Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Nov 8, 2022. It is now read-only.

is it necessary to add 3rd-party login(第三方登录)? #251

Open
mydearxym opened this issue Oct 12, 2018 · 20 comments
Open

is it necessary to add 3rd-party login(第三方登录)? #251

mydearxym opened this issue Oct 12, 2018 · 20 comments

Comments

@mydearxym
Copy link
Member

mydearxym commented Oct 12, 2018

各位好,目前 coderplanets 仅支持 github 作为第三方登录选项, 最初这么设计的原因是--我主观的认为作为一个面向开发者的论坛,github 提供的授权功能就已经够用(同时足够简单和纯粹), 但随着开发工作的推进,我发现仅提供 github 作为唯一的登录方式已经渐渐跟不上一些常见的需求,比如(但不限于):

  • 在某些地区/时段,github 的鉴权请求可能会被社会主义特色价值观阻挡..
  • 想发布招聘信息但没有 github 账号,比如人事/猎头朋友..
  • 与水平无关,不少开发者并没有 github 账号 ..
  • 设计师朋友,确实很少有 github 账号的 ..
  • 一些我暂时没想到但又客观存在的场景 ..

所以我初步计划增加以下社交账号作为补充:

image

期待各位热心朋友的意见:

  • 你是否觉得有必要增加其他的第三方登录选项 ?
  • 如果有必要,上图中的第三方登录选项是否可以满足你的需求?

有些国内的社交账号集成起来手续相对繁琐一些,可能需要一些时间。

谢谢各位。

@mydearxym
Copy link
Member Author

mydearxym commented Oct 12, 2018

translate:

hello there~, coderplanets only support github as 3-party login option for the moment, the reason for this design is -- I arbitrary believe that as a forum for developers, github provides enough authorization api (simple and pure enough) ), but as the development work progressed, I found that only providing github as the only login option has gradually failed to keep up with some common requirements, such as (but not limited to):

  • In certain regions/periods, github's authentication request may be blocked by "Socialist values with Chinese characteristics" ..
  • I want to post job information but no github account, such as personnel/headhunting friends..
  • Regardless of level, many developers do not have a github account..
  • Designer friends, there are very few github accounts..
  • Some scenes that I did not expect but exist objectively..

So I initially plan to support the following social accounts as a supplement:

image

I look forward to your comments:

  • Do you feel that there is a need to increase third party logins?
  • If necessary, can the third-party login option in the above figure meet your needs?

Thank you all.

@mydearxym mydearxym changed the title is it necessary to add 3-rd login(第三方登录)? is it necessary to add 3rd-party login(第三方登录)? Oct 12, 2018
@liukuo-yzh
Copy link

我觉得至少加上微信吧...如果你要在国内做

@mydearxym
Copy link
Member Author

@liukuo-yzh 感谢反馈 :)

这些第三方登陆都会加,但是前期我倾向于吸引开发者多一点, github 账号是个简单粗暴的过滤器。

@lifesign
Copy link

前期可以采用 github 登录,同时沉淀一些内容吸引用户。图中这些第三方登录还是比较主流的 应该能满足大部分需求

@mydearxym
Copy link
Member Author

@lifesign 感谢反馈,前期还是希望能多吸引些这里的 Gay 过来 : )

@Seevil
Copy link

Seevil commented Mar 12, 2019

再加个QQ登录就行了,国内外基本覆盖了,微博个人觉得可有可无

@mydearxym
Copy link
Member Author

@Seevil 多谢反馈, 你说的对 QQ 或者 微信基本就能覆盖国内了,但是需要等一段时间

@Yakumo-Yukari
Copy link

@Seevil 多谢反馈, 你说的对 QQ 或者 微信基本就能覆盖国内了,但是需要等一段时间

个人比较期待QQ登录 现在年轻一代主流还是使用QQ

@mydearxym
Copy link
Member Author

@Yakumo-Yukari 多谢反馈,会添加 QQ 登陆的 :)

@no1guangming
Copy link

github登陆不了惹,
站长

@mydearxym
Copy link
Member Author

@no1guangming 不好意思,前几天升级了 ssl 的证书,导致 www 前缀的域名解析出了点问题,正在修复中。。

@mydearxym
Copy link
Member Author

@no1guangming 已修复,感谢反馈 :)

@no1guangming
Copy link

no1guangming commented Nov 24, 2019 via email

@no1guangming
Copy link

no1guangming commented Nov 24, 2019 via email

@mydearxym
Copy link
Member Author

@no1guangming 请问具体是报的什么错误呢

@no1guangming
Copy link

no1guangming commented Nov 24, 2019 via email

@mydearxym
Copy link
Member Author

@no1guangming 今天白天 github 好像是无法直接访问(坐标成都),所以可能导致超时错误。看来在国内还是的加上微信登陆才行。。

@no1guangming
Copy link

no1guangming commented Nov 25, 2019 via email

@no1guangming
Copy link

no1guangming commented Nov 25, 2019 via email

@mydearxym
Copy link
Member Author

@no1guangming 太客气了,有问题随时联系 :)

Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

6 participants