-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 59
Closed as not planned
Labels
Description
Objective
Create a standardized template for calculating workflow costs and ROI to help justify automation adoption.
Context
From discussion #12461: Only 1/8 workflows (DO-1) included ROI calculations, despite high-frequency workflows having measurable cost and time savings. PM and executive stakeholders benefit from cost justification.
Approach
-
Create a new template file:
.github/templates/workflow-roi-template.md -
Include the following sections:
- Cost per run: GitHub Actions minutes, API calls, external service costs
- Frequency: Estimated runs per month
- Time savings: Hours saved per run (manual alternative)
- ROI calculation: Formula and example
- Break-even analysis: When automation pays for itself
-
Update developer.instructions to reference this template:
- Add guidance: "For high-frequency workflows (PR automation, scheduled), suggest cost/ROI analysis"
- Reference the template file
- Specify when to include ROI (>10 runs/month, >30min manual time)
Files to Modify
- Create:
.github/templates/workflow-roi-template.md - Update:
.github/instructions/developer.instructions.md- Add section "Cost and ROI Guidance"
- Reference the template
- Specify criteria for including ROI analysis
Acceptance Criteria
- Template includes all 5 sections with examples
- Formula is clear and reusable (cost savings - automation cost) / automation cost
- Developer instructions reference the template
- Guidance specifies when to proactively suggest ROI analysis
- Example calculation matches DO-1 format ($6,000+ savings, 29,900% ROI)
AI generated by Plan Command for discussion #12461
Reactions are currently unavailable