You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
In FLEDGE, it appears that generate_bid does have access to the interest_group object, but report_win does not. This poses a major problem for buyers hoping to leverage machine learning to generate bids because any signal unavailable to report_win cannot be used as a feature in a machine learning pipeline, even if it is available to generate_bid. Without feedback on how the ads perform for different states of the interest_group object we don't have an effective way of leveraging the interest group information for bidding.
To make this issue more concrete, we were hoping to train a machine learning model to help us bid on ad opportunities using the data sent to us from report_win. Model inference in FLEDGE is ugly, but possible: we could "partially query" the model during the interest group request and "partially query" the model during the contextual request, and then stitch these partial query results together in the generate_bid function. However, for this type of flow to work we would need to be able to log information from the interest_group object so this model can have interest group data over which to train.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
After this PR #303 we have a long term plan for resolving this issue. Before the Private Aggregation API comes into service though this issue is still relevant.
And in the short term (like for initial testing right now!), forDebuggingOnly.reportAdAuctionWin() and forDebuggingOnly.reportAdAuctionLoss() (described in the First OT Details doc) get things off the ground.
In FLEDGE, it appears that
generate_bid
does have access to theinterest_group
object, butreport_win
does not. This poses a major problem for buyers hoping to leverage machine learning to generate bids because any signal unavailable toreport_win
cannot be used as a feature in a machine learning pipeline, even if it is available togenerate_bid
. Without feedback on how the ads perform for different states of theinterest_group
object we don't have an effective way of leveraging the interest group information for bidding.To make this issue more concrete, we were hoping to train a machine learning model to help us bid on ad opportunities using the data sent to us from
report_win
. Model inference in FLEDGE is ugly, but possible: we could "partially query" the model during the interest group request and "partially query" the model during the contextual request, and then stitch these partial query results together in thegenerate_bid
function. However, for this type of flow to work we would need to be able to log information from theinterest_group
object so this model can have interest group data over which to train.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: