diff --git a/webextensions/sidebar/styles/base.css b/webextensions/sidebar/styles/base.css
index 26ddbf87f..67ac22ec3 100644
--- a/webextensions/sidebar/styles/base.css
+++ b/webextensions/sidebar/styles/base.css
@@ -787,6 +787,10 @@ tab-item.faviconized .contextual-identity-marker {
   mask: url("./icons/ArrowheadDown.svg") no-repeat center / 60%;
 }
 
+#contextual-identities-selector li:not([data-icon]) {
+  padding-left: calc(var(--favicon-size) + 0.7em);
+}
+
 
 #out-of-view-tab-notifier {
   background: transparent repeat-x bottom;