Any XU2 recipe that requires xp doesn't show the crafting table recipe on JEI

[Flamebom]

Modpack version
1.6.2

Can the issue be reproduced?
Yes

Logs
N/A

Issue
XU2 items that require xp (Magical Wood, Golden Lasso and probably Magical apple) don't have their JEI crafting recipe show up.

[NielsPilgaard]

Thank you for the report, I will investigate the issue.

[Frikkle]

I crafted one last night and I was pretty sure I did it from JEI. Just checked and for me the recipe shows. Version 1.62 stock.

[Frikkle]

@Flamebom You mentioned that after re-logging in it persists; I noticed in some other cases that in the client boot process there's a small change that items don't get properly registered (or the client crashes due to some recipe conflict, or some other mysterious reason).

Did you try restarting the client?

[stefancdr]

Can confirm I have the same issue. I had a suspicion what might be causing it, so I tried the following:

1. Tried crafting the item using the recipe (Frikkle told me what the recipe is) whilst having 0 xp. This did not work, the recipe did not show up and I could not craft the item (expected behaviour).
2. Gave myself 8 levels of XP using my XP charm and tried crafting the item. This worked as expected. Still could not see the recipe in JEI.
3. Gave myself 10+ levels of XP and restarted my client.
4. Recipe still does not work.

So my idea of what might be causing it is this: when you don't have enough XP to craft the item, the recipe is disabled by XU2. Since this is the case while starting/logging in, the recipe is (permanently) disabled in JEI (which should not happen) and/or it is not even registered as a valid recipe. This is probably a bug in XU2, but it might also be a bug in JEI causing it to permanently disable recipes instead of temporarily disabling them.

Above was my idea, unfortunately, did not fix it :-(.

[Flamebom]

@Frikkle yeah even after restarting the client I can't see the recipe
(Only restarted it once though)

[Frikkle]

Found this issue in the Extra Utils issue tracker; could be this. Over there it's not very specific in terms of description though; but it feels similar.

[NielsPilgaard]

It's not, none of those items exist in Extra Utilities for 1.12.2

[Frikkle]

Not sure if this is related, but while discussing other things today in the office I found out that at home my JEI does not show the recipe(s) for Liquifacted Coal created in the vanilla Furnace by smelting (char)coal. See screenshot.

My pc in the office running the same version (1.62 stock) does consistently show the recipe while my pc at home consistently doesn't. So the scope of this might be broader.

Additionally, @stefancdr has the exact same hardware setup as I do at home and for him the Golden Lasso structurally does not show.

[stefancdr]

Just noticed the 'Magical Wood' recipe is also broken for me (not sure since when, I know it worked on our previous custom modpack). The only recipe I have available in JEI is the enchanter recipe, not the regular 'bookshelf + gold ingot + 4 XP' recipe. See screenshot:

(Note: at the time of the screenshot I no longer had enough XP to craft the item, but I did succesfully craft the item 3x already, so the recipe itself does work...)

[Flamebom]

Maybe it's an issue for any recipe that requires xp?

[Flamebom]

do magical apples work?

[Frikkle]

@stefancdr could you check this tonight?

If this is the case, my missing Liquifacted Coal recipe would be another -unrelated- issue.

[stefancdr]

do magical apples work?

Yes, they do. "Unfortunately", I'm on 1.63a now which seems to work. Magical apples, magical wood and even the golden lasso work...

[Flamebom]

I mean like do the recpies show in JEI. the craft ones

[stefancdr]

Sorry for the confusion. Yes, all the recipes in JEI work for me in 1.63a, including the ones that did not for me in 1.62. Outlook voor Android downloaden<https://aka.ms/ghei36>

…

________________________________ From: Flamebom <notifications@github.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2019 6:13:29 PM To: NillerMedDild/Enigmatica2Expert Cc: Stefan de Ruiter; Mention Subject: Re: [NillerMedDild/Enigmatica2Expert] Any XU2 recipe that requires xp doesn't show the crafting table recipe on JEI (#1157) I mean like do the recpies show in JEI. the craft ones — You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub<#1157 (comment)>, or mute the thread<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABFYE4UAXJXRPIUZI6CTMMTPUBKKTANCNFSM4HI5FX7Q>.