You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Beginning with the new puf.csv file used by Tax-Calculator release 0.9.0, we have found that the old quick-sample settings being used by TaxBrain are no longer very good.
The old settings were to use a random-number seed of 80 and a 0.02 (two percent) sample.
With the old puf.csv file that produced sample results that were within plus/minus one percent of the full sample tax revenues.
But using these old settings with the new puf.csv file produces differences of more than plus/minus one percent in every year with the largest difference being over 2.8 percent.
We have found that changing the settings to a random-number seed of 180 and a sampling fraction of 0.05 (five percent) restores the old situation in which the sample results are within plus/minus one percent of the full sample tax revenues. For more details, see Tax-Calculator pull request 1441.
It seems as if TaxBrain users who use this feature (if there are any) are going to notice this change. So, it would seem like a simple enhancement to change the settings to 180 and 0.05.
Unless others object to this enhancement, perhaps @GoFroggyRun could prepare a webapp-public pull request that implements the new settings and changes the label on the button so that it says 5% instead of %2.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Beginning with the new
puf.csv
file used by Tax-Calculator release 0.9.0, we have found that the old quick-sample settings being used by TaxBrain are no longer very good.The old settings were to use a random-number seed of 80 and a 0.02 (two percent) sample.
With the old
puf.csv
file that produced sample results that were within plus/minus one percent of the full sample tax revenues.But using these old settings with the new
puf.csv
file produces differences of more than plus/minus one percent in every year with the largest difference being over 2.8 percent.We have found that changing the settings to a random-number seed of 180 and a sampling fraction of 0.05 (five percent) restores the old situation in which the sample results are within plus/minus one percent of the full sample tax revenues. For more details, see Tax-Calculator pull request 1441.
It seems as if TaxBrain users who use this feature (if there are any) are going to notice this change. So, it would seem like a simple enhancement to change the settings to 180 and 0.05.
@MattHJensen @feenberg @GoFroggyRun @PeterDSteinberg @brittainhard
Unless others object to this enhancement, perhaps @GoFroggyRun could prepare a webapp-public pull request that implements the new settings and changes the label on the button so that it says 5% instead of %2.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: