Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

refine GPR for lactate dehydrogenase #516

Closed
feiranl opened this issue Mar 28, 2023 · 5 comments
Closed

refine GPR for lactate dehydrogenase #516

feiranl opened this issue Mar 28, 2023 · 5 comments

Comments

@feiranl
Copy link
Collaborator

feiranl commented Mar 28, 2023

Description of the issue:

Enzyme localization
ENSG00000134333 cytosol
ENSG00000166800 cytosol
ENSG00000111716 cytosol,mitochondria
ENSG00000171989 cytosol,mitochondira,nucleus
ENSG00000166796 cytosol
ENSG00000151116 extracellular

We may need to modify the GPR for rxn:

remove ENSG00000134333 from Peroxisome MAR04281 and mitochondria MAR04280
remove ENSG00000166800 from Peroxisome MAR04281 and mitochondria MAR04280
remove ENSG00000111716 from Peroxisome MAR04281
remove ENSG00000166796 from Peroxisome MAR04281 and mitochondria MAR04280
remove ENSG00000151116 from Peroxisome MAR04281 and mitochondria MAR04280
After removal, the rxn MAR04281 contain no gene association, not sure which gene to keep.

@haowang-bioinfo
Copy link
Member

haowang-bioinfo commented Mar 29, 2023

After removal, the rxn MAR04281 contain no gene association, not sure which gene to keep.

what do you think about MAR04281, delete it or keep with blank GPR?

remove ENSG00000151116 from Peroxisome MAR04281 and mitochondria MAR04280

only remove ENSG00000151116 from the 2 rxns or delete it from model?

@feiranl
Copy link
Collaborator Author

feiranl commented Mar 29, 2023

The ENSG00000151116 are responsible for the cytosol reaction, so we don't have to delete it from the model. Now as for the MAR04281, ENSG00000171989 was kept, since it is the most versatile one.

@haowang-bioinfo
Copy link
Member

haowang-bioinfo commented Mar 29, 2023

for the MAR04281, ENSG00000171989 was kept, since it is the most versatile one.

okay

The ENSG00000151116 are responsible for the cytosol reaction

Despite of annotated with lactate/malate dehyrogenase domain, the function of ENSG00000151116 is vaguely determined.

@feiranl
Copy link
Collaborator Author

feiranl commented Mar 29, 2023

Oh, do you think we should delete it?

@haowang-bioinfo
Copy link
Member

haowang-bioinfo commented Mar 29, 2023

Oh, do you think we should delete it?

good question, basically I think every change should be made based on some evidence, such as literature, experimental results, and manual reasoning. In this case, function of ENSG00000151116 was annotated as regulaor.

Ah just found that it had been deleted in #443 (Met Atlas has not synced with v1.14) - so decision was already made!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants