Fault injection: get() incorrectly returns not_found (part II)

[slfritchie]

NOTE: This was first reported about 5 days ago in issue #107

eleveldb commit: 35f681e of branch slf-faulterl-introduction3 (which is a rebased branch from slf-faulterl-introduction2), which is in turn based upon today's develop branch at 9ab8ed6
leveldb commit: f4cf10d2ba1b999f10805ac35f22145e80932544 of today's develop branch
faulterl commit: 88bd8c8b377f8cdae9683218f229706f4f79ea8e of today's master branch

To recreate, in two cut-and-paste steps. Tested on OS X 10.8.5 and Ubuntu 12.04.2 LTS (GNU/Linux 3.2.0-54-generic x86_64). First:

mkdir /tmp/e
cd /tmp/e
git clone git@github.com:basho/eleveldb.git
cd eleveldb
git checkout -f 35f681e6e936a7f036e661b24fc73e7fe6f3e18f
./rebar get-deps ; (cd deps/faulterl ; git checkout -f 88bd8c8b377f8cdae9683218f229706f4f79ea8e) ; make ; rm priv/*.so ; (cd c_src/leveldb ; git checkout -f f4cf10d2ba1b999f10805ac35f22145e80932544) ; make ; ./rebar skip_deps=true eunit suites=NONE ; erlc -o deps/faulterl/ebin -I deps/faulterl/include priv/scenario/*erl ; deps/faulterl/ebin/make_intercept_c.escript trigger_commonpaths yo ; env `deps/faulterl/ebin/example_environment.sh $PWD/yo` erl -pz .eunit deps/*/ebin

And second. This one fails for OS X (Ubu case part 2 is below):

C4 = [{[{set,{var,1},{call,generic_qc_fsm,set_keys,[[<<173,0,0,0,0>>],{var,parameter_test_dir}]}},{set,{var,2},{call,generic_qc_fsm,open,[{var,parameter_test_dir},[read_write,{paranoid_checks,true},{open_timeout,0},{max_file_size,100},{sync_strategy,none},{create_if_missing,true},{limited_developer_mem,true},{compression,false},{write_buffer_size,16000000}]]}},{set,{var,3},{call,generic_qc_fsm,put,[{var,2},<<173,0,0,0,0>>,<<>>]}},{set,{var,4},{call,generic_qc_fsm,put_filler,[{var,2},{2245,<<22>>},54214]}},{set,{var,6},{call,generic_qc_fsm,fold_all,[{var,2}]}},{set,{var,7},{call,generic_qc_fsm,close,[{var,2}]}},{set,{var,8},{call,generic_qc_fsm,open,[{var,parameter_test_dir},[read_write,{paranoid_checks,true},{open_timeout,0},{max_file_size,100},{sync_strategy,none},{create_if_missing,true},{limited_developer_mem,true},{compression,false},{write_buffer_size,16000000}]]}},{set,{var,9},{call,generic_qc_fsm,get,[{var,8},<<173,0,0,0,0>>]}},{set,{var,10},{call,generic_qc_fsm,fold_all,[{var,8}]}}],1023},[{verify_trace,[]}]].
eqc:check(eqc:testing_time(30, generic_qc_fsm:prop(false, false)), C4).
[true = eqc:check(eqc:testing_time(30, generic_qc_fsm:prop(true, false)), C4) || _ <- lists:seq(1,30)].

The Ubuntu 12 Linux part 2 is:

C4c = [{[{set,{var,1},{call,generic_qc_fsm,set_keys,[[<<173,0,0,0,0>>],{var,parameter_test_dir}]}},{set,{var,2},{call,generic_qc_fsm,open,[{var,parameter_test_dir},[read_write,{paranoid_checks,true},{open_timeout,0},{max_file_size,100},{sync_strategy,none},{create_if_missing,true},{limited_developer_mem,true},{compression,false},{write_buffer_size,16000000}]]}},{set,{var,3},{call,generic_qc_fsm,put,[{var,2},<<173,0,0,0,0>>,<<>>]}},{set,{var,4},{call,generic_qc_fsm,put_filler,[{var,2},{2245,<<22>>},54214]}},{set,{var,6},{call,generic_qc_fsm,fold_all,[{var,2}]}},{set,{var,7},{call,generic_qc_fsm,close,[{var,2}]}},{set,{var,8},{call,generic_qc_fsm,open,[{var,parameter_test_dir},[read_write,{paranoid_checks,true},{open_timeout,0},{max_file_size,100},{sync_strategy,none},{create_if_missing,true},{limited_developer_mem,true},{compression,false},{write_buffer_size,16000000}]]}},{set,{var,9},{call,generic_qc_fsm,get,[{var,8},<<173,0,0,0,0>>]}},{set,{var,10},{call,generic_qc_fsm,fold_all,[{var,8}]}}],9023},[{verify_trace,[]}]].
eqc:check(eqc:testing_time(30, generic_qc_fsm:prop(false, false)), C4c).
[true = eqc:check(eqc:testing_time(30, generic_qc_fsm:prop(true, false)), C4c) || _ <- lists:seq(1,30)].

Here's an easier-to-read-for-humans formatting of the test case and failing diagnostic output:

{[{set,{var,1},
       {call,generic_qc_fsm,set_keys,
             [[<<173,0,0,0,0>>],{var,parameter_test_dir}]}},
  {set,{var,2},
       {call,generic_qc_fsm,open,
             [{var,parameter_test_dir},
              [read_write,
               {paranoid_checks,true},
               {open_timeout,0},
               {max_file_size,100},
               {sync_strategy,none},
               {create_if_missing,true},
               {limited_developer_mem,true},
               {compression,false},
               {write_buffer_size,16000000}]]}},
  {set,{var,3},{call,generic_qc_fsm,put,[{var,2},<<173,0,0,0,0>>,<<>>]}},
  {set,{var,4},{call,generic_qc_fsm,put_filler,[{var,2},{2245,<<22>>},54214]}},
  {set,{var,6},{call,generic_qc_fsm,fold_all,[{var,2}]}},
  {set,{var,7},{call,generic_qc_fsm,close,[{var,2}]}},
  {set,{var,8},
       {call,generic_qc_fsm,open,
             [{var,parameter_test_dir},
              [read_write,
               {paranoid_checks,true},
               {open_timeout,0},
               {max_file_size,100},
               {sync_strategy,none},
               {create_if_missing,true},
               {limited_developer_mem,true},
               {compression,false},
               {write_buffer_size,16000000}]]}},
  {set,{var,9},{call,generic_qc_fsm,get,[{var,8},<<173,0,0,0,0>>]}},
  {set,{var,10},{call,generic_qc_fsm,fold_all,[{var,8}]}}],
 1023}
Trace: [{open,ok},
        {put,yes,<<173,0,0,0,0>>,<<>>},
        {get,fold,<<173,0,0,0,0>>,<<>>},
        {close,ok},
        {open,ok},
        {get,get,<<173,0,0,0,0>>,not_found},
        {close,ok}]
verify_trace: {get,get,<<173,0,0,0,0>>,expected,[<<>>],got,not_found}
final_close_ok: true
verify_trace: failed

[slfritchie]

Update: I'm still seeing these errors with the mv-tuning7 branch in both repos.

% git log | head -20
commit b71954dc49e19268f5e6deadfac64643a3828459
Merge: eeb3c2b 6a34c91
Author: Scott Lystig Fritchie <slfritchie@snookles.com>
Date:   Fri Apr 18 16:22:43 2014 +0900

    Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin/mv-tuning7' into slf-faulterl-introduction3+mv-tuning7

commit 6a34c91c36a4ced1f6db337814c0b7a41bcd247d
Author: MatthewVon <matthewv@basho.com>
Date:   Thu Apr 17 16:28:41 2014 -0400

    force .so modules of leveldb into memory for initialization early in eleveldb loading.

and:

% ( cd c_src/leveldb ; git log | head -5 )
commit ddd7bbb9aa6e0ff5841e8fb07ac381190f73fce0
Author: MatthewVon <matthewv@basho.com>
Date:   Fri Apr 18 11:47:57 2014 -0400

    arg.  ReleaseRef() had two bugs that would hurt / fail retry.  Fixed.

[cmeiklejohn]

Moving to 2.0.1.