-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 4k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
add hook for deployment-time validation #1784
Comments
I think your solution would be to not throw an Error but instead use
to attach an error to the current construct node. This will not abort your program but WILL prevent the stack from deploying. |
@rix0rrr I tried the solution you suggested... every op, even |
If we report synthesis errors, they should only prevent the affected stack from deploying; right now, since they are checked during the synthesis step, they would abort the entire toolkit run regardless of whether they would be selected or not. Makes it possible to do region-dependent verification. Fixes #1784. ALSO IN THIS COMMIT If the 'cdk synth' output goes to the screen, don't automatically select upstream stacks for synthesis (as that would lead to an immediate error). Fixes #1783.
If we report synthesis errors, they should only prevent the affected stack from deploying; right now, since they are checked during the synthesis step, they would abort the entire toolkit run regardless of whether they would be selected or not. Makes it possible to do region-dependent verification. Fixes #1784. ALSO IN THIS COMMIT If the 'cdk synth' output goes to the screen, don't automatically select upstream stacks for synthesis (as that would lead to an immediate error). Fixes #1783.
If we report synthesis errors, they should only prevent the affected stack from deploying; right now, since they are checked during the synthesis step, they would abort the entire toolkit run regardless of whether they would be selected or not. Makes it possible to do region-dependent verification. Fixes #1784. ALSO IN THIS COMMIT If the 'cdk synth' output goes to the screen, don't automatically select upstream stacks for synthesis (as that would lead to an immediate error). Fixes #1783.
cdk should provide a hook for deployment-time validation checks.
for example, consider an app that includes two stacks... a Dev stack with implicit environment, and a Prod stack with explicit prod account/region set.
When I run my stack with prod credentials, there is nothing to prevent me from deploying my Dev stack into my prod account (and probably causing many problems that way).
I'd like to add a check somewhere in the Dev stack code to say
if (currentAccount === prodAccount) throw Error(...)
, but this means I the app doesn't work at all when run with Prod credentials (even cdk list throws the account check error).Ideally, if I added this check in this new hook, I'd only get the error if i try diff/deploy/destroy the Dev stack.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: