🏥 Safe Output Health Report - December 19, 2024

[github-actions[bot]]

This report analyzes the health and reliability of safe output jobs across all agentic workflows over the last 24 hours. Safe output jobs handle GitHub API operations like creating discussions, issues, pull requests, and comments based on agent output.

Overall Health: Excellent (95.92% Success Rate)

The safe output system demonstrated very high reliability with only 2 failures out of 49 workflow runs that produced safe outputs.

Full Report Details

Executive Summary

• Period: Last 24 hours (December 18-19, 2024)
• Runs Analyzed: 91 total workflow runs
• Workflows with Safe Outputs: 49 runs (53.8%)
• Safe Output Jobs Executed: 81 individual safe output operations
• Safe Output Jobs Failed: 2 operations
• Success Rate: 95.92%
• Error Clusters Identified: 1 unique error pattern

Safe Output Job Statistics

Job Type	Total Executions	Failures	Success Rate
add_comment	38	0	100%
add_labels	22	0	100%
missing_tool	12	0	100%
push_to_pull_request_branch	5	0	100%
create_pull_request	2	2	0%
noop	2	0	100%
TOTAL	81	2	97.53%

Key Observations

1. Most Reliable Job Types: add_comment, add_labels, missing_tool, push_to_pull_request_branch, and noop all achieved 100% success rates
2. Problematic Job Type: create_pull_request had a 0% success rate (2 failures out of 2 attempts)
3. High Usage: add_comment (38 executions) and add_labels (22 executions) are the most frequently used safe output operations

Error Clusters

Cluster 1: Missing GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID Environment Variable

• Error Pattern: Error: GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID environment variable is required
• Error Type: Configuration Error
• Count: 2 occurrences
• Affected Job Type: create_pull_request
• Affected Workflows: security-fix-pr workflow
• Affected Runs:
  • §20381227959
  • §20381704495

Sample Error:

##[error]Unhandled error: Error: GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID environment variable is required
    at main (eval at callAsyncFunction (/home/runner/work/_actions/actions/github-script/ed597411d8f924073f98dfc5c65a23a2325f34cd/dist/index.js:36187:16), (anonymous):41:11)

Root Cause: The create_pull_request safe output job script requires the GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID environment variable to generate branch names, but this variable is not being passed from the agent job to the safe_outputs job in the workflow execution context.

Impact:

• Severity: High
• User Impact: Complete failure of pull request creation in affected workflows
• Workflow Failure: Causes the entire workflow to fail
• Affected Workflow: Specifically impacts the security-fix-pr workflow

Root Cause Analysis

Configuration Issues

Missing Environment Variable Propagation

The GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID environment variable is set in the agent job context but is not being properly propagated to the safe_outputs job. This suggests a gap in the workflow compilation process where required environment variables for specific safe output operations are not being identified and passed through.

Technical Details:

• The variable is required by the create_pull_request script at line 364-366 (see error stack trace)
• The script uses this variable to generate unique branch names: ${workflowId}-${randomHex}
• Without this variable, the script throws an unhandled error before any git operations

Recommendations

Critical Issues (Immediate Action Required)

1. Fix Missing GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID Environment Variable

• Priority: High
• Root Cause: Environment variable not propagated to safe_outputs job
• Recommended Action:
  1. Update the workflow compilation logic to ensure GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID is included in the environment variables passed to the safe_outputs job
  2. Add GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID to the list of required environment variables for create_pull_request safe output jobs
  3. Verify that all workflows using create_pull_request safe output include this variable
• Affected: security-fix-pr workflow, potentially other workflows using create_pull_request
• Files to Review: Workflow compilation code, specifically safe output job environment variable configuration

Bug Fixes Required

1. Environment Variable Propagation in Workflow Compiler

• File/Location: Workflow compilation logic (likely in Go code that generates GitHub Actions YAML)
• Problem: Required environment variables for safe output jobs are not being identified and propagated
• Fix:
  • Add logic to detect which environment variables are required by each safe output job type
  • Ensure these variables are explicitly passed in the safe_outputs job env section
  • Consider creating a manifest of required variables per safe output type
• Affected Jobs: Primarily create_pull_request, but should audit all safe output job types

Process Improvements

1. Safe Output Job Validation

• Current State: Safe output jobs can fail at runtime due to missing configuration
• Proposed: Add pre-execution validation step that checks for required environment variables
• Benefits:
  • Fail fast with clear error messages
  • Prevent workflow execution that will inevitably fail
  • Easier debugging for users

2. Environment Variable Documentation

• Current State: Required environment variables for each safe output job type may not be clearly documented
• Proposed: Create comprehensive documentation mapping each safe output job type to its required environment variables
• Benefits:
  • Easier troubleshooting
  • Better developer experience
  • Facilitates workflow debugging

3. Test Coverage for Safe Output Jobs

• Current State: Limited testing for safe output job environment configurations
• Proposed: Add integration tests that verify all safe output job types can execute with minimal required environment
• Benefits:
  • Catch configuration issues before deployment
  • Ensure consistent behavior across safe output types
  • Prevent regressions

Work Item Plans

Work Item 1: Fix GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID Propagation

• Type: Bug Fix
• Priority: High
• Description: The create_pull_request safe output job requires GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID but this environment variable is not being passed from the agent job context to the safe_outputs job context, causing all create_pull_request operations to fail.

Acceptance Criteria:

• GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID is available in the safe_outputs job environment
• create_pull_request safe output jobs succeed in security-fix-pr workflow
• No regressions in other safe output job types
• Integration test added to verify environment variable propagation

Technical Approach:

1. Locate the workflow compilation code that generates the safe_outputs job definition
2. Add GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID to the environment variables passed to this job
3. Verify that the variable is set in the agent job context (it should be)
4. Test with a workflow that uses create_pull_request (e.g., security-fix-pr)

Estimated Effort: Small (1-2 hours)

Dependencies: Access to workflow compilation codebase

Work Item 2: Create Safe Output Environment Variable Manifest

• Type: Enhancement
• Priority: Medium
• Description: Create a comprehensive manifest documenting which environment variables are required by each safe output job type, and implement validation to ensure these variables are present.

Acceptance Criteria:

• Manifest file created with all safe output job types and their required variables
• Validation logic added to check for required variables before job execution
• Clear error messages when required variables are missing
• Documentation updated with environment variable requirements

Technical Approach:

1. Audit all safe output job scripts to identify required environment variables
2. Create a manifest file (JSON or YAML) mapping job types to required variables
3. Add validation step at the beginning of each safe output job script
4. Update workflow compilation to use the manifest for environment propagation

Estimated Effort: Medium (4-6 hours)

Dependencies: Completion of Work Item 1

Work Item 3: Add Integration Tests for Safe Output Jobs

• Type: Enhancement
• Priority: Medium
• Description: Add comprehensive integration tests that verify each safe output job type can execute successfully with minimal required environment configuration.

Acceptance Criteria:

• Integration test suite created for all safe output job types
• Tests verify environment variable requirements
• Tests verify basic job functionality (e.g., can create PR, can add comment)
• Tests run in CI/CD pipeline

Technical Approach:

1. Create test workflow definitions for each safe output job type
2. Set up test environment with mock GitHub API responses
3. Execute each safe output job type and verify success
4. Add tests to CI/CD pipeline

Estimated Effort: Large (1-2 days)

Dependencies: None (can run in parallel with other work items)

Metrics and KPIs

• Overall Safe Output Success Rate: 95.92%
• Most Reliable Job Type: add_comment, add_labels, missing_tool (100% success rate)
• Most Problematic Job Type: create_pull_request (0% success rate)
• Average Safe Outputs per Run: 1.65 operations per run with safe outputs
• Total Safe Output Operations: 81 operations across 49 runs

Success Rate by Job Type

1. add_comment: 100% (38/38)
2. add_labels: 100% (22/22)
3. missing_tool: 100% (12/12)
4. push_to_pull_request_branch: 100% (5/5)
5. noop: 100% (2/2)
6. create_pull_request: 0% (0/2) ⚠️

Historical Context

This is the first audit in the safe output health monitoring system. Future audits will include trend analysis and comparison with previous periods.

Baseline Established

• Date: December 19, 2024
• Success Rate: 95.92%
• Primary Issue: Missing environment variable in create_pull_request jobs

Next Steps

• Create GitHub issue for Work Item 1 (High Priority)
• Assign developer to fix GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID propagation
• Schedule follow-up audit after fix deployment
• Begin Work Item 2 (environment variable manifest)
• Plan Work Item 3 integration test suite

---

References:

• §20381227959
• §20381704495

AI generated by Safe Output Health Monitor

[pelikhan]

/plan

[github-actions[bot]]

🎉 Yo ho ho! Plan Command found the treasure and completed successfully! ⚓💰

[github-actions[bot]]

Plan Created

I've analyzed the Safe Output Health Report and created a comprehensive plan to address the identified issues:

Parent Tracking Issue: Created to coordinate all work related to fixing safe output environment variable propagation issues

Sub-Issues Created (5 tasks):

1. Fix GH_AW_WORKFLOW_ID propagation (High Priority) - Immediately addresses the critical bug causing 100% failure rate for create_pull_request operations
2. Create environment variable manifest - Establishes systematic documentation of requirements for each safe output job type
3. Add validation for required variables - Implements runtime checks to fail fast with clear error messages
4. Add integration tests - Prevents future regressions in environment configuration
5. Document environment requirements - Improves user experience and debugging

The plan prioritizes the critical bug fix first, then builds supporting infrastructure to prevent similar issues in the future.

---

All issues are now ready for assignment to GitHub Copilot agents or developers.

AI generated by Plan Command for discussion #7018