Remove unused images from entity specification

[jbutcher21]

Summary

• Remove 5 unreferenced image files from senzing/reference/images/
• These were left over from an earlier version of the entity spec that used embedded images
• The spec was rewritten to use text and tables; no file in the repo references these images

Closes #39

Test plan

• Confirmed no references to ges-image anywhere in the repo

---

Resolves #39

[github-actions]

🤖 Claude Code Review

Code Review Analysis

Overview

This pull request removes unused image files from the entity specification reference documentation. All files are binary images being deleted from senzing/reference/images/.

Review Results

Code Quality

✅ Code follows style guide - N/A for binary file deletion
✅ No commented-out code - N/A for binary file deletion
✅ Meaningful variable names - N/A for binary file deletion
✅ DRY principle followed - N/A for binary file deletion
✅ Identify Defects - No defects introduced. This is a cleanup operation removing unused assets.
✅ Project memory compliance - The .claude/CLAUDE.md file contains project-level instructions only, no local environment specifics. This change aligns with maintaining a clean reference directory structure.

Testing

✅ Unit tests for new functions - N/A, no functional code changes
✅ Integration tests for new endpoints - N/A, no functional code changes
✅ Edge cases covered - N/A, no functional code changes
✅ Test coverage > 80% - N/A, no functional code changes

Documentation

⚠️ Readme updated if needed - Should verify that no documentation references these deleted images:

• senzing/reference/images/ges-image-invalid_json.jpg
• senzing/reference/images/ges-image1-key_terms.jpg
• senzing/reference/images/ges-image2-flat_json.jpg
• senzing/reference/images/ges-image3-relationship.jpg
• senzing/reference/images/ges-image3-relationship.png

Action Required: Search for references to these images in:

• senzing/reference/senzing_entity_specification.md
• Other markdown files in the repository
• README.md files

✅ API docs updated - N/A for image deletion
✅ Inline comments for complex logic - N/A for image deletion
❌ CHANGELOG.md updated - If this project maintains a CHANGELOG.md, this removal should be documented
✅ Markdown formatting - N/A, no markdown files modified

Security

✅ No hardcoded credentials - N/A for image deletion
✅ Input validation implemented - N/A for image deletion
✅ Proper error handling - N/A for image deletion
✅ No sensitive data in logs - N/A for image deletion
✅ No license files (.lic) or license strings - Confirmed, only image files being removed

Summary

This is a straightforward cleanup PR removing unused binary image assets. The change is safe, but requires verification:

1. Critical: Ensure no markdown files reference these deleted images (broken image links would result)
2. Recommended: Update CHANGELOG.md if the project maintains one
3. Note: The duplicate file (ges-image3-relationship exists as both .jpg and .png) suggests previous cleanup work

Recommendation: ✅ Approve pending verification that no documentation references these images.

Automated code review analyzing defects and coding standards

[github-actions]

🤖 Claude Code Review

Code Review - PR Analysis

Code Quality

✅ Code follows style guide

• Status: PASS
• Analysis: This PR only modifies CHANGELOG.md (a documentation file) and removes binary image files. No source code changes to evaluate against coding standards.

✅ No commented-out code

• Status: PASS
• Analysis: The CHANGELOG.md changes contain no commented-out code. Only documentation updates.

✅ Meaningful variable names

• Status: N/A
• Analysis: No code changes with variables to evaluate.

✅ DRY principle followed

• Status: N/A
• Analysis: No code changes to evaluate for code duplication.

✅ Identify Defects

• Status: PASS
• Analysis: No logic, code, or functional changes that could introduce bugs. This is purely a documentation and asset cleanup PR.

✅ Project memory (./.claude/CLAUDE.md) considerations

• Status: PASS
• Analysis: The CHANGELOG.md at CHANGELOG.md:1-22 correctly follows Keep a Changelog format and CommonMark specification. The changes align with the project's documented architecture updates (entity specification consolidation, tools reference improvements).

Testing

✅ Unit tests for new functions

• Status: N/A
• Analysis: No new functions added.

✅ Integration tests for new endpoints

• Status: N/A
• Analysis: No new endpoints added.

✅ Edge cases covered

• Status: N/A
• Analysis: No code logic changes requiring edge case testing.

✅ Test coverage > 80%

• Status: N/A
• Analysis: No code changes affecting test coverage.

Documentation

✅ Readme updated if needed

• Status: PASS (mentioned in changelog)
• Analysis: CHANGELOG.md:16 mentions "README: restructured with Getting Started, Environment Setup, and tool-agnostic context loading for AI IDEs" - the README changes are documented but not shown in this diff.

✅ API docs updated

• Status: N/A
• Analysis: No API changes in this PR.

✅ Inline comments for complex logic

• Status: N/A
• Analysis: No code changes requiring inline comments.

✅ CHANGELOG.md updated

• Status: PASS
• Analysis: CHANGELOG.md:10-17 properly documents the changes under the "Changed" section with detailed bullet points covering all updates.

✅ Markdown files follow CommonMark specification

• Status: PASS
• Analysis: CHANGELOG.md:1-22 follows proper CommonMark formatting:
  • Consistent heading structure
  • Proper list formatting with indentation
  • No trailing whitespace issues visible
  • Links properly formatted at the bottom

Security

✅ No hardcoded credentials

• Status: PASS
• Analysis: No credentials present in the changes.

✅ Input validation implemented

• Status: N/A
• Analysis: No input handling code changes.

✅ Proper error handling

• Status: N/A
• Analysis: No error handling code changes.

✅ No sensitive data in logs

• Status: N/A
• Analysis: No logging code changes.

✅ No checked-in license files (.lic) or AQAAAD strings

• Status: PASS
• Analysis: No license files or sensitive strings detected in the changes.

---

Overall Assessment: ✅ APPROVED

This PR is a clean documentation and asset maintenance update with no code quality, security, or functionality concerns. The changes:

1. Remove unused binary image files (5 image files deleted from senzing/reference/images/) - good housekeeping
2. Update CHANGELOG.md with comprehensive documentation of January 2026 AWS workshop alignment changes

Strengths:

• Proper changelog format following Keep a Changelog standards
• Clear, descriptive bullet points explaining all changes
• Appropriate cleanup of unused assets
• Well-structured sub-bullets for detailed change descriptions

No issues found.

Recommendation: This PR is ready to merge.

Automated code review analyzing defects and coding standards

[github-actions]

🤖 Claude Code Review

Code Review

Pull Request Summary

This PR updates documentation and removes unused image files to align the toolkit with January 2026 AWS workshop findings. The changes focus on improving clarity and consolidating reference material.

---

Code Quality

✅ Code Style Adherence

No code changes in this PR - only documentation updates.

✅ No Commented-Out Code

The diff shows clean removals with no commented-out code left behind.

✅ Meaningful Variable Names

N/A - No code changes.

✅ DRY Principle

N/A - No code changes.

✅ Defect Identification

No bugs, logic errors, or security vulnerabilities detected in the documentation changes.

✅ Project Memory Configuration

The changes align with the project's .claude/CLAUDE.md guidance. The CHANGELOG update correctly follows the "Keep a Changelog" format mentioned in project instructions.

---

Testing

N/A Unit Tests

No code changes requiring unit tests.

N/A Integration Tests

No functional changes requiring integration tests.

N/A Edge Cases

No code logic to test.

N/A Test Coverage

No testable code changes.

---

Documentation

⚠️ Markdown Formatting (CHANGELOG.md)

File: CHANGELOG.md

Issues:

1. Line 9-10: The section heading format doesn't follow Keep a Changelog convention

   ### Changed 2026-02-10

   Should be:

   ### Changed

   The date belongs in the version heading ## [X.Y.Z] - 2026-02-10, not in subsection headings.

2. Line 13: Long line (> 120 chars) should be wrapped for better readability:

   - Align toolkit with January 2026 AWS workshop findings
     - Mapping assistant: better stage gating and improved multi-entity loop tracking

3. Missing version links at bottom: The [Unreleased] reference at line 9 should have a corresponding link definition at the bottom of the file pointing to the GitHub compare URL, following Keep a Changelog convention.

❌ CHANGELOG.md Structure

File: CHANGELOG.md:9-17

The CHANGELOG doesn't follow the standard Keep a Changelog structure:

• ### Changed 2026-02-10 should be just ### Changed (date goes in version header)
• Missing version links section at bottom
• The ## [Unreleased] section should eventually be renamed to a version number when released

Recommendation: Follow this structure:

## [Unreleased]

### Changed

- Align toolkit with January 2026 AWS workshop findings
  - Mapping assistant: better stage gating...

## [0.0.1] - 2026-02-10

[Unreleased]: https://github.com/senzing/mapper-ai/compare/v0.0.1...HEAD
[0.0.1]: https://github.com/senzing/mapper-ai/releases/tag/v0.0.1

✅ Content Accuracy

The changelog accurately describes the changes shown in the diff (image removal, documentation consolidation).

✅ Inline Comments

N/A - Documentation changes only.

---

Security

✅ No Hardcoded Credentials

No credentials present.

✅ Input Validation

N/A - No code changes.

✅ Error Handling

N/A - No code changes.

✅ Sensitive Data in Logs

N/A - No logging code.

✅ License Files

No .lic files or AQAAAD strings detected in the diff.

---

Summary

Overall Assessment: ✅ Approve with minor formatting suggestions

The PR successfully removes unused images and updates the CHANGELOG. However, the CHANGELOG formatting should be corrected to properly follow Keep a Changelog conventions:

Required Changes:

• Remove date from ### Changed 2026-02-10 subsection heading (should be just ### Changed)
• Consider adding version comparison links at the bottom of CHANGELOG.md

Optional Improvements:

• Wrap long lines for better readability
• Plan for converting [Unreleased] to a version number (e.g., [0.1.0]) when ready to release

The documentation improvements and image cleanup align well with the project's goals and the .claude/CLAUDE.md guidance.

Automated code review analyzing defects and coding standards