-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 506
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
General ZBMini issue. #4016
Comments
Today I have made a new debug INFO, ERROR,ERROR_L2,APS,APS_L2 see https://pastebin.com/RS2RmbEv During the log I have switched the lights logeerkamerlamp and kluskamerlamp in HA end using the regular wall light switch attached to the ZBmini. Strangely they now both work, but still showing multiple entries in HA (in the history of the lights) and in the log. |
Thanks for the logs. You mean like those 2 here?
The remarkable thing is that the device seems to send 2 attribute reports shortly after another. The first payload ( So on the one hand, the device does something odd, on the other hand, we should evaluate to let only bool values through... |
I am facing same issue her. Thught i WOuld give it a try before buyinf sonnof zigbee bridge and flash this with tasmota :( |
I guess this is a case where it's better to have the real device for testing. I'll put it on the order list for January. The group0 bindings will be removed in the next release, and /group/0 will use a normal broadcast to all routers, however every other group to which the device is added leads to the same effect. |
@manup, note that I implemented it like that because of the suggestion by you and @ebaauw in #1005. (and only because I wanted to add Hue scenes support #1471, which still isn't merged...). I only recently found out that group 65520 is invalid according to the zigbee specs (#3744 (comment)), and that sometimes sensors were added to the group, perhaps causing quite a few of the group0 issues. |
Thanks for your efforts so far! I am not in expert in de debug logs nor in the deCONZ api. @manup, I live in the netherlands, if you also live there I am happy to supply you the ZBmini to speed things up. |
I am seeing the same problem. |
@manup I live in Germany and have 3 Sonoff ZBMinis laying around. I would send you one over if this helps. |
That is exactly what I noticed as well. |
Thanks, I've already put them on the order list, should arrive in next two weeks. If the switch works in the deCONZ Cluster Info panel it really seems to be more an issue in the plugin handling of it. |
Hi, Same bug in my HA installation.
I have 4 ZBMINIs and I have exactly the same problem with all of them. If more information is needed, please tell me what you need. And another question. The ZBMINI recognizes HA as "light" instead of "switch". I think you should really recognize it as a "switch" rather than a "light". Greetings and thanks to the team for being attentive to the problem and hopefully it will be resolved soon. |
Had some issues setting these up but finally got them to work.
conbee II Issue now is the weird flickering of states |
Hi; I don't know how, but today I have (physically) connected two of the ZBMINI devices and reconnected them, and now they work perfectly for me. I don't know what could have happened to make them work for me now. :-( But hey, it was just that, commenting that with the same software versions the devices are working correctly. I will monitor and comment again if they stop working. A greeting. |
I am using 2.09.0 and I am able to control the ZBMINI. But it is recognized as light/bulb and I am not able to see the status. It switches to off in the UI and json answer. But the power is still on. @JCSCatena Do you see the correct status of the ZBMINI? |
I switched to ZHA with flashed sonoff ZigBee bridge and never got problems
again. Also my light bulbs and ithe ZigBee stuff without issues. I still
use deconz for some sensors but replaced hue finally complete with sonoff
Jose Carlos Serrano Catena <notifications@github.com> schrieb am Di., 5.
Jan. 2021, 22:55:
… I am using 2.09.0 and I am able to control the ZBMINI. But it is
recognized as light/bulb and I am not able to see the status. It switches
to off in the UI and json answer. But the power is still on.
@JCSCatena <https://github.com/JCSCatena> Do you see the correct status
of the ZBMINI?
In phoscon appears like this.....
As Light
[image: image]
<https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/43066090/103703815-85a1b700-4fa8-11eb-9f50-dcea707b97e9.png>
But in HA appears like this....
[image: image]
<https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/43066090/103704035-e16c4000-4fa8-11eb-9b90-32b854577734.png>
yes, I see the correct status.
A greetings.
—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
<#4016 (comment)>,
or unsubscribe
<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ADFUA77GHGBRBKKMLTWFVZTSYODFXANCNFSM4VIBPVNQ>
.
|
Ok, here's another one with same problem. |
How do you do step 3? I cant find repair in deconz. |
I'm having the same issue and will try this |
Ah, that makes sense. I tried this, but unfortunately it didn't work for me. I can switch them on, but the status is then off again, so I cant turn them really off. Turning off with a switch works fin. Then I can switch them on again with home assistant. (but never off without the physical button) |
well, I tried but I screwed something up, now conbee is having some issue, asking for a reboot :/ On step 3, do you re-pair in deconz or on phoscon? If you do it on deconz (from inside HA) how do you do it? |
I used phoscon. |
I 'm without luck. ZBmini works great within deCONZ but either in HA or Phoscon just won't work. it never changes states properly I'm running latest HA on a pi4, deCONZ 2.07.01, fw 26660700 |
I have the same issue (light can be toggled using local switch, not working in Phoscon, or at least only occasionally can be turned on, I do not use HA). |
I have two ZBMINI configured correctly, but now I have bought 5 more and I have the problem that is described in the BUG, that is, if the device is off, Phoscon or HA manages to turn it on, but then it is impossible to turn it off. From deConz if I can turn it off and on every time without problems. Hopefully it will be solved soon. Another thing that happens is that I have added the 5 devices to HA through Phoscon and now I have deleted them from Phoscon but in HA I cannot remove them, does anyone know how I can remove them from HA? Thank you. |
How you pair ZBmini? Phoscone app doesn't found it as light or switch. I also have problem with ZBmini and Home Assistant. Phoscone and Deconz make toggles correctly. |
Hi, I believe that I confirm that the problem is due to the fact that the ZBMINI device, once we pair it with phoscon / deconz / HA, does not refresh correctly in phoscon / HA. If we follow the steps indicated below, we can link them without problems. I had 2 ZBMINIs linked correctly, but I bought another 5 and there was no way they would work correctly in Phoscon / HA, but following the steps below all 5 have been linked without problems:
I hope these instructions help you. A greeting. |
It doesn't work for me
Where should delete ZBMINI?
If I don't have supervisor should I restart Deconz container? |
I am running deconz in docker, updated to marthoc/deconz:latest, and I can confirm that it works with the remaining zbmini that did not work before. The two that I had already gotten to work are still working. I am still a bit confused regarding why it was possible to get the two others configured and working before this update (they worked across restarts of deconz, etc.), but I guess it does not matter much now that they all work. Good job! |
It just updated the docker marthoc as well. And yes, all mine zbmini’s work fine now!!!
Great work! Thanks for the help! I am a happy topicstarter now!
Rick
Verstuurd vanaf mijn iPhone
… Op 1 mrt. 2021 om 22:33 heeft Mikkel Holm Olsen ***@***.***> het volgende geschreven:
I am running deconz in docker, updated to marthoc/deconz:latest, and I can confirm that it works with the remaining zbmini that did not work before. The two that I had already gotten to work are still working. I am still a bit confused regarding why it was possible to get the two others configured and working before this update (they worked across restarts of deconz, etc.), but I guess it does not matter much now that they all work. Good job!
—
You are receiving this because you were mentioned.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.
|
I guess this is confirmation enough and we see more happy people now 😄 Closing this one as resolved. Enjoy! |
The HA-Addon is still on an older Deconz-Version without the bugfix |
I´am having the same ptoblem! Versão | core-2021.3.2 |
@cylonr As @gang-himself mentioned: The HA Addon doesn't have this fix yet. |
@SwoopX You stole my pride here :( |
Hi everyone, I also still have the problem with deConz version 2.09.03 in HA. |
@Metaleon the people who maintain the ha addon. |
I tried that on the HA-Addon Discord-Channel but I wasn‘t heard. And unfortunately it looks like I‘m to newbie to github to manage to do a PR... 😢 |
Swap to the Marthoc Docker image.
` |
Now the HA-Addon is on 2.10.03. |
confirmed also from my side. Add v. 6.8.0 |
Good evening, I have a question concerning Sonoff ZBMini. It’s connected via Conbee II to phoscon/DeConz headless at its latest version and firmware. I can pair the device but after a few hours it isn’t reachable anymore — the connection gets lost, device is greyed out. If I click on „search for new lights“, the device comes back to life. This happens two or three times a day. In the near there are some Osram Smart Plugs which act as repeater. The stick itself is about 7 meters away. Linux is Debian Buster on an intel Nuc. Conbee II is connected via USB2. All other devices are reachable and acting as normal. Can someone help? Many thanks 🙏🏼 |
I reported this issue too.
|
Thanks! How do I identify V2? |
I had these problems too, but since the Conbee II Firmware-Update to 26700700 they seem to be gone. In my case it helped also to bring back the devices alive to simply switch the local switch on the zbmini (of course only if there is one connected). But some hours later they were offline again. |
Is there a possibility to trigger "search new lights" via API or shell command? That could be a temporary solution. |
I never had disconnections (device in pairing state) with 2.0.0 |
in deCONZ 2.12.6 with 2 sonoff mini 2.0 there is still the same problem |
Happy to have the issue with 1.0 only. |
Hi, This only happens with ZBmini Version 2: I have also an old one: System: Some new ideas how to fix? |
.... OK my fault, the phoscon update was not correctly installed. After updating again to version 2.13.04 statusrequest are correct |
Describe the bug
I have issues with 4 of my 5 Sonoff Zigbee mini switches (ZBmini) in Deconz, also in combination with HA. The ZBmini are recognized in Deconz in phoscon and in the VNC viewer and also in HA. Also the connected regular switches connected to the ZBmini’s work fine (you can hear the relay). However, the switching in phoscon and HA does not works:
Switching in HA or Deconz to on or off only works one time.
Switching triggers multiple events in HA history and in Deconz. Example:
2873: 14:10:49:898 Websocket 172.29.0.1:41700 send message: {"e":"changed","id":"35","r":"lights","state":{"alert":null,"on":true,"reachable":true},"t":"event","uniqueid":"84:71:27:ff:fe:93:13:58-01"} (ret = 140)
2874: 14:10:49:899 Websocket 192.168.2.20:54220 send message: {"e":"changed","id":"35","r":"lights","state":{"alert":null,"on":true,"reachable":true},"t":"event","uniqueid":"84:71:27:ff:fe:93:13:58-01"} (ret = 140)
2875: 14:10:49:900 Websocket 192.168.2.20:54434 send message: {"e":"changed","id":"35","r":"lights","state":{"alert":null,"on":true,"reachable":true},"t":"event","uniqueid":"84:71:27:ff:fe:93:13:58-01"} (ret = 140)
One of my ZBmini is working, but still triggering multiple events. I do not know why this ZBmini is working. I do not see a difference in Deconz.
My problems looks the same as described here: #3632 and https://community.home-assistant.io/t/zigbee2mqtt-switch-automatically-toggles-from-off-to-on-after-1-second/244833
Steps to reproduce the behavior
The issue is seen for 4 out of the 5 Sonoff ZBmini's. Restarting de HA and deCONZ containers does not help. Same for restarting the host (Qnap NAS). There also is no difference between deCONZ 2.7.1 and 2.8
Expected behavior
In HA and deCONZ is should be possible to swith the ZBmini on and off (independent of the regular switch connected to the ZB mini).
Screenshots
For screenshots see #3632
For me the screenshots form issue 3632 are the same. Only the Date code is difference (20200927) and the Power Source (unkown).
Additional screenshot:
Please let me know if any other screenshot is needed.
Environment
deCONZ Logs
I do no see errors in the debug INFO, ERROR,ERROR_L2,APS,APS_L2 (besides the multiple entries shown above).
Also see https://pastebin.com/jNQzdf2E
During the log I have tried switching the light (logeerkamerlamp) in phoscon en the regular wall light switch attached to the ZBmini.
Additional context
According HA I have 90 nodes and 150 entities.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: