Skip to content

[plan] Monitor and verify MCP parameter validation improvements #7954

@github-actions

Description

@github-actions

Objective

After implementing schema and error message improvements, monitor safe output health metrics for 7 days to verify that add_comment failure rate drops below 1%.

Context

This is the verification step that confirms our fixes are effective. We need to:

  1. Wait for changes to be deployed
  2. Monitor workflow runs using the affected tools
  3. Verify error rates have improved
  4. Document results

Approach

  1. Wait for parent issue fixes to be merged and deployed
  2. Monitor workflow runs over 7 days, focusing on:
    • Issue Monster workflow (primary affected workflow)
    • Any workflows using safeoutputs-add_comment MCP tool
  3. Collect metrics on success/failure rates
  4. Compare with baseline (93.33% success → target 99%+)

Monitoring Method

Use existing tools:

gh aw logs           # Download workflow logs
gh aw audit (run_id) # Audit specific runs

Or check the Safe Output Health Monitor discussion for automated reports.

Success Criteria

  • add_comment success rate is ≥99% over 7-day monitoring period
  • No new MCP validation errors for item_number parameter
  • Overall safe output success rate improves to ≥99%
  • Results documented in this issue

Verification Checklist

After 7 days:

  • Collect success/failure data from workflow runs
  • Calculate new success rate for add_comment tool
  • Verify no regression in other safe output tools
  • Document findings and close issue if successful
  • If failure rate still high, investigate remaining issues

Dependencies

This task depends on completion of:

AI generated by Plan Command for discussion #7934

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions