Bash auto-complete on OSX

[aik099]

Try typing this on OSX: hub pull and then TAB. The pull-request isn't available as possible option. When on Linux it works flawlessly.

The pull request functionality works, it's just auto-complete that doesn't work for it.

[mislav]

How did you install hub? Did you do any additional steps to enable tab-completion?

[aik099]

I've installed hub using Homebrew (http://brew.sh/). The bash auto-complete script used on linux and OSX is the same.

Here is OSX result of hub TAB (you can scroll right):

add                      ci                       fsck                     pf                       shortlog 
am                       citool                   gc                       pff                      show 
annotate                 clean                    get-tar-commit-id        pull                     show-branch 
apply                    clone                    grep                     push                     squash 
archive                  co                       gui                      rbm                      st 
bi                       column                   help                     rebase                   stage 
bisect                   commit                   imap-send                reflog                   stash 
blame                    config                   init                     relink                   status 
bp                       credential               instaweb                 remote                   submodule 
br                       credential-osxkeychain   log                      repack                   subtree 
branch                   describe                 merge                    replace                  svn 
bundle                   diff                     mergetool                request-pull             tag 
check-mailmap            difftool                 mv                       reset                    undo 
checkout                 fetch                    name-rev                 revert                   verify-commit 
cherry                   filter-branch            notes                    rm                       whatchanged 
cherry-pick              format-patch             p4                       send-email               

Here is Linux result of hub TAB (you can scroll right):

add                 checkout            describe            instaweb            reflog              stage 
alias               cherry              diff                log                 relink              stash 
am                  cherry-pick         difftool            merge               remote              status 
annotate            ci                  fetch               mergetool           repack              submodule 
apply               ci-status           filter-branch       mv                  replace             svn 
archive             citool              fork                name-rev            request-pull        sync.sh 
bi                  clean               format-patch        notes               reset               tag 
bisect              clone               fsck                p4                  revert              undo 
blame               co                  gc                  pf                  rm                  verify-commit 
bp                  column              get-tar-commit-id   pff                 send-email          whatchanged 
br                  commit              grep                pull                shortlog            
branch              compare             gui                 pull-request        show                
browse              config              help                push                show-branch         
bundle              create              imap-send           rbm                 squash              
check-mailmap       credential          init                rebase              st                  

Since pressing TAB does something, then I guess hub auto-complete script works. However it appears, that none of hub-specific commands are displayed. I can see all my custom aliases though (e.g. rbm, st)

The bash autocompletion engine was installed by Homebrew as well.

[mislav]

1. Is your ~/.bash_profile set to enable completion scripts from Homebrew?

   source "$(brew --prefix)/etc/bash_completion"

2. Does brew list hub include hub.bash_completion.sh?

3. Was the completion script symlinked by Homebrew?

   ls -l "$(brew --prefix)"/etc/bash_completion.d/ | grep hub

[aik099]

Is your ~/.bash_profile set to enable completion scripts from Homebrew?

Yes.

$> brew list hub

/usr/local/Cellar/hub/1.12.2/bin/hub
/usr/local/Cellar/hub/1.12.2/etc/bash_completion.d/hub.bash_completion.sh
/usr/local/Cellar/hub/1.12.2/share/man/man1/hub.1
/usr/local/Cellar/hub/1.12.2/share/zsh/site-functions/_hub

$> ls -l "$(brew --prefix)"/etc/bash_completion.d/ | grep hub

lrwxr-xr-x 1 alex admin  68 Aug 15 10:45 hub.bash_completion.sh -> ../../Cellar/hub/1.12.2/etc/bash_completion.d/hub.bash_completion.sh*

I believe auto-completion script is connected, because otherwise I'll be getting none suggestions at all. What might be happening is that hub.bash_completion.sh decides not to auto-complete pull-request and other Hub specific commands for some reason.

[mislav]

What might be happening is that hub.bash_completion.sh decides not to auto-complete pull-request and other Hub specific commands for some reason.

That's unlikely. What's more likely is that git gets run before completion scripts from Homebrew are loaded, somehow prematurely triggering the loading of git core completions.

Can you move source "$(brew --prefix)/etc/bash_completion" as early in your bash_profile as possible and restart your shell? Ideally no git commands should occur before loading completions. Just some thing to try.

[aik099]

I don't know why, but symlined version of auto-complete script from hub.bash_completion.sh -> ../../Cellar/hub/1.12.2/etc/bash_completion.d/hub.bash_completion.sh wasn't working as expected. I've copied actual SH file to my home folder's bash_completion.d folder and it started to work as expected.

Actually I had same solution on Linux and that's why it worked.

[mislav]

The symlinked version should work identically. That's the nature of
symlinks—they shouldn't be distinguishable from normal files (in most
cases). Homebrew is the way I've got it set up and it works. Maybe you
could try restoring it back to the symlink in Homebrew and try debugging
what might be wrong with it.

[aik099]

The __git_list_all_commands function should return hub + git native commands I suppose. When I run it on Linux I get this:

alias
pull-request
fork
create
browse
compare
ci-status
add
merge-octopus
merge-one-file
am
merge-ours
annotate
merge-recursive
apply
merge-resolve
archimport
merge-subtree
archive
merge-tree
bisect
mergetool
mktag
blame
mktree
branch
mv
bundle
name-rev
cat-file
notes
check-attr
p4
check-ignore
pack-objects
check-mailmap
pack-redundant
check-ref-format
pack-refs
checkout
patch-id
checkout-index
peek-remote
cherry
prune
cherry-pick
prune-packed
citool
pull
clean
push
clone
quiltimport
column
read-tree
commit
rebase
commit-tree
receive-pack
config
reflog
count-objects
relink
credential
remote
credential-cache
remote-ext
remote-fd
credential-store
remote-ftp
cvsexportcommit
remote-ftps
cvsimport
remote-http
cvsserver
remote-https
daemon
remote-testgit
describe
remote-testsvn
diff
repack
diff-files
replace
diff-index
repo-config
diff-tree
request-pull
difftool
rerere
reset
fast-export
rev-list
fast-import
rev-parse
fetch
revert
fetch-pack
rm
filter-branch
send-email
fmt-merge-msg
send-pack
for-each-ref
format-patch
shell
fsck
shortlog
fsck-objects
show
gc
show-branch
get-tar-commit-id
show-index
grep
show-ref
gui
stage
stash
hash-object
status
help
stripspace
http-backend
submodule
http-fetch
svn
http-push
symbolic-ref
imap-send
tag
index-pack
tar-tree
init
unpack-file
init-db
unpack-objects
instaweb
update-index
log
update-ref
lost-found
update-server-info
ls-files
upload-archive
ls-remote
upload-pack
ls-tree
var
mailinfo
verify-commit
mailsplit
verify-pack
merge
verify-tag
merge-base
merge-file
whatchanged
merge-index
write-tree
sync.sh

however, when I run it on OSX I get this:

alias
pull-request
fork
create
browse
compare
ci-status
alias
pull-request
fork
create
browse
compare
ci-status
-bash: __git_list_all_commands_without_hub_without_hub: command not found

The Bash version on OSX is (where it doesn't work):

GNU bash, version 3.2.51(1)-release (x86_64-apple-darwin13)
Copyright (C) 2007 Free Software Foundation, Inc.

The Bash version on Linux is (where it works):

GNU bash, version 4.1.10(2)-release (x86_64-slackware-linux-gnu)
Copyright (C) 2009 Free Software Foundation, Inc.

I guess there is something incorrect with syntax used to declare that __git_list_all_commands_without_hub_without_hub function.

[aik099]

Maybe sed doesn't work the same (see https://github.com/github/hub/blob/master/etc/hub.bash_completion.sh#L8).

[aik099]

I've just noticed that function used has _without_hub repeated 2 times at the end. I guess that is the problem. The auto-completion script is invoked only once.

[aik099]

I think I understand what's happening. I have both Hub and Git installed via Homebrew. The Hub creates __git_list_all_commands function and then Git replaces it with it's own. That's why including same Hub auto-complete script again from ~/.bash_completion.d folder helps (it just overwrites what Git has created before as it supposed to).

[aik099]

Yes, that was it. I had this:

1. the Homebrew git auto-completion script was included
2. the Homebrew Hub auto-completion script was included
3. my copy of git auto-completion script from included from ~/.bash_autocompletion.d which I've used before I've started to use Git from Homebrew, which already had it's own auto-complete script

I removed later script and all started to work.

[mislav]

Great. Thanks!

[danielgomezrico]

This is not working for me, tried adding:

if [ -f $(brew --prefix)/etc/hub.bash_completion.d ]; then
    . $(brew --prefix)/etc/hub.bash_completion.d/hub.bash_completion.sh
fi

to my .bash_profile but still not working.

• git version 2.6.4 (Apple Git-63)
• hub version 2.2.2
• Homebrew 0.9.5 (git revision 09f9; last commit 2016-01-15)

how can I do the setup?

[mislav]

@danielgomezrico Did you load git's own bash completion script before loading hub's? I don't know exactly where it is for Apple Git-63, but it should be somewhere on the system.

[danielgomezrico]

@mislav you mean using something like this? https://github.com/git/git/blob/master/contrib/completion/git-completion.bash

No, I tried tag with git command but theres no autocomplete for it neither.

[mislav]

@danielgomezrico Well, the way to load hub's completion is to first load git's own completion (it should complete git commands in the terminal), then when you verify that works, load hub's completion and restart the shell again.

[ushuz]

I installed both Git and Hub through Homebrew. The auto completion worked just fine until recently. hub [TAB] only gives me git's command but not hub's. I'm not sure the cause, the Apple Git, Homebrew Git and Hub had all been upgraded in the meantime.

$ /usr/local/bin/hub --version
git version 2.18.0
hub version 2.5.0

$ /usr/bin/git --version
git version 2.15.1 (Apple Git-101)

[mislav]

@ushuz See #1792 (comment)