Akmal / refactor: restore language switcher functionality in menu title and footer #368
Conversation
🤖 AI Code Analysis Results📝 Manual Coding⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜ 0% 0 of 4,545 characters (0%) in newly added lines are AI-generated 📊 Analysis Summary
📋 Per-File Breakdown (New Lines Only)
📝 This PR contains traditional hand-written code. 📊 Raw Data (for dashboard){
"timestamp": "2025-10-16T07:30:05.700Z",
"repository": "deriv-com/derivatives-trader",
"branch": "unknown",
"author": "unknown",
"summary": {
"totalCharacters": 4545,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0
},
"files": [
{
"name": "packages/core/src/App/Components/Layout/Header/Components/ToggleMenu/menu-title.tsx",
"totalCharacters": 191,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0,
"status": "modified",
"hasAddedContent": true,
"addedContent": " const { common, ui } = useStore();\n const { current_language } = common;\n const { is_mobile_language_menu_open, setMobileLanguageMenuOpen } = ui;\n <div\n </div>"
},
{
"name": "packages/core/src/App/Containers/Layout/trading-hub-footer.jsx",
"totalCharacters": 242,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0,
"status": "modified",
"hasAddedContent": true,
"addedContent": " ToggleLanguageSettings,\n const { common, ui } = useStore();\n const { current_language } = common;\n is_language_settings_modal_on,\n toggleLanguageSettingsModal,\n <ToggleLanguageSettings\n />"
},
{
"name": "packages/shared/src/utils/constants/default-options.ts",
"totalCharacters": 248,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0,
"status": "modified",
"hasAddedContent": true,
"addedContent": " * Supported languages: EN, ES, FR, PT, AR, IT, RU\nexport const UNSUPPORTED_LANGUAGES = [\n 'BN',\n 'DE',\n 'ID',\n 'KM',\n 'KO',\n 'MN',\n 'PL',\n 'SI',\n 'SW',\n 'TR',\n 'UZ',\n 'VI',\n 'ZH_CN',\n 'ZH_TW',\n 'TH',\n];"
},
{
"name": "packages/shared/src/utils/validation/declarative-validation-rules.ts",
"totalCharacters": 38,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0,
"status": "modified",
"hasAddedContent": true,
"addedContent": " message?: string | (() => string);"
},
{
"name": "packages/shared/src/utils/validator/validator.ts",
"totalCharacters": 166,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0,
"status": "modified",
"hasAddedContent": true,
"addedContent": " (typeof rule.options.message === 'function' ? rule.options.message() : rule.options.message) ||\n ? (rule.options.min?.toString() ?? '')"
},
{
"name": "packages/trader/src/AppV2/Containers/ContractDetails/__tests__/contract-details.spec.tsx",
"totalCharacters": 217,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0,
"status": "modified",
"hasAddedContent": true,
"addedContent": " // it('should render the PayoutInfo component', async () => {\n // await waitFor(() => renderContractDetails());\n // expect(screen.getByText('Payout Info Placeholder')).toBeInTheDocument();\n // });"
},
{
"name": "packages/trader/src/AppV2/Containers/ContractDetails/contract-details.tsx",
"totalCharacters": 68,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0,
"status": "modified",
"hasAddedContent": true,
"addedContent": " {/* <PayoutInfo contract_info={contract_info} /> */}"
},
{
"name": "packages/trader/src/Modules/SmartChart/Components/__tests__/top-widgets.spec.tsx",
"totalCharacters": 404,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0,
"status": "modified",
"hasAddedContent": true,
"addedContent": " // it('Should render info box and mocked chart title and should not render toast notification or recent trade info for Desktop', () => {\n // render(<TopWidgets {...mocked_props} />);\n // const chart_title = screen.getByText(/mockedcharttitle/i);\n // expect(screen.getByText(/info box content/i)).toBeInTheDocument();\n // expect(chart_title).toBeInTheDocument();\n // });"
},
{
"name": "packages/trader/src/Modules/SmartChart/Components/top-widgets.tsx",
"totalCharacters": 29,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0,
"status": "modified",
"hasAddedContent": true,
"addedContent": " {/* {InfoBox} */}"
},
{
"name": "packages/trader/src/Stores/Modules/Trading/Constants/__tests__/validation-rules.spec.ts",
"totalCharacters": 996,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0,
"status": "modified",
"hasAddedContent": true,
"addedContent": "type TExtendedRuleOptions = TRuleOptions<TTradeStore> & {\n condition: (store: TTradeStore) => boolean;\n message: string | (() => string);\n};\n const message = (multiplier_validation_rules.stop_loss.rules[0][1] as TExtendedRuleOptions).message;\n expect(typeof message === 'function' ? message() : message).toBe('Please enter a stop loss amount.');\n const message = (multiplier_validation_rules.take_profit.rules[0][1] as TExtendedRuleOptions).message;\n expect(typeof m..."
},
{
"name": "packages/trader/src/Stores/Modules/Trading/Constants/validation-rules.ts",
"totalCharacters": 1754,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0,
"status": "modified",
"hasAddedContent": true,
"addedContent": "// Helper function to create dynamic validation messages that update with language changes\nconst getDynamicMessage = (messageKey: string) => () => localize(messageKey);\n\n ['req', { message: getDynamicMessage('Amount is a required field.') }],\n message: getDynamicMessage('Barrier is a required field.'),\n message: getDynamicMessage('Higher barrier must be higher than lower barrier.'),\n message: getDynamicMessage('Barrier cannot be..."
},
{
"name": "packages/trader/src/Stores/Modules/Trading/trade-store.ts",
"totalCharacters": 192,
"aiCharacters": 0,
"percentage": 0,
"status": "modified",
"hasAddedContent": true,
"addedContent": " // Clear existing validation errors to prevent stale messages\n this.validation_errors = {};\n\n // Regenerate all validation rules with new language"
}
]
}🚀 Analysis powered by ShiftAI • Analyzes only PR changes, not entire files |
Dependency Review✅ No vulnerabilities or license issues or OpenSSF Scorecard issues found.OpenSSF Scorecard
Scanned Manifest Files |
Deploying derivatives-trader with
|
| Latest commit: |
929c4e6
|
| Status: | ✅ Deploy successful! |
| Preview URL: | https://3e2d2dc0.derivatives-trader.pages.dev |
| Branch Preview URL: | https://f-enable-languages.derivatives-trader.pages.dev |
akmal-deriv
changed the title
akmal-deriv
dismissed stale reviews from matin-deriv and nijil-deriv
via
c5dc596
- Added a new utility function `mapErrorMessage` to map error subcodes to user-friendly localized messages. - Updated the `showDigitalOptionsUnavailableError` function to utilize the new error mapping. - Created comprehensive tests for the `mapErrorMessage` function to ensure correct behavior for various error scenarios. - Refactored components and hooks across the application to replace direct error message usage with the mapped messages. - Updated types to include `subcode` and `errorcode_arr_js` for better error context. - Ensured consistent error handling in service error modals, trading components, and proposal handling.
|
Claude finished @akmal-deriv's task —— View job Code Review CompleteI've completed a comprehensive review of PR #368. Here are my findings organized by priority: 🔴 High Priority Issues1. Commented-Out Code Should Be Removed or Re-enabledFiles affected:
Issue: Multiple components and tests are commented out without explanation: {/* <PayoutInfo contract_info={contract_info} /> */}
{/* {InfoBox} */}Recommendation: Either:
2. Language Validation: Missing Runtime CheckFile: Issue: The Recommendation: Add validation in changeSelectedLanguage = async key => {
if (UNSUPPORTED_LANGUAGES.includes(key)) {
throw new Error(`Language ${key} is not supported`);
}
// ... rest of the code
}3. Potential Memory Leak in Language Change TimerFile: Issue: The Recommendation: Add cleanup logic or convert to a proper observable reaction. 🟡 Medium Priority Issues4. Dynamic Message Functions: Performance ConsiderationFile: Issue: The const getDynamicMessage = (messageKey: string) => () => localize(messageKey);While this enables dynamic language updates, it creates many closures. Each rule now stores a function instead of a string. Recommendation: This is acceptable for the use case, but consider:
5. Error Message Mapper: Missing Type Safety for SubcodesFile: Issue: The Recommendation: Create a union type for valid subcodes: type ErrorSubcode =
| 'AccountBalanceExceedsLimit'
| 'AlreadyExpired'
// ... etc
;
export const mapErrorMessage = (error: ErrorObject & { subcode?: ErrorSubcode }): string => {6. Language Switcher: No Loading StateFile: Issue: When clicking the language button, there's no visual feedback that a language switch operation is in progress. The Recommendation: Show a loading indicator while language is changing using 7. Inconsistent Error Handling ApproachFiles affected:
Issue: Error handling uses both Recommendation:
🟢 Low Priority / Suggestions8. Test Coverage for Error Message MapperFile: Good: Comprehensive tests for the error mapper ✅ Suggestion: Add integration tests to verify error messages actually display correctly in the UI when language changes. 9. Missing JSDoc for Public ExportsFile: Issue: Comment says "Supported languages: EN, ES, FR, PT, AR, IT, RU" but uses informal comment style. Recommendation: Use JSDoc for better IDE support: /**
* List of language codes that are not supported in this environment.
* Supported languages are: EN, ES, FR, PT, AR, IT, RU
* @constant {string[]}
*/
export const UNSUPPORTED_LANGUAGES = [10. Validation Store Clearing: Add CommentFile: Good: The code clears validation errors before regenerating rules ✅ Suggestion: The comment "Clear existing validation errors to prevent stale messages" is helpful. Consider adding why this is needed specifically for language changes. ✅ Things Done Well
🔒 Security ReviewNo security issues found. Specifically checked:
⚡ Performance ReviewMinor Concerns:
🧪 Testing ReviewIssues:
Recommendations:
📋 React/TypeScript Best PracticesGood:
Could Improve:
SummaryThis PR successfully restores language switcher functionality and introduces a robust error message mapping system. The main concerns are:
Overall, the implementation is solid, but the commented code needs immediate attention before merge. |
|
Claude finished @akmal-deriv's task —— View job Code Review CompleteI've completed a comprehensive review of PR #368, focusing on the latest changes and overall implementation. Here's my detailed analysis: 🔄 Changes Since Last ReviewCommit
Impact: This is a significant functional regression - users will now see generic "An error occurred. Please try again later." instead of helpful messages like "Stake must be between 1.00 and 2,000.00 USD". 🔴 Critical Issues1. Parameterized Error Messages Are Completely DisabledFiles: Issue: All parameterized error messages have been commented out, including essential validation messages:
User Impact: Users will see unhelpful generic error messages instead of actionable feedback. For example:
Root Cause: The comment in the mapper says "Temporarily commented out - messages with dynamic parameters" but doesn't explain why. This appears to be a temporary workaround for an unresolved issue. Recommendation:
2. Missing Context: Why Were Parameterized Messages Disabled?Impact: High - affects user experience across all trading flows The PR description doesn't mention this change, and there's no issue/ticket reference. This suggests:
Questions for team:
3. Commented-Out UI ComponentsFiles:
Issue: Production code has commented-out components: {/* <PayoutInfo contract_info={contract_info} /> */}
{/* {InfoBox} */}Recommendation:
🟡 High Priority Issues4. No Runtime Validation for Unsupported LanguagesFile: Issue: Risk: Users could potentially switch to unsupported languages through URL manipulation ( Recommendation: // In common-store.js:changeSelectedLanguage
changeSelectedLanguage = async key => {
if (UNSUPPORTED_LANGUAGES.includes(key)) {
console.warn(`Language ${key} is not supported`);
return Promise.reject(new Error(`Language ${key} is not supported`));
}
// ... rest of implementation
}5. Potential Memory Leak in Language Change TimerFile: Issue: Code: changeCurrentLanguage(new_language) {
if (this.current_language !== new_language) {
if (this.changing_language_timer_id) clearTimeout(this.changing_language_timer_id);
this.current_language = new_language;
this.is_language_changing = true;
this.changing_language_timer_id = setTimeout(() => {
this.is_language_changing = false;
}, 2500);
}
}Risk: If the store is destroyed while Recommendation: Add cleanup in a dispose/destructor method, or convert to MobX 6. Language Switcher UI: No Loading State IndicationFile: Issue: Clicking the language button triggers async Code Review: onClick={() => {
if (!is_mobile_language_menu_open) {
setMobileLanguageMenuOpen(true); // Just opens menu
}
}}User Experience Issue:
Recommendation: Show spinner or disabled state while 🟢 Medium Priority Issues7. Dynamic Validation Messages: Good Pattern, But Performance NoteFile: Assessment: ✅ Good solution for language switching Code: const getDynamicMessage = (messageKey: string) => () => localize(messageKey);Why this works well:
Performance consideration:
No changes needed - this is working as designed. 8. Inconsistent Error Handling StrategyFiles: Various Observation: The codebase is partially migrating from inline Old pattern: localize('Error message')New pattern: mapErrorMessage(error)Issue: Mixed approach makes maintenance harder. Some errors go through mapper, others don't. Recommendation:
