You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Raising an issue with more use-case details as requested after discussion around #516
Elemental provides a number of compelling features, some of which are tightly coupled to the base OS (such as image based updates and reset), others such as onboarding/inventory functionality are not necessarily coupled to the choice of base OS, and could potentially be decoupled to enable operation with other OS targets (such as vanilla SLEMicro).
As a potential user of Elemental, I may have several reasons for preferring flexibility to choose an alternate OS:
Existing operational/toolchain investment - not all users are ready for the operational cost of migrating to an image-based solution, particularly if it must be maintained in addition to some other OS (environments where not all deployments are via Elemental)
Some users have advanced customization needs, such as installing custom packages and drivers - this could potentially be achieved via the image based flow, but would require an automated way to layer customisations on top of every base-OS update to avoid undue operational friction compared with the corresponding package-based flow (does such a capability exist today in Elemental?)
Some customers have vendor support/certification requirements which would be complicated by supporting another OS variant with a different packaging/update strategy
My proposal is we consider adding the capability to register pre-installed hosts (main focus area is vanilla SLEMIcro for now, but could apply to other platforms), with a flow like:
Pre-installed OS with first-boot configuration (which installs elemental-register and elemental-system-agent)
elemental-register is run with a flag to indicate "no install" or similar, so we can register the system but opt out of all day-2 operations coupled to the choice of OS
The machine is registered and exposed as normal via MachineInventory but with an annotation to indicate OS management is disabled
MachineInventory can be consumed as normal to enable cluster bootstrap via elemental-system-agent
Raising an issue with more use-case details as requested after discussion around #516
Elemental provides a number of compelling features, some of which are tightly coupled to the base OS (such as image based updates and reset), others such as onboarding/inventory functionality are not necessarily coupled to the choice of base OS, and could potentially be decoupled to enable operation with other OS targets (such as vanilla SLEMicro).
As a potential user of Elemental, I may have several reasons for preferring flexibility to choose an alternate OS:
My proposal is we consider adding the capability to register pre-installed hosts (main focus area is vanilla SLEMIcro for now, but could apply to other platforms), with a flow like:
elemental-register
andelemental-system-agent
)elemental-register
is run with a flag to indicate "no install" or similar, so we can register the system but opt out of all day-2 operations coupled to the choice of OSMachineInventory
but with an annotation to indicate OS management is disabledelemental-system-agent
Checklist of tasks to complete:
--no-toolkit
)elemental.cattle.io/os.unmanaged
in register: add no-toolkit CLI option for pre-installed hosts #516)The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: