Introduction

This repo tries to benchmark the following implementations of transducer loss in terms of speed and memory consumption:

• k2
• torchaudio
• optimized_transducer
• warprnnt_numba
• warp-transducer
• warp-rnnt
• SpeechBrain

The benchmark results are saved in https://huggingface.co/csukuangfj/transducer-loss-benchmarking

WARNING: Instead of using warp-transducer from https://github.com/HawkAaron/warp-transducer, we use a version that is used and maintained by ESPnet developers.

Environment setup

Install torchaudio

Please refer to https://github.com/pytorch/audio to install torchaudio. Note: It requires torchaudio >= 0.10.0.

Install k2

Please refer to https://k2-fsa.github.io/k2/installation/index.html to install k2. Note: It requires at k2 >= v1.13.

Install optimized_transducer

pip install optimized_transducer

Please refer to https://github.com/csukuangfj/optimized_transducer for other alternatives.

Install warprnnt_numba

pip install --upgrade git+https://github.com/titu1994/warprnnt_numba

Please refer to https://github.com/titu1994/warprnnt_numba for more methods.

Install warp-transducer

git clone --single-branch --branch espnet_v1.1 https://github.com/b-flo/warp-transducer.git
cd warp-transducer
cd build
cmake -DCMAKE_BUILD_TYPE=Release ..
make -j warprnnt
cd ../pytorch_binding

# Caution: You may have to modify CUDA_HOME to match your CUDA installation
export CUDA_HOME=/usr/local/cuda
export C_INCLUDE_PATH=$CUDA_HOME/include:${C_INCLUDE_PATH}
export CPLUS_INCLUDE_PATH=$CUDA_HOME/include:${CPLUS_INCLUDE_PATH}

python3 setup.py build

# Then add /path/to/warp-transducer/pytorch_binding/build/lib.linux-x86_64-3.8
# to your PYTHONPATH
export PYTHONPATH=/ceph-fj/fangjun/open-source-2/warp-transducer/pytorch_binding/build/lib.linux-x86_64-3.8:$PYTHONPATH

# To test that warp-transducer was compiled and configured correctly, run the following commands
cd $HOME
python3 -c "import warprnnt_pytorch; print(warprnnt_pytorch.RNNTLoss)"
# It should print something like below:
#   <class 'warprnnt_pytorch.RNNTLoss'>

# Caution: We did not used any **install** command.

Install warp_rnnt

git clone https://github.com/1ytic/warp-rnnt
cd warp-rnnt/pytorch_binding

# Caution: You may have to modify CUDA_HOME to match your CUDA installation
export CUDA_HOME=/usr/local/cuda
export C_INCLUDE_PATH=$CUDA_HOME/include:$CUDA_HOME/targets/x86_64-linux/include:$C_INCLUDE_PATH
export CPLUS_INCLUDE_PATH=$CUDA_HOME/include:$CUDA_HOME/targets/x86_64-linux/include:$CPLUS_INCLUDE_PATH
python3 setup.py build
python3 setup.py install

# To test that warp-rnnt was installed correctly, run the following commands:
cd $HOME
python3 -c "import warp_rnnt; print(warp_rnnt.RNNTLoss)"
# It should print something like below:
#   <class 'warp_rnnt.RNNTLoss'>

Install SpeechBrain

Caution: You don't need to install SpeechBrain. We have saved the file that is for computing RNN-T loss into this repo using the following commands:

wget https://raw.githubusercontent.com/speechbrain/speechbrain/develop/speechbrain/nnet/loss/transducer_loss.py
mv transducer_loss.py speechbrain_rnnt_loss.py

echo "# This file is downloaded from https://raw.githubusercontent.com/speechbrain/speechbrain/develop/speechbrain/nnet/loss/transducer_loss.py" >> speechbrain_rnnt_loss.py

Note: You need to install numba in order to use SpeechBrain's RNN-T loss:

pip instal numba

Install PyTorch profiler TensorBoard plugin

pip install torch-tb-profiler

Please refer to https://github.com/pytorch/kineto/tree/main/tb_plugin for other alternatives.

Steps to get the benchmark results

Step 0: Clone the repo

git clone https://github.com/csukuangfj/transducer-loss-benchmarking.git

Step 1: Generate shape information from training data (Can be skipped)

Since padding matters in transducer loss computation, we get the shape information for logits and targets from the subset train-clean-100 of the LibriSpeech dataset to make the benchmark results more realistic.

We use the script https://github.com/k2-fsa/icefall/blob/master/egs/librispeech/ASR/prepare.sh to prepare the manifest of train-clean-100. This script also produces a BPE model with vocabulary size 500.

The script ./generate_shape_info.py in this repo generates a 2-D tensor, where each row has 2 columns containing information abut each utterance in train-clean-100:

• Column 0 contains the number of acoustic frames after subsampling, i.e., the T in transducer loss computation
• Column 1 contains the number of BPE tokens, i.e., the U in transducer loss computation

Hint: We have saved the generated file ./shape_info.pt in this repo so you don't need to run this step. If you want to do benchmarks on other dataset, you will find ./generate_shape_info.py very handy.

Step 2: Run benchmarks

We have the following benchmarks so far:

Name	Script	Benchmark Result folder
torchaudio	./benchmark_torchaudio.py	./log/torchaudio-30
optimized_transducer	./benchmark_ot.py	./log/optimized_transducer-30
k2	./benchmark_k2.py	./log/k2-30
k2 pruned loss	./benchmark_k2_pruned.py	./log/k2-pruned-30
warprnnt_numba	./benchmark_warprnnt_numba.py	./log/warprnnt_numba-30
warp-transducer	./benchmark_warp_transducer.py	./log/warp-transducer-30
warp-rnnt	./benchmark_warp_rnnt.py	./log/warp-rnnt-30
SpeechBrain	./benchmark_speechbrain.py	./log/speechbrain-30

The first column shows the names of different implementations of transducer loss, the second column gives the command to run the benchmark, and the last column is the output folder containing the results of running the corresponding script.

HINT: The suffix 30 in the output folder indicates the batch size used during the benchmark. Batch size 30 is selected since torchaudio throws CUDA OOM error if batch size 40 is used.

HINT: We have uploaded the benchmark results to https://huggingface.co/csukuangfj/transducer-loss-benchmarking. You can download and visualize it without running any code.

Note: We use the following command for benchmarking:

prof = torch.profiler.profile(
    activities=[ProfilerActivity.CPU, ProfilerActivity.CUDA],
    schedule=torch.profiler.schedule(
        wait=10, warmup=10, active=20, repeat=2
    ),
    on_trace_ready=torch.profiler.tensorboard_trace_handler(
        f"./log/k2-{batch_size}"
    ),
    record_shapes=True,
    with_stack=True,
    profile_memory=True,
)

The first 10 batches are skipped for warm up, the next 10 batches are ignored, and the subsequent 20 batches are used for benchmarking.

Step 3: Visualize Results

You can use tensorboard to visualize the benchmark results. For instance, to visualize the results for k2 pruned loss, you can use

tensorboard --logdir ./log/k2-pruned-30 --port 6007

Name	Overview	Memory
torchaudio
k2
k2 pruned
optimized_transducer
warprnnt_numba
warp-transducer
warp-rnnt
SpeechBrain

The following table summarizes the results from the above table

Name	Average step time (us)	Peak memory usage (MB)
torchaudio	544241	18921.8
k2	386808	22056.9
k2 pruned	63395	3820.3
optimized_transducer	376954	7495.9
warprnnt_numba	299385	19072.7
warp-transducer	275852	19072.6
warp-rnnt	293270	18934.3
SpeechBrain	459406	19072.8

Some notes to take away:

• For the unpruned case, warp-transducer is the fastest while optimized_transducer takes the least memory
• k2 pruned loss is the fastest and requires the least memory
• You can use a larger batch size during training when using k2 pruned loss

Sort utterances by duration before batching them up

To minimize the effect of padding, we also benchmark the implementations by sorting utterances by duration before batching them up.

You can use the option --sort-utterance, e.g., ./benchmark_torchaudio.py --sort-utterance true, while running the benchmarks.

The following table visualizes the benchmark results for sorted utterances:

Name	Overview	Memory
torchaudio
k2
k2 pruned
optimized_transducer
warprnnt_numba
warp-transducer
warp-rnnt
SpeechBrain

Note: A value 10k for max frames is selected since the value 11k causes CUDA OOM for k2 unpruned loss. Max frames with 10k means that the number of frames in a batch before padding is at most 10k.

The following table summarizes the results from the above table

Name	Average step time (us)	Peak memory usage (MB)
torchaudio	601447	12959.2
k2	274407	15106.5
k2 pruned	38112	2647.8
optimized_transducer	567684	10903.1
warprnnt_numba	229340	13061.8
warp-transducer	210772	13061.8
warp-rnnt	216547	12968.2
SpeechBrain	263753	13063.4

Some notes to take away:

• For the unpruned case, warp-transducer is the fastest one
• optimized_transducer still consumes the least memory for the unpruned case
• k2 pruned loss is again the fastest and requires the least memory
• You can use a larger batch size during training when using k2 pruned loss