Wrong alias root for other HTML output formats (e.g. AMP)

[bep]

I was reading some code and test related to this, and the alias path for the AMP type of output formats looks wrong. We create redirect pages for all HTML type of Output Formats. So for:

public/page/index.html
public/amp/page/index.htm

With an alias definition of /myalias you would currently get:

public/myalias/index.html
public/myalias/amp/index.html

We have test cases for the above, but to me that looks surprising and obviously wrong.

I would expect:

public/myalias/index.html
public/amp/myalias/index.html

[bep]

@regisphilibert could you have quick look at the above and tell me if you agree.

[regisphilibert]

This is news to me as I'm fairly unexperienced with HTML output format with a path set, AMP included, maybe others will have more use cases to build an opinion upon.

To me though:
If we follow the AMP recommended URL structure which have you recreate a sort of "alternate" site, yes, the correction you want tot make is needed.
But for any other HTML output format, the current behaviour is, I think, adapted to the user's expectation.

If this correction is limited to AMP, then I agree, if this is for every HTML output formats with a path set, then no I don't agree.

[regisphilibert]

I just found out that the path setting's value is added at the root fo the URL for every HTML (or isHtml = true) output formats.

I was not understanding the path setting properly.

[bep]

If this correction is limited to AMP, then I agree, if this is for every HTML output formats with a path set, then no I don't agree.

This is relevant for all HTML output formats with PATH set (which is kind of very AMP specific).

[github-actions]

This issue has been automatically locked since there has not been any recent activity after it was closed. Please open a new issue for related bugs.