Erlang and Elixir make it very easy to send messages between processes even across the network, but there are a few pitfalls.
- Sending a message to many PIDs across the network also copies the message across the network that many times.
- Send calls cost about 70 µs/op so doing them in a loop eventually gets too expensive.
Discord runs a single GenServer per Discord server and some of these ~100,000 PIDs connected to them from many different Erlang nodes. Increasingly we noticed some of them getting behind on processing their message queues and the culprit was the cost of 70 µs per send/2 call multiplied by connected sessions. How could we solve this?
Inspired by a blog post about boosting performance of message passing between nodes, Manifold was born. Manifold distributes the work of sending messages to the remote nodes of the PIDs, which guarantees that the sending processes at most only calls send/2 equal to the number of involved remote nodes. Manifold does this by first grouping PIDs by their remote node and then sending to Manifold.Partitioner on each of those nodes. The partitioner then consistently hashes the PIDs using :erlang.phash2/2, groups them by number of cores, sends to child workers, and finally those workers send to the actual PIDs. This ensures the partitioner does not get overloaded and still provides the linearizability guaranteed by send/2.
The results were great! We observed packets/sec drop by half immediately after deploying. The Discord servers in question also were finally able to keep up with their message queues.
Add it to mix.exs
defp deps do
[{:manifold, "~> 1.0"}]
endThen just use it like the normal send/2 except it can also take a list of PIDs.
Manifold.send(self(), :hello)
Manifold.send([self(), self()], :hello)When using Manifold there are two performance options you can choose to enable.
By default Manifold will send the message using vanilla External Term Format. If pack_mode is not specified or is set to nil or :etf then this mode will be used.
When messages are very large pack_mode can be set to :binary and this will cause Manifold to ensure that the term is only converted into External Term Format once. The encoding will happen in the sending process (either the calling process or a Manifold.Sender, see send_mode for additional details) and will
The :binary optimization works best with large and deeply nested messages that are being sent to PIDs across multiple nodes. Without the optimization, a message sent to N nodes will have to be translated into External Term Format N times. With large data structures, this operation can be expensive. With the optimization enabled, the encoding into binary happens once and then over distribution each sending process only needs to transmit the binary.
To send using the binary pack mode, just add the pack_mode argument
Manifold.send(self(), :hello, pack_mode: :binary)By default Manifold will send the message over the network from the caller process. If send_mode is not specified then the default behavior of sending from the caller process will be used.
When messages are very large, send_mode can be set to :offload which offloads the send from the calling process to a pool of Manifold.Sender processes. To maintain the linearizability guaranteed by send/2, the same calling process
always offloads the work to the same Manifold.Sender process. The size of the Manifold.Sender pool is configurable.
This send mode is optional because its benefits are workload dependent. The optimization works best when the cost of sending a message to a local process < the cost of sending a message over distribution. This is most common for messages that are very large in size. For some workloads, it might degrade overall performance. Use with caution.
Caution: To maintain the linearizability guaranteed by send/2, do not mix calls to Manifold with and without offloading. Mixed use of the two different send modes to the same set of receiving nodes would break the linearizability guarantee.
To use the :offload send mode, make sure the Manifold.Sender pool size is appropriate for the workload:
config :manifold, senders: <size>Then:
Manifold.send(self(), :hello, send_mode: :offload)Manifold takes a single configuration option, which sets the module it dispatches to actually call send. The default
is GenServer. To set this variable, add the following to your config.exs:
config :manifold, gen_module: MyGenModuleIn the above instance, MyGenModule must define a cast/2 function that matches the types of GenServer.cast.
Manifold is released under the MIT License. Check LICENSE file for more information.