DNS configuration over a VPN

[jkemp101]

I'm a little outside my wheelhouse here (don't know a lot about Go) but I am wondering if there were any plans to enhance the client resolution process to include client DNS configurations beyond resolv.conf (I'm specifically concerned with OS X). My particular issue is resolving some domains against specific DNS servers that are configured by VPN client software. On a Mac you need to run scutil -dns to see the true DNS configuration since a lot isn't necessarily in resolv.conf.

Many projects like the ease of native Go libraries for a number of reasons including simple cross compiling versus enabling cgo which solves the problem by using the native C resolution libraries.

[miekg]

[ Quoting <notifications@github.com> in "[miekg/dns] DNS configuration over ..." ]

I'm a little outside my wheelhouse here (don't know a lot about Go) but I am wondering if there were any plans to enhance the client resolution process to include client DNS configurations beyond `resolv.conf` (I'm specifically concerned with OS X). My particular issue is resolving some domains against specific DNS servers that are configured by VPN client software. On a Mac you need to run `scutil -dns` to see the true DNS configuration since a lot isn't necessarily in `resolv.conf`. Many projects like the ease of native Go libraries for a number of reasons including simple cross compiling versus enabling cgo which solves the problem by using the native C resolution libraries.

This is out of scope for this library; you can send a DNS query to any address. There is just a convience function to read config from /etc/resolv.conf. /Miek

…

-- Miek Gieben

[jkemp101]

@miekg Would you expect an external library (either 3rd party or native Go) to determine the list of DNS servers to query for a particular hostname? It seems like a DNS client isn't complete unless it is able to figure that out. For instance to know that x.example1.com should be queried at 1.1.1.1 but x.example2.com should be queried at 2.2.2.2.

[andrewtj]

If you're after a platform-native connection experience on OS X, getting a connection via the high-level socket APIs and then extracting an fd is generally the way to go.

[jkemp101]

I took another look at clientconfig.go and it is pretty lightweight, doesn't even try to assume where resolv.conf might reside. So as you said probably not the best place for this type of thing.