popular unsupported values of major keys

[matkoniecz]

Based on taginfo - so some may be fixed already (I noticed and removed barrier=log). Some have open PRs already. Some would be wrong to include, some would require checking.

Generated with https://github.com/matkoniecz/taginfo_api_wrapper_in_python#listing-popular-tags-unsupported-by-id

It is usable for review. But using it requires some thinking. For example I like shop = estate_agent and is in my opinion preferable to office = estate_agent (as office=estate_agent and other office=* is used both for places inaccessible to general population such as internal offices - and for ones accessible to general population, but changing id presents requires some investigation what other mappers think).

Note that some highly used values, are from imports of a low quality. That would allow filtering out values discussed separately and/or rejected. Many values initially on this list were filtered out and skipped.

If that list is useful - then more systematic reviewing like JOSM is doing may be useful.

Other potential comparisons: list tags supported by JOSM or Vespucci and not supported by iD.

• building=outbuilding 300k add two popular building values #528
• building=allotment_house 115k add two popular building values #528
• shop=estate_agent 4k
• shop=convenience;gas 2k
• shop=food 2k
• shop=ice_cream 2k
• shop=glaziery 1k
• shop=printing 1k
• natural=land 68k (note that very large part is remain of broken CanVec importing, see say https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/3524361691 - maybe at least nodes can be mass deleted, obviously after consulting Canadian community - though some of them indicate not yet mapped islets). Though I think that this value can be anyway excluded from listing here. Though maybe it can be a validator warning?
• natural=crevasse 36k - inflated by import (see https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/natural=crevasse#chronology ) - skipping
• natural=sinkhole 26k add natural=sinkhole  #604
• natural=hill 24k
• amenity=mobile_money_agent 10k
• amenity=waste_dump_site 7k
• landuse=village_green 104k New preset: landuse=village_green #15
• power=portal 136k Add gantry presets #649
• power=catenary_mast 54k Create catenary_mast.json #593
• power=terminal 37k proposed in Add preset for power=terminal #653
• power=insulator 27k
• power=heliostat 18k
• power=cable_distribution_cabinet 8k
• power=cable_distribution 4k
• power=connection 3k
• power=switchgear 3k
• power=compensator 2k
• power=abandoned:tower 2k (It is obviously mistagged abandoned:power=tower)
• power=circuit 2k
• place=allotments 18k
• railway=stop 99k
• railway=facility 8k (got deprecated - see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:railway%3Dfacility )
• railway=site 6k
• railway=junction 6k
• railway=preserved 6k
• railway=signal_box 5k
• barrier=jersey_barrier 17k Add more barrier presets #506
• barrier=handrail 8k
• barrier=avalanche_protection 5k, see Include man_made=snow_fence? #91
• barrier=hampshire_gate 4k Add more barrier presets #506
• barrier=line 4k
• barrier=debris 3k
• barrier=median_strip 3k
• highway=emergency_access_point 43k added highway=emergency_access_point #504
• highway=busway 6k Add highway=busway preset #163
• highway=via_ferrata 2k
• highway=priority 1k
• highway=speed_display 1k Add Radar Speed Sign preset #442
• highway=escape 1k Add Preset: highway=escape #146
• waterway=rapids 46k
• waterway=drystream 14k
• waterway=pressurised 6k
• craft = builder 2k
• craft = jeweller 1k
• man_made = kiln 29k
• man_made = gantry 11k Add gantry presets #649
• man_made = dolphin 9k
• man_made = tar_kiln 7k
• man_made = avalanche_protection 7k
• man_made = snow_fence 5k Include man_made=snow_fence? #91
• man_made = geoglyph 5k Consider adding man_made=geoglyph to presets #14
• man_made = waterway 5k
• man_made = tank 4k
• man_made = spoil_heap 4k
• man_made = cooling 4k
• man_made = snow_cannon 3k
• man_made = reinforced_slope 3k
• man_made = mine 3k
• man_made = telephone_box 3k
• man_made = telescope 3k
• man_made = communications_tower 3k
• man_made = excavation 3k
• man_made = flare 3k
• man_made = quay 3k Add preset for man_made=quay #810
• advertising = sign 5k
• advertising = flag 3k
• aeroway = navigationaid 32k
• aeroway = taxilane 5k
• aeroway = airstrip 5k
• aeroway = stopway 2k
• aeroway = tower 1k
• boundary = protected_area 101k
• boundary = postal_code 51k
• boundary = census 23k
• boundary = marker 17k
• boundary = landuse 16k
• boundary = local_authority 15k
• emergency = water_tank 24k - see popular unsupported values of major keys #529 (comment)
• emergency = suction_point 15k
• emergency = access_point 10k
• emergency = fire_water_pond 4k
• emergency = drinking_water 1k
• emergency = dry_riser_inlet 1k proposed in emergency=dry_riser_inlet #642 replaced with emergency = fire_service_inlet see Add emergency=fire_service_inlet #806
• cycleway = no 264k
• cycleway = shared 11k
• cycleway = shoulder 5k
• cycleway = yes 5k - note that it is not a good tagging and if supported then by some kind of warning or request to provide proper data
• cycleway:left = no 49k
• cycleway:right = no 208k
• cycleway:both = no 685k - see Handle cycleway:both similar to cycleway #743
• cycleway:both = lane 29k- see Handle cycleway:both similar to cycleway #743
• cycleway:both = shared_lane 9k- see Handle cycleway:both similar to cycleway #743
• cycleway:both = track 7k- see Handle cycleway:both similar to cycleway #743
• historic = yes 145k
• historic = charcoal_pile 44k
• historic = shieling 19k
• historic = railway 17k
• historic = citywalls 15k
• historic = bomb_crater 10k
• historic = mine 10k
• historic = mine_shaft 10k
• military = yes 2k
• route = ski 7k
• route = tracks 3k
• route = share_taxi 2k
• sport = golf 68k related: New preset: shop=golf #21
• sport = fitness 41k
• sport = athletics 36k
• sport = gymnastics 5k
• sport = skiing 5k note that it maybe is duplicate of sport=ski related: New preset: shop=ski #22
• sport = handball 5k
• sport = free_flying 4k
• sport = scuba_diving 4k
• sport = canoe 3k
• sport = soccer;basketball 3k
• sport = pelota 3k
• sport = football 3k - support, if any, would be some kind of complaint/QA report, see see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Football and https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:sport%3Dfootball
• sport = hockey 2k
• sport = gaelic_games 2k
• sport = disc_golf 2k
• sport = rugby 2k
• healthcare = centre 47k
• healthcare = nurse 1k

[tyrasd]

Thanks for compiling this list. I've marked off a few which have been recently added to the repository: highway=speed_display, highway=emergency_access_point and some of the barrier options.

[matkoniecz]

added some issue links

barrier=handrail seems a good target for me.

barrier=debris 3k and power=catenary_mast 54k power=heliostat 18k looks like a niche but valid to include as far as I can see

highway=via_ferrata 2k seems a good idea, but likely should be verified with wider community

note: no significant research was done here

[danieldegroot2]

@matkoniecz could you exclude power=abandoned:tower, please? It is obviously abandoned:power=tower.

[matkoniecz]

Noted in the list, opened some notes like https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/3277875 https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/3277873 https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/3277890 https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/3277888 https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/3277885

See https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/power=abandoned:tower#map and https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1klr

[westnordost]

Regarding shop=estate_agent 4k, would

1. a PR to deprecate shop=estate_agent and "upgrade" to office=estate_agent be accepted?
2. or, would a PR to add a non-searchable preset (to not promote, but understand it) for shop=estate_agent be accepted?

[matkoniecz]

office=estate_agent has problem of mixing "place where actual clients can go and talk/actually buy real estate" and "internal office of company handling real estate, no entry for clients"

Second one would be better tagged office=company - maybe with company=real_estate

So can we avoid deprecation here?

[matkoniecz]

I added listing for keys such as: craft, man_made, advertising, aeroway, boundary, emergency, cycleway (and its variants), historic, military, route, sport, healthcare (with some dubious popular values excluded)

And marked natural=crevasse as ignored, as it is basically import only

[danieldegroot2]

From existing list;

• sport = golf 68k - Related: New preset: shop=golf #21
• sport = skiing 5k - Possible duplicate of sport=ski. Related: New preset: shop=ski #22

[matkoniecz]

edited

[hamishmb]

I'm an avid StreetCompleter, and end up creating notes for some of these things because there's not an in-app way to add them, or change them.

I think these cleanups are a good idea too - what does man_made = beam even mean anyway? Due to my autism, I probably get confused by these things more easily than some.

[arch0345]

A preset for power=catenary_mast was added in #593

[arch0345]

#649 added a preset for power=portal in addition to man_made=gantry

A preset for power=terminal was proposed in #653

A preset for emergency=dry_riser_inlet was proposed in #642

[matkoniecz]

List updated.

[k-yle]

@matkoniecz irrigation=pivot isn't in the list, but it has 25k uses and presets in JOSM and Vespucci

[matkoniecz]

@k-yle That is because this list has only popular values of "major keys" (due to technical limitations and to avoid need for vading through import debris)

Feel free top open a new issue for it if support for that tag is needed/useful.

[Dimitar5555]

There is a field for all cycleway(:*) values except for cycleway:both which is tracked in #743.

man_made=gantry has also been added.

[matkoniecz]

man_made=gantry has also been added.

marked

[tyrasd]

emergency = water_tank 24k

I think this tag is already covered well enough, as the documented tagging methods are already represented as presets:

• https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/blob/v6.0.0/data/presets/emergency/water_tank.json
• https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/blob/v6.0.0/data/presets/emergency/water_reservoir_covered.json
• https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/blob/v6.0.0/data/presets/emergency/water_reservoir.json

Is there anything we have overlooked?

[matkoniecz]

marked as done

[matkoniecz]

cycleway:both which is tracked in #743.

marked

[matkoniecz]

@tyrasd

https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/blob/v6.0.0/data/presets/emergency/water_tank.json

Why then emergency=water_tank is not listed at https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/emergency=water_tank#projects (as specific value, emergency=* is generically listed) ?

[matkoniecz]

Maybe closing this issue and generating new one like this would be useful? (this will take me about 10 minutes, including time to move linked issues/PRs, so it is more question whether new one will be more useful)