Can't build Perl 5.005_60 on SPARC/Linux with -Duseshrplib

[p5pRT]

Migrated from rt.perl.org#1213 (status was 'resolved')

Searchable as RT1213$

[p5pRT]

From bjepson@home.com

When I compile Perl 5.005_60 on SPARC/Linux, I get many error messages
about relocations​:

cc -shared -L/usr/local/lib -o libperl.so perl.o gv.o toke.o perly.o op.o
regcomp.o dump.o util.o mg.o hv.o av.o run.o pp_hot.o sv.o pp.o scope.o
pp_ctl.o pp_sys.o doop.o doio.o regexec.o utf8.o taint.o deb.o
universal.o globals.o perlio.o

sv.o​: In function `Perl_sv_2pv'​:
/home/bjepson/src/perl5.005_60/sv.c​:1804​: relocation truncated to fit​:
R_SPARC_G
OT13 LLC43
/home/bjepson/src/perl5.005_60/sv.c​:1810​: relocation truncated to fit​:
R_SPARC_G
OT13 LLC44
/home/bjepson/src/perl5.005_60/sv.c​:1892​: relocation truncated to fit​:
R_SPARC_G
OT13 LLC45

Similar messages appear for Perl_sv_2bool, Perl_sv_setsv, Perl_sv_magic,
Perl_sv_rvweaken, S_sv_del_backref, Perl_sv_insert, Perl_sv_replace,
Perl_sv_clear, Perl_sv_free, Perl_sv_pos_b2u, Perl_sv_gets, Perl_sv_inc,
and many other symbols. The message finally ends with​:

make​: *** [libperl.so] Error 1

Configuration

---

I configured it with​:

sh Configure -Dprefix=/opt/perl -Duseshrplib -Doptimize='-g' -Uusemymalloc

and I removed POSIX from the list of extensions, because I have had
trouble building it on SPARC/Linux in the past (or I thought I had).

Other information​:

  The Linux distribution is Debian 2.1.

  $ uname -a
  Linux cx384756-a 2.0.35 #5 Wed Jul 14 09​:15​:34 EST 1999 sparc unknown

  libc='/lib/libc-2.0.105.so'

  $ cc -v
  Reading specs from /usr/lib/gcc-lib/sparc-linux/2.7.2.3/specs
  gcc version 2.7.2.3

This error also occurs if I use egcc as my compiler​:

  $ egcc -v
  Reading specs from /usr/lib/gcc-lib/sparc-linux/egcs-2.91.60/specs
  gcc version egcs-2.91.60 Debian 2.1 (egcs-1.1.1 release)

========================
Without -Doptimize='-g'​:

When I run Configure without -Doptimize='-g', I get an error when make
compiles util.c​:

`sh cflags libperl.so util.o` -fpic util.c
  CCCMD = cc -DPERL_CORE -c -Dbool=char -DHAS_BOOL
  -I/usr/local/include -O2
cc​: Internal compiler error​: program cc1 got fatal signal 6

When I use egcc in this fashion, I do not receive the fatal signal, but I
receive the relocation errors described above.

====================
Without -Duseshrplib

It seems like -Duseshrplib was the source of my troubles. Here is a
combination that works and passes most tests (POSIX works, so my fear
that it was broken, mentioned above, was unfounded)​:

  sh Configure -Dprefix=/opt/perl -Doptimize='-g' -Uusemymalloc \
  -Dcc=egcc -des

Here are the failure messages from 'make test'​:

op/grent............FAILED at test 1
pragma/warning......PROG​:
# op.c
$ENV{PERL_DESTRUCT_LEVEL} = 0 unless $ENV{PERL_DESTRUCT_LEVEL} > 3; #
known scal
ar leak
use warning 'unsafe' ;
my $a ; my @​a = () ; my %a = () ; my $b = \@​a ; my $c = \%a ;
@​a =~ /abc/ ;
@​a =~ s/a/b/ ;
@​a =~ tr/a/b/ ;
@​$b =~ /abc/ ;
@​$b =~ s/a/b/ ;
@​$b =~ tr/a/b/ ;
%a =~ /abc/ ;
%a =~ s/a/b/ ;
%a =~ tr/a/b/ ;
%$c =~ /abc/ ;
%$c =~ s/a/b/ ;
%$c =~ tr/a/b/ ;
{
no warning 'unsafe' ;
my $a ; my @​a = () ; my %a = () ; my $b = \@​a ; my $c = \%a ;
@​a =~ /abc/ ;
@​a =~ s/a/b/ ;
@​a =~ tr/a/b/ ;
@​$b =~ /abc/ ;
@​$b =~ s/a/b/ ;
@​$b =~ tr/a/b/ ;
%a =~ /abc/ ;
%a =~ s/a/b/ ;
%a =~ tr/a/b/ ;
%$c =~ /abc/ ;
%$c =~ s/a/b/ ;
%$c =~ tr/a/b/ ;
}
EXPECTED​:
Applying pattern match to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 5.
Applying substitution to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 6.
Can't modify private array in substitution at - line 6, near "s/a/b/ ;"
Applying character translation to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at -
line 7.
Applying pattern match to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 8.
Applying substitution to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 9.
Applying character translation to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at -
line 10
.
Applying pattern match to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 11.
Applying substitution to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 12.
Applying character translation to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at -
line 13.
Applying pattern match to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 14.
Applying substitution to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 15.
Applying character translation to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at -
line 16.
BEGIN not safe after errors--compilation aborted at - line 18.
GOT​:
Applying pattern match to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 5.
Applying substitution to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 6.
Can't modify private array in substitution at - line 6, near "s/a/b/ ;"
Applying character translation to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at -
line 7.
Applying pattern match to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 8.
Applying substitution to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 9.
Applying character translation to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at -
line 10
.
Applying pattern match to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 11.
Applying substitution to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 12.
Applying character translation to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at -
line 13.
Applying pattern match to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 14.
Applying substitution to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 15.
Applying character translation to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at -
line 16.
BEGIN not safe after errors--compilation aborted at - line 18.
Scalars leaked​: 1
FAILED at test 137
lib/anydbm..........FAILED at test 12
lib/db-btree........FAILED at test 36
lib/db-hash.........FAILED at test 31

Brian Jepson * (bjepson@​home.com) * http​://users.ids.net/~bjepson

[p5pRT]

From [Unknown Contact. See original ticket]

I forgot to add that my Linux kernel was built with SMP support.

On Fri, 13 Aug 1999, Brian Jepson wrote​:

Your e-mail has been received by the Perl Bug Squashing Team.

Ticket ID '[ID 19990813.002]' has been assigned. Please include this ticket ID in the
subject line of any followup messages related to this issue.

This is an automatic confirmation message.
--
Perl Bug Squashing Team
perlbug@​perl.org

Brian Jepson * (bjepson@​home.com) * http​://users.ids.net/~bjepson

[p5pRT]

From [Unknown Contact. See original ticket]

Brian Jepson <bjepson@​home.com> writes​:

====================
With -Doptimize='-g'

When I compile Perl 5.005_60 on SPARC/Linux, I get many error messages
about relocations​:

cc -shared -L/usr/local/lib -o libperl.so perl.o gv.o toke.o perly.o op.o
regcomp.o dump.o util.o mg.o hv.o av.o run.o pp_hot.o sv.o pp.o scope.o
pp_ctl.o pp_sys.o doop.o doio.o regexec.o utf8.o taint.o deb.o
universal.o globals.o perlio.o

sv.o​: In function `Perl_sv_2pv'​:
/home/bjepson/src/perl5.005_60/sv.c​:1804​: relocation truncated to fit​:
R_SPARC_G
OT13 LLC43

Looks like shared lib hints for Linux/SPARC need to set -fPIC rather
than -fpic.

--
Nick Ing-Simmons

[p5pRT]

From [Unknown Contact. See original ticket]

On Fri, 13 Aug 1999, Nick Ing-Simmons wrote​:
[...]

Looks like shared lib hints for Linux/SPARC need to set -fPIC rather
than -fpic.

Thanks - here is what I fed to Configure​:

-Dprefix=/opt/perl -Duseshrplib -Doptimize=-g -Uusemymalloc -Dcccdlflags=-fPIC -des

It built OK, but failed a few tests​:

op/grent............FAILED at test 1
pragma/warning......PROG​:
# op.c
$ENV{PERL_DESTRUCT_LEVEL} = 0 unless $ENV{PERL_DESTRUCT_LEVEL} > 3; # known scalar leak
use warning 'unsafe' ;
my $a ; my @​a = () ; my %a = () ; my $b = \@​a ; my $c = \%a ;
@​a =~ /abc/ ;
@​a =~ s/a/b/ ;
@​a =~ tr/a/b/ ;
@​$b =~ /abc/ ;
@​$b =~ s/a/b/ ;
@​$b =~ tr/a/b/ ;
%a =~ /abc/ ;
%a =~ s/a/b/ ;
%a =~ tr/a/b/ ;
%$c =~ /abc/ ;
%$c =~ s/a/b/ ;
%$c =~ tr/a/b/ ;
{
no warning 'unsafe' ;
my $a ; my @​a = () ; my %a = () ; my $b = \@​a ; my $c = \%a ;
@​a =~ /abc/ ;
@​a =~ s/a/b/ ;
@​a =~ tr/a/b/ ;
@​$b =~ /abc/ ;
@​$b =~ s/a/b/ ;
@​$b =~ tr/a/b/ ;
%a =~ /abc/ ;
%a =~ s/a/b/ ;
%a =~ tr/a/b/ ;
%$c =~ /abc/ ;
%$c =~ s/a/b/ ;
%$c =~ tr/a/b/ ;
}
EXPECTED​:
Applying pattern match to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 5.
Applying substitution to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 6.
Can't modify private array in substitution at - line 6, near "s/a/b/ ;"
Applying character translation to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 7.
Applying pattern match to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 8.
Applying substitution to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 9.
Applying character translation to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 10.
Applying pattern match to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 11.
Applying substitution to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 12.
Applying character translation to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 13.
Applying pattern match to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 14.
Applying substitution to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 15.
Applying character translation to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 16.
BEGIN not safe after errors--compilation aborted at - line 18.
GOT​:
Applying pattern match to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 5.
Applying substitution to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 6.
Can't modify private array in substitution at - line 6, near "s/a/b/ ;"
Applying character translation to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 7.
Applying pattern match to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 8.
Applying substitution to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 9.
Applying character translation to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 10.
Applying pattern match to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 11.
Applying substitution to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 12.
Applying character translation to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 13.
Applying pattern match to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 14.
Applying substitution to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 15.
Applying character translation to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 16.
BEGIN not safe after errors--compilation aborted at - line 18.
Scalars leaked​: 1
FAILED at test 137
lib/anydbm..........FAILED at test 12
lib/db-btree........FAILED at test 36
lib/db-hash.........FAILED at test 31

[p5pRT]

From [Unknown Contact. See original ticket]

Brian Jepson <bjepson@​home.com> writes​:

On Fri, 13 Aug 1999, Nick Ing-Simmons wrote​:
[...]

Looks like shared lib hints for Linux/SPARC need to set -fPIC rather
than -fpic.

Thanks - here is what I fed to Configure​:

-Dprefix=/opt/perl -Duseshrplib -Doptimize=-g -Uusemymalloc -Dcccdlflags=-fPIC -des

It built OK, but failed a few tests​:

op/grent............FAILED at test 1

I seem to recall that is a known problem with some /etc/group
setups - I can't remember the details.

pragma/warning......PROG​:
# op.c
$ENV{PERL_DESTRUCT_LEVEL} = 0 unless $ENV{PERL_DESTRUCT_LEVEL} > 3; # known scalar leak
use warning 'unsafe' ;
my $a ; my @​a = () ; my %a = () ; my $b = \@​a ; my $c = \%a ;
@​a =~ /abc/ ;
@​a =~ s/a/b/ ;
@​a =~ tr/a/b/ ;
@​$b =~ /abc/ ;
@​$b =~ s/a/b/ ;
@​$b =~ tr/a/b/ ;
%a =~ /abc/ ;
%a =~ s/a/b/ ;
%a =~ tr/a/b/ ;
%$c =~ /abc/ ;
%$c =~ s/a/b/ ;
%$c =~ tr/a/b/ ;
{
no warning 'unsafe' ;
my $a ; my @​a = () ; my %a = () ; my $b = \@​a ; my $c = \%a ;
@​a =~ /abc/ ;
@​a =~ s/a/b/ ;
@​a =~ tr/a/b/ ;
@​$b =~ /abc/ ;
@​$b =~ s/a/b/ ;
@​$b =~ tr/a/b/ ;
%a =~ /abc/ ;
%a =~ s/a/b/ ;
%a =~ tr/a/b/ ;
%$c =~ /abc/ ;
%$c =~ s/a/b/ ;
%$c =~ tr/a/b/ ;
}
EXPECTED​:
Applying pattern match to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 5.
Applying substitution to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 6.
Can't modify private array in substitution at - line 6, near "s/a/b/ ;"
Applying character translation to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 7.
Applying pattern match to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 8.
Applying substitution to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 9.
Applying character translation to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 10.
Applying pattern match to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 11.
Applying substitution to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 12.
Applying character translation to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 13.
Applying pattern match to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 14.
Applying substitution to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 15.
Applying character translation to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 16.
BEGIN not safe after errors--compilation aborted at - line 18.
GOT​:
Applying pattern match to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 5.
Applying substitution to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 6.
Can't modify private array in substitution at - line 6, near "s/a/b/ ;"
Applying character translation to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 7.
Applying pattern match to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 8.
Applying substitution to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 9.
Applying character translation to @​array will act on scalar(@​array) at - line 10.
Applying pattern match to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 11.
Applying substitution to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 12.
Applying character translation to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 13.
Applying pattern match to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 14.
Applying substitution to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 15.
Applying character translation to %hash will act on scalar(%hash) at - line 16.
BEGIN not safe after errors--compilation aborted at - line 18.
Scalars leaked​: 1
FAILED at test 137

I think that is generic fail on _60.

lib/anydbm..........FAILED at test 12

lib/db-btree........FAILED at test 36
lib/db-hash.........FAILED at test 31

Those two are generic.
--
Nick Ing-Simmons