Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Streamlining iplab reviews for BND-wrapped libraries #43

Open
merks opened this issue Oct 14, 2024 · 2 comments
Open

Streamlining iplab reviews for BND-wrapped libraries #43

merks opened this issue Oct 14, 2024 · 2 comments

Comments

@merks
Copy link
Contributor

merks commented Oct 14, 2024 •
edited
Loading

Currently the IP review infrastructure using dash-license for the content generated from

https://github.com/eclipse-orbit/orbit-simrel/blob/main/maven-bnd/tp/MavenBND.target

results duplicate iplab issues that result in approval delays and extra work for the IP staff. It also adversely impacts downstream consumers of Orbit. I'm not sure how best to improve the situation.

In an effort to gather information that might be helpful, I've investigated generating a report that provides information about the mapping between the maven coordinate of each artifact and the osgi bundle symbolic name and version produced for that artifact. In addition, I've collected the associating iplab issue(s) for each artifact.

I will copy and paste a prototype of such an automatically generated report in a separate comment below, which I will update based on feedback

I've create a corresponding iplab issue:

https://gitlab.eclipse.org/eclipsefdn/emo-team/iplab/-/issues/16675
@merks
Copy link
Contributor Author

merks commented Oct 14, 2024 •
edited
Loading

@merks merks mentioned this issue Oct 14, 2024
Merged
@merks
Copy link
Contributor Author

merks commented Oct 15, 2024

The generator could produce something like this which is effective just the mapping from the OSGi name/version of the Maven coordinates, in json format:

[
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.aopalliance", "bundle-version" : "1.0.0.v20230720-0728", "groupId" : "aopalliance", "artifactId" : "aopalliance", "version" : "1.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "com.github.jnr.a64asm", "bundle-version" : "1.0.0.v20230715-0746", "groupId" : "com.github.jnr", "artifactId" : "jnr-a64asm", "version" : "1.0.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "com.github.jnr.x86asm", "bundle-version" : "1.0.2.v20230715-0746", "groupId" : "com.github.jnr", "artifactId" : "jnr-x86asm", "version" : "1.0.2"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "com.github.jtidy", "bundle-version" : "1.0.5.v20240704-1200", "groupId" : "com.github.jtidy", "artifactId" : "jtidy", "version" : "1.0.5"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "com.github.package-url.packageurl-java", "bundle-version" : "1.5.0.v20231221-1500", "groupId" : "com.github.package-url", "artifactId" : "packageurl-java", "version" : "1.5.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "com.github.virtuald.curvesapi", "bundle-version" : "1.8.0.v20230927-1624", "groupId" : "com.github.virtuald", "artifactId" : "curvesapi", "version" : "1.8"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "com.google.javascript", "bundle-version" : "0.0.20240317.v20240319-0700", "groupId" : "com.google.javascript", "artifactId" : "closure-compiler", "version" : "v20240317"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "com.jcraft.jsch", "bundle-version" : "0.1.55.v20230916-1400", "groupId" : "com.jcraft", "artifactId" : "jsch", "version" : "0.1.55"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "com.jcraft.jzlib", "bundle-version" : "1.1.3.v20230916-1400", "groupId" : "com.jcraft", "artifactId" : "jzlib", "version" : "1.1.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "com.jgoodies.common", "bundle-version" : "1.8.1.v20240327-0800", "groupId" : "com.jgoodies", "artifactId" : "jgoodies-common", "version" : "1.8.1"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "com.jgoodies.forms", "bundle-version" : "1.9.0.v20240327-0800", "groupId" : "com.jgoodies", "artifactId" : "jgoodies-forms", "version" : "1.9.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "com.konghq.unirest-java", "bundle-version" : "3.14.5.v20230803-0817", "groupId" : "com.konghq", "artifactId" : "unirest-java", "version" : "3.14.5"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "com.zaxxer.sparsebits", "bundle-version" : "1.3.0.v20230929-1000", "groupId" : "com.zaxxer", "artifactId" : "SparseBitSet", "version" : "1.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.commons.httpclient", "bundle-version" : "3.1.0.v20240401-1000", "groupId" : "commons-httpclient", "artifactId" : "commons-httpclient", "version" : "3.1"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.junit", "bundle-version" : "4.13.2.v20240929-1000", "groupId" : "junit", "artifactId" : "junit", "version" : "4.13.2"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.antlr.runtime", "bundle-version" : "3.2.0.v20230929-1400", "groupId" : "org.antlr", "artifactId" : "antlr-runtime", "version" : "3.2"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.antlr.runtime", "bundle-version" : "3.5.3.v20230929-1400", "groupId" : "org.antlr", "artifactId" : "antlr-runtime", "version" : "3.5.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.httpcomponents.httpclient.win", "bundle-version" : "4.5.14.v20240401-1000", "groupId" : "org.apache.httpcomponents", "artifactId" : "httpclient-win", "version" : "4.5.14"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.httpcomponents.client5.httpclient5", "bundle-version" : "5.4.0.v20240920-0800", "groupId" : "org.apache.httpcomponents.client5", "artifactId" : "httpclient5", "version" : "5.4"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.httpcomponents.client5.httpclient5-win", "bundle-version" : "5.2.3.v20231203-1619", "groupId" : "org.apache.httpcomponents.client5", "artifactId" : "httpclient5-win", "version" : "5.2.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.httpcomponents.core5.httpcore5", "bundle-version" : "5.3.0.v20240912-1000", "groupId" : "org.apache.httpcomponents.core5", "artifactId" : "httpcore5", "version" : "5.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.httpcomponents.core5.httpcore5-h2", "bundle-version" : "5.3.0.v20240912-1000", "groupId" : "org.apache.httpcomponents.core5", "artifactId" : "httpcore5-h2", "version" : "5.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.lucene.analysis-common", "bundle-version" : "9.12.0.v20240929-0900", "groupId" : "org.apache.lucene", "artifactId" : "lucene-analysis-common", "version" : "9.12.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.lucene.analysis-smartcn", "bundle-version" : "9.12.0.v20240929-0900", "groupId" : "org.apache.lucene", "artifactId" : "lucene-analysis-smartcn", "version" : "9.12.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.lucene.core", "bundle-version" : "9.12.0.v20240929-0900", "groupId" : "org.apache.lucene", "artifactId" : "lucene-core", "version" : "9.12.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.lucene.facet", "bundle-version" : "9.12.0.v20240929-0900", "groupId" : "org.apache.lucene", "artifactId" : "lucene-facet", "version" : "9.12.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.lucene.misc", "bundle-version" : "9.12.0.v20240929-0900", "groupId" : "org.apache.lucene", "artifactId" : "lucene-misc", "version" : "9.12.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.lucene.queries", "bundle-version" : "9.12.0.v20240929-0900", "groupId" : "org.apache.lucene", "artifactId" : "lucene-queries", "version" : "9.12.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.lucene.queryparser", "bundle-version" : "9.12.0.v20240929-0900", "groupId" : "org.apache.lucene", "artifactId" : "lucene-queryparser", "version" : "9.12.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.lucene.sandbox", "bundle-version" : "9.12.0.v20240929-0900", "groupId" : "org.apache.lucene", "artifactId" : "lucene-sandbox", "version" : "9.12.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.poi", "bundle-version" : "5.3.0.v20240703-1000", "groupId" : "org.apache.poi", "artifactId" : "poi", "version" : "5.3.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.poi.ooxml", "bundle-version" : "5.3.0.v20240703-1000", "groupId" : "org.apache.poi", "artifactId" : "poi-ooxml", "version" : "5.3.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.poi.ooxml.schemas", "bundle-version" : "5.3.0.v20240703-1000", "groupId" : "org.apache.poi", "artifactId" : "poi-ooxml-lite", "version" : "5.3.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.ws.commons.util", "bundle-version" : "1.0.2.v20230723-0712", "groupId" : "org.apache.ws.commons.util", "artifactId" : "ws-commons-util", "version" : "1.0.2"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.xmlbeans", "bundle-version" : "5.2.1.v20240527-0800", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlbeans", "artifactId" : "xmlbeans", "version" : "5.2.1"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.anim", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-anim", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.awt.util", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-awt-util", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.bridge", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-bridge", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.codec", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-codec", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.constants", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-constants", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.css", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-css", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.dom", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-dom", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.ext", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-ext", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.extension", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-extension", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.gvt", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-gvt", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.i18n", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-i18n", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.parser", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-parser", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.script", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-script", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.shared.resources", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-shared-resources", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.dom.svg", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-svg-dom", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.svggen", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-svggen", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.transcoder", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-transcoder", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.util", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-util", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.batik.xml", "bundle-version" : "1.18.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "batik-xml", "version" : "1.18"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics.fop-core", "bundle-version" : "2.10.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "fop-core", "version" : "2.10"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics.fop-events", "bundle-version" : "2.10.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "fop-events", "version" : "2.10"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics.fop-util", "bundle-version" : "2.10.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "fop-util", "version" : "2.10"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "bundle-version" : "2.10.0.v20241009-1200", "groupId" : "org.apache.xmlgraphics", "artifactId" : "xmlgraphics-commons", "version" : "2.10"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.codelibs.nekohtml", "bundle-version" : "2.1.3.v20240413-0800", "groupId" : "org.codelibs", "artifactId" : "nekohtml", "version" : "2.1.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.commonmark", "bundle-version" : "0.23.0.v20240917-1000", "groupId" : "org.commonmark", "artifactId" : "commonmark", "version" : "0.23.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.commonmark-gfm-strikethrough", "bundle-version" : "0.23.0.v20240917-1000", "groupId" : "org.commonmark", "artifactId" : "commonmark-ext-gfm-strikethrough", "version" : "0.23.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.commonmark-gfm-tables", "bundle-version" : "0.23.0.v20240917-1000", "groupId" : "org.commonmark", "artifactId" : "commonmark-ext-gfm-tables", "version" : "0.23.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.commonmark-heading-anchor", "bundle-version" : "0.23.0.v20240917-1000", "groupId" : "org.commonmark", "artifactId" : "commonmark-ext-heading-anchor", "version" : "0.23.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.commonmark-image-attributes", "bundle-version" : "0.23.0.v20240917-1000", "groupId" : "org.commonmark", "artifactId" : "commonmark-ext-image-attributes", "version" : "0.23.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.commonmark-ins", "bundle-version" : "0.23.0.v20240917-1000", "groupId" : "org.commonmark", "artifactId" : "commonmark-ext-ins", "version" : "0.23.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.commonmark-task-list-items", "bundle-version" : "0.23.0.v20240917-1000", "groupId" : "org.commonmark", "artifactId" : "commonmark-ext-task-list-items", "version" : "0.23.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.commonmark-yaml-front-matter", "bundle-version" : "0.23.0.v20240917-1000", "groupId" : "org.commonmark", "artifactId" : "commonmark-ext-yaml-front-matter", "version" : "0.23.0"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.cyclonedx.core-java", "bundle-version" : "8.0.3.v20231221-1500", "groupId" : "org.cyclonedx", "artifactId" : "cyclonedx-core-java", "version" : "8.0.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.dom4j", "bundle-version" : "2.1.4.v20231001-0922", "groupId" : "org.dom4j", "artifactId" : "dom4j", "version" : "2.1.4"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.ant", "bundle-version" : "1.10.15.v20240901-1000", "groupId" : "org.eclipse.orbit", "artifactId" : "ant", "version" : "1.10.15"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.derby", "bundle-version" : "10.16.1.v20240802-0900", "groupId" : "org.eclipse.orbit", "artifactId" : "derby", "version" : "10.16.1.1"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.axis", "bundle-version" : "1.4.1.v20231107-0937", "groupId" : "org.eclipse.orbit", "artifactId" : "org.apache.axis", "version" : "1.4.1.20231107-0755"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.axis.ant", "bundle-version" : "1.4.1.v20231107-0937", "groupId" : "org.eclipse.orbit", "artifactId" : "org.apache.axis-ant", "version" : "1.4.1.20231107-0755"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.hamcrest.core", "bundle-version" : "1.3.0.v20230809-1000", "groupId" : "org.hamcrest", "artifactId" : "hamcrest-core", "version" : "1.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.hamcrest.core", "bundle-version" : "2.2.0.v20230809-1000", "groupId" : "org.hamcrest", "artifactId" : "hamcrest-core", "version" : "2.2"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.hamcrest.library", "bundle-version" : "1.3.0.v20230809-1000", "groupId" : "org.hamcrest", "artifactId" : "hamcrest-library", "version" : "1.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.hamcrest.library", "bundle-version" : "2.2.0.v20230809-1000", "groupId" : "org.hamcrest", "artifactId" : "hamcrest-library", "version" : "2.2"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.jdom", "bundle-version" : "1.1.3.v20230812-1600", "groupId" : "org.jdom", "artifactId" : "jdom", "version" : "1.1.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.jdom2", "bundle-version" : "2.0.6.v20230720-0727", "groupId" : "org.jdom", "artifactId" : "jdom2", "version" : "2.0.6.1"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.jcodings", "bundle-version" : "1.0.58.v20230703-0749", "groupId" : "org.jruby.jcodings", "artifactId" : "jcodings", "version" : "1.0.58"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.joni", "bundle-version" : "2.2.1.v20230703-0749", "groupId" : "org.jruby.joni", "artifactId" : "joni", "version" : "2.2.1"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.pushingpixels.trident", "bundle-version" : "1.3.0.v20231219-1530", "groupId" : "org.pushingpixels", "artifactId" : "trident", "version" : "1.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "javax.wsdl", "bundle-version" : "1.6.3.v20230730-0710", "groupId" : "wsdl4j", "artifactId" : "wsdl4j", "version" : "1.6.3"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.xml.serializer", "bundle-version" : "2.7.2.v20230928-1302", "groupId" : "xalan", "artifactId" : "serializer", "version" : "2.7.2"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.xalan", "bundle-version" : "2.7.2.v20230928-1302", "groupId" : "xalan", "artifactId" : "xalan", "version" : "2.7.2"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.xerces", "bundle-version" : "2.12.2.v20230928-1306", "groupId" : "xerces", "artifactId" : "xercesImpl", "version" : "2.12.2"},
  {"bundle-symbolic-name" : "org.apache.xml.resolver", "bundle-version" : "1.2.0.v20230928-1222", "groupId" : "xml-resolver", "artifactId" : "xml-resolver", "version" : "1.2"},
]

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
1 participant
@merks