Skip to content

Incorrect calculation for 100% damage taken from blocked hits #8704

@moxaj

Description

@moxaj

Check version

  • I'm running the latest version of Path of Building and I've verified this by checking the changelog

Check for duplicates

  • I've checked for duplicate open and closed issues by using the search function of the issue tracker

Check for support

  • I've checked that the calculation is supposed to be supported. If it isn't please open a feature request instead (Red text is a feature request).

What platform are you running Path of Building on?

Windows

What is the value from the calculation in-game?

I haven't checked ingame (it might not even be possible), but I would expect that 100% damage taken from blocked hits would mean your EHP doesn't increase from block itself.

What is the value from the calculation in Path of Building?

In pob, the calculation works up until 99%, and is broken at 100% (see reproduction steps).

How to reproduce the issue

Add these into your configuration tab:

+100% maximum chance to block attack damage
+100% chance to block attack damage
+100% maximum chance to block spell damage
+100% chance to block spell damage
You take 95% of Damage from Blocked Hits

For me the default EHP is 827, with these above it becomes 866 - that is expected, 90% of the time we are blocking 5% of the damage from hits.

Now increase the 95% value. The EHP becomes less and less, however at 100% it seems to behave as if it was at 0% (that is, just normal block without this stat). You can verify this by simply removing the You take 100% of Damage from Blocked Hits line and observing how the EHP doesn't change.

PoB for PoE1 build code

eNqtW19z2roSf24_hYeZ-3Sn4W8IPUN6hoSkyUzScCFtz3nqCFuATmSJseUknE9_V5JtDEVGwu5Dalv7W-2utKvdtRn--R5S7xVHMeHsstE-azU8zHweELa8bHx_vv00aPz55eNwgsTqaXGVECpHvnz8MFTXHsWvmAKuBTiBoiUWPzJe3V_wbI2YWGHOHtE_PPrKg8vGN85ww5sjFhCR3fkUxfE3FOLLxswHcMNDsY9ZcL19nhKuUIR8gaMHOe8oEfyRBzC6QDSG4RARNuP-CxZfI56sQa6G90rwmya6f5w8TZ8LMhFWlAmU-jCcULTB0Uwg4cXw57IxAtugJR6jEP4CN0QTYNU6azeapYCrJIqFPWq2xjjICdtnHRPhJMI3iwX2BXnF1xER1yvE_MIUJpwr7WNCBVlTgqOCVOcmxN1vzDtG2mcuEB1PZkWzdMqJuTgu9E8iVlcUrGjLWgLul4wI7IKYcBJz5ir-Dr3R7Aml4FxWtFMc4-gVCbIni5E3D-eE2RvnETF0zWMLu0vKCY7AXYUTYIZ9Dh7uOocj8oEssD2lkx4pwFWa0_S4mdnSOTM-TaApBDY7yhlPqCWl2AabjpFqjN8tqO6ZsOL1yoU6cI7Jpjz55m6SUw46F92z7qB10W71O31zvF5tYuIj-ojeSZiEECif0QveTtju9Abm7bJcCQYhwQS-6PdN2FsS4RNg15wGp8BWiMdG3KDEsQm7g1Rg5PsJHOyb7ZJ1B2VOZGU-OFP9PyT1PfPtfPM7i1RcLR7FpeuzwFPwGXnizym2xmynSX1vi2y1yidbYpbOuLFT6QFjf_UVzDxFAttF2pyq3-uV2lYSW9lWEh6wbQn_XYSDmSTwsJna7bNuGcrRUjcMR8vNbEUwDdyoM8mu0doiJkpDF9FWBt-dzmnTFKGOJvmJosDu5HCV6RXFxSjd7pebS5PbbU0MOSMAAmybHU8i_o_Mv6kbbBSFPIksF1wTWymQHTC61pjiIPHtTrS8jLiiUDLtqfH5OAwEpdQNOxIC-S9jHiytzaZmcULsCjhL1msII3I_2DKQRyfk16SQsnzqW1A_wWa28ml5yNpPsKW2niBPHOxn2YPY6yJPfgdltuTWU-QL-gjhIoRzQBXLUNNv44FxcaCksqqPFKFlnTbhbyD5SnY7YjdqyJBygPEsuo0w-3djzX-H3GqCGxZAsgWuYD3HPuLQNM8khFAax2MkkBekefUPFBHEREd1YmKMIn_1AEt_iyidQyS4bBSfyrs9YDtb22FT9Zvk1X245pHw8Lv8b4Iiscn6P4pQPQE-sSBM1ccQdihteLMVfxsFr1KLZ85pnDeN0HqNWbDD4znC2ENZEPGlEEpHeeOFKBZwauldGUuhC82q-0Ca0WMcBLhsnA8G3a5UUdZVKNqMdgkZAbkEzFXomXX6aTtMc5LTfhh-nz6oiw8rIdbxH83m29vb2RqJFV_gdziIznweNtcAAoE_xS-E0k-SbXME_66WI_VPMWpmnIa6TRY39Z30xYiAzHotm1JRZXVpCXnxjQscyzH5MLsZzuRUsRfDQnzFYXy1Af-5lYnDXsMhNaWknmGhN0MRc9kQUYLl6i9QQuXz_yWIErmynW7x8YNuNzIehXlJBbxgaWWc1yyfN2tp-9HDgx4ZUZFyk_Nl66zXM5XII8F2o2ml5OU1or5SenjP1onwmOpEhiT2f82TxUJ2FWEKEale6c3t7c318_2Pm9QfihC1JL9YEs5lO03_v41aM6xObC9O5rG-vGz8IPhNCTLGAhEKPupzStE6xvlOVUKnGlDAlXBTVFCXZf3Iw7y2BGZON-84AsdaQqrnRwQb5crHjwilJ5RpoIwfJm6yAWhmpLOKa3BLnaYaLKU6rGYusulpVEcOlmAhJCFqnDkdPWIJIbctuB1ZEF-G3vIll5tcU5XYJS-qjeudpkRmHqqjamKgB81g3Ss1odPREquq5qzRqnrUDB9jHxl114NmcF75cAZmMnHJqUo4feNMbXJwmhGhMn0xruwNxTmJmeGTWOEoPX1MnB4hRmUkpY4TkXkizG5coCixlWrIGCwkx8xQ3W4w6CDHSiLRTv1tMGiRxsxK163GQFYG1ams0X5pYlyyBGlVaDC_Hi0xQlYYG_RPh0ucRMXf0SsngS6ODO6yR1YWMCCxqM5GVXzV2eyXgNU53kJu9mJc73TUDP8uiMxEDnDRGZAVE-lU1ThI36rG4ZkwXyQRPpnBdD8T2WKn5TlIXrYcBGejZZEjrWZO5qBrrpPhqiQ8Ga3i_xgvMGhQegDkNCX-IRI2BmOIEt-wZKXEOhxItto58dJH4UFNnTlqB0_fS5TFAE1yhBGc5Xcl2aIdp7ytcYcRlS-WOa3G8Lf3L1WYyeZsskYsyNg9HcrRt-tgaT0uYuCpavmx7AFXtSHD4eYAI7Ncw2ZW1akqX9ZZaQtiJiJZzP_Lefi3KuLlVVpwdtMiEzLuMYF1i9R-y-aRhH9l7ZPhvYAyMy155XVe8ZoZJDHW715_YrTmTCFkc0AXkpqHkSgtXtOynnKoZgExmUOpL_XRFehXCjUW2EgO6c5CsxygJ_HaDpArDqvrjeabOEbU0w0G79yFAaZiH99xwKszx-ueoKU3e0Pr_al7pzCqoH7Ko1MDj8MK9WtQqF-DQifxOKRQ5d3ZrcEinbq0cdlvdxgOR1HJHgecrV9Zgo4zh8pTduuy_3kNm6Fdg3u0a5Cj57gT6goxnaoe2avBgO5nRm0htltV_05FF3YTINh4usdQZQ_q3KIKh8OOfV6ZQ7-uZW3XFWPct2Z1O_Yqr-V5PZvKRflRmFAsaoiE3RoCSreiU_Yq4tv12P_kk9J50_acEadkURWtel41Vte0LL26gkttefXJJZQDbkrY0mkJD4emTj1rUNtJUUfB1ztNJ1fjVz_ja0o2zisLUv2I67sGg6rB4_cJh8201aPaVKqNpL5C4GxBlmlDSd-kLSUFyp_s9IGKXx_4SSx4-MiDePu1wn_brdZ_vFB3DOXPqpiPPcG9uXx94yH1Rt0LVO_so6a1oTHxi-VrmHJ2OyQfMotOKPLxitMAR6kyWHb80l9LZR9SXLRaRwA7X6llsO4xVP5NXPbdRIbsdHrtYzMWfm-Vwc6PYIofHuaYo6rBkxPkk3OdAFP90C1i0DPTh_kvyOTvpnCEg5n6ToMnTMwwXRQ-hDm30NHZMPnqTWQvPF90W5T7Qsg9tm_Swef-EVj-Cje3Rqvd61oYxEktuR33ZSvb_zOfq5Y4LFj82xdLxlnSb5A5pVPEilNdHDNedoJlgH778-CzGROTJaFPC_UiDYRUbwNthdz9YNrZaWzNPltBWDMYcNjMo7Z-JaHuvnwcNvd_Z_t_ETIRaQ==

Screenshots

No response

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions