🐛 [firebase_auth] Not compatible with intl version latest

[zakblacki]

Please upgrade firebase_auth with intl 0.18

Because firebase_auth >=4.2.4 depends on firebase_auth_web ^5.2.4 which depends on intl ^0.17.0, firebase_auth >=4.2.4 requires intl ^0.17.0.

[darshankawar]

Thanks for the report. Using plugin example, if we run flutter pub add intl, it by default adds intl: ^0.17.0. But if we manually try to add intl: ^0.18.0, it gives below compile error:

Because every version of firebase_auth_web from path depends on intl ^0.17.0 and firebase_auth_example depends on intl ^0.18.0, firebase_auth_web from path is forbidden.
So, because firebase_auth_example depends on firebase_auth_web from path, version solving failed.
pub get failed
command: "/Users/dhs/Documents/Fluttersdk/flutter/bin/cache/dart-sdk/bin/dart __deprecated_pub --directory . get --example"
pub env: {
  "FLUTTER_ROOT": "/Users/dhs/Documents/Fluttersdk/flutter",
  "PUB_ENVIRONMENT": "flutter_cli:get",
  "PUB_CACHE": "/Users/dhs/.pub-cache",
}
exit code: 1

Process finished with exit code 1

firebase_auth_web seems to depend on intl: ^0.17.0 as shown below:

[darshankawar]

/cc @Lyokone

[Lyokone]

@zakblacki We reverted the upgrade to intl 0.18 since it was incompatible with flutter_localization. I guess you are on the master channel. You can force override to intl 0.18 if needed or go back to stable.

[Sun3]

Any updates on this issue? We should be able to use intl ^0.18.0

Thank you.

[Lyokone]

If you need to use ^0.18.0 you can always use dependency override to force the update. As long as the stable version is 3.7, we can only ship the intl version that is compatible with flutter_localization :)

[Sun3]

I understand... I am hoping in the near future the firebase_auth will upgrade to intl ^0.18.0

Thanks.

[jhonatan-3a]

any updates on this one ?

[Lyokone]

No new stable version of Flutter has been released, so we are still using 0.17.0. As said before, you can use

dependency_overrides:
  intl: ^0.18.0

if you really need the latest version (it should not be breaking with previous release)

[Fraa-124]

I have updated to Flutter 3.10.0 (stable), but I still cannot compile due to the dependency issue with firebase_auth 4.5.0, which relies on firebase_auth_web 5.4.0. In turn, firebase_auth_web 5.4.0 depends on intl 0.17.0, while flutter_localizations depends on intl 0.18.0.

Is it really that difficult to update firebase_auth_web to use intl 0.18.0?

[MagnusJohansson]

Now that Flutter 3.10 /Dart 3.0.0 stable is out, I think it's time to wake up and finally update [firebase_auth] to use intl 0.18.0

Because firebase_auth >=4.5.0 depends on firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0 which depends on intl ^0.17.0, firebase_auth >=4.5.0 requires intl ^0.17.0.
So, because my_app depends on both firebase_auth >=4.5.0 and intl >=0.18.0, version solving failed.

And, of course, as you know, when using flutter 3.10.0 with flutter_localizations one can't use intl 0.17.0 anymore.

Because my_app  depends on flutter_localizations from sdk which depends on intl 0.18.0, intl 0.18.0 is required.
So, because my_app depends on intl ^0.17.0, version solving failed.

So, please update [firebase_auth] / [firebase_auth_web] to be Flutter 3.10 / Dart 3.0.0 compatible.

[Yegorisa]

Agree with the last post, we can't compile the project at all with flutter 3.10.0 because of this issue

[Lyokone]

I've opened #10944 to update the last few things needed for Flutter 3.10.0. I hope you understand that we couldn't update to intl 0.18.0 before the stable release last night.

It is not that it's "really that difficult to update"

Again, you can always override your dependencies if you cannot wait for a library to update.

dependency_overrides:
  intl: ^0.18.1

[BirjuVachhani]

Overriding it didn't work for me. I had to add this as well in addition to the dependency_overrides

dependencies:
  flutter_localizations:
    sdk: flutter

[Lyokone]

We will shortly deploy a new version. This new version will not depend on intl anymore, so it will not cause any issues in the future.

[jhonatan-3a]

thank programming gods its no longer dependant on intl anymore, kudos!

[Lyokone]

It's published as part of firebase_auth: ^4.6.0

[jhonatan-3a]

awesomees