LCH 🠖 RGB mismatch compared to other libraries

[adrian5]

This library looks wonderfully feature rich, but playing with the demo page I noticed that it produces a different RGB color than other libraries, given LCH input.

Input: { l: 59.6, c: 61.3, h: 24.3 }

Output:

• css.land/lch: #ec5f67
• GIMP: #ec5f67
• colord: #ec5f67
• d3-color: #ec5f67
• chroma.js: #ef6066

Is this due to differences in the transformation stages, or maybe LCHab vs LCHuv? I have very limited knowledge of this topic, so I couldn't say.

[notsidney]

I noticed this as well when converting from RGB to LCH.

Input: #421AFD

Output:

• css.land/lch: lch(33.789% 122.345 301.987)
• chroma.js: lch(35.959% 125.517 306.756)

Most noticeable is the +5 to the hue, which skews the colour closer to purple

[meodai]

as far as I understand it. the conversion depends on the white-point.

CIELAB is calculated relative to a reference white, for which the CIE recommends the use of CIE Standard Illuminant D65.[1] D65 is used in the vast majority industries and applications, with the notable exception being the printing industry which uses D50

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIELAB_color_space#Cylindrical_representation:_CIELCh_or_CIEHLC

So you would have to know what white-point each library is using to be able to compare its results.

[notsidney]

It looks like colord uses W3C sample code for making the conversion from RGB → LAB:
https://github.com/omgovich/colord/blob/master/src/colorModels/lab.ts#L45
https://www.w3.org/TR/css-color-4/#color-conversion-code

The W3C draft specifies the D50 whitepoint:

Convert from a D65 whitepoint (used by sRGB) to the D50 whitepoint used in Lab

https://www.w3.org/TR/css-color-4/#rgb-to-lab

d3-color uses their own algorithm and also uses D50 as the whitepoint:
https://github.com/d3/d3-color/blob/main/src/lab.js#L5
https://observablehq.com/@mbostock/lab-and-rgb

And chroma.js uses D65 here:
https://github.com/gka/chroma.js/blob/master/src/io/lab/lab-constants.js#L6

So this looks to be the reason for the difference

[Arkkimaagi]

https://css.land/lch seems to use https://drafts.csswg.org/css-color-4/utilities.js for converting between sRGB and LCH, which document the steps like this:

function sRGB_to_LCH(RGB) {
    // convert an array of gamma-corrected sRGB values
    // in the 0.0 to 1.0 range
    // to linear-light sRGB, then to CIE XYZ,
    // then adapt from D65 to D50,
    // then convert XYZ to CIE Lab
    // and finally, convert to CIE LCH

function LCH_to_sRGB(LCH) {
    // convert an array of CIE LCH values
    // to CIE Lab, and then to XYZ,
    // adapt from D50 to D65,
    // then convert XYZ to linear-light sRGB
    // and finally to gamma corrected sRGB
    // for in-gamut colors, components are in the 0.0 to 1.0 range
    // out of gamut colors may have negative components
    // or components greater than 1.0
    // so check for that :)

I do not know what steps chroma.js uses, but it would be interesting to know and hear the reasons for the difference in steps taken.

[gka]

Update: chroma.js now allows you to set a Lab illuminant: https://gka.github.io/chroma.js/#chroma-setlabwhitepoint

@adrian5 perhaps this helps your issue?