Refactor update coordinates to better handle multi-coordinate indexes (…

…pydata#8094)

* generic warning implicitly wrap a pd.MultiIndex

* refactor update_coords (assign)

Fix more cases with multi-coordinate indexes:

- do not try to align existing indexed coordinates with the new
coordinates that will fully replace them

- raise early if the new coordinates would corrupt the existing indexed
coordinates

- isolate PandasMultiIndex special cases so that it will be easier to
drop support for it later (and warn now about deprecation)

* fix alignment of updated coordinates

when DataArray objects are passed as new coordinate objects

* refactor Dataset.assign

Need to update (replace) coordinates and data variables separately to
ensure it goes through all (indexed) coordinate update checks.

* fix and update tests

* nit

* fix mypy?

* update what's new

* fix import error

* fix performance regression

* nit

* use warning util func and improve messages

doc/whats-new.rst

@@ -14,7 +14,6 @@ What's New
 
     np.random.seed(123456)
 
-
 .. _whats-new.2023.08.1:
 
 v2023.08.1 (unreleased)
@@ -31,10 +30,19 @@ Breaking changes
 Deprecations
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~
 
+- Deprecate passing a :py:class:`pandas.MultiIndex` object directly to the
+  :py:class:`Dataset` and :py:class:`DataArray` constructors as well as to
+  :py:meth:`Dataset.assign` and :py:meth:`Dataset.assign_coords`.
+  A new Xarray :py:class:`Coordinates` object has to be created first using
+  :py:meth:`Coordinates.from_pandas_multiindex` (:pull:`8094`).
+  By `Benoît Bovy <https://github.com/benbovy>`_.
 
 Bug fixes
 ~~~~~~~~~
 
+- Improved handling of multi-coordinate indexes when updating coordinates, including bug fixes
+  (and improved warnings for deprecated features) for pandas multi-indexes (:pull:`8094`).
+  By `Benoît Bovy <https://github.com/benbovy>`_.
 
 Documentation
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~
@@ -120,7 +128,6 @@ Breaking changes
    numbagg                    0.1    0.2.1
   ===================== =========  ========
 
-
 Documentation
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~
 

xarray/core/coordinates.py

@@ -1,6 +1,5 @@
 from __future__ import annotations
 
-import warnings
 from collections.abc import Hashable, Iterator, Mapping, Sequence
 from contextlib import contextmanager
 from typing import (
@@ -24,7 +23,7 @@
 )
 from xarray.core.merge import merge_coordinates_without_align, merge_coords
 from xarray.core.types import Self, T_DataArray
-from xarray.core.utils import Frozen, ReprObject
+from xarray.core.utils import Frozen, ReprObject, emit_user_level_warning
 from xarray.core.variable import Variable, as_variable, calculate_dimensions
 
 if TYPE_CHECKING:
@@ -83,7 +82,7 @@ def variables(self):
     def _update_coords(self, coords, indexes):
         raise NotImplementedError()
 
-    def _maybe_drop_multiindex_coords(self, coords):
+    def _drop_coords(self, coord_names):
         raise NotImplementedError()
 
     def __iter__(self) -> Iterator[Hashable]:
@@ -379,9 +378,9 @@ def _update_coords(
         # redirect to DatasetCoordinates._update_coords
         self._data.coords._update_coords(coords, indexes)
 
-    def _maybe_drop_multiindex_coords(self, coords: set[Hashable]) -> None:
-        # redirect to DatasetCoordinates._maybe_drop_multiindex_coords
-        self._data.coords._maybe_drop_multiindex_coords(coords)
+    def _drop_coords(self, coord_names):
+        # redirect to DatasetCoordinates._drop_coords
+        self._data.coords._drop_coords(coord_names)
 
     def _merge_raw(self, other, reflexive):
         """For use with binary arithmetic."""
@@ -454,22 +453,40 @@ def __setitem__(self, key: Hashable, value: Any) -> None:
 
     def update(self, other: Mapping[Any, Any]) -> None:
         """Update this Coordinates variables with other coordinate variables."""
-        other_obj: Coordinates | Mapping[Hashable, Variable]
+
+        if not len(other):
+            return
+
+        other_coords: Coordinates
 
         if isinstance(other, Coordinates):
-            # special case: default indexes won't be created
-            other_obj = other
+            # Coordinates object: just pass it (default indexes won't be created)
+            other_coords = other
         else:
-            other_obj = getattr(other, "variables", other)
+            other_coords = create_coords_with_default_indexes(
+                getattr(other, "variables", other)
+            )
 
-        self._maybe_drop_multiindex_coords(set(other_obj))
+        # Discard original indexed coordinates prior to merge allows to:
+        # - fail early if the new coordinates don't preserve the integrity of existing
+        #   multi-coordinate indexes
+        # - drop & replace coordinates without alignment (note: we must keep indexed
+        #   coordinates extracted from the DataArray objects passed as values to
+        #   `other` - if any - as those are still used for aligning the old/new coordinates)
+        coords_to_align = drop_indexed_coords(set(other_coords) & set(other), self)
 
         coords, indexes = merge_coords(
-            [self.variables, other_obj],
+            [coords_to_align, other_coords],
             priority_arg=1,
-            indexes=self.xindexes,
+            indexes=coords_to_align.xindexes,
         )
 
+        # special case for PandasMultiIndex: updating only its dimension coordinate
+        # is still allowed but depreciated.
+        # It is the only case where we need to actually drop coordinates here (multi-index levels)
+        # TODO: remove when removing PandasMultiIndex's dimension coordinate.
+        self._drop_coords(self._names - coords_to_align._names)
+
         self._update_coords(coords, indexes)
 
     def _overwrite_indexes(
@@ -610,15 +627,20 @@ def _update_coords(
         original_indexes.update(indexes)
         self._data._indexes = original_indexes
 
-    def _maybe_drop_multiindex_coords(self, coords: set[Hashable]) -> None:
-        """Drops variables in coords, and any associated variables as well."""
+    def _drop_coords(self, coord_names):
+        # should drop indexed coordinates only
+        for name in coord_names:
+            del self._data._variables[name]
+            del self._data._indexes[name]
+        self._data._coord_names.difference_update(coord_names)
+
+    def _drop_indexed_coords(self, coords_to_drop: set[Hashable]) -> None:
         assert self._data.xindexes is not None
-        variables, indexes = drop_coords(
-            coords, self._data._variables, self._data.xindexes
-        )
-        self._data._coord_names.intersection_update(variables)
-        self._data._variables = variables
-        self._data._indexes = indexes
+        new_coords = drop_indexed_coords(coords_to_drop, self)
+        for name in self._data._coord_names - new_coords._names:
+            del self._data._variables[name]
+        self._data._indexes = dict(new_coords.xindexes)
+        self._data._coord_names.intersection_update(new_coords._names)
 
     def __delitem__(self, key: Hashable) -> None:
         if key in self:
@@ -691,13 +713,11 @@ def _update_coords(
         original_indexes.update(indexes)
         self._data._indexes = original_indexes
 
-    def _maybe_drop_multiindex_coords(self, coords: set[Hashable]) -> None:
-        """Drops variables in coords, and any associated variables as well."""
-        variables, indexes = drop_coords(
-            coords, self._data._coords, self._data.xindexes
-        )
-        self._data._coords = variables
-        self._data._indexes = indexes
+    def _drop_coords(self, coord_names):
+        # should drop indexed coordinates only
+        for name in coord_names:
+            del self._data._coords[name]
+            del self._data._indexes[name]
 
     @property
     def variables(self):
@@ -724,35 +744,48 @@ def _ipython_key_completions_(self):
         return self._data._ipython_key_completions_()
 
 
-def drop_coords(
-    coords_to_drop: set[Hashable], variables, indexes: Indexes
-) -> tuple[dict, dict]:
-    """Drop index variables associated with variables in coords_to_drop."""
-    # Only warn when we're dropping the dimension with the multi-indexed coordinate
-    # If asked to drop a subset of the levels in a multi-index, we raise an error
-    # later but skip the warning here.
-    new_variables = dict(variables.copy())
-    new_indexes = dict(indexes.copy())
-    for key in coords_to_drop & set(indexes):
-        maybe_midx = indexes[key]
-        idx_coord_names = set(indexes.get_all_coords(key))
-        if (
-            isinstance(maybe_midx, PandasMultiIndex)
-            and key == maybe_midx.dim
-            and (idx_coord_names - coords_to_drop)
-        ):
-            warnings.warn(
-                f"Updating MultiIndexed coordinate {key!r} would corrupt indices for "
-                f"other variables: {list(maybe_midx.index.names)!r}. "
-                f"This will raise an error in the future. Use `.drop_vars({idx_coord_names!r})` before "
+def drop_indexed_coords(
+    coords_to_drop: set[Hashable], coords: Coordinates
+) -> Coordinates:
+    """Drop indexed coordinates associated with coordinates in coords_to_drop.
+
+    This will raise an error in case it corrupts any passed index and its
+    coordinate variables.
+
+    """
+    new_variables = dict(coords.variables)
+    new_indexes = dict(coords.xindexes)
+
+    for idx, idx_coords in coords.xindexes.group_by_index():
+        idx_drop_coords = set(idx_coords) & coords_to_drop
+
+        # special case for pandas multi-index: still allow but deprecate
+        # dropping only its dimension coordinate.
+        # TODO: remove when removing PandasMultiIndex's dimension coordinate.
+        if isinstance(idx, PandasMultiIndex) and idx_drop_coords == {idx.dim}:
+            idx_drop_coords.update(idx.index.names)
+            emit_user_level_warning(
+                f"updating coordinate {idx.dim!r} with a PandasMultiIndex would leave "
+                f"the multi-index level coordinates {list(idx.index.names)!r} in an inconsistent state. "
+                f"This will raise an error in the future. Use `.drop_vars({list(idx_coords)!r})` before "
                 "assigning new coordinate values.",
                 FutureWarning,
-                stacklevel=4,
             )
-            for k in idx_coord_names:
-                del new_variables[k]
-                del new_indexes[k]
-    return new_variables, new_indexes
+
+        elif idx_drop_coords and len(idx_drop_coords) != len(idx_coords):
+            idx_drop_coords_str = ", ".join(f"{k!r}" for k in idx_drop_coords)
+            idx_coords_str = ", ".join(f"{k!r}" for k in idx_coords)
+            raise ValueError(
+                f"cannot drop or update coordinate(s) {idx_drop_coords_str}, which would corrupt "
+                f"the following index built from coordinates {idx_coords_str}:\n"
+                f"{idx}"
+            )
+
+        for k in idx_drop_coords:
+            del new_variables[k]
+            del new_indexes[k]
+
+    return Coordinates._construct_direct(coords=new_variables, indexes=new_indexes)
 
 
 def assert_coordinate_consistent(
@@ -773,11 +806,15 @@ def assert_coordinate_consistent(
 
 
 def create_coords_with_default_indexes(
-    coords: Mapping[Any, Any], data_vars: Mapping[Any, Variable] | None = None
+    coords: Mapping[Any, Any], data_vars: Mapping[Any, Any] | None = None
 ) -> Coordinates:
-    """Maybe create default indexes from a mapping of coordinates."""
+    """Returns a Coordinates object from a mapping of coordinates (arbitrary objects).
+
+    Create default (pandas) indexes for each of the input dimension coordinates.
+    Extract coordinates from each input DataArray.
 
-    # Note: data_vars are needed here only because a pd.MultiIndex object
+    """
+    # Note: data_vars is needed here only because a pd.MultiIndex object
     # can be promoted as coordinates.
     # TODO: It won't be relevant anymore when this behavior will be dropped
     # in favor of the more explicit ``Coordinates.from_pandas_multiindex()``.
@@ -791,34 +828,34 @@ def create_coords_with_default_indexes(
     indexes: dict[Hashable, Index] = {}
     variables: dict[Hashable, Variable] = {}
 
-    maybe_index_vars: dict[Hashable, Variable] = {}
-    mindex_data_vars: list[Hashable] = []
+    # promote any pandas multi-index in data_vars as coordinates
+    coords_promoted: dict[Hashable, Any] = {}
+    pd_mindex_keys: list[Hashable] = []
 
     for k, v in all_variables.items():
-        if k in coords:
-            maybe_index_vars[k] = v
-        elif isinstance(v, pd.MultiIndex):
-            # TODO: eventually stop promoting multi-index passed via data variables
-            mindex_data_vars.append(k)
-            maybe_index_vars[k] = v
-
-    if mindex_data_vars:
-        warnings.warn(
-            f"passing one or more `pandas.MultiIndex` via data variable(s) {mindex_data_vars} "
-            "will no longer create indexed coordinates in the future. "
-            "If you want to keep this behavior, pass it as coordinates instead.",
+        if isinstance(v, pd.MultiIndex):
+            coords_promoted[k] = v
+            pd_mindex_keys.append(k)
+        elif k in coords:
+            coords_promoted[k] = v
+
+    if pd_mindex_keys:
+        pd_mindex_keys_fmt = ",".join([f"'{k}'" for k in pd_mindex_keys])
+        emit_user_level_warning(
+            f"the `pandas.MultiIndex` object(s) passed as {pd_mindex_keys_fmt} coordinate(s) or "
+            "data variable(s) will no longer be implicitly promoted and wrapped into "
+            "multiple indexed coordinates in the future "
+            "(i.e., one coordinate for each multi-index level + one dimension coordinate). "
+            "If you want to keep this behavior, you need to first wrap it explicitly using "
+            "`mindex_coords = xarray.Coordinates.from_pandas_multiindex(mindex_obj, 'dim')` "
+            "and pass it as coordinates, e.g., `xarray.Dataset(coords=mindex_coords)`, "
+            "`dataset.assign_coords(mindex_coords)` or `dataarray.assign_coords(mindex_coords)`.",
             FutureWarning,
         )
 
-    maybe_index_vars = {
-        k: v
-        for k, v in all_variables.items()
-        if k in coords or isinstance(v, pd.MultiIndex)
-    }
-
     dataarray_coords: list[DataArrayCoordinates] = []
 
-    for name, obj in maybe_index_vars.items():
+    for name, obj in coords_promoted.items():
         if isinstance(obj, DataArray):
             dataarray_coords.append(obj.coords)
 

xarray/core/dataset.py

@@ -120,7 +120,7 @@
     from xarray.backends.api import T_NetcdfEngine, T_NetcdfTypes
     from xarray.core.dataarray import DataArray
     from xarray.core.groupby import DatasetGroupBy
-    from xarray.core.merge import CoercibleMapping
+    from xarray.core.merge import CoercibleMapping, CoercibleValue
     from xarray.core.parallelcompat import ChunkManagerEntrypoint
     from xarray.core.resample import DatasetResample
     from xarray.core.rolling import DatasetCoarsen, DatasetRolling
@@ -6879,6 +6879,10 @@ def assign(
         possible, but you cannot reference other variables created within the
         same ``assign`` call.
 
+        The new assigned variables that replace existing coordinates in the
+        original dataset are still listed as coordinates in the returned
+        Dataset.
+
         See Also
         --------
         pandas.DataFrame.assign
@@ -6934,11 +6938,23 @@ def assign(
         """
         variables = either_dict_or_kwargs(variables, variables_kwargs, "assign")
         data = self.copy()
+
         # do all calculations first...
         results: CoercibleMapping = data._calc_assign_results(variables)
-        data.coords._maybe_drop_multiindex_coords(set(results.keys()))
+
+        # split data variables to add/replace vs. coordinates to replace
+        results_data_vars: dict[Hashable, CoercibleValue] = {}
+        results_coords: dict[Hashable, CoercibleValue] = {}
+        for k, v in results.items():
+            if k in data._coord_names:
+                results_coords[k] = v
+            else:
+                results_data_vars[k] = v
+
         # ... and then assign
-        data.update(results)
+        data.coords.update(results_coords)
+        data.update(results_data_vars)
+
         return data
 
     def to_array(