Fix issue #2402: Handle missing templates gracefully

[devin-ai-integration]

Fixes #2402 by adding proper null checks for templates in the _build_prompt method. This prevents AttributeError when only system_template is provided or when response_template is missing.

Link to Devin run: https://app.devin.ai/sessions/a1a8c7607f844dd29c239c32548ad53c
Requested by: Joe Moura (joao@crewai.com)

[devin-ai-integration]

🤖 Devin AI Engineer

I'll be helping with this pull request! Here's what you should know:

✅ I will automatically:

• Address comments on this PR. Add "(aside)" to your comment to have me ignore it.
• Look at CI failures and help fix them

Note: I can only respond to comments from users who have write access to this repository.

⚙️ Control Options:

• Disable automatic comment and CI monitoring

[joaomdmoura]

Disclaimer: This review was made by a crew of AI Agents.

Code Review Comment for PR #2403: Handle Missing Templates Gracefully

Overview

This pull request addresses issue #2402 by implementing improved handling of missing templates in the crewAI framework. Significant changes span across three files, enhancing error handling and increasing the robustness of template processing.

Code Quality Findings

1. src/crewai/utilities/prompts.py

Positive Aspects

• The implementation of error handling for missing templates is robust and ensures backward compatibility with previous versions.
• A clear conditional logic is presented for template presence checks.

Specific Improvements

1. Condition Logic Improvement:

   • Current:

     if not system_template or not prompt_template:

   • Recommended:

     if not all([system_template, prompt_template]):

2. Template Validation Enhancement:

   • Introducing a validation method can help in isolating validation logic and improve readability.

   def _validate_templates(self, system_template, prompt_template, response_template):
       """Validates template configurations and returns appropriate defaults."""
       ...

3. String Concatenation Optimization:

   • Current:

     prompt = f"{system}\n{prompt}\n{response}"

   • Recommended:

     prompt = '\n'.join(filter(None, [system, prompt, response]))

2. test_fix_2402.py

Positive Aspects

• The test file covers multiple cases and maintains a clear structure.

Specific Improvements

1. Test Organization:

   • Moving tests into class structure can enhance organization and reusability.

   class TestTemplateHandling:
       ...

2. Error Handling Tests:

   • It is critical to add tests for specific error cases to improve coverage and ensure future reliability.

   def test_invalid_template_combination(self):
       ...

3. tests/test_templates.py

Positive Aspects

• Well-structured tests covering edge cases effectively.

Specific Improvements

1. Test Data Separation:

   • Consider creating test data fixtures for better manageability and clarity.

   @pytest.fixture
   def template_test_data():
       return ...

2. Assertion Enhancement:

   • More specific assertions could improve test reliability and clarity of pass/fail conditions.

   assert result is not None

Historical Context and Related PRs

• Previous patterns in handling templates have leaned towards improved error checks and handling for missing values. Notably, past pull requests have demonstrated a focus on robustness within the template processing logic. This trend indicates a move towards systematic error management, which is crucial for maintaining application stability.

Implications for Related Files

The changes in this PR hint at a broader architectural alignment towards more comprehensive error handling across templates. Future maintenance should consider revisiting these files to ensure continuity and compatibility as new features or templates are added.

General Recommendations

1. Documentation:

   • Enhance docstring documentation for all methods introduced or modified, especially for the new template handling behaviors and expected errors.

2. Error Messages:

   • Implement clear, user-friendly error messages to guide future developers or users facing issues with template handling.

3. Logging:

   • Introduce logging at critical functionality points to aid diagnostics where unexpected behaviors arise.

4. Test Coverage:

   • Increase the breadth of test coverage to encapsulate all conceivable usage patterns, particularly around edge cases and invalid inputs.

Summary

Overall, this pull request successfully enhances error handling for missing templates while maintaining substantial test coverage. Implementing the recommended changes would further increase the robustness, maintainability, and clarity of both the core functionality and associated tests. These improvements will ensure that the crewAI framework can gracefully manage template availability while providing clear feedback in case of issues.

Thank you for your hard work on this PR!