[Bug] Mainline mode breaking change between 5.1.2 & 5.1.3

[rducom]

Describe the bug

Breaking change in the version calculation on a tagged commit. The last working release is 5.1.2

Expected Behavior

{
  "Major":3,
  "Minor":1,
  "Patch":3,
  "PreReleaseTag":"",
  "PreReleaseTagWithDash":"",
  "PreReleaseLabel":"",
  "PreReleaseNumber":"",
  "WeightedPreReleaseNumber":"",
  "BuildMetaData":"",
  "BuildMetaDataPadded":"",
  "FullBuildMetaData":"Branch.master.Sha.517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c",
  "MajorMinorPatch":"3.1.3",
  "SemVer":"3.1.3",
  "LegacySemVer":"3.1.3",
  "LegacySemVerPadded":"3.1.3",
  "AssemblySemVer":"3.1.3.0",
  "AssemblySemFileVer":"3.1.3.0",
  "FullSemVer":"3.1.3",
  "InformationalVersion":"3.1.3+Branch.master.Sha.517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c",
  "BranchName":"master",
  "Sha":"517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c",
  "ShortSha":"517daf9",
  "NuGetVersionV2":"3.1.3",
  "NuGetVersion":"3.1.3",
  "NuGetPreReleaseTagV2":"",
  "NuGetPreReleaseTag":"",
  "VersionSourceSha":"517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c",
  "CommitsSinceVersionSource":0,
  "CommitsSinceVersionSourcePadded":"0000",
  "CommitDate":"2020-04-22"
}

Actual Behavior

{
  "Major":3,
  "Minor":1,
  "Patch":4,
  "PreReleaseTag":"beta.6",
  "PreReleaseTagWithDash":"-beta.6",
  "PreReleaseLabel":"beta",
  "PreReleaseNumber":6,
  "WeightedPreReleaseNumber":55006,
  "BuildMetaData":"",
  "BuildMetaDataPadded":"",
  "FullBuildMetaData":"Branch.master.Sha.517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c",
  "MajorMinorPatch":"3.1.4",
  "SemVer":"3.1.4-beta.6",
  "LegacySemVer":"3.1.4-beta6",
  "LegacySemVerPadded":"3.1.4-beta0006",
  "AssemblySemVer":"3.1.4.0",
  "AssemblySemFileVer":"3.1.4.0",
  "FullSemVer":"3.1.4-beta.6",
  "InformationalVersion":"3.1.4-beta.6+Branch.master.Sha.517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c",
  "BranchName":"master",
  "Sha":"517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c",
  "ShortSha":"517daf9",
  "NuGetVersionV2":"3.1.4-beta0006",
  "NuGetVersion":"3.1.4-beta0006",
  "NuGetPreReleaseTagV2":"beta0006",
  "NuGetPreReleaseTag":"beta0006",
  "VersionSourceSha":"33fb5feef4a83c079656dce3eac57b27f93bc39b",
  "CommitsSinceVersionSource":6,
  "CommitsSinceVersionSourcePadded":"0006",
  "CommitDate":"2020-04-22"
}

Both outputs are the dotnet gitversion call on the exact same commit, with just different GitVersion.Tool versions

Steps to Reproduce

Build a tag on Jenkins with 5.1.3, with the following Gitversion.yml

mode: Mainline
branches: 
  master:
    regex: ^master$
    tag: 'beta'
    is-release-branch: true
    is-mainline: true
  release:
    regex: releases?[/-]
    tag: ''
    is-release-branch: true
    is-mainline: true

Context

This bug breaks our release pipeline

Your Environment

Windows / Jenkins / dotnet core libs
Unfortunately, this happens on private projects, so can't link you to the git repo / CI

[asbjornu]

Seems like there are many problems related to tagged builds, lately. Any ideas what the source of those problems may be, @arturcic? I had an impression that our tests around this were pretty solid?

[arturcic]

I will try to find some time to look at

[rducom]

Here are the diags on my local machine, if this can help you.

For the 5.1.2 version :

INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:23] Dumping commit graph: 
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:34] *   517daf9 23 hours ago  (HEAD -> master, tag: v3.1.3, origin/master, origin/HEAD)
|\  
| * 994b7d6 25 hours ago  (ENH.TenantNotFoundException)
| * 752a504 25 hours ago 
| * 9e48cf2 26 hours ago 
|/  
*   dafcd95 3 weeks ago 
|\  
| * e86a825 3 weeks ago 
|/  
*   33fb5fe 4 weeks ago  (tag: v3.1.2)
|\  
| * f3ecbb9 4 weeks ago 
* |   e541809 4 weeks ago 
|\ \  
| |/  
|/|   
| * ae905fe 4 weeks ago 
| * 4accde1 4 weeks ago 
|/  
*   d1c8204 5 weeks ago 
|\  
| * 66d4f4f 5 weeks ago 
|/  
*   40afc7b 6 weeks ago 
|\  
| * 2e181ad 6 weeks ago  (sonarcloud)
| * a9a0460 6 weeks ago 
|/  
| * 8c073a6 6 weeks ago  (origin/no_controller_health)
|/  
| * 2f56edd 2 months ago  (origin/fix_cache_n_breaking_change)
| * 3c91252 2 months ago 
| * 0f1c0ec 2 months ago 
| * 9b579ff 2 months ago 
|/  
*   bc3317b 3 months ago  (tag: v3.1.1)
|\  
| * 60542e0 3 months ago 
|/  
* d477beb 3 months ago 
* 4ff8503 3 months ago 
*   c690b4a 3 months ago  (tag: v3.1.0)
|\  
| * deae123 3 months ago 
| * 0497cde 3 months ago 
| * b857c4b 3 months ago  (better.tenancy)
| * 3aa6867 3 months ago 
| * 511a208 3 months ago 
* | 9401ac2 3 months ago  (tag: v3.0.1)
|/  
*   0550b5f 4 months ago  (tag: v3.0.0)
|\  
| * 3aa5c29 4 months ago  (netcore3.1)
| * c03078e 4 months ago 
| * 3a6c5e7 5 months ago 
| * 269b0ba 5 months ago 
| * 5f14d42 5 months ago 
| * a9700d0 5 months ago 
|/  
| *   8a68299 3 months ago  (tag: v2.1.1, origin/release/2.0)
| |\  
| | * 4862bb9 3 months ago 
| | * d5c35f8 3 months ago 
| |/  
| *   5d06c44 3 months ago  (tag: v2.1.0)
| |\  
| | * b95e532 3 months ago 
| | * 2bdda47 3 months ago 
| | * 66e249e 3 months ago  (better.tenancy_2.0)
| | * f04640d 3 months ago 
| | * f2ce807 3 months ago 
| | * 0eef500 3 months ago 
| |/  
|/|   
| * 4f4875c 3 months ago  (tag: v2.0.7)
|/| 
| * aeaf683 3 months ago  (tryfix.concurrency.exception.for.2.0)
|/  
| * bfdc0e5 3 months ago  (backup/tryfix.concurrency.exception.for.2.0-15-44-25)
| * 3d4981b 3 months ago 
| * f52c8b1 3 months ago 
|/  
| * 10dd4ea 3 months ago  (ref_tenancy_comments)
| | * d3dbaa6 3 months ago  (origin/ref_tenancy_comments)
| |/  
| | * ac24afc 4 months ago  (origin/ref_tenancy)
| |/  
| | * a8da00a 5 months ago  (origin/tenancy_pooling_in_memory_cache)
| | * cc2f971 5 months ago  (origin/tenancy_pooling)
| | * 281b1ee 5 months ago 
| |/  
|/|   
| | *   7be18bd 5 months ago  (refs/stash)
| |/|\  
|/| | | 
| | | * 851e330 5 months ago 
| | * db92a6e 5 months ago 
| |/  
|/|   
* | 68e0eb0 5 months ago  (tag: v2.0.4, release/2.0)
|/  
| * dddcbfc 5 months ago  (ref_tenancy)
| * 694d95e 5 months ago 
| * f4d5d1d 5 months ago 
|/  
*   0cad4e2 5 months ago  (tag: v2.0.3)
|\  
| * 498eb3c 5 months ago 
|/  
*   44c10be 5 months ago  (tag: v2.0.2)
|\  
| * 02f0c58 6 months ago 
|/  
*   32fb736 6 months ago 
|\  
| * a4b072d 6 months ago 
|/  
*   4e1a1b1 6 months ago 
|\  
| * 3db0b48 6 months ago  (backporting.easy.customscope.registration)
| * 2192faf 6 months ago 
| * e747e67 6 months ago 
| * ef2757e 6 months ago 
| * f58d270 6 months ago 
| * 4a25a8a 6 months ago 
|/  
* cfd1401 6 months ago  (tag: v2.0.1)
| *   960f23f 6 months ago  (origin/release/1.4, release/1.4)
| |\  
| | * 918160b 6 months ago  (easy.customscope.registration)
| | * 7c6fd73 6 months ago 
| | * 8c25a4c 6 months ago 
| | * e9062cc 6 months ago 
| | * 9a8cf7b 6 months ago 
| | * 71c3b29 6 months ago 
| * |   c1c5bda 6 months ago  (tag: v1.4.1)
| |\ \  
| | |/  
| |/|   
| | * f86c44a 6 months ago  (try.fix.codetaskfactory.1.4)
| | * bf99eb0 6 months ago 
| * | a986db4 6 months ago 
| |/  
| | * 50bd308 6 months ago  (workaround.poltuu)
| |/  
|/|   
* |   2708f61 6 months ago  (tag: v2.0.0)
|\ \  
| |/  
|/|   
| * 9411b8b 6 months ago  (netcore3.support)
| * 51a6937 6 months ago 
| * 2a32d44 6 months ago 
|/  
* e2f6db6 6 months ago  (tag: v1.4.0)
*   d1d05db 6 months ago 
|\  
| * 11b1d4e 6 months ago  (error.page.v2)

INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:34] Working directory: C:\Sources\Lucca.Core.AspNetCore
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:34] IsDynamicGitRepository: False
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:36] Returning Project Root from DotGitDirectory: C:\Sources\Lucca.Core.AspNetCore\.git\ - C:\Sources\Lucca.Core.AspNetCore\
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:37] Running on Windows.
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:37] Project root is: C:\Sources\Lucca.Core.AspNetCore\
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:37] DotGit directory is: C:\Sources\Lucca.Core.AspNetCore\.git
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:52] Using latest commit on specified branch
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:57] Running against branch: master (517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c)
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:57] Current commit is tagged with version 3.1.3, version calculation is for metadata only.
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:58] 0 commits found between 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c and 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:59] Begin: Calculating base versions
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:61] Fallback base version: 0.1.0 with commit count source ad24537d17d26abcf1a74abab49ed13fd49551cb (Incremented: None)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v3.1.3': 3.1.3 with commit count source 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c (Incremented: None)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v3.1.2': 3.1.2 with commit count source 33fb5feef4a83c079656dce3eac57b27f93bc39b (Incremented: 3.1.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v3.1.1': 3.1.1 with commit count source bc3317b513e3bf7404f4372fbff02d09c9df9b90 (Incremented: 3.1.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v3.1.0': 3.1.0 with commit count source c690b4ab979316fee933adcb6a119582d8dc5493 (Incremented: 3.1.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v3.0.1': 3.0.1 with commit count source 9401ac26449410431f59f12d45739c71cec5e94a (Incremented: 3.0.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v3.0.0': 3.0.0 with commit count source 0550b5fb84ae67f365f1578f514eca1a6df1b7ea (Incremented: 3.0.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v2.0.4': 2.0.4 with commit count source 68e0eb0354d25d7e653f63452c2329c6e3b622b0 (Incremented: 2.0.5)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v2.0.3': 2.0.3 with commit count source 0cad4e2e712e905045c4aaed8edb38d111c4dbd1 (Incremented: 2.0.4)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v2.0.2': 2.0.2 with commit count source 44c10be75abf7ca152f2f22093c14db4feb37d85 (Incremented: 2.0.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v2.0.1': 2.0.1 with commit count source cfd1401c1215097199c17ac05acaa45bdc3fead4 (Incremented: 2.0.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v2.0.0': 2.0.0 with commit count source 2708f61be7b5bd156cebb3cffaf4e8d56520fa2e (Incremented: 2.0.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v1.4.0': 1.4.0 with commit count source e2f6db6042205578a56bcc0f1455394b04245e15 (Incremented: 1.4.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v1.3.3': 1.3.3 with commit count source 63ac4df415534b1c707210fc2975ee02688a982c (Incremented: 1.3.4)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v1.3.2': 1.3.2 with commit count source 6b7a53e406ae53128adf07becd0e4cfb41fac603 (Incremented: 1.3.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v1.3.1': 1.3.1 with commit count source b0d7bf91c2780b507752cbd80b17375f5f52baf6 (Incremented: 1.3.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v1.3.0': 1.3.0 with commit count source 23b921aa37d1e132a01c3d34c10f467416e4afaa (Incremented: 1.3.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v1.2.2': 1.2.2 with commit count source 7214c2c2306e049100f988ea5002654e92f83cba (Incremented: 1.2.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v1.2.1': 1.2.1 with commit count source b0f9d75890dfb8aea898340af820f188428c0c27 (Incremented: 1.2.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v1.2.0': 1.2.0 with commit count source 1de0ba793e5618c6cea2f366f18749d1ece5b609 (Incremented: 1.2.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v1.1.1': 1.1.1 with commit count source 73736a2da5e2e4aad6bcdc51a660ae5b570d996e (Incremented: 1.1.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v1.1.0': 1.1.0 with commit count source 5e1590dd876ccf6b9fb05cb075273d126bb81b54 (Incremented: 1.1.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v1.0.1': 1.0.1 with commit count source 25a34bbcb5d79f33070b0381202b53e7af8be819 (Incremented: 1.0.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v1.0.0': 1.0.0 with commit count source bb1a71397412e05ab141d38fccd9da15b1d91db8 (Incremented: 1.0.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.13.2': 0.13.2 with commit count source faaf531065e6735d3c3a60d6000674ec62e65ae5 (Incremented: 0.13.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.13.1': 0.13.1 with commit count source 9f9178c69de980ce6aa949f59346fafc7253f0be (Incremented: 0.13.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.13.0': 0.13.0 with commit count source da5823434800fbc019e70f49dd76aa5b6828a2aa (Incremented: 0.13.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.12.0': 0.12.0 with commit count source 3e17f5e2a113db1883a0369196c21be4cf9a7cea (Incremented: 0.12.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.11.4': 0.11.4 with commit count source 10081bd39e3186f45f9f3886384db9458a6c706e (Incremented: 0.11.5)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.11.3': 0.11.3 with commit count source 3a5deacdec81d1e62355c8c8313ab7e839a61a11 (Incremented: 0.11.4)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.11.2': 0.11.2 with commit count source 12f1fae271d4ac655e38d03e7c269711dc8abdea (Incremented: 0.11.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.11.1': 0.11.1 with commit count source 5d30580920012018bd51cd640bc695319ad348a5 (Incremented: 0.11.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.11.0': 0.11.0 with commit count source a6623300b68ec8b781e9a7d65167a92f59355120 (Incremented: 0.11.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.10.0': 0.10.0 with commit count source 1533f36a1d41733eb44bdb1e007877226f4e377c (Incremented: 0.10.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.9.0': 0.9.0 with commit count source 90f3f496c3f5472bc86138371f6943644b533909 (Incremented: 0.9.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.8.3': 0.8.3 with commit count source c5853b5b90eeea2fd2c5cbd5628ed8de3b151cca (Incremented: 0.8.4)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.8.2': 0.8.2 with commit count source 519d6ac120939a1744b2272ddcbeeaa503048f4f (Incremented: 0.8.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:69] Git tag 'v0.8.1': 0.8.1 with commit count source 6e2abbfb642ca6f65ef3bf097cbbac2e43426839 (Incremented: 0.8.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:70] Git tag 'v0.8': 0.8.0 with commit count source 65e27c5449ae8d3a7cc22bcbd2aa735279a27e41 (Incremented: 0.8.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:70] Git tag 'v0.7.1': 0.7.1 with commit count source 43b62f33496e50b82604ba531251ba7e82770496 (Incremented: 0.7.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:70] Git tag 'v0.7': 0.7.0 with commit count source 594dee09549943587acbd11e204928b07040c973 (Incremented: 0.7.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:70] Git tag 'v0.6': 0.6.0 with commit count source 51c491fb8ebc80c55c815ae3485a2183f6e3f7fe (Incremented: 0.6.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:70] Git tag 'v0.5.1': 0.5.1 with commit count source 07817937c7fba48507cb7049604c2037b70b42d3 (Incremented: 0.5.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:70] Git tag 'v0.5': 0.5.0 with commit count source 3ec6b8f14b34ff37cf6808524ce87d9e1965dc39 (Incremented: 0.5.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:70] Git tag 'v0.4': 0.4.0 with commit count source ea16a111aba5bee97e6cf4424fec3a0c5be902df (Incremented: 0.4.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:70] Git tag 'v0.3': 0.3.0 with commit count source fd3480b274f4f384a2ef66d9f2bf400b81a9c02a (Incremented: 0.3.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:70] Git tag 'v0.2': 0.2.0 with commit count source e5b262fdfb0bc128ce517411d69169031b0ce0f8 (Incremented: 0.2.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:70] Git tag 'v0.1': 0.1.0 with commit count source 62d2110e41600fca5fde652293857017b5ce7010 (Incremented: 0.1.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:76] Found multiple base versions which will produce the same SemVer (3.1.3), taking oldest source for commit counting (Git tag 'v3.1.2')
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:76] Base version used: Git tag 'v3.1.2': 3.1.2 with commit count source 33fb5feef4a83c079656dce3eac57b27f93bc39b (Incremented: 3.1.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:77] End: Calculating base versions (Took: 176.12ms)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:77] Begin: Using mainline development mode to calculate current version
    INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:82] Found possible mainline branches: master, release/1.3, origin/release/1.3, release/1.4, origin/release/1.4, release/2.0, origin/release/2.0
    INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:84] Mainline for current branch is master
    INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:84] Merge commit dafcd956b32bf155b1b56ca26bdb55a34bdc1349 incremented base versions Patch, now 3.1.3
    INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:85] Merge commit 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c incremented base versions Patch, now 3.1.4
    INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:85] 6 commits found between 33fb5feef4a83c079656dce3eac57b27f93bc39b and 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:85] End: Using mainline development mode to calculate current version (Took: 81.60ms)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:85] Begin: Getting version tags from branch 'refs/heads/master'.
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:27:88] End: Getting version tags from branch 'refs/heads/master'. (Took: 30.11ms)

For the 5.1.3 version :

INFO [04/23/20 13:14:47:94] Dumping commit graph: 
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:05] *   517daf9 23 hours ago  (HEAD -> master, tag: v3.1.3, origin/master, origin/HEAD)
|\  
| * 994b7d6 25 hours ago  (ENH.TenantNotFoundException)
| * 752a504 25 hours ago 
| * 9e48cf2 26 hours ago 
|/  
*   dafcd95 3 weeks ago 
|\  
| * e86a825 3 weeks ago 
|/  
*   33fb5fe 4 weeks ago  (tag: v3.1.2)
|\  
| * f3ecbb9 4 weeks ago 
* |   e541809 4 weeks ago 
|\ \  
| |/  
|/|   
| * ae905fe 4 weeks ago 
| * 4accde1 4 weeks ago 
|/  
*   d1c8204 5 weeks ago 
|\  
| * 66d4f4f 5 weeks ago 
|/  
*   40afc7b 6 weeks ago 
|\  
| * 2e181ad 6 weeks ago  (sonarcloud)
| * a9a0460 6 weeks ago 
|/  
| * 8c073a6 6 weeks ago  (origin/no_controller_health)
|/  
| * 2f56edd 2 months ago  (origin/fix_cache_n_breaking_change)
| * 3c91252 2 months ago 
| * 0f1c0ec 2 months ago 
| * 9b579ff 2 months ago 
|/  
*   bc3317b 3 months ago  (tag: v3.1.1)
|\  
| * 60542e0 3 months ago 
|/  
* d477beb 3 months ago 
* 4ff8503 3 months ago 
*   c690b4a 3 months ago  (tag: v3.1.0)
|\  
| * deae123 3 months ago 
| * 0497cde 3 months ago 
| * b857c4b 3 months ago  (better.tenancy)
| * 3aa6867 3 months ago 
| * 511a208 3 months ago 
* | 9401ac2 3 months ago  (tag: v3.0.1)
|/  
*   0550b5f 4 months ago  (tag: v3.0.0)
|\  
| * 3aa5c29 4 months ago  (netcore3.1)
| * c03078e 4 months ago 
| * 3a6c5e7 5 months ago 
| * 269b0ba 5 months ago 
| * 5f14d42 5 months ago 
| * a9700d0 5 months ago 
|/  
| *   8a68299 3 months ago  (tag: v2.1.1, origin/release/2.0)
| |\  
| | * 4862bb9 3 months ago 
| | * d5c35f8 3 months ago 
| |/  
| *   5d06c44 3 months ago  (tag: v2.1.0)
| |\  
| | * b95e532 3 months ago 
| | * 2bdda47 3 months ago 
| | * 66e249e 3 months ago  (better.tenancy_2.0)
| | * f04640d 3 months ago 
| | * f2ce807 3 months ago 
| | * 0eef500 3 months ago 
| |/  
|/|   
| * 4f4875c 3 months ago  (tag: v2.0.7)
|/| 
| * aeaf683 3 months ago  (tryfix.concurrency.exception.for.2.0)
|/  
| * bfdc0e5 3 months ago  (backup/tryfix.concurrency.exception.for.2.0-15-44-25)
| * 3d4981b 3 months ago 
| * f52c8b1 3 months ago 
|/  
| * 10dd4ea 3 months ago  (ref_tenancy_comments)
| | * d3dbaa6 3 months ago  (origin/ref_tenancy_comments)
| |/  
| | * ac24afc 4 months ago  (origin/ref_tenancy)
| |/  
| | * a8da00a 5 months ago  (origin/tenancy_pooling_in_memory_cache)
| | * cc2f971 5 months ago  (origin/tenancy_pooling)
| | * 281b1ee 5 months ago 
| |/  
|/|   
| | *   7be18bd 5 months ago  (refs/stash)
| |/|\  
|/| | | 
| | | * 851e330 5 months ago 
| | * db92a6e 5 months ago 
| |/  
|/|   
* | 68e0eb0 5 months ago  (tag: v2.0.4, release/2.0)
|/  
| * dddcbfc 5 months ago  (ref_tenancy)
| * 694d95e 5 months ago 
| * f4d5d1d 5 months ago 
|/  
*   0cad4e2 5 months ago  (tag: v2.0.3)
|\  
| * 498eb3c 5 months ago 
|/  
*   44c10be 5 months ago  (tag: v2.0.2)
|\  
| * 02f0c58 6 months ago 
|/  
*   32fb736 6 months ago 
|\  
| * a4b072d 6 months ago 
|/  
*   4e1a1b1 6 months ago 
|\  
| * 3db0b48 6 months ago  (backporting.easy.customscope.registration)
| * 2192faf 6 months ago 
| * e747e67 6 months ago 
| * ef2757e 6 months ago 
| * f58d270 6 months ago 
| * 4a25a8a 6 months ago 
|/  
* cfd1401 6 months ago  (tag: v2.0.1)
| *   960f23f 6 months ago  (origin/release/1.4, release/1.4)
| |\  
| | * 918160b 6 months ago  (easy.customscope.registration)
| | * 7c6fd73 6 months ago 
| | * 8c25a4c 6 months ago 
| | * e9062cc 6 months ago 
| | * 9a8cf7b 6 months ago 
| | * 71c3b29 6 months ago 
| * |   c1c5bda 6 months ago  (tag: v1.4.1)
| |\ \  
| | |/  
| |/|   
| | * f86c44a 6 months ago  (try.fix.codetaskfactory.1.4)
| | * bf99eb0 6 months ago 
| * | a986db4 6 months ago 
| |/  
| | * 50bd308 6 months ago  (workaround.poltuu)
| |/  
|/|   
* |   2708f61 6 months ago  (tag: v2.0.0)
|\ \  
| |/  
|/|   
| * 9411b8b 6 months ago  (netcore3.support)
| * 51a6937 6 months ago 
| * 2a32d44 6 months ago 
|/  
* e2f6db6 6 months ago  (tag: v1.4.0)
*   d1d05db 6 months ago 
|\  
| * 11b1d4e 6 months ago  (error.page.v2)

INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:05] Working directory: C:\Sources\Lucca.Core.AspNetCore
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:05] IsDynamicGitRepository: False
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:10] Returning Project Root from DotGitDirectory: C:\Sources\Lucca.Core.AspNetCore\.git\ - C:\Sources\Lucca.Core.AspNetCore\
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:10] Running on Windows.
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:10] Project root is: C:\Sources\Lucca.Core.AspNetCore\
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:10] DotGit directory is: C:\Sources\Lucca.Core.AspNetCore\.git
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:27] Using latest commit on specified branch
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:33] Running against branch: master (517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c)
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:33] Current commit is tagged with version 3.1.3, version calculation is for metadata only.
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:34] 0 commits found between 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c and 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c
INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:35] Begin: Calculating base versions
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:37] Fallback base version: 0.1.0 with commit count source ad24537d17d26abcf1a74abab49ed13fd49551cb (Incremented: None)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v3.1.3': 3.1.3 with commit count source 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c (Incremented: None)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v3.1.2': 3.1.2 with commit count source 33fb5feef4a83c079656dce3eac57b27f93bc39b (Incremented: 3.1.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v3.1.1': 3.1.1 with commit count source bc3317b513e3bf7404f4372fbff02d09c9df9b90 (Incremented: 3.1.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v3.1.0': 3.1.0 with commit count source c690b4ab979316fee933adcb6a119582d8dc5493 (Incremented: 3.1.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v3.0.1': 3.0.1 with commit count source 9401ac26449410431f59f12d45739c71cec5e94a (Incremented: 3.0.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v3.0.0': 3.0.0 with commit count source 0550b5fb84ae67f365f1578f514eca1a6df1b7ea (Incremented: 3.0.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v2.0.4': 2.0.4 with commit count source 68e0eb0354d25d7e653f63452c2329c6e3b622b0 (Incremented: 2.0.5)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v2.0.3': 2.0.3 with commit count source 0cad4e2e712e905045c4aaed8edb38d111c4dbd1 (Incremented: 2.0.4)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v2.0.2': 2.0.2 with commit count source 44c10be75abf7ca152f2f22093c14db4feb37d85 (Incremented: 2.0.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v2.0.1': 2.0.1 with commit count source cfd1401c1215097199c17ac05acaa45bdc3fead4 (Incremented: 2.0.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v2.0.0': 2.0.0 with commit count source 2708f61be7b5bd156cebb3cffaf4e8d56520fa2e (Incremented: 2.0.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v1.4.0': 1.4.0 with commit count source e2f6db6042205578a56bcc0f1455394b04245e15 (Incremented: 1.4.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v1.3.3': 1.3.3 with commit count source 63ac4df415534b1c707210fc2975ee02688a982c (Incremented: 1.3.4)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v1.3.2': 1.3.2 with commit count source 6b7a53e406ae53128adf07becd0e4cfb41fac603 (Incremented: 1.3.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v1.3.1': 1.3.1 with commit count source b0d7bf91c2780b507752cbd80b17375f5f52baf6 (Incremented: 1.3.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v1.3.0': 1.3.0 with commit count source 23b921aa37d1e132a01c3d34c10f467416e4afaa (Incremented: 1.3.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v1.2.2': 1.2.2 with commit count source 7214c2c2306e049100f988ea5002654e92f83cba (Incremented: 1.2.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v1.2.1': 1.2.1 with commit count source b0f9d75890dfb8aea898340af820f188428c0c27 (Incremented: 1.2.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v1.2.0': 1.2.0 with commit count source 1de0ba793e5618c6cea2f366f18749d1ece5b609 (Incremented: 1.2.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v1.1.1': 1.1.1 with commit count source 73736a2da5e2e4aad6bcdc51a660ae5b570d996e (Incremented: 1.1.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v1.1.0': 1.1.0 with commit count source 5e1590dd876ccf6b9fb05cb075273d126bb81b54 (Incremented: 1.1.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v1.0.1': 1.0.1 with commit count source 25a34bbcb5d79f33070b0381202b53e7af8be819 (Incremented: 1.0.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v1.0.0': 1.0.0 with commit count source bb1a71397412e05ab141d38fccd9da15b1d91db8 (Incremented: 1.0.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.13.2': 0.13.2 with commit count source faaf531065e6735d3c3a60d6000674ec62e65ae5 (Incremented: 0.13.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.13.1': 0.13.1 with commit count source 9f9178c69de980ce6aa949f59346fafc7253f0be (Incremented: 0.13.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.13.0': 0.13.0 with commit count source da5823434800fbc019e70f49dd76aa5b6828a2aa (Incremented: 0.13.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.12.0': 0.12.0 with commit count source 3e17f5e2a113db1883a0369196c21be4cf9a7cea (Incremented: 0.12.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.11.4': 0.11.4 with commit count source 10081bd39e3186f45f9f3886384db9458a6c706e (Incremented: 0.11.5)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.11.3': 0.11.3 with commit count source 3a5deacdec81d1e62355c8c8313ab7e839a61a11 (Incremented: 0.11.4)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.11.2': 0.11.2 with commit count source 12f1fae271d4ac655e38d03e7c269711dc8abdea (Incremented: 0.11.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.11.1': 0.11.1 with commit count source 5d30580920012018bd51cd640bc695319ad348a5 (Incremented: 0.11.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.11.0': 0.11.0 with commit count source a6623300b68ec8b781e9a7d65167a92f59355120 (Incremented: 0.11.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.10.0': 0.10.0 with commit count source 1533f36a1d41733eb44bdb1e007877226f4e377c (Incremented: 0.10.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.9.0': 0.9.0 with commit count source 90f3f496c3f5472bc86138371f6943644b533909 (Incremented: 0.9.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.8.3': 0.8.3 with commit count source c5853b5b90eeea2fd2c5cbd5628ed8de3b151cca (Incremented: 0.8.4)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.8.2': 0.8.2 with commit count source 519d6ac120939a1744b2272ddcbeeaa503048f4f (Incremented: 0.8.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.8.1': 0.8.1 with commit count source 6e2abbfb642ca6f65ef3bf097cbbac2e43426839 (Incremented: 0.8.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.8': 0.8.0 with commit count source 65e27c5449ae8d3a7cc22bcbd2aa735279a27e41 (Incremented: 0.8.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.7.1': 0.7.1 with commit count source 43b62f33496e50b82604ba531251ba7e82770496 (Incremented: 0.7.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.7': 0.7.0 with commit count source 594dee09549943587acbd11e204928b07040c973 (Incremented: 0.7.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.6': 0.6.0 with commit count source 51c491fb8ebc80c55c815ae3485a2183f6e3f7fe (Incremented: 0.6.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.5.1': 0.5.1 with commit count source 07817937c7fba48507cb7049604c2037b70b42d3 (Incremented: 0.5.2)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.5': 0.5.0 with commit count source 3ec6b8f14b34ff37cf6808524ce87d9e1965dc39 (Incremented: 0.5.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.4': 0.4.0 with commit count source ea16a111aba5bee97e6cf4424fec3a0c5be902df (Incremented: 0.4.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.3': 0.3.0 with commit count source fd3480b274f4f384a2ef66d9f2bf400b81a9c02a (Incremented: 0.3.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.2': 0.2.0 with commit count source e5b262fdfb0bc128ce517411d69169031b0ce0f8 (Incremented: 0.2.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:45] Git tag 'v0.1': 0.1.0 with commit count source 62d2110e41600fca5fde652293857017b5ce7010 (Incremented: 0.1.1)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:52] Found multiple base versions which will produce the same SemVer (3.1.3), taking oldest source for commit counting (Git tag 'v3.1.2')
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:52] Base version used: Git tag 'v3.1.2': 3.1.2 with commit count source 33fb5feef4a83c079656dce3eac57b27f93bc39b (Incremented: 3.1.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:52] End: Calculating base versions (Took: 174.08ms)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:52] Begin: Using mainline development mode to calculate current version
    INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:58] Found possible mainline branches: master, release/1.3, origin/release/1.3, release/1.4, origin/release/1.4, release/2.0, origin/release/2.0
    INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:59] Mainline for current branch is master
    INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:60] Merge commit dafcd956b32bf155b1b56ca26bdb55a34bdc1349 incremented base versions Patch, now 3.1.3
    INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:60] Merge commit 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c incremented base versions Patch, now 3.1.4
    INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:60] 6 commits found between 33fb5feef4a83c079656dce3eac57b27f93bc39b and 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:60] End: Using mainline development mode to calculate current version (Took: 79.15ms)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:60] Begin: Getting version tags from branch 'refs/heads/master'.
  INFO [04/23/20 13:14:48:64] End: Getting version tags from branch 'refs/heads/master'. (Took: 30.80ms)

[asbjornu]

This seems related to #2239, #2206 and #2074 at least.

[rducom]

On our Jenkins CI, we are building on merged branch (from source branch).
Things are getting worse, since the calculated semver2 is "NuGetVersionV2":"3.1.5-v3-1-3-0000" instead of "NuGetVersionV2":"3.1.3"

For the 5.2.4 version on Jenkins :

INFO [04/23/20 13:33:34:89] Dumping commit graph: 
INFO [04/23/20 13:33:34:93] *   517daf9 24 hours ago  (HEAD -> v3.1.3, tag: v3.1.3, origin/master, master)
|\  
| * 994b7d6 26 hours ago 
| * 752a504 26 hours ago 
| * 9e48cf2 26 hours ago 
|/  
*   dafcd95 3 weeks ago 
|\  
| * e86a825 3 weeks ago 
|/  
*   33fb5fe 4 weeks ago  (tag: v3.1.2)
|\  
| * f3ecbb9 4 weeks ago 
* |   e541809 4 weeks ago 
|\ \  
| |/  
|/|   
| * ae905fe 4 weeks ago 
| * 4accde1 4 weeks ago 
|/  
*   d1c8204 5 weeks ago 
|\  
| * 66d4f4f 5 weeks ago 
|/  
*   40afc7b 6 weeks ago 
|\  
| * 2e181ad 6 weeks ago 
| * a9a0460 6 weeks ago 
|/  
| * 8c073a6 6 weeks ago  (origin/no_controller_health, no_controller_health)
|/  
| * 2f56edd 2 months ago  (origin/fix_cache_n_breaking_change, fix_cache_n_breaking_change)
| * 3c91252 2 months ago 
| * 0f1c0ec 2 months ago 
| * 9b579ff 2 months ago 
|/  
*   bc3317b 3 months ago  (tag: v3.1.1)
|\  
| * 60542e0 3 months ago 
|/  
* d477beb 3 months ago 
* 4ff8503 3 months ago 
*   c690b4a 3 months ago  (tag: v3.1.0)
|\  
| * deae123 3 months ago 
| * 0497cde 3 months ago 
| * b857c4b 3 months ago 
| * 3aa6867 3 months ago 
| * 511a208 3 months ago 
* | 9401ac2 3 months ago  (tag: v3.0.1)
|/  
*   0550b5f 4 months ago  (tag: v3.0.0)
|\  
| * 3aa5c29 4 months ago 
| * c03078e 4 months ago 
| * 3a6c5e7 5 months ago 
| * 269b0ba 5 months ago 
| * 5f14d42 5 months ago 
| * a9700d0 5 months ago 
|/  
| *   8a68299 3 months ago  (tag: v2.1.1, origin/release/2.0, release/2.0)
| |\  
| | * 4862bb9 3 months ago 
| | * d5c35f8 3 months ago 
| |/  
| *   5d06c44 3 months ago  (tag: v2.1.0)
| |\  
| | * b95e532 3 months ago 
| | * 2bdda47 3 months ago 
| | * 66e249e 3 months ago 
| | * f04640d 3 months ago 
| | * f2ce807 3 months ago 
| | * 0eef500 3 months ago 
| |/  
|/|   
| *   4f4875c 3 months ago  (tag: v2.0.7)
| |\  
|/ /  
| * aeaf683 3 months ago 
|/  
| * d3dbaa6 3 months ago  (origin/ref_tenancy_comments, ref_tenancy_comments)
| | * ac24afc 4 months ago  (origin/ref_tenancy, ref_tenancy)
| |/  
| | * a8da00a 5 months ago  (origin/tenancy_pooling_in_memory_cache, tenancy_pooling_in_memory_cache)
| | * cc2f971 5 months ago  (origin/tenancy_pooling, tenancy_pooling)
| | * 281b1ee 5 months ago 
| |/  
|/|   
* | 68e0eb0 5 months ago  (tag: v2.0.4)
|/  
*   0cad4e2 5 months ago  (tag: v2.0.3)
|\  
| * 498eb3c 5 months ago 
|/  
*   44c10be 5 months ago  (tag: v2.0.2)
|\  
| * 02f0c58 6 months ago 
|/  
*   32fb736 6 months ago 
|\  
| * a4b072d 6 months ago 
|/  
*   4e1a1b1 6 months ago 
|\  
| * 3db0b48 6 months ago 
| * 2192faf 6 months ago 
| * e747e67 6 months ago 
| * ef2757e 6 months ago 
| * f58d270 6 months ago 
| * 4a25a8a 6 months ago 
|/  
* cfd1401 6 months ago  (tag: v2.0.1)
*   2708f61 6 months ago  (tag: v2.0.0)
|\  
| * 9411b8b 6 months ago 
| * 51a6937 6 months ago 
| * 2a32d44 6 months ago 
|/  
| *   960f23f 6 months ago  (origin/release/1.4, release/1.4)
| |\  
| | * 918160b 6 months ago 
| | * 7c6fd73 6 months ago 
| | * 8c25a4c 6 months ago 
| | * e9062cc 6 months ago 
| | * 9a8cf7b 6 months ago 
| | * 71c3b29 6 months ago 
| * |   c1c5bda 6 months ago  (tag: v1.4.1)
| |\ \  
| | |/  
| |/|   
| | * f86c44a 6 months ago 
| | * bf99eb0 6 months ago 
| |/  
|/|   
| * a986db4 6 months ago 
|/  
* e2f6db6 6 months ago  (tag: v1.4.0)
*   d1d05db 6 months ago 
|\  
| * 11b1d4e 6 months ago 
| * da0e497 6 months ago 
| * 0f00fc1 6 months ago 
| * 3e98296 6 months ago 
| * e2936df 6 months ago 
| * 542b14a 6 months ago 
| * b75bbd9 6 months ago 
| * 3347800 6 months ago 
| * 3a43b30 6 months ago 
| * a5278b8 6 months ago 
| * 6fa5161 6 months ago 
| * 27186b8 6 months ago 

INFO [04/23/20 13:33:34:93] Working directory: D:\workspace\v3.1.36560a448
INFO [04/23/20 13:33:34:94] Project root is: D:\workspace\v3.1.36560a448\
INFO [04/23/20 13:33:34:94] DotGit directory is: D:\workspace\v3.1.36560a448\.git
INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:01] Using latest commit on specified branch
INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:01] No branch configuration found for branch v3.1.3, falling back to default configuration
INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:02] Begin: Attempting to inherit branch configuration from parent branch
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:02] HEAD is merge commit, this is likely a pull request using v3.1.3 as base
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:03] Begin: Finding branch source of 'v3.1.3'
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:04] Begin: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'master'.
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:04] Found merge base of 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:04] Merge base of v3.1.3' and 'master is 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:04] End: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'master'. (Took: 5.78ms)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:04] Begin: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'release/1.3'.
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:04] Found merge base of 63ac4df415534b1c707210fc2975ee02688a982c
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:04] Merge base of v3.1.3' and 'release/1.3 is 63ac4df415534b1c707210fc2975ee02688a982c
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:04] End: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'release/1.3'. (Took: 1.17ms)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Begin: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'release/1.4'.
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Found merge base of e2f6db6042205578a56bcc0f1455394b04245e15
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Merge base of v3.1.3' and 'release/1.4 is e2f6db6042205578a56bcc0f1455394b04245e15
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] End: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'release/1.4'. (Took: 0.88ms)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Begin: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'release/2.0'.
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Found merge base of 68e0eb0354d25d7e653f63452c2329c6e3b622b0
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Merge base of v3.1.3' and 'release/2.0 is 68e0eb0354d25d7e653f63452c2329c6e3b622b0
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] End: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'release/2.0'. (Took: 0.40ms)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Begin: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'origin/master'.
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Found merge base of 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Merge base of v3.1.3' and 'origin/master is 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] End: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'origin/master'. (Took: 0.14ms)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Begin: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'origin/release/1.3'.
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Found merge base of 63ac4df415534b1c707210fc2975ee02688a982c
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Merge base of v3.1.3' and 'origin/release/1.3 is 63ac4df415534b1c707210fc2975ee02688a982c
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] End: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'origin/release/1.3'. (Took: 0.20ms)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Begin: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'origin/release/1.4'.
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Found merge base of e2f6db6042205578a56bcc0f1455394b04245e15
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Merge base of v3.1.3' and 'origin/release/1.4 is e2f6db6042205578a56bcc0f1455394b04245e15
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] End: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'origin/release/1.4'. (Took: 0.38ms)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Begin: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'origin/release/2.0'.
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Found merge base of 68e0eb0354d25d7e653f63452c2329c6e3b622b0
      INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Merge base of v3.1.3' and 'origin/release/2.0 is 68e0eb0354d25d7e653f63452c2329c6e3b622b0
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] End: Finding merge base between 'v3.1.3' and 'origin/release/2.0'. (Took: 0.32ms)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Multiple source branches have been found, picking the first one (master).
This may result in incorrect commit counting.
Options were:
master, origin/master, release/2.0, origin/release/2.0, release/1.4, origin/release/1.4, release/1.3, origin/release/1.3
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] End: Finding branch source of 'v3.1.3' (Took: 21.47ms)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Begin: Getting branches containing the commit '517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Trying to find direct branches.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] No direct branches found, searching through all branches.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:05] Searching for commits reachable from 'master'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:06] The branch 'master' has a matching commit.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:06] Searching for commits reachable from 'release/1.3'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:06] The branch 'release/1.3' has no matching commits.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:06] Searching for commits reachable from 'release/1.4'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:06] The branch 'release/1.4' has no matching commits.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:06] Searching for commits reachable from 'release/2.0'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:06] The branch 'release/2.0' has no matching commits.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:06] Searching for commits reachable from 'origin/master'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:07] The branch 'origin/master' has a matching commit.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:07] Searching for commits reachable from 'origin/release/1.3'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:07] The branch 'origin/release/1.3' has no matching commits.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:07] Searching for commits reachable from 'origin/release/1.4'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:07] The branch 'origin/release/1.4' has no matching commits.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:07] Searching for commits reachable from 'origin/release/2.0'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:07] The branch 'origin/release/2.0' has no matching commits.
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:07] End: Getting branches containing the commit '517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c'. (Took: 19.70ms)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:07] Begin: Getting branches containing the commit '517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:07] Trying to find direct branches.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:07] No direct branches found, searching through all branches.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:07] Searching for commits reachable from 'master'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:08] The branch 'master' has a matching commit.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:08] Searching for commits reachable from 'release/1.3'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:08] The branch 'release/1.3' has no matching commits.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:08] Searching for commits reachable from 'release/1.4'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:08] The branch 'release/1.4' has no matching commits.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:08] Searching for commits reachable from 'release/2.0'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:08] The branch 'release/2.0' has no matching commits.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:08] Searching for commits reachable from 'origin/master'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:09] The branch 'origin/master' has a matching commit.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:09] Searching for commits reachable from 'origin/release/1.3'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:09] The branch 'origin/release/1.3' has no matching commits.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:09] Searching for commits reachable from 'origin/release/1.4'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:09] The branch 'origin/release/1.4' has no matching commits.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:09] Searching for commits reachable from 'origin/release/2.0'.
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:09] The branch 'origin/release/2.0' has no matching commits.
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:09] End: Getting branches containing the commit '517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c'. (Took: 20.54ms)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:09] Found possible parent branches: 
  WARN [04/23/20 13:33:35:10] Failed to inherit Increment branch configuration, no branches found.
Falling back to master branch config
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:10] End: Attempting to inherit branch configuration from parent branch (Took: 80.16ms)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:11] Running against branch: v3.1.3 (517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:11] Current commit is tagged with version 3.1.3, version calculation is for metadata only.
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:11] 0 commits found between 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c and 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:12] Begin: Calculating base versions
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:12] Fallback base version: 0.1.0 with commit count source ad24537d17d26abcf1a74abab49ed13fd49551cb (Incremented: None)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:17] Git tag 'v3.1.3': 3.1.3 with commit count source 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c (Incremented: None)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:17] Git tag 'v3.1.2': 3.1.2 with commit count source 33fb5feef4a83c079656dce3eac57b27f93bc39b (Incremented: 3.1.3)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:17] Git tag 'v3.1.1': 3.1.1 with commit count source bc3317b513e3bf7404f4372fbff02d09c9df9b90 (Incremented: 3.1.2)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:17] Git tag 'v3.1.0': 3.1.0 with commit count source c690b4ab979316fee933adcb6a119582d8dc5493 (Incremented: 3.1.1)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:17] Git tag 'v3.0.1': 3.0.1 with commit count source 9401ac26449410431f59f12d45739c71cec5e94a (Incremented: 3.0.2)
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:18] Found multiple base versions which will produce the same SemVer (3.1.3), taking oldest source for commit counting (Git tag 'v3.1.2')
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:18] Base version used: Git tag 'v3.1.2': 3.1.2 with commit count source 33fb5feef4a83c079656dce3eac57b27f93bc39b (Incremented: 3.1.3)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:18] End: Calculating base versions (Took: 61.58ms)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:18] Begin: Using mainline development mode to calculate current version
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:18] Found possible mainline branches: master, release/1.3, origin/release/1.3, release/1.4, origin/release/1.4, release/2.0, origin/release/2.0
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:19] Mainline for current branch is master
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:19] Found branch merge point; choosing 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c as effective mainline tip
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:19] Current branch (v3.1.3) was branch from 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:19] Merge commit dafcd956b32bf155b1b56ca26bdb55a34bdc1349 incremented base versions Patch, now 3.1.3
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:19] Merge commit 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c incremented base versions Patch, now 3.1.4
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:19] 0 commits found between 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c and 517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c
    INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:19] Performing Patch increment for current branch 
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:19] End: Using mainline development mode to calculate current version (Took: 11.71ms)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:19] Using branch name to calculate version tag
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:19] Begin: Getting version tags from branch 'refs/heads/v3.1.3'.
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:20] End: Getting version tags from branch 'refs/heads/v3.1.3'. (Took: 11.70ms)
  INFO [04/23/20 13:33:35:21] Running on Windows.
{
  "Major":3,
  "Minor":1,
  "Patch":5,
  "PreReleaseTag":"v3-1-3.0",
  "PreReleaseTagWithDash":"-v3-1-3.0",
  "PreReleaseLabel":"v3-1-3",
  "PreReleaseNumber":0,
  "WeightedPreReleaseNumber":0,
  "BuildMetaData":"",
  "BuildMetaDataPadded":"",
  "FullBuildMetaData":"Branch.v3.1.3.Sha.517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c",
  "MajorMinorPatch":"3.1.5",
  "SemVer":"3.1.5-v3-1-3.0",
  "LegacySemVer":"3.1.5-v3-1-3-0",
  "LegacySemVerPadded":"3.1.5-v3-1-3-0000",
  "AssemblySemVer":"3.1.5.0",
  "AssemblySemFileVer":"3.1.5.0",
  "FullSemVer":"3.1.5-v3-1-3.0",
  "InformationalVersion":"3.1.5-v3-1-3.0+Branch.v3.1.3.Sha.517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c",
  "BranchName":"v3.1.3",
  "EscapedBranchName":"v3-1-3",
  "Sha":"517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c",
  "ShortSha":"517daf9",
  "NuGetVersionV2":"3.1.5-v3-1-3-0000",
  "NuGetVersion":"3.1.5-v3-1-3-0000",
  "NuGetPreReleaseTagV2":"v3-1-3-0000",
  "NuGetPreReleaseTag":"v3-1-3-0000",
  "VersionSourceSha":"517daf9325182cf5bbf47fc1b23a4af6c590f72c",
  "CommitsSinceVersionSource":0,
  "CommitsSinceVersionSourcePadded":"0000",
  "CommitDate":"2020-04-22"
}

