusion/create_partitioned.sql @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +CREATE EXTERNAL TABLE hits +STORED AS PARQUET +LOCATION 'partitioned'; diff --git a/datafusion/create.sql b/datafusion/create_single.sql similarity index 100% rename from datafusion/create.sql rename to datafusion/create_single.sql diff --git a/datafusion/results/partitioned.json b/datafusion/results/partitioned.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..958b6fddb --- /dev/null +++ b/datafusion/results/partitioned.json @@ -0,0 +1,58 @@ +{ + "system": "DataFusion (Parquet, partitioned)", + "date": "2023-12-02", + "machine": "c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2", + "cluster_size": 1, + "comment": "v33.0.0 (d2efaa9)", + + "tags": ["Rust", "column-oriented", "embedded", "stateless"], + + "load_time": 0, + "data_size": 14779976446, + + "result": [ +[0.027, 0.012, 0.014], +[0.074, 0.027, 0.026], +[0.142, 0.079, 0.077], +[0.390, 0.073, 0.077], +[1.043, 0.742, 0.730], +[1.200, 1.101, 1.082], +[0.062, 0.032, 0.032], +[0.062, 0.028, 0.029], +[1.427, 1.379, 1.376], +[2.526, 2.383, 2.345], +[0.442, 0.297, 0.300], +[0.483, 0.327, 0.331], +[1.191, 1.098, 1.139], +[3.213, 2.370, 2.403], +[1.343, 1.287, 1.284], +[0.891, 0.861, 0.863], +[3.064, 2.602, 2.594], +[3.007, 2.528, 2.559], +[6.752, 5.508, 5.604], +[0.307, 0.065, 0.064], +[9.928, 1.532, 1.532], +[11.092, 1.809, 1.795], +[21.671, 4.209, 4.193], +[55.553, 11.259, 11.202], +[2.506, 0.470, 0.459], +[0.674, 0.375, 0.370], +[2.503, 0.539, 0.548], +[9.512, 2.250, 2.220], +[8.435, 4.891, 4.883], +[0.515, 0.464, 0.472], +[2.041, 0.993, 0.995], +[5.709, 1.461, 1.458], +[8.232, 7.693, 7.728], +[11.450, 6.656, 6.624], +[11.788, 7.241, 7.282], +[1.799, 1.694, 1.721], +[0.277, 0.183, 0.187], +[0.140, 0.090, 0.093], +[0.145, 0.084, 0.083], +[0.507, 0.418, 0.413], +[0.090, 0.050, 0.050], +[0.111, 0.047, 0.047], +[0.106, 0.050, 0.055] +] +} diff --git a/datafusion/run.sh b/datafusion/run.sh old mode 100644 new mode 100755 index 008f94247..673f6dc9a --- a/datafusion/run.sh +++ b/datafusion/run.sh @@ -1,26 +1,42 @@ #!/bin/bash +# Check if an argument is provided +if [ "$#" -ne 1 ]; then + echo "Usage: $0 [single|partitioned]" + exit 1 +fi + +# Set the SQL file based on the argument +if [ "$1" = "single" ]; then + CREATE_SQL_FILE="create_single.sql" +elif [ "$1" = "partitioned" ]; then + CREATE_SQL_FILE="create_partitioned.sql" +else + echo "Invalid argument. Please use 'single' or 'partitioned'." + exit 1 +fi + TRIES=3 QUERY_NUM=1 +echo $1 cat queries.sql | while read query; do sync echo 3 | sudo tee /proc/sys/vm/drop_caches >/dev/null - echo "$query" > /tmp/query.sql + echo "$query" > /tmp/query.sql echo -n "[" for i in $(seq 1 $TRIES); do - # 1. there will be two query result, one for creating table another for executing the select statement - # 2. each query contains a "Query took xxx seconds", we just grep these 2 lines - # 3. use sed to take the second line - # 4. use awk to take the number we want - RES=`datafusion-cli -f create.sql /tmp/query.sql 2>&1 | grep "Query took" | sed -n 2p | awk '{print $7}'` - [[ $RES != "" ]] && \ - echo -n "$RES" || \ - echo -n "null" + # 1. there will be two query result, one for creating table another for executing the select statement + # 2. each query contains a "Query took xxx seconds", we just grep these 2 lines + # 3. use sed to take the second line + # 4. use awk to take the number we want + RES=`datafusion-cli -f $CREATE_SQL_FILE /tmp/query.sql 2>&1 | grep "Query took" | sed -n 2p | awk '{print $7}'` + [[ $RES != "" ]] && \ + echo -n "$RES" || \ + echo -n "null" [[ "$i" != $TRIES ]] && echo -n ", " - - echo "${QUERY_NUM},${i},${RES}" >> result.csv + echo "${QUERY_NUM},${i},${RES}" >> result.csv done echo "]," diff --git a/index.html b/index.html index 7cbc93e00..a0ab2c388 100644 --- a/index.html +++ b/index.html @@ -379,6 +379,7 @@ ,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c5.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":368,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002554,0.002257,0.002058],[0.041885,0.026659,0.026301],[0.377386,0.047169,0.046246],[1.111276,0.043512,0.042424],[1.337056,0.378329,0.378],[1.517051,0.516229,0.513954],[0.040641,0.02423,0.025701],[0.048797,0.029641,0.028597],[1.695267,0.591075,0.582311],[2.82141,0.663166,0.666039],[1.407029,0.255046,0.253865],[1.971179,0.258693,0.254872],[1.548181,0.639874,0.63798],[3.217226,1.0459,1.038888],[1.861833,0.815691,0.806401],[0.768044,0.530842,0.528053],[3.639183,2.567878,2.556752],[2.787874,1.658994,1.6746],[7.466028,4.180932,4.241429],[0.006217,0.003521,0.013345],[10.689073,0.56204,0.551567],[12.984685,0.686805,0.676753],[23.748547,1.311328,1.267505],[6.763271,0.285252,0.273009],[0.132152,0.028291,0.028296],[1.943504,0.226601,0.224721],[0.326737,0.029324,0.027575],[11.538898,0.516586,0.502331],[9.223633,6.920732,6.945943],[0.153429,0.074415,0.073831],[5.458251,0.556813,0.550952],[7.330739,0.895601,0.866605],[7.677006,4.602414,4.704338],[11.838616,2.964448,3.080231],[11.848512,2.947774,3.029332],[0.57868,0.525259,0.491508],[0.086986,0.062111,0.062906],[0.06579,0.032106,0.031138],[0.030254,0.01606,0.017036],[0.124381,0.093671,0.095871],[0.029603,0.019117,0.022236],[0.019694,0.010848,0.016053],[0.019806,0.010239,0.010112]],"source":"databend/results/c5.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":357,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.002354,0.001796,0.001676],[0.03541,0.019995,0.020233],[0.387346,0.031738,0.031385],[1.13763,0.030899,0.030119],[1.405919,0.423186,0.423155],[1.562987,0.578546,0.580928],[0.032613,0.014625,0.014217],[0.032749,0.02213,0.022904],[1.735342,0.53332,0.524569],[2.804289,0.599192,0.595315],[1.369841,0.17547,0.186941],[2.0922,0.181471,0.181655],[1.750355,0.683891,0.67764],[3.213623,1.051686,1.04771],[1.881785,0.830412,0.813682],[0.813736,0.602403,0.591426],[3.880537,2.488562,2.4804],[2.782833,1.3676,1.344967],[7.815274,4.236312,4.263853],[0.006507,0.003202,0.003167],[10.674944,0.451903,0.43883],[12.984352,0.543479,0.531805],[23.749905,1.028132,1.006847],[6.267209,0.20805,0.194846],[0.273405,0.027663,0.027727],[1.813349,0.183311,0.180188],[0.441909,0.027818,0.027427],[11.5565,0.410411,0.397217],[11.878248,11.803086,11.842988],[0.147288,0.058588,0.056877],[5.500723,0.496444,0.488228],[7.438851,0.982329,0.97478],[8.228235,5.575889,5.488849],[12.279272,3.42623,3.439635],[12.288545,3.465759,3.472598],[0.629652,0.542064,0.549532],[0.068277,0.055286,0.062397],[0.028899,0.023338,0.026963],[0.024785,0.016914,0.014623],[0.094073,0.082865,0.088973],[0.024245,0.013744,0.017487],[0.018292,0.009779,0.008906],[0.018714,0.009268,0.009275]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Databend","date":"2023-02-26","machine":"c6a.metal, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":70,"data_size":20922561953,"result":[[0.073969,0.002969,0.002275],[0.289053,0.0145,0.013984],[0.597566,0.020848,0.022175],[1.241144,0.019701,0.019218],[1.407042,0.266073,0.245832],[1.707674,0.265472,0.272181],[0.037721,0.015296,0.014786],[0.044271,0.019238,0.018279],[1.814285,0.29248,0.287474],[3.034563,0.304214,0.31072],[1.634329,0.286281,0.299248],[1.937083,0.177104,0.188476],[1.52924,0.28984,0.289497],[3.075821,0.461813,0.428307],[1.708843,0.27206,0.275821],[0.83204,0.234342,0.218837],[3.085068,0.494668,0.480146],[2.891979,0.477079,0.457178],[6.122974,0.690913,0.634832],[0.186429,0.004711,0.00394],[10.868874,0.099969,0.086985],[13.480312,0.11198,0.10336],[24.405612,0.431874,0.440055],[10.061871,0.2325,0.242135],[0.647733,0.046068,0.039222],[2.100647,0.046711,0.043591],[1.391526,0.041194,0.039617],[11.536597,0.093705,0.088706],[9.839564,1.566094,1.5916],[0.16243,0.049029,0.049039],[5.631392,0.26343,0.225562],[7.261623,0.304319,0.279184],[5.646363,1.06771,0.910199],[11.17362,0.789665,0.684581],[11.251824,0.766817,0.682614],[0.663092,0.261053,0.272992],[0.40079,0.083889,0.091102],[0.073341,0.021988,0.028371],[0.091126,0.019851,0.013461],[0.151101,0.058686,0.058112],[0.281109,0.016812,0.014878],[0.398818,0.015711,0.022669],[0.222298,0.011058,0.014887]],"source":"databend/results/c6a.metal.json"} +,{"system":"DataFusion (Parquet, partitioned)","date":"2023-12-02","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"v33.0.0 (d2efaa9)","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.027,0.012,0.014],[0.074,0.027,0.026],[0.142,0.079,0.077],[0.390,0.073,0.077],[1.043,0.742,0.730],[1.200,1.101,1.082],[0.062,0.032,0.032],[0.062,0.028,0.029],[1.427,1.379,1.376],[2.526,2.383,2.345],[0.442,0.297,0.300],[0.483,0.327,0.331],[1.191,1.098,1.139],[3.213,2.370,2.403],[1.343,1.287,1.284],[0.891,0.861,0.863],[3.064,2.602,2.594],[3.007,2.528,2.559],[6.752,5.508,5.604],[0.307,0.065,0.064],[9.928,1.532,1.532],[11.092,1.809,1.795],[21.671,4.209,4.193],[55.553,11.259,11.202],[2.506,0.470,0.459],[0.674,0.375,0.370],[2.503,0.539,0.548],[9.512,2.250,2.220],[8.435,4.891,4.883],[0.515,0.464,0.472],[2.041,0.993,0.995],[5.709,1.461,1.458],[8.232,7.693,7.728],[11.450,6.656,6.624],[11.788,7.241,7.282],[1.799,1.694,1.721],[0.277,0.183,0.187],[0.140,0.090,0.093],[0.145,0.084,0.083],[0.507,0.418,0.413],[0.090,0.050,0.050],[0.111,0.047,0.047],[0.106,0.050,0.055]],"source":"datafusion/results/partitioned.json"} ,{"system":"DataFusion (Parquet, single)","date":"2023-11-29","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"v33.0.0 (d2efaa9)","tags":["Rust","column-oriented","embedded","stateless"],"load_time":0,"data_size":14779976446,"result":[[0.068,0.045,0.046],[0.098,0.060,0.062],[0.175,0.111,0.106],[0.401,0.107,0.108],[1.011,0.812,0.815],[1.356,1.258,1.230],[0.094,0.069,0.068],[0.096,0.065,0.063],[1.548,1.432,1.459],[2.676,2.483,2.472],[0.488,0.342,0.337],[0.525,0.353,0.360],[1.350,1.246,1.244],[3.263,2.467,2.480],[1.460,1.376,1.394],[1.019,0.940,0.934],[3.053,2.688,2.713],[2.989,2.598,2.615],[6.715,5.675,5.654],[0.311,0.098,0.102],[9.910,1.566,1.577],[11.127,1.946,1.856],[21.951,4.155,4.082],[55.962,11.448,11.448],[2.450,0.555,0.576],[0.719,0.507,0.503],[2.437,0.637,0.635],[9.570,2.371,2.326],[9.068,5.013,4.951],[0.553,0.488,0.477],[2.074,1.104,1.121],[5.590,1.526,1.552],[8.068,7.646,7.726],[11.579,6.687,6.672],[11.953,7.284,7.291],[1.911,1.814,1.828],[0.440,0.311,0.322],[0.231,0.184,0.180],[0.242,0.171,0.170],[0.840,0.676,0.658],[0.153,0.094,0.098],[0.129,0.089,0.089],[0.156,0.097,0.105]],"source":"datafusion/results/single.json"} ,{"system":"Apache Doris","date":"2022-11-20","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","column-oriented","MySQL compatible","ClickHouse derivative"],"load_time":415,"data_size":17170564642,"result":[[0.07,0.03,0.03],[0.13,0.04,0.04],[0.11,0.04,0.03],[1.12,0.04,0.06],[1.06,1.06,1.05],[0.85,0.78,0.76],[0.01,0.02,0.02],[0.04,0.03,0.03],[0.57,0.56,0.54],[0.61,0.61,0.63],[0.16,0.11,0.11],[0.15,0.13,0.13],[0.59,0.58,0.58],[0.89,0.91,0.88],[0.79,0.77,0.77],[0.37,0.37,0.38],[1.09,1.07,1.09],[0.26,0.26,0.3],[2.1,2.02,2.04],[0.03,0.01,0.02],[10.82,1.14,1.14],[9,2.87,0.94],[12.17,1.29,0.98],[32.09,2.35,2.27],[1.28,0.13,0.14],[0.12,0.13,0.12],[0.14,0.15,0.14],[10.55,1.19,1.18],[10.04,9.56,9.52],[0.71,0.72,0.65],[1.84,0.44,0.42],[2.13,0.5,0.51],[3.17,3.16,3.37],[12,4.4,4.51],[11.83,4.46,4.27],[1.16,1.11,1.12],[0.07,0.05,0.05],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.02,0.02,0.02],[0.15,0.14,0.12],[0.04,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02],[0.03,0.02,0.02]],"source":"doris/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"} ,{"system":"Druid","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"Druid is killed and restarted after every query. Otherwise some queries make Druid degraded and results are incorrect. For example after Q13 even SELECT 1 works for 7 seconds","tags":["Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":19620,"data_size":45188608472,"result":[[0.032365,0.016716,0.016921],[0.400766,0.275591,0.271057],[0.38235,0.152084,0.151652],[1.379492,0.137201,0.128902],[3.278731,2.527105,2.515128],[8.576382,6.54654,6.503001],[null,null,null],[0.563852,0.273795,0.275086],[11.509993,10.636571,10.597993],[13.357647,12.42121,12.337247],[1.636875,0.8213,0.900056],[1.692544,0.512066,0.440511],[2.453274,1.769806,1.807207],[8.503408,7.261406,7.334872],[61.056041,59.251083,59.500549],[8.62067,8.236657,8.22538],[164.840762,null,null],[24.165797,22.308466,null],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[25.973369,25.597864,25.602509],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[7.805347,6.629776,6.947366],[0.257845,0.020327,0.016976],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[32.948154,31.04677,29.221959],[null,null,null],[7.230865,7.033713,6.972421],[20.54625,19.237428,19.258469],[54.065945,52.451318,52.466653],[null,null,null],[17.499267,null,null],[null,null,null],[60.478315,60.05494,60.458946],[1.698088,1.490317,1.461969],[1.409572,0.939003,0.907252],[0.866729,0.329539,0.287435],[null,null,null],[0.932473,0.420781,0.359095],[0.723142,0.3253,0.296865],[0.603483,0.150892,0.140716]],"source":"druid/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"}