Encoding Problem Black level 17: maybe color space related

[mootw]

Hi,

I am attempting to encode some images in avif format using this package. However I am experiencing what appear to be color space issues? I am not really sure. I am running on flutter web.

using image: 4.5.2
using flutter_avif: 3.0.0

This code creates invalid encoded avif images

  final image = img.Image(height: 100, width: 256);
  image.forEach((pixel) {
    pixel.r = pixel.x; 
    pixel.g = pixel.x; 
    pixel.b = pixel.x;
  });

  // return img.encodePng(image);

  // https://github.com/yekeskin/flutter_avif/issues/39#issuecomment-1858844793
  // https://web.dev/articles/compress-images-avif
  final avifFile = await encodeAvif(img.encodePng(image),
      // 0 (slowest/highest quality) - 10 (fastest/lowest quality)
      speed: 8,
      // 0 (lossless) - 63 (lowest)
      maxQuantizer: 40,
      minQuantizer: 25,
      maxQuantizerAlpha: 40,
      minQuantizerAlpha: 25);

img.encodePng(image) output:

avifFile: (uploaded renamed to avif_real.png since github does not allow avif files. download and rename to .avif. the file is NOT converted to png it is the exact avif binary)

I am confident that the image is being generated correctly, but the encodeAvif function is breaking the image. I suspect it is color space related but i am not sure. Since the "black level is 17, and white level is 234. I can find no option to fix it. This issue exists in real world test images, but this is for reproduction. I have used exif preserve to true, I have also tried switching the decoder in the encodeAvif class to not the web version (not sure why there are 2 separate implementations for that) to no success.

Images display the same in: firefox, my kde desktop using gwenview, and in GIMP.

GIMP says the avif image is using the: BT.601 sRGB-TRC RGB color space. This is the same for all of my test images (input of png, avif, and jpeg), along with the code above.

I have found no way to adjust the color space input and output. manually generating avif images in GIMP does not result in the raised blacks and lowered whites.

[yekeskin]

I am able to reproduce this issue on web. All other platforms seems to be working fine. My initial guess is that this might be realated to rgb to yuv conversion but I need to investigate some more.

[yekeskin]

I have also tried switching the decoder in the encodeAvif class to not the web version (not sure why there are 2 separate implementations for that) to no success.

This is because Flutter's internal image decoding is not reliable on web so I have to use an external decoder.

[mootw]

In my test image color saturation also is reduced during the encode, not just luminosity. If that is helpful.

I haven't looked in detail at the code yet, but i am not sure i would be qualified anyway. That makes sense! i have been doing some searching online about what might be causing the issue, and everything i can see points towards the colors being double converted to a Limited color space.

Assuming a start value of 0 and it is converted to a limited color space zero would get mapped to 16–235. and because the color space is now limited, after it gets mapped again, the resulting values are slightly off (due to 8 bit resolution), and we end up with a RGB black level of 17 and white level of 234 in the resulting image in all channels, rather than the expected 0, and 255 from only running a single conversion.

Let me know if I can assist in testing anything