9. Test Coverage GapsFiles:
Issue: Multiple tests are commented out or skipped: // it('should render the PayoutInfo component', async () => { ... });
it.skip('should substitute single parameter in error message', () => { ... });Impact on Coverage:
Recommendation:
✅ Things Done Well10. Excellent Validation Error Clearing on Language ChangeFile: Code: reaction(
() => this.root_store.common.current_language,
() => {
// Clear existing validation errors to prevent stale messages
this.validation_errors = {};
// Regenerate all validation rules with new language
this.setValidationRules(getValidationRules());
this.changeDurationValidationRules();
}
);Why this is good:
✅ No changes needed 11. Proper Language InitializationFile: Code: allowed_languages = Object.keys(getAllowedLanguages(UNSUPPORTED_LANGUAGES));
current_language = getInitialLanguage();Good practices:
✅ Well implemented 12. Language Switcher Footer IntegrationFile: Code: <ToggleLanguageSettings
is_settings_visible={is_language_settings_modal_on}
toggleSettings={toggleLanguageSettingsModal}
lang={current_language}
showPopover={showPopover}
/>Assessment:
✅ Good implementation 🔒 Security ReviewNo Critical Security Issues FoundReviewed:
Minor Recommendation: Add validation for ⚡ Performance ReviewLanguage Change PerformanceFlow:
Total: ~500ms - 2 seconds Optimization notes:
Recommendation: Add 🧪 Test Coverage AssessmentCoverage StatusWell-tested:
Missing/Inadequate:
Test Quality: // Good: Properly tests function message evaluation
const message = (multiplier_validation_rules.stop_loss.rules[0][1] as TExtendedRuleOptions).message;
expect(typeof message === 'function' ? message() : message).toBe('Please enter a stop loss amount.');Recommendation:
📋 React/TypeScript Best PracticesGood Practices Observed✅ Observer Pattern: const MenuTitle = observer(() => {
const { common, ui } = useStore();
// Component properly observes store changes
});✅ Type Safety: export type TErrorFields = 'take_profit' | 'stop_loss' | 'date_start' | 'stake' | 'amount';✅ Functional Components: Consistent use of functional components with hooks Could Be Improved// Current (menu-title.tsx:27)
{TranslationFlag[current_language] && TranslationFlag[current_language](22, 16)}
// Better - memoize the flag rendering
const flagIcon = useMemo(() =>
TranslationFlag[current_language]?.(22, 16),
[current_language]
);📊 SummaryMerge Blockers (Must Fix Before Merge)
Recommended Fixes
Positive Highlights
🎯 RecommendationDO NOT MERGE until issue #1 (parameterized error messages) is resolved. This is a significant UX regression that will affect all users. Once parameterized errors are working, this PR will restore language switching functionality effectively. The underlying architecture for dynamic validation messages is solid. Review completed by Claude Code • |
|
Some of the Claude comments worth looking into |
…ge method feat: Temporarily hide PayoutInfo component in ContractDetails feat: Temporarily hide InfoBox in TopWidgets component
|
Claude finished @akmal-deriv's task —— View job Code Review CompleteI've completed a comprehensive review of PR #368, focusing on correctness, code quality, performance, security, and testing. Here's my detailed analysis: 🔴 High Priority Issues1. Commented-Out UI Components Need ResolutionFiles:
Issue: Production code contains commented-out components with "Hidden as we disable longcode temporarily" comments: {/* <PayoutInfo contract_info={contract_info} /> */}
{/* {InfoBox} */}Impact: These appear to be intentionally hidden features, but there's no tracking issue or explanation of when they'll be restored. Recommendation:
2. All Parameterized Error Messages Are DisabledFile: Issue: Based on commit
User Impact: Users see generic "An error occurred. Please try again later." instead of actionable feedback like specific stake limits or barrier ranges. Root Cause: The comment says "Temporarily commented out - messages with dynamic parameters" but doesn't explain why. This appears related to the commit message "fix: Update error message mapping to use error code instead of subcode". Recommendation:
