-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1.3k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Transaction was made with 20 sat/vb instead of 2 sat/vb #5575
Comments
Thanks for opening your first issue here! |
Earlier today (6/19/2021) my withdrawal to external wallet was made with 100sat/vb - and it would have made more sense to have been 10sat/vb. If a link to the block on mempool.space shows the range and median fees on that block: https://mempool.space/block/0000000000000000000adee6d2d531f2c654d6b5b524ece6036d1ef5ea9e7acb |
I can confirm that this also happened to me. I attempted to send with a fee of 3 sat/bv but it instead sent it with a fee of 86 sat/vb which was the automatically chosen default prior to me modifying it. This lost me quite a bit of money. This happened on the latest v1.7.0 release. |
I've created a discussion that could prevent this issue from happening again in future, please upvote it if you find it useful. |
Description
Yesterday I wanted to send all of my funds to a cold storage. I chose 1 sat/vb fee and a dialog told me the minimum was 2 sat/vb (no idea why, since mempool was almost empty).
I then chose 2 sat/vb and continued. IIRC, the confirmation dialog didn't show the fee in sat/vb, only the total fee (if that is right, then I would suggest to add the sat/vb info as it would have saved me).
I saw ~13K sats as fee and thought that was alright, since the transaction had many inputs, but it turns out that was actually a 20 sat/vb fee.
I remember going back to the previous screen and saw 2 sat/vb was still there.
I am not sure this report will be useful, as it might be difficult to reproduce and happened only once (no balance left to try again).
Version
1.6.5 downloaded from Arch User Repository (AUR).
bisq.common.app.Version: Version{VERSION=1.6.5, P2P_NETWORK_VERSION=1, LOCAL_DB_VERSION=1, TRADE_PROTOCOL_VERSION=3, BASE_CURRENCY_NETWORK=0, getP2PNetworkId()=10}
.Steps to reproduce
I don't think it can realiably be reproduced.
Expected behaviour
Create the transaction with the correct fee: 2 sat/vb.
Actual behaviour
Transaction was created with a different (10x) fee: 20 sat/vb.
Device or machine
Arch Linux; Linux 5.12.10.
Additional info
Logs don't seem to have anything useful, just thousands of exceptions about some BSQ reimbursement.
Edit: realised there are many log files. Any particular string I could grep?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: