Should the numbers entered in the keyboard be stateful?

[KatieWoe]

Test device
iPad
Operating System
iPadOS 17
Browser
Safari
Problem description
For phetsims/qa#1008
The keypad for changing mass or other properties of the bodies is stateful in if it is open or not. Any numbers being entered are not stateful. If you press enter the new data is captured in state. If this is intended, feel free to close

Visuals

[AgustinVallejo]

@pixelzoom Is this a common code issue or should we take a look into it?

[pixelzoom]

Good question @KatieWoe!

Keypad statefulness is still not supported in common code, see phetsims/scenery-phet#540.

And for the 1.3 release of this sim, we specifically punted - see #234 (comment). The only requirement is that the PhET-iO API needs to include keypadDialog.isShowingProperty, and we've done that.

So closing this issue as "won't fix". @arouinfar @kathy-phet FYI.

[pixelzoom]

See also #293 (comment), where I noted this specific issue while testing the Standard Wrapper:

As with the State wrapper (see #289 (comment)), the initial state of KeypadDialog is incorrect in the Standard wrapper. See screenshot below, where the range and value are both missing. But that is to be expected, since we punted on instrumenting KeypadDialog and Keypad (see #234). And in practice there is no reason to create a wrapper where the initial state has the KeypadDialog open.