[arturcic]

I think this commit is the cause, at least this is the only one that makes sense 495ba8a

[arturcic]

This is the PR that introduced the change, #1743 @asbjornu

[asbjornu]

Thanks for the investigation, @arturcic. I suppose these are the problematic lines of code?

GitVersion/src/GitVersionCore/VersionCalculation/NextVersionCalculator.cs

Lines 75 to 87 in 5e9c79c

	if (taggedSemanticVersion != null)
	{
	// replace calculated version with tagged version only if tagged version greater or equal to calculated version
	if (semver.CompareTo(taggedSemanticVersion, false) > 0)
	{
	taggedSemanticVersion = null;
	}
	else
	{
	// set the commit count on the tagged ver
	taggedSemanticVersion.BuildMetaData.CommitsSinceVersionSource = semver.BuildMetaData.CommitsSinceVersionSource;
	}
	}

If I'm not mistaken, this is how those lines of code looked before #1743 was merged:

GitVersion/src/GitVersionCore/VersionCalculation/NextVersionCalculator.cs

Lines 66 to 70 in 8219706

	if (taggedSemanticVersion != null)
	{
	// set the commit count on the tagged ver
	taggedSemanticVersion.BuildMetaData.CommitsSinceVersionSource = semver.BuildMetaData.CommitsSinceVersionSource;
	}

In that case, we need to figure out why semver.CompareTo(taggedSemanticVersion, false) returns 1 for certain (but not all, mysteriously) tags.

[arturcic]

yes, would be handy to have some tests to cover that

[asbjornu]

Indeed, that piece of logic right there is a prime candidate for some rigid unit tests.