[Regression] Rendering into wrong outlet when hijacking renderTemplate and using this.render()

[alexdiliberto]

This one can be pooled into all of the other recent issues around rendering for v1.11.

I'm hijacking renderTemplate on all the routes and manually rendering into outlets and named outlets with nested children involved. The nested child route for both resources is rendering into the main outlet rather than their respective parent outlets.

Kind of a weird issue to describe...my description probably doesn't do it justice, so just check out the JSBins side by side.

v1.10 - Working
http://jsbin.com/qupekatuyu/2/edit?html,js,output

v1.11 - Broken
http://emberjs.jsbin.com/pidituqufu/1/edit?html,js,output

/cc @ef4

[alexdiliberto]

Any information here?

[alexdiliberto]

👊

Noting that this is still an ongoing issue in the latest release of Ember v1.13.4

[ef4]

You are probably right that there is a regression here, but this bug has been stuck at low priority because it seems to affect a very tiny slice of actual apps. We are three major releases in, with a single bug report.

There were a lot of underspecified corner cases in the old implementation, and we have tried to fix as many as is practical. I would like to fix this one too, but haven't found the time.

[jcope2013]

bumped into issue today in my app also on 1.13.5 as i jumped from 1.9

updated the jsbin in #10652 to latest version and seeing same issue

http://emberjs.jsbin.com/qucuragaxu/edit?html,css,js,output

changing my nested route renderTemplate from this

 renderTemplate: function(){
    this.render({outlet: 'fullPage'});
  }

to this

renderTemplate: function(){
    this.render({into: 'application', outlet: 'fullPage'});
  }

seems to be working at moment

[alexdiliberto]

@jcope2013 Glad I'm not the only one who is having this issue, but I looked at your example workaround and couldn't get it working with my original broken JSin

[jcope2013]

@alexdiliberto this seems to fix it? or make it act more like the 1.10 version which has other bugs http://emberjs.jsbin.com/rihifakimo/1/edit?html,js,output

i removed in the transfers route

this.render('accounts', { into: 'application' });

[alexdiliberto]

@jcope2013 Yea still not the same unfortunately by removing that render block...now the transition looks messed up. Hopefully this issue will be fixed.

[locks]

@ef4 @jcope2013 @alexdiliberto is this still happening?

[jcope2013]

@locks yes tried on ember 2.5 and still have to use workaround mentioned in #10916 (comment) or it doesn't work properly

[Serabe]

This issue is still happening in 2.6.2. In beta still looks like:

While in 1.10 it looked like:

[Serabe]

Still happening in 2.12. Moved it to this twiddle.

[btecu]

This issue can be closed since into was removed from Ember 3.0.

https://www.emberjs.com/deprecations/v2.x/#toc_rendering-into-a-render-helper-that-resolves-to-an-outlet