Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Every of GTPs for zen7 doesn't play in new sabaki! #643

Closed
ak47ak50 opened this issue Mar 12, 2020 · 11 comments
Closed

Every of GTPs for zen7 doesn't play in new sabaki! #643

ak47ak50 opened this issue Mar 12, 2020 · 11 comments
Labels
engines more info needed

Comments

@ak47ak50
Copy link

In 0.43,I have many GTPs for Zen7 can play normally. But in new 0.5, every of GTPs can't run. Does GTP in Sabaki 0.5 changed?
@yishn
Copy link
Member

yishn commented Mar 12, 2020

No. What is the error message?

@ak47ak50
Copy link
Author

ak47ak50 commented Mar 13, 2020 •
edited by yishn
Loading

  1. Load correct.
ZenGTP> name 
= Zen7
ZenGTP> version 
= 0.4
ZenGTP> protocol_version 
= 2
ZenGTP> list_commands 
= name
version
quit
known_command
list_commands
quit
boardsize
clear_board
komi
play
genmove
showboard
undo
pass
genmove
protocol_version
strength
maxtime
rotate
zen-analyze
loadsgf
printsgf
savesgf
time_settings
lz-analyze
time_left
set_free_handicap
final_score
analyze
go
auto
policy
territory
gogui-analyze_commands
sabaki-genmovelog
sabaki-flat

Starting Zen7...

E:\zen7GTP/Zen.dll load ok

Zen Initialize ok(59113473)

Threads:   4

BoardSize: 19

Komi:      7.5

Resign:    10.0%

Strength:  1000000 (counts, NN eval)

MaxSim:    1000000000 (playouts, MCTS search)

MaxTime:   30.0

PnLevel:   3

PnWeight:  1.00

VnMixRate: 0.75

ThinkInterval:    0.10

PrintInterval:  300.00

  1. But when genmove, it passed(see in Game Tree panel).
    ???
    pass

@ak47ak50
Copy link
Author

3.Do I send the GTP to you?

@yishn
Copy link
Member

yishn commented Mar 13, 2020 •
edited
Loading

Looking at the screenshot, it seems the engine is sending an empty response when asked for genmove B.

Can you please activate GTP logging in 'Preferences' > 'Engines', do this again, and send me the generated log file of GTP commands?

@jun63cn
Copy link

jun63cn commented Mar 13, 2020 •
edited by yishn
Loading 

[2020-03-13 20:52:18.379]     (in) : name
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.384]     (in) : version
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.386]     (in) : protocol_version
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.387]     (in) : list_commands
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.388]   (meta) : Engine Started
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.425]    (err) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.425]    (err) : Starting Zen7...
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.442]    (err) : F:\Ѹ������\Zen�ر��\zen7/Zen.dll load ok
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.631]    (err) : Zen Initialize ok(42582017)
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.632]    (err) : Threads:   6
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.632]    (err) : BoardSize: 19
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.632]    (err) : Komi:      7.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.633]    (err) : Resign:    10.0%
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.633]    (err) : Strength:  10000 (counts, NN eval)
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.633]    (err) : MaxSim:    1000000000 (playouts, MCTS search)
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.634]    (err) : MaxTime:   1000000000.0
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.634]    (err) : PnLevel:   3
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.634]    (err) : PnWeight:  1.00
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.635]    (err) : VnMixRate: 0.75
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.635]    (err) : ThinkInterval:    0.10
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.635]    (err) : PrintInterval:  300.00
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.635]    (err) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.648]    (out) : = Zen7
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.648]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.649]    (out) : = 0.4
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.649]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.649]    (out) : = 2
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.650]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.650]    (out) : = name
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.650]    (out) : version
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.651]    (out) : quit
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.651]    (out) : known_command
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.651]    (out) : list_commands
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.651]    (out) : quit
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.652]    (out) : boardsize
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.652]    (out) : clear_board
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.652]    (out) : komi
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.652]    (out) : play
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.652]    (out) : genmove
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.652]    (out) : showboard
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.653]    (out) : undo
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.653]    (out) : pass
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.653]    (out) : genmove
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.653]    (out) : protocol_version
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.654]    (out) : strength
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.654]    (out) : maxtime
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.654]    (out) : rotate
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.654]    (out) : zen-analyze
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.654]    (out) : loadsgf
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.654]    (out) : printsgf
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.655]    (out) : savesgf
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.655]    (out) : time_settings
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.655]    (out) : lz-analyze
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.655]    (out) : time_left
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.655]    (out) : set_free_handicap
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.655]    (out) : final_score
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : analyze
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : go
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : auto
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : policy
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : territory
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : gogui-analyze_commands
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : sabaki-genmovelog
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.657]    (out) : sabaki-flat
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.657]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.048]     (in) : komi 6.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.069]    (out) : = 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.070]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.089]     (in) : boardsize 19
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.108]    (err) : Komi: 7.5 -> 6.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.109]    (err) : BoardSize: 19 -> 19
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.109]    (out) : = 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.110]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.120]     (in) : clear_board
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.135]    (out) : = 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.135]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.144]     (in) : genmove B
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.159]    (out) : = 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.160]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.198]    (err) : * genmove for black...
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.199]    (err) :    Synchronize -> 1 (0.00s)
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.285]    (err) :    Sequence:   Q16 D16 R4 D3 C5 P3 M4 R10 Q3 R13 
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.286]    (err) :    Winning:    48.9%
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.286]    (err) :    Count:      1606
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.286]    (err) :    Playout:    1905
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.286]    (err) :    Time:       5.12s
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.286]    (err) :    Games/s:    371.78
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.286]    (err) :    Nodes:      12810
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.299]    (err) :    Synchronize -> 12810 (0.01s)
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.358]    (err) : Zen7-0.4 B No.   1 5.2s Q16 1606 48.87% Stop by Zen
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.359]    (err) : Q16  ->     1606, 48.87%, Q16 D16 R4 D3 C5 P3 M4 R10 Q3 R13 
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.360]    (err) : R16  ->      264, 49.97%, R16 D16 Q3 D4 F17 C14
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.361]    (err) : K16  ->        5, 21.22%, K16
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.362]    (err) : level result(terr,area)
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.580]    (err) :     0   92.5   93.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.587]    (err) :   100  -14.5  -13.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.588]    (err) :   200   -4.5   -3.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.588]    (err) :   300   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.589]    (err) :   400   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.589]    (err) :   500   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.589]    (err) :   600   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.590]    (err) :   700   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.590]    (err) :   800   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.590]    (err) :   900   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.591]    (err) : W+5.5
[2020-03-13 20:53:23.423]     (in) : quit
[2020-03-13 20:53:23.477]   (meta) : Connection Failed
[2020-03-13 20:53:23.491]   (meta) : Engine Stopped

@yishn
Copy link
Member

yishn commented Mar 13, 2020

Seems like Zen is sending a wrong response at genmove B. Can you try executing your engine on the command line and sending genmove B to see what happens?

@jun63cn
Copy link

jun63cn commented Mar 13, 2020 •
edited by yishn
Loading 

Microsoft Windows [版本 6.1.7601]
版权所有 (c) 2009 Microsoft Corporation。保留所有权利。

C:\Users\Administrator>d:

D:\>cd zen7

D:\zen7>zengtp

Starting Zen7...
D:\zen7/Zen.dll load ok
Zen Initialize ok(41992193)
Threads:   4
BoardSize: 19
Komi:      7.5
Resign:    10.0%
Strength:  10000 (counts, NN eval)
MaxSim:    1000000000 (playouts, MCTS search)
MaxTime:   1000000000.0
PnLevel:   3
PnWeight:  1.00
VnMixRate: 0.75
ThinkInterval:    0.10
PrintInterval:  300.00

genmove b
* genmove for black...
   Synchronize -> 1 (0.00s)
   Sequence:   Q16 D16 R4 D3 C5 P3 M4 P6 Q3 P4
   Winning:    47.9%
   Count:      1421
   Playout:    1803
   Time:       5.34s
   Games/s:    337.325
   Nodes:      11363
   Synchronize -> 11363 (0.05s)
Zen7-0.4 B No.   1 5.5s Q16 1421 47.89% Stop by Zen
Q16  ->     1421, 47.89%, Q16 D16 R4 D3 C5 P3 M4 P6 Q3 P4
R16  ->      352, 48.34%, R16 D16 Q3 D4 F17
level result(terr,area)
    0   91.5   92.5
  100  -15.5  -14.5
  200   -5.5   -4.5
  300   -7.5   -6.5
  400   -7.5   -6.5
  500   -7.5   -6.5
  600   -7.5   -6.5
  700   -7.5   -6.5
  800   -7.5   -6.5
  900   -7.5   -6.5
W+6.5
= Q16

@yishn
Copy link
Member

yishn commented Mar 13, 2020

For completion's sake, please send all commands to the engine that Sabaki is sending.

@rooklift
Copy link
Contributor

Just in case, can you also check any difference between genmove b and genmove B

yishn added a commit that referenced this issue Mar 13, 2020
@yishn
Update to @sabaki/gtp v3
fd86c2c 
#643
@yishn
Copy link
Member

yishn commented Mar 13, 2020

I had a hunch what might be the problem here, so I pushed a potential fix. Can you please try to build Sabaki from master and see if you still experience the issue?

@jun63cn
Copy link

jun63cn commented Mar 13, 2020

It's works well now . Thanks You!
UPYY`QNU~X}1ZUJS{7 4U@E

@yishn yishn closed this as completed Mar 13, 2020
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
engines more info needed
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
4 participants
@yishn @rooklift @jun63cn @ak47ak50