3. Runtime Validation for Unsupported Languages ✅ IMPLEMENTEDFile: Status: ✅ GOOD - This was addressed in commit if (UNSUPPORTED_LANGUAGES.includes(key)) {
return Promise.reject(new Error(`Language ${key} is not supported`));
}This properly prevents switching to unsupported languages via URL manipulation or API calls. 🟡 Medium Priority Issues4. Timer Memory Leak RiskFile: Issue: changeCurrentLanguage(new_language) {
if (this.changing_language_timer_id) clearTimeout(this.changing_language_timer_id);
this.current_language = new_language;
this.is_language_changing = true;
this.changing_language_timer_id = setTimeout(() => {
this.is_language_changing = false;
}, 2500);
}Risk: If the store is destroyed while Recommendation: Add cleanup in a dispose/destructor method, or convert to MobX 5. No Loading State Indication During Language SwitchFile: Issue: Clicking the language button opens the menu but doesn't show any loading state during the async onClick={() => {
if (!is_mobile_language_menu_open) {
setMobileLanguageMenuOpen(true); // Just opens menu
}
}}User Experience: Language switching involves:
Recommendation: Show a spinner or disabled state while 6. Test Coverage GapsFiles:
Issue: Multiple tests are skipped or commented out: it.skip('should substitute single parameter in error message', () => { ... });
// it('should render the PayoutInfo component', async () => { ... });Recommendation:
✅ Things Done Well7. Excellent Dynamic Validation Message PatternFile: Implementation: const getDynamicMessage = (messageKey: string) => () => localize(messageKey);
// Usage:
['req', { message: getDynamicMessage('Amount is a required field.') }]Why this is excellent:
✅ No changes needed 8. Proper Language Change ReactionFile: Implementation: reaction(
() => this.root_store.common.current_language,
() => {
// Clear existing validation errors to prevent stale messages
this.validation_errors = {};
// Regenerate all validation rules with new language
this.setValidationRules(getValidationRules());
this.changeDurationValidationRules();
}
);Why this is excellent:
✅ Well implemented 9. Robust Error Message Mapper ArchitectureFile: Good practices:
Note: While parameterized messages are currently disabled (issue #2), the underlying architecture is solid and ready for when they're re-enabled. 10. Clean Language Switcher IntegrationFiles:
Implementation:
✅ Good implementation 🔒 Security ReviewStatus: ✅ No security vulnerabilities found Checked:
⚡ Performance AnalysisLanguage Change Flow Performance:
Total: ~500ms - 2 seconds Optimization notes:
Recommendations:
const flagIcon = useMemo(() =>
TranslationFlag[current_language]?.(22, 16),
[current_language]
);📋 React/TypeScript Best PracticesGood Practices Observed:
Could Be Improved:
📊 Summary & RecommendationsCritical Items (Must Address):
Recommended Fixes:
Positive Highlights:
🎯 Final RecommendationConditional Approval with Required Fixes: The language switching functionality is well-implemented with a solid architecture. However, the parameterized error messages being disabled (Issue #2) is a significant UX regression that should be addressed. Options:
The other issues (#1, #4, #5, #6) should be addressed but are not merge-blockers. Questions for the team:
|
|
Claude finished @akmal-deriv's task —— View job PR Review Complete ✓I've completed a comprehensive review of PR #368 focusing on correctness, code quality, performance, security, and testing. Here are my findings: 🔴 High Priority Issues1. Commented-Out Production Code Needs ResolutionFiles:
Issue: Production components are commented out with "Hidden as we disable longcode temporarily": {/* <PayoutInfo contract_info={contract_info} /> */}
{/* {InfoBox} */}Recommendation:
2. All Parameterized Error Messages Are DisabledFile: Critical Issue: Based on commit
User Impact: Users will see generic "An error occurred. Please try again later." instead of actionable feedback with specific values. Test Impact: 6 tests skipped in Recommendation:
3. Language Validation ✅ IMPLEMENTED CORRECTLYFile: Status: ✅ GOOD - Runtime validation properly implemented: if (UNSUPPORTED_LANGUAGES.includes(key)) {
return Promise.reject(new Error(`Language ${key} is not supported`));
}This correctly prevents switching to unsupported languages. 🟡 Medium Priority Issues4. Timer Memory Leak RiskFile: Issue: changeCurrentLanguage(new_language) {
if (this.changing_language_timer_id) clearTimeout(this.changing_language_timer_id);
this.current_language = new_language;
this.is_language_changing = true;
this.changing_language_timer_id = setTimeout(() => {
this.is_language_changing = false;
}, 2500);
}Risk: If the store is destroyed while Recommendation: Add cleanup in a dispose/destructor method, or convert to MobX 5. No Loading State During Language SwitchFile: Issue: Language button provides no visual feedback during async operation: onClick={() => {
if (!is_mobile_language_menu_open) {
setMobileLanguageMenuOpen(true); // Just opens menu
}
}}User Experience Issue: Language switching involves: API call → localStorage update → moment.js init → URL update → WebSocket reconnection (total: ~500ms-2s) Store has Recommendation: Show spinner or disabled state while 6. Test Coverage GapsFiles:
Issue: Multiple tests are skipped or commented out due to disabled features. Recommendation:
✅ Things Done Well7. Excellent Dynamic Validation Message PatternFile: ✅ Great implementation: const getDynamicMessage = (messageKey: string) => () => localize(messageKey);
// Usage:
['req', { message: getDynamicMessage('Amount is a required field.') }]Why this is excellent:
No changes needed ✅ 8. Proper Language Change ReactionFile: ✅ Well-designed: reaction(
() => this.root_store.common.current_language,
() => {
// Clear existing validation errors to prevent stale messages
this.validation_errors = {};
// Regenerate all validation rules with new language
this.setValidationRules(getValidationRules());
this.changeDurationValidationRules();
}
);Why this is excellent:
No changes needed ✅ 9. Robust Error Message Mapper ArchitectureFile: ✅ Good practices:
Note: While parameterized messages are currently disabled (issue #2), the underlying architecture is solid and ready for when they're re-enabled. 10. Clean Language Switcher IntegrationFiles:
✅ Good implementation:
🔒 Security ReviewStatus: ✅ No security vulnerabilities found Checked:
⚡ Performance AnalysisLanguage Change Flow:
Total: ~500ms - 2 seconds Optimization notes:
Recommendations:
const flagIcon = useMemo(() =>
TranslationFlag[current_language]?.(22, 16),
[current_language]
);📋 React/TypeScript Best PracticesGood Practices Observed:
Could Be Improved:
📊 Summary & RecommendationsCritical Items (Must Address):
Recommended Fixes:
Positive Highlights:
🎯 Final RecommendationConditional Approval with Required Discussion: The language switching functionality is well-implemented with solid architecture. However, issue #2 (parameterized error messages being disabled) is a significant UX regression that needs discussion. Options:
The other issues (#1, #4, #5, #6) should be addressed but are not merge-blockers. Questions for the team:
|
Addressed important issues, but the critical issues it complains about are expected, the code was commented out for dynamic values and longcode |
|
Claude finished @akmal-deriv's task —— View job Code Review Complete ✓I've completed a comprehensive review of PR #368 focusing on correctness, code quality, performance, security, and testing. Based on the author's clarification that commented-out code and parameterized errors are intentional, I've adjusted my findings accordingly. 🎯 Overall AssessmentStatus: ✅ Approve with Recommendations This PR successfully restores language switcher functionality with a well-designed architecture for dynamic validation messages. The intentionally disabled features (parameterized errors, PayoutInfo, InfoBox) are properly documented with TODO comments as of commit 🟢 Strengths & Excellent Implementations1. Dynamic Validation Message Pattern ⭐File: Excellent solution for language switching: const getDynamicMessage = (messageKey: string) => () => localize(messageKey);
