How to compare the embeddings?

[Neltherion]

Hi

The original DeepInsight implementation in the MXNet first preprocesses the image (Face detection, cropping and preprocessing), then extracts its embeddings and finally normalizes it so that when we want to compare two features the code would be like this:

dist = np.sum(np.square(embedding1 - embedding2))
print("Distance => %s" % dist)
sim = np.dot(embedding1, embedding2.T)
print("Similarity => %s" % sim)

When I checked your example.py file I didn't see any of the mentioned preprocessings. The code simply reads an image, resizes it to (112,112) (without detecting the face) and then proceeds to extract its features.

Shouldn't we first detect the face and then the extract the embeddings?

I went ahead and did some tests with this code and the Similarities are off the charts and plain wrong (even with different dropout rates):

model = base_server.BaseServer(model_fp=configs.face_describer_model_fp,
                               input_tensor_names=configs.face_describer_input_tensor_names,
                               output_tensor_names=configs.face_describer_output_tensor_names,
                               device=configs.face_describer_device)

# Define input tensors feed to session graph
dropout_rate = 0.1

first_image = cv2.imread('./Images/1.jpg')
first_image = cv2.resize(first_image, (112, 112))
input_data = [np.expand_dims(first_image, axis=0), dropout_rate]
face_descriptor1 = model.inference(data=input_data)
embedding1 = preprocessing.normalize(face_descriptor1[0])

second_image = cv2.imread('./Images/4.jpg')
second_image = cv2.resize(second_image, (112, 112))
input_data = [np.expand_dims(second_image, axis=0), dropout_rate]
face_descriptor2 = model.inference(data=input_data)
embedding2 = preprocessing.normalize(face_descriptor2[0])

dist = np.sum(np.square(embedding1 - embedding2))
print("Distance => %s" % dist)

sim = np.dot(embedding1, embedding2.T)
print("Similarity => %s" % sim)

Am I doing something wrong?

Thanks

[YaroslavSchubert]

Dropout should be 1.0

[mohamadaminshams]

@Neltherion i want compare two embeding
did you find any solution?

[mohamadaminshams]

i found this solution
when you want compare two embeding you should use this lib:
https://github.com/AIInAi/tf-insightface/blob/master/services/face_services.py