diff --git a/disc_adj_rans/naca0012/of_grad_cd.csv.ref b/disc_adj_rans/naca0012/of_grad_cd.csv.ref index 43d5fd55..f6bb7da1 100644 --- a/disc_adj_rans/naca0012/of_grad_cd.csv.ref +++ b/disc_adj_rans/naca0012/of_grad_cd.csv.ref @@ -1,243 +1,243 @@ "VARIABLE" , "GRADIENT" , "FINDIFF_STEP" -0 , 0.00748791 , 0.001 -1 , 0.0169712 , 0.001 -2 , 0.0271195 , 0.001 -3 , 0.0350068 , 0.001 -4 , 0.0232689 , 0.001 -5 , -0.0287927 , 0.001 -6 , -0.106677 , 0.001 -7 , -0.15335 , 0.001 -8 , -0.129147 , 0.001 -9 , -0.0619824 , 0.001 -10 , -0.0117455 , 0.001 -11 , 0.0169851 , 0.001 -12 , 0.027076 , 0.001 -13 , 0.0283317 , 0.001 -14 , 0.0252285 , 0.001 -15 , 0.00904789 , 0.001 -16 , -0.0326991 , 0.001 -17 , -0.0898317 , 0.001 -18 , -0.122963 , 0.001 -19 , -0.101204 , 0.001 -20 , -0.0420788 , 0.001 -21 , 0.000392329 , 0.001 -22 , 0.022478 , 0.001 -23 , 0.0280512 , 0.001 -24 , 0.0199537 , 0.001 -25 , 0.0114851 , 0.001 -26 , 0.00200178 , 0.001 -27 , -0.0136283 , 0.001 -28 , -0.032991 , 0.001 -29 , -0.0424662 , 0.001 -30 , -0.027762 , 0.001 -31 , 0.00610704 , 0.001 -32 , 0.0226588 , 0.001 -33 , 0.0213315 , 0.001 -34 , 0.0231769 , 0.001 -35 , 0.0127829 , 0.001 -36 , 0.00509387 , 0.001 -37 , 0.000881109 , 0.001 -38 , -0.00275172 , 0.001 -39 , -0.00568375 , 0.001 -40 , -0.00309128 , 0.001 -41 , 0.0122073 , 0.001 -42 , 0.0367431 , 0.001 -43 , 0.0381076 , 0.001 -44 , 0.0153486 , 0.001 -45 , 0.015685 , 0.001 -46 , 0.00779089 , 0.001 -47 , 0.00268837 , 0.001 -48 , 0.000750711 , 0.001 -49 , 0.000391249 , 0.001 -50 , 0.00235287 , 0.001 -51 , 0.0103864 , 0.001 -52 , 0.0287948 , 0.001 -53 , 0.0502592 , 0.001 -54 , 0.042991 , 0.001 -55 , 0.00858604 , 0.001 -56 , 0.00892753 , 0.001 -57 , 0.00487473 , 0.001 -58 , 0.00217281 , 0.001 -59 , 0.000968268 , 0.001 -60 , 0.00108542 , 0.001 -61 , 0.0045273 , 0.001 -62 , 0.0153322 , 0.001 -63 , 0.0351337 , 0.001 -64 , 0.0520878 , 0.001 -65 , 0.0388631 , 0.001 -66 , 0.00389719 , 0.001 -67 , 0.00488039 , 0.001 -68 , 0.00403242 , 0.001 -69 , 0.0028987 , 0.001 -70 , 0.00137185 , 0.001 -71 , 0.000368357 , 0.001 -72 , 0.00306217 , 0.001 -73 , 0.0137902 , 0.001 -74 , 0.0318694 , 0.001 -75 , 0.0433312 , 0.001 -76 , 0.0286976 , 0.001 -77 , 0.00165814 , 0.001 -78 , 0.00331212 , 0.001 -79 , 0.00450232 , 0.001 -80 , 0.0041486 , 0.001 -81 , 0.00144877 , 0.001 -82 , -0.00228462 , 0.001 -83 , -0.00292026 , 0.001 -84 , 0.00449439 , 0.001 -85 , 0.0186435 , 0.001 -86 , 0.0267295 , 0.001 -87 , 0.0165407 , 0.001 -88 , 0.000827335 , 0.001 -89 , 0.0026815 , 0.001 -90 , 0.00469264 , 0.001 -91 , 0.00455069 , 0.001 -92 , 0.000536465 , 0.001 -93 , -0.00619365 , 0.001 -94 , -0.0108663 , 0.001 -95 , -0.00786675 , 0.001 -96 , 0.00223619 , 0.001 -97 , 0.00968814 , 0.001 -98 , 0.00661605 , 0.001 -99 , 0.000430853 , 0.001 -100 , 0.00179947 , 0.001 -101 , 0.00351603 , 0.001 -102 , 0.00338245 , 0.001 -103 , -0.000656189 , 0.001 -104 , -0.00782443 , 0.001 -105 , -0.0136667 , 0.001 -106 , -0.0132007 , 0.001 -107 , -0.00655114 , 0.001 -108 , -4.05891e-05 , 0.001 -109 , 0.00131339 , 0.001 -110 , 0.000151525 , 0.001 -111 , 0.000790136 , 0.001 -112 , 0.00197531 , 0.001 -113 , 0.0028519 , 0.001 -114 , 0.00189764 , 0.001 -115 , -0.00138936 , 0.001 -116 , -0.00504433 , 0.001 -117 , -0.0061129 , 0.001 -118 , -0.00403923 , 0.001 -119 , -0.00129092 , 0.001 -120 , -6.10614e-05 , 0.001 -121 , 0.00367925 , 0.001 -122 , 0.0630925 , 0.001 -123 , 0.164351 , 0.001 -124 , 0.249412 , 0.001 -125 , 0.298397 , 0.001 -126 , 0.336742 , 0.001 -127 , 0.374949 , 0.001 -128 , 0.37691 , 0.001 -129 , 0.305695 , 0.001 -130 , 0.180435 , 0.001 -131 , 0.0619926 , 0.001 -132 , -0.0269064 , 0.001 -133 , 0.0183989 , 0.001 -134 , 0.113709 , 0.001 -135 , 0.183592 , 0.001 -136 , 0.213517 , 0.001 -137 , 0.239015 , 0.001 -138 , 0.28033 , 0.001 -139 , 0.311833 , 0.001 -140 , 0.293488 , 0.001 -141 , 0.214472 , 0.001 -142 , 0.0967404 , 0.001 -143 , -0.0553176 , 0.001 -144 , -0.0420069 , 0.001 -145 , 0.0171897 , 0.001 -146 , 0.0571625 , 0.001 -147 , 0.070092 , 0.001 -148 , 0.0793335 , 0.001 -149 , 0.100061 , 0.001 -150 , 0.127153 , 0.001 -151 , 0.145327 , 0.001 -152 , 0.137698 , 0.001 -153 , 0.0820649 , 0.001 -154 , -0.0564188 , 0.001 -155 , -0.0558199 , 0.001 -156 , -0.0193753 , 0.001 -157 , 0.0047653 , 0.001 -158 , 0.0123407 , 0.001 -159 , 0.0148202 , 0.001 -160 , 0.0187626 , 0.001 -161 , 0.0244774 , 0.001 -162 , 0.0321613 , 0.001 -163 , 0.0421464 , 0.001 -164 , 0.0364993 , 0.001 -165 , -0.0400068 , 0.001 -166 , -0.0423937 , 0.001 -167 , -0.0218197 , 0.001 -168 , -0.00758439 , 0.001 -169 , -0.0025584 , 0.001 -170 , -0.00341555 , 0.001 -171 , -0.0108307 , 0.001 -172 , -0.0268295 , 0.001 -173 , -0.0448655 , 0.001 -174 , -0.0436121 , 0.001 -175 , -0.015658 , 0.001 -176 , -0.0229307 , 0.001 -177 , -0.0286488 , 0.001 -178 , -0.0219072 , 0.001 -179 , -0.0150282 , 0.001 -180 , -0.0111992 , 0.001 -181 , -0.0145018 , 0.001 -182 , -0.0320713 , 0.001 -183 , -0.0672901 , 0.001 -184 , -0.105424 , 0.001 -185 , -0.107617 , 0.001 -186 , -0.0529488 , 0.001 -187 , -0.0128446 , 0.001 -188 , -0.0241591 , 0.001 -189 , -0.0302865 , 0.001 -190 , -0.0299926 , 0.001 -191 , -0.0260554 , 0.001 -192 , -0.0296287 , 0.001 -193 , -0.0542022 , 0.001 -194 , -0.101322 , 0.001 -195 , -0.144659 , 0.001 -196 , -0.136728 , 0.001 -197 , -0.0646092 , 0.001 -198 , -0.0087657 , 0.001 -199 , -0.0261754 , 0.001 -200 , -0.0450501 , 0.001 -201 , -0.0537607 , 0.001 -202 , -0.050527 , 0.001 -203 , -0.0498284 , 0.001 -204 , -0.0706021 , 0.001 -205 , -0.113446 , 0.001 -206 , -0.145863 , 0.001 -207 , -0.124617 , 0.001 -208 , -0.0534875 , 0.001 -209 , -0.00688288 , 0.001 -210 , -0.0277712 , 0.001 -211 , -0.0587612 , 0.001 -212 , -0.0838713 , 0.001 -213 , -0.0912081 , 0.001 -214 , -0.0863706 , 0.001 -215 , -0.0872397 , 0.001 -216 , -0.10148 , 0.001 -217 , -0.109032 , 0.001 -218 , -0.0825329 , 0.001 -219 , -0.0316796 , 0.001 -220 , -0.0048217 , 0.001 -221 , -0.0249852 , 0.001 -222 , -0.0679614 , 0.001 -223 , -0.126407 , 0.001 -224 , -0.174961 , 0.001 -225 , -0.185491 , 0.001 -226 , -0.155055 , 0.001 -227 , -0.109822 , 0.001 -228 , -0.071674 , 0.001 -229 , -0.0397063 , 0.001 -230 , -0.0127185 , 0.001 -231 , -0.00251377 , 0.001 -232 , -0.0178807 , 0.001 -233 , -0.0651218 , 0.001 -234 , -0.153618 , 0.001 -235 , -0.251574 , 0.001 -236 , -0.292629 , 0.001 -237 , -0.242751 , 0.001 -238 , -0.14309 , 0.001 -239 , -0.0599745 , 0.001 -240 , -0.0180198 , 0.001 -241 , -0.00341126 , 0.001 +0 , 0.00748103 , 0.001 +1 , 0.016951 , 0.001 +2 , 0.0271005 , 0.001 +3 , 0.0350134 , 0.001 +4 , 0.0232918 , 0.001 +5 , -0.0287974 , 0.001 +6 , -0.106721 , 0.001 +7 , -0.153387 , 0.001 +8 , -0.129143 , 0.001 +9 , -0.0619589 , 0.001 +10 , -0.0117337 , 0.001 +11 , 0.0169778 , 0.001 +12 , 0.027052 , 0.001 +13 , 0.0283007 , 0.001 +14 , 0.0252105 , 0.001 +15 , 0.00904322 , 0.001 +16 , -0.0327104 , 0.001 +17 , -0.0898505 , 0.001 +18 , -0.122962 , 0.001 +19 , -0.101171 , 0.001 +20 , -0.0420399 , 0.001 +21 , 0.000410172 , 0.001 +22 , 0.0224766 , 0.001 +23 , 0.0280408 , 0.001 +24 , 0.0199371 , 0.001 +25 , 0.0114716 , 0.001 +26 , 0.00199447 , 0.001 +27 , -0.0136328 , 0.001 +28 , -0.0329911 , 0.001 +29 , -0.0424539 , 0.001 +30 , -0.0277368 , 0.001 +31 , 0.00613259 , 0.001 +32 , 0.0226714 , 0.001 +33 , 0.0213356 , 0.001 +34 , 0.0231783 , 0.001 +35 , 0.01278 , 0.001 +36 , 0.00509013 , 0.001 +37 , 0.000878723 , 0.001 +38 , -0.00275261 , 0.001 +39 , -0.00568267 , 0.001 +40 , -0.00308708 , 0.001 +41 , 0.0122141 , 0.001 +42 , 0.0367498 , 0.001 +43 , 0.0381113 , 0.001 +44 , 0.0153549 , 0.001 +45 , 0.0156916 , 0.001 +46 , 0.00779391 , 0.001 +47 , 0.00268895 , 0.001 +48 , 0.000750555 , 0.001 +49 , 0.000390859 , 0.001 +50 , 0.00235174 , 0.001 +51 , 0.0103833 , 0.001 +52 , 0.0287887 , 0.001 +53 , 0.050252 , 0.001 +54 , 0.0429872 , 0.001 +55 , 0.00859185 , 0.001 +56 , 0.00893482 , 0.001 +57 , 0.00487921 , 0.001 +58 , 0.00217463 , 0.001 +59 , 0.000968826 , 0.001 +60 , 0.00108511 , 0.001 +61 , 0.00452478 , 0.001 +62 , 0.0153247 , 0.001 +63 , 0.0351198 , 0.001 +64 , 0.0520721 , 0.001 +65 , 0.0388546 , 0.001 +66 , 0.00390119 , 0.001 +67 , 0.00488603 , 0.001 +68 , 0.00403642 , 0.001 +69 , 0.00290085 , 0.001 +70 , 0.00137334 , 0.001 +71 , 0.000369491 , 0.001 +72 , 0.00306088 , 0.001 +73 , 0.0137824 , 0.001 +74 , 0.0318535 , 0.001 +75 , 0.0433133 , 0.001 +76 , 0.0286883 , 0.001 +77 , 0.00166025 , 0.001 +78 , 0.00331555 , 0.001 +79 , 0.00450558 , 0.001 +80 , 0.00415197 , 0.001 +81 , 0.00145341 , 0.001 +82 , -0.0022786 , 0.001 +83 , -0.00291546 , 0.001 +84 , 0.00449291 , 0.001 +85 , 0.0186332 , 0.001 +86 , 0.0267163 , 0.001 +87 , 0.0165338 , 0.001 +88 , 0.000828267 , 0.001 +89 , 0.00268399 , 0.001 +90 , 0.00469804 , 0.001 +91 , 0.00456069 , 0.001 +92 , 0.000550421 , 0.001 +93 , -0.00617885 , 0.001 +94 , -0.0108541 , 0.001 +95 , -0.00786033 , 0.001 +96 , 0.00223489 , 0.001 +97 , 0.00968263 , 0.001 +98 , 0.00661277 , 0.001 +99 , 0.00043155 , 0.001 +100 , 0.00180388 , 0.001 +101 , 0.00353043 , 0.001 +102 , 0.0034095 , 0.001 +103 , -0.000626439 , 0.001 +104 , -0.00780725 , 0.001 +105 , -0.0136649 , 0.001 +106 , -0.0132049 , 0.001 +107 , -0.00655456 , 0.001 +108 , -4.27474e-05 , 0.001 +109 , 0.00131241 , 0.001 +110 , 0.000152359 , 0.001 +111 , 0.000796477 , 0.001 +112 , 0.00199578 , 0.001 +113 , 0.00288603 , 0.001 +114 , 0.00192302 , 0.001 +115 , -0.00139814 , 0.001 +116 , -0.00508229 , 0.001 +117 , -0.00615051 , 0.001 +118 , -0.00405857 , 0.001 +119 , -0.00129628 , 0.001 +120 , -6.17568e-05 , 0.001 +121 , 0.00366612 , 0.001 +122 , 0.0630666 , 0.001 +123 , 0.164321 , 0.001 +124 , 0.249387 , 0.001 +125 , 0.298412 , 0.001 +126 , 0.336847 , 0.001 +127 , 0.375123 , 0.001 +128 , 0.377054 , 0.001 +129 , 0.30574 , 0.001 +130 , 0.180412 , 0.001 +131 , 0.0619717 , 0.001 +132 , -0.0269337 , 0.001 +133 , 0.0183493 , 0.001 +134 , 0.113666 , 0.001 +135 , 0.18357 , 0.001 +136 , 0.213531 , 0.001 +137 , 0.239081 , 0.001 +138 , 0.280424 , 0.001 +139 , 0.311888 , 0.001 +140 , 0.293462 , 0.001 +141 , 0.214404 , 0.001 +142 , 0.0967017 , 0.001 +143 , -0.0553479 , 0.001 +144 , -0.0420568 , 0.001 +145 , 0.017151 , 0.001 +146 , 0.0571454 , 0.001 +147 , 0.0700936 , 0.001 +148 , 0.0793497 , 0.001 +149 , 0.100078 , 0.001 +150 , 0.127146 , 0.001 +151 , 0.14528 , 0.001 +152 , 0.137635 , 0.001 +153 , 0.0820327 , 0.001 +154 , -0.056447 , 0.001 +155 , -0.0558594 , 0.001 +156 , -0.0194022 , 0.001 +157 , 0.00475395 , 0.001 +158 , 0.0123385 , 0.001 +159 , 0.0148215 , 0.001 +160 , 0.0187614 , 0.001 +161 , 0.024465 , 0.001 +162 , 0.032131 , 0.001 +163 , 0.0421069 , 0.001 +164 , 0.0364775 , 0.001 +165 , -0.0400321 , 0.001 +166 , -0.0424251 , 0.001 +167 , -0.0218386 , 0.001 +168 , -0.00759162 , 0.001 +169 , -0.00256025 , 0.001 +170 , -0.00341628 , 0.001 +171 , -0.0108332 , 0.001 +172 , -0.0268377 , 0.001 +173 , -0.0448839 , 0.001 +174 , -0.043639 , 0.001 +175 , -0.015677 , 0.001 +176 , -0.0229504 , 0.001 +177 , -0.0286727 , 0.001 +178 , -0.0219211 , 0.001 +179 , -0.0150329 , 0.001 +180 , -0.0111999 , 0.001 +181 , -0.0145024 , 0.001 +182 , -0.0320742 , 0.001 +183 , -0.0672979 , 0.001 +184 , -0.105439 , 0.001 +185 , -0.107639 , 0.001 +186 , -0.0529659 , 0.001 +187 , -0.0128566 , 0.001 +188 , -0.0241741 , 0.001 +189 , -0.0302944 , 0.001 +190 , -0.0299934 , 0.001 +191 , -0.0260534 , 0.001 +192 , -0.0296275 , 0.001 +193 , -0.0542046 , 0.001 +194 , -0.10133 , 0.001 +195 , -0.144673 , 0.001 +196 , -0.136746 , 0.001 +197 , -0.0646214 , 0.001 +198 , -0.00877102 , 0.001 +199 , -0.0261815 , 0.001 +200 , -0.0450511 , 0.001 +201 , -0.0537571 , 0.001 +202 , -0.0505227 , 0.001 +203 , -0.0498258 , 0.001 +204 , -0.0706027 , 0.001 +205 , -0.113452 , 0.001 +206 , -0.145874 , 0.001 +207 , -0.124629 , 0.001 +208 , -0.0534944 , 0.001 +209 , -0.00688432 , 0.001 +210 , -0.0277719 , 0.001 +211 , -0.05876 , 0.001 +212 , -0.0838719 , 0.001 +213 , -0.0912138 , 0.001 +214 , -0.0863779 , 0.001 +215 , -0.0872437 , 0.001 +216 , -0.101482 , 0.001 +217 , -0.109037 , 0.001 +218 , -0.0825389 , 0.001 +219 , -0.0316826 , 0.001 +220 , -0.00482186 , 0.001 +221 , -0.0249853 , 0.001 +222 , -0.0679633 , 0.001 +223 , -0.126413 , 0.001 +224 , -0.174968 , 0.001 +225 , -0.185489 , 0.001 +226 , -0.155042 , 0.001 +227 , -0.109808 , 0.001 +228 , -0.0716668 , 0.001 +229 , -0.0397056 , 0.001 +230 , -0.0127191 , 0.001 +231 , -0.00251355 , 0.001 +232 , -0.017878 , 0.001 +233 , -0.0651064 , 0.001 +234 , -0.153567 , 0.001 +235 , -0.251467 , 0.001 +236 , -0.292481 , 0.001 +237 , -0.242612 , 0.001 +238 , -0.143002 , 0.001 +239 , -0.0599388 , 0.001 +240 , -0.0180115 , 0.001 +241 , -0.00341046 , 0.001