// Usage:
['req', { message: getDynamicMessage('Amount is a required field.') }]Why this is excellent:
2. Proper Language Change ReactionFile: Well-designed language change handler: reaction(
() => this.root_store.common.current_language,
() => {
// Clear existing validation errors to prevent stale messages
this.validation_errors = {};
// Regenerate all validation rules with new language
this.setValidationRules(getValidationRules());
this.changeDurationValidationRules();
}
);Benefits:
3. Language Validation Implemented Correctly ✅File: Runtime validation properly prevents unsupported languages: if (UNSUPPORTED_LANGUAGES.includes(key)) {
return Promise.reject(new Error(`Language ${key} is not supported`));
}This correctly blocks URL manipulation attempts (e.g., 4. Robust Error Message Mapper ArchitectureFile:
5. Clean UI IntegrationFiles:
🟡 Medium Priority Recommendations6. Timer Memory Leak RiskFile: Issue: changeCurrentLanguage(new_language) {
if (this.changing_language_timer_id) clearTimeout(this.changing_language_timer_id);
this.current_language = new_language;
this.is_language_changing = true;
this.changing_language_timer_id = setTimeout(() => {
this.is_language_changing = false;
}, 2500);
}Risk: If the store is destroyed while Recommendation: // Add a dispose method to CommonStore
dispose() {
if (this.changing_language_timer_id) {
clearTimeout(this.changing_language_timer_id);
}
}Or convert to MobX 7. No Loading State During Language SwitchFile: Issue: Language button provides no visual feedback during async operation: onClick={() => {
if (!is_mobile_language_menu_open) {
setMobileLanguageMenuOpen(true); // Just opens menu
}
}}User Experience Impact: Language switching involves:
Recommendation: <div className={is_language_changing ? 'loading' : ''}>
{is_language_changing ? <Spinner /> : (
TranslationFlag[current_language]?.(22, 16)
)}
</div>8. Performance: Memoization OpportunityFile: Current: {TranslationFlag[current_language] && TranslationFlag[current_language](22, 16)}Recommendation: const flagIcon = useMemo(() =>
TranslationFlag[current_language]?.(22, 16),
[current_language]
);Impact: Minor optimization, but good practice for components that may re-render frequently. 9. Test Coverage GapsFiles:
Status: Tests properly commented/skipped due to intentional feature disabling ✓ Recommendation: Consider adding:
10. Error Boundary ConsiderationContext: Language switching involves multiple async operations Risk: If localization fails during language change, it could crash the app. Recommendation: Consider wrapping language-sensitive components with error boundaries: <ErrorBoundary fallback={<LanguageSwitchError />}>
<MenuTitle />
</ErrorBoundary>🔒 Security ReviewStatus: ✅ No security vulnerabilities found Checked:
⚡ Performance AnalysisLanguage Change Flow Performance:
Total: ~500ms - 2 seconds Optimizations Observed:
Recommendations:
📋 React/TypeScript Best Practices✅ Good Practices Observed:
📊 Code Quality AssessmentCorrectness: ✅ Excellent
Code Quality: ✅ Good
Performance: ✅ Good
Security: ✅ Excellent
Testing: 🟡 Adequate
🎯 SummaryWhat Was Done Well:
Recommended Improvements (Non-Blocking):
Intentionally Disabled (As Expected):
All three are properly documented with TODO comments as of commit 🎬 Final Recommendation✅ APPROVE - This PR successfully restores language switcher functionality with a solid architecture. The intentionally disabled features are properly documented, and the core implementation is sound. The recommended improvements are minor and non-blocking. The language switching implementation is well-designed, secure, and performant. Great work on the dynamic validation message pattern! 🎉 |
🤖 Auto-generated PR
This PR was automatically created by ShiftAI CLI.
refactor: restore language switcher functionality in menu title and footer