Change website to url

[dbkaplun]

No description provided.

[osg]

+1

[JaredCubilla]

+1

[TimDaub]

+1

[DonDebonair]

+1
@thomasdavis I think there's enough support to go ahead and merge the PR?

[osg]

bump @thomasdavis

[olivif]

+1

shall we merge? :)

[chrisdotcode]

I'm indifferent to this - and I don't mind merging it, but can someone give me reason as to why they prefer 'url'?

[stp-ip]

A url could point to a resource, an app or similar, it does not need to be a website. In addition to that it makes all urls consistently with naming them url.
(as a sidenote: bibJSON uses "source")

[chrisdotcode]

Sounds good. We'll merge this when we can.

[aloisdg]

Sorry, to add a new comment. Just to say that I think about @stp-ip sidenote and I really like it. It will add more cohesion with bibjson. I feel that it is more "human-compliant".

bibjson spec:

"source": {
         "description": "The URL where the collection file was uploaded from, if there is one",
         "format": "url",
         "type": "string"
       },

Since every body seems agree with URL. I think we should keep it for the current version, but , at least, keep this idea for the next one.

[olivif]

@aloisdg hmm, interesting. I do like it. Let's re-open and rename the issue to url -> source so we don't forget 😄

[aloisdg]

Glad you like it too 😄 By the way, the new title shouldn't be "How to rename website?" or "What would be a better alternative for website?"

Call an url "url" is like called a string "string", isn't it?

[olivif]

@aloisdg I think there was a PR for this which already got merged in, so the property is called Url now (used to be website). That's why "Change url to (bibJSON) source" made sense to me 😄

[aloisdg]

@olivif The conversation was created for an older version. I think that we should read it straight. With the current title, it seems that the fourth first commenters agree with the switch to "source". Thats not right.

[olivif]

@aloisdg yeah I agree, it's confusing. maybe we should create a new issue instead of reusing this? 😄

[stp-ip]

It's a different issue in my opinion. Most likely 2-3:

• Use source instead of url to be similar to bibjson
• Use source instead of url for all occurances (I would probably dislike that. As a website is not really the source.)

Closing as the old issue is done and anything else should start with a clean issue.