EIP Editing Office Hour Meeting 8

[poojaranjan]

Date and Time

Tuesday, Dec 13, 2022, at 15:00 UTC

Location

Zoom: TBA on EthCatHerders Discord #eip-editors
Recording: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL4cwHXAawZxqnDHxOyuwMpyt5s8F8gdmO

Agenda

• Visit EIPs in Draft Review, Last Call & Final
• Misc. Pull Requests
• Open Q&A

Other details

• Working Document : https://hackmd.io/@poojaranjan/EIPEditingOfficeHour
• Announcement Blogpost

(Add your Pull Request number to be added to the agenda.)

[macfarla]

Re EIP-1474 (outstanding PR ethereum/EIPs#5986 to move it to draft) - much of the (old) content of this EIP is now duplicated in the execution-apis repo https://github.com/ethereum/execution-apis/ - maybe it would be better for EIP-1474 to specify the generics - error handling, error codes, and how to propose new methods - and leave the specification of the RPC methods and their parameters to the execution-apis spec repo.

[Hardblock-IMSE-CNM]

Hi team,
Is it possible to add to agenda ethereum/EIPs#6076 to move EIP-4519 to Final?
Thank you.

[dtedesco1]

Hi Team, if there's room in the agenda, I'd like to join to get feedback on EIP-4974.

[poojaranjan]

To Final

• Update EIP-4519: Move to Final ethereum/EIPs#6076
• Update EIP-5489: Move to final ethereum/EIPs#6062
• Update EIP-5757: Move to final ethereum/EIPs#6033
• Update EIP-2481: Move to final ethereum/EIPs#6015
• Update EIP-4519: Move to Final ethereum/EIPs#6124

To Review

• Update EIP-5793: update EIP to Review status (eth/68) ethereum/EIPs#6031
• Update EIP-4844: update to Review status ethereum/EIPs#6030
• Update EIP-5298: Move to Review ethereum/EIPs#5934

To Draft

• Add EIP-6059: Parent-Governed Nestable Non-Fungible Tokens standard ethereum/EIPs#6059
• Update EIP-1753: Move to draft ethereum/EIPs#5872
• Add EIP-6122: Forkid checks based on timestamps ethereum/EIPs#6122
• Add EIP-6120: Universal Token Router ethereum/EIPs#6120
• Update EIP-4944: Move from Stagnant to Draft ethereum/EIPs#6114
• Update EIP-725: Improvements ethereum/EIPs#6103
• Add EIP-6093: Custom errors for commonly-used tokens ethereum/EIPs#6093
• Pickup latest eipw version ethereum/EIPs#6091
• Update EIP-4974: Community Feedback ethereum/EIPs#5135
• Update EIP-1474: Move status to draft ethereum/EIPs#5986
• Add EIP-5850: Complex Numbers stored in Bytes32 types ethereum/EIPs#5850
• Add EIP-5994: Token Balance Update Hooks (Pods) ethereum/EIPs#6000
• Add EIP-5875: Instruction to Get Transaction Index of Block ethereum/EIPs#5875
• Add EIP-6036: Subscribeable NFT Extension ethereum/EIPs#6036
• Add EIP-5883: Token Transfer by Social Recovery ethereum/EIPs#5883

[poojaranjan]

Closing in favor of #201