Individual items of playground=* and area=

[imagoiq]

Hi,

I've notice that individual installations inside a playground are flagged as Untagged area object when they are tagged with area=yes.

Here is a good example: https://osmose.openstreetmap.fr/en/issue/e48ceb6f-f1eb-7410-1311-f84189b202ca

If you look at the imagery, you can see that the installations inside this particular playground have for each one a different surface (not tagged as I'm not exactly sure what it is from imagery).

According to the wiki, almost all kind of installations may be tagged as an area, it appears as well that there is no main tag: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:playground

I'm not entirely sure of my analysis, can you confirm that it is correct? (I can make a pull request afterwards). Perhaps, the area around the playground is not included within the installations?

[frodrigo]

One of this tags is expected inthe check
https://github.com/osm-fr/osmose-backend/blob/master/plugins/TagFix_Area.py#L30
As playground is not ok alone.

[imagoiq]

From what we can read on the wiki, it seems ok.

This is what I understand from the wiki:

On the left side of https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:playground, it's clearly saying: "[use] leisure=playground for the area around the devices".

In ID, it has a mixed interpretation:

You can add a "seesaw" has a single point, and it only adds the key playground=seesaw. But it doesn't allow you to add it with an area, as opposed to the wiki:

So, I'm a bit lost.

[Famlam]

I would agree with imagoiq that it seems to be correct to tag these items without another main key (and hence made PR #1464 to fix it)

[frodrigo]

Yes, I am agree too.
Merged. But not deployed, yet.