-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 186
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Pop!_OS 20.04: Display Recognized but not usable #279
Comments
When attempting with
|
Hi Brandon. 😇 I didn't get much time to investigate this issue yet. However, everything appears to be fine on Wayland, if you don't mind switching to it as a workaround. Here's a helpful guide for enabling Wayland on Pop!_OS: https://www.reddit.com/r/pop_os/comments/75wn18/how_do_i_start_wayland_session/doag5r8/ |
I have an NVidia chip that I use often off-dock, so since I don't want to be hopping between it and xorg, using Wayland as a workaround isn't really an option for me. I have been connecting to my monitor directly with my laptop's built-in HDMI port in the meantime. |
Ah, that's unfortunate. 😣 I'll be taking a closer look at it in the near future. |
Just made an account to drop in and say I'm basically in exactly the same boat on system76 laptop very similar setup. X11 w/ Nvidia. Xrandr was recognizing the display when connected but it had a black screen and would show up in the display settings but if I tried to extend my display to it it would just pop back over to my default display. I've since uninstalled displaylink/evdi but oh well that's what I get for updating my kernel lol. |
I am also in the same boat, brand new laptop and after 2 days of using it the 5.11 Kernel comes out and my 2nd Monitor quits working. I ended up going back to the 5.8 Kernel, and it is fine, I just have to be careful what software I update. |
Hi I have the same problem, I uninstalled DL 5.4, switched back to kernel Version 5.8 and reinstalled DL 5.3, but now my old configuration does'nt work either. Not sure why. In the release notes it said something about firmware upgrades for the chips, does that play a role ? I use an i-tec docking station.
|
Yep, as others I'm on a System76 machine and now video on my dock is effectively dead. |
Perhaps this is good news. It looks like NVIDIA support using XWayland is coming. This was merged last week: https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/xorg/xserver/-/merge_requests/587 |
I have this issue on a System76 Darter Pro (darp5 model) which only has Intel graphics (no Nvidia or AMD) running Pop!_OS 20.10. I'm using DisplayLink for my SideTrak portable monitor. https://standsteady.com/products/sidetrak Similar to @bolek2000, I tried going to back to kernel 5.8 and driver version 5.3, but that no longer works either. Unfortunately, the laptop broke, and I'm getting it repaired under warranty, so I won't have access to it to do any testing or provide any more information for now. However, I wanted to make sure my case was documented as well. |
@displaylink-emajewsk Just curious if there's any news on this. Thanks! |
Weighing in as well. System76 Darter Pro (darp5, Intel UHD 620), unable to use dock for a few weeks now. Tried going back to previous kernels, drivers, etc, no go. Interested in helping any way I can. Please let me know if there are any commands, outputs, etc that might help, as I would love to use my dock again. |
Running Ubuntu 20.04 on a System76 Galago Pro (glap3-c) with Intel UHD WL2 Graphics. Using the System76 Drivers and second display is unusable with the dock, have to connect discretely with an HDMI cable. I believe the issue is an incorrect (unpatched) EVDI 1.9.1 that is being bundled with DLM 5.4. #275 |
The current release of EVDI, 1.9.1, is what is in the DLM 5.4 release. |
I'm running Pop_OS 20.10 and my displaylink dock connected monitors stopped working too, but I was able to get it working again by following the instructions in this reddit post :
|
@omad my only concern with doing this is that I am actually running on a System76 machine and don't 2amt to lose any hardware specific fixes/optimizations with the newer kernel. |
I'm not on a System76 machine, and everything has been working fine. However, if you are concerned, it's easy to re-run |
@displaylink-emajewsk Has there been any progress figuring out the issue with Xorg? |
This has not been resolved. I ended up switching to Linux Mint, which is
much more conservative in updates and it is still using the 5.4 Kernel
which works fine with my display. Just providing this as an alternative if
you need your second or third display.
System: Kernel: 5.4.0-72-generic x86_64 bits: 64 compiler: gcc v:
9.3.0 Desktop: Cinnamon 4.8.6
wm: muffin dm: LightDM Distro: Linux Mint 20.1 Ulyssa base:
Ubuntu 20.04 focal
Thanks,
…On Tue, May 11, 2021 at 7:31 PM Brian Zwahr ***@***.***> wrote:
@displaylink-emajewsk <https://github.com/displaylink-emajewsk> Has there
been any progress figuring out the issue with Xorg?
—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
<#279 (comment)>,
or unsubscribe
<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AEDRWO2GRVYANUZRKQL4S4DTNG45JANCNFSM43AOGKZQ>
.
--
Brent A. Pinkston
***@***.***
740-310-3846 mobile
|
@omad Are you saying that MESA 21.0.0 is broken as well?
Or will MESA 21.0.0 not work with Kernel 5.8.x ? BTW; One can also perform these changes using GRUB CUSTOMIZER (in the Repos) and UKUU Utility (https://teejeetech.in/tag/ukuu/). |
The instructions in @omad's comment worked for me, with a couple of differences:
|
I'm wondering, is this a bug in MESA 21, or a bug in DLM/EVDI? Has anyone reported this upstream to MESA? |
Has anyone used this script with any success? displaylink-debian: https://github.com/AdnanHodzic/displaylink-debian |
@cement-head I just tried that. It makes it to the point where it's configuing Xorg, then freezes the GUI. I can move the mouse and switch to other TTY's (ctrl-alt-F3), but I can't interact with anything in GNOME. I rebooted from the F3 TTY. Possibly related to this issue since the installer also asked to install linux-source for me: AdnanHodzic/displaylink-debian#581 |
Could we please get some of update on this? If there's anything we can do to help, I'm sure at least some of us would be happy to do so. @displaylink-emajewsk @displaylink-dkurek @displaylink-mlukaszek @DisplayLink-Admin |
@echosa That's exactly what happened to me - EXACTLY! |
Bought this: https://www.amazon.com/Docking-MCY-Displayport-Ethernet-Compatible/dp/B08L4RK1M7 Works, with no drivers - Ubuntu 20.04, Kernel 5.11, System76 PPA |
Yes, but when you've already dropped money on a docking station that was working the solution shouldn't be to have to buy something else. |
This also doesn't help those of us who are using a USB-A DisplayLink docking station since we don't have a type-c port. |
@timnolte @brandoningli I agree with both of you guys - I'm frustrated with the lack of willingness on Synaptics part (DL) to concede that they need to be ahead of kernel releases, not six months behind them. Guess my point is that there is hardware that is fully compatible with the LINUX kernel that doesn't need a driver. Synaptics/DL should open source their driver and push it into the LINUX kernel. |
Have this issue as well —monitor is detected but not able to display anything on it. Dock and monitor works just fine on the windows boot and with my MacBook Pro. I have tried official installer and the displaylink-debian: https://github.com/AdnanHodzic/displaylink-debian Not sure what else to try...
|
The previous instructions stopped working for me, so now I'm back to using the latest kernel and packages and hoping this gets fixed soon. I might try Wayland again, since the monitor works there. Unfortunately, using Wayland breaks some of my existing tools and programs I use, like AutoKey. :-( |
Guys, This is because of GL renderer in Mesa 21 has changed from llvmpipe to zink, and this made XServer go completly new path which is at the moment not working. |
If your MESA (OpenGL renderer) is running on llvmpipe, it's running on software rendering as opposed to hardware rendering, and it's basically not installed properly. You should be able to get it (MESA/OpenGL) to run directly on your GPU (dGPU, iGPU or eGPU), if you get the correct hardware drivers installed.
|
I'm not sure how much my experience will contribute but here I will share what happened to me: I use a System 76 AdderWS with a GeForce RTX 2070 (driver version 460.73.01), Pop OS 20.04 with kernel 5.11.0-7614-generic. I tried to use a Dell Universal Dock D6000 (https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/accessories/apd/452-BCYT?c=us&l=en&s=gen&sku=452-BCYT). I installed the latest DisplayLink drivers at the moment (5.4.0-55.153) and rebooted. This totally broke my laptop, after reboot, it got stuck loading modules and it never gave me access, not even while unplugged from the docking station. The only way to recover my laptop was to forcefully access the terminal and uninstall the DisplayLink drivers. So in conclusion from my experience:
IMHO, If the hardware is not compatible with my setup and I'm unable to use the docking station, well that's a shame, sometimes happens and I'm unlucky. BUT the fact that the drivers completely break the laptop is completely crazy and IT SHOULD NOT HAPPEN. |
Related Xorg-xserver issue: |
I wonder how long it will take that change to make its way into the apt repos for Pop!_OS once its merged. Hopefully, it's not a "wait for 21.10 or later" kinda thing. |
Bug with fix porting request is here: If you want to have it faster then lobby it:) |
Okay - everyone on this thread should cross post to the Ubuntu Bug report and let them know that this affects a lot of people! |
This looks as if it's fixed, but the XOrg Server needs to be built for Ubuntu 20.04: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/xorg-server/+bug/1931547 Can someone do this, or provide instructions? |
FWIW, I'm on PopOS 20.04 and a workaround for this is to switch to wayland versus xorg (this worked for me). The gist: comment out the following in
Reboot, then at login before you login click on the gear icon on the bottom right and select 'PopOS on Wayland'. The caveat here is that wayland is unstable on some GPUs. However, I'm on all Intel machine on a Dell laptop and its buttery smooth. YMMV. |
Seems to be working in X11 after the 21.04 update! After I upgraded, my second display wasn't working at all. I uninstalled the driver, rebooted, installed the driver again, rebooted, and now it's working in X11! Not sure why, but I'm not going to question it. :-D |
@echosa It's likely the point release XOrg XServer 1.20.11 (Hirsute) vs 1.20.9 (Focal), that has the fix from the master. Just needs to be rebuilt for Focal, and it's taking weeks & weeks (nothing new about that). |
@cement-head https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/xorg-server/+bug/1931547 they built and provided links for hir/foc |
Please add: Or way couple days more until this will appear in main repo. Issue is fixed. |
Can confirm it's working on Pop 21.04 on Wayland as well.
Poof! Monitors popped on! Yay! |
On Pop 20.04:
For me the external display is now working again, but everything is responding very slowly when using the display link. So when I type, the letters are showing up a couple of seconds later on the screen. When I change windows by clicking it takes several seconds as well. If I remember right I had this behavior before long time ago, but I don't remember, if there was a solution... Update: The lagging issue only happens, when the laptop lid is closed, see #290 |
Fixed for me as well running Ubuntu 20.04 LTS on System76 Galp-3c using System76 PPA.
|
on DisplayLink's website? Yes
xserver-xorg-core
version 1.20.9-2ubuntu1.2~20.04.2Using a Dell USB3 docking station. All other functions (USB, Ethernet) work fine. Display will show up in the GNOME settings with the correct metadata, and I can ask GNOME to
join displays, but it immediately sets back to single display on my laptop's built-in monitor.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: