-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 975
can load bookmark in tor tab before tor finishes loading #14680
Comments
Fix #14680 Test Plan: 1. open brave, turn on showing bookmarks toolbar and showing home button in about:preferences. bookmark some sites. 2. open tor tab and try to click on bookmarks before tor finishes loading. also try clicking on the home button and clicking the History > Home menu item. 3. these loads should be blocked until tor finishes initializing
Just to be clear: Does this actually load without going through the Tor SOCKS proxy? If so, what is the mechanism by which it does that? We can merge #14709 but I would like to fix the root of the problem if there is a path by which in the profile/partition/context of a private tab with Tor we can ever bypass the proxy, ideally at the level of muon, rather than block stuff at a high level in browser-laptop like this. In particular, if we just haven't processed the notification that tor is online yet, but the request still goes through the Tor SOCKS proxy, I don't think it's really a problem. |
@riastradh-brave pretty sure it goes through the proxy, so the page loader spins indefinitely |
@diracdeltas Oh, so the problem is that the page loader interferes with the Tor progress indicator, not that this is a leak? |
@diracdeltas @riastradh-brave question on this issue, the expected result seems to be “these loads should be blocked until tor finishes initializing”. In the terminal I see |
@riastradh-brave i thought it was a leak when i first opened it but then i couldn't repro it. 🤷♀️ |
@LaurenWags that's expected - the PR does nothing to retry the page load. it just blcoks it. |
great, thanks for the confirmation @diracdeltas! 👍 |
Test plan
See #14709
Original issue description
STR:
expected result:
the site does not load until tor finishes initializing
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: