FT2023-2 Proposal for Amendments

[amilan17]

Details

Document:
https://wmoomm.sharepoint.com/:b:/s/wmocpdb/EXx8OPTXgstBo5bpm9ty-ZUBZzEpc40i4YhNONtRPqKZHQ?e=0cmRCL

Issues:
https://github.com/wmo-im/wmds/milestone/9

[amilan17]

Subject: RE: [WMO - fp-oscar-surface] Fw: FT2023-2 Vol. I.3 -WMDR: Proposal for amendments to WIGOS codes

Please find below some comments on behalf of Switzerland being also the Operator of OSCAR/Surface - for your consideration:

Feedback on behalf of Switzerland:

• Following program has been forgotten which needs to be integrated into OSCAR/Surface:
  Name: Copernicus
  Notation: C3S
  Description: The Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S) operated by the European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF), on behalf of the European Union

Feedback on behalf of Switzerland in its role as OSCAR/Surface operators:

• Elimination of observing method «Sunshine duration»: Since this method is being applied at 428 stations in 25 countries all the FPs need to be contacted and we need a migration plan. Therefore this needs to be considered when planning/implementing the change.
• Variable «Upper (X, Y components, horizontal)”: here we do have the same problem as we do with «Temperature profile», «Atmospheric pressure profile» etc., which have been already eliminated from the code list. Since we can’t search for a specific geometry in OSCAR/Surface we can’t implement this amendment in OSCAR/Surface and therefore also WDQMS won’t be able to use it. (Unfortunately Franziska was on leave when this was discussed in the TT and couldn’t address it there. The question is how to proceed here since “Temparture profile” and “Atmospheric pressure profile” already have been eliminated.

Best regards
Estelle

[amilan17]

@joergklausen please note the feedback.

[amilan17]

As a result of this feedback, Copernicus will be added, Sunshine duration will continue to become invalid and the changes to the wind variables will be reversed pending discussions on how to implement.

[joergklausen]

Subject: RE: [WMO - fp-oscar-surface] Fw: FT2023-2 Vol. I.3 -WMDR: Proposal for amendments to WIGOS codes

Please find below some comments on behalf of Switzerland being also the Operator of OSCAR/Surface - for your consideration:

Feedback on behalf of Switzerland:

* Following program has been forgotten which needs to be integrated into OSCAR/Surface:
  Name:  Copernicus
  Notation:  C3S
  Description: The Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S) operated by the European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF), on behalf of the European Union

Feedback on behalf of Switzerland in its role as OSCAR/Surface operators:

* Elimination of observing method  «Sunshine duration»: Since this method is being applied at 428 stations in 25 countries all the FPs need to be contacted and we need a migration plan. Therefore this needs to be considered when planning/implementing the change.

* Variable «Upper (X, Y components, horizontal)”: here we do have the same problem as we do with  «Temperature profile», «Atmospheric pressure profile» etc., which have been already eliminated from the code list. Since we can’t search for a specific geometry in OSCAR/Surface we can’t implement this amendment in OSCAR/Surface and therefore also WDQMS won’t be able to use it. (Unfortunately Franziska was on leave when this was discussed in the TT and couldn’t address it there. The question is how to proceed here since “Temparture profile” and “Atmospheric pressure profile” already have been eliminated.

Best regards Estelle

As discussed with @amilan17 today:

• C3S is not an observing program, it is a data rescue project and a climate data service. I therefore question if Copernicus / C3S should be included in the program/network tree. I believe, the intent is to allow Copernicus / C3S to mint WSIs for (old) stations. In my mind, they could be listed as an organization in OSCAR/Surface and be given the rights / credentials to do that.

• As to wind, I agree to postpone this and keep it on hold. We should have a plan / Timeline for this change, though.