Skip to content

[plan] Document obfuscation warnings as expected pattern in agentic workflows #12281

@github-actions

Description

@github-actions

Objective

Create documentation explaining why dynamic command execution (obfuscation warnings from zizmor) is an expected and intentional pattern in gh-aw agentic workflows.

Context

From discussion #12276, 63 workflows generate 126 low-priority obfuscation warnings from zizmor security scanning. These warnings are expected because dynamic execution is a core feature of agentic workflows, not a security flaw.

Current Situation

  • Tool: zizmor detects dynamic command execution as potential obfuscation
  • Affected: 63 workflows (all agentic workflows with AI-generated commands)
  • Status: Expected and acceptable ✅
  • Mitigation: Runtime safety checks already in place

Required Documentation

Add a new documentation page explaining:

  1. Why obfuscation is intentional

    • AI agents generate contextual commands at runtime
    • Enables flexible automation without hardcoded scripts
    • Core feature enabling adaptive workflow behavior
  2. Safety measures in place

    • Sandboxed execution environment
    • Limited permissions scope (read-only for most agents)
    • Secret verification before execution
    • Audit logging of agent commands
    • Firewall checks on agent output
  3. Trade-offs accepted

    • ✅ Enables agent flexibility
    • ⚠️ Reduces static auditability (accepted)
    • ✅ Mitigated by runtime monitoring
  4. When to be concerned

    • Unexpected obfuscation in non-agentic workflows
    • Missing safety checks in agent execution
    • Overly permissive permissions

Suggested Location

  • Create: docs/src/content/docs/security/dynamic-execution.md
  • Update: docs/src/content/docs/security/index.md to reference new page

Acceptance Criteria

  • Documentation clearly explains intentional dynamic execution pattern
  • Safety measures are documented with examples
  • Guidance provided for when obfuscation warnings should be investigated
  • Linked from security documentation index
  • Run make agent-finish before committing

AI generated by Plan Command for discussion #12276

Metadata

Metadata

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions