Execution plan incorrect and failure : try to update a role which was detroyed by the same plan #533
Comments
|
Hi @semangard 👋 Based on the logs you provided, it looks like the role with ID Would you be able to provide a minimal Terraform configuration that reproduces this issue? |
|
Hello @mrparkers,
According to me the order of the steps should be the opposite:
Here is my commit where the role deleted was also unassigned to the group (commented it) Please not:
|
semangard
changed the title
|
I have been able to reproduce it the failure at 100%:
Here is the plan: Here is the execution with the failure at the end: |
|
@mrparkers : do you confirm my analysis (cf. reproduce case) and thus that there is a bug ? |
|
Hey @semangard, I was able to reproduce this locally. Thanks for the detailed bug report. I opened #538 to fix this. |
|
Hi @mrparkers BTW I am wondering if we could face the same issue with other realtionships (associations between objects) like for example:
Maybe it should be checked also. |
|
Good point - although I did check for this before I submitted the PR. The |
|
Hello @mrparkers
Despite I am using latest version :
Have you released the fix ? |
|
Hi @mrparkers |
|
Hey @semangard, this seems like a different issue. I can try to reproduce this if you can give me a sample HCL snippet to work with. |
|
When i did these changes all at a time then I got the error According to me it is still more or less the same kind of issue : order on how things are applied : if a role is deleted or recreated (here because roles are moved from a managed resource to a read-only resource => new ID) then this role sould be: |
|
Hey @semangard, I tried to follow your instructions, but I wasn't able to reproduce this. I tried writing some HCL similar to what I saw in your screenshots - an openid client, a few client roles, a few groups, and some group role assignments. Then, I added a data source for the openid client and referenced that with the roles, and got no changes from Terraform (as expected). I also tried adding a new client and moving the roles to that client, and everything was recreated auccessfully. It would help me if you could give me some exact HCL to copy/paste, and instructions on how to modify the HCL to reproduce this. Thanks! |
|
Hi @mrparkers |
|
Closing for now, feel free to open if this issue comes back. |
Hello,
I have the following error into the same TF execution plan:
==> Why a resource is updated whereas it was just destroyed by the same execution plan ?
Full execution plan
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: