Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

IRMQTTServer turns off AC when changing temperature #783

Closed
silvanverschuur opened this issue Jun 25, 2019 · 4 comments
Closed

IRMQTTServer turns off AC when changing temperature #783

silvanverschuur opened this issue Jun 25, 2019 · 4 comments
Assignees
@crankyoldgit
Labels
bug help wanted

Comments

@silvanverschuur
Copy link

I'm using the IRMQTTServer to control my Whirlpool AC unit. I can send a on message to the ir_server/ac/cmnd/power topic. The AC unit turns on, this works fine.

When I change the temperature afterwards (ir_server/ac/cmnd/temp topic) the unit turns off.
This also happens when changing the mode from fan -> cool for example. So all parameters are sent to the unit when sending a power on, changing values turn the unit off.

Whirlpool PACW12HP
Remote: DG11J2-31

I've tried IRrecvDumpv2 to see if the remote is detected correctly. All buttons are recognized, unit is detected as Model: 1 (DG11J13A).

Version/revision of the library used

Version 2.6.2
@crankyoldgit crankyoldgit self-assigned this Jun 26, 2019
@crankyoldgit
Copy link
Owner

This sounds like a bug.
Can you please capture and record the sequence you want to have happen via IRrecvDumpV2 and put it in here?
e.g. Record what you want the device to do, but using your remote to create the signals, rather than the ESP generating them.

Whirlpool has only recently been added & is experimental, and we may not have it's behaviour sorted out perfectly. Thus we need to compare it to what it really should be doing.

@silvanverschuur
Copy link
Author

silvanverschuur commented Jun 26, 2019 •
edited
Loading

@crankyoldgit

I've captured the power on (temperature on the remote is 23 degrees) and an increase temperature message (temp from 23 -> 24 degrees). It seems to me that the code contains every parameter (mode, temp, fan speed, etc). So when I increase the temperature all the other parameters are also transmitted.

Power

IRrecvDumpV2 is now running and waiting for IR input on Pin 14
Timestamp : 000004.052
Encoding  : WHIRLPOOL_AC
Code      : 83060452000080000000000000D600010000000001 (168 bits)
Mesg Desc.: Model: 1 (DG11J13A), Power toggle: On, Mode: 2 (COOL), Temp: 23C, Fan: 0 (AUTO), Swing: Off, Light: On, Clock: 00:00, On Timer: Off, Off Timer: Off, Sleep: Off, Super: Off, Command: 1 (POWER)
Library   : v2.6.2

Raw Timing[343]:
   +  9044, -  4454,    +   648, -  1600,    +   650, -  1604,    +   644, -   490, 
   +   644, -   488,    +   650, -   492,    +   644, -   498,    +   644, -   502, 
   +   644, -  1614,    +   644, -   480,    +   650, -  1600,    +   650, -  1610, 
   +   644, -   494,    +   644, -   492,    +   644, -   498,    +   644, -   502, 
   +   644, -   488,    +   650, -   474,    +   650, -   484,    +   644, -  1604, 
   +   648, -   488,    +   650, -   492,    +   644, -   498,    +   646, -   502, 
   +   644, -   488,    +   648, -   480,    +   644, -  1606,    +   648, -   484, 
   +   648, -   490,    +   648, -  1614,    +   648, -   494,    +   650, -  1622, 
   +   644, -   488,    +   648, -   480,    +   644, -   484,    +   648, -   484, 
   +   644, -   494,    +   644, -   494,    +   648, -   494,    +   648, -   498, 
   +   648, -   488,    +   650, -   480,    +   644, -   484,    +   644, -   488, 
   +   644, -   492,    +   644, -   494,    +   648, -   494,    +   648, -   498, 
   +   650, -   470,    +   650, -  7908,    +   644, -   480,    +   650, -   484, 
   +   644, -   488,    +   644, -   488,    +   648, -   494,    +   648, -   494, 
   +   648, -   502,    +   644, -  1614,    +   648, -   476,    +   648, -   484, 
   +   648, -   488,    +   648, -   494,    +   644, -   498,    +   648, -   498, 
   +   648, -   502,    +   644, -   488,    +   648, -   480,    +   644, -   484, 
   +   644, -   488,    +   644, -   488,    +   648, -   494,    +   644, -   498, 
   +   644, -   502,    +   644, -   494,    +   644, -   480,    +   648, -   480, 
   +   648, -   484,    +   648, -   490,    +   644, -   494,    +   648, -   492, 
   +   650, -   498,    +   650, -   488,    +   650, -   480,    +   644, -   484, 
   +   644, -   488,    +   644, -   494,    +   644, -   494,    +   648, -   498, 
   +   644, -   502,    +   644, -   488,    +   648, -   480,    +   644, -   484, 
   +   644, -   484,    +   648, -   488,    +   650, -   492,    +   644, -   498, 
   +   650, -   498,    +   648, -   488,    +   644, -   480,    +   648, -   480, 
   +   648, -   484,    +   648, -   488,    +   650, -   492,    +   644, -   498, 
   +   644, -   502,    +   644, -   488,    +   650, -   480,    +   648, -  1604, 
   +   644, -  1608,    +   648, -   488,    +   650, -  1614,    +   648, -   498, 
   +   648, -  1618,    +   648, -  1596,    +   648, -  7904,    +   644, -   480, 
   +   648, -   480,    +   650, -   484,    +   648, -   490,    +   648, -   488, 
   +   648, -   498,    +   644, -   502,    +   644, -   488,    +   650, -  1600, 
   +   648, -   486,    +   648, -   484,    +   648, -   488,    +   648, -   494, 
   +   644, -   498,    +   648, -   502,    +   648, -   488,    +   650, -   480, 
   +   652, -   480,    +   648, -   488,    +   648, -   494,    +   648, -   494, 
   +   648, -   498,    +   648, -   498,    +   650, -   488,    +   650, -   474, 
   +   648, -   488,    +   640, -   484,    +   650, -   488,    +   648, -   490, 
   +   648, -   492,    +   650, -   498,    +   648, -   488,    +   648, -   476, 
   +   648, -   484,    +   644, -   488,    +   644, -   490,    +   648, -   494, 
   +   644, -   498,    +   644, -   502,    +   644, -   488,    +   648, -   476, 
   +   648, -   484,    +   644, -   484,    +   648, -   488,    +   650, -   488, 
   +   650, -   498,    +   644, -   502,    +   648, -   490,    +   648, -  1610, 
   +   648, -   484,    +   648, -   488,    +   650, -   488,    +   648, -   498, 
   +   644, -   502,    +   644, -   502,    +   648, -   476,    +   644

uint16_t rawData[343] = {9044, 4454,  648, 1600,  650, 1604,  644, 490,  644, 488,  650, 492,  644, 498,  644, 502,  644, 1614,  644, 480,  650, 1600,  650, 1610,  644, 494,  644, 492,  644, 498,  644, 502,  644, 488,  650, 474,  650, 484,  644, 1604,  648, 488,  650, 492,  644, 498,  646, 502,  644, 488,  648, 480,  644, 1606,  648, 484,  648, 490,  648, 1614,  648, 494,  650, 1622,  644, 488,  648, 480,  644, 484,  648, 484,  644, 494,  644, 494,  648, 494,  648, 498,  648, 488,  650, 480,  644, 484,  644, 488,  644, 492,  644, 494,  648, 494,  648, 498,  650, 470,  650, 7908,  644, 480,  650, 484,  644, 488,  644, 488,  648, 494,  648, 494,  648, 502,  644, 1614,  648, 476,  648, 484,  648, 488,  648, 494,  644, 498,  648, 498,  648, 502,  644, 488,  648, 480,  644, 484,  644, 488,  644, 488,  648, 494,  644, 498,  644, 502,  644, 494,  644, 480,  648, 480,  648, 484,  648, 490,  644, 494,  648, 492,  650, 498,  650, 488,  650, 480,  644, 484,  644, 488,  644, 494,  644, 494,  648, 498,  644, 502,  644, 488,  648, 480,  644, 484,  644, 484,  648, 488,  650, 492,  644, 498,  650, 498,  648, 488,  644, 480,  648, 480,  648, 484,  648, 488,  650, 492,  644, 498,  644, 502,  644, 488,  650, 480,  648, 1604,  644, 1608,  648, 488,  650, 1614,  648, 498,  648, 1618,  648, 1596,  648, 7904,  644, 480,  648, 480,  650, 484,  648, 490,  648, 488,  648, 498,  644, 502,  644, 488,  650, 1600,  648, 486,  648, 484,  648, 488,  648, 494,  644, 498,  648, 502,  648, 488,  650, 480,  652, 480,  648, 488,  648, 494,  648, 494,  648, 498,  648, 498,  650, 488,  650, 474,  648, 488,  640, 484,  650, 488,  648, 490,  648, 492,  650, 498,  648, 488,  648, 476,  648, 484,  644, 488,  644, 490,  648, 494,  644, 498,  644, 502,  644, 488,  648, 476,  648, 484,  644, 484,  648, 488,  650, 488,  650, 498,  644, 502,  648, 490,  648, 1610,  648, 484,  648, 488,  650, 488,  648, 498,  644, 502,  644, 502,  648, 476,  644};  // WHIRLPOOL_AC
uint8_t state[21] = {0x83, 0x06, 0x04, 0x52, 0x00, 0x00, 0x80, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0xD6, 0x00, 0x01, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0x01};

Increase temperature


Timestamp : 000040.612
Encoding  : WHIRLPOOL_AC
Code      : 83060062000080000000000000E200020000000002 (168 bits)
Mesg Desc.: Model: 1 (DG11J13A), Power toggle: Off, Mode: 2 (COOL), Temp: 24C, Fan: 0 (AUTO), Swing: Off, Light: On, Clock: 00:00, On Timer: Off, Off Timer: Off, Sleep: Off, Super: Off, Command: 2 (TEMP)
Library   : v2.6.2

Raw Timing[343]:
   +  9034, -  4448,    +   648, -  1600,    +   644, -  1604,    +   644, -   484, 
   +   644, -   494,    +   644, -   492,    +   644, -   498,    +   644, -   498, 
   +   644, -  1608,    +   648, -   480,    +   644, -  1600,    +   648, -  1604, 
   +   648, -   488,    +   644, -   492,    +   644, -   498,    +   644, -   498, 
   +   650, -   488,    +   644, -   480,    +   644, -   480,    +   648, -   484, 
   +   644, -   488,    +   644, -   492,    +   644, -   498,    +   644, -   498, 
   +   644, -   488,    +   648, -   476,    +   644, -  1600,    +   648, -   484, 
   +   644, -   488,    +   644, -   492,    +   644, -  1614,    +   648, -  1618, 
   +   644, -   488,    +   644, -   480,    +   646, -   484,    +   644, -   484, 
   +   648, -   488,    +   644, -   494,    +   644, -   498,    +   644, -   502, 
   +   644, -   490,    +   644, -   480,    +   644, -   484,    +   644, -   484, 
   +   648, -   488,    +   644, -   488,    +   648, -   494,    +   648, -   498, 
   +   644, -   470,    +   644, -  7894,    +   644, -   480,    +   650, -   480, 
   +   648, -   484,    +   644, -   490,    +   648, -   488,    +   648, -   494, 
   +   648, -   498,    +   644, -  1608,    +   650, -   480,    +   644, -   480, 
   +   648, -   484,    +   644, -   490,    +   644, -   494,    +   644, -   498, 
   +   644, -   498,    +   648, -   484,    +   650, -   474,    +   648, -   480, 
   +   648, -   484,    +   644, -   490,    +   644, -   494,    +   644, -   498, 
   +   644, -   498,    +   648, -   490,    +   644, -   476,    +   648, -   480, 
   +   650, -   484,    +   644, -   488,    +   648, -   490,    +   648, -   494, 
   +   648, -   498,    +   644, -   488,    +   644, -   480,    +   644, -   484, 
   +   644, -   484,    +   650, -   488,    +   644, -   492,    +   644, -   498, 
   +   644, -   496,    +   648, -   488,    +   644, -   480,    +   644, -   484, 
   +   644, -   484,    +   648, -   488,    +   644, -   494,    +   644, -   496, 
   +   644, -   498,    +   648, -   490,    +   644, -   478,    +   644, -   484, 
   +   644, -   484,    +   650, -   488,    +   644, -   494,    +   644, -   498, 
   +   644, -   502,    +   644, -   490,    +   648, -   476,    +   648, -  1600, 
   +   648, -   484,    +   644, -   488,    +   648, -   490,    +   648, -  1612, 
   +   648, -  1618,    +   648, -  1590,    +   648, -  7892,    +   648, -   478, 
   +   644, -   484,    +   644, -   484,    +   648, -   488,    +   644, -   494, 
   +   644, -   498,    +   644, -   498,    +   648, -   488,    +   646, -   478, 
   +   644, -  1600,    +   648, -   486,    +   644, -   488,    +   648, -   488, 
   +   648, -   494,    +   648, -   498,    +   644, -   490,    +   644, -   480, 
   +   650, -   480,    +   644, -   484,    +   648, -   490,    +   644, -   494, 
   +   644, -   498,    +   644, -   498,    +   650, -   484,    +   650, -   474, 
   +   648, -   480,    +   648, -   484,    +   648, -   484,    +   648, -   494, 
   +   644, -   498,    +   646, -   498,    +   648, -   488,    +   644, -   480, 
   +   646, -   484,    +   644, -   484,    +   644, -   488,    +   644, -   494, 
   +   644, -   498,    +   644, -   498,    +   648, -   484,    +   648, -   474, 
   +   650, -   480,    +   644, -   484,    +   650, -   488,    +   644, -   494, 
   +   644, -   494,    +   650, -   496,    +   650, -   488,    +   644, -   480, 
   +   644, -  1606,    +   644, -   484,    +   650, -   488,    +   644, -   492, 
   +   644, -   498,    +   644, -   502,    +   644, -   470,    +   644

uint16_t rawData[343] = {9034, 4448,  648, 1600,  644, 1604,  644, 484,  644, 494,  644, 492,  644, 498,  644, 498,  644, 1608,  648, 480,  644, 1600,  648, 1604,  648, 488,  644, 492,  644, 498,  644, 498,  650, 488,  644, 480,  644, 480,  648, 484,  644, 488,  644, 492,  644, 498,  644, 498,  644, 488,  648, 476,  644, 1600,  648, 484,  644, 488,  644, 492,  644, 1614,  648, 1618,  644, 488,  644, 480,  646, 484,  644, 484,  648, 488,  644, 494,  644, 498,  644, 502,  644, 490,  644, 480,  644, 484,  644, 484,  648, 488,  644, 488,  648, 494,  648, 498,  644, 470,  644, 7894,  644, 480,  650, 480,  648, 484,  644, 490,  648, 488,  648, 494,  648, 498,  644, 1608,  650, 480,  644, 480,  648, 484,  644, 490,  644, 494,  644, 498,  644, 498,  648, 484,  650, 474,  648, 480,  648, 484,  644, 490,  644, 494,  644, 498,  644, 498,  648, 490,  644, 476,  648, 480,  650, 484,  644, 488,  648, 490,  648, 494,  648, 498,  644, 488,  644, 480,  644, 484,  644, 484,  650, 488,  644, 492,  644, 498,  644, 496,  648, 488,  644, 480,  644, 484,  644, 484,  648, 488,  644, 494,  644, 496,  644, 498,  648, 490,  644, 478,  644, 484,  644, 484,  650, 488,  644, 494,  644, 498,  644, 502,  644, 490,  648, 476,  648, 1600,  648, 484,  644, 488,  648, 490,  648, 1612,  648, 1618,  648, 1590,  648, 7892,  648, 478,  644, 484,  644, 484,  648, 488,  644, 494,  644, 498,  644, 498,  648, 488,  646, 478,  644, 1600,  648, 486,  644, 488,  648, 488,  648, 494,  648, 498,  644, 490,  644, 480,  650, 480,  644, 484,  648, 490,  644, 494,  644, 498,  644, 498,  650, 484,  650, 474,  648, 480,  648, 484,  648, 484,  648, 494,  644, 498,  646, 498,  648, 488,  644, 480,  646, 484,  644, 484,  644, 488,  644, 494,  644, 498,  644, 498,  648, 484,  648, 474,  650, 480,  644, 484,  650, 488,  644, 494,  644, 494,  650, 496,  650, 488,  644, 480,  644, 1606,  644, 484,  650, 488,  644, 492,  644, 498,  644, 502,  644, 470,  644};  // WHIRLPOOL_AC
uint8_t state[21] = {0x83, 0x06, 0x00, 0x62, 0x00, 0x00, 0x80, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0xE2, 0x00, 0x02, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0x02};

If I need to capture other buttons please let me know.

@crankyoldgit
Copy link
Owner

@silvanverschuur Can I please get you to try using the library and example code from the master branch. I think I may have already fixed this in #758
Let me know if that solves your problem or not.

As for other captures, I'd really like to know if the settings are really "toggles" or not.
i.e. they only appear when you change the setting, not in every copy of the messages

@silvanverschuur
Copy link
Author

@crankyoldgit I can confirm that the master branch fixes my problem. Everything now works as expected. Thanks!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees

@crankyoldgit crankyoldgit

Labels
bug help wanted
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
2 participants
@silvanverschuur @crankyoldgit