Eclipse JUnit reports success when there are no stepdefs

[dgradl]

Although Cucumber has this notion of a yellow state for pending steps, these are treated as ignored but cucumber JUnit and the eclipse JUnit feature lists the steps as ignored, but the scenario and feature as green (successful). It would seem to me that they should list as failed.

[aslakhellesoy]

Sounds like a duplicate of #196. Please request this to be re-opened if I misunderstood and this is not the case.

[dgradl]

Well I saw that other ticket as well, but I didn't see what that had to do with the JUnit component, I thought it was referencing the CLI interface, since I'm not sure passing --strict to the Eclipse JUnit Launcher seems intuitive and I also believe the notification events (to RunNotifier) that JUnitReporter sends is the source of the inaccurate result. If you meant for that ticket to cover JUnit specifically, I just couldn't see it from the details.

[aslakhellesoy]

In order to be consistent with the command line interface, undefined or pending steps (yellow ones) should not cause a failure unless running in strict mode. With JUnit this can be done with:

@Cucumber.Options(strict = true)

Well, once it's implemented that is.

Would that suffice?

[TrueDub]

Has this been implemented for JUnit yet? It works well in the CLI.

[klausbayrhammer]

Yes is is. See #284 for more details

[lock]

This thread has been automatically locked since there has not been any recent activity after it was closed. Please open a new issue for related bugs.