Upgrading Microsoft.dotnet fails, multiple versions installed

[Peter-76]

Brief description of your issue

Winget fails to upgrade Microsoft .NET SDK as there are multiple version installed.

Steps to reproduce

[winget upgrade]
Name                              ID                                    Version          Verfügbar        Quelle
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dropbox                           Dropbox.Dropbox                       124.3.4898       124.4.4910       winget
Microsoft 365 Apps for enterprise Microsoft.Office                      16.0.13801.20638 16.0.13929.20372 winget
Microsoft 365 Apps for enterprise Microsoft.Office                      16.0.13801.20638 16.0.13929.20372 winget
OBS Studio                        OBSProject.OBSStudio                  26.1.1           27.0.0           winget
Visual Studio Community 2019      Microsoft.VisualStudio.2019.Community 16.10.31321.278  16.10.31402.337  winget
Microsoft .NET SDK                Microsoft.dotnet                      5.2.421.26362    5.3.121.27113    winget
Python 3                          Python.Python.3                       2.7.6150         3.9.5150.0       winget
Microsoft Windows Desktop Runtime Microsoft.dotnetRuntime               3.1.16.30112     5.0.6.30021      winget
Microsoft .NET SDK                Microsoft.dotnet                      5.1.421.11822    5.3.121.27113    winget

So there are 2 versions of Microsoft .NET SDK listed.

[winget upgrade --id "Microsoft.dotnet" -e]
Mehrere installierte Pakete mit übereinstimmenden Eingabekriterien gefunden. Bitte verfeinern Sie die Eingabe.
Name                             ID
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Microsoft .NET SDK               Microsoft.dotnet
Microsoft .NET SDK 5.0.301 (x64) {d13b364c-ee85-41ba-93a9-0015b6c2945d}
Microsoft .NET SDK 5.0.104 (x64) {ffd9c013-1ec9-45ed-8ca2-104e6a0800b7}`

Upgrade fails.

[winget list Microsoft.dotnet]
Name                                             ID                                     Version       Verfügbar     Quelle
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Microsoft .NET SDK                               Microsoft.dotnet                       5.2.421.26362 5.3.121.27113 winget
Microsoft .NET SDK 5.0.301 (x64)                 {d13b364c-ee85-41ba-93a9-0015b6c2945d} 5.3.121.27113
Microsoft .NET SDK 5.0.104 (x64)                 {ffd9c013-1ec9-45ed-8ca2-104e6a0800b7} 5.1.421.11822
Microsoft Windows Desktop Runtime                Microsoft.dotnetRuntime                5.0.6.30021
Microsoft Windows Desktop Runtime - 5.0.7 (x86)  {d13b2de2-6d8a-496e-adce-ffbc4a8efc0c} 5.0.7.30113
Microsoft Windows Desktop Runtime - 3.1.16 (x86) {eadb038c-8c60-4258-8cf9-e43e809329a4} 3.1.16.30112

Winget list returns 6 results, but only 1 has ID Microsoft.dotnet.
In addition there seems to be already the latest version installed, but under a different name with another ID {d13b364c-ee85-41ba-93a9-0015b6c2945d}

Expected behavior

As winget list Microsoft.dotnet returns exactly one app with ID Microsoft.dotnet, this one should be updated without an error

Actual behavior

Upgrade fails

Environment

[winget --info]
Windows Package Manager v1.0.11451
Copyright (c) Microsoft Corporation. Alle Rechte vorbehalten.

Windows: Windows.Desktop v10.0.19043.1052
Paket: Microsoft.DesktopAppInstaller v1.11.11451.0

[denelon]

@Peter-76 thank you for reporting this. We're working through some of the upgrade scenarios #752, and enhancement to the manifest schema #1073 to improve this experience.

[denelon]

I've added "Blocking-Issue" related to #1073.

[denelon]

We have implemented support for looking at Windows Apps & Features data in the manifest for Windows Package Manager 1.3 Release Candidate to help better correlation with the right packages, as well as evaluating the "displayVersion" for version comparison. The user will still see "packageVersion" displayed as that is the preference for DotNet packages one this rolls out to GA.

Note: We still have some work on the service side to complete the implementation.

[denelon]

We've rolled the changes out. This issue should be resolved.