Firmware update inconsistent behavior post reboot

[maheshbabu022]

Hi,
I have been trying update using fwupdmgr on many of Ubuntu based systems and its been working all good. In this specific instance after performing a reboot post fwpdmgr command, Im seeing 2 different types of errors(on 2 separate instance) and the systems takes a halt. It calls for a force reboot(hard reboot). After hard reboot the system boots and i happen to see the update to next version has been(when the error was capsule size - 0) done and sometimes it would have failed(Unable to open the file).

Attached are the snap shots of the instances that i have observed.

More details -

• FWUPD-EFI version 1.4

• FWupdmgr - 1.7.9

Command used for upgrade -

fwupdmgr install --force --allow-older --show-all --no-reboot-check --no-remote-check --assume-yes --allow-reinstall -y -v $file

• Every time, before calling fwupdmgr command, any stale *.cap file is cleaned up.

• The ESP partition where the cap file is created has a space of 250MB.

Frequency of this issue -

• Trying 2 cab file updates back to back (there is a reboot between each update). The issue gets uncovered for the second cab update.

• Single cab update for the same cab file does not pose this error(attached).

[hughsie]

Those are all very old versions -- can you try with fwupd-efi 1.6 and fwupd 1.9.anything please?

[maheshbabu022]

Thanks @hughsie. Our OS for device is confined to Ubuntu 22.04 and have a logical tie up to use 1.4 version. Just wanted to check, in case the upgrade to 1.6 is a non-starter then...is there a way to counter this issue and also your insights as why the file discovery is an issue, though i could see the file being intact before going for a reboot.

[maheshbabu022]

Some Observation -
Adding delay of about 30 secs after running fwupdmgr and then going for a reboot helps in discovering the file and reading it successfully. Not sure this logic has a relation to problem directly or indirectly. Can you please help me get the rationale here.

[shyjuchandera]

Hi @hughsie , I am also facing the same issue during the reboot post fwupdmgr command execution. When the system got rebooted after the fwupdmgr command , it shows 'cap file not found'(same as in the screenshot posted in the original issue).

fwupdmgr - 1.7.9

[superm1]

Can you please reproduce using current versions?
1.7 is eol.

https://github.com/fwupd/fwupd/security/policy